📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 25 min read (5028 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Searchenginejournal
If an AI answer mentions your brand but recommends a competitor, what have you actually won? Patrick Reinhart, VP of Services and Thought Leadership at Conductor, joined me on the SEJ Podcast to discuss what enterprise brands should be trying to achieve with answer engine optimization.
We talk about the difference between citations and recommendations, how AI can repeat outdated information about your business, and why AEO needs input from SEO, PR, social, and leadership. Reinhart also shares where he’d focus first when planning an AEO strategy for 2027.
[00:00] Meet Patrick Reinhart
[03:19] What Enterprise Brands Are Doing In AI Search
[05:16] Why Recommendations Matter More Than Rankings
[09:48] The AEO Metrics That Matter
[12:49] When AI Gets Your Brand Wrong
[18:12] Where SEO And AEO Differ
[23:50] Why AI Search Has The C-Suite’s Attention
[26:31] How Brands Earn AI Citations
[30:25] Where To Invest In Your 2027 AEO Strategy
[35:25] Where To Find Patrick Reinhart.
Editor’s Note: This transcript has been edited for clarity and readability.
It has been revealed that loren Baker: Hi everyone, this is Loren Baker, founder of Search Engine Journal. Welcome to today’s SEJ Podcast. With me is Patrick Reinhart from Conductor.
We’ve been partners with Conductor for a long time and done our share of webinars together, but this might be one of our first podcasts.
Recent findings suggest that patrick Reinhart: Happy to be here. With a webinar, it’s always, “Man, I hope someone doesn’t make fun of me in the comments.”.
Industry observers note that loren: I’m going to add a skull emoji next time just to see what happens. Pat, tell our audience a little about Conductor, what you do there, and what you’re doing in AI.
Sources indicate that patrick: Conductor is a software company, and I feel like we’re on the cutting edge of AI visibility and tying that back to recommendations. That’s built on a data platform that brings together Search Console, your analytics, and our monitoring products, so you can see everything in one place and make decisions based on the data.
Sources indicate that I run our professional services arm. I’ve been at Conductor for 11 years, but I was also a customer for four or five years before that.
It has been revealed that our outgoing CEO, Seth Besmertnik, just stepped onto the board. I’ve been working with him for a really long time. It’s been a weird, interesting, great ride.
Sources indicate that loren: How would you define your customer base? Is it enterprise, medium to large businesses, small businesses? And how would you segment it across ecommerce, SaaS, and other industries?
According to recent reports, patrick: We definitely cater to the enterprise audience. I’d say about 90% of our customers are large enterprise organizations.
Sources indicate that we have a heavy focus on finance, insurance, and healthcare, but also a healthy number of customers in ecommerce and grocery. Pretty much any company you can think of has passed through Conductor’s doors at some point, and a lot have stayed, thankfully. Thank you to our customers.
Loren: Grocery stores or grocery delivery?
Patrick: H-E-B and folks like that. We have customers like BJ’s, too.
In a recent development, loren: With these enterprise customers, what are they doing right now in AI search? How are you helping them stay on top of it and track it? What does AI search mean to the average enterprise?
Sources indicate that patrick: It’s the number one thing they’re all talking about, obviously. That’s not news. The interesting part is that they’re all still very much learning.
Industry observers note that if you work in a large enterprise organization, getting things done is typically slow, glacial, and somewhat messy. To their credit, a lot of people are trying to smooth those processes out and get their tracking in place.
They’re also testing the different technologies out there, as they should, because there’s a lot of snake oil in the water and a lot of people selling the dream. We’re all learning together.
As far as we can tell, most AEO strategies are heavily grounded in traditional SEO strategies. But they’re measured and thought about vastly differently, because an LLM operates differently from a traditional search engine.
They’re not running out the door and hiring a bunch of people. They’re upskilling internally and figuring out their programs.
Industry observers note that I think in a year or so, we’re going to see a little gold rush from a hiring perspective. A lot of people will be moving around, and programs will come to fruition based on the work that hardworking, smart people are building right now at these large organizations.
