The EFL sent a warning to all 72 member clubs to remind them of their responsibilities on social media.
Halaman 45 dari 63 • Total 12423 artikel tersedia dalam direktori berita harian.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (23 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The EFL sent a warning to all 72 member clubs to remind them of their responsibilities on social media.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (14 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Jobi McAnuff likes what he sees from Middlesbrough this season.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (19 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
Exclusive: Ryan Haynes lifts the lid on Wembley, relegation, promotion and life after Coventry City.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (11 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Sebastian Berhalter is enjoying life at Middlesbrough.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (28 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
A number of players left Coventry City during the transfer window as changes were made to Frank Lampard's squad and in the Under-21 group.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (13 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Riley McGree scored in Australia's 3-0 victory over Qatar.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (536 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Industry observers note that stoke City signed Luke Graham from Dundee in the summer, and the 22-year-old has quickly become a hit at the Be635 Stadium. He has started in 13 of SCFC’s 15 Championship matches, playing the full 90 minutes in each of the last 12.
Graham’s form has seen him emerge as a starter on the international stage for Scotland too. He earned plaudits for his display in the win over North Macedonia, but Monday marked a tougher night for the Tartan Army as they were thrashed 4-0 by Switzerland.
Despite this, Graham still earned praise from The Scotsman. In their player ratings after the heavy defeat, journalist Lewis Anderson wrote: “A second consecutive start for the Stoke City man and once again barely put a foot wrong, providing a steady presence at the heart of the defence. He deflected Amdouni’s strike into his own net, but can be pleased with his contribution during this international break.”.
There’s no hiding that the Switzerland loss was a tough one for Scotland, Graham included. He may have given a decent account of himself despite the heavy defeat, but Sebastien Pocognoli’s side were thumped on a night that was supposed to be fondly remembered for Andy Robertson breaking the caps record.
Industry observers note that the Stoke City man did do a decent job individually though, so the praise is justified. He managed a 93% pass completion rate with 53 of 57 completed, and he made the joint-most defensive contributions at nine. Graham also won 75% of his ground duels.
It has been revealed that graham did not need to be as active defensively against a weaker North Macedonia side, registering only five defensive contributions. However, he was still strong in duels with six won (two ground, four aerial), and he showed his ability in possession with his 56 passes the most by any player in the win (all stats via FotMob).
Graham has been in good form for Stoke City, and he has carried that momentum into his international duties. It means he should be confident of maintaining his high levels as SCFC return to Championship football this weekend.
The Scottish youngster will surely retain his place in Mark Robins‘ backline as they look to continue their impressive league form. The Potters sit 3rd in the table after a five-game unbeaten streak, including four wins.
A challenging game awaits next though, as table-toppers Birmingham City visit the Bet365 Stadium. It would be a real statement of intent by the Potters if they were to win, as they could move to the top of the Championship table.
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest Stoke City news in your inbox every morning.
Enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Boro notebook as the start of the January transfer window draws closer.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
Get the full Coventry City Premium experience for less than 50p per week.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (317 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Today, more information about the structure and cost of Goncalo Ramos’ move to AC Milan has been revealed.
It’s fair to say that Ramos’ start to life with Milan has been poor. The Portuguese striker has not scored (or assisted) as many as had been hoped from a player worth a substantial amount and it’s fair to suggest that some have been disappointed with his time at San Siro so far.
Read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
However, the club will not be giving up on him anytime soon, considering he is their record arrival.
This evening, Calcio e Finanza have looked at the fee paid for Ramos – as they did for Diego Moreira recently – and picked apart both the fee, the bonuses and the structure of the payment, as MilanNews relays.
According to recent reports, in terms of the fixed fee, the Rossoneri agreed on a deal worth €70 million, with an extra €3.1m in additional costs. This figure will be paid over the course of four years, with yearly payments scheduled on July 15 on each year – ending in July 2029 – and each payment will be worth €17.5m.
Then, there is €16m in bonuses that can be achieved, taking the total fee to almost €90m if all bonuses are achieved.
It has been revealed that if Milan win the Scudetto, €2m will be owed; then there are several Champions League bonuses, which could be worth up to €5.2m if the Diavolo win the competition. Finally, if he is the top goalscorer in Serie A, another €2m will be owed to PSG.
These bonuses are capped at €16m and are repeatable, but they’ll only be redeemable if the Portuguese plays 60% of games in that season, unless he is the top scorer, where only the €2m will be owed.
📅 20 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 30 min read (5909 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

According to recent reports, for all the money spent, Tottenham Hotspur have started this season without a reliable out-and-out striker and short of a top goalkeeper. And it is already costing them dear.
Industry observers note that we keep hearing that Dominic Solanke will be the man to give Spurs a goalscoring threat, but how long has it been since we have seen him fully fit and firing? Maybe not since his Bournemouth days.
Antonin Kinsky may have finished last season well, but there was further evidence in this defeat that he is well short of the best goalkeepers in the division.
It is a puzzle how Tottenham signed 10 new players, but did not upgrade two of the most crucial positions on the pitch.
Only when Aston Villa were out of sight and the game was effectively over did Spurs break their Premier League goal drought. And even then it was a midfielder, Conor Gallagher, and a defender, Jan Paul van Hecke, who were on target.
Solanke had gone off just before Villa scored their second goal, which highlighted the significant difference between the two sides on Saturday and where Spurs are badly lacking.
According to recent reports, zion Suzuki, the Villa goalkeeper, released a long ball upfield, Nicolas Jackson managed to lay it off for Johan Mazambi, who returned the favour. Jackson touched the ball past Micky van de Ven’s challenge before beating Kinsky with a well-struck shot.
Spurs are stunned as Nicolas Jackson doubles Aston Villa's lead 😳📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/il7NKbgFCQ.
It has been revealed that it was an excellent goal, but Kinsky got a good hand to it and a top goalkeeper would have pushed it around the post. On the evidence of the first half, when he made four saves, Suzuki would have also stopped the ball creeping into the net.
Recent findings suggest that suzuki cost Villa in the region of £30m and he looks a more than able replacement for Emiliano Martínez. Spurs, on the other hand, have not had a top-class goalkeeper since Hugo Lloris and it is a puzzle that so much faith has been placed in Kinsky.
It has been revealed that spurs spent most of the summer firmly denying any links to Jackson before Villa signed him from Chelsea for an initial £47.5m that could rise to £65m. Given the London club paid an initial £75m for Sávio and committed to a £60m obligation to make Omar Marmoush’s season-long loan permanent, Jackson might have been a relative bargain for them.
Sources indicate that asked if Tottenham had made a big mistake by failing to sign a proper number nine, head coach Robert De Zerbi remarked: “The transfer market was long. The situation changed many times. There was also the financial rules, at the end of the transfer market. And we had to respect the rules.
In a recent development, “We didn’t sell the players who we thought, in the beginning, there was the possibility, the chance to sell. There are a lot of reasons. I think the club and the coach, we are not sleeping, we know the characteristics of the players, we know everything. And if we didn’t make any different decisions, it was because we couldn’t.”.
According to recent reports, that sounded a bit like excuses, but De Zerbi did not put up much of a defence for Solanke as he noted: “We need more from him, for sure, but he’s one of my players. I like Dom as a player and I stay with him until the end. He needs to stay better, to feel better. The physical condition is not good enough, but it’s normal for him. Maybe he is not confident enough in himself at this moment, because he’s much better than this. I think we can’t say everything is bad, but it’s not enough.”.
In a recent development, it was Sávio who forced Suzuki into making a brilliant double save from him in the first half, when Tottenham were well on top. The Japan international also stopped an Archie Gray shot from squirming through his legs and into the net, and dived to turn another Sávio effort around his right-hand post.
According to recent reports, jackson was not the only Villa upcoming boy who upstaged Tottenham’s expensive new attackers. Manzambi not only assisted for Jackson, but also marked his first start for the Midlands club with a goal that put the visitors ahead in first-half stoppage time.
In a recent development, johan Manzambi is off the mark for Aston Villa, and what a time to do it! ⚽️📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/rLRbbUM4Jm.
Andrew Robertson will have been disappointed with his attempt to clear the ball, John McGinn played it into the path of Boubacar Kamara and his scuffed shot fell into the path of Manzambi, who found the back of the net.
Substitute Mohammed Kudus was correctly denied an equaliser following a VAR check before Jackson’s goal and a brilliant strike from Emiliano Buendía that effectively clinched a first league win of the season for Villa.
Emi Buendia, that is a BEAUTIFUL strike 😮💨📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/nNplbL7mpd.
Unai Emery, the head coach, spent years watching Martínez and Ollie Watkins win games for Villa with decisive actions, and is hoping this was evidence that Suzuki and Jackson can do the same for him.
“They are here for it [making the same impact],” Emery said. “His commitment, Zion is really very good. His commitment, Nico Jackson as well is fantastic. But every player needs to understand how we can feel better collectively, how they can help us with their qualities, and how we can collectively exploit our best performance.
“Today we made one clear step forward. Zion is keeping his performance like he did before. Jackson today clearly improved his performance. This is the way forward and the example for the other players.
According to recent reports, “Manzambi played a good match, but he’s not yet understanding everything we need on the field with our positioning. He’s a fantastic player and must feel free playing to try to exploit himself and his qualities. But, of course, always under our structure.”.
Speaking after the match, former Spurs man Joe Cole was critical of the club’s summer business which has left them without an out-and-out goalscorer and a weak defence.
"You can't rule them out of a relegation battle"Steven Gerrard and Joe Cole have major concerns for Spurs 😬🎙️ @lynseyhipgrave1 | 📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/JivM5pNfM9.
Plenty of fans leaving before full-time...
and heartbreak for the ones that stayed...
"It's a long international break, you don't want to be in the bottom three"John McGinn on the 'relief' for Aston Villa to pick up their first league win of the season 😅🎙️ @lynseyhipgrave1 | 📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/Gl38uj1pig.
We’ve got a three-week international break after this weekend, so there’s a little while before both teams will be back in action, but this is what awaits them when they return:.
vs Man Utd (A) - Oct 10th, 5.30pm.
vs Coventry (H) - Oct 19th, 8pm.
vs Chelsea (A) - Oct 24th, 5.30pm.
vs Crystal Palace (H) - Oct 31st, 5.30pm.
vs Brentford (H) - Oct 10th, 3pm.
vs Fenerbahce (H) - Oct 14th, 8pm.
vs Newcastle (A) - Oct 17th, 5.30pm.
vs Man City (H) - Oct 24th, 12.30pm.
"The fans deserved the win." 👏Emi Buendia highlights his appreciation to Aston Villa supporters after a much-needed victory 💜🎙️ @jules_breach | 📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/Qjn6RihNGD.
John McGinn is also speaking to TNT now, so we’ll get you his quotes soon.
Villa only had seven touches in the Spurs box in that second half, but that was enough to secure two goals and all three points.
Spurs thought they had pulled themselves level while Villa were only 0-1 up after 60 minutes, but VAR judged Robertson to be offside.
Spurs thought they had their first Premier League goal of the season...Until VAR ruled it out for offside 😬 pic.twitter.com/FJsrLhm0FG.
Emi Buendia, that is a BEAUTIFUL strike 😮💨📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/nNplbL7mpd.
Possession: Spurs 64% vs 36% Villa.
Touches inside opposition box: 31 vs 18.
Aston Villa have jumped with their first win of the season, while Tottenham have sunk back into the relegation zone.
“We were looking for this win from the beginning. We had a really difficult start of the season in terms of results and not finding our best football but I think today we showed a really good character.”.
Sources indicate that and that is it! A second late consolation goal is not enough to stem the boos from the stands.
In a recent development, late action from Tottenham but they leave it too late to get a result. Another loss at home sends De Zerbi back to the drawing board.
This will be the last of the game probably as Maddison is fouled outside the area for Spurs’ third free kick in quick succession. Robertson takes it and sends a perfect delivery to the back post.
It is the first one that Mings has been caught under and van Hecke gets there to send it past Suzuki.
Sources indicate that another foul for Spurs, on the corner of the box. Maddison to take again and Mings does great work to judge the path of the ball and head it out from the centre of the box.
In a recent development, callagher gets the ball in midfield and feeds Savio on the left who pulls it back. The ball he sends into the box is cleared from a crowd of bodies by Barkley.
Though Savio takes the corner rapidly, it comes out to the edge of the area. Bentancur rises to meet the ball lifted in to the box and flicks it on behind himself towards goal, and it just goes wide of the post.
Maddison stands over it, and goes for goal, curling it very well, though Suzuki is in the right place to punch it away. It falls to Kudus, whose follow-up is a much less exciting effort, sailing over the bar.
We will have seven minutes added on here.
Kudus has been fouled as he try to get forward. Spurs are still looking for a second goal and Savio is fouled on the left side of the box. Cash gets a card for it and it is a very interesting position, not far from the touchline.
It has been given as a Gallagher goal for now.
Sources indicate that but it is just too little too late for Spurs. No celebration from De Zerbi and hardly a cheer from the fans remaining in the stadium.
Tammy Abraham has come on by the way, replacing Jackson for the final few minutes.
According to recent reports, A consolation for Spurs! They have their first league goal to almost no reaction from their fans.
Kudus cuts the ball back and it is not clear whether Cash or Gallagher get there first to poke it home.
It looks like a Cash own goal...
The Spurs fans are leaving in droves. All you can hear in the stadium now are the rejoicing Villa fans.
McGinn comes off for Ross Barkley and Kamara off for Mbaye.
Spurs replace Bentancur and Tonali with Lucas Bergvall and Connor Gallagher.
This is absolutely what Villa needed. They have been great out of possession, just patient and disciplined and taking their chances when they come.
This is going to be a long three weeks for De Zerbi. Spurs have not managed a shot on target in the half, despite all their dominance on the ball.
That must be the final nail in the coffin for Spurs.
In a recent development, gomes makes a great run, sending the ball out to McGinn on the right win. Rather than send the ball in to the box, he sends it out to the edge of the area and there is Buendia. He runs on to it late, finding the top left corner with an immaculate strike.
The Spurs fans are flooding out.
Sources indicate that villa have been calm without the ball in this half. Spurs have dominated possession but Villa have been very organised in defence.
Sources indicate that gray is fouled 35 yards out and Maddison takes the free kick. It only meets the first man in the box, who is Ruggeri, who clears.
Spurs are having no luck and have just not been able to get themselves in front.
Marmoush gets the ball from Maddison on the edge of the area and takes a shot on the turn. It’s blocked by Lindelof for a corner.
Savio takes again but Suzuki punches it away in the centre of the box.
Kudus tries a ball from on the right of the area, looking to find Robertson at the back post but Suzuki again comes confidently to claim it.
Change for Villa as Manzambi comes off to make way for George Hemmings.
17 minutes for Spurs to find a goal...or two.
Tonali comes close! From 35 yards out, the Italian takes a touch to shift it onto his left foot and sends a curling effort towards goal. Suzuki dives but can’t get there and the ball just whistles past the top far corner of the goal.
At least Spurs’s heads haven’t gone down but they still have nothing to show for it.
Sources indicate that savio sends a cross in from the right but there’s only Buendia in the box to meet it. He sends it out and Jackson finds himself with it again on the left side. Villa’s play breaks down but they are not backing down.
Well it’s gone from bad to worse for Spurs.
Jackson gets his first goal for his newly introduced club and van Hecke has got to do better there.
It has been revealed that he gets on the end of an incredible long ball from Suzuki, and van Hecke does not get close enough to challenge him. He takes a touch to get it past van de Ven and sends it past Kinsky from the edge of the box into the bottom corner. The keeper gets a hand on it but it comes in off the post, almost in slow motion.
James Maddison will be coming on shortly.
Tonali sends a ball across to Savio on the right corner of the box, and his low ball in goes out the back for a corner.
Solanke can’t control it as it comes in and that will be his last action before he makes way for Maddison.
Marmoush goes down on the edge of the box, pushed by Joao Gomes, earning a free kick.
Sources indicate that robertson and Marmoush standing over it, just on the left of the area. Robertson is the one to take, lifting it towards the back post but Suzuki comes out to claim easily.
In a recent development, so close for Spurs! A fantastic run from Robertson but the defender strays just offside just outside the box. He takes the ball down to the back line, drawing Suzuki off his line, and it is crossed back past the keeper and bundled over the line by Kudus.
According to recent reports, huge cheers before VAR takes a look. The wait goes on.
Ruggeri intercepts a loose ball in midfield and makes a run down the left side. He lifts a ball towards the centre of the box, but Betancur beats the waiting Manzambi to it, bringing it down and nudging it towards his keeper.
Savio again on the right edge of the box lifts a ball across the box towards the back post, but Suzuki judges it well and comes off his line to claim it.
We’re back underway as Kinsky had to receive a bit of treatment there.
Sources indicate that tonali plays it in for Savio but it’s intercepted by a Villa shirt. It’s played out for Jackson on the left wing to have a run and he gets past van Hecke very easily to reach the edge of the area and take a shot – which goes high and wide.
According to recent reports, unai Emery warned Nicolas Jackson about getting unnecessary bookings yesterday after having to substitute him on a yellow card at half-time last week. 30 seconds into the second half, Jackson got a needless yellow car for stopping a free-kick being rapidly taken. Emery pointed straight to his head when it happened.
According to recent reports, savio tries to find Bentancur as he makes a run down the centre of the field. The midfielder gets a head on it but it heads the wrong way.
But the game is opening as Spurs push, and Villa go on the counter with Manzambi running down the left side. He feeds a ball through to Jackson who carries it into the box but Kinsky judges it well and comes out to block the shot.
Spurs are pressing very high now and Villa have dropped very deep, especially their midfield.
It has been revealed that savio tries to put a ball in to the box but it’s trapped by Manzambi who plays the ball out. Ruggeri gets the ball back in to midfield to Buendia, who tees up Manzambi for a run into the box. The Swiss international is closed down well though.
Time to see how Spurs will react after that goal.
There’s still plenty of fight left as Kudus sends the ball out to Savio, trying to get to the touchline to cross a ball back in but Ruggeri stays on him.
We’re back in action in north London.
Spurs: Mateus Fernandes for Mohammed Kudus.
Villa: Wan-Bissaka for Matty Cash.
Industry observers note that and as I’m typing this , it’s an early yellow for Jackson for a silly foul. Here we go!
Johan Manzambi is off the mark for Aston Villa, and what a time to do it! ⚽️📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/rLRbbUM4Jm.
It has been revealed that it looks like Mohammed Kudus will be on at half-time for football. He’s been going through his own half-time warm-up. Matt Cash has been doing the same for Villa, so maybe we will see him too.
Possession: Spurs 57% vs 44% Villa.
Touches inside opposition box: 14 vs 11.
In all fairness to Spurs, they have pushed for a goal all half and only been denied by some fantastic keeping from Zion Suzuki.
Here are some of the biggest saves of the half:.
Zion Suzuki with a double save to deny Spurs an opener 🧤📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/b7WITUtjf2.
Recent findings suggest that back-to-back huge saves from Zion Suzuki! 🤯📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/uXKkicEeer.
It has been revealed that predictably, there were boos from the home fans at half-time. That was the ninth half of Premier League football Spurs have failed to score in. They should have done and would have done if it weren’t for the heroics of Zion Suzuki in the Villa goal. Manzambi’s goal was only Villa’s second in the League this season and this is the first time they have led in a League game.
Spurs looking shaky now as they come close to conceding a second, seconds before the whistle finally blows.
Boos around the stadium as the players head down the tunnel. De Zerbi has work to do.
Spurs have not come from behind to win since November 2024.
This is a tall challenge now, as van Hecke is the first to go into the book for a foul on Jackson.
To rub salt in the wound, Spurs have a decent shout for a free kick on the edge of the box before that as Gomes pushes Mateus Fernandes as he makes a run into the box.
It has been revealed that well this is the last thing Spurs would have wanted. Minutes before half-time Manzambi puts the vistors in front.
It has been revealed that robertson slides to try and stop a ball going out for a corner but he only finds McGinn. He sends it into the box and finds Kamara, who takes a shot. It bounces towards goal and Manzambi pokes it past Kinsky for the lead.
According to recent reports, van de Ven is off the pitch on his feet, sporting an impressive bruise now. Spurs are down to 10 as they try to get the swelling down.
There will be five minutes added, though play is yet to resume as van de Ven receives treatment for a cut below his eye.
The last thing Spurs need now is to be forced into another defensive change after losing Porro.
Wan-Bissaka picks up the ball sent out to him on the wing by Manzambi, who is fouled by Marmoush.
The free kick is outside the area, but McGinn takes looking goalwards.
Mings makes the run looking to get his head on it, but van de Ven goes up with him and gets there first to clear it, though the Dutch international takes a blow to the head and goes down for treatment.
It has been revealed that joao Gomes races forward, sending the ball to Ruggeri on his left. He tries to put it in the box, but it goes out the back off Archie Gray for Villa’s first corner.
In a recent development, mcGinn delivers but it comes off Solanke, who clears. No luck yet as we head towards half-time, despite plenty of action in front of goal.
Roberston again with a sliding cross that Lindelof sends out the back.
Another corner for Spurs, but it is headed away again by Mings, who gets up high. That’s Spurs’s seventh corner.
Great long ball from Robertson to try and find Marmoush but Suzuki comes far outside his area to control it with his chest on the bounce and play it away with his feet.
Villa get a free kick inside as Bentancur catches Manzambi, but the Swiss international goes down and receives some treatment on the pitch. He has to go off for a minute, but he is on his feet.
Sources indicate that but Spurs come again and it’s Tonali this time. He takes a shot from outside the area, and would have beaten Suzuki low on the right, but the shot is just wide.
Spurs get a corner, delivered by Savio, and it’s headed on to Solanke at the back post. He heads it towards goal but it’s blocked by Wan-Bissaka. Cries for handball, but it’s cleared.
Recent findings suggest that marmoush makes a very well-timed run to get on a long ball from van Hecke, and does well to stay onside. But his first touch is not good enough and Suzuki can come to collect.
Recent findings suggest that jackson picks up a ball from Kamara, played over him into the Spurs half. He puts it into the centre of the field towards Buendia, who tees up Manzambi but his shot from distance sails over the bar.
Villa now having a spell. Manzambi gets onto a loose ball in midfield and lays it off to Buendia who feeds Jackson in the centre of the field. He does well to keep the ball down and turn round van Hecke to take a shot on the edge of the area, but he skews his shot wide.
He should be hitting the target at least from there but you can see how desperate both sides are to get their noses in front here.
Recent findings suggest that jackson gets around Gray and runs into the box on the left side. He pokes a ball through to Buendia, who takes a shot on goal at the near post, but Kinsky gets down to his left to stop the shot.
It has been revealed that mings almost causes a catastrophe for Villa as he and Lindelof close a loose ball down. Suzuki comes out to claim, but the defender pokes it towards him, almost past him under pressure and the keeper has to send it out the sideline.
In a recent development, four huge saves by Suzuki as Spurs have had five early shots in total to Villa’s single shot on target. They are finding a lot of joy against the left side of Villa’s defence.
Fernandes has an attempt from distance, but drags his shot wide.
Well Spurs are really pushing for a goal!
It’s a perfect first involvement for Gray, as he times a perfect run to get behind Ruggeri to pick up a ball from Savio. He lets it run inside the box but it flashes across the face of goal, just tipped away by Suzuki.
Another attempt denied immediately after as Savio connects perfectly with the volley on the edge of the area, and Suzuki dives down to his left to parry away.
Incredible start for the Villa keeper and Spurs can smell a goal coming.
Spurs had started on the front foot, but let’s see how they handle this change.
Porro went straight down the tunnel when he went off. It was a problem with his left leg. That’s a blow for Spurs, as Porro offers an attacking threat.
It has been revealed that early concern for Spurs as Porro has gone down and is looking very frustrated. Archie Gray has gone out to warm up, but this is a huge blow for De Zerbi if Porro has to come off.
He had been missing due to a muscle injury but it’s not clear if that’s the problem here. He has been very good so far today, helping build play and bringing huge amounts of experience.
And a shot on target next for Villa as Manzambi has an effort from just inside the 18-yard box off his left foot, but Kinsky makes a relatively easy save as the ball boucnes towards him.
Villa get their first chance, as Jackson races down the left side but van de Ven is content to stay close and as no Villa players follow him into the box, van Hecke is the one who clears his cross into the box.
Suzuki has been good with his feet since joining Villa, but he’s kicked about three balls straight out of play so far today.
Recent findings suggest that no wonder De Zerbi had his t-shirt pulled over his head. Tottenham looked certain to score their first Premier League goal of the season through Savio. Suzuki didn’t know too much about the first shot, which hit him, but reacted well to tip the second over.
Outstanding from the Villa keeper!
Tonali crosses a great ball in from the left and Savio has two great chances from close range but Suzuki blocks the first with his chest and tips the second over the bar.
The corner, delivered by Savio, is headed out by Mings and Villa keep control.
Suzuki plays a long ball out down the field, and as Jackson and van de Ven tussle to reach it, the defender is shoved to the floor and gets the free kick.
Sums up the early battles so far.
Spurs are putting a lot of pressure on Villa as they try and play the ball out, and McGinn loses the ball again in midfield. Spurs surge forward again but Mings gets his head onto the ball crossed into the box and Villa survive again.
Savio takes but it is headed out. It falls to Porro outside the box who lifts another ball in, but the Villa line holds firm and clears for a throw in from the left side.
Marmoush tries to run into the box but a well-time challenge by Kamara gets the ball off him.
Villa lose the ball in midfield and it’s played up to Solanke. Lindelof comes across well but concedes a corner.
And we are underway in north London!
According to recent reports, watch for some long balls from Tyrone Mings down the channels for Nicolas Jackson today. The pair had a little chat before kick-off with Jackson seemingly telling Mings where he wants the ball released to.
Tottenham XI: Kinsky, Porro, Van Hecke, Van De Ven, Robertson, Tonali, Bentancur, Savio, Fernandes, Marmoush, Solanke.
Subs: Dubravka, Tosin, Senesi, Gallagher, Maddison, Udogie, Gray, Bergvall, Kudus.
Tottenham XI: Kinsky, Porro, Van Hecke, Van De Ven, Robertson, Tonali, Bentancur, Savio, Fernandes, Marmoush, Solanke.
Subs: Dubravka, Tosin, Senesi, Gallagher, Maddison, Udogie, Gray, Bergvall, Kudus.
Both teams are coming out of the tunnel now, greeted with plenty of noise from the home and away fans.
The stakes are very high for a match so early on the season and kick-off here we come!
This is the second fixture of the week, as Brentford stormed past Chelsea last night 3-0.
Coming up this weekend for you:.
Everton vs Ipswich Town (Sat 3pm).
Nottingham Forest vs Coventry (Sat 5.30pm).
Bournemouth vs Liverpool (Sun 2pm).
Led out by the skipper 🫡 pic.twitter.com/5MLh8ZpvU4.
It's almost time ⏰#COYS pic.twitter.com/EewgmTnngl.
Just heard on TNT that Newcastle have won more games at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in 2026 than Tottenham have...
An early goal here for Villa could be catastrophic for the home team.
Neither club have had any players called up for England, but plenty of players will be leaving to join up with their national teams abroad.
From Spurs, Pedro Porro has retained his place in Spain’s squad. Both Micky van de Ven and Jan Paul van Hecke have been called up for the Netherlands and goalkeeper Antonin Kinsky will join the Czech Republic squad, still awaiting his first senior cap.
In a recent development, among the Villa players to receive call-ups, Johan Manzambi will be leaving to join the Switzerland squad, while captain John McGinn has been called up for Scotland once again. Zion Suzuki will leave to join Japan in the three-week break as well.
No Mathys Tel in the Spurs squad. De Zerbi has given him plenty of chances, but Tel has always been one of the first players the head coach has criticised this season.
"I don't see any player that would strike fear into me."Steven Gerrard and Glenn Hoddle give their thoughts on Spurs' transfer business and current squad 💰🎙️ @lynseyhipgrave1 | 📺 Stream now on TNT Sports & HBO Max pic.twitter.com/eM22XDDAjs.
Industry observers note that who is the superstar that Spurs need? Join the conversation and let us know who you think is the missing piece in the comments section.
Recent findings suggest that “We have to improve in everything, because like I remarked, after the game we conceded the first goal in a bad way, because we knew what was the strategy in the defensive phase. One long ball on Gakpo is not enough to concede a goal. Also the second goal could have closed Gakpo better and stronger, and the third goal is an individual skill of Szoboszlai.
Recent findings suggest that “We can improve in the qualities of the play. I think we created more chances than the other games, also because Liverpool played with more courage.
“There was more space to attack, to make one-to-one, but I have experience enough to say that sometimes when you are the coach of the team, without you knowing the reason, you are able to score, you can score. And other times, another situation where I think you are playing well, not fantastic, but well enough to score, enough to win, and you don’t win.
“You have to stay calm, to be confident in what you are doing, what the players are doing. They have my full confidence. We move on and we keep going to be better day by day, but not by words, but by fact.”.
“Similar, like us, but their potential is a huge potential. They signed, spending, a lot of very good players, but they need as well, time to get compact everything and to achieve understanding their idea.
Industry observers note that “Of course, (Roberto) De Zerbi, he’s a fantastic manager. He played fantastic football here and performed fantastic here in Brighton. He did a fantastic job before as well, in Shakhtar, and in Italy, and after Brighton, a fantastic job in Marseille.
“And now, when I can watch them, they are in this process, but of course, they are getting better, they compete fantastic, even losing against Liverpool.
Recent findings suggest that “Of course, being very, very demanding defensively for us, trying to impose and dominate our moment with the ball as well during the game. This is the challenge. Of course, Tottenham, I expect them to be in the top four.”.
It has been revealed that two changes for Villa from the side that lost to Nottingham Forest, with Johan Manzambi and Joao Gomes entering the mix. It’s a first full debut for Manzambi since joining the club from Freiburg over the summer. Gomes returns having served his suspension following a red card against Brighton on the opening weekend.
Representing Aston Villa ✊ pic.twitter.com/5xnjiPnRny.
Only one change from the team that faced Everton, as Pedro Porro returns to the starting XI, replacing Archie Gray. Carabao Cup goal-scorer Connor Gallagher is on the bench.
Our Spurs side to face Villa 📋🔢 @krakenfx pic.twitter.com/Xgpl4Hx9VV.
Good afternoon and welcome to our coverage of today’s bottom-of-the-table epic: Tottenham Hotspur vs Aston Villa. This tie is incidentally the match-up between the last two winners of the Europa League, though so far neither of them have looked like European champions.
It is definitely fair to say that this season has not started the way either of these teams would have wanted, as the host side currently sit in what is apparently their favourite position – 17th – and the visitors are all the way in 19th, only above Coventry.
Despite getting off to a fairly convincing start in the Champions League with a 3-2 win over Club Brugge, Villa only scored their first league goal last week in their match against Nottingham Forest, though it was a futile one as they still lost 2-1 at Villa Park.
Tottenham meanwhile are still waiting for their first league goal, despite putting one past Liverpool in their 3-1 defeat in the Carabao Cup third round. With no European football and already out of one cup competition, Roberto De Zerbi has only the FA Cup in January and the rest of the league season to drag Spurs out of the perpetual rut they appear to find themselves in. They sit only one point above Villa as they have been able to see out two 0-0 draws – against Everton and Nottingham Forest – instead of one.
Sources indicate that there has been plenty of talk about the money spent by both teams, without the results yet to show for it. The total sits around half a billion between them, adding to the mounting pressure on both De Zerbi and Unai Emery. Summer signings for both teams have struggled to land, something which will not be helped by the upcoming international break.
But before then, the teams have 90 minutes to try and get their seasons up and running, and we will be bringing you the team news, lineups and all the action from the match! Stay tuned!
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (20 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Our fan panel look towards the January transfer window and the positions they'd be looking at.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (20 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Adilson Malanda gave an interview in his native France about life at Middlesbrough and future goals.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (16 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
Andy Burnham has urged caution over scrapping the Saturday 3pm football blackout.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (19 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
The Coventry City winger will be hoping for his first Japan start since June 2021.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (15 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Kieran Scott and Chris Jones recently signed fresh contracts at Middlesbrough.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (23 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
The midfielder left the Sky Blues at the end of his contract and is now with League Two Rochdale.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (13 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Kim Hellberg likes to regularly tweak his Middlesbrough team.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (28 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
A number of Premier League clubs are mentioned to be monitoring the striker while one report claims an astronomical price tag has been set.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (19 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
The popular midfielder is yet to make a Premier League start for the Sky Blues.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (14 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Former Middlesbrough star Hayden Hackney can represent England and Scotland.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 23 min read (4600 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

By NATHAN SALT - FOOTBALL REPORTER.
Published: 07:00 EST, 13 November 2026 | Updated: 11:11 EST, 14 November 2026.
Walking into a club in turmoil is nothing latest for Mauricio Pochettino.
He arrived at Southampton with the Saints three points clear of the relegation zone. Tottenham Hotspur were crying out for some leadership after Andre Villas-Boas and Tim Sherwood's spells, while Chelsea picked up Pochettino in 2023 on the back of their lowest league finish for more than 25 years.
Recent findings suggest that now it's Manchester United that require what Victor Wanyama once described as Pochettino's 'magic touch' – and they need it quick as they sit in the relegation zone with ten games played. Pochettino remains weeks removed from the January transfer window and has a number of first-team regulars out with long-term injuries, so his reputation of improving the players at his disposal will be put to the test.
He has developed a reputation for placing faith in youth – while at Tottenham, Pochettino handed 12 debuts to players aged 21 or under, more than any other manager.
Money will be tight and United look almost certain to miss out on next season's Champions League, which will make squad development significantly harder, so Pochettino will have to make do and mend with a lot of the current underperforming crop of players.
With all that in mind, Daily Mail Sport runs the rule over the 36 players Pochettino will be inheriting when he walks through the door at Carrington next week.
And you can scroll to the end of the article to have your say on who should stay, and who should go...
Mauricio Pochettino will rapidly have to assess which Man United players to discard.
Industry observers note that lammens won't be going anywhere. He is United's No 1 and despite a downturn in form this season, he's not become a bad goalkeeper overnight. Pochettino's trusted goalkeeping coach Toni Jimenez will almost certainly replace Craig Mawson to bring some fresh ideas.
Jimenez focuses a lot on developing goalkeepers to be comfortable as sweepers and playing higher up. That is a sore spot in Lammens' game – recently exposed by Bournemouth striker Evanilson – but proper coaching should help develop Lammens, just like Jimenez developed Hugo Lloris.
A summer arrival from Leeds United as a back-up goalkeeper. Pochettino has more notable problems than messing around with his No2.
Heaton is hugely popular at the club and while he doesn't play, he is viewed as a vital cog in the dressing room given his wealth of experience. He turns 41 later this season and has been busy preparing for life away from the pitch.
Heaton has completed courses on becoming a sporting director, as well as an executive leadership short course from Oxford University.
He also holds his goalkeeper coach B-Licence, A-Licence outfield, and a certificate of football management from UEFA.
According to recent reports, pochettino would be wise to keep Heaton in-house, even if not as a player. He is a respected figure who knows United inside out and that shouldn't be overlooked as Pochettino tries to build out a culture.
Senne Lammens (right) has made a shaky start to the season but will be going nowhere.
Dalot is highly respected by every manager that works with him for the effort he puts in, something that can't always be said of some of his team-mates.
But he is woefully short of the required quality to take United forward and he is not a comfortable fit for Pochettino's ideals, either.
Pochettino gets width in his sides via the full backs and that requires a relentless runner – which Dalot is – having quality both defensively and in attack, which Dalot does not.
Malo Gusto, who is keen to leave Chelsea and could become a key target for United, spoke of how Pochettino developed his game in 2024 when he stated: 'He helps us a lot. He has tried to show us the desire to win, to keep fighting against every team.
Recent findings suggest that 'He talks to us a lot about tactics, technique and everything. He is a good person as well. He tries to help us a lot on the pitch and off it. He is a good coach for this young team.
In a recent development, 'He is here for this. He knows he has to wake up our mentality, to wake up our desire to win everything.'.
United have neglected their back-line for years and it's time for a dramatic refresh, starting with shifting Dalot, who is under contract until 2028.
It is time for Man United to move on from Diogo Dalot - he is short of the quality required.
Noussair Mazraoui (Full back, 28).
Dalot has at least shown he has the engine to get up and down, which could offer a lifeline under Pochettino, but Mazraoui hasn't.
Full backs are essential to Pochettino's high-intensity, high press 4-2-3-1, and that's not a formula that suits Mazraoui's abilities.
Privately, sources close to the dressing room have suggested in recent weeks that Mazraoui, another under contract until 2028, is keen for a new challenge.
Matthijs de Ligt (centre back, 27).
Overhauling the defence is one of the main topics of conversation among agents and players right now but De Ligt's future is secure at Old Trafford.
He is under contract until 2029, with the option of a further year, and many figures behind the scenes believe he can bounce back from such a long period out with injury to be a success.
De Ligt's injury record, as well as the fact he isn't a natural fit for Pochettino's idea of the perfect, mobile centre back, makes him an intriguing prospect.
Strong in physical duels, he could become a key squad player.
Harry Maguire (centre back, 33).
Maguire has taken more criticism than most during his time at United and deserves credit for how he has overcome it.
His contract expires in the summer, with the option of a further year, and Maguire has described playing for United as the 'ultimate honour' so is unlikely to agitate to leave.
That being said, Pochettino puts a lot of emphasis on recovery pace given the high line he has favoured in the past and the Argentine's tactics have routinely exposed centre backs in transition, with speed essential to masking shortcomings.
Maguire would undoubtedly struggle in that department and while his physical profile would appeal, he stated earlier this year that he does not want to be kept around for 'sentimental value'.
In a recent development, 'I love this club. But it's got to be right for myself, it's got to be right for the club as well,' Maguire said in March before a one-year extension was triggered.
In a recent development, 'I don't want to be staying on sentimental value. I want to be staying because I want to be there and the club want me to drive the club forward still, and they feel like I've got a substantial part to play in it.'.
The prospect of a diminishing role, with United planning multiple defensive reinforcements, may see both sides agree it's time for a change.
After seven years it may be time for Harry Maguire to move on, with his contract expiring.
Lisandro Martinez (centre back, 28).
A player that looks to have one foot out the door after calling out director of football Jason Wilcox following the defeat by Atletico Madrid.
Sources indicate that it's funny, almost, given Pochettino's arrival should suit Martinez down to the ground. In theory, he is the exact type of player his compatriot would implore his bosses to recruit.
Pochettino puts huge emphasis on passing out from the back and Martinez is the best in that category among United's centre backs.
Pochettino is also incredibly intense, something Martinez has been for some time at United, sometimes to the group's benefit and sometimes to its detriment.
The Argentine's contract expires in the summer and while there is an option to trigger a further year to avoid a World Cup winner walking away for nothing, the expectation is that he won't agree to a latest one and his time at United is more likely than not drawing to a close.
He holds a desire to play in Spain and that may not vanish overnight. But if anyone can connect with Martinez about a longer-term role, it's a fellow Argentine.
VERDICT: Keep (but expect to go!).
Patrick Dorgu (Full back/winger, 22).
Has the potential to be the biggest winner of the Pochettino appointment.
Pochettino's full-back-turned-winger style totally plays into Dorgu's hands given both his engine and his comfort playing higher up the pitch. Look at the development of Danny Rose – who played more games for Pochettino than any other player – and Kyle Walker, as well as Sergino Dest with the USA.
Dorgu has a lot of the attributes Pochettino craves while he also remains raw enough that intense, but targeted, coaching could improve him.
He should immediately become one of Pochettino's go-to men.
Where there are concerns around Maguire's ability to play in a system which squeezes everyone that bit higher up the pitch, Yoro should thrive.
He showed against Villa, with a chase down to deny Nicolas Jackson a run on goal, that he possesses the necessary recovery pace.
Pochettino's centre backs need to be strong passers and Yoro can improve in this area, although he has shown a willingness to dictate with long diagonals, as well as burst through lines as a ball-carrier.
United need five reliable centre backs in the squad moving forward and Yoro can establish himself as the No1.
Given Pochettino's track record with young players, he should be really excited at becoming a key piece of the puzzle under him.
A reunion… but one that may not last very long.
In a 2017 book about Pochettino, Shaw revealed his desire to work under him again and that wish has now come true.
According to recent reports, 'With Southampton he achieved the impossible,' noted Shaw. 'We were one of the best footballing teams in the league... I do hope that I can play for him again one day. And I think he really wants me to play under him again.'.
Pochettino used to call Shaw his 'son' and their relationship has stayed strong over the years.
But Pochettino is also a winner and will be acutely aware that Shaw cannot maintain the levels that Pochettino will require from his full backs after years of injury problems.
Sources close to the player have suggested the potential for a one-year extension given the relationship with Pochettino, even if those same sources believe the time is right for a fresh start.
A long servant but not one that can take United forward from this lowest of ebbs.
Luke Shaw and Pochettino enjoyed success together at Southampton but the reunion won't last long.
Arriving as an Ineos project, United aren't going to cut their losses on Heaven just yet.
His strong passing ability will appeal to Pochettino and his coaches and he's worth a season of proper coaching to see how high or low his ceiling is.
Heaven can be reckless, particularly in his approach to tackling, but he's got a good physical profile and those who have worked with him have praised his approach to training and willingness to listen to coaches.
United are likely to go out and sign two upcoming centre backs in the summer – at least they hope to – but Heaven should get a shot at development as a bit-part player.
Wholly ignored despite a left back crisis this season, Amass is widely expected to be out the door in January.
It is hard to blame him, either, given United's decision to keep him around has stunted his development.
Amass is a strong crosser of the ball and, in time, could develop into a full back in Pochettino's vision.
But neither Amass nor Pochettino will have time to wait and see. With a left back high on the shopping list, to go with Dorgu's expected ascension, this relationship shouldn't last too long.
An academy player to keep an eye on.
Kamason has played both at right back and right wing for United's Under 21s and that plays massively into his hands in a bid to try and catch the eye of his upcoming manager.
The United youngster is a well-rounded full back that constantly looks to get forward, all while not neglecting his defensive responsibilities.
Kamason has trained regularly with the first team in recent months and that could be a sign of things to come under Pochettino, too.
United rolled the dice on Leon a year ago in a deal worth an initial £3.3million – but the move has not worked out at all.
The 19-year-old hasn't come close to making a first-team appearance and his agent has even suggested they are getting itchy feet despite sub-par performances for United's Under 21s.
According to recent reports, 'If there isn't a initiative to break into the first team between December and January, we'll look for a way out for him,' Leon's representative Renato Bittar admitted. 'A loan somewhere where he can compete, get playing time, and return to Manchester.'.
Having observed the academy teams closer than most in recent seasons, Leon hasn't shown anywhere near enough to merit becoming a project player for Pochettino.
Mount left for United in the same summer Pochettino was hired by Chelsea, so their crossover was minimal.
How much say Pochettino had in that decision remains unclear, perhaps it was insignificant, but now they will finally work together.
Mount feels disposable, not least because he hasn't registered a single assist in the Premier League for United since joining in 2023 for £60million.
With so many options ahead of him in those inverted winger roles, and with Bruno Fernandes and Youri Tielemans preferred as No 10s, Mount needs shifting.
Bruno Fernandes (Midfielder, 32).
Contract talks have stalled in recent weeks and months but an ambitious fresh manager could swing momentum back towards reigning Player of the Year Fernandes staying at Old Trafford.
The way Pochettino platformed Christian Eriksen and Dele Alli at Tottenham, as well as Cole Palmer at Chelsea, suggests Fernandes will get the role he needs to be at his very best.
Industry observers note that fernandes' mobility, and ability to run beyond his centre forward, is a strength, as is his vision to supply team-mates in open play and at set-pieces. If Fernandes plays well, so do United, generally. Pochettino favours inverted attackers, so Fernandes could even start off the left if his manager wanted to position Matheus Cunha or Tielemans more centrally.
'He's given me the freedom to play my stuff and I like it when he frees you because I feel I can express my stuff more,' Palmer said of Pochettino's coaching back in 2024.
Sources indicate that 'I'm loving it. Every day he's talking to you about different things, not just football things but life things as well. He's good at making you feel good and trying to get the best out of you.'.
That's music to the ears of Fernandes.
Pochettino's free-flowing approach could be exactly what is needed to keep Bruno Fernandes.
Pochettino knows all about Santos having worked with him at Chelsea when he was a teenager still finding his way.
The reports at that time, during a pre-season tour in North Carolina and Philadelphia, were that Santos' profile appealed to Pochettino, only for the club to go ahead and sanction loan moves to Nottingham Forest and then Strasbourg.
Santos is a summer arrival for £50m and will get more time to find his role in this United side.
He has enough talent to become a reliable deputy to Baleba as the deep-lying midfielder when everyone is fully fit.
Youri Tielemans (Midfielder, 29).
Tielemans is a high-IQ player that signed a five-year contract in the summer so, truthfully, won't be going anywhere.
That being said, Tielemans' running power isn't there and the demands of a Pochettino system, if he is still the same coach that bowed out at Chelsea, may make that secondary midfield role difficult.
It feels like Tielemans could be a specialist player that Pochettino uses in games where his side expect to dominate possession.
Tielemans' composure on the ball is superior to that of many of his team-mates and that's not a trait Pochettino will overlook rapidly, even if he reportedly had reservations on a younger Tielemans when he was managing at Tottenham.
A big winner. The £70m summer signing needs to be used in the correct way to realise his potential and Pochettino's track record should be music to Baleba's ears.
Pochettino has typically liked one of his central midfielders to drop deep in possession to create a back three – see Eric Dier at Tottenham – and Baleba should be comfortable fulfilling that role.
Moises Caicedo and Wanyama are two other success stories in the deeper No6 role that Baleba should now thrive in under Pochettino's watch, with his combativeness and tackling making him a natural fit.
'Tactically, he has taught me a lot,' Wanyama previously remarked of Pochettino.
Recent findings suggest that 'Before, I was just thinking, "I'll just sit here and defend". But if you're playing for him, it's not only defending. You have to attack also. You have to know the right time. I have learned so much from him.'.
Now it's time for Baleba to study up and take his game to the next level.
Carlos Baleba has a had a slow start to life at United but a managerial change could unlock his potential.
It transpired that Pochettino wanted to make Ugarte his first signing at Chelsea, only for United to get in ahead of them for the Uruguayan.
Ugarte was all set to leave United in the summer were it not for a serious injury at the World Cup that left him sidelined for months.
Pochettino liked the profile of player he saw when Ugarte was scouted at Sporting Lisbon but he looks a different, far less effective, player in England.
Minds appear to be made up upstairs when it comes to moving on from Ugarte.
Where Baleba will need to drop deep, the other midfielder in Pochettino's system is the one who is expected to drive and bypass midfield blocks.
Pochettino will be acutely aware that Mainoo is extremely popular among United fans and while athleticism is often levelled against him as a weak point in his game, Pochettino will need to find a way of improving that while also nurturing his many talents.
Tottenham's Mousa Dembele was moulded by Pochettino from an attacking midfielder into a deep-lying controller, urged to dribble to break lines and open up the game.
Mainoo has many similar traits to others Pochettino has worked with, such as Weston McKennie with the US national team.
According to recent reports, 'They will get pushed in training more than the games they will be playing. It is all a mental thing,' former Southampton striker Rickie Lambert once stated.
If Mainoo can come through the initial boot camp, he can flourish.
Kobbie Mainoo is one of United's top talents and will stay but has to improve his physicality.
A better player than people give him credit for but one that really needs to put a full season together at first-team level to see where he is at.
That won't be under Pochettino at United but United, if they really believe he can be part of their future, need to find Fletcher a loan move where he can feature in 35-40 games.
Clubs in League One would be all over him.
Tyler Fletcher (Midfielder, 19).
The deep-lying midfielder that can drop in to form a back three is fundamental to how Pochettino wants to play and that's a style that would suit Tyler Fletcher, rather than the more attacking Jack.
Again, figures at United and up in Scotland, just want to see Fletcher get a run of games under his belt.
Kilmarnock wanted him in the summer, but United wanted to keep Fletcher in house.
If Pochettino and United really care about his career, he should be one of the first out the door on loan in January.
Senior academy figures are the most excited about Thwaites' potential, even if it would be unfair to expect him to make a significant impact on the first team in the near future.
Technically his level is particularly high, a European pass-first, press-resistant game that will appeal to Pochettino and his coaches.
But physically there is a way to go, which should mean Thwaites is kept around as a project player.
Brought in as an Ineos project piece, after two mediocre loan spells in Switzerland with Lausanne, it's time to have Kone come back into the building and put him to work with a relentless coach like Pochettino.
Kone's twitchy game-style and desire to break through lines makes him something of a hybrid of players Pochettino has coached in the past.
Having watched him up close in the academy set-up before he went out on loan, and spoken to those who coached Kone then, it would be a substantial gamble for Pochettino to put his trust in him.
It has been revealed that but Kone's ceiling feels sky high. It's time to see if he can go into the lab and come out as a Dembele-Wanyama hybrid.
VERDICT: Keep as project player.
Cristian Orozco (Midfielder, 18).
Physically he has an advanced profile for his age but United have long preached that they want to take things slow as Orozco settles into life in England and gets a grip of the language.
He is neat and tidy on the ball and has shown an ability to zip passes through the lines but not enough to suggest an elevation to the first-team group.
Academy football doesn't develop players quickly enough so a carefully selected loan move, perhaps in a technical league like the Netherlands or Belgium, would be ideal.
He needs to look at how Pochettino used players like Lucas Moura and Eriksen in the past to see how he can take his game to the next level.
Cunha has a swagger about him that United like and while he was better suited to Ruben Amorim's system than he was Michael Carrick's, Pochettino's preference for narrow wide players, funnelling them into central areas while full backs create the width, means this managerial shift should play into his hands.
'Cunha is a maverick who does things that are hard to find in some players,' Amorim once remarked of the Brazilian.
Recent findings suggest that 'He plays with the ball, but he has an aura that can do something to the opponent's heads. And that is really vital.'.
It was recently suggested to Daily Mail Sport that a move for Rashford could be explored as early as January, with a desire to go back abroad.
A managerial change always puts things into flux and not least given that Pochettino mentioned in 2022 that he'd 'always liked' Rashford, before adding: 'I think he's a great player. He just needs the confidence and for himself to believe, to put him at the top level. The quality is there for him.'.
Pochettino is unlikely to have changed an opinion as solid as that one in the years that followed and so it will be curious to see if Rashford could become the athletic, pressing No9 in Benjamin Sesko's absence.
Rashford wants to feel the love and has shown what he can do when his confidence is high. It isn't right now but don't bet against Pochettino showing him that love.
Rashford has been linked with another move away but could become a pressing No 9.
One of the more interesting profiles for Pochettino to consider.
On the face of it, Zirkzee lacks the intensity in the press and the mobility that Pochettino demands of his forwards.
Yet, Zirkzee can drop in, allowing the No10 to run in behind, which Pochettino values in a striker.
Sources indicate that in the long term, expect Zirkzee to depart. In the short term, Pochettino may see him as a very specific tool to exploit certain opponents.
Tenacious defensively after improving immeasurably out of possession under Amorim, that's a massive plus for Amad in the eyes of Pochettino.
He's among the glut of hybrid 10-wingers that United seem to stockpile and, once Sesko returns, Amad will find himself locked in a battle with Shea Lacey and Bryan Mbeumo for regular starts.
Amad's energy should give him the edge from day one to be a natural fit for Pochettino's high press.
Pochettino loves working with young players and Lacey is ready-made for that inverted winger style that the Argentine prefers, so he should be licking his lips at the prospect of more opportunities.
Lacey has played both off the right and as a No10 in academy teams and that stands him in good stead to operate in central areas, as well as isolate his full back one v one, which too many in this squad are not confident to do.
Lacey should be studying the development of Dele Alli under Pochettino and hoping he can bring his game on similarly.
Shea Lacey is (right) is a hugely promising youngster who will love working with Pochettino.
Like Cunha, Mbeumo looked a more natural fit in Amorim's two-10s system and there are similarities that could put him back in those positions under Pochettino.
He's played a lot as a No 9 and may need to deputise there for the time being but the long-term dilemma for Pochettino will be the battle between Mbeumo, Amad and Lacey cutting in from the right.
It's one of the few areas of the pitch where there will be decent competition for places.
Mbeumo will need to find a position and master it or he may be caught in between roles.
Injured until, most likely, the end of January and so it will take some time for Pochettino to get his teeth into Sesko's development.
The Slovenian feels very close to Pochettino's ideal No9 profile given his athleticism, physicality in the air, ability to press from the front and his instinctive finishing ability.
Benjamin Sesko could raise his level under a manager who routinely improves forwards.
Academy sources feel the teenager, who arrived for an initial £4million, has been unfairly criticised so far as he tries to adapt to a newly introduced club since moving up from Tottenham.
Thompson has picked up in recent academy games but in terms of his profile he looks more comfortable as a touchline winger, minus the blistering pace we usually see in that position.
His best bet is to remain in the academy and look towards a season-long loan next season.
One of the most intriguing academy prospects now that JJ Gabriel is closing in on a move to Real Madrid.
Ajayi looks physically capable of holding his own in first-team sessions and before a ball was kicked this term the development plan was to have him make a first-team debut before the season was out.
On-pitch failings may kick that can down the road but Ajayi is comfortable anywhere across the front line, has an acceleration that's invaluable and a technical level beyond his years.
Pochettino needs to take him under his wing to see what he can squeeze out of him before next summer.
VERDICT: Integrate into first-team training.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (249 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Today, a suggestion has emerged about Inter coach Cristian Chivu and the fact that he may have been an AC Milan fan in the past.
It’s no secret that lots of people grew up watching Milan as one of the best clubs in the world. Now, kids grow up with Paris Saint-Germain, Real Madrid and Barcelona dominating the world stage. However, once upon a time, that was Milan.
Sources indicate that read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
As a result, there will have been people who fell in love with the club due to their days of glory and have stuck around since and one of Inter’s most important figures could be among them.
At the presentation of Mauro Suma’s book, Federico Buffa shared an insight about Chivu and how, in the past, he fell in love with the Diavolo, as PianetaMilan relays.
“Chivu lived on the border between Romania and Serbia, and in Romania they weren’t broadcasting the European Championship. His father, through an antenna system, managed to pick up the Serbian signal and he saw Van Basten’s goal live, a goal that can’t be scored.
“From there, he, like many others around Europe in those years, became a Milan fan.”.
Recent findings suggest that after seeing Van Basten’s goal, it was an understandable reaction. Perhaps his former allegiance is why he’s not managed to beat Milan since taking over as the Nerazzurri’s head coach.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (14 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
Coventry City have seven players presently away on international duty.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (25 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Gazette Boro writer Craig Johns answers your questions on Boro, with Will Lankshear's injury and squad depth on this week's agenda.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (496 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Co