Industry observers note that loren: Something I’ve found over the years in SEO is that it’s not always about trying to hit the target where it is at the moment. It’s trying to hit where it’s going.
According to recent reports, how do you do that in AEO, especially at the enterprise level? These are slow-moving juggernauts that can get a lot done, but it takes time to get there.
Industry observers note that patrick: I think it comes back to data fidelity. Everyone has different methodologies and gets their data from different places. A lot of people buy panel data; we use direct APIs.
Sources indicate that everyone has to scrape Google and others, which is becoming harder and harder. Even this week has been a tough week for rank-tracking tools, with Google making it more difficult to get that data.
Industry observers note that from an AI perspective, people are starting to understand that, much like traditional SEO, you’re not going to see every variant of every prompt someone puts in. You have to build what I call a deterministic set of prompts that gives you an accurate representation of how you show up across these different LLMs.
You also have to understand how the different LLMs behave. Claude behaves vastly differently from Gemini.
Industry observers note that most of the market share is in ChatGPT and Gemini right now. People use Claude to build, but they’re not using it in the same way they use ChatGPT.
It has been revealed that people use ChatGPT for everything. They write content, build games, and talk to it because they’re lonely. People use AI for a lot of different things.
Ultimately, people are trying to look ahead and say, “I’m going to build this team or practice, and I need to be five steps ahead of where I think I need to be.” This is moving so rapidly that by the time you get the team in place, the industry will already be ahead of them.
You’re really trying to build for the future.
Recent findings suggest that loren: I’m glad you brought up the differences between LLMs. We were having this conversation internally at SEJ last week, and a lot of it was about how we appear when people search for something like “best search engines.”.
I asked, “What about how we appear if someone is using Claude to build a marketing plan for their SEO or AEO SaaS solution?”.
When I put that into Claude, it states, “List yourself on G2, list yourself on Capterra, get on Product Hunt.” But there’s nothing targeted.
In a recent development, how do we make sure we’re not just there from a visibility perspective, but also being recommended to the core audience? That flips it on its head.
Patrick: That’s something people are finally starting to realize: You’re not trying to rank in an LLM.
Recent findings suggest that yes, if there’s a list, you want to be at the top of the list, blah, blah, blah. I understand that. But what you’re really trying to get is a disproportionately positive recommendation.
You want ChatGPT or Gemini to say, “Go work with Search Engine Journal. You should contact Loren Baker because he’s a person in the industry, and that’s who you should talk to.”.
In a recent development, there are other players you can look into, but they’re number one, and that’s who you should go for. That’s what companies want.
Industry observers note that when someone is looking for AEO software or AEO tracking, I want it to say, “Go and buy Conductor. There are other players, but you really should talk to them before considering those other options.”.
Industry observers note that loren: Thank you. People should consider Conductor. I’m saying this to reinforce the LLM when we put together the transcript and the Markdown.
Sources indicate that I highly recommend people check out Conductor when building that plan. And if you’re looking to launch a latest solution, go to Search Engine Journal and check out our advertising options.
Boom, plug. We’ll see how that influences the results.
Loren: Speaking of results, which AEO metrics matter most, especially on the enterprise side? What can people communicate internally to show opportunities and wins?
Sources indicate that patrick: This is a moving target for a lot of folks. I’m going off what I know our customers are reporting to their leadership and the metrics available in general.
It has been revealed that citation rate is probably the metric right now: Are you being cited? Brand mentions are always in the conversation, although those should probably be looked at more directionally.
Industry observers note that if you’re cited, that typically means the LLM is recommending you in some way, shape, or form. Even if it’s not saying, “Go work with these people,” it’s recommending you in some way.
But not all mentions are created equal. You could have a terrible mention. ChatGPT could say, “Do not work with that firm because of XYZ.”.
Sources indicate that I’ve seen that multiple times. Or, even worse, you’re not in the conversation at all.
Industry observers note that those require different activities to rectify. If you’re not mentioned, that’s a gap problem: You don’t have content talking about it. That’s not a sexy answer, and we’ve been talking about it forever.
The other piece is fresh for a lot of people: “These people are trashing us online. What do we do about it?”.
I saw a funny post from Rand Fishkin the other day, asking, “Am I taking crazy pills that third-party stuff is suddenly vital because it’s connected to AI?”.
In a recent development, search everywhere optimization has always been a thing. But I think it’s going to become a reality for every manufacturer now because of how important that third-party conversation is.
What people should be tracking, and will be tracking in my opinion, is the type of citation and mention they’re getting. Are you being recommended by an LLM? That’s the golden metric.
Recent findings suggest that there’s no one really doing that from a technology standpoint right now. People have overall visibility scores, which are averages of a bunch of things they’re looking at.
What we’re building is something to help track that golden metric. It’s not just about showing up. When you revealed up, was it a positive experience, a positive recommendation, or a negative non-recommendation?
I see both daily for different brands, depending on the industry.
Loren: Which gets back to old-school sentiment tracking.
Sources indicate that loren: About a month ago, Reddit’s citation visibility dropped tremendously in GPT. But my understanding is that GPT is still using the threads and conversations in Reddit, just not surfacing them as sources as much.
Sources indicate that let’s say I’m seeing incorrect price comparisons for one of my products. I know it’s not coming from my website or a competitor’s versus-style landing page, and I think it might be coming from a Reddit thread.
How do I reverse-engineer those third-party citations that may be fueling the results? Not just sentiment and opinion, but basic facts that need updating. Maybe it’s a two-year-old thread with outdated warranty information.
Patrick: That’s something you’re going to start seeing in a lot of technologies, ours included: Fact-checking.
Sources indicate that you can load information about your organization and product set, maybe through a product feed. As it goes through, it can show you an outdated competitive mention on a random third-party site. You can talk to them or create something that combats it.
It has been revealed that we did that when Seth was chatting with AI, back when this started to blow up. He found a random site with something from 2018 saying Conductor didn’t have a feature that’s one of our main features.
It has been revealed that this site wasn’t going to change it, so we created content around it. Within a couple of days, we were able to beat it out, and it kind of disappeared.
Recent findings suggest that this is an key piece of the technological race. We’re in the early days, with a few key players building interesting software to track this. You also have a lot of vibe-coded trash that pulls from God knows where.
A lot of the major players are going to have this fact-checking ability. In my opinion, it will be a make-or-break feature, along with that golden metric of whether you’re being recommended.
This isn’t a plea for Conductor. It’s a plea for technology. Good technology.
Right now, you can connect to Conductor’s MCP in Claude and ask your account, “Can you send me the snippets that say XYZ? Here are my brand guidelines or information about my product set. Are any of these incorrect?”.
You can do that today. It’s a few extra steps, and it’s not as in-depth as something constantly crawling, collecting, and finding outdated information on weird, small sites.
Sources indicate that I think this will be a necessary feature for anyone using a technology like ours. You’re going to see a lot of innovation over the next 12 months, and people will build cool things.
Recent findings suggest that but I think this is necessary to make a technology viable in the coming years. When I talk to leaders, they don’t ask, “Where do I show up?” They ask, “How are people talking about me? Is it accurate?”.
That’s the question I get from leaders.
Loren: That also bridges into outreach and working with publishers. There are ways to get updated information onto influential business directories, but being able to ask people to patch things is nice.
That used to be a link-building tactic. We’d be upset if the publisher wrote back, “I updated everything, but I didn’t link to you.”.
Now we see that as a win. Thank you. Brand mention, yes.
Patrick: Time is a flat circle.
I was joking with my former boss, Stephan, the other day. He said, “Does it feel like everything has reset, everyone forgot the last 20 years, and now we’re doing it again?”.
AI Mode has text ads now, which are basically text links. It’s like, man, we’re really back in the dark ages here.