Swansea City sit 6th in the Championship table after a fine first quarter of the 2026/27 campaign. Vitor Matos has been hailed for his work in South Wales, but it has not gone unnoticed with overseas interest starting to gather pace.
On Monday, it was reported that French side RC Strasbourg had made an approach for Matos, and he was keen on making the switch. Now, reporter Ben Jacobs states that the Swans boss is now expected to become the new manager of the Ligue 1 club.
Matos has been in charge of Swansea City for just shy of a year. He was appointed from Maritimo on November 24th and his contract with the Championship club runs until 2030, so Strasbourg will be paying a compensation fee to secure his services.
For the first time in a while, it felt as though Swansea City had a really good thing going under Matos. He impressed last season after taking charge, and he was backed well in the summer transfer window in a bid to take the side to the next level.
Their strong start to the 2026/27 campaign indicated they were well placed to return to the Championship promotion fight too. Form faltered before the break with four defeats in five games, but Matos would have been backed to turn things around again.
Sources indicate that the Swans have pressed brilliantly under Matos, and they’ve returned to the forward-thinking, stylish football that was on show throughout the 2010s. Now though, they seem set to lose their boss, and it marks a significant setback.
It remains to be seen just how quickly the move progresses from here, but it appears all signs point towards Matos leaving for Strasbourg.
Swansea City have certainly had more misses than hits in managerial appointments since dropping from the Premier League in 2018.
Graham Potter, Steve Cooper and Russell Martin marked three consecutive successes, both both Potter and Martin were poached. Between then, all of Michael Duff, Luke Williams and Alan Sheehan tried and failed to turn around the Swans’ fortunes.
In a recent development, matos has been a big hit though, perhaps giving home that the hierarchy can identify a strong replacement. The help of Jamestown Analytics will not go amiss as the South Welsh side face the tough task of filling the big gap left behind by a sudden managerial change.
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest Swansea City news in your inbox every morning.
Enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (14 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Callum Brittain is loving life under Kim Hellberg at Middlesbrough.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (25 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
The Sky Blues are back in Premier League action on Saturday when they welcome the bottom club to the CBS Arena.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (18 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
As Premier League interest in Will Lankshear increases, Boro have made their stance clear.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (14 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Coventrytelegraph
The 62-year-old spent 18 months in charge at Coventry City.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Get the full Middlesbrough FC Premium experience for less than 50p per week.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (15 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Middlesbrough picked up just one point from their last two games.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (16 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Max Arfsten has been used in a number of since joining Middlesbrough.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (308 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Alexandre Pato is one of the greatest ‘What If’ players of his generation and AC Milan will always hold him in high regard.
It has been revealed that for many, even non-Milan fans, Pato is one of the defining players of the ‘What If’ term. The Brazilian had everything required to make him a modern great. Fantastic in front of goal, skilful, fun and genuinely exciting, he seemed like a potential world beater.
According to recent reports, read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
With the Rossoneri, there are only fond memories and he’s one that most will have loved growing up.
Sources indicate that however, his record with injuries prevented him from ever becoming the player that most hoped he’d be one day. Yet, the relationship never soured and he remains a fan favourite, even to this day.
Speaking to Luca Toni for the Prime special Fenomeni column, Pato responded to some questions about his injury troubles and one encounter with Alessandro Nesta in the dressing room, as MilanNews relays.
Recent findings suggest that “I remember that after yet another injury, Nesta came into the locker room furious and mentioned I shouldn’t have played. I have enormous respect for AC Milan, who gave me everything, but perhaps that moment could have been handled better.
“One of the things that hurt me the most, and which I’ve never spoken about before, was hearing people at the club say I’d never play again. That was sad, especially because as players, we know that a club is like a company, and if you don’t play, someone else comes in to replace you.
Industry observers note that “At that time, I couldn’t speak out, especially because I was young and didn’t understand. With today’s mentality, I’d handle myself differently.”.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 4 min read (820 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

Published: 16:25 EST, 13 November 2026 | Updated: 16:42 EST, 14 November 2026.
The goalkeeper involved in the collision that killed Spanish footballer Jesus de Miguel has been hit with a 12-match ban - but may never play again.
FC Andorra goalkeeper Jesus Owono has been sanctioned after a horrifying foul with Tenerife's De Miguel earlier this month.
Owono was sent off and the match was abandoned with De Miguel, 30, admitted to intensive care, where he later died.
The goalkeeper was subjected to chants of 'murderer' by Tenerife supporters and retreated from public view amid the significant backlash.
Now his manager Carles Manso has stated: 'We will give him space so that he feels completely free to make any decision, whether he wants to return, when, or if he does not want to return.
'When he feels it is appropriate and when he feels genuinely ready to take a decision like that [he will do so].
Andorra goalkeeper Jesus Owono has been banned for 12 games and could quit football for good after he collided with Tenerife's Jesus De Miguel, who died.
The striker was struck in the chest by Owono's flying knee as the keeper attempted to clear the ball near the halfway line.
De Miguel was rushed to hospital following the incident after appearing motionless on the pitch.
'What we have to do is support him in every way and be close to him.'.
Earlier this month, Owono issued a statement describing his 'enormous pain' following the tragic on-field collision.
According to recent reports, owono said: 'These are being the most difficult days of my life. I am struggling to find the words and find it very difficult to assimilate anything that has happened.
'I feel an enormous pain for the loss of Jesús. I think of him, his family, and everyone who loved him. I know there will be many issues to address; I will face whatever comes with the utmost respect.
'But right now, honestly, I cannot think of anything else except Jesús and the pain we are experiencing. Rest in peace, Jesus.'.
The tragedy occurred as the game entered the seventh minute of stoppage time, when De Miguel looked set to race away on the counter-attack for Tenerife in search of a winner.
As he watched a long ball drop into his path, the striker was struck in the chest by Owono's flying knee as he attempted to clear the ball near the halfway line.
After initially rolling around on the floor, De Miguel became motionless, and medical staff rushed onto the pitch to attend to him.
Police are investigating the death of De Miguel due to protocol, and they are also now probing the emergency medical response.
Owono noted he could not 'think of anything else except Jesús and the pain we are experiencing' (Source: Instagram/Jesus Owono).
Tenerife striker De Miguel died in the morning following the horrifying clash with Owono.
Owono was initially given a red card for the challenge before the decision was soon taken by the referee to abandon the fixture.
De Miguel was seen to for over five minutes while his team-mates were visibly distressed, with some appearing to be in tears.
The stadium had been in complete silence while De Miguel was being treated, but as he was taken off the pitch the striker was given a standing ovation by the crowd.
He had become a father just last year, and according to El Espanol, his wife and baby daughter were watching in the stands as the fatal incident occurred.
After being taken to an ambulance on a stretcher, there is believed to have been an approximate 15-minute wait before they made their way to the hospital.
De Miguel is believed to have suffered a cardiac arrest while being transported to hospital and had to be revived inside the ambulance, according to Spanish media outlet Marca.
Spanish newspaper AS reported that De Miguel's team-mates had travelled to hospital after he had been taken to intensive care.
In a statement, CD Tenerife confirmed the striker's death, saying: 'Broken with pain, with a lump in our throat and unable to believe that this is true, from CD Tenerife we communicate the tragic death, this Tuesday, November 3, 2026, at 8:00 a.m., of Jesus de Miguel Alameda.'.
Tenerife stated: 'We are with his devastated family, with his loved ones, with all the people of Tenerife who today mourn this cruel outcome'.
'There are no words of comfort; there is absolutely nothing to mitigate this feeling full of sadness.
'We are with his devastated family, with his loved ones, with all the people of Tenerife who today mourn this cruel outcome.
'The family of Jesus de Miguel is grateful for each and every one of the expressions of support received, and also requests, from the bottom of its heart, maximum respect for his privacy, in these terrible moments.'.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (12 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Will Lankshear is Middlesbrough's key man this season.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (15 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Radek Vitek arrived at Middlesbrough this summer and replaced Sol Brynn.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (548 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Industry observers note that bolton Wanderers have made a positive start to life in the Championship since winning promotion in the summer. Steven Schumacher‘s Trotters sit seven points above the bottom three after 15 games; a good position, but they will know there is still a lot of work to do.
Recent findings suggest that despite their good start, BWFC have found a number of problems that they will have to fix if they want to remain in the Championship. One of those issues has been depth in midfield, with Schumacher’s squad containing just five players they deem ready to play in the central areas.
Recent findings suggest that attacking midfield has been a particularly unsettled area, with Atsuke Ito and Ruben Rodrigues failing to lock down the position. One solution would be to make a loan move for Middlesbrough’s Leo Castledine.
According to recent reports, the 21-year-old has featured in just eight games for Boro, and with Kim Hellberg‘s side hunting promotion, it seems unlikely that he will force his way into the starting picture. It means the door is ajar for Bolton Wanderers to swoop in and pick up a player who could help them avoid relegation.
It has been revealed that for Schumacher and co, it is all about staying in the Championship this season. Depth in all areas will be key to do just that, and Bolton Wanderers need it in the attacking midfield role.
The Trotters play a 4-2-3-1 formation that utilises a single attacking midfielder. Ito and Rodrigues have been the main two players to play the role, with three goals coming from the pair. The problem is, both have spent time on the injury table, and neither player has hit the heights Schumacher needs.
Castledine, who showed just what he can do at the position with Huddersfield Town in 2025/26, would slot in not only as welcome depth, but as a player who knows the role inside out.
Castledine’s move from Chelsea to Middlesbrough has not yet worked out and Boro have other priorities this season. He has not found a regular role and with promotion at the forefront of Hellberg’s mind, moving the 21-year-old on to strengthen his squad and help the player develop suits all.
That opens the door for Bolton Wanderers to pick up a quality player in an area of need for a low-cost deal. It satisfies all parties, including Castledine’s need for regular football and Middlesbrough’s desire to add quality as they push for the Premier League.
Other clubs are sure to be lurking, but BWFC could be a great destination for Castledine as he looks for a chance to prove his ability in the Championship.
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest Bolton Wanderers news in your inbox every morning.
Enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (16 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Middlesbrough failed to win their last two games before this current break.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (12 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Blackburn Rovers released a statement on Tuesday morning.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (25 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The highly-rated teenager moved to the Tigers amid what was a whirlwind few days at the end of the transfer window.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (15 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Swansea City are due to visit the Riverside next Tuesday evening.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 28 min read (5570 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Nature

In a recent development, the scarcity of terrestrial rocks older than 3.9 billion years (Gyr) has hindered our understanding of Earth’s early evolution, fuelling persistent debates on how and when the first continental crust formed and plate tectonics started. At present, the only unequivocally documented >3.9-Gyr-old rocks are from the Acasta Gneiss Complex, Canada1,2,3. Here we report a 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss from eastern Hebei, North China Craton, in which primary magmatic zircon records elevated δ18O values (average +6.77 ± 0.23‰) and positive εHf(t) values (weighted mean +1.45 ± 0.27). This suggests a low-temperature altered basaltic source that originated from a mantle depleted in the Hadean. In contrast to the low-pressure origin inferred for the roughly 4.0-Gyr-old Idiwhaa unit in Acasta2, the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss reported here exhibits geochemical signatures attributed to a high-pressure origin4. Thermodynamic and trace element modelling demonstrate that its parental magma formed by means of low-degree (8–16%) melting of basaltic crust at >1.6 GPa and 740–820 °C, suggesting rapid burial of (near-)surface-altered oceanic crust to mantle depths along a cool thermal gradient. We propose that this rapid burial was most likely achieved through a transient subduction event.
This is a preview of subscription content, access via your institution.
Access Nature and 54 other Nature Portfolio journals.
Get Nature+, our best-value online-access subscription.
Receive 51 print issues and online access.
Prices may be subject to local taxes which are calculated during checkout.
All data are available in the supplementary tables of this manuscript. These tables are available in the Zenodo repository (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22911249; ref. 93). Source data for the figures are provided with this paper.
It has been revealed that bowring, S. A. & Williams, I. S. Priscoan (4.00–4.03Ga) orthogneisses from northwestern Canada. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 134, 3–16 (1999).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that reimink, J. R., Chacko, T., Stern, R. A. & Heaman, L. M. The birth of a cratonic nucleus: lithogeochemical evolution of the 4.02–2.94 Ga Acasta Gneiss Complex. Precambrian Res. 281, 453–472 (2016).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Reimink, J. R., Chacko, T., Stern, R. A. & Heaman, L. M. Earth’s earliest evolved crust generated in an Iceland-like setting. Nat. Geosci. 7, 529–533 (2014).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, moyen, J.-F. The composite Archaean grey gneisses: petrological significance, and evidence for a non-unique tectonic setting for Archaean crustal growth. Lithos 123, 21–36 (2011).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
O’Neil, J., Carlson, R. W., Francis, D. & Stevenson, R. K. Neodymium-142 evidence for Hadean mafic crust. Science 321, 1828–1831 (2008).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, sole, C. et al. Evidence for Hadean mafic intrusions in the Nuvvuagittuq Greenstone Belt, Canada. Science 388, 1431–1435 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that augland, L. E. & David, J. Protocrustal evolution of the Nuvvuagittuq Supracrustal Belt as determined by high precision zircon Lu–Hf and U–Pb isotope data. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 428, 162–171 (2015).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that shimojo, M. et al. Occurrence and geochronology of the Eoarchean, ~3.9 Ga, Iqaluk Gneiss in the Saglek Block, northern Labrador, Canada: evidence for the oldest supracrustal rocks in the world. Precambrian Res. 278, 218–243 (2016).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that cates, N. L. & Mojzsis, S. J. Pre-3750 Ma supracrustal rocks from the Nuvvuagittuq supracrustal belt, northern Québec. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 255, 9–21 (2007).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Nutman, A. P. et al. Fifty years of the Eoarchean and the case for evolving uniformitarianism. Precambrian Res. 367, 106442 (2021).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that harley, S. L. & Kelly, N. M. in Developments in Precambrian Geology Vol. 15 (eds van Kranendonk, M. J. et al.) 149–186 (Elsevier, 2007).
Liu, D. Y., Nutman, A. P., Compston, W., Wu, J. S. & Shen, Q. H. Remnants of ≥3800 Ma crust in the Chinese part of the Sino-Korean craton. Geology 20, 339–342 (1992).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that ge, R., Zhu, W., Wilde, S. A. & Wu, H. Remnants of Eoarchean continental crust derived from a subducted proto-arc. Sci. Adv. 4, eaao3159 (2018).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, johnson, T. E. et al. An impact melt origin for Earth’s oldest known evolved rocks. Nat. Geosci. 11, 795–799 (2018).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, guitreau, M., Blichert-Toft, J., Martin, H., Mojzsis, S. J. & Albarède, F. Hafnium isotope evidence from Archean granitic rocks for deep-mantle origin of continental crust. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 337–338, 211–223 (2012).
Article Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that dong, C. et al. Newly introduced discovery of 3.84–3.64 Ga diverse granitoids in eastern Hebei, North China Craton: petrogenesis and significance. GSA Bull. 136, 5249–5261 (2024).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
OʼNeil, J., Boyet, M., Carlson, R. W. & Paquette, J.-L. Half a billion years of reworking of Hadean mafic crust to produce the Nuvvuagittuq Eoarchean felsic crust. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 379, 13–25 (2013).
Article Google Scholar.
Wang, D., Qiu, X.-F. & Carlson, R. W. The Eoarchean Muzidian gneiss complex: long-lived Hadean crustal components in the building of Archean continents. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 605, 118037 (2023).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that bennett, V. C., Brandon, A. D. & Nutman, A. P. Coupled 142Nd-143Nd isotopic evidence for Hadean mantle dynamics. Science 318, 1907–1910 (2007).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that rizo, H., Boyet, M., Blichert-Toft, J. & Rosing, M. T. Early mantle dynamics inferred from 142Nd variations in Archean rocks from southwest Greenland. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 377–378, 324–335 (2013).
Article Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, li, C.-F. et al. Differentiation of the early silicate Earth as recorded by 142Nd-143Nd in 3.8–3.0 Ga rocks from the Anshan Complex, North China Craton. Precambrian Res. 301, 86–101 (2017).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
In a recent development, liou, P. et al. Long-term isolation of Hadean mantle domains revealed from coupled 147-146Sm-143-142Nd systematics in the eastern North China Craton. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 638, 118761 (2024).
Article Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, vervoort, J. D. & Kemp, A. I. S. Isotope evolution of the depleted mantle. Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 53, 195–221 (2025).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Valley, J. W. et al. 4.4 billion years of crustal maturation: oxygen isotope ratios of magmatic zircon. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 150, 561–580 (2005).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that chen, R.-X., Zheng, Y.-F. & Xie, L. Metamorphic growth and recrystallization of zircon: distinction by simultaneous in-situ analyses of trace elements, U–Th–Pb and Lu–Hf isotopes in zircons from eclogite-facies rocks in the Sulu orogen. Lithos 114, 132–154 (2010).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Ge, R.-F., Wilde, S. A., Zhu, W.-B. & Wang, X.-L. Earth’s early continental crust formed from wet and oxidizing arc magmas. Nature 623, 334–339 (2023).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that koshida, K., Ishikawa, A., Iwamori, H. & Komiya, T. Petrology and geochemistry of mafic rocks in the Acasta Gneiss Complex: implications for the oldest mafic rocks and their origin. Precambrian Res. 283, 190–207 (2016).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that rollinson, H. Do all Archaean TTG rock compositions represent former melts? Precambrian Res. 367, 106448 (2021).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that liou, P. & Guo, J. Generation of Archaean TTG gneisses through amphibole-dominated fractionation. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 124, 3605–3619 (2019).
Article Google Scholar.
In a recent development, laurent, O. et al. Earth’s earliest granitoids are crystal-rich magma reservoirs tapped by silicic eruptions. Nat. Geosci. 13, 163–169 (2020).
It has been revealed that tiepolo, M., Oberti, R., Zanetti, A., Vannucci, R. & Foley, S. F. Trace-element partitioning between amphibole and silicate melt. Rev. Mineral. Geochem. 67, 417–452 (2007).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that kemp, A. I. S. et al. Hadean crustal evolution revisited: latest constraints from Pb–Hf isotope systematics of the Jack Hills zircons. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 296, 45–56 (2010).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Amelin, Y., Kamo, S. L. & Lee, D.-C. Evolution of early crust in chondritic or non-chondritic Earth inferred from U–Pb and Lu–Hf data for chemically abraded zircon from the Itsaq Gneiss Complex, West Greenland. Can. J. Earth Sci. 48, 141–160 (2011).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Hiess, J., Bennett, V. C., Nutman, A. P. & Williams, I. S. In situ U–Pb, O and Hf isotopic compositions of zircon and olivine from Eoarchaean rocks, West Greenland: new insights to making old crust. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 73, 4489–4516 (2009).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Wu, F.-Y., Zhang, Y.-B., Yang, J.-H., Xie, L.-W. & Yang, Y.-H. Zircon U–Pb and Hf isotopic constraints on the Early Archean crustal evolution in Anshan of the North China Craton. Precambrian Res. 167, 339–362 (2008).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that vezinet, A. et al. Growth of continental crust and lithosphere subduction in the Hadean revealed by geochemistry and geodynamics. Nat. Commun. 16, 3850 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that rosas, J. C. & Korenaga, J. Rapid crustal growth and efficient crustal recycling in the early Earth: implications for Hadean and Archean geodynamics. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 494, 42–49 (2018).
Article Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that herzberg, C., Condie, K. & Korenaga, J. Thermal history of the Earth and its petrological expression. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 292, 79–88 (2010).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Johnson, T. E., Brown, M., Gardiner, N. J., Kirkland, C. L. & Smithies, R. H. Earth’s first stable continents did not form by subduction. Nature 543, 239–242 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, smithies, R. H. et al. Oxygen isotopes trace the origins of Earth’s earliest continental crust. Nature 592, 70–75 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Moore, W. B. & Webb, A. A. G. Heat-pipe Earth. Nature 501, 501–505 (2013).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that gerya, T. V., Stern, R. J., Baes, M., Sobolev, S. V. & Whattam, S. A. Plate tectonics on the Earth triggered by plume-induced subduction initiation. Nature 527, 221–225 (2015).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Baes, M., Sobolev, S., Gerya, T., Stern, R. & Brune, S. Plate motion and plume-induced subduction initiation. Gondwana Res. 98, 277–288 (2021).
Article Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that O’Neill, C., Marchi, S., Zhang, S. & Bottke, W. Impact-driven subduction on the Hadean Earth. Nat. Geosci. 10, 793–797 (2017).
Article Google Scholar.
Kitoga, L. S. et al. Silicified seafloor contribution to TTG formation: insights from zircon O and Si isotopes. Geochem. Perspect. Lett. 39, 22–27 (2026).
Article Google Scholar.
Griffin, W. L. et al. The Hf isotope composition of cratonic mantle: LAM-MC-ICPMS analysis of zircon megacrysts in kimberlites. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 64, 133–147 (2000).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Griffin, W. L. et al. Zircon chemistry and magma mixing, SE China: in-situ analysis of Hf isotopes, Tonglu and Pingtan igneous complexes. Lithos 61, 237–269 (2002).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Amelin, Y., Lee, D.-C., Halliday, A. N. & Pidgeon, R. T. Nature of the Earth’s earliest crust from hafnium isotopes in single detrital zircons. Nature 399, 252–255 (1999).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Black, L. P. et al. Improved 206Pb/238U microprobe geochronology by the monitoring of a trace-element-related matrix effect; SHRIMP, ID–TIMS, ELA–ICP–MS and oxygen isotope documentation for a series of zircon standards. Chem. Geol. 205, 115–140 (2004).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Wiedenbeck, M. et al. Further characterisation of the 91500 zircon crystal. Geostand. Geoanalytical Res. 28, 9–39 (2004).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Williams, I. S. in Applications of Microanalytical Techniques to Understanding Mineralizing Processes Vol. 7 (eds McKibben, M.A. et al.) 1–35 (Society of Economic Geologists, Inc., 1998).
In a recent development, nasdala, L. et al. Zircon M257 - a homogeneous natural reference material for the ion microprobe U-Pb analysis of zircon. Geostand. Geoanalytical Res. 32, 247–265 (2008).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that stacey, J. S. & Kramers, J. D. Approximation of terrestrial lead isotope evolution by a two-stage model. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 26, 207–221 (1975).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, ludwig, K. R. SQUID 1.02, A User’s Manual. Berkeley Geochronology Center Special Publication No. 2, 17 pp (2001).
Ludwig, K. R. User’s Manual for Isoplot 3.00: A Geochronological Toolkit for Microsoft Excel. Berkeley Geochronology Center Special Publication No. 4, 71 pp (2003).
In a recent development, ickert, R. B. et al. Determining high precision, in situ, oxygen isotope ratios with a SHRIMP II: analyses of MPI-DING silicate-glass reference materials and zircon from contrasting granites. Chem. Geol. 257, 114–128 (2008).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Wan, Y. et al. Extreme zircon O isotopic compositions from 3.8 to 2.5 Ga magmatic rocks from the Anshan area, North China Craton. Chem. Geol. 352, 108–124 (2013).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, coble, M. A. et al. Trace element characterisation of MAD-559 zircon reference material for ion microprobe analysis. Geostand. Geoanalytical Res. 42, 481–497 (2018).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Yuan, H.-L. et al. Simultaneous determinations of U–Pb age, Hf isotopes and trace element compositions of zircon by excimer laser-ablation quadrupole and multiple-collector ICP-MS. Chem. Geol. 247, 100–118 (2008).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that bao, Z. et al. Comparison of synthetic zircon, high-temperature and high-pressure sintered zircon and fast hot-pressing sintered zircon for in situ hafnium isotope analysis by LA-MC-ICP-MS. J. Anal. At. Spectrom. 38, 2313–2323 (2023).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that patchett, P. J. & Tatsumoto, M. A routine high-precision method for Lu-Hf isotope geochemistry and chronology. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 75, 263–267 (1981).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Thirlwall, M. F. & Anczkiewicz, R. Multidynamic isotope ratio analysis using MC–ICP–MS and the causes of secular drift in Hf, Nd and Pb isotope ratios. Int. J. Mass Spectrom. 235, 59–81 (2004).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Vervoort, J. D., Patchett, P. J., Söderlund, U. & Baker, M. Isotopic composition of Yb and the determination of Lu concentrations and Lu/Hf ratios by isotope dilution using MC-ICPMS. Geochem. Geophys. Geosyst. 5, Q11002 (2004).
Article Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that sláma, J. et al. Plešovice zircon — a new natural reference material for U–Pb and Hf isotopic microanalysis. Chem. Geol. 249, 1–35 (2008).
Article Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that fisher, C. M., Vervoort, J. D. & DuFrane, S. A. Accurate Hf isotope determinations of complex zircons using the “laser ablation split stream” method. Geochem. Geophys. Geosyst. 15, 121–139 (2014).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that söderlund, U., Patchett, P. J., Vervoort, J. D. & Isachsen, C. E. The 176Lu decay constant determined by Lu–Hf and U–Pb isotope systematics of Precambrian mafic intrusions. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 219, 311–324 (2004).
Article Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that bouvier, A., Vervoort, J. D. & Patchett, P. J. The Lu–Hf and Sm–Nd isotopic composition of CHUR: constraints from unequilibrated chondrites and implications for the bulk composition of terrestrial planets. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 273, 48–57 (2008).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that ickert, R. B. Algorithms for estimating uncertainties in initial radiogenic isotope ratios and model ages. Chem. Geol. 340, 131–138 (2013).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Furnes, H., Rosing, M., Dilek, Y. & de Wit, M. Isua supracrustal belt (Greenland)—a vestige of a 3.8 Ga suprasubduction zone ophiolite, and the implications for Archean geology. Lithos 113, 115–132 (2009).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that hoffmann, J. E. et al. Mechanisms of Archean crust formation inferred from high-precision HFSE systematics in TTGs. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 75, 4157–4178 (2011).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that O’Neil, J., Francis, D. & Carlson, R. W. Implications of the Nuvvuagittuq greenstone belt for the formation of Earth’s early crust. J. Petrol. 52, 985–1009 (2011).
Article Google Scholar.
O’Neil, J., Carlson, R. W., Papineau, D., Levine, E. Y. & Francis, D. in Earth’s Oldest Rocks 2nd edn (eds van Kranendonk, M. J. et al.) 349–374 (Elsevier, 2019).
Industry observers note that caro, G., Morino, P., Mojzsis, S. J., Cates, N. L. & Bleeker, W. Sluggish Hadean geodynamics: evidence from coupled 146,147Sm–142,143Nd systematics in Eoarchean supracrustal rocks of the Inukjuak domain (Québec). Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 457, 23–37 (2017).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, wasilewski, B., O’Neil, J. & Rizo, H. Geochemistry and petrogenesis of the early Archean mafic crust from the Saglek-Hebron Complex (Northern Labrador). Precambrian Res. 328, 321–343 (2019).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Vigneresse, J. L., Barbey, P. & Cuney, M. Rheological transitions during partial melting and crystallization with application to felsic magma segregation and transfer. J. Petrol. 37, 1579–1600 (1996).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Brown, M. Crustal melting and melt extraction, ascent and emplacement in orogens: mechanisms and consequences. J. Geol. Soc. 164, 709–730 (2007).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Rosenberg, C. L. & Handy, M. R. Experimental deformation of partially melted granite revisited: implications for the continental crust. J. Metamorph. Geol. 23, 19–28 (2005).
Article Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that xiang, H. & Connolly, J. A. D. GeoPS: an interactive visual computing tool for thermodynamic modelling of phase equilibria. J. Metamorph. Geol. 40, 243–255 (2022).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Holland, T. J. B. & Powell, R. An improved and extended internally consistent thermodynamic dataset for phases of petrological interest, involving a newly introduced equation of state for solids. J. Metamorph. Geol. 29, 333–383 (2011).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Green, E. C. R. et al. Activity–composition relations for the calculation of partial melting equilibria in metabasic rocks. J. Metamorph. Geol. 34, 845–869 (2016).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that white, R. W., Powell, R. & Johnson, T. E. The effect of Mn on mineral stability in metapelites revisited: new a–x relations for manganese-bearing minerals. J. Metamorph. Geol. 32, 809–828 (2014).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Holland, T. & Powell, R. Activity–composition relations for phases in petrological calculations: an asymmetric multicomponent formulation. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 145, 492–501 (2003).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that white, R. W., Powell, R. & Clarke, G. L. The interpretation of reaction textures in Fe-rich metapelitic granulites of the Musgrave Block, central Australia: constraints from mineral equilibria calculations in the system K2O–FeO–MgO–Al2O3–SiO2–H2O–TiO2–Fe2O3. J. Metamorph. Geol. 20, 41–55 (2002).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Loucks, R. R., Fiorentini, M. L. & Henríquez, G. J. New Magmatic oxybarometer using trace elements in zircon. J. Petrol. 61, egaa34 (2020).
Article Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that sobolev, A. V. et al. Deep hydrous mantle reservoir provides evidence for crustal recycling before 3.3 billion years ago. Nature 571, 555–559 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Shaw, D. M. Trace element fractionation during anatexis. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 34, 237–243 (1970).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, bédard, J. H. A catalytic delamination-driven model for coupled genesis of Archaean crust and sub-continental lithospheric mantle. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 70, 1188–1214 (2006).
Article Google Scholar.
Qian, Q. & Hermann, J. Partial melting of lower crust at 10–15 kbar: constraints on adakite and TTG formation. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 165, 1195–1224 (2013).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Xiong, X. et al. Partitioning of Nb and Ta between rutile and felsic melt and the fractionation of Nb/Ta during partial melting of hydrous metabasalt. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 75, 1673–1692 (2011).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Hulsbosch, N., Hertogen, J., Dewaele, S., André, L. & Muchez, P. Alkali metal and rare earth element evolution of rock-forming minerals from the Gatumba area pegmatites (Rwanda): quantitative assessment of crystal-melt fractionation in the regional zonation of pegmatite groups. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 132, 349–374 (2014).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Icenhower, J. & London, D. An experimental study of element partitioning among biotite, muscovite, and coexisting peraluminous silicic melt at 200 MPa (H2O). Am. Mineral. 80, 1229–1251 (1995).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Raimbault, L. & Burnol, L. The Richemont rhyolite dyke, Massif Central, France; a subvolcanic equivalent of rare-metal granites. Can. Mineral. 36, 265–282 (1998).
CAS Google Scholar.
Xie, H. et al. Data for “Hadean mantle depletion and 3.95-Gyr subduction implied by North China rocks”. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22911249 (2026).
According to recent reports, wan, Y. S. et al. Early Neoarchean (~2.7 Ga) tectono-thermal events in the North China Craton: a synthesis. Precambrian Res. 247, 45–63 (2014).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that chu, H. et al. The geological significance of the rediscovered fuchsite quartzite with abundant Eoarchean detrital zircons in eastern Hebei Province [in Chinese with English abstract]. Chin. Sci. Bull. 61, 2299–2308 (2016).
Wan, Y. S. et al. Discovery of early Eoarchean-Hadean zircons in eastern Hebei, North China Craton [in Chinese with English abstract]. Acta Geol. Sin. 95, 277–291 (2021).
It has been revealed that wan, Y. S. et al. Discovery of ~3.8 Ga TTG rocks in eastern Hebei, North China Craton [in Chinese with English abstract]. Acta Geol. Sin. 95, 1321–1333 (2021).
It has been revealed that ge, R. F. et al. A 4463 Ma apparent zircon age from the Jack Hills (Western Australia) resulting from ancient Pb mobilization. Geology 46, 303–306 https://doi.org/10.1130/g39894.1 (2018).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Barker, F. in Trondhjemites, Dacites, and Related Rocks (ed. Barker, F.) 1–12 (Elsevier, 1979).
Stracke, A., Genske, F., Berndt, J. & Koornneef, J. M. Ubiquitous ultra-depleted domains in Earth’s mantle. Nat. Geosci. 12, 851–855 (2019).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
We are grateful to E. Bell and M. Guitreau for their constructive feedback, which greatly improved the manuscript. We express our gratitude to C. Yang for making the zircon mounts. Z. Bao and J. Liu are thanked for their help with zircon SHRIMP U–Pb–O isotope and trace element analyses. We also thank Z. Bao, X. Qiu and X. Tong for assistance with the zircon Hf analyses and X. Wang and L. Tian for the zircon Cameca trace element analyses.
This work was supported by the Key Program of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (42130311), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (41872200), the Joint Fund of the National Natural Science Foundation of China (U2344210) and Deep Earth Probe and Mineral Resources Exploration - National Science and Technology Major Project (2025ZD1005300).
These authors contributed equally: Hangqiang Xie, Chunyan Dong.
Beijing SHRIMP Center, Institute of Geology, Chinese Academy of Geological Sciences, Beijing, China.
Hangqiang Xie, Chunyan Dong, Shoujie Liu, Dunyi Liu & Yusheng Wan.
College of Earth Sciences, Jilin University, Changchun, China.
State Key Laboratory of Critical Earth Material Cycling and Mineral Deposits, Institute of Continental Geodynamics, Frontiers Science Center for Critical Earth Material Cycling, School of Earth Sciences and Engineering, Nanjing University, Nanjing, China.
School of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Curtin University, Perth, Western Australia, Australia.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Y.W., H.X., C.D., P.L., S.L. and D.L. carried out fieldwork and sample analyses. R.G. and H.X. undertook the thermodynamic–trace element modelling. H.X. and C.D. wrote the draft of the manuscript. Y.W., R.G. and S.A.W. improved the text and data interpretation. All of the authors contributed towards interpreting and editing the manuscript.
Correspondence to Hangqiang Xie or Yusheng Wan.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Nature thanks Elizabeth Bell, Martin Guitreau and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
a, Geological map of the early Precambrian rocks in the North China Craton94, showing the distribution of Archaean and Palaeoproterozoic rocks. b, Geological map of the Qian’an-Lulong area (modified after refs. 95,96,97), showing the spatial distribution of the early Archaean Muchangkou–Shimen Complex, which includes the Muchangkou Complex in the Huangbaiyu area and the Shimen Complex in the Labashan area16. c, Geological map of the Shimen Complex16. The complex is composed of Eoarchaean to Mesoarchaean granitoids and supracrustal rocks as enclaves of varying sizes in undeformed 2.5-Gyr-old potassic granite.
Recent findings suggest that a, View of the hill showing the outcrop location of the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss. b, The 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss is aligned parallel to the foliation in the 3.5-Gyr-old potassic granite gneiss and is intruded by 2.5-Gyr-old undeformed potassic granite. The locations of samples J2212, J2302 and J2303 are shown. c, 3.95-Gyr-old banded trondhjemitic gneiss (J2212). The light-coloured layers, commonly less than 1 cm in width, are considered to be deformed granitic veins. d, Trondhjemitic gneiss (J2302). e, Trondhjemitic gneiss (J2303). Compared with sample J2212, there are fewer veins in J2302 and J2303 and these were removed during sample preparation. f, Trondhjemitic gneiss (J2302) shows a granoblastic texture and is composed of plagioclase, quartz and biotite, with minor microcline. g, Trondhjemitic gneiss (J2303) has a similar texture and mineral composition to J2302, except for containing less biotite. h, 3.95-Gyr-old banded trondhjemitic gneiss (J2212) consists of different components. The lower right contains more K-feldspar (monzogranitic layer) compared with the upper left (trondhjemitic layer), consistent with the banded characteristics in the field. Both layers show the same foliation defined by oriented biotite flakes.
Sources indicate that a, 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss (J2302). b, Trondhjemitic gneiss (J2303). c, Banded trondhjemitic gneiss (J2212, including zircons analysed in two sessions from the same sample, marked as J2212A and J2212B). On the left are CL images and on the right are secondary electron images. MA and RC identify magmatic and recrystallized domains, respectively, whereas R represents overgrowth rims and grains newly formed during metamorphism. The analytical sites are marked with white circles, together with the analysis number and age. Secondary electron images show that the weakly modified zircons retain euhedral prismatic shapes, a typical characteristic of magmatic zircon. This feature is particularly evident in zircons from sample J2303, which have been less affected by metamorphism.
a, Zircon analyses of trondhjemitic gneiss sample J2302 define two concordant age groups at 3.95 Gyr and 3.45 Gyr, interpreted as the timing of magmatic crystallization and subsequent metamorphism, respectively. b, Most zircons in trondhjemitic gneiss sample J2303 are magmatic and cluster near 3.95 Gyr. Overgrowth rims show radiogenic Pb loss, including analysis 61.1R, which is the closest to concordia. c, Zircon analyses from banded trondhjemitic gneiss sample J2212 (including zircons analysed in two sessions from the same sample, marked as J2212A and J2212B) are more scattered, with the main population along a discordia line from 3.95 Gyr. However, several zircons with magmatic zoning yield concordant ages of 3.86–3.70 Gyr, potentially owing to the intrusion of thin granitic veins and/or partial resetting of the U–Pb system of 3.95-Gyr-old zircons. Analysis 63.1MA in J2212B has the oldest 207Pb/206Pb age of 3,989 ± 10 Myr but indicates slightly reverse discordance, probably because of local enrichment of radiogenic Pb during later metamorphism98. d, Concordia diagram of all samples for analyses with <20% discordance. The weighted mean 207Pb/206Pb age of 3,951 ± 3 Myr (95% confidence level, MSWD = 1.15, n = 33) for magmatic/recrystallized cores is considered the best estimate for the magmatic crystallization age of the trondhjemitic gneiss protolith.
According to recent reports, zircon Lu–Hf isotope analyses were carried out in two sessions. Circles and triangles represent the results of the first analyses and squares represent the results of the second analytical session. All of the magmatic/recrystallized zircons with >3.9-Gyr 207Pb/206Pb age have homogeneous 176Hf/177Hf ratios except for J2302-2.1MA, which has a high 176Lu/177Hf ratio. The magmatic/recrystallized zircons with <3.9-Gyr 207Pb/206Pb age in samples J2302 and J2303 are all located near the Pb loss line. Some newly formed zircons have much higher 176Hf/177Hf ratios, which may be related to external fluids introduced during metamorphism.
In a recent development, a–c, REE patterns of zircons from the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss (samples J2302, J2303 and J2212, respectively). The REE data were filtered using the methods suggested in ref. 26. d,e, Magmatic oxygen fugacity and H2O content of the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss. The oxygen fugacity (fO2) was calculated using the oxybarometer proposed in ref. 82 based on the average REE content of the filtered magmatic zircons. The magmatic water content was calculated using the hygrometer established in ref. 26 and the effect of U loss in the whole rock was corrected assuming a Th/U ratio of 5 (ref. 26). Considering that the composition of sample J2212 may have been influenced by alteration and the intrusion of thin younger veins, the average composition of J2302 and J2303 was used for calculating the fO2 and water content of J2212.
In a recent development, a, An–Ab–Or diagram99. Note that sample J2212 plots in the granite field owing to the presence of thin younger granitic veins. The homogeneous 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss (samples J2302 and J2303) is similar to the granitoids in Anshan and Nuvvuagittuq (mainly trondhjemitic gneiss) but different from those in Acasta, Tarim and Greenland (mainly tonalitic and granodioritic gneisses). b, Nb versus Ta diagram. c, Sr versus Y diagram. and d, La/Yb versus Yb classification diagrams for high-pressure, medium-pressure and low-pressure TTGs4. The 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss consistently plots in the high-pressure TTG field, being similar to the 3.72-Gyr-old Aktash gneiss in the Tarim Craton and some TTG rocks in Greenland but different from many other ≥3.8-Gyr-old granitoids around the world, which mostly plot into the medium-pressure and low-pressure TTG fields. Several samples from the literature that plot outside the ranges in b and d are not shown.
It has been revealed that a,b, LILE contents of the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss and potential source rocks (Supplementary Tables 6 and 7). The dashed red lines represent LILE contents required for the source to produce the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss by 7%, 10%, 20% and 30% melting, assuming that these elements are perfectly incompatible with bulk partition coefficient equal to 0. Considering that the degree of partial melting of a mafic rock source needs to be >7% for melt aggregation to form magma but <30% to match the high SiO2 contents of the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss, the LILE contents of the source need to be in the grey shaded area. Because the sources of Eoarchaean TTGs are from mafic rocks, we have compiled the geochemical data of Eoarchaean mafic rocks worldwide (Methods and Supplementary Table 7). Comparing the LILE contents of these mafic rocks with those required to form the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss, the amphibolite group I in Acasta is the most suitable source to use for modelling, consistent with the fact that it is the only mafic rock >3.95 Gyr old. c, P–T pseudosection for the composition of amphibolite group I from Acasta, assuming X(H2O) = 1.5 wt% and Fe3+/(Fe3+ + Fe2+) ratio = 0.1. The dashed white lines represent the wt% of melt.
Industry observers note that a–d, The red dot denotes the median sodic TTG composition4, which was assumed as the starting melt composition. Solid black and orange curves represent the effects of fractional crystallization of plagioclase and hornblende, respectively, whereas dashed black and orange curves represent the effects of accumulation of plagioclase and hornblende, respectively. Orange squares show the compositions of the 3.95-Gyr-old high-pressure TTGs from this study. Small dots represent melts produced by partial melting of the Acasta amphibolite group I (Supplementary Table 9), colour-coded by pressure. Comparison highlights that plagioclase accumulation and hornblende fractional crystallization can explain the positive Eu and Sr anomalies in our samples (a,b) but they fail to simultaneously reproduce the high (La/Yb)N and (Gd/Yb)N ratios and the high SiO2 contents observed in the rocks (c,d). By contrast, melts formed under high-pressure conditions match well with the main geochemical characteristics of the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic samples.
The positive εHf(t) values of magmatic zircons from the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss indicate that its basaltic precursor was young juvenile crust derived from a DMD. Even if the basaltic precursor (assuming 176Lu/177Hf = 0.022) was derived from a 4.5-Gyr-old DMD with a similar 176Lu/177Hf ratio (0.0384) to modern depleted mantle, its extraction time from the mantle could not be earlier than 4.0 Ga (solid blue line). If the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss was formed by partial melting of basalt immediately extracted from a DMD with similar 176Lu/177Hf ratio, then the timing of mantle depletion can be estimated to be about 4.35 Ga (dashed black line). Earlier depletion of the mantle is required if partial melting of a basaltic precursor occurred some time after its extraction from a DMD (dashed blue line) or the degree of depletion in the mantle is less than modern depleted mantle (dashed red line). If the basaltic precursor was derived from a possible ultra-depleted mantle proposed by some researchers100, the depletion can be slightly delayed. Nevertheless, the depletion still needs to be no later than 4.2 Ga even if the 176Lu/177Hf of the ultra-depleted mantle is as high as 0.041 (solid purple line). Therefore, a Hadean DMD is necessary to yield the Hf isotope composition of the 3.95-Gyr-old trondhjemitic gneiss.
A guide to Supplementary Tables 1–10 (tables supplied separately).
Supplementary Tables 1–10 – see Supplementary Information document for full descriptions.
In a recent development, springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
Sources indicate that xie, H., Dong, C., Li, P. et al. Hadean mantle depletion and 3.95-Gyr subduction implied by North China rocks. Nature (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11280-2.
Version of record: 11 November 2026.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11280-2.
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:.
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (20 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The ex-City head coach is out of work after a poor start to the new season.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 5 min read (1059 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Sempremilan

Recently, it’s felt like AC Milan have been set on signing Nicolo Tresoldi in the winter. It may be the easy option, but is it the right one?
Industry observers note that at a time when Milan are doing the PR side of things almost perfectly, Tresoldi feels like another easy win. It seems increasingly likely that Francesco Camarda departs in the winter mercato, so why not replace him with another Milanista?
Read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
Replace the boy who was destined to become king with another who seems further down the career line. He’s already scored a senior goal – or three – at San Siro and he’s got attention from all of Europe’s best clubs. However, if the Rossoneri came knocking, would he be able to say no to his boyhood club?
Well, here is the alternative view: maybe they shouldn’t knock at all.
According to recent reports, now, it’s unpopular to suggest that Tresoldi isn’t the right man, but stick with us here, especially after reports today. If you’ve not seen, Club Brugge have made a statement in the Belgian outlet Het Laatste Nieuws that they won’t be selling him in January.
It’s a ‘club policy’ and even for €60-70 million, he won’t be leaving Belgium. We’ve seen these kinds of statements become pointless in the past and this could become one of them. However, that’s not really the important thing here.
Recent findings suggest that instead, it’s that Tresoldi has now entered a new bracket. €50m in January is steep, but it’s workable. Ultimately, we’re not in record-breaking territory. Taking that €10-20m step upwards, though, that’s where we enter that territory. There’s also a possibility that more would be needed, too.
It’s a figure that Gerry Cardinale may not be afraid to spend. In fact, reports would have you believe that he really loves Tresoldi and sees him as a perfect addition to a strong frontline roster. However, that’s a lot of money on two strikers in one season.
Recent findings suggest that then, you’ve also got negotiations with Brugge to deal with. Historically, the Diavolo have found it difficult to close deals with them and with Tresoldi, it’ll be harder than ever, especially after the Ardon Jashari situation.
With the figures being discussed too, you can only imagine how small the margins will be.
Then, you have maybe the most difficult factor. Tresoldi, taking romanticism out of it, has only performed in, with respect, sub-tier leagues. Now, that’s not to take away from his records; scoring-wise, he’s been phenomenal and he’s matched it in the Champions League.
Industry observers note that however – and it’s a big however – we’ve already seen that it doesn’t always translate. For example, look at Charles De Ketelaere, but that’s not the real parallel here.
According to recent reports, here, we head to the parallel. In the summer just gone, Milan hired a latest Portuguese coach, who initially faced a few questions. After an up-and-down first half of the season, they find themselves in need of a statement January window and stumble upon a boyhood fan of the Rossoneri.
Industry observers note that stated fan is banging goals in for fun in a league outside of Europe’s top five, but there’s no need to panic as he’s performing in the Champions League, even against the biggest teams. So, the Rossoneri make the plunge.
Six months later, they try to sell him and a year after that, he’s on loan at Porto, with an €18m buy clause sitting in his deal, unlikely to be touched. Of course, that’s Santiago Gimenez.
There are differences between them, of course, but the formula has already been tried and the results speak for themselves. Trying it again, whilst enticing for the same romantic reasons as Gimenez’s arrival, may not be the answer.
Industry observers note that yes, Gimenez had issues with selection and injuries and eventually, both together. Nevertheless, even without these problems, it was a rushed deal and the Diavolo are going to be the ones paying for that rush next season.
Sources indicate that the point here isn’t to discredit the Mexican, but rather suggest that rushing to sign a romantic connection isn’t always the best way to spend major money. It’s about balance, which is why another striker signing like Nicolas Füllkrug wouldn’t be ideal.
Denying that Tresoldi could become a great would be naive, but it would also be as bad to ignore the reasons why the deal is becoming more of a gamble. At €50m, it makes sense, but we’re entering an echelon of deals that requires serious consideration.
In January, Milan would probably have to spend upwards of €70m and that wouldn’t guarantee them Champions League football. Nothing really will offer complete assurances in football; few things – if anything – are guaranteed. Yet, for that fee, it would be expected and you’re still not really addressing the challenges within the squad completely.
To do that, Cardinale would have to spend at least another €30-40m to satisfy the fanbase and that’s unreasonable halfway through a season.
Recent findings suggest that so, diversifying the money across the team and then reassessing in the summer may be the best route forward. After all, with this increased price demand, you’re hardly going to be paying more in the summer – and if their demands reach that amount, you’re voicing latest questions.
It has been revealed that with Markus Krösche also coming in, the January mercato will be one where everything has to be considered carefully and judgements will be made before February 1 rolls around. Spending so heavily on one target may also be an early and unnecessary strike on his record, if it doesn’t work.
For many, Tresoldi made sense in January because he’d be an investment at an investment price. Now, you’re looking at a major budget depletion for a striker who has yet to become a senior international and/or a regular goalscorer in one of Europe’s top five leagues.
Recent findings suggest that the romantic side of it is great; it’s difficult not to fall for that. Financially, though, signing Tresoldi is becoming a tougher sell and that’s where we might have to start listening to the brain rather than the heart.
📅 20 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 29 min read (5740 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