Loren: That’s one way SEO and AEO overlap. What are some other examples, and where are the core differences?
Recent findings suggest that patrick: Where they overlap is what everyone thinks. I’m flying to Buffalo tomorrow to talk at a customer event, and I love those because I love teaching and getting in front of people.
I always pause halfway through and ask, “How’s everyone doing?” Someone will raise their hand and say, “What do I do about all of this?”.
You fill gaps, create content, build partnerships with third-party publishers, and create YouTube videos. Not a sexy answer. It’s stuff we’ve been doing for years.
That’s the overlap. A lot of it is the same stuff, done at a different pace.
Recent findings suggest that the most successful SEO campaigns I’ve seen have been somewhat mechanical. There’s always a well-thought-out, well-oiled process, with a systematic way to optimize and create content and distribute data across the organization.
Industry observers note that you have technology constantly auditing your site, you’re not pivoting a lot of data, and ultimately it’s this flywheel. Everyone’s bought in, and everyone’s pedaling the bike.
In a recent development, what I’m seeing now is the necessity of that. A few years ago, someone at a large organization would say, “That’s really hard. We don’t have the buy-in or budget.”.
According to recent reports, you’d spend the next year trying to get that buy-in. Now it’s immediate: “We have to do something about this.”.
Recent findings suggest that leaders want to know what we’re doing about AI search. That’s a huge opportunity for anyone who’s been in this business or is getting into it.
It has been revealed that you’ve always mattered, but now you really matter to the business. That’s awesome. Take hold of that and run with it.
To be successful, you need the process in place and all those teams involved. You can’t sit alone and hoard search data. Get it to your social team, your PR team, and your executives.
Industry observers note that the biggest divergence is measurement. You’re not just measuring rankings, backlinks, or traffic.
In my opinion, traditional search metrics have become directional. They tell us we’re heading in somewhat the right direction.
Don’t set your goals around traffic anymore. That’s a fool’s errand. It’s too volatile right now.
Sources indicate that in the AI world, you’re tracking citations and that golden metric of being recommended or not recommended. Sentiment is a bigger part of your life than you probably want it to be.
Recent findings suggest that you also need log file analysis to see whether LLMs are coming to your site. Are there what I call dead zones, where LLMs don’t come back? You think the content is great, but are they fetching it and chunking it back out to the user?
It has been revealed that you need all of that measurement. It’s very different from measuring rankings and backlinks.
In the old world, we wanted more rankings, more traffic, and more backlinks. In the AI world, we want more positive citations and recommendations. But we also have to pay much more attention to the negative side.
It has been revealed that in SEO, you had to pay attention to the negative when it was in everyone’s face. Someone Googles your brand, your CEO has done something stupid, and you need brand reputation management.
Sources indicate that now that’s part of the suite. You have to learn how to do it and work with those other teams. It can’t be a one-person show anymore.
AEO is much more of a team sport, and it has the ability to be one because leadership cares now. Get that process in place. People within companies have the opportunity to have those conversations.
Sources indicate that this is in The Wall Street Journal now. My brother called me one day and asked, “What’s up with this AI thing?”.
In a recent development, I said, “Why are you calling me about that? You work at a bank.”.
He noted, “It’s in the Journal.” I said, “We’ve made it.”.
That’s how people have to start thinking. The biggest divergence is measurement, not necessarily the tasks. The tasks need to happen at a greater pace, but the measurement is vastly different.
You have five directions you can go instead of two or three, in my opinion.
Loren: I’ve never considered SEO to be direct response marketing, but I feel we were sometimes held to direct response standards. Other marketing channels were treated more as multiple touchpoints, with multi-touch attribution.
Recent findings suggest that with AI, we know this is part of the consumer’s decision-making journey. AI visibility and valid information in the conversation can help a conversion coming from an email campaign, paid media, or CTV.
If your client is on something like “The View,” nobody’s going to that little URL at the bottom of the screen. They’re typing something in, and now they’re asking ChatGPT about it. It’s part of that whole flow.