According to recent reports, andoni Iraola spun on his heels, turned his back to the action and began to bite his nails. Managers often envisage the worst outcome when the clock ticks down, and here, in the 93rd minute, Bournemouth had a corner.
It has been revealed that he needn’t have worried. As the set-piece was swung in, Alisson Becker moved powerfully off his line and plucked the ball from the air, a catch that essentially confirmed Liverpool would leave Dorset with three points. It was a catch, too, that put the gloss on another impeccable personal afternoon.
According to recent reports, when Iraola took charge at Anfield, one question he had to answer – given Bournemouth had conceded 167 goals in his three years in charge – was whether he could make Liverpool defensively resilient. This dour 1-0 success, though, proves he is taking them in the right direction: he is the first Liverpool manager since Joe Fagan in 1983 to start with five unbeaten league games.
Alexander Isak might have scored the goal that leaves Bournemouth winless in the Premier League but this success owed everything to Alisson’s enduring brilliance – a comment that also applies to Virgil van Dijk – the enormous promise of Jérémy Jacquet and the grit of Ronaldo Araújo.
You go to top level football matches hoping to see something that will take your breath away and how Alisson did that in the 17th minute with a reflex save from an Evanilson backheel, the shape of his body resembling a fielder in the slips diving to prevent a boundary.
It proved to be the foundation stone from which Liverpool were able to build and inflict Bournemouth’s first home defeat since January. There are plenty of [valid] questions to ask of Liverpool’s attack at present but, defensively, it is starting to come together.
Recent findings suggest that “It was a really good fight,” Alisson stated, in that self-effacing way of his. “But we have to improve a lot – on the ball and sometimes off the ball as well but we improved in the second half. We adapted to the opponent and that’s what we are doing.”.
In a recent development, any manager with a well-drilled defence stands a chance of improving and that is what Liverpool are doing. Only four weeks ago the discussion was about how easy it was for teams to play through their middle – remember that chaotic afternoon at Newcastle to start? – but that is changing swiftly.
Since Iraola replaced Jeremie Frimpong with Araújo at right-back, three consecutive Premier League clean sheets have followed. Araújo, the Uruguayan on loan from Barcelona, revels in doing the dirty work while Jacquet, the £60m signing from Rennes, oozes quality.
“He’s [Jacquet] very young and adapted really well to the Premier League,” Iraola noted. “The first games, he was physically feeling the change of rhythm and I had to sub him. This was a step forward. He looked solid until the end. He’s in a good place physically and I hope he can continue his development.”.
It has been revealed that don’t confuse positivity about one aspect of the team as being a guide to its collective health. There was always a chance this contest would become a cagey affair and, Evanilson’s chance aside, the opening 45 minutes were as flat as you could imagine.
Iraola again played his three £100m+ signings but Bradley Barcola is still adjusting to the physicality of English football and Florian Wirtz is still finding it difficult to impose himself on a game; patience with the German will not be infinite.
He would do worse than to look at Isak, who is now on a run of four goals in four league games and is influencing games in the manner Liverpool envisaged when they broke the British transfer record to sign him last August.
Isak had an unusual afternoon. His only shot in the first half almost took out some low-flying pigeons, a cross early in the second half was sliced so badly that the weekend hackers on the nearby Queens Park golf course would have felt a flood of sympathy but then he got his third opening.
Cody Gakpo, who could have been in Manchester City blue had the cards played out differently earlier this month, wriggled down the right flank and squeezed in a cross that Isak seized upon and turned in from six yards. Liverpool never looked back.
Industry observers note that alexander Isak grabs his fourth Premier League goal of the season! 🔴 pic.twitter.com/5ehwhl1it4.
Sources indicate that “A striker’s job is like this,” Iraola mentioned, who badgered Isak persistently to press Bournemouth’s defence. “He had a couple of crosses that he did not hit properly or control. He has to help us to be closer to the box, to play in the opposition’s half and have more meaningful possession. And then if the team is playing there, he will receive rewards in terms of goals.”.
In a recent development, one, ultimately, was enough to see off Bournemouth, whose start to the campaign is something of a riddle. They shouldn’t be anywhere near the relegation places but that is the reality and Thursday’s historic Europa League win in Real Sociedad couldn’t mask the home crowd’s frustration.
In a recent development, “Our attitude and effort is good,” head coach Marco Rose stated. “But, at this level, small things and little details decide games.”.
Speaking to Sky Sports after the match, Iraola said: “I’m obviously happy with the result because I know this is a difficult place to come, very difficult place to get three points. And we could see it, especially in the beginning of the game. In the first 20 minutes we weren’t at the level [required] and it cost us. We finished the first half better and in the second half we played better, but that beginning of the game has surprised us, not surprised us [because] we knew where we were coming but it [was] difficult for us.”.
According to recent reports, jeremy Jacquet has made the kind of quietly authoritative start to his Liverpool career that revealed why there was such excitement in February within the club when they completed his deal. So much focus on so many players but Jacquet has never been anything other 7.5/8 out of 10.
Industry observers note that "Let's go! One of many!" Virgil van Dijk giving Jérémy Jacquet his POTM award after Liverpool's 1-0 win at Bournemouth ⭐️ pic.twitter.com/6xWvjmrF8Y.
"That's a big moment to me to play with Virgil!" 🫡Jérémy Jacquet after Liverpool's 1-0 win at Bournemouth! pic.twitter.com/UsTimGME39.
It has been revealed that cody Gakpo has been Liverpool’s stand-out forward this term and he was at the heart of Isak’s goal this afternoon. Speaking about the job the Dutchman is doing to fill the void left by Mohamed Salah on the right flank, Ashley Young said on Sky Sports: “Players have to step up when you lose significant players and you get the opportunities. I think Cody Gakpo is doing that. He’s a bit fortunate [in the build-up to Liverpool’s goal] but you create your own luck. He gets the ball down the line, that’s what you want to do and he puts the ball in the box. That’s what Isak’s waiting for.”.
Fair play to anyone who retained Brobbey in their Fantasy Football teams this week...
4 - Brian Brobbey is the fourth player in Premier League history to score a hat-trick against the side starting the day top of the table, after Robbie Fowler v Aston Villa in November 1998, Dirk Kuyt v Man Utd in March 2011, and Romelu Lukaku v Man Utd in May 2013.Unstoppable. pic.twitter.com/vygVYazIQD.
Maresca’s side maintain their immaculate record, but boy were they made to work for it this afternoon.
Sunderland are still 5-3 down but have not given up the ghost. Surely the best match of the season so far?
Recent findings suggest that it ends goalless at Elland Road after Mitchell’s goal was disallowed for offside. Kamada went close to breaking the deadlock in the final stages...
Industry observers note that daichi Kamada can't guide his header on target! ❌ pic.twitter.com/AgKM6Q9apq.
Bournemouth lose at the Vitality for the first time in 13 matches as Iraola makes a winning return to the South Coast. Liverpool were hardly impressive, but to their credit they managed the final stages of this match with a minimum of fuss.
Andoni Iraola returns to the Vitality Stadium with a win! ✅ pic.twitter.com/FSgvE6EGFB.
Bournemouth are awarded a corner but Brooks’ delivery goes straight into the inviting gloves of Alisson.
Koumas pressures Petrovic, but the goalkeeper demonstrates off some tidy footwork to escape the danger.
Bournemouth cannot get out though, and Petrovic is forced into a routine save off Koumas moments later.
Bournemouth win a free-kick in a dangerous position after a handball, but Scott cannot get his strike up and down fast enough and it sails over.
Four minutes of stoppage time to play.
Haaland gets in on the act, but only after a VAR check. That should be that...
Erling Haaland has now scored against all 25 teams he has faced in the Premier League ✅⚽ pic.twitter.com/X9uqcrgbwk.
Araujo gets his pocket picked in the corner but Jebbison cannot compose himself and blasts his cross off the other side of the pitch.
Liverpool go the other way and win a corner, but Mac Allister puts too much air on his delivery and it is easily dealt with.
Rayan wins a free-kick as he holds off Kerkez on the halfway line. Bournemouth then switch play to the far side but Truffert’s speculative effort flies well over the bar.
According to recent reports, nyoni shows off his composure on the ball, playing simple passes on the half-turn to keep play flowing. The midfield area is quite congested, which suits Liverpool at this point in the game.
According to recent reports, liverpool are baiting Bournemouth’s press in an attempt to play around their front line. They are doing a good job at holding on to the ball and frustrating their opponents, for now.
Gravenberch and Koumas are on for Gakpo and Isak.
Industry observers note that brooks has brought some energy to Bournemouth’s forays down the left. He attempts to slip a ball into the left channel but Nyoni is wise to it and positions himself perfectly to cut it out.
In a recent development, liverpool have dropped deep and Bournemouth wait patiently for an opening. They eventually find Tavernier in the left half-space but his cross flies over everyone.
That is his last contribution to the match as Rose rings the changes: Tavernier, Smith and Christie make way for Brooks, Jebbison and Cook.
Truffert spins in a teasing ball from the left but Jacquet does well to flick the ball away from the danger zone.
It has been revealed that wirtz and Barcola make way for Nyoni and Munoz. Quiet afternoon from both of the outgoing players.
A stunning block from Hill prevents Isak pulling trigger as he looked to have the goal in his sights.
Truffert clears the resulting corner to safety.
In a recent development, isak is concentrating his efforts in more central areas and here he almost gets played in behind but the ball just runs away from him. Better.
Recent findings suggest that worth mentioning that Jacquet has been fantastic in all phases of the game. Plenty of advanced regains and tidy passes forward.
In a recent development, it’s raining goals in Manchester and no prizes for guessing who has scored for Sunderland. Brobbey has his hat-trick.
Sources indicate that brobbey has his hat-trick and the look on Enzo Maresca’s face as he assesses the defending from his team. They’ve been great pouring forward, less so trying to stymie Sunderand’s attack. But this is one of those games where you just sit back and enjoy the unfolding drama. It’s been so good from both teams.
Semenyo gets his second goal of the afternoon to extend the league leaders’ advantage.
Chance! Jacquet jumps and wins the ball well inside Bournemouth’s half and his intervention sends the ball into Isak’s path. The forward just drags his effort wide and turns out he was in an offside postion anyhow.
What an afternoon this is turning out to be. There have been more slices than on an erratic day on the local municipal golf course and Ronald Araujo is the latest to be afflicted by the condition. None of that will matter to Andoni Iraola, though, as Alexander Isak’s fourth goal in four Premier League games has given Liverpool a huge advantage. They haven’t played with fluency but the breakthrough was significant.
Sources indicate that isak opens the scoring at the Vitality, finally getting into the box and sweeping in from close range. So much credit has to go to Gakpo who tiptoes past two Bournemouth defenders by the touchline before spearing a cross infield, and while he may not be attributed with the assist owing to a touch off Wirtz, his delivery makes it all the way through to Isak who taps in.
Alexander Isak grabs his fourth Premier League goal of the season! 🔴 pic.twitter.com/5ehwhl1it4.
It has been revealed that adams has been superb as one of Bournemouth’s two midfield sentries. Kerkez looks to have been played into the left channel but the American swoops in and shields the ball out of play before staring down his Hungarian opponent.
Mitchell thinks he’s given the visitors the lead but his goal is ruled out for offside.
Recent findings suggest that tyrick Mitchell's opener is disallowed for an offside in the build up! ❌ pic.twitter.com/7y975TxaUj.
According to recent reports, liverpool give up possession in Bournemouth’s half and Christie strides forward releasing Rayan before continuing his run to the near post. The Brazilian picks out his team-mate but Christie gets too strong a contact on the ball and the ball sails wide.
Truffert passes the ball straight to Gakpo inside his own box but Adams is on the scene in a flash and snaps into a tackle and takes the ball away from the Liverpool forward.
The second has already settled into a holding pattern, with neither side creating much. Isak makes a run down the right hand side and, with players loaded in the box, he blasts the ball high into the sky and beyond his team-mates. That pretty much sums things up.
Industry observers note that wirtz has given the ball away twice in the first minute of the second half. Carragher is on Sky Sports commentary duties and he says he’s surprised to see him back out on the pitch.
Szoboszlai concedes a foul on the far side but the subsequent delivery is too heavy and sails over everyone.
No half-time changes from either manager.
Industry observers note that 3 - This is the first time that @ManCity have taken the lead three times in the first half of a Premier League match.Overall, it's just the seventh time in competition history that a side has gone ahead on three separate occasions in a first half.Canvas. pic.twitter.com/JaQ4qDarls.
In a recent development, isak’s first-half heatmap makes for interesting reading. The good news, for Liverpool fans, is that he’s stationed himself predominantly in the final third. The bad news... those positions have been everywhere but the box.
There must be significant temptation to drift out to the wide areas and drop deep when the ball is not coming to you, but surely Liverpool need their No 9 closer to Bournemouth’s goal?
Bournemouth 0 Liverpool 0Leeds United 0 Crystal Palace 0 Manchester City 3 Sunderland 2.
Significant chance missed from Haaland of all people to make it 4-2 to City in what has been a pulsating, spell-binding first 45 minutes. It’s fast, furious and a helluva lot of fun to watch. Brilliant from Ndiaye to tee up Haaland who shoots wide of a post. A game for attackers shall we say ...
Recent findings suggest that there are significant advantages to having a goalkeeper who is 6ft 5in with long arms and massive hands. Brobbey’s shot cannons off Guehi and would have looped over a number of goalkeeper but Donnarumma sticks out a giant arm to help nudge the ball over the bar and keep City 3-2 in front in the fifth minute of first half stoppages.
Not a pretty half from the returning Iraola’s side, who will need to be much better in the second period to challenge for the three points.
Bournemouth have dropped points late on in a number of matches this season and will perhaps rue not being able to capitalise on their early advantage.
City are in front. Again. Semenyo this time, he fires the ball beyond Roefs having collected a loose ball int he box.
Industry observers note that antoine Semenyo gets his first goal of the season! 🎯 pic.twitter.com/1n2W5Cyxz0.
A relatively slick Liverpool move sees the ball worked out to Araujo on the right who has minded to bomb on with increasing frequency, and while he’s able to win a corner, Szoboszlai’s delivery is cleared with a minimum of fuss.
Iraola came into this game saying that his side held an advantage having played two days earlier than Bournemouth in midweek. You would never have guessed it from what we have witnessed here today.
And right on cue, a frustrated Isak attempts a specultative effort from range which sails high and wide.
Sunderland are level again as Brobbey scores after lengthy VAR check for offside.
Sunderland fans sing “F--- VAR” and City fans boo the delay while they both awaited the verdict, which has now gone Sunderland’s way.
In a recent development, brian Brobbey levels it AGAIN! 🤯 pic.twitter.com/YvelzwnmY8.
Can’t hold a lead today City. Wow, Sunderland are level again in an instant and it’s that man Brobbey again. There’s a VAR check going on to check for offside.
So, this is not a rush to make a sweeping criticism, it’s simply an observation. But Liverpool fans will be looking at Bradley Barcola and waiting to see that first burst, that moment of electricity, that has indicated why they bought him. It’s like you look for a touch, a pass, a moment of skill. He’s just had a shot saved but it all seems very tentative for him at the moment. And that is what he needs - a moment.
Jacquet does brilliantly to close down Christie as the Scot was stealing into the box and looking to pull the trigger.
Sources indicate that chances! Barcola forces Petrovic into an awkward-looking save, before follow-up efforts from Wirtz and Gakpo are charged down.
Mac Allister is fouled 25 yards out moments later and Szoboszlai gets another go. Here, he drags his effort just wide.
It’s all happening at the Etihad. Cherki restores City’s lead with his third Premier League goal of the season.
In a recent development, it’s a great finish from Cherki to put City back in front but it doesn’t happen if Ndiaye is quick to read Danso’s risky pass and win possession. Sharp as a button in that moment.
According to recent reports, rayan Cherki puts Manchester City back in front! 💫 pic.twitter.com/PP4MAV9kw3.
In a recent development, A really poor piece of defending from Kerkez gives Bournemouth a free-kick out on the right. Tavernier spins in an inswinger but Van Dijk heads clear. Truffert releases another assault on Liverpool’s box off the second phase but Alisson is wise to it and gathers.
In a recent development, it appears that Liverpool are beginning to settle, they take the opportunity to circulate the ball in front of Bournemouth’s first line of pressure, waiting for the right moment to pounce. The final pass is poor, though, and Araujo through-pass goes all the way through to Petrovic. It was aimed at Isak ...I think.
Recent findings suggest that some signs of life from Liverpool, as they create a substantial overload down their left, Kerkez, Mac Allister, Barcola and Isak meeting on that flank. Barcola attempts a sprint into the channel off the shoulder of the ball-side centre-back but he is deemed offside. Looked close, but a bit better from Liverpool.
Araujo has the chance to launch a long throw into the box but Silva beats Van Dijk to the summit and Petrovic gathers the loose ball.
Sources indicate that scott then sprays a wonderful ball over to Rayan on the right but his cutback to Tavernier comes to nothing after the midfielder loses the ball. Liverpool then spring a counter of their own, but Bournemouth recover and charge down a hopeful Gakpo effort from the edge of the box.
Industry observers note that liverpool will not be pleased with their start to this match. They’ve struggled to string more than three passes together without ceding possession and Isak has cut an isolated figure up top.
First time that Bournemouth have gone through the gears and the move ends with Alisson Becker saving brilliantly from Evanilson. It’s a funny stadium, here, as it can be quiet then all of a sudden a tempest whips up and you can sense the mood changing. Liverpool are struggling for alacrity and Andoni Iraola is keeping an eye on Florian Wirtz, who is moving gingerly after taking a bang to his left foot.
Some start at the Etihad. You had to wonder if a big early missed chance from Nilson Angulo was going to haunt Sunderland with City taking the lead just a few minutes later through a quite sublime free-kick from Enzo Fernandez. But Sunderland have immediately hit back. Maresca will decry the defending but it’s brilliant from Enzo Le Fee, who surges forward and then splits Nunes and Dias with an inch perfect pass that Brobbey takes beautifully in his stride before finishing.
On Fernandez’s free-kick before then, he’d very much shaped as if he’s going to cross the ball from a free-kick on the right side of the penalty area. He’d clearly spotted an opening in the top right though and, while giving the firm impression to Roefs he was going to whip in a cross, he obviously had other ideas. The execution was immaculate but it was telling just how effectively he’d managed to deceive the Sunderland goalkeeper. It was world class.
Sources indicate that A slight mix-up sees Kerkez and Wirtz bump into each other by the touchline. The Germany international limps away and grimaces but should be fine to continue.
Industry observers note that chance! Alisson makes amends with a stunning save. Tavernier had hit the by-line and lasered a cross to Evanilson who, with the ball slightly behind him, improvised and flicked it toward the near post. Alisson gets down swiftly and turns behind for a corner which comes to nothing.
Jacquet gives away a needless foul on the near side but Scott’s delivery goes straight into Alisson’s hands. The Brazilian’s throw out is poor, though, and Scott darts into Liverpool’s box, just unable to pick out a team-mate.
Barcola is presented with green grass to run into, but just as he builds a head of steam Hill comes across in a flash and snuffs out the foray forward.
Woah, Brobbey responds immediately, stealing in between City defenders before slotting past Donnarumma.
Industry observers note that instant response from Sunderland as Brian Brobbey equalises! 💥 pic.twitter.com/et6AHGPAbl.
Enzo Fernandez opens the scoring at the Etihad with a direct free-kick from out wide. Really poor from Roefs who was caught napping. That’s Fernandez’s first City goal.
Enzo Fernandez gets his first Manchester City goal in style! 🤩 pic.twitter.com/fVOnJvACYY.
Industry observers note that wirtz earns a free-kick just outside the D. Bournemouth feel aggrieved as there looked to have been an earlier foul on Scott and to make matters worse Szoboszlai is standing over the ball.
His effort leaves Petrovic rooted to the spot but the ball veers just wide of the mark.
Recent findings suggest that evanilson’s willingness to drop deep is asking questions of Liverpool’s centre-backs. Do they follow him and risk disrupting their backline coverage?
The hosts attempt to work a short corner routine but Truffert’s eventual through-ball is too strong and the ball rolls out for a Liverpool goal-kick.
This wouldn’t go down as a fixture you would circle for being noteworthy but make no mistake this is a huge afternoon for Liverpool. They have had some days at the Vitality Stadium in recent years and last season’s defeat put a huge dent in Arne Slot’s hopes of trying to find a revival. It’s also a massive test for Bournemouth, coming down from the euphoria of beating Real Sociedad. Let’s see how it all transpires.
Evanilson makes a smart run into the right channel and while Jacquet gets his foot on the ball he’s instantly smothered by Scott and the ball goes out for a Liverpool goal-kick. A sign of how high both sides will be willing to jump in search of the ball.
Both sides will look to force mistakes out of the other and Szoboszlai is able to pick Adams’ pocket on the halfway line. He offloads to Araujo who runs into a cul de sac down the right flank.
We are under way at the Vitality. Bournemouth are in their customary black-and-red home shirts kicking from right to left and Liverpool are in their white away kit and red shorts.
Recent findings suggest that the players have emerged from the tunnel, Van Dijk and Smith at the front of the lines. A few pyrotechnics add to the atmosphere but one thing missing is the accidental sitting in the wrong dugout from the returning Iraola. He knows where he’s going.
Here is a reminder of today’s squads in full:.
Bournemouth: Petrovic; Smith, Hill, Silva, Truffert; Adams, Scott; Rayan, Christie, Tavernier; EvanilsonSubstitutes: Di Gregorio, Soler, Diakite, Cook, Brooks, Gannon-Doak, Sanchez, Toth, Jebbison.
Liverpool: Alisson; Araujo, Van Dijk, Jacquet, Kerkez; Mac Allister, Szoboszlai; Barcola, Wirtz, Gakpo; IsakSubstitutes: Mamardashvili, Gomez, Tsimikas, Frimpong, Gravenberch, Nyoni, Munoz, Koumas, Ngumoha.
The Egyptian king grabbed his first hat-trick for Trabzonspor yesterday, in a 4-0 win over league-leaders Galatasaray no less. That’s his seventh goal in eight matches.
When Salah is happy, we're all happy 👑👑👑 pic.twitter.com/DtzaOl3hD3.
"He's certainly very quick"Jamie Carragher's first impressions of Bradley Barcola ⚡️ pic.twitter.com/oXjzXBuZwm.
Since losing to Arsenal 3-2 on January 3, Bournemouth have not lost at the Vitality in 12 matches, picking up four wins and eight draws.
Jan 7: Bournemouth 3 Tottenham Hotspur 2Jan 24: Bournemouth 3 Liverpool 2 Feb 7: Bournemouth 1 Aston Villa 1Feb 28: Bournemouth 1 Sunderland 1Mar 3: Bournemouth 0 Brentford 0Mar 20: Bournemouth 2 Manchester United 2Apr 22: Bournemouth 2 Leeds United 2May 3: Bournemouth 3 Crystal Palace 0 May 19: Bournemouth 1 Manchester City 1Aug 29: Bournemouth 1 Everton 1Sep 8: Bournemouth 4 Lincoln City 0 (League Cup)Sep 12: Bournemouth 2 Brentford 2.
According to recent reports, andoni Iraola returns to Bournemouth this weekend knowing what to expect from players he understands so well. Sadly, I do not mean Liverpool’s.
Having built his reputation creating a hard-working, well-drilled team rich in potential, Iraola is responsible for infusing those same characteristics into the most expensively assembled squad in Liverpool history.
In a recent development, his first six games demonstrate it is no quick fix. The Basque coach is the first Liverpool appointment to work with more than £700m of recent signings while being entitled to feel he has been dealt a bad hand.
Recent findings suggest that everything Iraola has remarked and done so far screams that he is searching for the right blend in his starting XI while having to eradicate negative traits, with and without the ball. It was telling that the excellent performance of his youngsters against Tottenham Hotspur in midweek offered the clearest hint of Iraola’s vision than anything we have seen with all the high-priced stars on the pitch.
There is a reason the Kop stood to acclaim the energy and application of youngsters Lewis Koumas, James McConnell and Trey Nyoni – and why Iraola keeps name-checking them. Iraola is indebted to them for issuing a reminder of the non-negotiables that come with being a Liverpool footballer; regardless of price tag and reputation, leaving everything on the pitch is compulsory. It is a concern that so many of the renowned players need to hear that message.
Jurgen Klopp named Florian Wirtz in his first squad as Germany manager and has remarked that fans must refrain from expecting “special moments” from the Liverpool playmaker as a matter of course.
Of Wirtz, he said: “I think he’s the player who covered the most ground at Liverpool this season, so the willingness is absolutely there.
In a recent development, “We have to move away from the idea that we need to see special moments from him. He is there to help us as a team. We have to make sure that Flo feels comfortable with us.”.
Wirtz has delivered seven goals and 11 assists in his 54 Liverpool appearances.
In a recent development, adam Smith, 35, played for Iraola 81 times and he admitted his former manager’s visit to the Vitality will be a sentimental affair. He stated: “It’s going to be an emotional day for everyone I think, [for] our ex-manager and some of our players that have played under him, but we’ll be up for the game for sure.”.
Your Eagles at Elland Road 🦅 pic.twitter.com/QGBqKJoSD1.
Recent findings suggest that 📋 Your #LUFC XI... pic.twitter.com/U0fRnjJLjv.
Bournemouth signed Truffert from Rennes in the summer of 2025 to replace Kerkez – who had just joined Liverpool – and the left-back has been a revelation at the Vitality. So much so that this week he earned himself a call-up to Zinedine Zidane’s first France squad.
Truffert topped the charts for most overlapping runs by any player in Europe’s top five leagues last season and laid on five assists.
Virgil van Dijk says Liverpool are still a work in progress at the moment and there are a lot of positive signs ahead of their game against Bournemouth💪Watch Super Sunday live: https://t.co/0AejI4B8dF pic.twitter.com/oSMxxIw9lQ.
Liverpool’s season so farAug 23: Newcastle United 2 Liverpool 2Aug 29: Liverpool 2 Nottingham Forest 2Sep 4: Ipswich Town 0 Liverpool 2Sep 9: Liverpool 2 Atlético Madrid 1 (Champions League)Sep 12: Liverpool 0 Fulham 0Sep 15: Liverpool 3 Tottenham Hotspur 1 (League Cup).
Roefs; Mukiele, Danso, Ballard, Methalie; Xhaka, Sadiki; Meunier, Le Fee, Angulo; Brobbey.
Le Bris shuffles his pack after Sunderland’s midweek victory over AZ in the Europa League, making five changes.
RLB's XI to take on Manchester City! ❤️👊 #MCISUN pic.twitter.com/u8kcYvqybE.
Foden, suspended after his red card in the Manchester derby last weekend, is replaced by Ndiaye. Doku is part of a match-day squad for the first time since the Community Shield.
Lining up for City this afternoon! 👊XI | Donnarumma, Nunes, Dias (C), Guéhi, Gvardiol, Anderson, Fernández, Ndiaye, Cherki, Semenyo, HaalandSUBS | Rulli, Kovačić, Doku, Aït-Nouri, Bouaddi, O'Reilly, Allan, Khusanov, Lewis🤝 @etihad pic.twitter.com/Zs6zcSr3pm.
Speaking before his return to the South Coast, Iraola said: “I know where we are going [the Vitality], and I know the stats they have there [unbeaten in 12 matches], not only in their stadium, overall, I think if you see the games they’ve lost in a long while, you realise how difficult it is to beat Bournemouth.
“But, I suppose I also have the advantage that I know them very well, they also have the advantage that they know me very well, so you never know who has more advantage in that sense.
He added: “On a personal side, I’m very much looking forward to meet them [his former players], to hug them. It’s players that I love, staff that I’ve been working with who I appreciate so much, and I was pushing for them [against Real Sociedad] when they were playing their first European game. I wish them all the best, but there is another part, which is the most crucial one right now that we need to go there and win.”.
Just the one alternation to the side Rose fielded last weekend as Christie comes in for Kluivert.
Bournemouth: Petrovic; Smith, Hill, Silva, Truffert; Adams, Scott; Rayan, Christie, Tavernier; Evanilson.
Substitutes: Di Gregorio, Soler, Diakite, Cook, Brooks, Gannon-Doak, Sanchez, Toth, Jebbison.
🍒 TEAM NEWS 🔴Your #afcb team to take on Liverpool 👊 pic.twitter.com/y2X6N21JeS.
Iraola makes three changes to the XI that drew against Fulham, preferring Kerkez, Mac Allister and Gakpo to Tsimikas, Gravenberch and Munoz.
Industry observers note that team news is IN! ⚪️ #BOULIV pic.twitter.com/BACwn7HrGu.
Good afternoon and welcome to our live coverage of the Premier League match between Liverpool and Bournemouth as Andoni Iraola returns to the Vitality Stadium for the first time since his big move up north. The Basque propelled Bournemouth to upcoming heights, guiding the club into Europe and his successor, Marco Rose, ensured they made a winning start to life on the Continent by defeating Real Sociedad in midweek.
Previewing Iraola’s Vitality Stadium return, Craig Beazley, host and creator of the Up The Cherries In All Departments podcast, said: “We’ve now got the Andoni Iraola return … Andoni is very much a legend really, there should be a statue of Sir Eddie Howe and Sir Andoni Iraola [outside the ground] as well.”.
Across three seasons, Iraola guided Bournemouth to 12th, ninth and sixth in the Premier League, winning 47 of his 127 matches in charge (37 per cent).
According to recent reports, liverpool are still acclimatising to his exacting style of play and their results suggest as much. They are 10th in the table having drawn three and won one, impressing in flashes but struggling to maintain consistently productive final-third patterns and pressing structures. Deploying Ronald Araújo at right-back has proved effective, though, with Liverpool conceding just two goals in their last four matches.
Recent findings suggest that the Cherries are searching for their first Premier League win of the season and have retained the 4-2-3-1 shape from the Iraola days, with Rose preferring a similarly vertical attacking strategy. They continue to leverage their strengths in transitions and in wide areas as Adrien Truffert rains in crosses for any one of Bournemouth’s exuberant frontline to pounce on.
Elsewhere, Manchester City welcome Sunderland, who also secured a Europa League win during the week, to the Etihad while in-form Leeds United host Crystal Palace knowing a win would lift them into the top four.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (29 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The young Tigers recorded just a second Professional Development League win of the season against the Cod Army who started the day in second place.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (19 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Tigers star was finally back on the pitch after a long spell out injured.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 11 min read (2201 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

Published: 09:41 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 09:44 EST, 14 November 2026.
In a career spanning almost 20 years, Peter van Vossen won the Champions League, made it to the quarter-finals of the World Cup with his country and won league titles in both the Netherlands and Scotland.
Sources indicate that point being, it’s reductive to define his time in football by one excruciating miss. But here we are.
Recent findings suggest that it’s 30 years to the day since Van Vossen missed an open goal for Rangers during a crucial Old Firm clash at Celtic Park. Leading 1-0 and with less than seven minutes remaining, the Dutch forward had a chance to seal all three points for the nine-in-a-row-chasing Light Blues. Instead, he blazed over with the goal at his mercy.
According to recent reports, in the decades since, the spurned chance has become the benchmark by which all other misses have been measured. ‘Sure, it was bad — but was it “Van Vossen” bad?’.
The man himself has seldom spoken about the events of that powder keg of a night. Until now. Living the quiet life in rural Holland, Van Vossen has given Daily Mail Sport a full account of his professional nadir.
Industry observers note that ‘I mostly remember being mad at Jorg [Albertz],’ he says. ‘I was seriously p***** off with him. Paul Gascoigne played a pass inside to me and I clipped a first-time ball in behind the Celtic defence, who were pressing high. If Jorg had just left it, I was one-on-one with the goalie and I would have fancied my chances.
Rangers striker Peter van Vossen sends the ball skywards in a crucial Old Firm clash in 1996.
‘I also thought there was a chance he might have been offside, so when you see me running through and stretching out my arms, that’s not me telling him that we’re through; that’s me telling him to leave it and get out of the way!
‘Anyway, he didn’t, I continued my run, he passed it to me and, because I was still livid when the ball arrived at me, I wasn’t paying enough attention. It took a bit of a bobble, I ended up basically hitting it with my shin and, yeah, it unfortunately flew over the bar.’.
To his relief, Rangers held on for a 1-0 win to leapfrog their bitter rivals at the top of the table, albeit only after Andy Goram saved a Pierre van Hooijdonk penalty awarded moments after Van Vossen’s horror miss.
‘Walter Smith came up to me in the dressing room afterwards and mentioned, “It’s just as well The Goalie saved that penalty otherwise I’d have f****** killed you!”’ smiles Van Vossen.
‘It was horrible but I can laugh about it now because we won the game. I wish I had scored but I didn’t, so there’s nothing I can do except try to find the humour in it.’.
It has been revealed that van Vossen signed for Rangers in January 1996 in a swap deal that saw Oleg Salenko join Istanbulspor. He came with some pedigree, too, having won the Champions League with Ajax in 1995, a year after featuring for the Netherlands on their run to the last eight of the World Cup in the US.
Sources indicate that at that time, Rangers, bankrolled by David Murray, were in the throes of a project designed to deliver European glory, while maintaining their dominance of Scottish football. Those two objectives, indicates Van Vossen, were misaligned.
It has been revealed that ‘We had a quality group of players that was far better than anything else in Scotland at the time,’ he states. ‘That made us incredibly difficult to beat in the league. But when we went into European games, we were exposed. The lack of competition in the league along with the lifestyles of some of our players was not compatible with taking on champions from other countries.
‘I always felt like we were technically a little behind. Our training usually consisted of a warm-up, a game of football, and a warm-down. That was a big adjustment for me. At Ajax, we played in a system and we worked hard on making sure everybody knew their role. In Scotland, it seemed like there was no real system. You could run anywhere you wanted. I don’t really think I learned anything in my time there.’.
That’s not to say he didn’t enjoy his two-and-a-half years in Glasgow. Quite the opposite.
‘I loved playing for Rangers,’ he notes. ‘Particularly that second season [1996/97]. I started really well and scored seven or eight goals in the first handful of games. I remember people being quite surprised because I had taken some time to settle. They would joke, “Who are you, Van Vossen’s better twin brother?” But I loved it.’.
A dejected Van Vossen can't believe he's missed in a moment that would follow him forever.
Industry observers note that he reserves particular affection for Walter Smith. ‘He was a fantastic manager and a true gentleman,’ he nods. ‘He helped me through a difficult time in my personal life. When I wasn’t in his team on the weekend, for example, I would ask him if I could go back to the Netherlands to see my children. He always stated yes on the condition that I was back in time for training at 10am on Monday.
In a recent development, ‘He genuinely cared about his players. I remember Vitesse being interested in bringing me back to Holland and their coach Leo Beenhakker coming to watch me at Ibrox.
In a recent development, ‘After the game, he found Walter and remarked, “We want to sign Peter, but we think £300,000 is too much”. Walter said to him, “Listen to me carefully. We don’t do business like this. First, you and I will go for a lunch, have a respectful chat and only when we’ve got to know each other, that’s when we’ll talk about money”.
According to recent reports, ‘Walter came to me afterwards and mentioned, “Look, I know you’re not playing as much as you would like but I won’t let you sign for him. This isn’t a good manager and I can’t allow it. You’re one of my players and I care about getting you the right move, not just any move”. I really respected that.’.
Van Vossen endured a much more difficult relationship with Smith’s assistant Archie Knox, a man he describes as ‘manipulative’.
Industry observers note that ‘I didn’t get on with him,’ he claims. ‘People talk a lot nowadays about creating a safe space and the right culture in workplaces. To me, Archie didn’t do that. He was always shouting, always right on top of you, in your face, kicking bottles. He behaved like a madman.
Van Vossen scored nine goals in 31 caps for the Netherlands between 1992 and 2000.
Industry observers note that ‘At Ajax, the coaches wanted to know how you were feeling. They understood that being well mentally was as crucial as being physically fit. Archie wasn’t interested in that. He was always aggressive, but only with the players he didn’t like. He had his favourites. If you weren’t one of them, he made sure you knew all about it.’.
Industry observers note that background tensions aside, Van Vossen’s first full season at Ibrox, 1996/97, has assumed a special place in Rangers’ folklore. They finished five points clear of Celtic to equal their rivals’ record of nine consecutive league titles, having laid the foundations with four league wins out of four over Tommy Burns’ side.
Despite his famous miss being the closest he ever came to scoring in an Old Firm clash, Van Vossen insists he relished those occasions.
‘I loved those games,’ he indicates. ‘The atmosphere, home and away, was unbelievable and the quality of the players on the pitch was outstanding. To be honest, there wasn’t a whole lot of football played. There were lots of mistakes, fights and loads of running. I remember feeling tired after just ten minutes. I wasn’t built for that kind of pace! But they were great to be part of.
‘The week of Old Firm matches, you could feel the pressure building. I remember being in Glasgow city centre one day and I needed a taxi. I waved one down but when it pulled up, the driver must have been a Celtic fan because he raised his middle finger and swore at me before driving away. Whereas, with Rangers taxi drivers, it was the opposite. I honestly think they would have driven me around Scotland for free.
Van Vossen had a spell in charge of Fortuna Sittard but now labels himself a 'house husband'.
‘That’s just what football is like in Glasgow. It’s on a whole other level to anything else. I’ve played in big derbies in the Netherlands and Turkey. Believe me, nothing comes close to the Old Firm.’.
After finding his playing time limited as Rangers pursued ten-in-a-row, Van Vossen was relieved to learn that his old international manager, Dick Advocaat, would take over from Smith in time for the 1998/99 season. His joy, however, was short-lived when Murray used him as a makeweight in a transfer for Feyenoord midfielder Giovanni van Bronckhorst.
‘David Murray was a brilliant guy, but he made a huge mistake when he tried to sell me to Feyenoord behind the back of Dick Advocaat,’ indicates Van Vossen. ‘Dick was taking over and he was keen for me to be part of his prepares.
‘I remember he was flying from Amsterdam to Glasgow when he phoned me to talk about some of his ideas. I noted, “Dick, I’m sorry, but I think I’m joining Feyenoord. The deal is almost done”. He told me to stay put and said that when he got to Glasgow, he and I were going to go and see Murray.
It has been revealed that ‘I remember Dick remarked to him, “How can you sell players behind my back? I need to be involved in these conversations”. Murray said, “You’re absolutely right, I apologise”. He handed me a blank cheque and said, “Peter, write down whatever number you want to stay. It’s not a problem”.
Industry observers note that ‘But I couldn’t do it. I respected him for apologising to Dick, but I had lost confidence in him. I couldn’t play for somebody who would do something like that.
Van Vossen scored 11 goals in his 36 appearances for Rangers between 1996 and 1998.
‘I took a 60 per cent drop in wages to join Feyenoord but they were the team I had supported as a boy and I needed to be somewhere I was wanted and where I was being treated with respect.’.
It has been revealed that although his spell at Ibrox ended on a slightly sour note, Van Vossen recalls it fondly. ‘It was a family,’ he claims. ‘Everybody had a part to play, from the players on the pitch to the ladies in the kitchen. I mean, they were incredible. I remember being on a ferry one time and I got chatting to a truck driver who told me he sold flowers. We had a good conversation and exchanged numbers.
‘When I got back to Glasgow, I got in touch with him and said, “Can you do me a favour? Can you deliver ten bouquets of flowers to Ibrox?” Sure enough, this huge truck pulled up outside the ground one day, with something like ten thousand flowers in the back. They pulled out ten bouquets and delivered them to the ladies in the kitchen. They were delighted, but it was the least I could do. They treated you like one of their own. Like I say, we were one big family.’.
These days, the head of that family is one of Van Vossen’s old teammates, Derek McInnes, and he’s backing him to deliver silverware.
Despite carving out a successful career, Van Vossen is remembered primarily for THAT miss.
According to recent reports, ‘I remember Derek well,’ he indicates. ‘Like me, he didn’t play every game, but he always gave 100 per cent and I expect he’ll be the same as a manager. He’s a people person and I imagine he is a fantastic man-manager. I have no doubt he’ll do a great job.’.
Having dabbled in management and punditry since hanging up his boots, Van Vossen now describes himself as a ‘house husband’ who dotes on wife Jojanneke and his stepchildren Sem, Lilly, Madée and Eva. He’s also presently writing his autobiography. The simple pleasures, he insists, are what matter most to him.
Sources indicate that ‘I don’t need to have lots of expensive things and a certain kind of lifestyle to be a rich man,’ he adds. ‘I’m a rich man because of the memories I have and the good times I enjoyed as a footballer.
Industry observers note that ‘If I close my eyes, I can still remember what it was like to run onto the pitch at Ibrox in front of 50,000 supporters, and it gives me goosebumps. I am very fortunate to have had that opportunity.’.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (13 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Tigers' youngsters were in action on Tuesday afternoon.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (16 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Mariners bounced back after a run of four straight league defeats.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (14 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Tigers' Under-21s were in action at the MKM Stadium.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (594 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

West Ham are on the lookout for potential transfer targets as the January window nears, and it appears they’ve got eyes on the next generation. The Sun states that WHUFC are interested in Joe Duncan, who is currently on loan at Southend United from Bristol City.
Industry observers note that the 20-year-old, who was a surprise call-up to Craig Bellamy’s Wales squad for their UEFA Nations League fixtures against Norway and Portugal, has caught the eye in the National League. Duncan has earned rave reviews since moving to Roots Hall, playing a key role in them sitting in 3rd place.
According to recent reports, ipswich Town are also said to be monitoring Duncan’s situation, with the shot-stopper’s contract set to expire at the end of the season. The Bristol City academy graduate is yet to make a senior first-team appearance at Ashton Gate, having joined aged 11.
It is common for Football League sides to loan out their academy prospects to non-league outfits to give them a taste of regular first-team action. Duncan is following that very path, and interest from West Ham and Ipswich Town shows his success is not going unnoticed.
Penning his first professional contract at Bristol City in the summer of 2023, the two-time Wales U21 international flourished at Tiverton Town and Farborough.
Sources indicate that with Tiverton, he was nominated for their Player of the Month award in each month he was there which speaks volumes about the impact he had in Devon. A stint with Farnborough last season brought similar success, helping to retain their National League South status after arriving in March.
Making the step-up to the National League with Southend United felt like the perfect stepping stone ahead of the new season and he has impressed at Roots Hall, despite only keeping one clean sheet.
A first senior call-up to the Wales squad indicates the potential Duncan has though, featuring on the bench in their defeat to Norway on Saturday.
Discussion is rife around what business West Ham may do in the January transfer window, but adding another young ‘keeper to their ranks shouldn’t be top of the to-do list.
Although the goalkeeping department is an area of concern due to the uncertain future of Alphonse Areola and poor performances of Mads Hermansen, the Hammers have plenty of talent waiting in the wings.
Finlay Herrick has shown his worth in the limited minutes he has been given, while Mason Terry continues to aid his development with loan moves in non-league, signing for Yeovil Town last week.
A January addition between the sticks will be paramount for Scott Parker to help shore up a leaky defence, but it is much more likely to be a senior figure.
Duncan is undoubtedly a fine talent who could become a big name in the years to come. However, a move to WHUFC may not provide a clear pathway to first-team football, given the young shot-stoppers already in their ranks.
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest West Ham United news in your inbox every morning.
Enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Gunners supremo has been talking about City's qualities in the Premier League.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (18 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
It's the third year running that Grimsby Town have exited at the group stage.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (16 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The experienced stopper is relishing the battle with the highly-rated Greek star.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (14 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
'We don’t want players who think they have ‘cracked it’'.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The 22-year-old full-back is keen to make his mark at the MKM Stadium.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (379 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

AC Milan have been incredibly interested in a move for Virgil van Dijk in recent years and the opportunity to do so may now have arrived.
Last summer, Gerry Cardinale hoped to sign van Dijk, with just a year left on his deal. However, the timing was not right and the American couldn’t make it work. Yet, that wasn’t the end of the interest and things could heat up in the early stages of next year.
According to recent reports, read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
It has been revealed that as Gazzetta dello Sport wrote this morning (seen below), it’s not the first opening that the Rossoneri have had with van Dijk, but it’s perhaps their biggest yet. For the first time, he’s cast doubt on his Liverpool future, with his current deal set to expire at the end of the season.
Speaking yesterday, he admitted that it would be ‘fine’ if there was a renewal offer made, but if not, he had no matter heading elsewhere.
Sources indicate that cardinale has been obsessed with the idea of adding the imposing Dutchman to his Diavolo defence for some time now, even trying to sign him in the summer. However, the terms of a deal weren’t right then.
Andoni Iraola hasn’t shown a strong determination to tie van Dijk down to a fresh deal, so the Dutchman would be free to discuss a new home in the early parts of 2027.
Recent findings suggest that milan wouldn’t be alone in their interest in a move, though. Interest from Turkey – Galatasaray, Fenerbahce and Trabzonspor – is present, as are Saudi Arabian clubs. So, it will be dependent on whether the Dutchman prioritises money or his childhood passion.
He fell in love watching Alessandro Nesta and Paolo Maldini, and now the time may come to emulate them as long as the foundations are right. So, the Rossoneri must return to the Champions League, as well as adding some other key players.
Nevertheless, his arrival would be compared to Luka Modric in defence, an elite player whose reputation is among the best of his peers. He could be the core part of a new defence for the Diavolo.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (19 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The highly-rated defender is on his way back from a lengthy spell on the sidelines.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (21 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
'Everyone wants to crack on, and we all have the same goal of getting this club promoted'.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (21 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
'They have only lost once at home this season, so it’s going to be a tough game'.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (19 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
City are not in action until they face Brighton and Hove Albion on November 22.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Kevin Kilbane has been celebrating an amazing turnaround in fortune for Hull City.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (26 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Iwan Morgan bagged a brace during the victory at 10-man Swindon Town, while Andy Cook and Josh Andrews were also on target.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (20 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The best and worst clubs in Europe for results against their squad value have been ranked.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (680 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

By MICHAEL PAVITT, SPORTS REPORTER.
Published: 11:31 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 12:52 EST, 14 November 2026.
Carlo Ancelotti hit out at an 'inexperienced' referee after the Brazil boss and captain Raphinha were sent off in the closing stages of their shock 3-2 defeat by Japan.
Security staff were required to enter the pitch at full time to separate players from the officials, with Brazil having been left furious over the nature of Japan's stoppage time winner.
Ancelotti and Raphinha, who had been substituted, were among those to furiously protest following Tatsuhiro Sakamoto's late strike.
Singaporean referee Jansen Foo Chuan Hui had allowed play to continue after Takumi Minamino had made multiple challenges on Brazil midfielder Joao Gomes, before eventually coming away with the ball.
Amid Brazilian appeals for a foul, Japan launched a late attack with Sakamoto ultimately lifting the ball over goalkeeper Pedro Morisco.
Brazilian protests continued despite Japan's winner being confirmed by VAR, with Ancelotti and Raphinha being shown red cards by the referee for their reactions.
Security staff intervened after Brazil stars confronted the referee after their 3-2 defeat by Japan.
Carlo Ancelotti was sent off as Brazil were beaten in stoppage time in their friendly in Singapore.
Ancelotti criticised the 'inexperienced' referee following the match and revealed he had been told he had been sent off for failing to control his bench.
Recent findings suggest that 🚨🚨| Raphinha and Carlo Ancelotti have been SENT OFF for Protesting. 🟥😳 pic.twitter.com/YoXrZW9N0U.
'He gave me the red card because he noted I was not able to control the bench, and that all the players were on the field, that is the reason,' Ancelotti said.
Sources indicate that ancelotti added: 'A pity the result, because we don't like to lose the game, but we have to look at what we did well. There are many things. Some players who played for the first time, who showed good quality. For 70 minutes, the team was good.
'The result, obviously, is conditioned by the attitude of the referee, who did not blow the whistle.
'But it's not his fault; it was a high-level match, and I think he didn't have the experience to manage this type of match.'.
Barcelona star Raphinha claimed post-match that Brazil had also been angered over a potential handball in the build-up to Japan's opening goal, as well as seeing a penalty appeal waved away.
'First of all, I'd like to take this opportunity to apologise for my behaviour and for being sent off,' Raphinha told Globo.
Recent findings suggest that 'Sometimes it's hard to keep calm, especially after what I felt were so many refereeing errors during the match. I tried to speak to him several times, and not once did I feel he was open to discussion. I believe that he made many errors throughout the game, and that is unacceptable.
Recent findings suggest that 'In my view, their first goal involved a foul where the opponent took the ball off me with his hand. I think it's a foul, but I can understand why it wasn't given based on the current law.
Brazil captain Raphinha was also dismissed amid their protests over Japan's winning goal.
Brazil had been convinced there had been a foul in the build-up to Tatsuhiro Sakamoto's winner.
In a recent development, 'Then there was the penalty in the first half, in my opinion it was a penalty, but he remarked no. Then, for their third goal, there was a clear foul on Joao Gomes. With the help of VAR, he eventually allowed the goal. It's very difficult not to talk about the refereeing.'.
Brazil had fallen 2-0 down in the friendly with Takefusa Kubo and Keito Nakamura scoring in the opening 20 minutes at Singapore's National Stadium.
Real Madrid winger Vinicius Jr scored twice to level the match before Sakamoto's controversial late winner.
It is the second time Japan have beaten Brazil 3-2 in the past 18 months, but the five-time world champions did win 2-1 in their last-32 meeting at this summer's World Cup.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (23 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Thoughts have already turned to what the winter window might look like for some of the Tigers's squad members.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (651 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

According to recent reports, derby County are positioned in 23rd place in the table after their first 15 fixtures. DCFC are in the drop zone along with Preston North End and Burnley and they are five points from safety behind Watford and Lincoln City.
Recent findings suggest that the Rams won 3-1 at home against Bolton Wanderers last time out before the international break. Ryan Nyambe, Jack Robinson and Rhian Brewster got their goals against the Trotters at Pride Park as they secured a valuable three points.
It has been revealed that elek has delivered his verdict on John Eustace’s side on the Not The Top 20 Podcast: “Relegation standard, they have to be. It comes with all the caveats, he’s a manager we like in John Eustace, their injuries are one of, if not the main reason, they are as poor as they have been this season. They did put in a much better performance last time out, we saw them win a game.”.
He added: “Of course they can (get out of trouble), when (Patrick) Agyemang gets back he will give them so much more from an attacking perspective. They have so many defenders out. Matt Clarke probably being the most crucial one, he’s set to come back relatively soon which will improve them. But even so, from this moment on, whether it’s Eustace or whoever else, if someone can keep them up it will be one hell of an effort because they’ve really made their task pretty difficult to stay up given the way they have started.”.
Derby County’s victory over Bolton Wanderers was a massive one and has eased some pressure off Eustace. However, DCFC’s head coach still has heat on him.
Industry observers note that the Rams are back in action this weekend as they aim to build some momentum and claw their way closer to safety. They face a tricky away trip to St Mary’s to face Southampton and they will need to be at their best to get something against the promotion chasing Saints.
Eustace joined his current club back in February 2025 and left Blackburn Rovers in the process. They were in a relegation battle when he joined and he managed to keep them up.
It has been revealed that the ex-Birmingham City man had Derby County competing for the play-offs in the last campaign. They missed out on the final day at the expense of eventual winners Hull City after they lost to Sheffield United.
It has been revealed that derby County’s squad has been plagued with injuries this term, as Elek has alluded to. DCFC need to get their injured players back fit as soon as possible.
Sources indicate that patrick Agyemang will give them more firepower up top and will be itching to return. The Rams also remain without defenders Matt Clarke, Eiran Cashin and Craig Forsyth, hence why they have delved into the free agent market over recent times to bring in experienced duo Robinson and Shane Duffy.
It has been revealed that if the Rams were to sack Eustace in the near future, there are plenty of available managers who they could consider. Rob Edwards and Steve Cooper seem the most likely candidates, whilst the likes of Sean Dyche, Steven Gerrard, Paul Heckingbottom and Gary Rowett are unattached.
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest Derby County news in your inbox every morning.
Enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (21 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
'We’re down to the bare bones again with injuries and call-ups, but it didn’t look like that'.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (35 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
After missing the trip to Arsenal, Hull City fan Natalie Murphy wonders whether an International break really offers a rest when you don’t know what to do with a football-free Saturday.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (252 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Last night, several AC Milan players were in action with their respective national teams, and it gives us a chance to go through their performances.
Recent findings suggest that yesterday was the first ‘proper’ day of international action, after players had travelled and had time to rest after their commitments on the previous weekend. So, Milan had several of their 13 departees take to the field.
In a recent development, read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
The headline fixture came at San Siro, where Mike Maignan and Adrien Rabiot played in a 3-1 home win for the Azzurri. A big loss for France under Zinedine Zidane, both Milan players played the full 90 minutes, with the midfielder even captaining Les Bleus. It wasn’t a game to remember, though.
Diego Moreira was started on the right of Belgium’s front three in a 2-1 win against Turkiye, playing 70 minutes. A constant threat, he made a key pass and registered a few shots. His confidence is certainly on the rise; that can’t be denied.
At Wembley, Luka Modric came on as a substitute in a 2-1 defeat. Brought on for only 15 minutes, it wasn’t enough time to make an impact. However, you could tell when he came on, as Croatia started playing to his direction.
It has been revealed that finally, Christian Comotto played 60 minutes in Italy U-20’s win against Portugal. It’s certainly positive to see him getting minutes.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (19 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The former Mariners manager was subjected to chanting during Saturday's match at the County Ground.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (19 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Tigers have enjoyed a positive start to life in the top flight following promotion.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 36 min read (7249 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Nature

The global transition towards sustainable energy systems has identified tidal power as a uniquely predictable and substantial renewable energy resource1. However, the highly unsteady sea environment subjects turbines to severe hydrodynamic loads, greatly increasing capital and maintenance costs2,3. Large-scale state-of-the-art turbines at present rely on complex, expensive active pitch systems to mitigate these fluctuations. Here we present a reliable, passive alternative: flexible rubber blades featuring chordwise trailing-edge deformation. We experimentally demonstrate that these flexible blades achieve an equivalent total energy yield over simulated tidal cycles compared with rigid blades with active pitch control, while mitigating high-frequency fatigue-inducing load fluctuations by up to one-third. This passive load regulation arises from aeroelastic deformation that flattens blade camber under load, enabling structural robustness without added mechanical complexity. These findings suggest that chordwise-flexible blades can enhance the durability and performance of tidal turbines, offering a promising pathway towards more reliable and cost-effective tidal energy generation.
Recent findings suggest that the global imperative to transition towards sustainable energy systems has intensified research and development in renewable energy technologies. Among these, tidal energy presents a uniquely predictable and substantial resource. Unlike other renewables such as wind and solar, tidal currents are governed by an astronomical cycle, which offers a consistent and forecastable power source4,5. The scale of this resource is significant. Tidal power is estimated at 50 TW h yr−1 in Europe6 and as much as 220 TW h yr−1 in the USA alone7. Near-term deployment targets are 1 GW by 2035 in the UK3, with international roadmaps project deployments eventually exceeding 300 GW worldwide by 20508. These highlight the potential of tidal energy in contributing to energy security and renewable energy portfolios.
Sources indicate that despite their promise, the harsh hydrodynamic environment presents an important barrier to the economic viability of this renewable energy source. A primary challenge is the hydrodynamic load fluctuations that arise from large variations in flow velocity, turbulence, turbine yaw with respect to the incoming stream, velocity shear along the water depth2, wave-induced oscillating currents9, and wake interaction within turbine arrays10. These fluctuating loads are a primary design consideration and are associated with accelerated fatigue, reduced operational lifespans and unplanned downtime. These reliability concerns result in blade and turbine designs with high capital costs, which directly increase the levelized cost of energy (LCOE)3.
To address the challenge of the dynamic loads, various mitigation strategies have been developed. Active control typically deploys systems to actively regulate the pitch11 or camber12 of the blades, therefore, to regulate power output, control mean loads and improve start-up performance. Although the active control systems are effective in certain operational envelopes, the reliability of sophisticated sensors and actuators in the harsh undersea environment remains a concern. Furthermore, the response times of the activator limit effectiveness against rapid, high-frequency load fluctuations13,14.
Recent findings suggest that to address these concerns, there has been an increased focus on developing passive control mechanisms. Passive control is mainly realized in two ways: introducing changes in the blade pitch or modifying the blade camber. Passive pitch control involves designing blades that can rotate around their spanwise axis in response to changing hydrodynamic loads, thereby altering their angle of attack. This is typically achieved by incorporating a pre-loaded torsional spring mechanism at the blade root. Theoretical work in refs. 15,16 are among the first to introduce the concept. Both demonstrated that complete cancellation of the load fluctuation is possible without compromising the mean power. This is followed by a numerical study in ref. 17, which confirmed more than 80% load fluctuations can be reduced in sheared flow conditions, with additional benefits such as faster wake recovery, which improves turbine array performance. Reference 18 has contributed a general framework for the design of passive pitching systems, identifying the locations of the pivot point for maximizing load mitigation. Experimental validations in ref. 19 have confirmed the ability of passive pitching systems in the reduction of time-averaged loadings.
Sources indicate that passive pitching systems are effective for low-frequency, large-scale adjustments and power regulation by adjusting the global angle of attack of the blades. However, the added inertia due to the displacement of the pitching axis required by effective pitching systems, as well as the bearing friction, limits the response of the system to high-frequency disturbances, such as turbulent eddies or rapid shear variations. Moreover, despite being simpler than active control systems, passive pitch blades still introduce extra moving parts and potential failure points in harsh undersea environments. Research has identified that for wind turbine applications, most of the failures originate from the pitch system20, highlighting the significant operational advantage of a robust, passive design.
According to recent reports, an alternative design philosophy can be found in nature, where organisms from fish to trees passively reconfigure their shape through distributed material compliance to manage fluid dynamic forces21,22. Drawing from these biological principles, passive morphing flexible blades offer an alternative strategy, where flexibility is distributed along the blade, allowing each blade section to adapt automatically through fluid–structure interaction. Therefore, a faster response time can be achieved with a fixed-pitch blade that does not require hinges and bearings. Passive morphing blades are common in wind energy applications23,24, in which the blade twists to feather in response to a wind gust. This technique, known as aeroelastic tailoring, requires ad hoc structural design, whose scalability and reliability for large tidal turbines is yet to be demonstrated. In fact, for similar power-rated turbines, the bending moment experienced by tidal turbines is higher than that of wind turbines. Therefore, the need for a scalable, reliable, passive system that can mitigate both rapid, localized turbulent fluctuations and slower, large-scale changes in inflow velocity on large-scale tidal turbines remains unmet.
Industry observers note that this study directly addresses this challenge by proposing a blade with chordwise flexibility, rather than spanwise flexibility, as in aeroelastic tailoring. The frontal and thickest part of the blade, which provides structural integrity, is rigid. Instead, the trailing edge is flexible from root to tip. Specifically, we provide the first comprehensive experimental demonstration that a carefully designed chordwise-flexible blade can achieve both control of the mean power and thrust with the quasi-steady variations of flow velocities over the tidal cycle (for example, the diurnal tidal cycle) and mitigation of the high-frequency (turbulence) hydrodynamic load fluctuations on tidal turbines, while enabling the same yield as a conventional rigid blade equipped with active pitch control. To demonstrate this potential, we experimentally evaluated the performance of these chordwise-flexible blades against a rigid baseline in the FloWave Ocean Energy Research Facility at the University of Edinburgh. The turbine was tested across a range of nominal inflow velocities u∞ = 0.5–1.0 m s−1, and tip-speed ratios (λ) from 3 to 9, with the flexible blades designed for optimal performance at u∞ ≈ 0.85 m s−1. Our analysis first addresses the low-frequency load mitigation over a tidal cycle before examining the high-frequency load fluctuations and the underlying physical mechanisms of the deformation of the blade. Overall, we demonstrated a new pathway to enhance turbine reliability and survivability, reducing capital costs associated with the active pitch system, and reducing maintenance costs by removing hinges, bearings and actuators, ultimately reducing the LCOE.
Industry observers note that the structural design of a tidal turbine is primarily dictated by low-frequency loads, which, in this context, refers to the quasi-steady hydrodynamic loads that change as the mean inflow velocity varies over a tidal cycle. To investigate the potential for load control in this regime, the time-averaged performance of the flexible blades was compared against a rigid baseline. Figure 1 demonstrates the time-averaged power (CP), thrust (CT), and root bending moment (CM) coefficients as a function of tip-speed ratio λ, at all tested inflow velocities. The results demonstrate that the introduction of blade flexibility does not compromise the primary function of energy capture of the turbine. As shown in Fig. 1a, at the rated velocity (uR = 0.878 m s−1) and above, the power coefficient of the flexible blade closely matches that of the rigid blade, achieving a comparable peak CP of approximately 0.37. Notably, the limited value of the maximum CP of both the rigid and flexible blades compared with full-scale state-of-the-art turbines is due to the low Reynolds number at which the model-scale turbines were tested (Methods).
The key advantage of the flexible blade design is its ability to passively regulate peak loadings. At the rated velocity, the thrust coefficient of the flexible blade is comparable to that of the rigid blade near the optimal power-producing tip-speed ratio (λ ≈ 5.5−6), as shown in Fig. 1b. However, the performance of the flexible blades diverges from rigid ones for λ values beyond this optimal range. This high λ region is typically explored by the turbine control strategy to cap power when inflow velocity exceeds the rated velocity. Under these conditions, the flexible blade thrust passively decreases, whereas the rigid one increases. This demonstrates a load-shedding mechanism that can protect the turbine structure during the most demanding high-flow conditions and will be discussed in detail in the next section, in which we simulate the power and thrust a tidal turbine experiences over a tidal cycle. However, at off-design conditions, the flexible blade exhibits higher CT and CM values than at its design speed. While this results in higher thrust coefficients at lower velocities, the absolute forces, which scale with velocity squared (\(F\propto {u}_{\infty }^{2}\)), are much smaller during lower flow periods and are not as notable for the structural design of the turbine as the peak loads experienced at or above rated velocity. Therefore, the ability of the flexible blade technology to match power performance while simultaneously offering a passive mechanism to reduce the most important structural loads represents a marked advancement for designing more durable and cost-effective tidal turbines.
a–c, Time-averaged coefficients of power (a), thrust (b) and root bending moment (c) as a function of the tip-speed ratio for rigid and flexible blades at different flow speeds.
Recent findings suggest that to quantify the practical benefits of the passive load mitigation of the chordwise-flexible blade in realistic inflow, we simulate the performance over a representative tidal cycle and compare it against a rigid blade turbine with the same control strategy and a state-of-the-art, actively pitch-controlled turbine (see Supplementary Note 2 for modelling of the active pitch-and-speed control turbine). The sinusoidal inflow velocity represents the flow seen by a tidal turbine during a tidal cycle is shown in Fig. 2a, which is.
In a recent development, a–d, Time history over a simulated tidal period of the freestream speed (a), the quasi-steady power (b), the tip-speed ratio (c) and the quasi-steady thrust (d). Data are presented for a rigid-blade turbine with only an active speed controller, a state-of-the-art active pitch-and-speed controller, and rubber blades with an active speed controller. All data are divided by the corresponding rated value.
Sources indicate that the cut-in velocity of the turbine is selected at u∞/uR = 0.2. The turbine operates at λ = 5.5 when the velocity is lower than rated. At the rated speed, all turbine configurations are operated at the same tip-speed ratio (λR) and provide the same quasi-steady power (PR) and thrust (TR). At higher than rated velocities, λ is such that P/PR = 1. The maximum velocity is set at u∞/uR = 1.2, representative of typical tidal turbine operating conditions.
The simulation first confirms that the passive design of the flexible blade does not compromise its primary function of energy capture. The normalized power profiles shown in Fig. 2b coincide for the rubber blade with speed control and the state-of-the-art active pitch control turbine, where the turbine speed is shown in Fig. 2c. As the total energy harvested is proportional to the integral of the power curves over the tidal cycle, the overlap of the curves confirms a negligible difference in overall energy yield. This demonstrates that the load-mitigation benefits of flexible blades can be achieved without a penalty to energy capture in a real-world setting.
The advantage of the flexible blade design is revealed by the differences in the quasi-steady thrust (Fig. 2d) between the turbine configurations. The state-of-the-art active pitch system limits structural loads by actively feathering the blades into the flow while maintaining the rated rotational speed. For a rigid blade, using only an overspeed-control strategy, the fixed geometry cannot adapt to the increasing flow; solely increasing the tip-speed ratio results in an increasing thrust that peaks at approximately 1.65 times the rated value (Fig. 2c). By contrast, with a comparable speed-control strategy, the passive system of the flexible blade achieves the same quasi-steady power and similar quasi-steady thrust as the active control.
It is also important to note that flexible blades show a slightly higher thrust coefficient at lower, off-design velocities (Fig. 1b) than the baseline rigid blade. However, the absolute thrust force, which scales with velocity squared, is smaller during these periods than the peak values over the tidal cycle. As the maximum loading dictates the primary structural design requirements of a turbine, the nearly identical peak thrust of the passive flexible blade to that of the complex, state-of-the-art active pitch system suggests comparable outcomes for turbine longevity and maintenance costs, representing a marked advancement towards more durable and cost-effective tidal energy systems. Overall, these results indicate that the chordwise-flexible blades can offer a compelling and robust alternative to the state-of-the-art active pitch-and-speed control turbine system.
According to recent reports, an effective passive system must also address high-frequency load fluctuations, which are a primary driver of fatigue damage. In this context, high frequency refers to the unsteady load components that occur at frequencies of the order of the period of revolution, such as those induced by turbulence, velocity shear or wake interaction, and so on. Figure 3 quantifies the effectiveness of the flexible blades by presenting the standard deviation of load fluctuations relative to the reference rigid blades at rated velocity. To reflect realistic conditions over a tidal cycle, the data for u∞/uR ≤ 1 are presented at the optimal tip-speed ratio (λ = 5.5) for maximum power extraction, whereas the data for conditions above the rated velocity (u∞/uR = 1.06) are presented at the higher tip-speed ratio (λ = 8) that is used to cap power. Figure 3 shows a substantial reduction of unsteady loads for all three components when the turbine is operating under its most demanding conditions. At the rated velocity (u∞/uR = 1.0), where the turbine operates at its optimal λ for maximum power extraction, the flexible blades provide effective fluctuation reduction across power, thrust and root bending moment (mitigated by approximately 18%, 23% and 28%, respectively). Furthermore, even when the inflow velocity increases beyond the rated velocity (u∞/uR = 1.06), the load fluctuation mitigation remains substantial. This demonstrates the powerful and robust damping ability of the flexible blades during both the maximum-power and power-capping phases of operation, when the absolute magnitude of fluctuating forces is greatest. At the lowest velocities (for example, u∞/uR = 0.51), where the blade operates in a stalled condition, fluctuations are known to increase relative to the rigid blade. However, their absolute magnitude is small, reaching only about 15–35% of the fluctuation level of the rigid blade at its rated velocity. A more detailed analysis, presented in Supplementary Note 3, confirms that this mitigation is robust across a wide range of tip-speed ratios under these high-flow conditions.
It has been revealed that a–c, Standard deviation of power (a), thrust (b) and root-bending moment (c) of flexible and rigid blades, for the optimum tip-speed ratio (λ = 5.5). All quantities are divided by those of the rigid blade at rated velocity.
In a recent development, to illustrate the physics of the passive load regulation mechanism demonstrated previously, the deformation of the flexible blade is visualized at the tip section. Figure 4 highlights the phase-averaged digital image correlation (DIC) measurements of the tip of the same flexible blade at a constant azimuthal angle, in which the blade is horizontal with downward velocity. The successful application of this technique using fully submerged cameras represents a significant experimental achievement, as most underwater DIC studies to date have been performed through observation windows rather than submerging the camera in the fluid25. In this way, complex optical distortions and refractive index mismatches associated with viewing ports are avoided, thereby achieving a more accurate measurement. In this study, the DIC system measured the deformation of the suction side of the blade. The full blade profile was then reconstructed by adding the known thickness distribution of the undeformed blade to the measured deformed chord line.
Phase-averaged profiles of one blade tip measured with DIC when the blade span is horizontal, and the tangential velocity is pointing downwards. Coordinates x, y are normalized by the chord length at the blade tip with origin at the quarter chord.
In a recent development, the measurements demonstrate the mechanism of the passive morphing concept. The undeformed flexible blade was designed with a significant initial camber, noticeably higher than that of the conventional rigid blade profile. The high camber present in both the initial blade shape and the subsequent deformed shape before reaching the designed operating point is the primary reason for the higher thrust force generated by the flexible blade operating off-design. Under hydrodynamic loading, the flexible trailing edge deflects upwards, causing the entire profile to flatten into a shape with less camber. This passive feathering becomes more pronounced with higher inflow velocities, which is the mechanism that reduces the thrust coefficient at high tip-speed ratios and velocities.
Sources indicate that DIC measurements of different blades (Extended Data Figs. 1 and 2) show that blades with lower flexural rigidity undergo greater camber reduction and exhibit stronger load shedding. Specifically, for blades with the same mould geometry, a too-stiff blade results in a too-low pitch and too-high camber, and thus high mean and unsteady thrust. Conversely, a too-soft blade results in an over-pitched blade and low power capture.
Recent findings suggest that the observed mean load-shedding behaviour shown in Fig. 1 arises primarily from quasi-steady passive morphing, and not from dynamic blade deformation resulting in hysteresis, vortex dynamics, and so on. DIC reconstructions of each individual blade at the same azimuthal position reveal only a narrow spread about the mean shape, corresponding to a standard deviation of the pitch variation of approximately ±0.2° (Extended Data Fig. 3).
Recent findings suggest that to further verify that the mean load-shedding behaviour is due to a quasi-steady morphing, we compare the measured blade deformations (Fig. 4) and the corresponding power and thrust (Fig. 1) with those computed with an in-house fluid–structure interaction solver based on a quasi-steady low-order model (Methods). The blade shapes computed with this program are in good agreement with those measured experimentally, and so are the predicted power and thrust for different tip-speed ratios (Extended Data Fig. 4). Because the numerical solver assumes the blade is in static equilibrium under hydrodynamic loads, these results confirm that the governing physics is quasi-steady.
Industry observers note that the fluid–structure interaction of the flexible blades is governed by two non-dimensional groups such as the Reynolds number (Re) and Cauchy number (Ca) (defined in the Methods). The experiments are performed at sufficiently high Re that the hydrodynamic load coefficients are about the same as those at full scale, as shown by the almost identical values for the rigid blade tested at different velocities in Fig. 1. To ensure geometric similarity between the model and the full-scale strain of the flexible blades, the Young modulus E of rubber must be scaled up to maintain the same Ca across scales. As discussed in Supplementary Note 4, rubber features a sufficiently high range of E for full-scale applications. Furthermore, rubber has the advantage of matching the mass density of water, enabling the design of buoyancy-neutral blades and preventing mass-related load fluctuations.
In a recent development, to demonstrate the scalability of the present results, numerical simulations are performed using the in-house fluid–structure interaction solver to model a utility-scale turbine. A rated speed of u∞ = 3.0 m s−1 and a 20-m diameter turbine is selected consistently with modern, state-of-the-art commercial turbines26 and typical energetic tidal sites27. Simulations performed at the respective Re and the same Ca confirm that power and thrust coefficient curves are similar at model and full scale (Extended Data Fig. 5), and therefore the present results are applicable to utility-scale turbines. Although E of the steel spar can be scaled up in numerical simulations, this is not possible in practice. Therefore, different full-scale spar design options are discussed in Supplementary Note 5.
Industry observers note that finally, rubber features high fatigue endurance. Preliminary calculations in Supplementary Note 6 show that the fatigue life of a full-scale rubber blade would substantially surpass the 20 years of service expected by state-of-the-art turbines.
Overall, by allowing similar control on power at thrust above rated speed than active pitch control systems, and mitigating load fluctuations, this technology offers a viable pathway to lower the LCOE. Furthermore, the reduction in load fluctuations enables deployment in energetic, highly turbulent sites previously deemed unviable due to the high fatigue loads. Further analysis of the potential industrial impact of this technology is presented in Supplementary Note 7.
Recent findings suggest that this experimental investigation has evaluated the performance of tidal turbine flexible rubber blades with passive chordwise flexibility, compared against conventional rigid blades. Our results confirmed that the power coefficient of the flexible blade at the design tip-speed ratio is comparable to that of its rigid counterpart, demonstrating that load mitigation benefits are achieved without penalty to the primary function of the turbine as an energy harvester.
In a recent development, the main advantage of the flexible blades is their ability to deform, shedding the excess of load at off-design conditions. This reconfiguration allows control of power by manipulating the angular velocity of the turbine, while achieving passive mitigation of the high-frequency fluctuations that drive fatigue damage.
Recent findings suggest that therefore, the chordwise-flexible blades offer a compelling and robust alternative to state-of-the-art active pitch control. By mitigating loads with a much simpler setup, the flexible blade eliminates a significant source of potential failure and maintenance costs in offshore renewables.
The mechanism for load mitigation is confirmed through DIC measurement and a quasi-steady low-order code, which shows that the stiffness and initial geometry of the blade produce a controlled ‘feather’ as loads increase. The no-flow geometry and stiffness of the blade are designed so that, under flow conditions approaching the design point, it deforms toward the reference rigid-blade configuration.
Looking ahead, this work opens up new pathways for tidal turbine design and cost reduction. The demonstrated reductions in peak and fatigue loading could allow a reduction in structural requirements for both the blades and their supporting structure, lowering capital costs and enabling higher generator ratings, which in turn improve rated capacity per unit mass. Moreover, the increased robustness from the removal of the pitching system reduces operational and maintenance costs. These factors contribute to a lower LCOE of tidal turbines, addressing the primary barrier to the large-scale deployment of tidal energy farms. By making the technology more financially viable, this technology offers a realistic and attractive option for renewable energy production.
All experiments were conducted in the FloWave Ocean Energy Research Facility at the University of Edinburgh, a circular combined wave–current basin designed for scaled testing of offshore renewable energy devices. The tank has a diameter of 25 m and, for the present campaign, was operated in current-only mode with a working water depth of 1.92 m. A schematic of the facility is shown in Extended Data Fig. 6a. The experiments were performed at six inflow velocities in the range u∞ = 0.444–0.923 m s−1, corresponding to a diameter-based Reynolds number,.
from 0.49 × 106 to 1.16 × 106, where ν is the kinematic viscosity and d is the turbine diameter. See Supplementary Note 4 for a discussion on the Reynolds number scaling.
Industry observers note that floWave turbulence is between 8% and 9%, and integral length scales of about 25% of the water depth28. These turbulent characteristics are consistent with energetic tidal sites such as, for example, the Fall of Warness29. There, the turbulence intensity is between 5% and 11%, with integral length scales of approximately 30–50% of the channel depth. The mean vertical shear in FloWave is approximately a power law with a 1/12 exponent (Extended Data Fig. 6b), which is only slightly weaker than the 1/10 power-law profile commonly used to represent tidal flows30. Extended Data Table 1 summarizes the comparison between FloWave and the representative tidal sites.
Industry observers note that A three-bladed horizontal-axis turbine with a rotor diameter d = 1.26 m was installed in the tank centre, at hub height zhub = 0.876 m. The turbine is equipped with a brushless d.c. motor and a 25:1 planetary gearbox. The main components of the turbine are outlined in Extended Data Fig. 7.
The results presented in the main text refer to four sets of blades: one set of rigid blades used as a baseline and three sets of rubber blades. The baseline rigid blades are CNC-machined (SS316) using a modified NACA 63-415 hydrofoil profile along the span. The profile was modified to ensure a blunt trailing edge, as specified in ref. 31. These blades exhibited negligible flapwise and edgewise deformations. Notably, utility-scale tidal turbine blades exhibit some structural compliance. However, here the model-scale rigid blade was deliberately made rigid to provide a defined geometry.
Recent findings suggest that the main text presents the results for the rigid blades and one set of rubber blades with the optimal stiffness. Conversely, the Extended Data figures also include results for the other two sets of rubber blades, with higher and lower stiffness than optimal. The flexible blades were manufactured by injecting a proprietary rubber mixture into a mould and around a steel spar. All rubber blades have the same mould geometry. See Extended Data Fig. 8 for schematics of the rubber blade. The aeroelastic properties of the blade are tailored along its span by varying the ratio of the rigid spar width to the local chord length, which increases from the tip towards the root with an average of 45%.
Industry observers note that the thrust and torque are measured by a force transducer installed between the turbine rotor and the motor shaft (Extended Data Fig. 7). The transducer is bespoke, manufactured by Applied Measurements, rated for an axial load of 1,300 N and a torque of 100 N m, and a resolution of 0.005 N and 0.0004 N m, respectively. In this study, thrust is the net force measured by the hub transducer along the streamwise direction, and torque is the net edgewise moment about the hub axis. Moreover, each blade root was instrumented with a flapwise custom root-bending-moment sensor. Calibration matrices for each sensor were obtained in situ before the test by applying known weights at four points along the cantilever beam attached to the sensor. All force signals were transmitted to a National Instruments NI 9203 acquisition system through a slip ring. The load cells were zeroed without flow before each set of measurements. For each measurement, loads were recorded at a sampling frequency of 128 Hz for 300 s. Rotor angular velocity was measured using an inductive proximity sensor that emitted one pulse per blade pass (three pulses per revolution), enabling determination of the revolution period and computation of the angular velocity.
The principal measured quantities were torque (Q), thrust (T), flapwise root-bending moment (M) and angular velocity (ω). Measured loads and power are non-dimensionalized using standard turbine coefficients:.
The tip-speed ratio is defined as.
where ω is the turbine angular velocity in radians per second.
It has been revealed that sensor accuracy and calibration uncertainties were propagated to the non-dimensional coefficients using standard bias-limit uncertainty analysis32, including thrust-torque transducer manufacturer specification (0.1% of full-scale capacity) and primary uncertainties in u∞, ω and geometric parameters. For the present setup, the maximum total bias limits is of order 10−2 for CP and of order 10−2 for CT (representative values). Supplementary Note 1 provides the full derivations and tables.
Blade deformation was measured using phase-locked DIC with underwater cameras and LED illumination (LaVision). The camera system had a fixed focal length of 1.1 m and a field of view of approximately 0.87 m × 0.56 m, sufficient to capture the full blade span (0.56 m). Phase locking was achieved by using the proximity-sensor signal to trigger image acquisition as a blade passed a fixed azimuthal position, with a horizontal span and a downward tangential velocity. For each condition, between 89 and 447 instantaneous deformation fields were recorded over a 300 s period, depending on u∞ and λ.
Images were processed in LaVision DaVis 11 using a subset size of 21 × 21 pixels and a grid step size of 2 × 2 pixels, resulting in a spatial resolution of approximately 0.68 mm near the blade tip (approximately 2% of the tip chord). A reference image in quiescent water was acquired before each set of measurements. In the present configuration, DIC was used to measure the deformation of the suction-side surface of the blade. The full blade profile was reconstructed by combining the measured chord-line deformation with the known undeformed thickness distribution.
A bespoke fluid–structure interaction (FSI) solver was developed for the present study. The solver couples an in-house code based on blade element momentum theory (BEMT), with a panel method with an integral boundary-layer formulation (XFOIL), and a finite element analysis commercial software (Abaqus). The code uses a two-level iterative process, as schematically shown in Extended Data Fig. 9. The process begins with an initial blade geometry. In the outer loop, the BEMT solver is used to calculate the axial and tangential induction factors on a finite number of blade sections at different radial coordinates. Then, the flow velocity and angle of attack experienced by each blade section are computed. These values are used as initial conditions for the inner FSI loop. First, the pressure distributions around each blade section are computed with XFOIL. Then, the pressure distributions from each blade section are combined to obtain a three-dimensional pressure distribution on the blade, which is used as input to Abaqus, in which a upcoming deformed shape is computed. The Abaqus model includes the steel spar. This new shape is then discretized into sections and returned to XFOIL to recalculate the pressure field. This iterative process continues until the blade shape converges. This deformed blade geometry at equilibrium is then fed back into the outer BEMT loop to revision the induction factors. This entire two-level process is repeated until convergence. The power and thrust coefficients of the whole turbine are then computed by integrating the loads computed with XFOIL for each blade section and multiplying by three to account for the three-bladed turbine.
This code was used to design the stress-free mould shape for each blade stiffness, ensuring that the equilibrium blade shape matches the reference rigid blade at the design flow speed and tip-speed ratio. The model-scale simulations in Extended Data Figs. 4 and 5 are initialized with the mould geometry and use the actual stiffness of the metal spar and of the rubber. In the full-scale simulations (Extended Data Fig. 5), the stiffness of both the spar and the rubber is 10.6 times higher than at model scale to ensure that the model and full-scale Cauchy number for both the spar and the rubber is the same, where.
where ρ is the fluid mass density and E is the Young’s modulus.
The data supporting the findings of this study are available at Edinburgh DataShare repository33.
The in-house fluid–structure interaction code (coupled BEMT, XFOIL and finite element analysis) used to design the blades and to generate the numerical results reported in this study is available at Edinburgh DataShare repository33.
Coles, D. S. et al. A review of global tidal stream energy resources. Proc. R. Soc. A 481, 20240841 https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.2024.0841 (2025).
Article Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that scarlett, G. T. & Viola, I. M. Unsteady hydrodynamics of tidal turbine blades. Renew. Energy 146, 843–855 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2019.06.153 (2020).
Article Google Scholar.
ORE Catapult. Tidal Stream Technology Roadmap. Report 2024 https://edin.ac/494DOPp (ORE Catapult, 2024).
Taveira-Pinto, F., Rosa-Santos, P. & Fazeres-Ferradosa, T. Marine renewable energy. Renew. Energy 150, 1160–1164 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2019.10.014 (2020).
Article Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that neill, S. P. et al. The wave and tidal resource of Scotland. Renew. Energy 114, 3–17 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2017.03.027 (2017).
Article Google Scholar.
Magagna, D. Ocean Energy: Technology Development. Report 2020 https://doi.org/10.2760/81693 (Publications Office of the European Union, 2020).
According to recent reports, kilcher, L., Fogarty, M. & Lawson, M. Marine Energy in the United States: An Overview of Opportunities https://research-hub.nlr.gov/en/publications/marine-energy-in-the-united-states-an-overview-of-opportunities/ (National Renewable Energy Lab, 2021).
Ocean Energy Systems. Ocean Energy and Net Zero: An International Roadmap to Develop 300 GW of Ocean Energy by 2050 https://edin.ac/43dmNid (OES, 2023).
Industry observers note that scarlett, G. T., Sellar, B., van den Bremer, T. & Viola, I. M. Unsteady hydrodynamics of a full-scale tidal turbine operating in large wave conditions. Renew. Energy 143, 199–213 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2019.04.123 (2019).
Article Google Scholar.
Vogel, C. R. & Willden, R. H. J. Improving tidal turbine performance through multi-rotor fence configurations. J. Marine Sci. Appl. 18, 17–25 https://doi.org/10.1007/s11804-019-00072-y (2019).
Article Google Scholar.
Bossanyi, E. A. The design of closed loop controllers for wind turbines. Wind Energy 3, 149–163 https://doi.org/10.1002/we.34 (2000).
Article Google Scholar.
Barlas, T. K., van Wingerden, W., Hulskamp, A. W., van Kuik, G. A. M. & Bersee, H. E. N. Smart dynamic rotor control using active flaps on a small-scale wind turbine: aeroelastic modeling and comparison with wind tunnel measurements. Wind Energy 16, 1287–1301 https://doi.org/10.1002/we.1560 (2013).
Article Google Scholar.
Barlas, T. & Lackner, M. Smart rotor blade technology applied to the upwind reference turbine. In Proc. IEA Topical Expert Meeting on the Application of Smart Structures for Large Wind Turbine Rotor Blades (Sandia National Labs, 2008).
Sources indicate that barlas, T. K., van der Veen, G. J. & van Kuik, G. A. M. Model predictive control for wind turbines with distributed active flaps: incorporating inflow signals and actuator constraints. Wind Energy 15, 757–771 https://doi.org/10.1002/we.503 (2012).
Article Google Scholar.
Viola, I. M. et al. Morphing blades: theory and proof of principles. Int. Mar. Energy J. 5, 183–193 https://doi.org/10.36688/imej.5.183-193 (2022).
Article Google Scholar.
Pisetta, G., Le Mestre, R. & Viola, I. M. Morphing blades for tidal turbines: a theoretical study. Renew. Energy 183, 802–819 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2021.10.085 (2022).
Article Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that dai, W., Broglia, R. & Viola, I. M. Mitigation of rotor thrust fluctuations through passive pitch. J. Fluids Struct. 112, 103599 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluidstructs.2022.103599 (2022).
Article Google Scholar.
Ōtomo, S. et al. A general framework for the design of efficient passive pitch systems. Phys. Fluids 36, 067122 https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0212626 (2024).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Gambuzza, S., Pisetta, G., Davey, T., Steynor, J. & Viola, I. M. Model-scale experiments of passive pitch control for tidal turbines. Renew. Energy 205, 10–29 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2023.01.051 (2023).
Article Google Scholar.
Carroll, J., McDonald, A. & McMillan, D. Failure rate, repair time and unscheduled O&M cost analysis of offshore wind turbines. Wind Energy 19, 1107–1119 https://doi.org/10.1002/we.1887 (2016).
Article Google Scholar.
Vogel, S. Life in Moving Fluids: The Physical Biology of Flow https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctvzsmfc6 (Princeton Univ. Press, 1996).
Fish, F. E. & Lauder, G. V. Passive and active flow control by swimming fishes and mammals. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 38, 193–224 https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev.fluid.38.050304.092201 (2006).
Article MathSciNet Google Scholar.
Bottasso, C. L., Croce, A., Gualdoni, F. & Montinari, P. Load mitigation for wind turbines by a passive aeroelastic device. J. Wind Eng. Ind. Aerodyn. 148, 57–69 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jweia.2015.11.001 (2016).
Article Google Scholar.
In a recent development, cognet, V., du Pont, S. C. & Thiria, B. Material optimization of flexible blades for wind turbines. Renew. Energy 160, 1373–1384 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2020.05.188 (2020).
Article Google Scholar.
In a recent development, liu, B. et al. Digital image correlation in extreme conditions. Thin-Wall. Struct. 205, 112589 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tws.2024.112589 (2024).
Article Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, fagan, E. M., Wallace, F., Jiang, Y., Kazemi, A. & Goggins, J. Design and testing of a full-scale 2 MW tidal turbine blade. In Proc. European Wave and Tidal Energy Conference (EWTEC, 2019).
According to recent reports, thomson, J., Polagye, B., Durgesh, V. & Richmond, M. C. Measurements of Turbulence at Two Tidal Energy Sites in Puget Sound, WA. IEEE J. Ocean. Eng. 37, 363–374 https://doi.org/10.1109/JOE.2012.2191656 (2012).
Article Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that sutherland, D. R. J., Noble, D. R., Steynor, J., Davey, T. & Bruce, T. Characterisation of current and turbulence in the FloWave ocean energy research facility. Ocean Eng. 139, 103–115 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.oceaneng.2017.02.028 (2017).
Article Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that sellar, B. & Sutherland, D. R. J. Tidal Energy Site Characterisation at the Fall of Warness, EMEC, UK. Report by University of Edinburgh (TETHYS, 2016).
Lewis, M., Neill, S. P., Robins, P., Hashemi, M. R. & Ward, S. Characteristics of the velocity profile at tidal-stream energy sites. Renew. Energy 114, 258–272 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.renene.2017.03.096 (2017).
Article Google Scholar.
In a recent development, harvey, S. W. T. et al. Tidal turbine benchmarking project: stage I - steady flow experiments. In Proc. European Wave and Tidal Energy Conference (EWTEC, 2023).
Moffat, R. J. Using uncertainty analysis in the planning of an experiment. J. Fluids Eng. 107, 173–178 https://doi.org/10.1115/1.3242452 (1985).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
In a recent development, zhang, Z. & Tan, J. Data for flexible rubber blades for tidal turbines paper. Edinburgh DataShare https://doi.org/10.7488/ds/8103 (2026).
This work was supported by the Compagnie Générale des Établissements Michelin SCA, ‘Flexible trailing edges for tidal and wind turbines - Phase 2’, and by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) Centre for Doctoral Training in Wind and Marine Energy Systems and Structures, EP/S023801/1. The Shake-The-Box equipment in FloWave was funded by the EPSRC Core Equipment Grant ‘MPIP: Multi-Purpose Imaging Platform for Volumetric Velocity Measurements’, EP/X035174/1.
These authors contributed equally: Zhehong Zhang, Junchen Tan, Eric-Carin Neba, Sylvain Morival, Kuba Frankowski.
School of Engineering, Institute for Energy Systems, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.
Zhehong Zhang, Junchen Tan, Kuba Frankowski & Ignazio Maria Viola.
Manufacture Française des Pneumatiques Michelin, Clermont-Ferrand, France.
Eric-Carin Neba, Sylvain Morival & Bertrand Daval.
Department of Industrial Engineering, Alma Mater Studiorum – University of Bologna, Forlì, Italy.
Department of Energy and Power Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China.
School of Aerospace Engineering, Tsinghua University, Beijing, China.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Z.Z., J.T. and K.F. conducted the investigation; Z.Z., J.T., E.-C.N., S.M. and I.M.V. devised the methodology, Z.Z., J.T. and K.F. developed the software, Z.Z. and J.T. conducted the formal analysis; Z.Z., J.T. and K.F. helped with data curation; Z.Z., J.T. and K.F. wrote the original draft, Z.Z. and I.M.V. reviewed and edited the manuscript; Z.Z. and J.T. helped with visualization; E.-C.N., S.M., B.D. and I.M.V. conceptualized the study; K.F. conducted the numerical analysis. B.D. and I.M.V. helped with the resources, supervised the study, helped with project administration and funding acquisition.
Correspondence to Bertrand Daval or Ignazio Maria Viola.
It has been revealed that E.-C.N., S.M. and B.D. are employed by Manufacture Française des Pneumatiques Michelin, which has filed a patent on the technology demonstrated in this manuscript.
Nature thanks Benjamin Thiria and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
a–c, Time-averaged coefficients of (a) power, (b) thrust, and (c) root bending moment as a function of λ for flexible rubber blades. d, Phase-averaged profiles of blade tips with different stiffness measured with digital image correlation at u∞ = 0.708 m s−1. In d, the blade span is horizontal, and the tangential velocity is pointing downwards; coordinates x, y are normalised by the chord length at the blade tip with origin at the quarter chord.
a–c, Standard deviation of the coefficients of (a) power, (b) thrust, and (c) root-bending moment of the flexible blade nondimensionalised with the corresponding value of the rigid blade at rated speed.
Sources indicate that a–b, Probability density function (PDF) of \(\beta {\prime} =\beta -\bar{\beta }\), where β and \(\bar{\beta }\) are the instantaneous and the phase-averaged pitch, respectively, of the tip section of one blade (optimal stiffness). Measurements are taken with digital image correlation when the blade span is horizontal, and the tangential velocity is pointing downwards, at (a) u∞ = 0.444 m s−1 and (b) 0.708 m s−1.
Recent findings suggest that a–d, Time-averaged coefficients of (a,c) power and (b,d) thrust, (a,b) measured experimentally and (c,d) computed numerically. e, Phase-averaged profiles of blade tips measured experimentally and numerically at u∞ = 0.444 m s−1 and u∞ = 0.708 m s−1. The blade span is horizontal, and the tangential velocity is pointing downwards. Coordinates x, y are normalised by the chord length at the blade tip with origin at the quarter chord.
a–b, Time-averaged coefficients of (a) power, and (b) thrust, as a function of the tip speed ratio at model and full scale.
It has been revealed that a, Schematic of FloWave in plan and oblique view. (A) wavemaker paddles around circumference, (B) turning vanes and flow conditioning filters, (C) current drive impeller units, (D) buoyant raisable floor (15 m ϕ), (E) schematics of streamlines of flow across the tank; direction of flow recirculation shown by blue arrows. Figure adapted with permission from Sutherland et al. 28. b, Vertical velocity profiles at the tank centre. Time-averaged flow velocity measured with a Vectrino velocimeter along a vertical line at the tank centre, and power law least squares best fit.
Schematic of the turbine assembly: (A) turbine blades, (B) interface plates, (C) root-bending-moment transducer, (D) turbine hub, (E) thrust torque transducer, (F) slip ring, (G) 25:1 planetary gearbox, (H) brushless DC motor. b, Schematic of the flexible blade cross-section, showing the rigid leading-edge spar and the flexible trailing edge.
Schematic of the flexible blade cross-section, showing the rigid leading-edge spar and the flexible trailing edge.
Industry observers note that the mould geometry Xi,j is used as input, where i = 0 and j = 0 indicate the iteration number of the inner and outer loop, respectively. The lift and drag coefficient curves (\({C}_{{{\rm{L}}}_{i,j}}(\alpha )\), \({C}_{{{\rm{D}}}_{i,j}}(\alpha )\)) are computed with XFOIL for various blade sections, and the induction factors (\({a}_{i,j},{a}_{i,j}^{{\prime} }\)) are computed with BEMT. Then the pressure distribution (pi,j(x)) around each blade section is computed with XFOIL and assembled into a three-dimensional load condition for Abaqus, where the new geometry is computed (Xi,j, with i increased by one). The inner loop is repeated till ∣∣Xi,j − Xi−1,j∣∣ is smaller than an acceptable threshold ϵi. If converged, the new geometry is Xi,j, where j is increased by one. The outer loop is repeated from the computation of the lift and drag coefficient for the new geometry, till ∣∣Xi,j − Xi,j−1∣∣ is smaller than an acceptable threshold ϵj.
This file contains Supplementary Notes 1–7, including Supplementary Figs. 1–5, Supplementary Tables 1 and 2, and Supplementary References.
Industry observers note that zhang, Z., Tan, J., Neba, EC. et al. Flexible rubber blades for tidal turbines. Nature (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11278-w.
Version of record: 11 November 2026.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11278-w.
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:.
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The City talisman says the gulf between England's top two divisions is signifcant.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (18 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Members of the Tigers' squad continue to attract admiring glances from other potential suitors.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (20 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The influential centre-back has been outstanding in the opening weeks of the new Premier League season.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (22 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Get the full Hull City, Hull FC and Hull KR Premium experience for less than 50p per week.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (21 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Tigers centre-back has headed back to Hull early from international duty because of a knee injury.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (245 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Christian Comotto is one of the brightest gems to emerge from the AC Milan youth system in recent years, but he could stop shining.
In the summer, there was plenty of interest in Comotto. After a strong season with Spezia in Serie B, the youngster was ready to make the step up to Serie A and several clubs came forward offering themselves as potential destinations to aid his growth.
Read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
Industry observers note that yet, Milan made the decision to keep him, believing they could offer him the mentorship and minutes to raise his level and ceiling. However, it’s not played out that way, with the Italian hardly playing so far.
With who is in front of him, it’s understandable, but that doesn’t make his lack of minutes any less frustrating.
Speaking to Sportitalia after Italy U-20’s win against Portugal, he admitted that he was happy with the minutes he’d received, but didn’t deny that he wanted more, as MilanPress relayed.
“I’m only 18, so it’s understandable that with players like Modric and Rabiot ahead of me, it can be more difficult to find space,” he noted.
Industry observers note that “I’m happy to have made my debut in both Serie A and the Europa League. I’m an ambitious guy and I expect more playing time in the coming months. As for everything else, we’ll see later.”.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (498 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Co

Reading youngster Tyler Sackey has featured only in cup matches for the club over the past three seasons. His three senior appearances this term have come in the EFL Trophy, and the 20-year-old has impressed in his outings.
Aside from his EFL Trophy appearances, Sackey has played for the U21s in Premier League 2, operating from central midfield. He impressed last term, and now looks set for a chance to prove his abilities on the senior stage away from Leam Richardson‘s squad.
In a recent development, pete O’Rourke states that Reading have agreed to send Sackney on loan to National League side Aldershot Town. It will give him a chance to play frequent first-team football for the first time in his promising career.
Sackey signed a new contract at the Berkshire outfit in the summer, keeping him tied down until 2029.
Industry observers note that on Sackey’s senior debut, he scored in a 3-1 EFL Trophy win against West Ham United U21s. He also scored against Walsall in the same competition in the 2024/25 season.
The Reading prospect has recent experience against National League sides, including scoring against Woking in a pre-season friendly with a composed left-footed finish this summer.
According to recent reports, sackey offers a creative presence in central midfield and further forward as a No. 10. He has made 158 successful passes in the Premier League 2 this term while winning 59.5% of his duels and having 270 touches. Combined with 27 defensive contributions, it reveals the Royals youngster’s well-rounded game and his work rate out of possession in winning the ball back and showing to receive the ball.
This will be Sackey’s first chance at regular senior minutes, so he needs to be given time to adjust to the physical demands of the game and settle into his role in the team and dressing room at Aldershot.
Reading aren’t afraid to trust youthful creative midfielders, so Sackey has the potential to pave his way into the first team.
Charlie Savage is a prime example of this, following a youth career with Manchester United and a brief loan with Forest Green Rovers. He quickly became a key influence, and Bristol City loanee Josh Stokes has been entrusted with a similar role, having provided three assists so far this season.
Sackey will hope to impress with Aldershot Town to soon replicate those performances for his parent club.
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest Reading news in your inbox every morning.
Enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (25 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
We asked City supporters for their take on the season so far after 10 games and the result was somewhat mixed.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (20 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The impressive defender took the plunge at 20 to leave England and try his luck abroad.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (30 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Stoke City defender discusses changes behind the scenes at Clayton Wood, togetherness driving the squad and his hopes of making an impact with Republic of Ireland.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (22 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Tigers' Wembley hero has been forced to watch the early weeks of the season from the touchline.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (37 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Nine wins in 12 games have transformed the mood around Stoke City and no one knows better than Tony Pulis how supporters can make that team difficult to stop once it gets going.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (32 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The Premier League's five-person board of directors, led by chief executive Richard Masters, is asking clubs for legal protection should Manchester City's sponsors decide to sue them personally.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 6 min read (1188 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