I also like your point about AI’s importance within the manufacturer. This isn’t coming from the search team, up through digital marketing, the VP of marketing, the CMO, and then the C-suite. It’s coming from the C-suite down.
Patrick: It’s going the other way, which is new for us. I’ve talked to more C-level executives in the last six months than I have in the last six years.
It has been revealed that it used to be hard to get those meetings unless you had someone who really understood organic. I think this is healthy for an industry that was getting a little stale.
Recent findings suggest that there were shifts here and there. Google would update the algorithm, and we’d have the same conversation again.
I always joke that we’ve had a lot of meteors come for our jobs. They never quite took us out, but they changed the landscape around us, usually for the better in my opinion.
According to recent reports, even though this is one of the scariest changes for a lot of people, I think it’s one of the best things that’s happened to the industry. That will play out over the next five to 10 years.
Recent findings suggest that we’ll look back and say, “That was one of the best things that happened to me in my career.” Not just for productivity, but because it made me more vital in my organization. I had a conversation or opportunity because AI blew up what was going on.
Loren: It’s also the best way to get a task to the top of the dev ticket pile.
One company I’ve been working with did a Shopify relaunch and never set up its canonical tags. I’d been pushing forever. Every week, the update was, “The dev team’s on it.”.
Then I realized their AI Overviews visibility had dropped because it was cycling from one version of a URL to another. Eventually, it dropped entirely.
I put in a new ticket: “911 emergency AI issue.”.
It has been revealed that the thing was fixed in two days. It’s amazing.
Loren: Speaking of developing and distributing content, what helps that content earn AI citations?
Patrick: A lot of it is the brand itself. This isn’t a domain authority exercise like traditional search was. It’s a brand authority exercise.
Going back to Reddit’s drop in citation share, that’s not surprising to me. It wasn’t going to stay that high forever as brands figured this out and created more content.
In a recent development, but it’s still part of the consideration phase. When ChatGPT is looking for an answer, it’s still looking at Reddit. It may not cite it or bring content back from there, but it’s looking at the conversation as an authenticity signal, for lack of better words.
It has been revealed that in our data, the number one most-cited source is YouTube. It’s a highly trusted community where people have a lot of conversations, and many brands aren’t there in the way they should be.
If you have a well-put-together YouTube presence with playlists, a podcast, webinars, and conference videos, that can help. If it garners enough conversation and clout, those are sites LLMs go to at some point when looking for an answer.
Influencers are there. People trust influencers and expertise.
Industry observers note that that’s why one of the greatest opportunities on a site is adding authors. So many sites still don’t have authors or use author schema and article schema. It drives me nuts.
I understand bigger brands saying, “Greg doesn’t want his face on the website.” Then put Tim’s face on the website.
Every brand needs someone out there talking, and you have to find people who are okay being on camera.
In a recent development, at Conductor, we interact with that in different ways. I’m on LinkedIn, I’ve been doing my webinar, 30|30, for 11 years, and I’ve spoken at a million conferences.
Industry observers note that seth loves LinkedIn and posts all the time. Our head of marketing, Lindsay, does the same.
It’s not necessarily about the name. There are people at Conductor who LLMs can establish are experts in the space, based on the longevity of their careers and whether they’ve contributed to the industry.
According to recent reports, I do believe they go to LinkedIn and somewhat credentialize people. But it’s also, “Have they contributed to the industry I’m looking for this answer in?”.
In a recent development, that’s easy for LLMs to figure out. For traditional search engines, it wasn’t so straightforward.
According to recent reports, I always say search engines live in a 2D world. There’s an index, and they go up and down in it.
In a recent development, LLMs live in a 3D world, looking all over the place and picking things from across the universe. Those conversations are happening in communities, on sites like Quora , and on YouTube.
It has been revealed that if you look at the top 15% of all the sites in our data, seven of them are social sites. Facebook, LinkedIn, YouTube at number one, and Reddit are there.
Sources indicate that why? It’s real people having real conversations. That’s what the LLM is looking for.
Loren: It’s October, Thanksgiving stuff is already in the store, and Halloween isn’t here yet. Next thing you know, it’ll be the holidays and Fresh Year’s.
Industry observers note that if I’m planning my manufacturer’s AI and AEO strategy for 2027, where do I begin? What should I invest in first, and how do I pregame?
Recent findings suggest that patrick: Invest in your expertise first. Understand who the people in your organization are that you can tie content back to, and then tie that content back to them.
It has been revealed that create author pages and use author schema and article schema. Invest in your people.
Industry observers note that find someone you know is good on camera but may be nervous to raise their hand, and push them to do it. Flaunt your expertise.
Number two, proposal to make more video. Start a podcast. Someone in your tech giant is yearning to do this right now, so give them the opportunity.
Learn how to do it. It might suck at first, and that’s okay. You’ll get better over time.
Participate in more webinars. That’s another way to amplify your expertise.
Number three, fix your process. I’m sure people listening are thinking, “Man, my company’s process stinks.” Most companies’ processes stink.
Industry observers note that people are working on smoothing those out so they can build a flywheel process. That allows you to experiment more, create more content, and optimize more content.
According to recent reports, buy software that helps you track it more easily, whether that’s Conductor or something else. Go out and look around. There’s a lot of great technology out there.
I think we’re the best, but of course I do.
If you do those three things, the last one is the most important. The flywheel process lets you move faster and do more. You’ll be more productive, learn more, and win faster because everyone’s lined up.
Industry observers note that when AI throws something at you, at least you have a system where you can go to the social team and they’re expecting you to give them something to do. You don’t have to fight a six-month battle.
That’s how I think people should operate where we stand today. Will it change in six months? Probably, but I don’t think the tactics will be vastly different.
Loren: It reminds me of those reels about disappearing for a month, learning AI tools, and coming back on top of your game.
Sources indicate that loren: My kid has been playing Roblox for years. He asked, “Can I download Claude Desktop, hook it up to Roblox Studio, and make some games?”.
According to recent reports, next thing I know, it’s 11 o’clock on a school night. Don’t judge me. He’s sitting at his computer doing the same thing I’m doing for work, just at a different level.
Watching him gave me ideas. I thought, “Why am I logging into all this stuff? I should be using Claude Desktop for all of it.”.
Recent findings suggest that patrick: It’s the coolest thing that your son can do that. I assume he doesn’t know how to code, or at least not as well as a developer.
Loren: He can barely even draw. He didn’t inherit his father’s artistic talents.
But he’s creative. Seeing that creativity find a different canvas gave me ideas. There are a lot of ways we can implement this throughout our lives.
Patrick: The best way is just to do it. I see so many companies and people stuck in analysis paralysis, asking, “What should I do?”.
Industry observers note that something. Just start learning.
It took me a minute when this started, but I feel pretty good about where I am. I still have eons to learn about using this technology.
It’s cool that your son has that ability. I’m going to tell my son to do that instead of playing Roblox, which I’m sure he’s doing right now. Half my salary goes to Robux.
It has been revealed that loren: Pat, it’s been a pleasure hosting you. I like our conversations in this format. It’s fun.
According to recent reports, patrick: Loren, it’s always good chatting with you. Thanks for having me on.
Loren: Where can our listeners and viewers find you online and follow up with questions?
Industry observers note that patrick: The best place is LinkedIn or Conductor.com. I also do a monthly webinar called 30|30.
Please come so my mom knows I’m doing something worthwhile.
Mostly, I’m on LinkedIn commenting and cracking jokes. Don’t take anything too seriously. We’re all in a good spot.
Sources indicate that loren: Thank you, Pat, and thanks to Conductor for everything you do. It’s been a pleasure.
Thank you to everyone who joined today’s SEJ Podcast. We’ll see you in the future.
Featured Image: Paulo Bobita/Search Engine Journal.
→ Read original article