By JOHN MCGARRY, SCOTTISH CHIEF SPORTS FEATURE WRITER.
Published: 12:41 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 13:14 EST, 14 November 2026.
In an age where much of the football on show in the English Premier League is so robotic as to be almost unwatchable, flashes of individual brilliance are increasingly becoming things to be cherished.
Across his time at Liverpool and Bournemouth, Ben Gannon-Doak has sporadically distinguished himself as someone who can light up a game by doing something out of the blue and out of the ordinary.
It has been revealed that as many a defender will testify, that electric burst of pace across a short distance makes him unplayable at times. He has an X-factor which sets him apart from the crowd.
What a shame that injuries have restricted his number of appearances to this point. Since moving south from Celtic in 2022, including a loan spell with Middlesbrough, Gannon-Doak has played fewer than 50 times.
At the very time in his career when he could have done with smoothing off the rough edges, he’s spent far too long rehabilitating from one setback or another.
In the build-up to Friday’s match with North Macedonia, Sebastien Pocognoli spoke about how encouraged he was that the player was finally seeing more game time on the south coast, partly as a result of the team’s maiden voyage in Europe.
Ben Gannon-Doak started in a right wing-back role and had an energetic yet frustrating night.
According to recent reports, the hope of all concerned was that the recent run of matches which the winger had so evidently needed would translate into a more accomplished display in a Scotland jersey. Alas, this proved to be wishful thinking.
Even against very ordinary opposition, Gannon-Doak’s display proved to be another frustrating watch for the Tartan Army.
Time and time again, he brought them to the edge of their seats by facing up a white jersey and seemingly disappearing in a puff of smoke towards the line. Rarely, however, did the end product materialise.
For a winger with such blinding speed to continually struggle with the all-important final ball is a difficult thing to repeatedly witness.
We shall never know, of course, if the player’s crossing ability would be better by this stage if he hadn’t endured such wretched luck with injuries. But you suspect it’s now just about as good as it’s ever going to be.
The trouble for Pocognoli is that the quality of the delivery from wing-backs into the penalty box is arguably the most crucial facet of his preferred 3-4-3 system.
When it breaks down, as it did so often against the group outsiders, the whole thing threatens to grind to a halt.
Gannon-Doak's crossing remains an area of concern for Scotland given his wide position.
According to recent reports, on his record-equalling 102nd cap, Andy Robertson was also guilty of being wasteful on the other flank. Given we know what the skipper has delivered down the years, though, we can write that off as merely a bad night at the office.
The difference with Gannon-Doak is that we’ve rarely seen him tear it up on the flank in a Scotland jersey. So much pace and potential. Not enough positive outcomes when it comes to delivering crosses. In 21 matches, he has three assists and one goal. Those aren’t great numbers.
Just how long do you persevere with a player who doesn’t look to have the requisite skill set for such a specialised and vital position?
Aaron Hickey clearly doesn’t have the pace of the man who he replaced late on, yet he’s hardly a slouch. He is, though, more switched on defensively. And he does know how to cross a football.
It was telling that Gannon-Doak’s most positive contribution of the night against the group outsiders came when he left his station to move infield and take Oli McBurnie’s pass in his stride with the score standing at one-apiece.
His surge towards the goal initially looked like it had been hampered by a heavy touch only for VAR to correctly identify that he’d been impeded by the goalkeeper. He earned his corn in that moment.
John McGinn’s conversion from 12 yards, his second goal of the night, spared Pocognoli’s blushes after a display which didn’t exactly inspire.
That sequence of play certainly raised the possibility that Gannon-Doak could be utilised to better effect in another role.
Gannon-Doak's forward burst led to the award of a penalty and hinted at an alternative role.
According to recent reports, if played more centrally, his crossing – undoubtedly his weak spot – would not be such an concern. But the acceleration and driving runs would still be there to cause chaos in and around the penalty box. That will always be his strong suit.
To get the best out of him, maybe the manager needs to redefine him.
Any redeployment would, obviously, create another problem. If Pocognoli remains wedded to the current system, it seems likely that Billy Gilmour and Lewis Ferguson will occupy the two holding berths.
Ahead of them, and behind the main striker, McGinn and Scott McTominay are virtually undroppable. It might be the case then, that Gannon-Doak is eventually utilised as an impact sub. Yet, it would not be a plan without its merits.
Sources indicate that he’s got a part to play in this set-up. Probably just not where he’s at the moment being positioned.
Sources indicate that you’d be surprised, frankly, if he started in St Gallen on Monday. Switzerland are a far superior side to North Macedonia, already assured of promotion to League A by topping the section and looking to end this campaign with a flourish against a Scotland side they beat comfortably at Hampden.
They’ll ask far more questions of Pocognoli’s side. It feels like a task more suited to Hickey.
Scotland, collectively, will need to buck up their ideas if they are to stand any chance of emerging with a positive outcome or, at the least, some credit.
Scotland fans are desperate to see Gannon-Doak succeed but a little change might be needed.
There was a flatness to Friday’s performance, especially in a first half in which the much-vaunted high-press was conspicuous by its absence.
The passing was too safe and predictable. The tempo was low and the play was unimaginative. By half-time, the visitors had fashioned the better chance when Enis Bardhi smashed the ball into the side net.
Scotland were markedly better after the turnaround. After Billy Gilmour’s scarcely believable miss, they were deserving of the opener which came when McGinn burst into the box and lashed home after fine work from Che Adams.
Stemming straight from a corner, North Macedonia’s equaliser – which ended their eight-game goal drought – asked a serious question of Pocognoli’s players.
To their credit, they stepped up with Gannon-Doak’s foray into the box causing the moment of indecision on which the game swung.
The manner of a first Hampden win for Pocognoli won’t live long in the memory. The fervent hope is that it proves to be the start of something.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (31 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Lou Macari has dedicated his life to helping the most vulnerable people in Stoke-on-Trent and he is grateful that football gave him the chance to do it.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (29 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Lewis Koumas reflects on how two years on loan in the Championship helped get him ready to force his way into the Liverpool first team.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (20 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Former Stoke City coach believes Luke Graham is 'more than capable of playing at that level'.
📅 20 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 26 min read (5225 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Sometimes comments, however over the top, hit home. Michael Carrick will desperately hope the remark from his former Manchester United team-mate Gary Neville is not one of them. That it does not stick. That it does not come to define his time in charge of United this season – if he lasts this season. Or be used in one of those highlight reels, with doom-laden music, to explain the story of this Premier League campaign.
On TV co-commentary duty for Sky, Neville referred to United as “blue mannequins” (they were wearing their away kit) and said that for a period after half-time it was the worst he had ever seen them play since he started watching, aged five. Neville is now 51. That is a lot of games to settle on this conclusion so strongly and, surely, inaccurately.
Sources indicate that "They were absolutely mannequins!" Gary Neville indicates Michael Carrick has to stop defending the Manchester United players. pic.twitter.com/Pa4PqIoRbh.
It has been revealed that but so passive was their football that is the way he felt in the moment. For a club with United’s “attack, attack, attack” tradition – becoming something of a distant memory as seasons pass – that is a damning as it gets.
Sources indicate that neville’s Sky paymasters will be delighted by his emotive, insulting, headline-grabbing language. But he of course exaggerated a point to make a point. United, and Carrick, were, indeed, far too passive, lacking aggression, urgency and belief. They just do not press. United did, for too long, play like a team of dummies.
Against Fulham they almost played walking football until they conceded, desperation kicked in and they chased the game to salvage a late draw.
It has been revealed that it begs the question: what is Carrick doing with this team? Yes, he may have been let down by no defensive signings in the summer – even if he must have bought into the initiative to prioritise a midfield rebuild – but he is far from absolved from blame.He will cling to the response to Lisandro Martínez’s own goal, to striking a post twice in the first half from Matheus Cunha and Bruno Fernandes, to managing to avoid a third successive defeat in a week, which would have led to the crisis klaxon being sounded. Carrick can talk about how ridiculous it would be to question his position as head coach. But is it?
Recent findings suggest that we now go into a three-week international break and the Premier League vacuum would have been filled by a debate over Carrick’s future, whether he is up to the job and another existential examination as to where United are heading. And who is to blame.
That still might happen. United did not lose. But they were not remotely good enough, as has been the case for most of the season. Their only league win in five was against newly promoted Ipswich Town, having lost to newly promoted Hull City. They have also drawn at Everton and now at Fulham, who started the day bottom of the table and remain winless. Apart from facing Manchester City, it has hardly been the most taxing of starts. Except they are down in 12th and have not played well at all.
Industry observers note that it is not just that. Last year, United revamped their attack. Benjamin Sesko was absent through injury but are Cunha – despite his goal – Bryan Mbeumo and Marcus Rashford actually showing they are good enough? They, too, are passive and do not effect the play. Do not have that killer instinct. There is then an over-reliance on Fernandes. And if he does not do it, then who steps up?
That 15 minutes after half-time that culminated in the Martínez mishap was certainly woeful. But despite going close, United were also second best in the opening period, with Fulham’s 19-year-old academy product Josh King showing why he was so close to a senior England call-up. The forward ran riot, tormenting left-back Luke Shaw and was only denied by Senne Lammens. On more than one occasion, especially with a smart save with his right boot.
The goalkeeper was at the centre of Fulham’s goal, which was a shambles that summed up the state of United, who are just too easy to play against. And, so, Fulham’s captain Calvin Bassey was too strong for Cunha, who threw himself to the ground, looking for a foul, losing the ball from Kobbie Mainoo’s easy pass. The defender strode forward before Lammens parried his low shot, which then bounced off Martínez and back past the goalkeeper and into the net.
Sources indicate that it was a Hammersmith End House of Horrors for United. To cap it all, Martínez then tried to blame Lammens who had, frankly, kept United in the game up until that point and could legitimately have told him where to go. And asked why he could not trap a ball and clear.
Sources indicate that "A horror at the Hammersmith end!"Lisandro Martínez puts the ball into his own net and Fulham lead! 😯 pic.twitter.com/jDmY4zL2XN.
It has been revealed that fulham will certainly feel their own frustration. But with their new head coach Álvaro Arbeloa and an evolving team – if only striker Gonzalo García was more deadly – there are clear signs of optimism, having also just drawn at Liverpool.
Recent findings suggest that united’s late equaliser was fortunate. Yes, they applied pressure but to no real effect until Cunha’s shot deflected off the boot of Fulham defender David Affengruber as he tried to block, to wrong-foot goalkeeper Bernd Leno, who had also been outstanding. It was credited to Cunha, his first of the season, and the relief from Carrick was understandably palpable.
Manchester United are LEVEL! 🔴 pic.twitter.com/DCxwlrzf1M.
But, once again, it was not up to the standard needed. And beyond the point, beyond the avoidance of defeat, that is the reality of where United are right now under Carrick who needs to step up, take more responsibility. And, like his team, be far less passive. Otherwise, he will not last.
Recent findings suggest that might these games offer less possession and more counter-attacking chances? That’s glass half full.
I was purely referring to the fact that they walked around the pitch. I’ve never seen a Manchester United team walk around on the pitch that much.
According to recent reports, michael has got to stop defending them. I get why he wants to defend them, he’s loyal, and there’s a long way to go into the season.
Both teams were the same, I called them mannequins. I’ve never seen United walk around so much out of possession, no alertness, no being on your toes.
I wish he could play those attacking players, but they are going to kill him defensively.
Neville goes on to call that period: “An absolute disgrace, nowhere near good enough.”.
It has been revealed that "They were absolutely mannequins!" Gary Neville says Michael Carrick has to stop defending the Manchester United players. pic.twitter.com/Pa4PqIoRbh.
In a recent development, I know Manchester United have a lot of individual quality, I have played against them for many years and know them really well. I know to be alert in case they shoot from distance. When you make some saves in the game you feel very focused. Unfortunately I couldn’t keep out the goal but that is football.
I didn’t think we were. Did you think we were? Football is a difficult game. We controlled a lot of the first half. It’s the Premier League and you will have spells where you don’t have it all your own way. To expect total dominance for the whole game, I don’t think anyone gets that in this league.
I thought we should have won the game, I thought we created enough to win the game. The goal we did concede is one of them goals. The boys could have thought it is one of those days but I really like the reaction. We nearly won it in the end. We came to get the win of course, the way it panned out and the way we finished is the positive we take from it.
In a recent development, I think we did a good game. Obviously not an easy game for us, we were in the bottom position but we saw personality with the ball, we were brave. We had moments where we had to defend but in general we did a good game.
We wanted to control the transition and the counter attacks. We know they put too many people inside so we have to control the space behind our midfielders. They sometimes found the spaces, it is a difficult match against a big team and for me they will be near the top of the league by the end of the season.
Industry observers note that now we have to find the first victory. If you see our first five games we have already played Man Utd, Chelsea, at Anfield, at Sunderland. Now we have an October that will be so important for us.
Industry observers note that there were so many things for them, you can see it in the foul by [Harry] Maguire. Every decision was for them. I knew after the game against Manchester City that they don’t like Manchester United to lose.
It’s hard to explain, I feel after the first half we always get a lot of chances and create, play well.
Sources indicate that in the beginning of the second half they put in more energy than us and we cannot accept this. We always play better after conceding goal, and it cannot be like this.
Industry observers note that I don’t think today was about final decisions, we were a bit unlucky, I hit the post, and Bruno hit the post. We need to create more and hope the luck comes and we score. We need to improve in every single position.
According to recent reports, it was too slow, Fulham ran more and looked like they wanted to win more. Bassey just eased Cunha out the way [for Fulham’s goal] and looked like he wanted to take the game to Man United and Carrick will be thinking ‘we need to do a lot more’.
It was a game that was a real struggle for both teams. Both lacked confidence. There were challenges for both managers coming into this game, they both need the international break to start their seasons again.
In a recent development, the defensive work from both teams was awful and lacked effort. Carrick will be relieved going back to Manchester with a goal and a point.
Manchester United play Spurs when the Premier League returns in three weeks, in a game that will feel huge.
In a recent development, 5 - With five points, this is Manchester United's joint-lowest tally after five games of a Premier League season, also picking up five in 2014-15.Sluggish. pic.twitter.com/UZTBWRpGnm.
It has been revealed that fulham remain winless but the draw lifts them above Spurs, who will spend the international break at the foot of the table. It is just one win in five for United, and it was another performance which was far from convincing. It could have been worse though, they were a few minutes away from losing. On this evidence, both of these teams are in for a struggle relative to expectations.
Fulham wanted a free-kick on the edge of the box for a sliding challenge on Kevin for Maguire but the referee decides he got the ball.
United break forward and win a corner. It comes for Martinez who shifts his feet to shoot with his right foot and the goal-bound effort was blocked!
Just the three minutes of added time to play, but United are the team pushing forward searching for an unlikely winner.
Industry observers note that united may have just spared themselves a damaging defeat, and there might just be time to go on an win this. Cunha with a speculative shot from outside the box, and Affengruber extends his left leg to block the shot but the deflection leaves Leno stranded. A stroke of luck for United but Fulham have invited it.
It has been revealed that manchester United are LEVEL! 🔴 pic.twitter.com/DCxwlrzf1M.
Industry observers note that bassey now penalised for a high boot on Dalot, United free-kick on the halfway line. Fulham just about standing firm, and they are helped when a crossfield pass towards Dorgu bounces off for a throw-in.
In a recent development, united with another corner and there are loud appeals for a handball penalty against Bassey, the proximity was very close but his hand was up. But VAR takes a look and the fact the hand was tucked in towards his chest spares the Fulham defender.
Fulham and the home crowd happy with a goal kick after an overhit cross towards Shaw at the back post. Dorgu has been sent on in Carrick’s last throw of the dice, replacing Shaw at left-back.
You would not say United are pulling Fulham from pillar to post, it feels a little hopeful, but it is one-way traffic. An attack against defence session in Fulham’s half. Charles and Kevin do well to relieve the pressure momentarily, but United are back on the attack again.
Industry observers note that here are those changes: Mason Mount on for Kobbie Mainoo for United, while Andersen replaces King for the home team. Arbeloa happy to hold what he has. Lisandro Martinez volleys a shot over the bar.
Positive first involvement from Zirkzee, releasing Mbeumo, but the Fulham defenders read his intentions and blocked the shot after he cut inside. Joachim Andersen is preparing to come on for Fulham, as is Mason Mount for United.
Much better from Fulham, another attack started by Bassey reading play just like the goal, but this time Lammens’s wrists were strong to parry Kevin’s shot. Rashford is then flagged offside.
Fulham change: Larsson is on for Berge, Sweden for Norway. And Carrick has brought on Zirkzee for Rashford. Famous last words, but does that make you more likely to score a goal? Not that Rashford can feel hard done to.
It has been revealed that fulham have stopped playing since they scored, and they needed Leno again to tip a Cunha shot around the post. The United forward was falling over, but he generated enough power to trouble the goalkeeper. From the corner, Maguire picks up the ball on the far side and chips a cross over the blue shirts in the middle.
Industry observers note that kevin sold himself in a one-on-one with Rashford, but King did well to put his foot in at the edge of the box and the ball bounces through kindly to Leno. Tielemans then misplaces a pass when United were in a promising position.
If United had played like this from the start of the second half they would not be losing, but now they have just 20 minutes plus stoppage time to overturn the deficit.
Fulham making a double sub: Kevin and Palacios on for Iwobi and Bobb.
United have roused themselves since conceding, winning a flurry of corners.
Recent findings suggest that what a save from Leno! Mbeumo’s curling shot from outside the box was arcing beautifully into the far corner, but the German goalkeeper tipped his effort around the post.
Then Maguire is eased out at the back post, and Fulham breathe a sigh of relief.
Strong words from Gary Neville after the goal went it: “I’ve watched United since the age of five and that is the worst 15 minutes [from half-time to the goal] I have seen them play.”.
Well doesn’t that just sum up United’s season so far. There are appeals for a foul on Cunha from Bassey, but the Fulham defender was stronger and he took some initiative to drive towards the box. Bassey let fly and kept his shot down, Lammens could only stick out a leg and the ball rebounded off the helpless Martinez and back into the net.
In a recent development, "A horror at the Hammersmith end!"Lisandro Martínez puts the ball into his own net and Fulham lead! 😯 pic.twitter.com/jDmY4zL2XN.
Fulham have a corner after it opened up nicely for Iwobi at the edge of the box, but his left-footed strike deflects behind. A very smooth footballer, but finishing has never been Iwobi’s strong suit. Fulham fail to make anything of the corner.
Fulham and United’s fans now urging their teams on after the game halted to glacial pace. Nothing much happening at all since the start of the second half.
In a recent development, gary Neville growing increasingly frustrated by the lack of intensity out of possession by both teams: “Never walk on a football pitch.” Questions have been asked of United’s fitness levels and physical readiness for the upcoming season. Fulham enjoying a spell of possession in United’s half again.
More from Neville: “It’s like it’s time for the whites to play against the blue mannequins, before they reverse it up the other end. One thing I do know, I’ve played in a lot of football matches, it’s not right.”.
Industry observers note that there has been a real lack of conviction in Rashford’s play in the final third, this time it was underhit pass across the box towards Mbeumo which was cut out. Good ball by Tielemans to release Rashford, but no end product again.
It has been revealed that sir Alex Ferguson is watching on at Craven Cottage. The game has slipped into one of its lulls again.
Nice football from Fulham involving Charles and Iwobi but United break forward after a loose touch by Bobb. Fernandes did well to keep the ball and wait for support, and Castagne is booked for a block on Rashford.
The first few minutes of the half are played deep in Fulham’s territory, but United’s delivery from wide is not good enough and Cunha is penalised for a foul in the middle in any case.
Fulham kick off in the second half.
At half-time that is another worrying performance from Manchester United. Yes, they could be ahead and have created chances, with Bruno Fernandes hitting the post. But on the balance of play they should be behind with Fulham’s 19-year-old Josh King the best player on the pitch and United reliant on goalkeeper Senne Lammens. Michael Carrick has more work to do during the interval than Fulham’s Alvaro Arbeloa and cannot be happy with how defensively vulnerable his team and but also how wasteful they are in front of goal.
Recent findings suggest that both teams will believe they should have scored in that first half in a game that has oscillated between periods of passivity and flurries of goal-mouth action. When United speed up their interplay, it looks like they can cut through Fulham, but Carrick’s team’s box defending leaves much to be desired. There were 26 shots on goal without reward in that 45 minutes.
Another chance is missed, this time Rashford with a side foot over the bar from a Cunha cross that took a nick on the way through. Always leaning back, poor technique from a player of his standing.
Fulham then throw a punch back, but King is booked for diving after pushing the ball beyond Maguire. The attacker is not happy, but not sure he can have any complaints.
United almost caught out by a one-two between Iwobi and Garcia, but Lammens rushes off his line to get there first. Both attacks look to have the beating of both defences, but somehow there have been no goals.
In a recent development, united’s best move of the game, starting with a whipped pass from Tielemans when under pressure into Dalot who turns into space inside. Fernandes could have taken a shot on himself from the edge of the box, but he moved the ball on to Rashford but his side-foot shot was tame and straight at Leno.
It has been revealed that the game has settled after that flurry of chances when both teams could easily have scored. Fulham do well to block Rashford’s sight of goal as he cuts inside looking for a shot, and then Mbeumo commits a foul.
It has been revealed that cunha with a deflected strike from distance, which arcs over Leno and glances off the post! The sort of deflection that gives a goalkeeper no chance, Leno was scrambling.
Sources indicate that mainoo’s shot is blocked from the corner, and then Fulham break forward with numbers. Iwobi picks out Josh King in the box, and Lammens sticks out a right leg to keep out his driven shot.
Josh King is again showing why he was so close to a full England call-up. The 19-year-old is at the heart of the action as Fulham continue to create chance after chance against a very shaky Manchester United defence who have been reliant on goalkeeper Senne Lammens.
Fulham respond, with Robinson’s cross looping to the back post to the unmarked King but he could not get over the side-foot volley and it was a comfortable save from Lammens.
In a recent development, this stop was less comfortable though: Lammens plunges to his right to keep out a dig by Sander Berge from the edge of the box. It came after Garcia kicked fresh air in the area.
Then Bobb collects the ball in space at the edge of the box and is able to turn but he dragged his shot wide.
The home team and crowd have burst into life.
It has been revealed that fernandes hits the post for United! He should score, and it was poor defending from Fulham. Affengruber ran beyond the ball and was rolled by Cunha who was able to drive into the box, and he pulled the ball back for Fernandes who dragged his shot a touch, and it rebounded off the foot of the post.
Bruno Fernandes hits the post! 😬 pic.twitter.com/jMzn8ZyoYa.
Better from United, turning the screw around the Fulham box but neither Mainoo nor Rashford fashion room for a shot, and then Dalot shoots wide from 25 yards with his weaker left foot.
Recent findings suggest that josh King finding space off the shoulder of United’s midfield again, but his shot from a tight angle is always rising. United are asking for trouble though if Fulham’s most creative player keeps collecting the ball in those spaces.
United then come forward, with Robinson selling himself against Mbeumo, but Rashford cannot get over the header at the back post.
Fulham with a smooth passage of play from deep, finding space down United’s right and Garcia had made a dangerous run between Maguire and Martinez. Iwobi looked for his team-mate, but the ball glanced off his foot as he tried to direct it towards goal.
It has been revealed that the interesting thing about Manchester United’s attack is that while they are all, clearly, individually good players do they actually do enough to warrant their status at the club? The truth is Matheus Cunha, Bryan Mbeumo and Marcus Rashford simply have to do more and dominate games. We are yet to see that form them this season and, apart from Lisandro Martinez forcing a fine save from Bernd Leno, Fulham have carried the greater threat here.
According to recent reports, fulham have a corner after Josh King used his body well against Shaw. There has been lots of cat and mouse so far, both teams trying to play patiently from deep and the out of possession team lying in wait for a mistake. United clear the Fulham corner.
According to recent reports, bassey defends well in the area, but United are starting to warm to their task. Tielemans lifts a dangerous cross into the box, and Fernandes’s header deflects off Affengruber and behind for a corner.
A short corner comes to nothing, but from a second or possibly third phase Lisandro Martinez lets fly from distance with a swerving, outside of the left foot shot. Appeared destined for the corner, but Leno pushed the ball around the post. Great try from Martinez.
In a recent development, united have settled on the ball now, enjoying some possession of their own in non-threatening areas. Neither team appears too interested in gambling on the high press, a degree of wariness in their approaches. That was a nice Fulham move, sweeping from right to left, but Iwobi chipped a cross into Lammens’s gloves. Tielemans then looks for the run of Rashford with a through ball, but the forward is offside. Plenty of green grass behind Fulham’s back four though.
Fulham move the ball well again, Robinson setting the ball back for Garcia to strike from just outside the box but he dragged his shot wide of the near post. Too much time and space for the forward if you are United inclined, though. Tielemans then passes the ball out of play, splitting the difference between Dalot and Mbeumo.
Recent findings suggest that promising signs for Josh King as he carries the ball from the right touchline into a dangerous central position, unchallenged by United’s midfield. The home team have monopolised the ball so far, United sitting off in a shape, perhaps waiting for an error and the chance to counter-attack.
United get the game under way at Craven Cottage.
Very difficult to predict what you are going to be served by either of these teams. Both of their seasons are on a knife edge even at the this early juncture.
If Manchester United could choose a Premier League away fixture to revitalise their season, Fulham would be it. Not just because they are bottom of the league with just one point, albeit impressively earned last week away to Liverpool, but because United have not been beaten at Craven Cottage since December 2009 – although, not such a good omen for United, is the fact that Michael Carrick was in their team that day (playing at centre-back).
Industry observers note that michael Carrick dismissed as “ridiculous” any suggestion that his job as Manchester United’s head coach was at risk this early in the season. But he needs a positive result today against Fulham otherwise much of the prolonged international break will be taken up by debate as to whether he is up to it. United do not play again after today until they host stricken Tottenham Hotspur on October 10 and their start to this season has simply not been good enough. The concern for Carrick appears his inability to positively affect games when things are going against United.
Fulham starting XI: Leno, Castagne, Affengruber, Bassey, Robinson, Berge, Charles, King, Bobb, Iwobi, Garcia.
Subs: Lecomte, Andersen, Palacios, Muniz, Kevin, Larsson, Manuel Angel, Sessegnon. Smith Rowe.
Industry observers note that here's how The Fulham shape up. ⚪️ pic.twitter.com/0IxS0J3ldf.
United starting XI: Lammens, Dalot, Martinez, Maguire, Shaw, Mainoo, Tielemans, Fernandes, Mbeumo, Cunha, Rashford.
Subs: Darlow, Mazraoui, Mount, Zirkzee, Dorgu, Yoro, Andrey Santos, Heaven, Baleba, Lacey.
Presenting your United XI to face Fulham ✊.
The script pretty much writes itself these days. A flicker of optimism and hope of a fresh start giving way to the same old frustrations, complaints and inquests, the cumulative toll of which places an ever greater strain on a club mired in mediocrity but with little reprieve from the expectations that come with bearing such an illustrious name.
Michael Carrick says Pro Ref’s apology over the derby fiasco means little to Manchester United – but warned his players they cannot allow such setbacks to derail their season.
Chief refereeing officer Howard Webb formally apologised to United after the VAR officials Matt Donohue and Blake Antrobus failed to spot Enzo Fernandez was offside before wrongly allowing Erling Haaland’s winning goal to stand in Manchester City’s 1-0 victory at Old Trafford.
United were left shocked by the scale of the blunder, which came with 30 minutes of the game remaining and City already down to 10 men.
But Carrick has told his players not to become preoccupied with such injustices as they bid to overcome their poor start to the season before a crucial trip to Craven Cottage.
“It can have an impact in the moment of time, it can have a big impact, but we can’t let it have an impact on the rest of the season,” the United manager noted.
Industry observers note that “That’s for us to get back to winning ways as soon as possible. Listen, one-off things can happen, at the time it was a pretty significant one, we know that. I don’t think I need to go over that.
“But yeah, I’ve got faith in it [VAR], it’s the system that we work towards and that we use so the apology doesn’t mean an awful lot.”.
Carrick added: “I can appreciate and I respect it for them putting their hands up and saying we got that wrong, I think it happens - it does happen.
It has been revealed that “But moving forward, yeah, we just have to deal with it, what’s thrown in front of us. And maybe we get one or two decisions on the back of how it balances out - percentages or law of averages or whatever that may be.
“But that was a pretty significant one to take and had a huge impact on that game and that’s why it was particularly tough.”.
Michael Carrick may have had a point when he said it was “ridiculous” to question his future this early in the season, but this afternoon’s game at Fulham will shape the mood at Manchester United for the next three weeks.
A tally of four points from their first four games of the season is a disappointing start, and Brighton added to the sense of gloom in the League Cup by becoming the first side in 50 years to win from 2-0 down at Old Trafford.
With Champions League football on the agenda, that competition was at the bottom of United’s priority list but the ragged nature of the performance prompted boos around the stadium.
The no-show at Hull and defeat to 10-man City also fall into the “it’s how you lose” category of defeat, while there are widening fissures between the fanbase and the club’s hierarchy over ticketing policy and Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s political interventions.
Sources indicate that the mood has also been sour at Fulham in the first few weeks of the season. In fact, they start the game bottom of the Premier League with one point, but do have the incentive of knowing a draw would take them above Spurs.
Following reports of friction between some established players and new head coach Alvaro Arbeloa though, they produced their best performance of the season in a goalless draw at Anfield last week when they had chances to win the game.
Sources indicate that fulham made nine changes in the League Cup in mid-week, but still ran out 3-2 winners at West Ham. Despite the west London club being an established mid-table Premier League team for a number of seasons, and United’s vulnerable state for the past few years, Fulham have beaten their opponent’s just once in the league since December 2009.Full team news on the way shortly.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (270 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

This morning, some progress has been made by AC Milan in their attempt to renew Adrien Rabiot’s deal, it seems.
It’s been a season of big renewals so far for Milan, and they’re not yet done. In fact, there are a few core players who they are looking to tie down to longer-term deals and Rabiot is among them.
Read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
With five goals and as many assists already this season, he’s thriving for Ruben Amorim, who is keen to keep him as an essential player in his team.
In this morning’s edition of Corriere dello Sport (via MilanNews), the leading line is that Rabiot remains key, and that the Rossoneri aim to tie down his future by the end of the season. That much is not new information, but it’s a reminder that he’s not been forgotten.
Sources indicate that with Christian Pulisic’s renewal finalised, the Frenchman is next in line, with his importance not unknown to the Diavolo. Indeed, they are ready to offer him what could be his final ‘significant’ contract, which would see him extend his stay at San Siro until 2030.
Alongside this, a pay rise from €3.5 million to €5m per season is expected, another reminder of his importance.
In a recent development, the step here, though, is that the offer has now officially been made and is laying on the table. Rabiot played at San Siro last night, and he’ll now take some time to evaluate the offer from the club, which he now calls home.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (27 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Stoke City striker Robert Bozenik has a big smile on his face after helping the team to three successive wins in the Championship.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 5 min read (940 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

It has been revealed that blackburn Rovers dropped a saddening bombshell on Tuesday morning as they unveiled head coach Tony Mowbray will be stepping back from his position due to health issues. The boss expressed his pride in the players, thanked his coaching staff and the supporters for their backing, and asked for privacy for himself and his family.
It marks the second time Mowbray has done so, temporarily withdrawing from his position at Birmingham City in February 2024 after being diagnosed with bowel cancer.
Recent findings suggest that the news has been met with an outpouring of support from across English football, and deservedly so. Mowbray is one of the most universally liked figures in our game, and all hope to see him recover speedily.
It has been revealed that blackburn Rovers fans have sent their best wishes and got behind Mowbray first, of course. However, the news has understandably led to questions over what happens next at Ewood Park.
Industry observers note that at the time of writing, it appears Blackburn Rovers will not be appointing a fresh head coach – not permanently, anyway. The wording of the club’s statement confirming Mowbray’s situation said he is ‘stepping back’, not stepping down, leaving, or anything similar.
First-team coaches Damien Johnson and Mike Dodds are taking over duties for the time being, and no further statement will be made, the club states.
According to recent reports, the situation played out similarly upon Mowbray’s withdrawal from duties at Birmingham City. His long-term assistant Mark Venus took charge in his absence before the boss took formal medical leave and Gary Rowett was appointed on an interim basis.
This is a latest and developing situation, but Rovers’ statement indicates a new boss will not be coming in at this moment in time. Trusted local reporter Elliott Jackson has since stated on X that the club ‘are certainly not looking for a successor right now’.
In a recent development, without arguing semantics but to add clarity, I’m told Tony Mowbray has not ‘resigned’ or ‘stepped down’.He’s ‘stepped back’ to take a period to focus on his health. How long is that for? We don’t know.Club are certainly not looking for a successor right now. #Rovers🌹 https://t.co/9M8aWSEgsx.
Recent findings suggest that mowbray cuts a hugely popular figure at Ewood Park. After relegation in 2016/17, he led them back from League One and consolidated their place back in the Championship before moving on at the end of his contract in 2022.
Sources indicate that there were some reservations over his return though. It felt like an easy and crowd-pleasing move, but some questioned whether Mowbray could replicate his previous success after his absence and ill-fated second stint as West Brom boss.
Sources indicate that however, Mowbray quickly made his presence felt at Blackburn Rovers, and they have overachieved in the first 15 games of the campaign. A side widely touted as relegation candidates now sits 13th in the table, three points off the play-offs and with substantial wins over top sides like West Ham, Millwall and Middlesbrough.
Mowbray has brought forward-thinking back to Ewood Park. It has seen creative aces like Todd Cantwell and Dapo Afolayan thrive, and star striker Andri Gudjohnsen has benefitted massively. Furthermore, the boss’ track record with developing youngsters has helped Kristi Montgomery come on leaps and bounds.
Recent findings suggest that the 62-year-old has given Rovers fans something to celebrate again after tough years with poor football and growing frustration towards the ownership. Of course, hostility towards the hierarchy has not waned, but the quality of the football on display and positivity surrounding Mowbray’s return have made for a welcome change.
Sources indicate that this is an unforeseen development that Blackburn Rovers have no choice but to deal with. Losing Mowbray, even if only temporarily, is a big blow, and it will impact the players.
Recent findings suggest that johnson and Dodds will focus on offering continuity. It will be smart to stick to Mowbray’s methods and a similar tactical strategy, but they must be prepared to make bold decisions and necessary changes if form does falter.
Then, there’s the responsibility of the club hierarchy. It appears an external successor is not going to be named, but if Mowbray can not return to the dugout, the likes of Balaji Rao, Steve Curwood and Rudy Gestede have to be prepared with a plan to ensure it doesn’t derail their season.
It has been revealed that when Birmingham City were met with the same situation, their initial action to promote Venus as interim boss did not work. Then, they acted too late to bring in an external replacement, and Rowett could not save them from relegation.
It is an awful predicament for Rovers, but they must be prepared for all scenarios to protect the club.
In the short term, though, Johnson, Dodds, the rest of the coaching staff and the Blackburn Rovers squad will be determined to deliver a derby day win over rivals Burnley for Mowbray as he recovers.
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest Blackburn Rovers news in your inbox every morning.
Sources indicate that enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (26 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Manager Mark Robins, defender Ben Wilmot, game-changing midfielder Jack McGlynn and Stoke City's sparkling form has gone unnoticed by EFL decision makers.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (22 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
A busy summer transfer window at Stoke City saw half a dozen senior players make a permanent exit.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 5 min read (984 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

By JAKE FENNER, US SPORTS WRITER.
Published: 13:29 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 13:42 EST, 14 November 2026.
Perhaps it's incredibly cynical, and maybe too harsh, to call the tears that fell down the face of Mauricio Pochettino 'performative.' But it's the first word that came to mind – followed by 'surprising' and 'a bit much.'.
It was only four months ago when the Argentine who had been atop the United States' men's national team since 2024 signed a contract extension to stay on board for another four years.
'We want to try to have a lasting impact on the sport in the country that has welcomed us so warmly and for that impact to extend beyond results on the field,' Pochettino said when his contract was signed.
Recent findings suggest that yet, after a few months and one international window, that experiment to make a 'lasting impact' has ended. Pochettino may have cried because he fell in love with the country, but it's not like he got fired. Instead, he's off to lead one of the world's greatest football brands in Manchester United.
Recent findings suggest that so now the question turns to the legacy Pochettino leaves behind. Plenty of American soccer writers and fans point to the spirit the former Chelsea boss created and how he helped to energize a team which had been bogged down by past coaches.
But Pochettino's results don't scream success. The World Cup finish was nothing special compared to his peers, his record against the best nations the USA faced was poor and he'll leave as the first full-time USMNT manager in nearly 30 years to not win at least one trophy.
Mauricio Pochettino cried as he left the United States' top job for Manchester United.
Pochettino's USMNT played exciting football, but ultimately didn't progress past the norm.
But any potential for further growth evaporated when the Argentine returned to England.
By all accounts, the greatest thing Pochettino did was install a hungry, all-in-or-nothing culture in a team bogged down by an earth-rocking scandal and a poor 2024 Copa America run.
In a recent development, but he did so in a way that often left the biggest players of the USMNT system behind. Rather than keep a consistent core of his best players around, he seemed intent on tinkering with the lineup in each window.
It has been revealed that the results reflect that instability. Leading to the World Cup, Pochettino played 12 games against sides in the top 30 of the FIFA World Rankings. He won just three fixtures – drawing once and losing the remaining eight.
According to recent reports, all the while, he was linked to returns to Europe. Pochettino may have mentioned in his exit press conference that he 'never said I wanted to go back to the Premier League' but the Premier League certainly wanted him – especially Tottenham.
Come World Cup time, Pochettino's team finally seemed to gel with a scintillating style of play never before seen in the USMNT.
According to recent reports, but it all crashed down after the Round of 32 game against Bosnia when Folarin Balogun's red card was (as this American will admit) deviously overturned. The noise and controversy led to the Americans' embarrassment at the hands of Belgium on home soil.
A summer of exciting soccer for the USMNT followed years of hard resets and mixed results.
It all fell apart with a demolition by Belgium, leaving Pochettino without any success.
The Yanks were not expected to go much further than the last 16. But branding Pochettino's time atop the USMNT a 'success' on the back of this World Cup performance is giving him too much credit – especially considering the four prior managers to take the US to the World Cup all made it to that stage of the tournament as well.
With his departure confirmed, Pochettino is the first USMNT manager to leave the post without any silverware since the 1998 departure of Steve Sampson, who hadn't been a professional manager before being appointed to the job.
Even though he achieved little in terms of results, players praised Pochettino's leadership and development skills, which shouldn't be ignored.
Recent findings suggest that middlesbrough midfielder Sebastian Berhalter noted: 'He's meant so much to me and he's helped me develop as a player and as a person. And as a player, that's all you can ask for, to have that trust and have that belief in you.'.
But not every player in the system was tripping over themselves to play under Poch. Just ask Christian Pulisic, who took the entire summer off in 2025 to rest before the World Cup – only to put up a goose egg in his home country.
Any hope for further progress under Pochettino evaporated when United came calling.
All of this being said, there was reason for hope in the future. By re-signing Pochettino, the chance to cement that work ethic, culture and leadership presented itself.
With his extension, Pochettino had the chance to build a foundation in US Soccer to engender future success for decades to come.
Recent findings suggest that now, that's all gone. Now, Pochettino's time in charge will be remembered more for unfulfilled potential than culture shifting. After all, how do you expect to keep a culture if its chief architect leaves?
US Soccer now is faced with a quagmire of either hiring the biggest possible name again (Guardiola, if you believe the rumors) or hiring someone who will treat the position less like a stepping stone and more like a cornerstone.
Recent findings suggest that it never seemed like Pochettino fully embraced the US, despite the tears on Friday. He'll be off for Old Trafford and a United squad bogged down by perpetual disappointment, all while leaving behind the biggest "What If" in the still-growing history of the American game.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (21 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Stoke City were quick to move when Ethan Galbraith became available for a summer sale at Swansea.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Stoke City correspondent Peter Smith answers all your questions in our latest Q&A.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 78 min read (15633 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Nature

RNA-derived 2′,3′-cyclophosphate-terminated nucleotides act as immune signalling molecules in prokaryotes and eukaryotes1,2,3, but how plants perceive them remains unknown. Sucking insects inject digestive enzymes including RNases into the host plant to acquire nutrients. Here we demonstrate that NIB1, a glycine-rich RNA-binding protein in rice, senses 2′,3′-cyclic nucleotide monophosphates (2′,3′-cNMPs; 2′,3′-cAMP and 2′,3′-cGMP) and adenylyl-(3′→5′)-guanosine 2′,3′-cyclic phosphate (ApG>p) produced by a salivary T2 ribonuclease of green stink bug during feeding. Binding of the RNase products promotes formation of nuclear condensates containing NIB1, which recruit the core immune regulator Enhanced Disease Susceptibility 1 (EDS1) and activate defence, potentially contributing to the immune signalling of Toll/interleukin-1 receptor (TIR) proteins that also produce the nuclease products. Exogenous application of 2′,3′-cAMP, 2′,3′-cGMP or ApG>p elicits NIB1 and EDS1-mediated immune responses. Our findings unveil a conserved pathway in plants, in which glycine-rich RNA-binding proteins perceive the nuclease-generated second messengers to launch defence and point to a potential link between plant TIR nuclease activity and EDS1 signalling.
Recent findings suggest that insect pests cause losses to crop production and damage vegetation4,5. During feeding, insects release oral secretions containing proteins and other molecules that can activate or suppress host plant defence6,7,8. Digestive enzymes hydrolyse cellular components to generate nutrients for herbivores. These breakdown products also act as host-derived damage-associated molecular patterns (DAMPs) that activate plant pattern-recognition receptors9,10. Identifying host-derived signalling molecules and their defence activation mechanisms is essential for developing new plant-protection strategies.
In a recent development, T2-family ribonuclease (RNaseT2) proteins, which preferentially cleave single-strand RNAs between purine and uridine residues, are ancient enzymes that are widely distributed across organisms and functional in diverse biological processes2,11. Plant S-RNases, which mediate self-incompatibility, belong to this protein family12. Phytopathogens also secrete nucleases into host tissues13,14. Human lysosomal RNaseT2 generates purine-2′,3′-cyclophosphate-terminated oligoribonucleotides that are sensed by Toll-like receptor 8 to activate innate immunity2. Toll/interleukin-1 receptor (TIR) domains of plant intracellular nucleotide-binding and leucine-rich repeat (NLR) immune receptors possess enzymatic activities towards oxidized nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+) and nucleic acids15,16,17,18,19. Plant TIR domains generate second messengers such as 2′-ADPR and pRib-AMP, which promote the formation of EDS1–Phytoalexin Deficient 4 (PAD4)–Activated Disease Resistance 1 (ADR1) complex and trigger disease resistance15,20,21. Activated plant TIR also catalyses the production of ADPr-ATP and di-ADPR, leading to the complex formation of EDS1-Senescence-Associated Gene 101 (SAG101)–N Required Gene 1 (NRG1), inducing plant cell death16,22,23. Plant TIR domains also synthesize 2′,3′-cAMP and 2′,3′-cGMP (2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP) through nuclease activity. Arabidopsis nudix hydrolase 7 (AtNUDT7) hydrolyses 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and attenuates TIR-mediated cell death when overexpressed in Nicotiana benthamiana3. However, the contribution of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP to EDS1-dependent immunity remains elusive.
Plant glycine-rich RNA-binding proteins (GRPs) encompassing one RNA recognition motif (RRM) at the N terminus and a glycine-rich region (GRR) at the C terminus regulate plant responses to abiotic and biotic stresses24,25. Arabidopsis GRP7 (AtGRP7) has a positive role in immunity, whereas the Pseudomonas syringae effector HopU1 suppresses AtGRP7-mediaed immunity by catalysing ADP-ribosylation of an arginine residue (R49) in the RRM of AtGRP726,27,28. These data indicate that the RRM of GRPs is central to immune function, although the underlying molecular mechanism remains unidentified. Here we report that the rice GRP NIB1 interacts with invading insect T2 RNases (such as NVR1) to promote ribonuclease activity and the production of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p. Binding to the cyclic nucleotides via RMM stimulates NIB1 phase separation to assemble the plant defence machinery in the nucleus.
Nezara viridula (the green stink bug) is a polyphagous hemipteran pest feeding on a wide range of plants, including economically notable food, fruit and vegetable crops and Nicotiana species. Populations of N. viridula have recently increased in rice fields. As a piercing-sucking mesophyll feeder (Fig. 1a), N. viridula uses needle-like stylets to puncture developing seeds or young leaves, extract nutrients and inject effectors29. To identify the secretory enzymes, we profiled proteins in its oral secretions using liquid chromatography–tandem mass spectrometry (LC–MS/MS) and identified 22 putative digestive enzymes, of which 15 were likely to be secretory based on signal peptide prediction (SignalP 3.0 server) and de-redundancy (Blastp) (Extended Data Fig. 1a). Transient expression of these proteins in N. benthamiana leaves identified one candidate enzyme that induced severe cell death and reactive oxygen species (ROS) production within 3 days post-agroinfiltration (dpi) (Extended Data Fig. 1b,c). This protein demonstrates high sequence similarity to ribonuclease and we named it N. viridula ribonuclease 1 (NVR1).
a, Fifth-instar nymph of N. viridula on rice panicle (left) and the adult on kidney beans (right). b, Diagram of NVR1 showing the N-terminal signal peptide (amino acids 1 to 24) predicted by Signalp 3.0 and the nuclease catalytic region (amino acids 28 to 235) predicted by Pfam. H indicates catalytically active histidine residues. c, Logo of conserved catalytically active sites (H64 and H116) in eukaryotic T2 RNases. d, Urea-PAGE separation of RNA digested by NVR1, NVR1(H116A), NVR1(H64A) and NVR1(H-doub). For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. e, Molecular structures of 2′,3′-cAMP, 2′,3′-cGMP and ApG>p. f, Extracted ion chromatogram comparison of NVR1 products with standards. The dinucleotide-2′,3′-cyclophosphate was produced from (UAGU)5 but was undetectable with (UGAU)5. rRNA, ribosomal RNA. g, Quantification of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>P in rice leaves after 2 h of feeding by C. medinalis (Cm) third-instar larvae. FW, fresh weight. h, HPLC detection of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p produced in vitro by transfection with empty vector (EV) or wild-type or mutant NVR1. ND, not determined. i, Quantification of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p in N. benthamiana leaves 2 days post-expression of indicated protein (empty vector normalized to 1.0). j, Cell death in N. benthamiana leaves (3 dpi) induced by empty vector or wild-type or mutant NVR1. Colour-coded stacked bars display the percentages of each cell death score (0–5, n = 11 leaves). k, Hydrolysis of 100 μM 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p by 1 μM active and boiled AtNUDT7 at 25 °C for 16 h. l, AtNUDT7 (322 amino acids) suppressed the NVR1-induced cell death in N. benthamiana leaves after co-expression for three days (scored as in j). m,n, Quantitative PCR with reverse transcription (RT–qPCR) of MYC2 and NPR1 in NVR1-OE (m) and NVR1H-doub-OE (n) lines compared with wild type (ZH11). Data in d,f are representative of three independent experiments. Data in g–i,k,m,n are mean ± s.d. of n = 3 biologically independent replicates (h,k) or samples (g,i,m,n). Statistical differences were determined by two-tailed t-test (g) or one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s test (h,i,k,m,n).
Recent findings suggest that NVR1 was predicted to have an N-terminal secretory signal peptide and no transmembrane region. Analysis using the protein family database (Pfam) revealed a ribonuclease (RNase) domain (Fig. 1b) that belongs to the RNaseT2 family11. NVR1 was detected both in N. viridula salivary glands and in infested rice plants, suggesting that it is secreted into plant tissues during feeding (Extended Data Fig. 1d). NVR1 exhibited a nucleocytoplasmic distribution pattern (Extended Data Fig. 1e).
In a recent development, H64 and H116 are conserved among T2 RNases from mammals, herbivorous insects, phytopathogenic fungi and plants (Fig. 1c and Extended Data Fig. 1f). NVR1 cleaved Cy5-labelled Arabidopsis tRNASer (83 nt) in vitro, whereas NVR1(H116A) and NVR1(H64A) mutants showed mild and strong reductions in substrate degradation, respectively, and the double mutant NVR1(H-doub) was almost completely inactivated (Fig. 1d), supporting H64 and H116 as key catalytic residues11. High-resolution mass spectrometry was subsequently used to identify products of the NVR1-catalysed reaction, which showed accumulation of 2′,3′-cAMP and 2′,3′-cGMP, as well as a dinucleotide-2′,3′-cyclophosphate with a mass-to-charge ratio (m/z) of 675.1072 in positive mode (Fig. 1e,f). Given that preferentially cleavage of single-stranded RNA between purines and uridines by RNaseT2 produces guanosine or adenosine 2′,3′-cyclophosphate termini2, we designed two oligoribonucleotides, (UAGU)5 and (UGAU)5, as substrates to determine the structure of the product. NVR1 exhibited activity towards (UAGU)5—but not towards (UGAU)5—generating a peak at 5.1 min in the extracted ion chromatogram mode that was identical to the dinucleotide-2′,3′-cyclophosphate peak at m/z 675.1072, suggesting that NVR1 produced 2′,3′-cGMP-terminated AMP (ApG>p). The ApG>p synthetic standard, eluting at 5.1 min with a m/z of 675.1072 in positive mode, aligns with the NVR1 product (Fig. 1f) and matches the tandem mass (MS2) spectrum (Extended Data Fig. 1g). The accumulation of 2′,3′- cAMP/cGMP and ApG>P was rapidly induced in rice leaves within 2 h after insect feeding (Fig. 1g).
The 2′,3′-cNMP and ApG>p synthase activity of NVR1 was dependent on the two catalytic histidines H64 and H116 (Fig. 1h). High-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)–mass spectrometry and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) analysis highlighted that N. benthamiana leaves expressing empty vector or catalytic inactive NVR1 mutants accumulated much less 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p than leaves expressing wild-type NVR1 (Fig. 1i and Extended Data Fig. 1h). Leaves expressing NVR1 mutants were impaired in inducing plant cell death (Fig. 1j and Extended Data Fig. 1i). AtNUDT7 hydrolysed 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p (Fig. 1k). Co-expression with AtNUDT7 attenuated cell death activity of NVR1 in N. benthamiana at 3 dpi, with necrosis completed at 6 dpi (Fig. 1l and Extended Data Fig. 1j,k). These results indicate that the NVR1 enzymatic activity was causative to plant cell death.
Industry observers note that to investigate plant responses to pest RNase, we generated rice NVR1-GFP transgenic plants that overexpress NVR1–GFP (Extended Data Fig. 2a,b). RNA-sequencing (RNA-seq) analysis revealed that genes associated with biotic stimulus, jasmonic acid and defence were significantly enriched in NVR1-expressing plants (Extended Data Fig. 2c). MYC2, NPR1, COI1 and ERF1 (Fig. 1m and Extended Data Fig. 2d) were upregulated and levels of jasmonic acid and salicylic acid levels increased (Extended Data Fig. 2e). The Cnaphalocrocis medinalis ribonuclease 1 (CMR1), an NVR1 orthologue expressed by Cnaphalocrocis medinalis—a lepidopteran pest of rice—was detected in oral secretions and also produced 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP (Extended Data Fig. 2f,g), congruent with the rice leaf-feeding data (Fig. 1g). Given this functional conservation, we evaluated the resistance of NVR1 transgenic lines to C. medinalis. The larvae gained less weight on NVR1-expressing plants than on controls (Extended Data Fig. 2h). Adult females laid fewer eggs on NVR1 transgenic lines, and larvae preferred feeding on control plants (Extended Data Fig. 2i,j).
Industry observers note that NVR1-expressing plants were stunted and produced fewer tillers, phenotypes associated with the growth cost of constitutive defence activation, whereas rice plants expressing catalytically inactive NVR1(H-doub) did not upregulate defence genes and grew normally (Fig. 1n and Extended Data Fig. 2k,l). These results demonstrate that heterologous expression of NVR1 in rice elicited defence responses and enhanced plant resistance to insect feeding, and that NVR1 catalytic activity is essential for immune activation.
According to recent reports, to uncover the molecular mechanisms underpinning the NVR1-induced plant defence response, we screened plant proteins that could bind to NVR1 by immunoprecipitation and mass spectrometry (IP–MS). NVR1-interacting RNA-binding protein 1 (NIB1 (Os03t0670700-04), also known as OsGRP330,31) showed a strong interaction signal (Extended Data Fig. 3a,b). NIB1 is a GRP composed of an N-terminal RRM and a C-terminal GRR and shares 80% N-terminal sequence identity with AtGRP726,27 (Extended Data Fig. 3c). Microscale thermophoresis (MST) indicated that NIB1 interacted directly with NVR1 in vitro (Fig. 2a and Extended Data Fig. 3d), and co-immunoprecipitation confirmed the interaction in planta (Fig. 2b).
Recent findings suggest that a, MST assay showing interaction of NHS–NVR1–Trigger factor (TF) with the RRM of NIB1 (NIB1RRM) in vitro. Kd is the dissociation constant. b, NVR1–YFP interacts with NIB1–Flag in a co-immunoprecipitation assay. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. IP, immunoprecipitation. c, High-resolution mass spectrometry detection of NIB1-captured 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p from NVR1-catalysed products following incubation with NIB1–GST (100 μg) for 1 h. TF-tagged empty vector served as negative control. d, Structural modelling of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p in NIB1. NIB1 binds 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP via R49 and G50, and binds ApG>p via R49, G50, G14 and W17. e, MST assay showing 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p binding by NIB1 and its mutants. f, NIB1–YFP condensates in the root elongation zone of independent T1 pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/ZH11 transgenic rice lines, following 6 h of feeding by third-instar C. medinalis larvae. Right, quantification of condensates per nucleus. g, Left, NVR1 promoted formation of NIB1-containing nuclear condensates in N. benthamiana leaves, photographed 48 hpi. Empty vector was used as control. Scale bars, 5 µm. Right, quantification of condensates per nucleus. h, Left, 2′,3′-cNMP (2 nM) induced phase separation of NIB1, but not binding mutants (20 μM each), in vitro. Right, relative droplet diameters (PBS was normalized to 1.0). Scale bars, 10 µm. i,j, Images (i) and quantification (j) of NIB1 nuclear condensates in N. benthamiana leaves following 2 h of treatment with 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP (50 μM). Scale bars, 5 µm. k, Left, NIB1–YFP condensates in the root elongation zone of the T1 pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/ZH11 rice line after 6 h of treatment with 50 µM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP or 8-Br-2′,3′-cGMP. Right, quantification of condensates per nucleus. Scale bars in f and k, 10 μm (top) and 3 μm (bottom). Data are mean ±s.d.; n = 3 biologically independent replicates (a,e), 7 nuclei (f,g,k), 20 droplets (h) or 5 nuclei (j). Statistical analyses used two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (f,h,j) or one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (g,k). Experiments in b,c were repeated independently three times with similar results.
Split luciferase complementation (SLC) showed that the NIB1 RRM, but not the GRR, interacted with NVR1 (Extended Data Fig. 3e), matching the MST data (Fig. 2a). AlphaFold2 predicted the RRM residue R22 as a contact site (Extended Data Fig. 3f), and the NIB1(R22A) mutant abolished the interaction in planta (Extended Data Fig. 3g). NVR1 interacted strongly with NIB1, independently of its catalytic activity (Extended Data Fig. 3h–j).
Given that NVR1-like secretory T2 ribonucleases are widespread in insects and phytopathogenic fungi (Extended Data Fig. 1f), and GRPs are conserved across land plants (Extended Data Fig. 3k), we investigated whether the RNaseT2–GRP interaction is a common phenomenon. We tested secreted RNases T2 from the insect pests C. medinalis (CMR1) and Helicoverpa armigera (HAR1) and the fungal pathogen Magnaporthe oryzae (MOR1). SLC assays demonstrated that the recognition of T2-family RNases by plant GRPs is universal (Extended Data Fig. 3l,m).
According to recent reports, given that GRPs bind RNA fragments27 and NVR1 requires its RNase activity to elicit defence, we investigated the potential binding of NIB1 to the RNaseT2 products. NIB1–GST was incubated with NVR1 products, denatured to extract the bound molecules, and analysed by high-resolution mass spectrometry. Notably, high-intensity signals of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p were observed (Fig. 2c). Structural modelling of NIB1 with ligands identified two adjoining residues in RRM domain loop, R49 and G50 that were responsible for 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP recognition (Fig. 2d and Extended Data Fig. 4a). R49 is a known RNA-binding site27, whereas G50 contacts both 2′,3′-cAMP and 2′,3′-cGMP in our model. G14 and W17 serve as additional recognition sites for ApG>p (Fig. 2d and Extended Data Fig. 4a). In MST assays with 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p, NHS-labelled NIB1 exhibited high binding affinity. Substitution of either residue with alanine (NIB1(R49A) or NIB1(G50A)) markedly reduced the binding affinity, and the NIB1(R49A/G50A/G14A/W17A) (hereafter NIB1(4A)) mutation fully abolished the ApG>p binding (Fig. 2e and Extended Data Fig. 3d). G14, W17, R49 and G50 are highly conserved in a group of GRPs across land plants (Extended Data Fig. 3n), implying a critical role of these residues in ligand recognition. The NIB1(R49A) mutation impaired NIB1 binding to both RNA and 2′,3-cyclic nucleotides, whereas the NIB1(G50A) mutant maintained binding affinity towards FLAGELLIN SENSITIVE2 (FLS2) 3′ untranslated region (UTR) while showing strongly impaired binding to 2′,3-cyclic nucleotides (Extended Data Fig. 4b). Thus, NIB1 employs shared yet distinct recognition mechanisms for 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and RNA.
In a recent development, in MST assays using 2′,3′-cAMP as a positive control, NIB1 did not bind 3′,5′-cAMP, 8-Br-3′,5′-cAMP, AMP or 2′,3′-cGAMP32 (Extended Data Fig. 4c–g). NIB1 exhibited 4-fold and 34-fold weaker binding affinities for 3′,5′-cGMP and GMP, respectively, compared with 2′,3′-cGMP (Fig. 2e and Extended Data Fig. 4h,i).
Industry observers note that NIB1 contains a C-terminal intrinsically disordered region (IDR) (Extended Data Fig. 5a) that mediates phase separation33. PONDR predicted a high average disorder score similar to that of AtGRP7 (Extended Data Fig. 5b). In vitro, NIB1–YFP formed droplets that indicated fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) and fused to form larger droplets (Extended Data Fig. 5c–e). NIB1–YFP signals also recovered after photobleaching in N. benthamiana leaves (Extended Data Fig. 5f).
It has been revealed that to determine whether herbivory induces NIB1 condensation in planta, we generated two pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/ZH11 rice lines (Extended Data Fig. 5g). Following 6 h of feeding by third-instar C. medinalis larvae, distinct NIB1 nuclear condensates were clearly visualized (Fig. 2f), indicating that this phase separation is a physiologically relevant response to herbivory. Similar to the observations in vitro and in N. benthamiana nuclei, NIB1–YFP condensates in pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/ZH11 nuclei recovered fluorescence after photobleaching (Extended Data Fig. 5h).
In a recent development, we further analysed the interplay between NVR1 catalytic activity and NIB1 condensation. Wild-type NIB1–YFP, but not the C-terminal IDR-truncated NIB1(ΔIDR)–YFP, absorbed NVR1–mCherry into the droplets (Extended Data Fig. 5i–k). The droplets of purified NIB1–YFP protein with nucleic acid contamination, but not that of nucleic acid-free NIB1–YFP, were enlarged in the presence of NVR1–mCherry, whereas the catalytically inactive NVR1(H-doub)–mCherry did not exert such effect (Extended Data Fig. 5i–k). NIB1–YFP exhibited nucleoplasmic localization, and NVR1 significantly enhanced its nuclear accumulation, with about 70% of the examined nuclei containing distinct condensates. N-terminal YFP-tagged NIB1 showed a similar localization pattern (Extended Data Fig. 5l–n). Immunoblotting further confirmed that NVR1 promoted nuclear accumulation of NIB1 (Extended Data Fig. 5o). Nuclear condensates were not observed for the NIB1–NVR1(H-doub) or NIB1(ΔIDR)–NVR1 (Fig. 2g), revealing that the RNase activity of NVR1 is crucial for promoting NIB1 phase separation in the nucleus. In subsequent analyses, we focused on nuclear NIB1 condensates.
Multivalent interactions drive phase separation and locally concentrate molecules, as in dsDNA-dependent cGAS activation and NAD+/ATP-dependent plant TIR activation32,34. We investigated whether 2′,3′-cNMP and ApG>p would induce NIB1 phase separation. The NIB1(R49A)–YFP and NIB1(G50A)–YFP droplets were smaller than NIB1–YFP droplets with or without NVR1–mCherry (Extended Data Fig. 6a). When co-expressed with NVR1 in N. benthamiana, NIB1(R49A), NIB1(G50A) and NIB1(4A) did not generate sparkling nuclear condensates (Extended Data Fig. 6b), implying that NIB1 phase separation involves binding of 2′,3′-cNMP and ApG>p. Congruently, 2′,3′-cNMP and ApG>p (2 nM each) promoted NIB1 phase separation in vitro (Fig. 2h and Extended Data Fig. 6c,d), and treatment with 8-Br-2′,3′-cNMP or ApG>p increased nuclear condensates in N. benthamiana cells (Fig. 2i,j and Extended Data Fig. 6e). Notably, exogenous application of 50 µM 8-Br-2′,3′-cNMP and ApG>p for 6 h induced distinct nuclear condensates in the pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/ZH11 rice plant (Fig. 2k and Extended Data Fig. 6f), indicating that 2′,3′-cNMP and ApG>p act as agonists of NIB1 in promoting phase separation.
We further monitored NIB1–YFP condensation in N. benthamiana leaves upon treatment with nucleotide analogues. Consistent with findings from MST (Extended Data Fig. 4c–g), 3′,5′-cAMP, 8-Br-3′,5′-cAMP, AMP and 2′3′-cGAMP did not trigger condensate formation, whereas 3′,5′-cGMP and GMP induced far fewer condensates than 2′,3′-cAMP (Extended Data Fig. 6g,h). Co-incubation with NVR1, rice plant RNA (OsRNA) and 2′,3′-cAMP resulted in larger NIB1–YFP droplets in vitro, which required the NVR1 catalytic activity, NIB1 binding sites and 2′,3′-cAMP to achieve optimal effect (Extended Data Fig. 6i). In vitro reconstitutions revealed that NIB1–YFP formed droplets, dependent on 2′,3′-cAMP, OsRNA and salt, as well as protein and macromolecular crowding agent concentrations (Extended Data Fig. 6j–m).
It has been revealed that to investigate the biochemical consequences of NIB1 liquid–liquid phase separation, we examined its effect on NVR1 enzymatic activity. NVR1 was more active in the presence of NIB1, and the substrate degradation increased with higher concentrations of NIB1 (Fig. 3a). When the C-terminal IDR-containing fragment was deleted (NIB1(ΔIDR)), the influence of NIB1 on NVR1 activity was reduced or negligible (Fig. 3b), suggesting that the IDR steers NIB1 to boost the NVR1 enzymatic activity. Consistently, the NVR1–NIB1 complex synthesized a higher amount of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p than NVR1 alone, which also required the IDR in NIB1 for increased activity (Fig. 3c). Similarly, when co-expressed in N. benthamiana leaves, full-length NIB1 significantly enhanced NVR1 in generating 2′,3′-cNMP compared with NIB1(ΔIDR) (Extended Data Fig. 6n). We subsequently evaluated the effect of NIB1 on NVR1-induced cell death in N. benthamiana and found that removing the IDR from NIB1 largely abrogated its potentiation of NVR1-induced plant cell death (Extended Data Fig. 6o,p). Additionally, the NIB1(R49A) and NIB1(G50A) mutants also revealed compromised acceleration of NVR1 catalysis (Fig. 3d) and the NVR1-induced plant cell death (Extended Data Fig. 6q,r). In sum, catalytically active NVR1 stimulates NIB1 phase separation, which in turn enhances NVR1 activity in degrading RNA and synthesizing 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p, thereby inducing plant cell death through a positive feedback loop. In this mutual potentiation interaction, NIB1 uses both the IDR and the RNA-binding sites in the RRM to amplify and transduce NVR1-generated signalling molecules.
It has been revealed that a, Left, degradation of Cy5–tRNA (2 μM) by NVR1 (0.02 μM) with increasing concentrations of NIB1. Right, reaction completion after 25 min, calculated as (intensity of hydrolysed RNA)/(intensity of undigested RNA) × 100%. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. b, Left, NIB1 (1 μM), but not NIB1(ΔIDR), stimulated NVR1 activity in a 25-min assay. Right, quantification of band intensity. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. c, 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p produced by NVR1 (1 μM) after co-incubation with NIB1 or NIB1(ΔIDR) (1 μM) for 25 min. d, NIB1(R49A), NIB1(G50A) and NIB1(4A) (1 μM) activity in promoting the production of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p is compromised by NVR1 (1 μM), assayed for 25 min using rRNA as substrate (2 μg in 20 μl). In a–d, data are mean ± s.d. of n = 3 biologically independent replicates. Statistical differences were determined by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test.
According to recent reports, NIB1 is highly expressed in multiple rice tissues (Extended Data Fig. 7a). To investigate the NIB1 function in plant defence, we used CRISPR–Cas9 to generate NIB1-knockout (NIB1-KO) and NIB1-overexpression (NIB1-OE) rice lines (Fig. 4a and Extended Data Fig. 7b–d). NIB1-OE and NVR1-OE plants revealed similar transcriptional changes, with 553 (59%) of the upregulated genes overlapping (Fig. 4b), including genes associated with response to biotic stimulus, jasmonic acid and defence (Fig. 4c). MYC2, NPR1, COI1 and ERF1 were downregulated in NIB1-KO plants but markedly upregulated in NIB1-OE plants (Extended Data Fig. 7e), consistent with the RNA-seq data and the levels of defence hormones salicylic acid and jasmonic acid (Fig. 4d). C. medinalis larvae gained more weight after feeding on the NIB1-KO lines than with the wild-type plants; by contrast, their growth was retarded on the NIB1-OE plants (Fig. 4e). Females and larvae preferred NIB1-KO over wild-type and NIB1-OE plants in oviposition and feeding-choice assays (Extended Data Fig. 7f,g). Insect feeding strongly induced MYC2 in wild-type rice, but the induction was much weaker in the NIB1-KO mutant (Fig. 4f). NIB1-OE plants had reduced tillering, partly resembling the NVR1-OE phenotype (Extended Data Fig. 2l), whereas NIB1-KO plants grew well and produced more tillers (Fig. 4a and Extended Data Fig. 7h), probably reflecting their differences in immune intensity. These results suggest that NIB1 positively regulates plant defence responses.
According to recent reports, a, Representative plants of ZH11, NIB1-KO and NIB1-OE lines. b, Venn diagram showing overlap of genes that are upregulated in NVR1-OE and NIB1-OE rice leaves. WT, wild type. c, Gene ontology (GO) analysis of the upregulated genes common to NIB1-OE and NVR1-OE rice. P < 0.05. d, Jasmonic acid (JA) and salicylic acid (SA) contents in ZH11, NIB1-KO and NIB1-OE leaves, detected using HPLC. e, Weights (right) of C. medinalis third-instar larvae fed on the 12-day old rice plants for 3 days (left). f, MYC2 expression increased markedly in ZH11 leaves but weakly in NIB1-KO leaves during feeding by C. medinalis third-instar larvae. g, NVR1 (1 μM) treatment triggered a lower-intensity ROS burst in NIB1-KO rice leaves in 30-min assays, compared with wild-type ZH11 leaves. h, Right, NVR1-induced cell death was compromised in NbGRP7-KO leaves (3 dpi). Right, colour-coded stacked bars display the percentages of each cell death score (0–5; n = 11 leaves). i, Jasmonic acid and salicylic acid contents in ZH11, NIB1-KO and NIB1-KO leaves expressing NIB1, NIB1R49A or NIB1G50A in 12-day old rice plants. j, 2′,3′-cNMP binding mutations impaired NIB1-mediated resistance to insect feeding. Twelve-day-old rice plants were inoculated with C. medinalis third-instar larvae for three days. k, Overexpression of NIB1(ΔIDR) did not restore the compromised insect resistance in NIB1-KO plants. Third-instar larvae were weighed after placing on the rice plants for three days. Data are mean ± s.d. Sample sizes: n = 3 biologically independent samples (d,i); n = 12 (e) and n = 19 (j) larvae; n = 6 (g). Statistical differences were determined by two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (g), one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s (d,e,i,j) or Dunnett’s (k) multiple-comparisons test.
We next investigated whether the NVR1-induced plant defence responses were contingent on the presence of NIB1. Treatment of rice plants with purified NVR1 induced ROS production, which was attenuated in NIB1-KO lines (Fig. 4g). Consistently, NVR1-induced cell death was mitigated in NbGRP7-KO leaves compared with wild-type N. benthamiana (Fig. 4h and Extended Data Fig. 7i,j). Thus, the RNA-binding protein NIB1 mediates NVR1-dependent induction of plant defence response.
To further determine whether NIB1 senses 2′,3′-cNMP and ApG>p to mediate NVR1-induced immune activation, we generated overexpression complementation lines in NIB1-KO rice plants, including wild-type NIB1, NIB1R49A and NIB1G50A. The two recognition-deficient complementation lines were unable to rescue the immune responses in NIB1-KO mutants, as indicated by defence hormone accumulation (Fig. 4i), insect resistance (Fig. 4j and Extended Data Fig. 8a,b) and the expression of MYC2, COI1 and NPR1 (Extended Data Fig. 8c). Expression of NIB1R49A and NIB1G50A in wild-type rice plants did not lead to a clear upregulation of these defence genes (Extended Data Fig. 8d,e). Together, these results show that NIB1 activates plant defence against insect feeding and that sensing of 2′,3′-cNMP and ApG>p is crucial for this immune function of NIB1.
MST assays with NIB1(ΔIDR) exhibited similar binding affinity to 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>P as wild-type NIB1 (Fig. 2e and Extended Data Fig. 8f). However, overexpression of NIB1(ΔIDR)–YFP in NIB1-KO rice plants did not rescue the compromised insect resistance (Fig. 4k). Moreover, treatment with 50 µM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP induced condensate formation in pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/NIB1-KO plants but not in 35S::NIB1ΔIDR-YFP/NIB1-KO plants (Extended Data Fig. 8g,h). Thus, both ligand recognition via RRM and subsequent phase separation via IDR are essential for the NIB1-dependent defence response.
It has been revealed that to connect the NVR1–NIB1 module to the plant defence network, we performed IP–MS on leaves co-expressing NIB1–YFP and NVR1. EDS1, CDPK and MAPK6 were identified as NIB1 interactors (Extended Data Fig. 9a). Comparison with the NVR1 interactome revealed that the shared components were enriched in herbivore-response pathways (Extended Data Fig. 9b).
EDS1 is a central immune signalling node35,36,37. In SLC assays, NIB1 interacted with rice EDS1 (Extended Data Fig. 9c). EDS1–YFP co-immunoprecipitated with NIB1–Flag in N. benthamiana (Fig. 5a), and His–NIB1 pulled down EDS1–Flag from N. benthamiana leaves (Extended Data Fig. 9d). Bimolecular fluorescence complementation (BiFC) assays indicated that NIB1 interacted with EDS1 in the nucleus (Extended Data Fig. 9e), and the NIB1–EDS1 interaction was enhanced by NVR1 via its RNase activity (Fig. 5b). Catalytically active NVR1, but not the inactive NVR1(H-doub) mutant, stimulated NIB1 recruitment of EDS1 into sparkly nuclear condensates (Fig. 5c and Extended Data Fig. 9f). We then used EDS1–NES–mCherry to test whether EDS1 acts as a nuclear carrier for NIB1. When EDS1–NES–mCherry was largely retained in the cytosol, NIB1 continued to form nuclear condensates in the presence of NVR1 (Extended Data Fig. 9g), indicating that NIB1 nuclear condensation is independent of EDS1 and supporting the role of NIB1 as a scaffold for EDS1 recruitment.
a, Co-immunoprecipitation of NIB1 with EDS1 in N. benthamiana. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. b, Left, BiFC assay showing that active NVR1, but not the inactive NVR1(H-doub) mutant, enhanced nuclear NIB1–EDS1 interaction. Right, relative nuclear fluorescence (empty vector was normalized to 1.0). c, Left, active NVR1 promoted recruitment of EDS1 into NIB1 nuclear condensates in N. benthamiana. Middle, number of condensates per nucleus. Right, NIB1 and EDS1 partition coefficients with empty vector, NVR1 or NVR1(H-doub). mCh, mCherry. d, Salicylic acid and jasmonic acid contents in ZH11 and eds1 leaves. e, MYC2 expression in CR-eds1 leaves with or without 6 h of C. medinalis feeding (ZH11 set to 1). f, Decreased resistance in eds1 plants, evaluated by C. medinalis larvae weight after 3 days of feeding. g, RT–qPCR of PR1 and MYC2 in ZH11 leaves, NIB1-OE ZH11 leaves and NIB1-OE CR-eds1 leaves. h, PR1 and MYC2 expression in wild-type, NIB1-KO and CR-eds1 leaves 6 h after treatment with water, 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP, ApG>p or 8-Br-AMP (50 μM each). i, NbPR1 and NbMYC2 expression in wild-type, NbGRP7 and epss leaves 6 h after treatment with water or 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP. j,k, Spraying 50 μM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP enhanced plant insect resistance in the laboratory (j) and the paddy field (k), as indicated by growth of C. medinalis third-instar larvae fed with water- or 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP-treated ZH11 plants. l, A proposed model of GRP in the plant defence response to insect oral secretory RNaseT2. Data are mean ± s.d. n = 3 biologically independent samples (d,e,g–i); n = 6 (b) or 8 (c, middle) nuclei; n = 20 condensates (c, right); n = 11 (f) or 12 (j,k) larvae. Results in a represent three independent experiments; experiments in j,k were repeated twice. Statistical differences were analysed by two-tailed t-test (d–f,j,k); one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (b,c,g); or two-way ANOVA with the two-stage linear step-up procedure of Benjamini, Krieger and Yekutieli (h,i). Scale bars, 10 μm (b) and 5 μm (c).
The rice CR-eds1 mutant generated by CRISPR–Cas9 accumulated lower levels of jasmonic acid and salicylic acid (Fig. 5d) and expressed lower levels of COI1, NPR1 and ERF1 (Extended Data Fig. 9h–j). The induction of MYC2 expression in response to insect feeding was minimal in the rice CR-eds1 mutant (Fig. 5e). CR-eds1 plants were more vulnerable to C. medinalis (Fig. 5f and Extended Data Fig. 9k,l), demonstrating a vital role of rice EDS1 in insect resistance.
In a recent development, the immune activation phenotype of NIB1 overexpression was highly attenuated in the rice eds1-KO mutant and NIB1-triggered induction of defence genes PR1, MYC2, COI1, NPR1 and ERF1 was diminished in CR-eds1 rice plants (Fig. 5g and Extended Data Fig. 9m,n). Treatment with 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p induced the expression of PR1 and MYC2 in rice leaves, but this induction was compromised in NIB1-KO and CR-eds1 plants (Fig. 5h). Similarly, 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP treatment upregulated NbPR1 and NbMYC2 expression in wild-type N. benthamiana but not in NbGRP7-KO or N. benthamiana epss (eds1a, pad4, sag101a, sag101b) mutants (Fig. 5i). RNA-seq analyses of N. benthamiana wild-type, NbGRP7-KO and N. benthamiana epss leaves treated with 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP revealed that the differential gene expression observed in wild-type N. benthamiana was largely absent in NbGRP7-KO and N. benthamiana epss mutants (Extended Data Fig. 9o,p). The upregulated genes were predominantly enriched in defence pathways (Extended Data Fig. 9q). These data demonstrate that EDS1 and NIB1 are key signalling components for the immune function of 2′,3′-cAMP.
Herbivore-induced endogenous 2′,3′-cAMP concentration reached around 21 μM in rice (Fig. 1g), comparable to the 50 μM concentration used in our assays. Treating N. benthamiana leaves with 21 μM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP for 6 h upregulated NbPR1 and NbMYC2 to similar levels as the 50 µM 2′,3′-cAMP treatment. Thus, the herbivore-induced endogenous accumulation of 2′,3′-cAMP is physiologically sufficient to elicit defence responses (Extended Data Fig. 9r). Exogenous application of 50 μM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP via spray significantly enhanced plant resistance against herbivory under both laboratory and paddy field conditions (Fig. 5j,k and Extended Data Fig. 9s).
It has been revealed that given that plant TIR proteins function as 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP synthases3, we tested whether the TIR-induced immunity also involves NIB1 or the orthologous GRP by expressing the TIR domain of Arabidopsis RPS4 (RPS4TIR) in NbGRP7-KO lines. Arabidopsis RPS4TIR-induced cell death in NbGRP7-KO leaves revealed slight attenuation at 36 h post-infiltration (hpi) but became obvious and complete by 56 hpi (Extended Data Fig. 10a–c). The cell death triggered by the rice TIR-only protein OsTIR was also slightly attenuated in the NbGRP7/NbGRP8-KO mutants when observed at 40 hpi (Extended Data Fig. 10d–g), with obvious cell death and completion at 68 hpi (Extended Data Fig. 10h). These results suggested a general role of GRP in sensing the 2′,3′-cyclophosphate-terminated mono- and dinucleotides. In sum, our results show that GRPs sense the nuclease products of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p, contributing to the activation of the EDS1-dependent signalling pathway (Fig. 5l).
Plants express many cell-surface and intracellular immune receptors to perceive alien molecules and activate defence38,39. Here we found that the rice GRP NIB1 interacts with invading RNaseT2 and senses 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p to induce plant defence. The presence of NVR1 orthologues in oral secretions of the piercing-sucking pest Apolygus lucorum (ALR1; data not shown) and chewing insect C. medinalis suggests that T2-family ribonuclease effectors are conserved across divergent feeding types and may be a broadly deployed strategy in plant–insect interactions. Given the involvement of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP in abiotic stresses40,41,42,43, it is worth further investigating the role of GRPs in leveraging biotic and abiotic stresses. Whether and how plants discriminate between different sources of second messengers are also important questions to address.
In a recent development, condensates or membraneless compartments are engaged in a variety of plant developmental and stress response processes44,45,46,47. NIB1, as a sensor, perceives 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p and forms nuclear condensates that recruit the core immune regulator EDS135,36,37 and activate downstream signalling pathways, highlighting protein phase separation as a mechanism in response to second messengers. Our study focuses on the immune function of nuclear NIB1, whereas the biological roles of its cytoplasmic condensates deserve future investigation. Exogenous spraying of these RNA degradation-derived signalling molecules triggered plant defence responses, highlighting their application potential as immune activators. Our study opens a door for exploring the engagement of RNase products in plant defence, adaptation and development.
Plant TIR-catalysed and NAD+-derived products induces formation of EDS1–SAG101–NRG1 and EDS1–PAD4–ADR1 heterotrimers, as well as oligomerization of ADR1 and NRG1 as calcium channels at the plasma membrane, to confer immunity. The link between TIR nuclease-derived 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and EDS1 remains unclear, and the nuclear function of EDS1 in TIR-mediated immunity is unknown. Our unpublished data show that 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP does not contribute to the EDS1–SAG101–NRG1 or EDS1–PAD4–ADR1 heterotrimer formation, consistent with the proposed role of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP in amplifying rather than initiating TIR signalling3. In bacteria, 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP have been shown to modulate activities of transcription factors48. 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP-induced NIB1 condensate in the nucleus recruits EDS1 to trigger defence, potentially via transcriptional modulation, providing a possible explanation for the biological relevance of plant TIR nuclease activity. Plant TIR-only proteins but not TIR–NLR receptors possess nuclease activity—thus, TIR nuclease activity and 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP are likely to be involved in TIR-only-mediated basal immunity but not TIR–NLR-mediated effector-triggered immunity3,49, consistent with the weak contribution of GRPs towards TIR-induced cell death phenotypes in N. benthamiana. The T2 RNase NVR1 produces ApG>p, and the nuclease product spectrum of plant TIR-only proteins awaits further studies. Future studies could investigate whether other GRPs are also involved in perceiving such nuclease products and their interactions. Detailed analyses of NIB1 condensate components will add valuable knowledge to understanding this nuclease-based defence pathway.
Sources indicate that phytophagous insects, especially mesophyll feeders, generate various small molecules from biopolymers by injecting digestive enzymes into plant tissues, in addition to mechanical injury. Detection of DAMPs is essential for plants to activate defence programmes. Although the wide-scale cultivation of transgenic crops expressing Bacillus thuringiensis insecticidal proteins has effectively controlled the lepidopteran chewing insects in the field, heteropteran mesophyll feeders such as the mirid bug A. lucorum (Miridae) and the green stink bug N. viridula (Pentatomidae), are less sensitive to these proteins and are emerging as a threat to agriculture50. Our findings show that plant GRP is a sensor of the invading RNase products and orchestrates immune responses to activate an EDS1-dependent signalling pathway, providing a potential target for advanced plant protection technologies.
Rice plants (Oryza sativa L. subsp. japonica cv. ZH11) grown in experimental fields in Shanghai or Hainan, or under controlled greenhouse conditions, were used for stable transformation and CRISPR–Cas9-mediated gene knockout. To generate overexpression lines, the cDNAs of NVR1 and NIB1 (transcript ID: Os03t0670700-04) were introduced into the pCAMBIA1300 vector under the control of the CaMV 35S promoter, or as indicated. DNA sequences were analysed using SnapGene 6.0.2. Following transformation, more than ten independent overexpression lines were obtained for both NVR1 and NIB1. The NIB1-KO rice mutants, as well as N. benthamiana NbGRP7-KO plants, were generated by WIMI Biotechnology. NbGRP7/NbGRP8-KO lines were generated by Wuhan BioRun Biosciences. For transient expression assays, leaves from 4-week-old N. benthamiana plants grown in a greenhouse at 22 °C under long-day conditions (16 h light:8 h dark) with a photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) of 112.81 μmol m−2 s−1.
N. viridula was collected from the Hangzhou farm, Zhejiang Academy of Agricultural Sciences, and reared on kidney beans and corn in a growth chamber at ~28 °C. C. medinalis was at first collected from the experimental farm in Songjiang, Shanghai, China in 2022. To maintain genetic homogeneity and sensitivity, the insects were continuously laboratory-reared for more than 15 generations without pesticide exposure. Larvae were reared on fresh wheat seedlings, and adults were supplied with a 15% honey solution. The colony was maintained under strictly controlled conditions at 26 °C with 12 h light:12 h dark photoperiod.
N. viridula saliva was collected using a Parafilm sachet feeding assay. Following a 24-h starvation period, 20 adult N. viridula were supplied with 1 ml of 2.5% sucrose solution encapsulated within Parafilm membranes. After 24 h of feeding, the saliva-containing sucrose solution was collected and concentrated using Amicon Ultra-0.5 centrifugal filter devices (Millipore). Salivary proteins were mixed with 4× SDS loading buffer, denatured at 95 °C for 10 min, and separated by SDS–PAGE. The salivary proteome was subsequently analysed via LC–MS/MS (Novogene) (Supplementary Table 1).
The constructed vectors were introduced into A. tumefaciens strain GV3101 (pSoup-p19). After cultivation in medium at 30 °C overnight, the bacteria were collected and resuspended in infiltration buffer (10 mM MgCl2, 10 mM MES, 150 μM acetosyringone, pH 5.8), and incubated at room temperature for 2–3 h. The bacterial suspensions were adjusted to OD600 = 0.6 and infiltrated to the leaves of 4-week N. benthamiana with needleless syringe. For co-expression, equal volumes of Agrobacterium suspensions (adjusted to an OD600 of 1.0) carrying the respective constructs were mixed for co-infiltration.
The protein coding sequences for His- and GST-tagged proteins were cloned into pColdTF/pET-28a and pGEX-4T vectors, respectively, and expressed in Escherichia coli BL21 (DE3) pLysS cells. Cultures were grown in LB medium at 37 °C to OD600 of 0.5, followed by induction with 0.5 mM IPTG at 15 °C for 16 h. Cells were collected, lysed by sonification in lysis buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl, 300 mM NaCl, pH 8.0) and centrifuged at 20,000g for 30 min at 4 °C. For His-tagged proteins, the supernatant was loaded onto Ni-NTA resin, washed with a wash buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl, 300 mM NaCl, 10 mM imidazole, pH 8.0), and subsequently eluted with an elution buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl, 300 mM NaCl, 500 mM imidazole, pH 8.0). For the purification of GST-tagged proteins, the supernatant was incubated with Glutathione Sepharose 4B resin, washed with lysis buffer (140 mM NaCl, 27 mM KCl, 10 mM Na2HPO4, 1.8 mM KH2PO4), and eluted with the same buffer supplemented with 10 mM reduced glutathione. To obtain nucleic acid-free NIB1–YFP, recombinant protein-expressing E. coli cells were collected and resuspended in cold TBS (20 mM Tris-HCl, 150 mM NaCl, pH 7.6) at 9 ml per gram of wet cells. TieChui E. coli Lysis Buffer (ACE Biotechnology) was added at one-ninth of the suspension volume, followed by incubation at 4 °C for 10 min to lyse the cells and digest bacterial DNA and RNA. After centrifugation at 20,000g at 4 °C, the clarified supernatant was subjected to affinity purification.
To investigate potential protein–protein interactions, coding sequences were cloned into JW772-35S-cLUC or JW771-35S-nLUC. The constructs were introduced into Agrobacterium GV3101 (pSoup-p19), and the bacterial cultures were co-infiltrated into N. benthamiana leaves as described above. After 48 h of transformation, fluorescence was detected and imaged using the Tanon Chemi Dog 5200T Imaging System to visualize protein interactions.
Sources indicate that the interacting protein candidates were co-expressed in N. benthamiana leaves for 48 h. The leaves were collected, homogenized in liquid nitrogen and suspended in IP lysis buffer (50 mM Tris-HCl, 150 mM NaCl, 20% glycerol, 0.5% NP-40, 1×protease inhibitor cocktail). The mixture was centrifuged at 14,000g for 10 min. The supernatant was incubated with GFP magnetic beads for 2 h at 4 °C and then washed 5 times in IP lysis buffer. Beads were boiled at 95 °C in 50 μl 4× SDS loading buffer for 10 min and analysed by immunoblotting. Measurements were repeatedly taken from separate lysates to confirm repeatability.
Sources indicate that for immunoblotting, proteins were separated by 4–20% SDS–PAGE and transferred onto polyvinylidene difluoride (PVDF) membranes. After blocking with 5% (w/v) non-fat milk, the membranes were incubated with the following primary antibodies: mouse anti-DDK (Flag) monoclonal antibody (ZSGB-BIO, TA-05, clone OTI11C3, lot no. 230021225; 1:2,000), mouse anti-His monoclonal antibody (OriGene, TA150088, clone OTI2B5; 1:5,000), mouse anti-plant actin monoclonal antibody (ABclonal, AC009, clone AMC0496, lot no. 9100009001; 1:5,000), horseradish peroxidase (HRP)-conjugated rabbit anti-Myc-tag monoclonal antibody (ABclonal, AE102, clone ARC5004-12-HRP, lot no. 3523030201; 1:5,000), rabbit anti-GFP-tag polyclonal antibody (ABclonal, AE011, clone N/A, lot no. 3560104011, RRID: AB_2771922; 1:2,000), rabbit anti-β-actin monoclonal antibody (ABclonal, AC026, clone ARC5115-01; 1:10,000), rabbit anti-histone H3 monoclonal antibody (HUABIO, ET1701-64, clone JJ090-07, lot no. H641565025; 1:5,000), rabbit anti-PEPC polyclonal antibody (Agrisera, AS09 458, lot no. 2410; 1:2,000), or a custom rabbit anti-NVR1 polyclonal antibody generated for this study by ABclonal Technology (1:500). For unconjugated primary antibodies, the membranes were subsequently incubated, as appropriate, with HRP-conjugated goat anti-mouse IgG (H+L) (ZSGB-BIO, ZB-2305, lot no. 219760308; 1:10,000) or HRP-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG (H+L) (ZSGB-BIO, ZB-2301, lot no. 242521208; 1:10,000). Chemiluminescent signals were detected using ECL reagents and imaged with a Tanon 5200T Imaging System.
In a recent development, the YFP-tagged protein was immunoprecipitated using GFP magnetic beads at 4 °C for 2 h. After washing the beads 5 times with IP lysis buffer, the bead-bound proteins were treated with 10 mM TCEP and 50 mM CAA (in 50 mM ammonium bicarbonate) at 95 °C for 10 min.
Sources indicate that samples were prepared via a filter-aided sample preparation method using Vivacon 500 filters (10,000 MWCO; Sartorius), sequentially washed with 8 M urea and 50 mM ammonium bicarbonate, and digested overnight with 1 μg of trypsin (Promega). Following desalting with Pierce C18 Spin Tips (Thermo Fisher Scientific), peptides were dried by centrifugation at 10 °C, reconstituted in 0.1% formic acid, and subjected to LC–MS/MS analysis.
Sources indicate that LC–MS/MS analysis was performed using a timsTOF Pro 2 mass spectrometer coupled to a nanoElute liquid chromatography system (Bruker Daltonics). In brief, 200 ng of peptides were separated on a reversed-phase analytical column (25 cm × 75 µm internal diameter, IonOpticks) over a 60-min gradient at a flow rate of 300 nl min−1 and a column temperature of 50 °C. The mobile phases consisted of buffer A (0.1% formic acid in water) and buffer B (0.1% formic acid in acetonitrile). The gradient elution profile was set as follows: an increase to 22% buffer B from 0 to 45 min, up to 37% buffer B from 45 to 50 min, and a final step at 80% buffer B from 50 to 60 min. The mass spectrometer was operated in DDA-PASEF mode with the following parameters: capillary voltage, 1,500 V; dry gas flow, 3.0 l min−1; and drying temperature, 180 °C. The collision energy was linearly ramped as a function of ion mobility.
The raw LC–MS/MS data were searched against the N. benthamiana protein sequence database (Nbe_v1.1_pep.fa.gz), downloaded from NbenBase (https://nbenthamiana.jp/downloads), using MSFragger within FragPipe v22.0. Trypsin was specified as the digestion enzyme, allowing up to two missed cleavages. Precursor and fragment ion mass tolerances were set to 10 ppm and 0.02 Da, respectively. Carbamidomethylation of cysteine (+57.021 Da) was set as a fixed modification, whereas methionine oxidation (+15.995 Da) was included as a variable modification. Peptide and protein identifications were filtered to a 1% false discovery rate using a target-decoy strategy (Supplementary Tables 3, 6 and 7).
According to recent reports, his–TF and His–TF–NIB1 were incubated with 15 μl of Ni-NTA resin for 1 h at 4 °C. Protein extracts from leaves expressing EDS1–Flag were added to each resin and incubated overnight at 4 °C. The resin was washed 6 times with IP lysis buffer, resuspended in 50 μl of 4× SDS loading buffer and heated at 95 °C for 10 min. Bound proteins were analysed by immunoblotting.
Sources indicate that target coding sequences were cloned into pCAMBIA1300S-cYFP or pCAMBIA1300S-nYFP. Following co-expression of the fusion proteins in N. benthamiana leaves for 2 days, YFP signals were acquired by 20× water immersion objective through Leica TCS SP8 STED 3X.
In a recent development, MST was used to determine the protein–protein interactions and the binding affinities of NIB1 and its mutated versions to the indicated small molecules or RNA, protein labelling was performed in strict accordance with the manufacturer’s protocol. In brief, the purified recombinant proteins (NIB1–GST, NIB1(R49A)–GST, NIB1(G50A)–GST and NIB1(4A)–GST) at a concentration of 10 μM were labelled with NT–647–NHS using the Monolith Protein Labeling Kit RED-NHS 2nd Generation (NanoTemper Technologies). The labelled NIB1–GST and its mutants were adjusted to 50 nM in PBST buffer (PBS, with 0.05% Tween-20) and 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p (5 μM to 0.000153 μM) were added separately. For characterizing the interaction between NVR1 and NIB1 (NIB1RRM and NIB1GRR), 10 μM NVR1–TF was labelled and adjusted to 40 nM in PBST buffer. Subsequently, NIB1–GST, NIB1RRM–GST and NIB1GRR–GST (2.5 μM to 0.0000763 μM) were added separately. For protein–RNA interaction, the Cy5-labelled FLS2 3′-UTR served as the target and adjusted to 20 nM. NIB1–GST and the mutant fusions (10 μM to 0.000306 μM) were incubated with target. To access the interaction between NIB1(ΔIDR) and 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>P, the labelled NIB1(ΔIDR) was used as target and adjusted to 50 nM. The target protein was independently mixed with 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>P (10 μM to 0.000306 μM). Furthermore, to test the binding affinity of NIB1–GST with 3′,5′-cAMP, 3′,5′-cGMP, 8-Br-3′,5′-cAMP, AMP, GMP and the unrelated cyclic dinucleotides 2′,3′-cGAMP, 50 nM labelled NIB1–GST was used as target and independently mixed with the indicated compounds (15 μM to 0.000458 μM). A Microscale Thermophoresis Monolith NT.115 instrument (NanoTemper Technologies). was used to measure binding reactions at 25 °C, 40% MST power and 20% LED power. Measurements were repeatedly taken repeatedly from separate protein preparations to confirm repeatability. The curve was fitted using the MO.AffinityAnalysis_x86_2.3.0.7385, and the dissociation constant (Kd) value was determined.
NIB1–YFP fusion protein and its various mutants were purified by Ni-NTA resin. NIB1–YFP droplets with 10% PEG 8000, or as specifically indicated, were observed by Leica TSC SP8 STED 3× 100× oil immersion objective. The droplets were bleached by 100% intensity 488 nm laser and the recovery was recorded every 3 s 290 ms for 50 frames in FRAP. Fusion of NIB1 droplets was recorded through time-lapse photography. Droplet diameters were measured from microscopy images using Fiji (ImageJ, version 1.54f).
Target proteins fused with fluorescent protein (YFP or mCherry) were co-expressed in N. benthamiana leaves. Condensates in leaves were observed by Leica TSC SP8 STED 3X (Leica) 40 × oil immersion objective. To prevent fluorescence bleed-through during imaging, all images were acquired using the sequential scanning mode on a Leica TCS SP8 confocal microscope. YFP was excited with a 488 nm laser and detected at 498–540 nm, and mCherry was independently excited with a 561 nm laser and detected at 600–630 nm. The images of condensates were analysed using Fiji (ImageJ, version 1.54f). Line profile analysis was performed to evaluate co-localization of the proteins. To quantify the partition coefficient of the EDS1–mCherry into NIB1–YFP condensates with or without NVR1, regions of interest of equivalent size were analysed. The partition coefficient (Kp) was defined as the ratio of intracondensate EDS1 fluorescence intensity to that of the extracondensate background.
The Cy5-labelled AttRNAser (83 nt) used as substrate for NVR1 digestion was obtained through in vitro transcription using T7 RiboMAX Express RNAi System. A reaction mixture containing 0.5 mM Cy5-UTP and 1 mM synthesized AttRNAser DNA template (sequence listed in Supplementary Table 13) were incubated at 37 °C for 30 min. The template DNAs were then removed by 0.5 μl RNase-Free DNase (Promega) at 37 °C for 30 min. In the RNase activity assay, 2 μM Cy5-AttRNAser was incubated with 0.02 μM NVR1 in buffer containing 20 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7.5, 5 mM NaCl, 5 mM MgCl2, 1 mM ATP, 0.5 μl RNase Inhibitor at 25 °C for 20 min. The reaction was stopped by 400 μl stop solution (40 mM Tris-HCl pH 7.5 and 500 mM NaCl). Then RNAs were purified with PCIA solution (phenol:chloroform:isopentyl alcohol, 25:24:1) and the RNA pellet was resuspended in 1× TBE urea loading buffer. The RNA was then separated using 16% urea polyacrylamide gels at 150 V for 90 min and subsequently detected with a Amersham Typhoon 5.
Cy5-labelled FLS2 3′-UTR were synthesized in vitro using the HyperScribe T7 High Yield Cy5 RNA Labeling Kit (APExBIO) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. In brief, the 3′-UTR sequence of FLS2, as previously described44, was amplified using a forward primer containing a T7 promoter sequence (TAATACGACTCACTATAGGGGAAGTTTAGCAGCAAAGC) and a reverse primer (GTTCATCAAAACCAAATTTC). One microgram of DNA template containing a T7 promoter was combined in a 20 μl reaction volume. The reaction mixture consisted of 2 μl of 10× Reaction Buffer, 2 μl of T7 RNA Polymerase Mix, 2 mM each of ATP, GTP, and CTP, 1.5 mM UTP and 0.5 mM Cy5-UTP. The reaction was thoroughly mixed and incubated at 37 °C for 2 h. Following transcription, the DNA template was digested by adding 1 μl of DNase I and incubating at 37 °C for 15 min. The synthesized Cy5-labelled RNA was subsequently purified via phenol/chloroform extraction and ethanol precipitation. To evaluate the labelling efficiency, the absorbance of the purified RNA was measured at 260 nm and the Cy5 maximum excitation wavelength using NanoDrop.
Recent findings suggest that cytoplasmic and nuclear fractions were extracted according to the manufacturer’s manual instructions of Minute Cytoplasmic and Nuclear Extraction Kit for Cells. In brief, leaves (0.1 g, co-expressing NIB1–YFP and EDS1–mCherry with or without NVR1 for 48 h) were homogenized in cytoplasmic extraction buffer. Following centrifugation (14,000g, 5 min, 4 °C), the cytoplasmic supernatant was collected. The pellet was lysed in nuclear extraction buffer through repeated cycle of vortexing and ice incubation, and then centrifuged through a pre-chilled filter cartridge (14,000g, 30 s) to collect the nuclear extract. Histone H3 and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC) served as nuclear and cytoplasmic markers, respectively, to confirm successful fractionation.
It has been revealed that leaves were incubated in DAB solution (1 mg ml−1 DAB, 0.05% Tween-20, 10 mM Na2HPO4, pH 5.8) for 4–5 h in the dark. Bleaching buffer (ethanol:acetate:glycerol, 3:1:1) was added to displace DAB stain, and the sample was heated to 90–95 °C 3–5 times until the chlorophyll was removed completely. The samples were immersed in 50% glycerol for imaging.
RNaseT2 proteins were filtrated from the genomes of plants (Gossypium hirsutum, Nicotiana tobacum, O. sativa), fungi (Fusarium graminearum, M. oryzae), insects (N. viridula, A. lucorum, Nilaparvata lugens, Aphis gossypii, C. medinalis, H. armigera) and mammals (Homo sapiens and Rattus norvegicus) using PF00445 HMM search or NCBI blastp. The GRPs (GRPIVa) encoded in genomes of 18 plant species of 14 families (Physcomitrella patens, Adiantum capillus, Cycas revoluta, Picea abies, Nymphaea colorata, O. sativa, Zea mays, Sorghum bicolor, Brachypodium distachyon, G. hirsutum, Arabidopsis thaliana, Vitis vinifera, Carica papaya, Cucumis sativus, Glycine max, Solanum lycopersicum, Solanum tuberosum and Populus trichocarpa) were filtrated under the condition of only one PF00076 domain. The genomes were obtained from Phytozome (https://phytozome-next.jgi.doe.gov/) or NCBI (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/datasets/genome/), and insect proteomes were obtained from the NCBI Protein database (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/protein/). All filtrated proteins in these two classes were aligned by MUSCLE 5.1, trimmed using trimAl 1.2. The phylogenetic tree was constructed by using IQ-TREE 2.2.0 and annotated by Evolview v3. Conservation diagram of amino acid residues was shown using Jalview 2.11.2.5.
It has been revealed that total RNA was extracted from leaves of ~4-week-old wild-type O. sativa ZH11 and transgenic lines, as indicated. Leaves of four-week-old tobacco (N. benthamiana) were infiltrated with 50 μM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP for 6 h, followed by RNA extraction. RNA-seq was performed by Personalbio. Clean reads were aligned to the O. sativa reference genome (GCF_001433935.1_IRGSP-1.0_genomic.fna; https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/datasets/genome/GCF_001433935.1/) or the N. benthamiana reference genome (Niben.genome.v1.0.1; https://solgenomics.net/ftp/genomes/Nicotiana_benthamiana/assemblies/) using HISAT2. Differential gene expression analysis was subsequently performed using DESeq, with differentially expressed genes identified based on the thresholds of |log2(fold change)| > 1 and P < 0.05. GO enrichment and volcano plots were generated using R v4.3.2 in RStudio 2023.09.1. The differentially expressed genes and corresponding GO enrichment results are provided in Supplementary Tables 2, 4, 5, 8–12.
According to recent reports, the third-instar C. medinalis larvae were placed on leaves of the 12-day-old rice seedlings of the indicated lines. Larval weight was recorded after the feeding for three days. Oviposition selection assay was conducted in nylon mesh cages (90 × 70 × 90 cm). Three one-month-old, uniform rice plants per genotype were grouped and arranged triangularly to prevent positional bias. 15 pairs of newly emerged moths were mated for 48 h. Subsequently, males were removed, and the 15 mated females were released into the cage centre with a 15% honey solution. After 24 h of oviposition at 26 °C (12 h:12 h light:dark photoperiod), the total number of eggs laid on the three plants of each genotype was summed. The assay was repeated with three independent cages. Oviposition preference was quantified by the oviposition index: OI = (T − C)/(T + C), where T and C are the number of eggs in the mutants and wild type, respectively. The deviation of the oviposition index against 0 was tested using a one-sample Student’s t-test.
For larval feeding preference, leaf segments (3 cm) from 3 plant lines were arranged equidistantly in a circle within a Petri dish. Ten third-instar larvae (pre-starved for 2 h) were introduced to the centre. After 1 h of selection in darkness, the number of larvae settled on each plant was recorded. The selection rate was calculated as Ntarget/Ntotal selection × 100%, where Ntarget and Ntotal selection represent the number of larvae on a specific plant and the total number of larvae making a definitive choice, respectively.
For field test, wild-type ZH11 seeds were sown in soil, and 35-day-old plants were transplanted into six 1 m × 1 m field plots. Each plot was surrounded by two rows of rice plants serving as buffer rows, and all six plots were maintained within mesh enclosure. Four weeks after transplantation, the plots were arranged in an alternating pattern and sprayed with either water or 50 μM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP. Following treatment, 20 mated female C. medinalis moths were released at the centre of the enclosure. Once rolled-leaf shelters became visible, the number of shelters was counted. Insects and plant positions were randomized in laboratory assays, field treatments followed an alternating design, and outcomes were assessed blind to genotype or treatment.
According to recent reports, leaves tissue of 4-week-old rice plants were ground into powder with liquid nitrogen and resuspended in 500 μl ethyl acetate. Following vortex for 1 min and centrifugation at 14,000g for 10 min at 4°C, the supernatant was transferred and dried in vacuum concentrator and resuspended in 30 μl 30% (v/v) methanol. The samples were centrifuged at 14,000g for 15 min and the supernatant was applied to the LC–MS/MS on a QTRAP 6500+ mass spectrometer (AB SCIEX) for analysis. Salicylic acid samples were diluted to 1/100 with 30% (v/v) methanol.
In a recent development, leaf sheath segments of 2 mm were excised from 2-week-old rice seedlings and pre-incubated overnight in sterile distilled water. The samples were then treated with water or purified recombinant His–NVR1 protein in buffer containing 20 μM luminol and 10 μg ml−1 HRP. Luminescence was recorded at 1-min intervals for 100 min with Varioskan Flash multireader (Thermo Fisher Scientific).
In a recent development, NVR1 (1 μM) and the rRNA substrate (2 μg) were incubated in a 20-μl reaction mixture at 25 °C for 25 min. The reaction was stopped by adding methanol, and the mixture was centrifuged at 12,000g for 10 min at 4 °C. The supernatant was collected and analysed by liquid chromatography–high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC–HRMS) using a Q Exactive quadrupole-Orbitrap high-resolution mass spectrometer coupled to a Dionex Ultimate 3000 RSLC (HPG) ultrahigh-performance liquid chromatography system. The injection volume was 1 μl. The samples were separated on an ACQUITY UPLC HSS T3 column with a particle size of 1.8 μm. The mobile phase were water (A) and methanol (B), each containing ammonium formate (2 mM). The gradient elution was set as follows: 0–6.5 min, 2% methanol; 6.5–8.5 min, 20% methanol; 8.5–11 min, 98% methanol; 11.1–15.0 min, 2% methanol. The flow rate was consistently set to 0.40 ml min−1, and the column temperature was precisely maintained at 40 °C. Detection was performed in positive-ion mode using a heated electrospray ionization source. LC–HRMS data were analysed using Thermo Scientific Xcalibur 4.1.50.
Extraction of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP was performed as described3. Leaf tissue was ground into powder with liquid nitrogen. Samples were resuspended in 600 μl 4% acetate containing 1 mM IBMX and vortexed for 2 min. The supernatant was extracted twice with 800 μl chloroform. The samples were dried through vacuum spinning and resuspended in 50 μl sterile water.
Sources indicate that the dissolved samples were subjected to analysis by LC–MS/MS on a QTRAP 6500+ mass spectrometer (AB SCIEX) coupled to an Agilent 1290 LC system. Chromatographic separation was achieved using a Waters XSelect HSS T3 column with a particle size of 2.5 μm and dimensions of 100 mm × 3.0 mm. Sample of 1 μl was injected. The mobile phase consisted of water (A) and methanol (B), both containing 2 mM ammonium formate. The gradient elution method was used as follows: 0–2.5 min, 2% B; 2.5–3.0 min, 2–70% B; 3.0–5.0 min, 70–99% B; 5.0–7.0 min, 99% B; 7.1–10 min, 2% B. The flow rate was set at 0.4 ml min−1, and the column temperature was maintained at 40 °C. Metabolites were detected using electrospray ionization in negative ion mode with multiple reaction monitoring. The mass spectrometer parameters were as follows: −4,500 V of capillary voltage, 500 °C of source temperature, 50 psi of ion source gas 1 (GS1) and gas 2 (GS2), and 35 psi of curtain gas. Data acquisition and analysis were performed using Analyst 1.6.3 software (AB SCIEX).
According to recent reports, step 1. To a stirred solution of 2′,3′-O-isopropylideneguanosine (1.0 eq) in anhydrous tetrahydrofuran (THF) at 0 °C under an inert atmosphere, trimethylsilyl chloride (TMSCl) (1.0 eq) was introduced, followed by the dropwise addition of pyridine (2.5 eq). The reaction mixture was stirred at room temperature for 2 h. Next, isobutyryl chloride (1.0 eq) was added dropwise at 0–5 °C, and the mixture was stirred at room temperature for an additional 1 h. After quenching and extraction, the crude product was obtained and purified by C18 flash chromatography. The final product was characterized by LC–MS and 1H NMR spectroscopy for structural confirmation. Step 2. To a stirred solution of the Step 1 product (1.0 eq) and starting compound 2 (1.0 eq, CAS: 104992-55-4) in dichloromethane (DCM) at 0 °C, 5-(benzylthio)-1H-tetrazole (5-BTT) (1.0 eq) was added. The reaction mixture was stirred at room temperature for 3 h. Reaction solution washed water and brine, the DCM solution was concentrated under vacuum, the crude by C18 flash purification. Confirmed by LC–MS, 1H NMR and 31P NMR. Step 3. To a stirred solution of iodine (1.0 eq) in a THF:water:pyridine mixture (10:5:1, v/v/v), the Step 2 product was added at room temperature. The reaction mixture was stirred at room temperature for 1 h, followed by the addition of 10% sodium sulfite solution until the colour disappeared. The reaction mixture was then concentrated under vacuum, and the residue was extracted with ethyl acetate. The organic layer was dried over anhydrous Na2SO4, filtered, and concentrated under vacuum. The crude product was used directly in the next step without further purification. Confirmed by LC–MS and 31P NMR. Step 4. To a stirred solution of the Step 3 product (1.0 eq) in DCM, trifluoroacetic acid was added at room temperature. The reaction mixture was stirred at 45 °C for 4 h. After completion, the solution was concentrated under vacuum. Due to the product’s high water solubility, the residue was purified directly by C18 flash chromatography. Confirmed by LC–MS, 1H NMR and 31P NMR. Step 5. To a stirred solution of the Step 4 product (1.0 eq) in acetonitrile, N-methylmorpholine (1.0 eq), 2-methoxy-1-ethanesulfonyl chloride (2.0 eq), trimetaphosphate tri-tetrabutylammonium salt (1.0 eq), 1H-4(5)-nitroimidazole (0.1 eq), and DBU (3.0 eq) were added sequentially under nitrogen protection. The reaction mixture was stirred at room temperature until completion. MgCl2 (2.0 eq) was then added, and the mixture was stirred at room temperature. After completion, the solvent was concentrated under vacuum, and water was added to the residue to adjust the pH to 3–4. The mixture was extracted with ethyl acetate, washed, dried, and concentrated to obtain the crude product, which was further purified by preparative HPLC and lyophilization. Confirmed by LC–MS, 1H NMR and 31P NMR. Step 6. To a stirred solution of the Step 5 product (1.0 e) in THF, HF (6.0 eq) was added at room temperature. The reaction mixture was stirred at 50 °C until completion. Triethylamine was then added to the residue to adjust the pH to 6–7, and the mixture was concentrated under reduced pressure to obtain the crude product. The crude product was purified by preparative HPLC and lyophilization. Confirmed by LC–MS, 1H NMR and 31P NMR. Step 7. To a stirred solution of the Step 6 product (1.0 eq) in methanol (10 volumes), NH3/methanol (10.0 eq) was added at 0 °C. The reaction mixture was stirred at 0 °C for 6 h until completion. The methanol solution was then concentrated under vacuum and the residue was purified by preparative HPLC followed by lyophilization. Confirmed by LC–MS, 1H NMR and 31P NMR.
NIB1–GST was incubated with 10 μl of glutathione agarose resin at 4 °C for 2 h. Empty vector (encoding TF tag) or NVR1 products were added to the resin for an overnight incubation at 4 °C. Then the resin was treated with 100 μl of 80% acetonitrile and 5% formic acid and incubated at 25 °C for 30 min before proceeding with liquid chromatography analysis.
In a recent development, the 12-day-old rice seedlings were sprayed with 50 μM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP, 8-Br-2′,3′-cGMP or ApG>p for 6 h, with water and 8-Br-AMP as controls. After treatment, RNA was extracted, and the expression levels of defence genes were analysed by RT–qPCR. Leaves of 4-week-old N. benthamiana plants were infiltrated with 50 μM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP for 6 h, and gene expression was analysed by RT–qPCR.
AlphaFold2 was used to predict the structure of the NVR1–NIB1 complex. The 3D structures of 2′,3′-cAMP and 2′,3′-cGMP were obtained from PubChem (https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/), and ApG>p was modelled using ChemBioDraw Ultra 14.0. The ligands were optimized using density functional theory (DFT) in Gaussian 16 and prepared for docking with NIB1 using AutoDockTools 1.5.7. Molecular docking was performed using AutoDock 4.2.6 with ligand-specific grid boxes at a spacing of 0.375 Å. Grid dimensions were adjusted to 46 × 50 × 50 for 2′,3′-cAMP, 50 × 56 × 56 for 2′,3′-cGMP and 100 × 100 × 100 for ApG>p. The Lamarckian genetic algorithm was applied with 50 runs, a population size of 150 and 2.5 × 106 energy evaluations. The lowest-energy poses were analysed using PyMOL 2.5.5 and LigPlot+ 2.2.8.
According to recent reports, statistical analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism 9 (GraphPad Software). Comparisons between two groups were performed using unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-tests. For comparisons among multiple groups, one-way ANOVA followed by Dunnett’s or Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test was used, as appropriate. Two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test or the two-stage linear step-up procedure of Benjamini, Krieger and Yekutieli was performed, as indicated in the figure legends. Statistical significance was set at P < 0.05, with a false discovery rate of 5% for analyses using the Benjamini–Krieger–Yekutieli procedure. For violin plots, width indicates data density, lines show the median and quartiles, and dots represent individual values. Details of the statistical tests are provided in the corresponding figure legends.
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article.
All data are available in the main text, supplementary materials or public repositories. Raw RNA-seq data have been deposited in the NCBI Sequence Read Archive (SRA) under BioProject accession numbers PRJNA1043423, PRJNA1313367 and PRJNA1512165. The O. sativa reference genome (GCF_001433935.1_IRGSP-1.0_genomic.fna) was obtained from NCBI (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/datasets/genome/GCF_001433935.1/) and the N. benthamiana reference genome (Niben.genome.v1.0.1) was obtained from the publicly accessible Sol Genomics Network database (https://solgenomics.net/ftp/genomes/Nicotiana_benthamiana/assemblies/). The proteomics data generated in this study have been deposited in the ProteomeXchange repository under accession number PXD063305. The N. benthamiana protein sequence dataset (Nbe_v1.1_pep.fa.gz) was obtained from NbenBase (https://nbenthamiana.jp/downloads). Sequences used for phylogenetic analyses were obtained from Phytozome (https://phytozome-next.jgi.doe.gov/), NCBI Datasets (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/datasets/genome/) and NCBI Protein database (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/protein/). Uncropped gels and blots are shown in Supplementary Fig. 1. Source data are provided with this paper.
No custom code was developed in this study.
It has been revealed that duggal, Y. et al. Cellular effects of 2′,3′-cyclic nucleotide monophosphates in Gram-negative bacteria. J. Bacteriol. 204, e00208-21 (2022).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
Greulich, W. et al. TLR8 is a sensor of RNase T2 degradation products. Cell 179, 1264–1275.e13 (2019).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Yu, D. et al. TIR domains of plant immune receptors are 2’,3’-cAMP/cGMP synthetases mediating cell death. Cell 185, 2370–2386.e18 (2022).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Bai, Y. et al. Natural history-guided omics reveals plant defensive chemistry against leafhopper pests. Science 375, eabm2948 (2022).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Deutsch, C. A. et al. Increase in crop losses to insect pests in a warming climate. Science 361, 916–919 (2018).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Alborn, H. T. et al. An elicitor of plant volatiles from beet armyworm oral secretion. Science 276, 945–949 (1997).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that chen, C. Y. et al. An effector from cotton bollworm oral secretion impairs host plant defense signaling. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 116, 14331–14338 (2019).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, guo, J. et al. A tripartite rheostat controls self-regulated host plant resistance to insects. Nature 618, 799–807 (2023).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Boutrot, F. & Zipfel, C. Function, discovery, and exploitation of plant pattern recognition receptors for broad-spectrum disease resistance. Annu. Rev. Phytopathol 55, 257–286 (2017).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that schmelz, E. A. et al. Fragments of ATP synthase mediate plant perception of insect attack. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 103, 8894–9 (2006).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Luhtala, N. & Parker, R. T2 family ribonucleases: ancient enzymes with diverse roles. Trends Biochem. Sci. 35, 253–259 (2010).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that kubo, K. et al. Collaborative non-self recognition system in S-RNase-based self-incompatibility. Science 330, 796–9 (2010).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Mukherjee, D., Gupta, S., Ghosh, A. & Ghosh, A. Ustilago maydis secreted T2 ribonucleases, Nuc1 and Nuc2 scavenge extracellular RNA. Cell Microbiol. 22, e13256 (2020).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, yang, B. et al. Fg12 ribonuclease secretion contributes to Fusarium graminearum virulence and induces plant cell death. J. Integr. Plant Biol. 63, 365–377 (2021).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Huang, S. et al. Identification and receptor mechanism of TIR-catalyzed small molecules in plant immunity. Science 377, eabq3297 (2022).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Jia, A. et al. TIR-catalyzed ADP-ribosylation reactions produce signaling molecules for plant immunity. Science 377, eabq8180 (2022).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Leavitt, A. et al. Viruses inhibit TIR gcADPR signalling to overcome bacterial defence. Nature 611, 326–331 (2022).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Manik, M. K. et al. Cyclic ADP ribose isomers: Production, chemical structures, and immune signaling. Science https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adc8969 (2022).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Wan, L. et al. TIR domains of plant immune receptors are NAD+-cleaving enzymes that promote cell death. Science 365, 799–803 (2019).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, wu, Y. et al. A canonical protein complex controls immune homeostasis and multipathogen resistance. Science https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adr2138 (2024).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, yu, H. et al. Activation of a helper NLR by plant and bacterial TIR immune signaling. Science 386, 1413–1420 (2024).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Xiao, Y. et al. Activation and inhibition mechanisms of a plant helper NLR. Nature https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-08517-3 (2025).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Huang, S. et al. Balanced plant helper NLR activation by a modified host protein complex. Nature 639, 447–455 (2025).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Yang, X. et al. RNA G-quadruplex structure contributes to cold adaptation in plants. Nat. Commun. 13, 6224 (2022).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that sukarta, O. C. A. et al. GLYCINE-RICH RNA-BINDING PROTEIN 7 potentiates effector-triggered immunity through an RNA recognition motif. Plant Physiol. 189, 972–987 (2022).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
In a recent development, fu, Z. Q. et al. A type III effector ADP-ribosylates RNA-binding proteins and quells plant immunity. Nature 447, 284–8 (2007).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that jeong, B. R. et al. Structure function analysis of an ADP-ribosyltransferase type III effector and its RNA-binding target in plant immunity. J. Biol. Chem. 286, 43272–81 (2011).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Nicaise, V. et al. Pseudomonas HopU1 modulates plant immune receptor levels by blocking the interaction of their mRNAs with GRP7. EMBO J. 32, 701–12 (2013).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that giacometti, R. et al. Digestive activity and organic compounds of Nezara viridula watery saliva induce defensive soybean seed responses. Sci Rep. 10, 15468 (2020).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Kim, J. Y. et al. Glycine-rich RNA-binding proteins are functionally conserved in Arabidopsis thaliana and Oryza sativa during cold adaptation process. J. Exp. Bot. 61, 2317–2325 (2010).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, xu, W. et al. OsGRP3 enhances drought resistance by altering phenylpropanoid biosynthesis pathway in rice (Oryza sativa L. Int. J. Mol. Sci. 23, 7045 (2022).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Du, M. & Chen, Z. J. DNA-induced liquid phase condensation of cGAS activates innate immune signaling. Science 361, 704–709 (2018).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Xu, F. et al. Phase separation of GRP7 facilitated by FERONIA-mediated phosphorylation inhibits mRNA translation to modulate plant temperature resilience. Mol. Plant 17, 460–477 (2024).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Song, W. et al. Substrate-induced condensation activates plant TIR domain proteins. Nature 627, 847–853 (2024).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Dongus, J. A. & Parker, J. E. EDS1 signalling: at the nexus of intracellular and surface receptor immunity. Curr. Opin. Plant Biol. 62, 102039 (2021).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that lapin, D., Bhandari, D. D. & Parker, J. E. Origins and immunity networking functions of EDS1 family proteins. Annu. Rev. Phytopathol. 58, 253–276 (2020).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that sun, X. et al. Pathogen effector recognition-dependent association of NRG1 with EDS1 and SAG101 in TNL receptor immunity. Nat. Commun. 12, 3335 (2021).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that zipfel, C. Pattern-recognition receptors in plant innate immunity. Curr. Opin. Immunol. 20, 10–6 (2008).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Zhou, J.-M. & Zhang, Y. Plant immunity: danger perception and signaling. Cell 181, 978–989 (2020).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Chodasiewicz, M. et al. 2’,3’-cAMP treatment mimics the stress molecular response in Arabidopsis thaliana. Plant Physiol. 188, 1966–1978 (2022).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Kosmacz, M. et al. Interaction of 2′,3′-cAMP with Rbp47b plays a role in stress granule formation. Plant Physiol. 177, 411–421 (2018).
PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that van Damme, T. et al. Wounding stress causes rapid increase in concentration of the naturally occurring 2’,3’-isomers of cyclic guanosine- and cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cGMP and cAMP) in plant tissues. Phytochemistry 103, 59–66 (2014).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
Luo, W. et al. COLD6–OSM1 module senses chilling for cold tolerance via 2’,3’-cAMP signaling in rice. Mol. Cell 84, 4224–4238.e9 (2024).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Zavaliev, R., Mohan, R., Chen, T. & Dong, X. Formation of NPR1 condensates promotes cell survival during the plant immune response. Cell 182, 1093–1108.e18 (2020).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, huang, S., Zhu, S., Kumar, P. & MacMicking, J. D. A phase-separated nuclear GBPL circuit controls immunity in plants. Nature 594, 424–429 (2021).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Huang, S. & Dong, X. Biomolecular condensates in plant immunity. Cell Host Microbe 33, 1276–1290 (2025).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
In a recent development, kim, J. H. et al. Increasing the resilience of plant immunity to a warming climate. Nature 607, 339–344 (2022).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Cui, B. et al. Bacteriophages hijack 2′,3′-cNMPs to enhance transposase-mediated phage DNA integration in Acinetobacter baumannii. Sci. Adv. 12, eaec7770 (2026).
Article PubMed PubMed Central CAS Google Scholar.
Tian, H. et al. Activation of TIR signalling boosts pattern-triggered immunity. Nature 598, 500–503 (2021).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that lu, Y. et al. Mirid bug outbreaks in multiple crops correlated with wide-scale adoption of Bt cotton in China. Science 328, 1151–4 (2010).
Article PubMed CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that we thank J. Parker and H. Cui for providing the CR-eds1 N. benthamiana and rice seeds; L.-L. Chen and Y.-J. Qi for help in RNase activity assay; S.-S. Wang, L.-Y. Jing, W.-J. Cai, L. Liu, S.-N. Yin, Y.-Y. Gao, W.-X. Lan, X.-Y. Xu and W.-L. Hu for help with mass spectra, MST analysis and microscope observations; J.-J. Chai, Z.-H. He and Y. Zhang for discussions; Y.-W. Deng, J.-Y. Liu, X.-M. Zhang and X.-X. Chen for help with insect collection and plant cultivation.
Recent findings suggest that the work was supported by the Strategic Priority Research Program of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (grant no. XDB 1490000) to X.-Y.C., the National Natural Science Foundation of China (32388201 X.-Y.C. and 32422007 J.-Q.H.), STI 2030-Major Projects, Biological Breeding of Stress tolerant and High Yield Cotton Varieties (2023ZD04040) to M.C., Yunnan Revitalization Talent Support Program “Top Team” Project (202305AT350001) to X.-Y.C., Winall Hi-tech Seed Project (GMLM2023) to X.-Y.C., the Foundation of Youth Innovation Promotion Association of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and the Shanghai Rising-Star Project (24QA2710300) to J.-Q.H.
These authors contributed equally: Xiao-Xiang Guo, Jia-Fa Huang, Jing-Tong Zhao, Yi-Jie Gan.
State Key Laboratory of Plant Trait Design, CAS Center for Excellence in Molecular Plant Sciences, Shanghai Institute of Plant Physiology and Ecology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Shanghai, China.
Xiao-Xiang Guo, Jia-Fa Huang, Jing-Tong Zhao, Yi-Jie Gan, Xiaoxiao Liu, Longxian Chen, Wen-Kai Wu, Yu-Fei Li, Jia-Ling Lin, Jing-Jing Bao, Gui-Bin Nie, Yin Tang, Mei Chen, Ling-Jian Wang, Jin-Quan Huang, Ying-Bo Mao, Xiaofei Yang, Ertao Wang, Li Wan & Xiao-Ya Chen.
University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China.
Xiao-Xiang Guo, Jia-Fa Huang, Jing-Tong Zhao, Yi-Jie Gan, Wen-Kai Wu, Yu-Fei Li, Jing-Jing Bao, Gui-Bin Nie, Yin Tang & Xiao-Ya Chen.
State Key Laboratory for Quality and Safety of Agro-Products, Institute of Virology and Biotechnology, Zhejiang Academy of Agricultural Sciences, Hangzhou, China.
School of Life Science and Technology, ShanghaiTech University, Shanghai, China.
Shanghai Key Laboratory of Plant Functional Genomics and Resources, Plant Science Research Center, Shanghai Chenshan Botanical Garden, Shanghai, China.
Analytical Applications Center, Shimadzu, Shanghai, China.
Department of Cell and Developmental Biology, John Innes Centre, Norwich, UK.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, X.-X.G., J.-F.H., J.-T.Z., Y-J.G., L.W. and X.-Y.C. conceived and designed the study. X.-X.G., J.-F.H., J.-T.Z., Y.-J.G., X.L. and T.S. performed the experiments. L.C. analysed RNA-seq data. L.-J.W. and M.C. generated transgenic plants. Y.-F.L. modelled protein. J.-Q.H., W.-K.W., J.-L.L., J.-J.X., J.-J.B., G.-B.N. and Y.T. identified compounds. J.-L.D. performed the MALDI–MS experiments. X.-X.G., L.W. and X.-Y.C. wrote the manuscript. E.W., Y.D., X.Y. and Y.-B.M. commented on the manuscript. All authors discussed and commented on the manuscript. X.-Y.C. and L.W. supervised the study.
Correspondence to Li Wan or Xiao-Ya Chen.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Recent findings suggest that nature thanks Rui Ji; John MacMicking, who co-reviewed with Shuai Huang; and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
a, Flow chart of N. viridula T2 ribonuclease NVR1 identification from oral secretions. b, NVR1-induced cell death and ROS production (DAB staining) in Nicotiana benthamiana (Nb) leaves at 3 dpi. Stacked bars display cell death scores (0-5, n = 11 leaves). EV, empty vector. c, Immunoblot analysis of NVR1-YFP protein transiently expressed in Nb leaves. Actin served as loading control. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. d, Immunoblot detection of the NVR1 present in N. viridula salivary glands (Sg) and Nv-infested rice plants. Actin was detected on a separate blot prepared from the same samples and processed in parallel. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. e, Nucleocytoplasmic distribution of NVR1-YFP in Nb leaves (2dpi). Scale bar: 15 µm. Data are representative of three independent experiments. f, Phylogenetic tree of NVR1 and the T2 family RNases from representative mammals, herbivorous insects, phytopathogenic fungi, and plants, constructed by IQ-TREE. g, MS/MS fragmentation patterns (MS2-spectra) of NVR1 products from (Fig. 1f) and standards. h, MALDI-MS images of 2′,3′-cAMP (m/z 329.053), 2′,3′-cGMP (m/z 345.048), and ApG>p (m/z 709.381) in Nb leaves transiently expressing EV, NVR1, or its mutated variants for two days. Data are representative of two independent experiments. i, j, Immunoblots of protein expression correlating with the cell death phenotypes (Fig. 1j and l). Actin served as the loading control (i) or as a sample-processing control on a separate, parallel-processed blot (j). For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. k, Cell death phenotypes upon co-expression of NVR1 and AtNUDT7 at 6 dpi (n = 15).
Industry observers note that a, b, qRT-PCR determination of NVR1 transcript (a) and immunoblot detection of NVR1-GFP protein (b) in NVR1-OE rice lines (#2 and #18) compared with WT (ZH11). Actin served as loading control. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. c, Representative Gene Ontology (GO) items of genes with significantly upregulation in NVR1-OE rice leaves compared with WT. d, qRT-PCR validation of COI1 and ERF1 upregulation in NVR1-OE rice leaves, compared to the WT. e, HPLC determination of Jasmonic acid (JA) and salicylic acid (SA) levels in WT and NVR1-OE rice leaves. f, Amino acid sequence of CMR1 with MS/MS-identified peptides indicated by green bars. g, Detection of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP after incubation CMR1 (0.02 μM) with rice RNA (100 ng OsRNA) in 20-μL reaction mixture at 25 °C for 1 h. h, Growth of C. medinalis larvae on WT and NVR1-OE rice plants. The third instar larvae were weighed after placing on the 12-day-old rice plants for three days (n = 12). i, Oviposition index of C. medinalis females on WT and NVR1-OE plants over 24 h (n = 3 independent cages). Oviposition index: OI = (T − C)/(T + C), where T and C are the number of eggs in the NVR1-OE and WT plants, respectively. j, Larval selection rates toward WT and NVR1-OE lines (n = 3 independent petri dishes). k, qRT-PCR analysis of COI1 and ERF1 expression in WT and NVR1H-doub-OE rice leaves. l, Representative WT, NVR1-OE and NVR1H-doub-OE plants. Right, and the number of tillers (n = 10). Data are mean ± SD from 3 biologically independent samples. Statistical differences were determined by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s (a, d, e, h, k, l) or Dunnett’s (j) multiple comparisons tests, or a one-sample Student’s t-test comparing the oviposition index to zero (i). For (c), p < 0.05.
Recent findings suggest that a, Volcano plot of NVR1-bound peptide abundance in NVR1-YFP-expressing Nb leaves. Red and blue dots indicate significantly increased and decreased peptides, respectively (gray, non-significant). Fold change ≥ 2 or ≤ 0.5 and P < 0.05; two-sided t-test. b, SLC assay verifying NVR1 interactions with rice candidate proteins (IC1-IC3). c, Schematic of NIB1 showing the RNA Recognition Motif (RRM) and a glycine-rich region (GRR). d, Coomassie blue staining of NVR1-TF and the indicated NIB1-GST variants used for MST assays (related to Fig. 2a,e). e, SLC assay showing RRM-dependent NVR1-NIB1 interaction in Nb. f, AlphaFold2 prediction of the NVR1 (blue)-NIB1 (pink) complex. g, SLC assay showing the requirement of R22 for NVR1-NIB1 interaction. h, i, SLC assays of NVR1 interactions with OsGRPs (OsGRP1, 2, 4-6, LOC_Os12g43600), using NIB1 (OsGRP3) as a positive control (bottom right). j, SLC assay showing NVR1-NIB1 interaction is independent of RNase activity, as NVR1H-doub still interacted with NIB1. k, Phylogenetic tree of NIB1 homologs from 18 land plant species (Physcomitrella patens, Adiantum capillus, Cycas revoluta, Picea abies, Nymphaea colorata, Oryza sativa, Zea mays, Sorghum bicolor, Brachypodium distachyon, Gossypium hirsutum, Arabidopsis thaliana, Vitis vinifera, Carica papaya, Cucumis sativus, Glycine max, Solanum lycopersicum, Solanum tuberosum, Populus trichocarpa). The tree was constructed by IQ-TREE and annotated by Evolview v3. l, SignalP-5.0 prediction of N-terminal signal peptides in CMR1, MOR1, and HAR1. m, SLC display of the GRP-RNaseT2 interaction. T2 family RNases from herbivorous insects of C. medinalis (CMR1) and H. armigera (HAR1), and phytopathogenic fungus Magnaporthe oryzae (MOR1), and GRPs from rice (NIB1) and cotton (GhGRP1A) were tested. n, Sequence logos showing high conservation of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP binding sites (R49, G50) and ApG>p-additional sites (G14, W17) among NIB1 homologs in (k). For all SLC assays (b, e, g-j, m), the blue-to-red scale indicates weak-to-strong interaction fluorescence. Images are representative of three independent experiments.
a, Full-scale structural overview of the molecular docking of 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p with NIB1 (the dashed box corresponds to Fig. 2d). b, MST analysis of NIB1, NIB1R49A and NIB1G50A binding to FLS2 3′-UTR. c-i, MST-determined binding affinities of 3′,5′-cAMP, 8-Br-3′,5′-cAMP, AMP, 2′,3′-cGAMP, 3′,5′-cGMP, and GMP to NIB1, with 2′,3′-cAMP serving as a positive control. Data are mean ± SD. n = 3 biologically independent replicates.
a, Schematic of NIB1 protein domains, with the PONDR-predicted intrinsically disordered region (IDR) at the C-terminus highlighted in yellow. b, PONDR-predicted average disorder scores of OsGRPs and AtGRPs. c, d, Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) assay of NIB1-YFP. Scale bar: 1 µm. e, Time-lapse microscopy of NIB1 droplet fusion. Scale bar: 3 µm. f, Representative FRAP images and normalized recovery profiles of NIB1-YFP nuclear condensates (indicated by the arrow) in Nb leaves. Scale bar: 5 μm. g, Immunoblot detection of NIB1-YFP in leaves of T1 pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/ZH11 rice plants, using GFP antibody. Actin served as loading control. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. h, FRAP images and normalized recovery profiles of NIB1-YFP nuclear condensates in the root elongation zone of T1 pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/ZH11 transgenic rice line. Scale bar, 2 µm. i, BN-PAGE showing a clear mobility shift of conventionally purified NIB1-YFP protein (not treated with TieChui E. coli lysis buffer). For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. j, k, NVR1 (1 μM), but not the inactive NVR1H-doub (1 μM), enlarged NIB1 (10 μM) droplets. Assays were performed using NIB1-YFP (j) or nucleic acid-free NIB1-YFP (k). Right: relative droplet diameters normalized to PBS (n = 20). Scale bars: 2 µm. l, Representative images and fluorescence intensity line profiles demonstrating that NVR1-enhanced nuclear enrichment of NIB1. Scale bar, 5 µm. m, Percentage of nuclei containing condensates (n = 5). n, NVR1 induced YFP-NIB1 nuclear condensates. Scale bar, 5 µm. o, Immunoblot analysis showing the NVR1-promoted nuclear accumulation of NIB1-YFP. Histone H3 and PEPC served as nuclear and cytoplasmic markers, respectively. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. Data are mean ± SD. FRAP data (c, d, f, h) were obtained from 3 independent droplets or condensates. Statistical differences were evaluated by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple comparisons test (j and k) or a two-tailed t-test (m). Images in n are representative of three independent experiments.
Industry observers note that a, b, 2′,3′-cNMP binding sites mediated NIB1 droplets formation in vitro (a, 40 μM) and nuclear condensates (b). c, d, ApG>p (2 nM) induced in vitro phase separation of NIB1, but not its binding mutants (c). Relative diameters are in d. e, ApG>p (50 μM) stimulated NIB1 nuclear condensates in leaf cell at 2 hpi. f, NIB1-YFP condensates in the root elongation zone of T1 pNIB1::NIB1-YFP/ZH11 transgenic rice cells treated with 50 µM ApG>p for 6 h. g, h, NIB1 condensate formation with 3′,5′-cAMP, 3′,5′-cGMP, 8-Br-3′,5′-cAMP, AMP, GMP and 2′,3′-cGAMP. Nuclear condensates quantification is shown in h. i, Influence of NVR1/NVR1H-doub (1 μM), plant RNAs (100 ng/μL) and 2′,3′-cAMP (2 nM) on NIB1-YFP (20 μM) droplet sizes. j-l, NIB1-YFP phase diagrams under varying 2′,3′-cAMP, OsRNA, and salt (j-k), or PEG 8000 (l). m, Coomassie blue staining of purified recombinant proteins. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. n, NIB1, but not NIB1ΔIDR, enhanced 2′,3′-cNMP production in Nb leaves expressing NVR1. o-r, The NIB1ΔIDR mutant (o-p) and 2′,3′-cNMP/ApG>p binding-deficient mutants (NIB1R49A, NIB1G50A, and NIB14A) (q-r) did not intensify NVR1-induced cell death in Nb leaves. Stacked bars display each cell death score (0-5). Immunoblots confirmed expression. Actin was detected on a separate blot prepared from the same samples and processed in parallel. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. Droplet diameters normalized to PBS controls (n = 20). For nuclear condensates, n = 6 in b, n = 5 in e, n = 7 in f, and n = 3 in h. Cell death (o, q), 11 leaves were scored. Scale bars: 10 µm (a, c, i), 5 µm (b, e, g), 10 µm (top) / 3 µm (bottom) (f), and 2 µm (j). Data are mean ± SD. Statistics: two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (a, d, e, i), one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s test (b, h) or Dunnett’s test (n), or a two-tailed t-test (f).
It has been revealed that a, Heatmap analysis of OsGRPs expression pattern across rice tissues, using data from the Rice Expression Database (RED; https://ngdc.cncb.ac.cn/red/home). b, Two different NIB1 knockout (NIB1-KO) rice lines in the ZH11 background generated by CRISPR/Cas9. Deletion and insertion are indicated. c, qRT-PCR determination of NIB1 transcript level in WT, NIB1-KO (#9 and #16), NIB1-OE (#18 and #30) rice leaves. Rice ACTIN1 acted as an internal control. d, Immunoblot identification of NIB1-GFP fusion protein in NIB1-OE lines using anti-GFP antibody. Actin was used as the loading control. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. e, qRT-PCR validation of MYC2, NPR1, COI1 and ERF1 expression in leaves of wild-type, NIB1-KO and NIB1-OE rice plants. f, Oviposition index of C. medinalis females on WT, NIB1-OE and NIB1-KO plants over 24 h. g, Larval selection rates toward WT, NIB1-OE and NIB1-KO plants. h, Tiller numbers in representative plants of ZH11, NIB1-KO and NIB1-OE lines (See also Fig. 4a). i, Two different NbGRP7 knockout (NbGRP7-KO) Nb lines generated by CRISPR/Cas9. Mutation sites of the KO lines are shown. j, Immunoblot analysis of NVR1 protein expression correlating with the cell death phenotype shown in Fig. 4h. Actin served as loading control. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. Data are presented as mean ± SD. Sample sizes are as follows: n = 3 biologically independent samples (c, e), n = 3 independent cages (f), n = 3 independent petri dishes (g), and n = 10 independent plants (h). Statistical differences were determined using one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple comparisons test (c, e, g, h), a one-sample Student’s t-test against zero (f).
In a recent development, a, Oviposition index of C. medinalis females on ZH11, NIB1-KO, and NIB1-KO plants expressing various NIB1 mutant plants over 24 h. b, Larval selection rates toward ZH11, NIB1-KO, and NIB1-KO expressing various NIB1 mutants. c, qRT-PCR detection of expression of defense genes in ZH11, NIB1-KO, and NIB1-KO leaves expressing various NIB1 mutant proteins defective or compromised in 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP and ApG>p binding, showing that NIB1R49A and NIB1G50A were compromised to restore the NIB1-KO immune response. d,e, qRT-PCR detection of expression of defense genes MYC2, COI1, NPR1 and ERF1 in leaves of the WT (ZH11), NIB1R49A-OE and NIB1G50A-OE lines. f, MST showing the binding affinities of NIB1ΔIDR with 2′,3′-cAMP/cGMP or ApG>p. g, Immunoblot of the NIB1-YFP and NIB1ΔIDR-YFP protein in leaves of indicated transgenic rice lines (NIB1-KO background), using GFP antibody. Actin was detected on a separate blot prepared from the same samples and processed in parallel. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. h, Representative images of NIB1-YFP or NIB1ΔIDR-YFP condensates in the root elongation zone of the indicated independent T1 transgenic rice lines (NIB1-KO background) following treatment with 50 µM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP for 6 h. Right: Quantification of NIB1 condensates per nucleus. Scale bars: 10 μm (top) and 3 μm (bottom). Data are presented as mean ± SD. Sample sizes are as follows: n = 3 independent cages (a), n = 3 independent petri dishes (b), n = 3 independent biological samples (c-e), n = 3 biologically independent replicates (f), and n = 7 biologically independent samples (h). Statistical differences were determined using a one-sample Student’s t-test against zero (a), one-way ANOVA with Dunnett’s multiple comparisons test (b), one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple comparisons test (c-e), or two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (h).
In a recent development, a, Volcano plot of NIB1-bound peptide abundance in NIB1-YFP-expressing leaves. Red/blue dots indicate increased/decreased peptides. b, GO analysis of upregulated proteins in NVR1 and NIB1 interactomes. c-e, NIB1-EDS1 interaction tested by SLC (c), Semi-in vivo Pull-down (d), and BiFC (e) assays. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. f, NIB1 and EDS1 line profiles after co-expression with EV, NVR1, or NVR1H-doub in (Fig. 5c). g, Localization (left) and line profiles (right) of NIB1 and EDS1-NES with NVR1. h, CRISPR/Cas9-generated eds1 mutant (CR-eds1) in rice (ZH11), showing a 32-bp deletion in the first exon. i, j, Relative EDS1 (i) and defense genes (COI1, NPR1, ERF1; j) transcript levels in ZH11 and CR-eds1. k, l, C. medinalis oviposition index (k) and larval selection rates (l) on ZH11 and CR-eds1 plants. m,n, Representative plants (m) and relative expression of defense genes (n) in ZH11, NIB1-OE/ZH11, and NIB1-OE /CR-eds1 lines. o-q, Venn diagrams (o), DEGs heatmap (p), and GO terms of upregulated genes (q) in WT, NbGRP7-KO, and epss mutant Nb leaves treated with 50 µM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP or ddH2O for 6 h. r, NbPR1 and NbMYC2 expression 6 h after ddH2O, 21, or 50 μM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP. Images in c-e are representative of three independent experiments. s, Rolled leaves per plant by C. medinalis larvae after water or 50 µM 8-Br-2′,3′-cAMP treatment (n = 15). For i, j, n, r, relative gene expression was determined by qRT-PCR. Data are mean ± SD of n = 3 biologically independent samples. Statistical significance was determined by two-tailed t-test (i, j, l, s), one-sample t-test (k), or one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s test (m, n, r). For a, fold change ≥ 2 or ≤ 0.5 and p < 0.05, two-sided t-test. For (b and q), p < 0.05. Scale bars, 20 μm (e) and 5 μm (g).
Industry observers note that a, Cell death phenotype of RPS4TIR in WT and NbGRP7-KO Nb leaves 36 h post-infiltration (hpi). Color-coded stacked bars display the percentages (in each case) of each cell death score (0-5). 11 leaves were scored. b, Expression of proteins (EV and RPS4TIR-MYC) in WT and NbGRP7-KO Nb leaves were detected by immunoblot using anti-MYC antibody. Actin was detected on a separate blot prepared from the same samples and processed in parallel. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. c, Cell death phenotypes of RPS4TIR in NbGRP7-KO at 56 hpi (n = 17). d, Two independent NbGRP7/NbGRP8-KO knockout (NbGRP7/NbGRP8-KO) lines were generated using the CRISPR/Cas9 system. The corresponding mutation target sites are shown. e, Cell death phenotype following transient expression of OsTIR in WT and NbGRP7/ NbGRP8-KO leaves at 40 hpi. f, Color-coded stacked bars display the percentages (in each case) of each cell death score (0-5). 11 leaves were scored. g, Immunoblot detection of OsTIR-MYC in WT and NbGRP7/NbGRP8-KO leaves using an anti-MYC antibody. Actin was used as the loading control. For gel source data, see Supplementary Fig. 1. h, Cell death phenotypes of OsTIR in NbGRP7/NbGRP8-KO at 68 hpi (n = 24). RPS4TIR and OsTIR-induced cell death assays were performed under laboratory conditions and the greenhouse conditions described in the Methods, respectively.
Uncropped gels and blots corresponding to the main and extended data figures.
Guo, XX., Huang, JF., Zhao, JT. et al. A plant RNA-binding protein senses 2′,3′-cNMP produced by insect effectors. Nature (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11259-z.
Version of record: 11 November 2026.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11259-z.
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:.
Sorry, a shareable link is not at the moment available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (27 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Stoke City legend Mike Pejic explains how Ben WIlmot is finding his best form and what he is seeing different from Million Manhoef.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (267 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Gerry Cardinale wants to return AC Milan to the top and he hopes that adding another elite player next summer will help to achieve that goal.
It has been revealed that with the signing of Luka Modric, and the subsequent quality that he’s shown since, Milan may tap into the experienced free agent market more. Of course, opportunities have to be right, but Cardinale is becoming more in favour of signing these types of players.
Recent findings suggest that read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
So, in the summer, they may look to Anfield instead of the Bernabeu, where Virgil van Dijk could become the new Luka Modric.
In a recent development, calciomercato.com relays words from Gazzetta dello Sport, building on their report this morning of the interest in van Dijk. The move, it seems, would be pushed for by Cardinale and the American is already working up a blueprint.
In January, the Rossoneri will strengthen the defence, with Goncalo Inacio and Massire Sylla the favoured names presently. With these additions, the American would hope for a return to the Champions League, which would be essential to signing van Dijk.
So, with the mix of promising youth recruited in January, they would hope to finalise the defensive transformation with a world-class player next season. Cardinale remains convinced of van Dijk’s quality, and he can discuss a move as early as February 1.
With no sign of the stalemate at Anfield ending, the American – who holds a stake in Liverpool’s ownership – remains hopeful.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (35 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
A number of former Rams have found jobs throughout the EFL after choosing to hang up their boots with one in particular choosing to move to one of Derby’s direct rivals.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (25 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Stories from in and around Stoke City including a familiar face in the stands watching the Potters win at Fratton Park.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (35 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Former NFL star has left Championship rivals Birmingham City three years after buying into the club and an exchange with ex-Derby boss Wayne Rooney is set to be a lasting image.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (32 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Gudjon Thordarson inspired a takeover at Stoke City in the 1990s, won at Wembley Stadium with the Potters as a manager and guided them to a dramatic promotion.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (31 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Sam Clucas says he is glad to see Stoke City make a strong start to this season as he looks back at his time at the club.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (36 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County find themselves in the Championship relegation zone heading into the second international break of the campaign with real concerns that the Rams could find themselves in League One come May.
📅 15 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (28 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Question of Sport question writer James Knowles has dived into his deep knowledge of Stoke City to concoct a book full of tricky questions.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (558 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

QPR boss Julien Stephan has shown no hesitation in offering first-team opportunities to upcoming starlets in his time at Loftus Road. Among those to break into the senior squad this season has been Leon Scarlett, and reports recently stated the 17-year-old has interest from AC Milan and Eintracht Frankfurt.
Industry observers note that now, it is separately claimed by Football Insider that Scarlett has interest on UK shores too. They state that the Hoops prospect is also on the radar of Premier League sides Arsenal and Brighton & Hove Albion, as well as Scottish giants Rangers.
It has been revealed that it is remarked that the R’s remain confident they can keep Scarlett, given the first-team opportunities on offer at Loftus Road. However, the teenage winger did start his academy career in the Arsenal setup before switching to West London in 2025, so the chance to return and push for a breakthrough could be tempting.
It has been revealed that aged just 17, Scarlett has become a part of Stephan’s first-team squad. His performances in the youth setup have caught the eye, leading to his quick ascent to the senior group in West London.
Attacking injuries and the previous unavailability of Rayan Kolli brought chances for Scarlett – perhaps a little quicker than expected. Nonetheless, he has earned his five Championship appearances, starting in the 2-2 draw against Preston North End, alongside four substitute outings.
Scarlett is very much in the developmental years of his career. His early involvement at Championship level does not mean he is a fixed member of Stephan’s squad yet, especially with previously sidelined players like Kolli and Ilias Chair back in the fold, while Rumarn Burrell nears his comeback.
Interest emphasises belief in Scarlett’s potential and highlights the good work going on in the Hoops’ academy ranks. However, they must remain patient with the teenager’s progression as he continues to grow on and off the pitch.
According to recent reports, interest from clubs of the stature of Arsenal and AC Milan could prove tempting for Scarlett. Rangers would offer a unique and exciting opportunity too, while Brighton & Hove Albion and Eintracht Frankfurt are esteemed developers of young prospects.
In a recent development, all of those teams would be able to offer a high level of academy coaching and access to elite facilities. That is where they may have an edge over QPR.
It has been revealed that however, the Hoops are more likely to be able to offer senior minutes and a quicker ascent to regular first-team selection. It means a potential Scarlett move could come down to his personal preference – does he want top coaching in elite academy facilities? Or does he want to progress with more senior exposure?
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest Queens Park Rangers news in your inbox every morning.
Enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (38 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County see their Championship commitments paused over the next couple of weeks with boss John Eustace expected to put the players who have not been called up for international duty through their paces.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (28 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Stoke City will have to pay Dundee an extra instalment on Luke Graham's transfer fee as the young defender goes from strength to strength.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (18 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
The football worlds in the Potteries and Iceland are remembering an influential former manager.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Get the full Stoke City Premium experience for less than 50p per week.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (25 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has urged caution over scrapping the Saturday 3pm blackout, warning it protects the income of lower-league clubs.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (546 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

By CRAIG HOPE, CHIEF FOOTBALL REPORTER.
Published: 15:30 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 15:40 EST, 14 November 2026.
Declan Rice has laughed off criticism from Graeme Souness by claiming his numbers 'aren't bad for a centre back', after he was accused of playing 'old man's football' and 'cheating' by dropping into defence.
Souness has long believed the Arsenal and England star does not do enough for a midfielder and stated recently he might as well play centre back, adding that he would not get a game for the likes of Real Madrid and Barcelona.
Rice is aware of what Souness has noted but believes his return of 22 goals and 33 assists since joining the Gunners in 2023 disproves the former Liverpool midfielder's opinion.
‘My numbers since I joined Arsenal speak for themselves,’ said Rice. ‘For a “centre back”, I think that’s not bad numbers. I’ve had a lot of assists, a lot of goals. To be a top-class centre back getting those numbers, I’m delighted with that!’.
Rice, who will start as an advanced midfielder when England take on Spain here in Madrid on Sunday night, added: ‘Look, Graeme’s got his opinion. I think he’s had his opinion since my West Ham days. I’ve seen his views. I can’t change his opinion. I can only do what I do, which is go on the pitch, perform, play well and block out the noise.’.
Rice also believes Souness, 73, may not understand how the game has evolved.
England and Arsenal midfielder Declan Rice has laughed off Graeme Souness' criticism after he was accused of playing 'old man's football' 'cheating' by dropping into defence.
Pundit Souness believes Rice would not get a game for the likes of Real Madrid and Barcelona.
Recent findings suggest that ‘If you speak about the positioning, the “old man's football”, look at Harry Kane, for instance,’ began Rice. 'We played him the other week and he dropped next to the centre backs 20-30 times to pick up the ball. The game is different now. It's what the game demands, to get away from your man, to go into different areas to create overloads, to create two v ones, to progress the ball up the pitch. Football is way different. It's changed a lot, and you're always trying to look for tactical advantages.
Industry observers note that ‘In terms of me as a midfielder, I'm constantly watching clips with Mikel (Arteta). He's constantly coaching me on the pitch. How I can progress the ball from deep, drop next to the goalkeeper, go to full back to get on the ball, to take the ball up the pitch.
‘So, I feel like we're now seeing something totally different to what he would see, but in his time football was different. He was a top-class midfielder who won lots of stuff. There's no argument against him. As a pundit, as a person, his career, you have to respect what he's done.
‘I didn't get to see him play, but obviously his accolades were top, and I've never got to meet him in person. If I did, there would be no disrespect. I’d shake his hand. I’d chat with him. It’s an opinion at the end of the day. It’s football.’.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (39 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County head into the international break on a high after coming from behind to beat Bolton Wanderers at Pride Park and the Rams have just under two weeks to initiative for their next game.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (262 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Last night, Mike Maignan and Adrien Rabiot were opponents at San Siro, a rare occasion for the star AC Milan duo.
Before last night’s game, there was plenty of attention given to Maignan and the shared story he had with Gianluigi Donnarumma. For both, it was a return home, but only the Frenchman (or duo) were given a warm welcome from the Rossoneri in the crowd.
Read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
How did they perform in their home stadium, though?
In a recent development, as Gazzetta dello Sport – seen below – writes, Maignan’s performance was worthy of a 6/10. However, there were frustrations with some of his decisions to rush out, leading to questions about the need for him to be a ‘goalkeeper-superhero’.
For Rabiot, it was a 5.5 for his performance. The Frenchman struggled to find space when attacking, and whilst France’s attack was strong, they were missing some key names.
Elsewhere, Goal gave Maignan a 6/10 thanks to some good stops against Pio Esposito and admitted that he couldn’t have done much with either of his goals. Additionally, he dove the right way for the penalty, but power took it past him.
It has been revealed that rabiot, though, was bumped up to a 7/10. The captain ‘set the tone’ at both ends and was unlucky not to score at least once. Not only that, but he made an excellent recovery run to stop Riccardo Calafiori, which highlighted how important he is in the midfield.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (33 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County’s financial problems over the past few years have been well documented by the Independent Football Regulator might have come up with a way to solve those problems.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (20 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
A signed teamsheet has emerged from Sir Stanley Matthews' famous farewell match at the Victoria Ground.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (36 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Mohammed Fuseini has endured a frustrating time of things since arriving at Derby County but the Ghanaian forward now has an ideal opportunity to stake a claim in the Rams’ starting XI.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (34 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County goalkeeper Jacob Widell Zetterstrom appeared to be Sweden’s number one at the World Cup but has now been usurped in the pecking order by Stoke City’s Viktor Johansson.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (26 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Mark Robins and his team will have a number of contract decisions as players head into the final few months of deals.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (32 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County are already turning their attention to what could be a difficult clash with Championship promotion chasers Southampton and could potentially welcome back a number of players.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (30 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Team news from the away camp as Stoke City prepare to host a Birmingham side that is level on points at the top of the Championship.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (22 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
DerbyshireLive is launching a latest Premium newsletter for Rams fans to get all the latest from Pride Park.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (15 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Tony Mowbray is stepping back from his job at Blackburn Rovers.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (649 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Out-of-work managers often take the time out of the spotlight to evolve their coaching game, and this was no different for newly introduced Sheffield Wednesday boss Dave Challinor. Between leaving Stockport County and taking the SWFC job, the 51-year-old has revealed Celtic’s Martin O’Neill and Brentford boss Keith Andrews’ influences.
In an interview with The Star, Challinor revealed he had dinner with O’Neill, alongside watching his Celtic side train and play. On O’Neill, the Owls boss said: “He is a really inspirational character. He is a figurehead for that football club. The success he’s had at such a massive place is enormous.”.
Challinor then toured Brentford’s training ground and took inspiration from how the Bees prepare for set pieces.
According to recent reports, “Brentford, I suppose for any club in England, or across the world, really, just the way they go about it and the way they’ve done it from the very, very top, is unbelievable,” he stated. “They are an inspiration not just to me as a manager, but I’d suggest football clubs the length and breadth of the country.”.
Industry observers note that challinor has plenty of experience in the dugout, but for someone who has followed his trajectory, there is always more to learn. He has journeyed through the football pyramid from Colwyn Bay to Sheffield Wednesday in 16 years, so he can take valuable lessons from those who have pedigree at a higher level.
In terms of his managerial abilities as an individual, Challinor will have taken plenty from O’Neill at Celtic. The 74-year-old progressed through lower leagues like the Sheffield Wednesday boss before managing big clubs in top leagues, such as Leicester City, Celtic and Aston Villa.
The sheer amount of knowledge and experience O’Neill has gained over the years means he will have had some valuable nuggets of advice to pass down to Challinor.
It has been revealed that as for Brentford, touring their training ground would have been more of a lesson in full club management, and what can help traditionally ‘smaller’ clubs compete with the elite. The Bees are not the wealthiest club by any means, but they are sustainably run from the top to the bottom, and meticulous training sessions and match preparation means they are now in their sixth season as a Premier League side.
Challinor will have taken valuable lessons from these trips, and it will only benefit SWFC.
It has been revealed that david Storch has expressed that Sheffield Wednesday are just at the start of a long-term rebuild. Challinor was not appointed with immediate success in mind, he was brought in to lead a newly introduced era at Hillsborough.
In a recent development, some of the Hillsborough faithful will expect a strong push for promotion from League One this season, and justifiably so. Despite Storch stating the need for patience, the squad is strong enough to emerge as a strong contender at the top end of an evenly matched third tier.
It has been revealed that challinor’s willingness to learn and take inspiration from other managers and model clubs is an excellent attribute. Despite the success he has found in the dugout already, his desire to grow as a boss is only a good thing for SWFC as they rebuild under his leadership.
Tomorrow’s Player Challenge and the latest Sheffield Wednesday news in your inbox every morning.
Sources indicate that enjoyed that? Add us to your Google sources.
See more EFL transfer news and match reaction from The72, first, in Google Search.
The72 is an independent news source dedicated to England's second, third and fourth tiers — every one of the 72 clubs across the Championship, League One and League Two, covered with the same care the Premier League gets everywhere else.
Whether your club is chasing promotion or fighting to stay up, we're covering it.
The day's EFL news, every morning.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (32 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County took on Premier League side Everton at Hill Dickinson Stadium on Thursday with John Eustace seeing a number of his injured players stepping up their recovery.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (26 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Robert Bozenik is hoping to hold onto his starting shirt as Stoke City take on Birmingham at the top of the Championship.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (38 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County have had a rotten season on paper with the Rams firmly in the battle to avoid dropping out of the Championship but there could be a silver lining for boss John Eustace.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (307 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

AC Milan have been considering a move for Massire Sylla recently and the Senegalese defender’s stock is only rising at the moment.
There are plenty of defensive options for Milan in the winter mercato. Goncalo Inacio is probably the preference for most, but the profile of Sylla cannot be ignored. Another signing for the future, he’s similar in many ways to Sankhoun Diawara, and the Frenchman has already started to have an impact.
Industry observers note that read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
Gazzetta dello Sport have looked a little at his background and his profile. A physical defender, he has previously admitted that he’s a lover of ‘the fight’; a player who loves duels and wins them a lot of the time.
Called up to the Senegalese national team this month, his story is one of patience, tenacity and the ability to persist when faced with obstacles. His career started at Diambars Academy, one of the most notorious in Senegal, starting as a midfielder but eventually moving back to defence.
Industry observers note that his coaches wanted him to learn to play with his feet, but his defensive qualities shone, hence the move back. With that, though, he started to see the ball more and both aspects of his game improved substantially.
From there, he joined Pau in 2024 and within six months, he was playing for the senior team in Ligue 2. At 19, he moved to Lyn and then Union Saint-Gilloise paid €2 million for him last January.
It wasn’t an immediate fit, though, and he was called overexcited, thanks to his yellow card record. Yet, he’s settled and now is a key figure in a three-man defence and picking out his best traits are difficult because there are so many.
📅 25 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 10 min read (2091 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Manchester City have been found guilty of 114 of the 115 charges brought by the Premier League over breaches of its financial rules. It is a decision that, if upheld, would equate to one of the biggest scandals in football history.
City face a range of sanctions from a fine to points deductions and even expulsion from the Premier League. Or a combination of all, under rule W51 of its handbook. No punishment has yet been announced.
If the verdict is upheld, with City expected to appeal, it will also raise question marks over the 20 trophies the club have won under Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, whose Abu Dhabi group took over in 2008.
The charges can be broken down into five categories and relate to a period from 2009-23 in which City won six League Cups, three FA Cups, seven league titles and the Champions League. There is the provision for removing past titles, but that would appear remote.
City have been the dominant force in English football for most of that time, but that status is under threat with a verdict that will send shockwaves around Europe and could have huge ramifications for the club.
That is unless they can win an appeal, with sources cautioning it still may take up to another two to three years for the case to be resolved, following on from an already five-year investigation.
The Premier League’s rules provide for an independent appeal board with broad powers, including the ability to uphold, vary or overturn the independent commission’s decision.
Industry observers note that it would therefore appear that despite the verdict, the case is far from being resolved and punishment decided. The details of the commission’s findings, when published, will be crucial to determining what happens next.
But if it is upheld, the verdict also opens up the possibility of City facing legal action from other clubs who feel they missed out on trophies and even merit money from league placings.
It is understood Premier League clubs are already discussing legal action and possible compensation claims as a result of the guilty verdict.
Each of those cases would have to be held individually, potentially leading to years more of litigation. Conversely, if City win their appeal, they too could take legal action against the Premier League the damage caused to their reputation.
Sources indicate that there has not yet been an official confirmation of the independent panel’s verdict from the Premier League. The Premier League declined to comment.
However, several sources have told Telegraph Sport that the panel has found City guilty of all but one of the charges they faced. The one that has not been proved is noted to be one of the most serious of the 115.
The damning verdict for City is a major new test of fragile UK relations with the United Arab Emirates, with whom bilateral trade was worth £25bn last year. Redacted freedom of information documents, seen by Telegraph Sport, show Abu Dhabi hosted UK government officials including Lord Stockwood, then investment minister, as recently as February. Khaldoon Al Mubarak, the City chairman and trusted adviser to the UAE president, was present at the meeting. Government notes from the meeting recorded that he “noted they are very proud of what they have achieved through their investments in Manchester”.
The Government previously caused acrimony among senior leaders in Abu Dhabi after putting forward legislation to ban foreign states from owning UK newspapers and news magazines. The intervention prompted the collapse of a takeover of The Telegraph in April 2024, which was largely funded by Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, the owner of City and vice-president and deputy prime minister of the United Arab Emirates.
Sources indicate that the previous UK government has admitted its embassy in Abu Dhabi and the Foreign Commonwealth & Development Office (FCDO) in London discussed the charges levelled at City by the Premier League. However it refused to disclose the correspondence.
According to recent reports, city have steadfastly maintained they are innocent, promising “irrefutable” evidence in support of their position, and had assembled some of the most expensive lawyers in the country to argue their case. Despite the verdict, the club are understood to be confident that it will win the argument in the end. Senior figures are said to be calm about the latest development, as significant as it seems.
Industry observers note that city rebuilt their team this summer and it is understood that signings were brought in on conventional player contracts, rather than terms including clauses triggered in the event of a heavy punishment. Given the club have consistently denied breaching financial regulations, and their deals for new players to work with head coach Enzo Maresca underlines their position.
On Friday, a City spokesman noted: “The Premier League process remains ongoing, with significant elements to be completed, and subject to strict confidentiality. As such, Manchester City FC’s position remains consistent with the club’s statement of February 2023.
“The club have diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis that the Premier League board and executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair-minded regulator, free from partisan influence.”.
Sources close to Pep Guardiola, the former City manager who stepped down last summer after 10 years of remarkable success at the club, including a treble triumph in 2023 and an unprecedented fourth straight league title in 2024, insist he has not been informed of any verdict.
In the days after City were first charged, Guardiola mounted a fierce defence of the club, claiming: “I am fully convinced we will be [proved] innocent.”.
The verdict vindicates the Premier League’s decision to launch an investigation after explosive allegations that City had routinely broken financial rules were first made in Der Spiegel in 2018 based on the Football Leaks documents.
Uefa previously accused City of breaches of its financial regulations and confirmed in 2020 that it was suspending the club from the Champions League for two years for “overstating” sponsorship revenue between 2012 and 2016.
Sources indicate that city denied the Uefa charges and, after an appeal to the Court of Arbitration for Sport, the two-year ban was overturned. Cas found that a number of the claims brought by Uefa had fallen outside a five-year “time bar” and others were “not established”.
Recent findings suggest that it did, however, still impose a €10m fine after ruling that City failed to cooperate with investigators. City had previously also agreed a settlement with Uefa of €20m in 2014 following an investigation into their finances.
Sources indicate that legal experts agreed that the commission’s verdict is far from the end of the case. Yasin Patel, barrister at Church Court Chambers, mentioned: “City’s lawyers will now analyse this decision and look at the options open to them to appeal, which may include procedural impropriety, wrongful interpretation of law, and legal errors – importantly, they can guarantee an appeal.
“Sanctions could include a major fine, points deduction, relegation or even all three. Factoring in whether titles and trophies should be stripped, whether other clubs have been robbed of further revenue and opportunities due to City’s wrongdoings and losses incurred, we safely say that this is only the first chapter of a long-running legal saga that will not end any time soon.”.
In a recent development, ian Hargreaves, partner with specialist disputes firm Quillon Law, said the verdict was “not the end of the story but the beginning of a new phase”, and added: “There is also the question of whether the panel’s decision can withstand a hard-fought appeal, and on what grounds any challenge might be brought. Much will depend on the detail of the panel’s findings and reasoning, which will inevitably be closely scrutinised by both sides.”.
Former Manchester City midfielder Rodri, who won the Ballon d’Or during his trophy-laden spell at the club, mentioned he believed the club were innocent.
Industry observers note that “For the players, it’s different than it is for journalists. I can understand all opinions, but we try to stay positive,” the Spain midfielder said while on international duty.
“When you see all the people who worked hard at City to achieve success, you know what we achieved can’t be taken away. It wasn’t paid for with money, but with effort and teamwork. Everything we achieved was deserved; we marked one of the great eras of English football. I believe in the club’s innocence – we already went through this in 2020.”.
Andy Burnham, the Prime Minister, remarked: “I think we would all need to study the independent commission’s report in some considerable detail before reaching any conclusions.”.
Zohran Kwame Mamdani, the mayor of Newly introduced York, posted “114” in relation to the charges while former Manchester United players David de Gea and Rio Ferdinand both asked whether they should be due winner’s medals from past seasons.
The Premier League statement in February 2023 said that “a number of alleged breaches” had been referred to an independent commission. It then detailed each specific rule against each season in which the alleged breach took place. The precise number was not clear from the statement and led to varying reports between 115 and 130. Friday’s news suggested the figure was 115.
All the way to 2009-10, the first full season following the club’s takeover by Sheikh Mansour, who is a member of the Abu Dhabi Royal family and the vice president of the United Arab Emirates. There were charges relating to all 14 seasons until the Premier League completed their investigation during the 2022-23 campaign. In that time, City won seven Premier League titles, six League Cups, three FA Cups and the Champions League. They have since won another league title – the first club to do so four times in a row – as well as the Uefa Super Cup, the Fifa Club World Cup and the FA Cup and League Cup double last season.
They can be split into five groups. The biggest relates to the seasons from 2009-10 until 2017-18 and the requirement for clubs to provide accurate financial information and act in the utmost good faith.
It has been revealed that the next set of rules concern the full disclosure of manager and player payments. The alleged manager breaches related to the period between 2009-10 and 2012-13, when Roberto Mancini was leading the team. The alleged breaches with respect to player payments relate to all of the seasons between 2010-11 and 2015-16.
Industry observers note that as well as providing financial detail, clubs were required to meet Uefa and Premier League rules which were designed to bring a club’s spending broadly in line with their income by placing set limits on losses. City were charged with breaches of Uefa’s licencing and financial fair play rules from 2013-14 until 2017-18, and the Premier League’s profit and sustainability rules from 2015-16 until 2017-18.
The final set of charges spanned the five seasons during which City were being investigated by the Premier League and rules that require members to cooperate in the utmost good faith by providing information and documents.
It has been revealed that A full picture will only emerge when the commission publishes its findings but we know that the Premier League investigation began in December 2018 following allegations in the German newspaper Der Spiegel based on the Football Leaks documents. These included alleged payments to former manager Mancini for consultancy work at an Abu Dhabi-based club that was separate to his regular contract at City.
In a recent development, we also know that City were alleged to have breached rules over setting out image rights payments to players in their club contract. Der Spiegel reported that the Premier League investigation also focused on payments to under-age players, as well as whether club sponsors were paying for commercial deals themselves or a significant proportion was in fact effectively coming from owner Sheikh Mansour.
In a recent development, city have always denied breaking any rules. In response to the Premier League statement about the alleged breaches, they stated that they have “irrefutable evidence” to support their position and “look forward to this matter being put to rest once and for all.”.
At the start of the hearing in September 2024, Guardiola also remarked: “Wait for the independent panel. We believe we have not done anything wrong.”.
Of the Football Leaks documents, City remarked: “We will not be providing any comment on out-of-context materials. The attempt to damage the club’s reputation is organised and clear.”.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (28 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Vitor Matos has transformed the Swansea City side into promotion candidates over the last 12 months and losing him could be a major blow.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (23 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Prime Minister Andy Burnham says scrapping the Saturday 3pm football blackout requires careful thought given the potential financial implications.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 4 min read (786 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

By OLIVER HOLT, CHIEF SPORTS WRITER and CRAIG HOPE, CHIEF FOOTBALL REPORTER.
Published: 16:03 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 16:48 EST, 14 November 2026.
Thomas Tuchel was dragged into a bitter race row on the eve of England's Nations League showdown with Spain.
Tuchel had been asked before England's departure for Spain about England's protocols in case their players suffered racist abuse at the Metropolitano Stadium on Sunday evening.
England players were notoriously subject to racial abuse at the Bernabeu in 2004 and England have not played in Madrid since.
But Spain manager Luis de la Fuente reacted angrily when he was told that Tuchel had addressed the subject.
Sources indicate that 'Tell Tuchel that there is no racism in Spain,' de la Fuente noted. 'Just like in England. We are not racist.'.
The row then deepened when a Spanish journalist told Tuchel about De La Fuente's reaction and the England coach grew exasperated with the line of questioning.
Tuchel had been asked before England's departure for Spain about England's protocols.
'Tell Tuchel that there is no racism in Spain,' de la Fuente said. 'Just like in England. We are not racist.'.
'I was polite enough to answer a question from your colleagues,' Tuchel mentioned, 'and you run and ask Spain's coach and tell them that I talked about racism in Spain.
According to recent reports, 'I never talked about racism in Spain. I answered a question politely. I never expect racism. The dressing room is the most anti-racist place in the world. This is a perfect example of how you create confusion out of nothing.'.
Industry observers note that tuchel had earlier said: 'It's important that the players know about the protocol. And then, yeah, we will give our answers if stuff like this happens. Best answers are on the pitch.
According to recent reports, 'We had a same discussion before the Serbia game [in Belgrade in September 2025]. There is a protocol in place.'.
England midfielder Declan Rice said that Tuchel had not yet addressed the group about racism protocols but that they were clear about what they would do if any England players were abused.
England's game against Bulgaria in Sofia in 2019 was halted after allegations of racism against England players but the game was completed.
Thomas Tuchel has revealed that James Trafford will face world champions Spain on Sunday night, raising questions over Jordan Pickford’s status as England’s No 1.
It was assumed that Pickford, who the head coach maintains is his first choice, would keep the jersey given the identity of the opposition and the chance for England to top their Nations League group with victory here in Madrid.
However, Tuchel will hand Leeds stopper Trafford his fifth cap at the Metropolitano Stadium.
’We want to try and see how far Traff is,’ said Tuchel, who rotated his keepers during last month’s international break. ‘So he gets a highly competitive match. We had some changes in the back four in the last match (2-1 win over Croatia on Thursday), so we went for more stability and more experience with Pickers.
It has been revealed that ‘Tomorrow is a high-pressure match, on the biggest stage, and it's exactly what we need to see where we are with him (Trafford). Hopefully he's not too over-excited or overly nervous, because there's no need to be. We trust him. But it is different to play for England than to play for your club.
'To have the opportunity to play matches where it really matters is the best way to show up, and to show that you're ready.’.
It was put to Tuchel that it would make more sense to play the goalkeeper he believes is his No 1 in the biggest game from this round of fixtures.
’It was the circumstances of the last match, that we had some changes in the back four, and that was the decision in the goalkeeping team,’ he said. 'Jordan is at the moment our No.1. I have a very clear picture in high-pressure moments. He played in tournaments and played for me in the World Cup.’.
Meanwhile, centre back Ezri Konsa is also set to start after recovering from a knee concern.
‘I’m very pleased with how he has fitted in seamlessly at Arsenal,’ said Tuchel. ‘It just looks like he's always been there. For us, it’s amazing that he plays on the highest level, competes for every title, is in an atmosphere and in a situation where it really matters that you stay focused and you show up every three days. It's only positives for us.’.
PROBABLE ENGLAND XI: Trafford; White, Quansah, Konsa, Hall; Anderson, Rice; Rogers, Jude Bellingham, Gordon; Kane.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 123 min read (24614 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Nature

Breast cancer, the most diagnosed cancer among women, is stratified by gene expression patterns into luminal and basal-like subtypes, and the latter is associated with worse prognosis1,2,3. Recent advances in single-cell technologies have underscored the presence of intratumour heterogeneity, which poses substantial challenges in cancer treatment and achieving long-term disease-free survival4,5,6,7. Here we extensively profile epigenetic heterogeneity in a cohort of treatment-naive human luminal tumours, which were obtained directly after surgical resection. By applying a single-cell epigenetic approach based on cytometry by time-of-flight, we identify a recurrent subpopulation of basal-like cells in luminal tumours with a conserved epigenetic signature across patients. These basal-like cells, also identified by deconvolution of whole-genome DNA methylation patterns, are characterized by high expression of aggressive oncogenic traits and downregulation of hormone receptor signalling. Direct comparison of single-cell proteomic and genomic profiling of monomethylation and trimethylation of histone 3 on lysine 4 revealed that these marks are key features associated with loss of luminal identity. Finally, we highlight the potential of concomitant single-molecule profiling of histone modifications on cell-free nucleosomes in blood as an epigenetic liquid biopsy approach for early diagnosis of breast cancer. Moreover, the epigenetic basal signature measured in blood is linked to prognosis, which enables the identification of patients at increased risk for disease relapse.
Industry observers note that gene expression profiles classify breast cancers into luminal A or luminal B (hormone-receptor-positive (HR+)), HER2-positive and basal-like subtypes. Among these, basal-like subtypes largely overlap with triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC)2,3. These classifications guide treatment management and prognosis. Luminal HR+ breast cancer generally responds to endocrine therapy with favourable outcomes, yet many patients relapse8. Single-cell and spatial studies have revealed substantial intratumoural heterogeneity among subtypes, which potentially drive treatment resistance and recurrence4,5,6,7,9.
According to recent reports, chromatin organization, mediated by DNA and histone post-translational modifications (PTMs), facilitates the acquisition of epigenetically distinct cellular states in genetically identical cells10,11,12. Although single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) and single-cell chromatin-accessibility sequencing (scATAC–seq) delineate intratumour heterogeneity13,14,15,16, the contribution of chromatin patterns remains unclear17. Single-cell profiling of histone marks, such as trimethylation of histone 3 on lysine 27 (H3K27me3), implicates chromatin states in breast tumour heterogeneity and treatment resistance18,19. However, these methods measure a limited number of chromatin marks, which hinders analyses of complex patterns and interactions. We developed a cytometry by time-of-flight (CyTOF) method to systematically profile multiple histone PTMs and decode population-specific chromatin patterns to examine heterogeneity among cancer cells20,21,22,23.
Tumour epigenetic states are also reflected in blood. Cell-free, plasma-circulating nucleosomes, released mainly by dying normal and cancer cells, retain tissue-of-origin epigenetic patterns24,25,26,27. Our single-molecule imaging platform, epigenetics of plasma isolated nucleosomes (EPINUC), captures multiple epigenetic features on plasma nucleosomes28. This method detects colorectal cancer, including low-burden early-stage disease28, and enables minimally invasive molecular profiling and treatment monitoring of paediatric brain tumours29.
Here we present a holistic epigenetic analysis of primary treatment-naive breast tumours and blood cell-free nucleosomes. Linking recurrent intratumoural epigenetic patterns to circulating nucleosomes connects tumour epigenetic heterogeneity with its potential clinical implications. This work reveals epigenetic alterations as key mediators of intratumour heterogeneity and potential biomarkers for early diagnosis and prognosis.
It has been revealed that to assess heterogeneity in breast tumour histone modifications, we performed epigenetic focused CyTOF on fresh, surgically resected tumours from treatment-naive women and quantified histone modifications at single-cell resolution (Fig. 1a and Supplementary Table 1). The cohort included mainly luminal HR+ tumours and only one basal triple-negative (TN, HR–) tumour (n = 12; Supplementary Table 2 and Supplementary Fig. 1a,b), as standard neoadjuvant therapy excluded most TN cases from treatment-naive eligibility. Following batch correction and normalization, uniform manifold approximation and projection (UMAP) analysis of all 12 tumours revealed that tumour cells largely occupied patient-specific regions, whereas stromal cells clustered together across patients. This result aligns with previous studies that measured single-cell genomic differences13,14 (Fig. 1b, Methods and Supplementary Fig. 2a). Partial overlap among luminal tumour cells from different patients probably reflects shared lineage-specific epigenetic programs. As expected, stromal cells expressed vimentin and αSMA, whereas tumour cells expressed the epithelial keratins, EpCAM and E-cadherin (Fig. 1b,c and Supplementary Fig. 2b,c). Notably, the basal TN tumour differed from HR+ tumours, showing low expression of the luminal marker GATA3 and high expression of the basal marker cytokeratin-5 (K5; also known as KRT5) and mesenchymal vimentin markers (Fig. 1b,c and Supplementary Fig. 2d). Stromal and tumour chromatin patterns also differed, a result that underscores their role in dictating cellular identity (Fig. 1d and Supplementary Fig. 2e). CyTOF analysis of MCF7 (luminal) and four basal-like TN cell lines validated that GATA3 and K5 expression patterns can differentiate luminal and basal-like identities. Moreover, SHAP analysis30,31 identified these two markers as the strongest discriminators of tumour type (Fig. 1e,f). Using multiple cell-identity markers, we derived a PermCell luminal signature (Methods) that accurately distinguished the identities of the cell lines (Fig. 1g).
a, Schematic of the experiment. Tumours were dissociated, depleted of CD45+ immune cells, stained with metal-conjugated antibodies and analysed by CyTOF (Supplementary Table 1). Ac, acetylation; Me, Methylation; Ub, Ubiquitination. b, UMAP of the CyTOF dataset (1,157,765 cells, n = 12 tumours, mean of 96,480 cells per tumour; Supplementary Table 3). Shown are around 1,000 cells per sample (one replicate per tumour), coloured by sample (left) or marker intensity (right). Dashed outlines indicate HR+, TN and stromal cell regions. c,d, Heatmaps of mean marker levels in stroma, TN tumour (n = 1) and luminal tumours (n = 11); rows are standardized and clustered. e, UMAP of breast cancer cell lines. Shown are 5,000 cells per line, coloured by line (left) or marker intensity (right). f, XGBoost classifier segregating luminal and basal-like cell lines using all cell identity markers (Supplementary Table 1). SHAP scores indicate feature importance. g, UMAP as in e, coloured by a luminal signature score derived from the indicated markers (bottom). Asterisk indicates markers absent from the cell-line panel. h, UMAP of cells from tumour 5 (representative of n = 11) following DBSCAN clustering and noise (unclassified cells) removal, coloured by subpopulation, marker intensity and luminal signature. i, Heatmap of mean marker levels per subpopulation in h, row-standardized as z-scores. Rows and columns are clustered. j, UMAP of two luminal PDX models, coloured as in h. For PDX-1, six tumours were sampled equally to match PDX-2 cell numbers. k,l, Mean CyTOF Ki-67 levels versus the percentage of Ki-67+ cells by IHC (k) or cycling cells by epigenetic signature (l, n = 11). Data show linear fit (lines), 95% confidence intervals (CI, grey), Pearson’s r and two-sided P values. Tumour 20 showed outlier CyTOF Ki-67 levels and was excluded. m,n, UMAP and DBSCAN clustering of MCF7 parental cells (m) and a single-cell-derived clone (n, clone 5, using only epigenetic features, coloured as in h.Results were reproduced in seven independent MCF7 CyTOF experiments and three independently derived clones (Extended Data Fig. 2). Schematic in a created in BioRender; Furth, N. https://biorender.com/twf1psb (2026).
It has been revealed that we next examined intratumour heterogeneity, focusing on the cancer cells of each luminal breast tumour separately. UMAP clustering and density-based spatial clustering of applications with noise (DBSCAN) across all features revealed three subpopulations in each tumour, which we termed cycling, luminal and basal-like (Fig. 1h,i and Extended Data Fig. 1a,b). These subpopulations were also conserved in two different luminal patient-derived xenograft (PDX) models. This finding validates the observed heterogeneity as an inherent feature of luminal breast tumours and excludes contamination of normal cells (Fig. 1j and Extended Data Fig. 1c). MCF7 cells indicated similar luminal and basal-like heterogeneity, although most cells were cycling, as expected for a cell line (Extended Data Fig. 1d). In tumours, only a luminal subset cycled and expressed high levels of Ki-67, a result consistent with previous immunohistochemistry (IHC) and scRNA-seq studies14,32. CyTOF Ki-67 levels correlated with pathology estimates (Fig. 1k). Cycling cells also showed high levels of multiple chromatin modifications, both in raw measurements and following normalization to core histones (Fig. 1i, Extended Data Fig. 1a–c and Supplementary Fig. 3). We validated this result by repeating CyTOF analyses of two tumours (14 and 18), adding the established cell cycle marker phospho-Rb (pRb). pRb-positive cells showed an increase in core histones, as expected from cycling cells, and a larger increase in histone PTMs (Supplementary Fig. 3). Accordingly, the epigenetically inferred cycling fraction strongly correlated with Ki-67 levels (Fig. 1l).
Most cancer cells strongly expressed GATA3 and scored highly for the luminal signature, consistent with clinical classification (Fig. 1h, Extended Data Fig. 1a,b and Supplementary Fig. 4a). Moreover, in each tumour, the PDX samples and the MCF7 cells, we identified a minor recurrent subpopulation that acquired basal-like identity, with high K5 expression and a reduced luminal signature (Fig. 1h–j, Extended Data Fig. 1 and Supplementary Fig. 4a). This phenotypic diversity is consistent with previous single-cell studies of human and mouse breast tumours14,21,33,34. Notably, luminal and basal-like cells also had distinct histone PTM signatures (Fig. 1h–j and Extended Data Fig. 1). Accordingly, UMAP plots based solely on histone modifications revealed separation of the subpopulations, which validated the epigenetic basis of this phenotypic diversity (Supplementary Fig. 4b). In MCF7 cells, epigenetic UMAP and clustering similarly identified several clusters, including a K5hi basal-like population (Fig. 1m). These basal-like cells with reduced luminal signalling appeared closer in UMAP space to the TN cell lines, which provided further support for their basal-like identity (Supplementary Fig. 4c). Independent CyTOF experiments, additional MCF7 parental cell culture and populations derived from independent single-cell clones revealed similar subpopulation patterns, a result that argues against a genetic basis for these effects (Fig. 1n and Extended Data Fig. 2a–c). Moreover, individual PDX tumours derived from the same donor and grown independently in different mice showed similar subpopulation proportions, which provides support for a dynamic and plastic relationship between cell states (Extended Data Fig. 2d). Overall, our data revealed inherent intratumour heterogeneity in luminal tumours, with epigenetic variability between distinct subpopulations.
Recent findings suggest that we further explored the characteristics of the cycling, luminal and basal-like subpopulations. Unsupervised clustering grouped corresponding subpopulations across patients, which confirmed their robustness and similarity (Fig. 2a). Across tumours, luminal cells expressed oestrogen receptor (ER), GATA3 and cytokeratin-8 and cytokeratin-18 (K8/18; also known as KRT8 and KRT18, respectively), whereas basal-like cells downregulated these luminal markers and highly expressed K5 (Fig. 2b). As these subpopulations also exhibited distinct and conserved chromatin patterns, we applied a machine-learning algorithm to predict intratumour classification35. In each tumour, a model trained on a random subset predicted the remaining cells with 94% accuracy, which confirmed the robust differences between subpopulations (Fig. 2c and Extended Data Fig. 3a). It also assigned 78% of unclustered ‘noise’ cells with >95% confidence, generating classifications that aligned with the original clustering and UMAP positions (Extended Data Fig. 3b). SHAP analysis identified the features driving each subpopulation. In detail, histone PTMs, particularly the four acetylation marks, were leading predictors of cycling cells despite overlap of individual marks with basal-like cells (Extended Data Fig. 3c,d). Polycomb-associated H3K27me3 and H2Aub also contributed to the features, a finding consistent with previously observed Polycomb deregulation and pro-proliferative activity in breast cancer36,37,38.
a, The three subpopulations from each HR+ tumour (n = 14, including 3 anchor repeats; Supplementary Table 3) clustered by CyTOF features. The dendrogram shows recurrent patterns across patients. b, Heatmap of mean cell identity marker differences between basal-like and luminal subpopulations (n = 14, as in a). c, Confusion matrix of XGBoost predictions of subpopulations (HR+ tumours, n = 14). Rows are normalized per true class, with 94% accuracy. d, SHAP scores for feature contribution to basal-like versus luminal classification, ranked in descending order. XGBoost accuracy = 92%. e, Heatmap as in b of the top discriminating histone PTMs shown in d; rows are clustered. f, UMAP plots of tumours 4 and 5, luminal PDX models (n = 2) and MCF7 cells, coloured by the basal-like epigenetic signature (Extended Data Fig. 4a). The dashed line indicates the basal-like population. g, Percentage of basal-like cells in HR+ tumours stratified by luminal A (n = 7) or luminal B (n = 4) subtype. Boxes: median and 25–75th percentiles; whiskers indicate 1.5× interquartile range (IQR); and points are individual tumours. Two-sided Wilcoxon rank-sum test. h, Percentage of basal-like cells versus tumour mutational burden (n = 11). Data show the linear fit (line), 95% CI (grey shading), Spearman’s ρ and two-sided P value. i, Levels of luminal identity markers in K5hi and K5low cells from tumour 19. Dots indicate protein intensity (log2) in technical repeats of 200 sorted cells (6–7 wells per population). Two-sided Welch’s t-test, with no adjustment for multiple comparisons. j, Volcano plot of protein expression differences between K5hi and K5low cells, as in i. Axes show protein intensity difference and –log10[P]. P values (two-sided Student’s t-tests) were corrected by false-discovery rate (FDR). Green and pink depict proteins significantly deregulated (fold change > 1.5, q < 0.05). Labelled proteins have fold change >2 and correspond to enriched terms in k. k,l, Functional enrichment of proteins significantly upregulated defined in j. k, MSigDB hallmark terms. l, Mammary epithelial cell (MEC) lineages50 (Supplementary Table 4a). Terms with nominal P < 0.05 are shown (one-sided hypergeometric test). Dot size indicates overlapping proteins, colour –log10[P]. m, CD74 protein expression as in i. n–o, MCF7 cells were sorted by CD74 levels and assayed for Transwell migration towards FBS and EGF (n) or wound healing (o), using n = 3 independently recovered sorted populations from the same experiment. For o, the gap area was quantified relative to day 0. Data are the mean ± s.e.m.; dots indicate replicates. Two-sided Welch’s t-test, Holm-corrected.
Luminal and basal-like separation was similarly epigenetic driven, with H4K20me3, H3K36me3 and H3K9me2 marks having the highest SHAP scores (Fig. 2d). Across tumours, basal-like cells consistently had increased H3K9me2 and H3K4 monomethylation and trimethylation, whereas luminal cells had enhanced H4K20me3, H3K36me3, H3K9me3 and H3K27me3 marks (Fig. 2e). These results align with subtype-associated histone PTM signatures39 and reported roles for H3K4 demethylases, such as JARID1B, in luminal–basal transitions40. Both luminal and basal-like cells highlighted similar pRb distribution, which provide support for the conclusion that these results reflect distinct cell states rather than cell cycle differences (Extended Data Fig. 3e). Similar epigenetic signatures distinguished luminal and basal-like populations in PDX models (Extended Data Fig. 3f). Accordingly, epigenetic-only basal-like PermCell scores accurately captured basal-like cells in tumours, PDXs and MCF7 cells (Fig. 2f and Extended Data Fig. 4). Overall, our computational framework confirms that there is recurrent epigenetic heterogeneity in HR+ breast tumours and highlight chromatin patterns associated with basal-like K5hi cells.
Recent findings suggest that consistent with the CyTOF results, tumours with higher fractions of epigenetically defined basal-like cells had fewer ER-positive and progesterone receptor (PR)-positive cells, as measured by IHC (Extended Data Fig. 5a,b and Supplementary Table 2). Basal-like cells were also more abundant in worse-prognosis luminal B than luminal A tumours. This result is in agreement with studies showing that these tumours exhibit features shared with the basal-like subtype3,41,42,43 (Fig. 2g). Although tumour mutational burden was low across the cohort, it correlated positively with the CyTOF-defined basal-like fraction, which parallels the greater genomic instability typically associated with TNBC44,45 (Fig. 2h and Supplementary Table 2). TP53 mutant tumours likewise contained more basal-like cells (Extended Data Fig. 5c), a finding reminiscent of single-cell studies of glioblastoma showing that genetic mutations may affect balance between cellular states46. Overall, these associations between pathological and molecular characteristics link the epigenetically distinct basal-like subpopulation to a more aggressive disease phenotype.
In a recent development, to characterize these cells functionally, we performed FACS to sort cells from tumour 19 and then low-input mass spectrometry. After excluding stroma through pan-cytokeratin staining, cells were sorted according to K5 levels to enrich for basal-like cells compared with the luminal population. K5low cells highly expressed luminal markers and proteins associated with oestrogen signalling, whereas basal-like K5hi cells expressed proteins involved in oncogenic pathways, such as MYC–mTOR signalling (Fig. 2i–k). Moreover, multiple chromatin regulators differed between these subpopulations, including the H3K4me1 methyltransferase SETD7 and histone demethylase KDM4A, consistent with the histone PTM differences observed by CyTOF47,48 (Extended Data Fig. 5d). KDM4A, enriched in K5hi cells, targets H3K9me3 and H3K36me3, which potentially accounts for their reduced levels and H3K9me2 accumulation in the basal-like population49. Comparisons with a normal mammary single-cell atlas50 revealed hormone-sensing programs in K5low cells and an alveolar progenitor signature in K5hi cells (Fig. 2l), a result consistent with their enrichment in luminal and basal TN tumours, respectively50.
Sources indicate that to gain a mechanistic understanding of these findings, we sorted MCF7 cells using K5-specific and GATA3-specific antibodies and performed transcriptomic profiling, comparing basal-like cells (K5hiGATA3low) to bulk MCF7 or extreme luminal cells (K5lowGATA3hi; Extended Data Fig. 5e,f). Notably, basal-like cells were enriched for epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition (EMT) genes (P < 0.05; Extended Data Fig. 5f). We then focused on differentially expressed cell surface markers to enable live sorting, which revealed that CD74 was significantly upregulated in basal-like cells in both MCF7 and tumour 19 proteomic analyses (Fig. 2m and Extended Data Fig. 5g). Live-sorted CD74hi cells exhibited increased migratory capacity in migration and wound-healing assays, which provided further support for the more aggressive phenotypes of basal-like cells (Fig. 2n,o and Extended Data Fig. 5h). Together, these single-cell and bulk proteomics and functional assays identify epigenetically distinct K5hi basal-like cells in luminal tumours associated with aggressive traits such as reduced luminal signalling, elevated oncogenic signalling and increased migratory potential.
Industry observers note that the distinct chromatin and phenotypic states of the basal-like subpopulation led us to explore whether intratumour epigenetic heterogeneity is also apparent in DNA methylation patterns. Thus, we conducted deep whole-genome bisulfite sequencing (WGBS) on three luminal tumours from our cohort. DNA methylation patterns accurately capture breast cancer subtyping, as shown by The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA)51. We next jointly deconvoluted the TCGA and our WGBS data into functional archetypes (V1–V3), with each tumour positioned in the deconvolution space. Stratifying the data into three archetypes revealed the expected separation of basal (TN) tumours from luminal (HR+), with archetype V3 associated with basal tumours (Extended Data Fig. 6a). Tumours 18, 19 and 23 from our cohort clustered with the luminal tumours, as expected from their bulk clinical subtyping. Correlation of the archetype contribution with RNA expression confirmed the association of V1 and V2 with luminal transcriptional programs, whereas V3 was associated with EMT, a result consistent with previous studies of TN tumours52,53,54 (Extended Data Fig. 6b and Supplementary Fig. 5a). To improve resolution, we added a fourth archetype (V4). This analysis revealed another layer of diversity: basal TN tumours were strongly associated with V3, which corresponded with reduced oestrogen signalling and increased oncogenic signalling, whereas luminal tumours were more heterogeneous and spread across the V1 axis (Fig. 3a,b and Supplementary Fig. 5b). Notably, V1 was strongly enriched for EMT, thereby potentially capturing an intermediate-transitional state between luminal and basal-like programs. Moreover, the percentage of CyTOF-measured, vimentin-positive cells, indicative of EMT, in tumours 18 and 19 differed accordingly (Fig. 3c and Supplementary Fig. 5c). Tumour 19, with a higher V1 contribution, also comprised more vimentin-positive cells, as assessed by CyTOF. These results support the use of WGBS deconvolution to capture functionally distinct cellular states in tumours, such as luminal cells undergoing EMT.
Sources indicate that a, TCGA BRCA DNA-methylation dataset (n = 782)51 deconvoluted into four archetypes, with UMAP of archetype composition per tumour coloured by PAM50 subtype (left) or archetype contribution (right). The three tumours (18, 19 and 23) analysed in this study are indicated and vary mainly along the V1 archetype. b, Genes ranked by correlation between DNA-methylation archetypes and matched TCGA BRCA expression data, followed by gene set enrichment analysis (GSEA) against the MSigDB hallmark collection. V1 differs from the luminal archetypes (V2 and V4) on the EMT axis. Representative normalized enrichment scores (NES) are shown. Black outline indicates Benjamini-Hochberg-adjusted P < 0.05. All terms provided in Supplementary Fig. 5b. c, Top, UMAP of CyTOF measurements (tumours 18 and 19, stroma excluded), coloured by vimentin expression, with vimentin-positive cells highlighted. Bottom, the vimentin-positive fraction per tumour. d, Top, scATAC–seq of luminal tumours (n = 9)13 analysed for WIP fraction58 and gene activity. Matrix reveals Pearson’s correlations between the WIP fraction and UCell scores per tumour. Bottom, UMAPs of cancer cells from patient 10-R, coloured by WIP fraction or the basal–luminal index (the difference between z-scored luminal and basal gene sets59; higher values indicate more basal-like expression). e, UMAP of H3K4me1 snCUT&Tag data (stroma removed). Cells are represented by a scTransform-normalized gene activity matrix reflecting H3K4me1-associated regulatory activity per gene, with the read count excluded. Louvain clustering and cell numbers per tumour are indicated. f, Differentially H3K4me1-marked genes per cluster in e (two-sided Wilcoxon signed-rank test, log2 fold change > 1, adjusted P < 0.01) were analysed for enrichment against MSigDB Hallmark and breast-related collections (Supplementary Table 4). Shown are terms enriched among genes with increased H3K4me1 in cluster 2 in at least two out of three tumours (one-sided hypergeometric test, FDR < 0.05). Circle sizes indicate overlapping genes; colour, –log10[FDR]. g,h, UMAPs of H3K4me1 (g) and H3K4me3 (h) snCUT&Tag data, analysed as in e and f and coloured by UCell scores for signatures comprising genes contributing to the respective enrichments (Gaussian-smoothed). For H3K4me3 enrichment, see Extended Data Fig. 8h. i, Pearson’s correlations between snCUT&Tag read number and UCell scores for the indicated gene signatures per tumour and histone mark. Gene signatures shown in d,f,i are derived from previously published studies (refs. 13,59,85,86,87,88).
To directly link the CyTOF-defined subpopulations with DNA methylation patterns, we sorted K5hi and K5low cells from tumour 5 and tumour 23, followed by enzyme-mediated methylation sequencing (EM-seq). Functional enrichment of differentially methylated promoters revealed hypermethylation of oestrogen-response programs in K5hi cells, whereas genes associated with aggressive and oncogenic features, including KRAS signalling and mesenchymal or basal-state transitions, were hypomethylated (Extended Data Fig. 6c,d). We next derived a CpG island (CGI) methylation signature to distinguish the two states using CGIs that were concordantly differentially methylated across both tumours. In TCGA breast cancer data, this signature scored higher in basal-like tumours, which indicated that the K5hi methylation program resembles basal-like tumours (Extended Data Fig. 6e). K5hi samples also demonstrated higher contribution to the basal-associated and EMT-associated archetypes than K5low samples, in both the three-archetype and four-archetype models (Extended Data Fig. 6f,g). Thus, the CyTOF-defined basal-like population exhibits basal-like and EMT-related methylation programs, which reveals another layer of intratumoural epigenetic heterogeneity.
It has been revealed that having identified distinct DNA methylation programs associated with tumour cell states, we next assessed cell-to-cell variability by clustering read-level methylation patterns across 100-bp genomic bins and calculating empirical entropy as an estimation of cell-type heterogeneity55. Genes near high-entropy bins were associated with functional terms related to poor differentiation, tumour aggressiveness and basal compared with luminal identity (Supplementary Fig. 6a). This result suggests that empirical entropy, by capturing diverse DNA methylation states, can be used as a proxy for cell-to-cell heterogeneity and reveal functional differences between subpopulations. We next calculated the mean entropy for each CGI (Extended Data Fig. 7a). As expected, most CGIs were unmethylated across all cells56, thus showing zero entropy. The variable CGIs (entropy > 0) were functionally enriched for EMT and the related Hedgehog signalling pathways, which indicated that these are differentially regulated in tumours57 (Extended Data Fig. 7b). This analysis suggests that intratumour variability in methylation patterns may be associated with cell identity transitions.
To further explore intratumour entropy and its relation to cell identity, we leveraged a published multiomic study of luminal breast cancer that included single-cell expression and chromatin accessibility measurements13. Focusing on cancer cells, we observed intratumour heterogeneity in luminal and basal-like expression patterns, as previously described14,54 (Supplementary Fig. 6b). Using the ATAC–seq modality, we calculated the within-peak (WIP) fraction, a metric of epigenetic noise58, whereby a low-WIP fraction may indicate a destabilized or noisier epigenome, which supports cell plasticity. For each tumour, we correlated the WIP fraction with chromatin accessibility of basal-like and luminal gene signatures. Cells that scored high for EMT and basal-like identity demonstrated lower WIP fraction, a finding reminiscent of the higher DNA methylation entropy associated with these signatures (Fig. 3d and Supplementary Fig. 6c). Single-cell multiome analysis of a freshly resected independent luminal tumour reproduced the basal–luminal continuum and association between basal identity and reduced WIP fraction (Supplementary Fig. 6d,e). To explore whether the increased epigenetic noise is associated with higher transcriptional heterogeneity, we divided cells into quartiles according to a published basal–luminal index59 and basal-like and luminal gene sets (Methods). Indeed, across all tumours, cells with a high basal identity showed higher transcriptional heterogeneity (Extended Data Fig. 7c). In line with these observations, the CyTOF-defined basal-like subpopulation also showed higher epigenetic heterogeneity (Extended Data Fig. 7d). Moreover, read-level methylation entropy was higher in K5hi-sorted compared with K5low-sorted populations in both tumours analysed by EM-seq, with higher variability among the K5hi 200-cell replicates (Supplementary Fig. 6f,g). Together, our analyses across DNA methylation, chromatin accessibility and histone PTMs indicate that the basal-like subpopulation exhibts a noisy epigenetic landscape and increased transcriptional heterogeneity.
Our CyTOF analysis highlighted a global increase in several histone PTMs in the basal-like subpopulation, including H3K4 monomethylation and trimethylation (Fig. 2e). To explore the genomic distribution of these marks, we conducted single-nucleus CUT&Tag (snCUT&Tag) on three luminal tumours from our cohort60. Similar to the CyTOF data (Fig. 1b), stroma cells clustered together across patients, showing H3K4me1 and H3K4me3 deposition on fibroblast and endothelial markers. By contrast, tumours clustered separately, which indicated inter-patient variability (Extended Data Fig. 8a–d).
In each tumour, malignant cells clustered into distinct H3K4me1-defined or H3K4me3-defined states (Fig. 3e and Extended Data Fig. 8e,f). Differential analysis of H3K4me1 distribution between clusters highlighted a recurrent group of cells across tumours, annotated as ‘cluster 2’, with significant H3K4me1 enrichment at genes associated with basal-like identity and EMT (Fig. 3f,g and Extended Data Fig. 8g,i). In tumour 15, cluster 1 was also enriched for basal-like genes (adjusted P < 0.05), but not EMT. H3K4me3 similarly identified basal-like subpopulations in all tumours (Fig. 3h and Extended Data Fig. 8h,i). Accordingly, peaks associated with these clusters indicated enrichment for transcription factor motifs linked to EMT and basal-like identity (Supplementary Fig. 7a). Next, we trained a classifier to identify H3K4me1-marked and H3K4me3-marked genes that contribute to variation between the clusters. For both histone methylations, these genes were enriched in terms related to breast cancer cellular identity, including oestrogen signalling, basal-like and mesenchymal identity (Supplementary Fig. 7b–e). Overall, our analysis provides support for chromatin-defined cell states in luminal tumour cells, including a basal-like state distinguished by H3K4me1 and H3K4me3 distributions.
Industry observers note that the above snCUT&Tag results aligned with the heterogeneity observed by CyTOF, which led us to compare the single-cell datasets and integrating both genomic and protein information. CyTOF-defined basal-like cells highlighted global increases in both H3K4 methylation marks. We reasoned that sequencing reads per nucleus may reflect global levels of the target modification. Single-cell epigenomic analyses generally assume similar global modification levels, discarding read-count information, as in our analysis above61 (Fig. 3e–h). Departing from this convention, we examined whether read counts capture additional aspects of epigenetic heterogeneity. Across all three tumours and both modifications, read counts negatively correlated with luminal identity signatures and positively with basal-like and mesenchymal signatures (Fig. 3i and Extended Data Fig. 9a,b). Consistently, cells with high read counts, potentially indicative of elevated global levels of H3K4me1 or H3K4me3, showed less enrichment of these active marks at luminal identity genes. Although requiring further validation, this direct comparison suggests that read counts may serve as proxy for global levels of histone modifications to capture additional aspects of epigenetic variation.
To further integrate these datasets, we label-transferred the CyTOF classification (Figs. 1 and 2) onto the H3K4me1 snCUT&Tag dataset. CyTOF-predicted basal-like populations were enriched in the basal-like clusters identified by H3K4me1 genomic profiling (Fig. 3e and Extended Data Fig. 9b). For tumour 15, cluster 1 was also predicted to comprise basal-like cells, consistent with its higher H3K4me1 deposition on basal-like-associated genes (Fig. 3g and Extended Data Fig. 9c). CyTOF-predicted basal-like cells also showed higher H3K4me1 deposition at EMT and basal-like gene signatures, which further confirmed their distinct epigenetic and functional features (Extended Data Fig. 9d). To validate these results, we sorted luminal PDX models and MCF7 cells by K5 expression, followed by H3K4me1 CUT&Tag. K5low-specific peaks were enriched near oestrogen signalling genes, whereas K5hi-specific peaks were associated with basal-like and mesenchymal programs, which confirmed the distinct H3K4me1 landscapes between subpopulations (Extended Data Fig. 9e). Together, the protein abundance and genomic distribution data implicate H3K4me1 and H3K4me3 as epigenetic determinants of the basal-like subpopulation in luminal tumours.
The repressive mark H3K9me2 was also identified as a strong contributor to the epigenetic basal-like signature (Fig. 2d,e). Thus, we conducted H3K9me2 snCUT&Tag on tumour 8, which was also profiled for H3K4me1. Given that H3K9me2 occupies large genomic regions, its distribution is not readily interpretable in relation to gene activity, especially in low-coverage single-cell datasets. We therefore leveraged the H3K4me1 data and trained a classifier, assuming opposing genomic distributions of enhancer-associated H3K4me1 and repressive H3K9me2 chromatin62,63, to identify malignant versus stromal cells (Extended Data Fig. 9f). We next clustered tumour cells by H3K9me2 genomic distribution and applied the same H3K4me1-based inference framework. This approach predicted strong enrichment of basal-like cells in cluster 4, consistent with elevated H3K9me2 deposition on oestrogen-related genes (Extended Data Fig. 9g–i). This cluster also showed the highest H3K9me2 read counts per nucleus, which provided support for its correspondence to the H3K9me2hi basal-like cells identified by CyTOF (Extended Data Fig. 9j). Overall, these analyses highlight an epigenetically distinct basal-like population with globally increased and redistributed active and repressive histone modifications over genes associated with luminal-basal identity and EMT.
Our multimodal analysis linked the chromatin landscape to intratumoural cell-state diversity. We next aimed to translate our tissue-level findings to a liquid biopsy test based on our single-molecule EPINUC technology, which profiles the epigenetics of plasma-isolated nucleosomes28,29. We tailored EPINUC for breast cancer by developing single-molecule systems to quantify the breast-tissue-related proteins K5, L1CAM and MUC1, and added the histone PTMs H4K16ac and H4K20me3 (refs. 64,65,66,67) (Fig. 4a, Supplementary Table 5 and Supplementary Fig. 8a–c). Nucleosomes from plasma were captured and their combinatorial modifications imaged by TIRF microscopy, whereas protein biomarkers were quantified in parallel single-molecule antibody-capture assays (Fig. 4a). The expanded 29-parameter panel was applied to a cohort of plasma from 77 women with luminal breast cancer and 30 healthy women, and the results revealed significant differences (Supplementary Table 6). For example, cancer samples contained more H3K9ac and H4K16ac nucleosomes (Fig. 4b). As PTMs were normalized to nucleosome abundance, these differences reflect the epigenetic state rather than tumour burden. We also used EPINUC to measure PTM ratios and co-occurrence, which revealed increased bivalent (H3K4me3 and H3K27me3) nucleosomes, as previously observed in colorectal cancer and pancreatic cancer28. Indeed, bivalency is altered across cancers68, and can prime drug-tolerant persister programs in breast cancer19.
It has been revealed that a, Schematic of the experiment. Circulating nucleosomes and proteins are captured on a microscope coverslip, which facilitates sensitive quantification of multiple histone PTMs and protein biomarkers from <1 ml plasma28. Fluorophore-conjugated antibodies enable simultaneous measurement of multiple marks, including their ratios and co-occurrence on individual nucleosomes. b, Selected EPINUC features in healthy women (n = 30) and in patients with stage T1 (n = 42) or stage T2–T4 luminal breast cancer (n = 30; Supplementary Tables 5 and 6). Boxes show median and 25–75th percentiles, and whiskers extend to the most extreme values within 1.5× the IQR. Circles represent individual samples. P values were calculated by two-sided two-sample Wilcoxon test and corrected for multiple comparisons (Bonferroni). NS, not significant. c, Individual PPS analysis distinguishing healthy individuals from all patients with luminal breast cancer or stage T1 breast cancer. Colour indicates the PPS values, reflecting the predictive power of each individual feature. See Supplementary Table 5 for EPINUC feature annotation. d, PCA of healthy (n = 30) and luminal breast cancer (n = 77) samples using all contributing features shown in c (PPS > 0). Samples are coloured by group; ellipses indicate 95% CI for the group barycentre. e, XGBoost classifier distinguishing healthy individuals from all patients with luminal breast cancer or stage T1 breast cancer, using all features measured and their combinations. SHAP scores indicate the contribution of each feature to classifier performance. f,g, Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves for random forest models discriminating healthy individuals (n = 30) from all patients with luminal breast cancer (n = 77; f), T1 luminal breast cancer (n = 42; g) or T2–T4 luminal breast cancer (n = 30; g). Models used multiplicative feature combinations followed by Boruta feature selection. AUCs were 0.95 (95% CI, 0.91–0.98), 0.95 (95% CI, 0.90–0.99) and 0.96 (95% CI, 0.91–1.00), respectively; shaded areas indicate 95% CI. h, Confusion matrix of model predictions for the 25% test set from the multi-institutional cohort (188 samples), comparing samples from healthy individuals (n = 13) and from patients with luminal breast cancer (n = 34), with specificity set to 0.9. Rows were normalized to show predictions as a percentage of samples in each true group. Schematic in a created in BioRender; Furth, N. https://biorender.com/qxlshkj (2026).
L1CAM and MST1 were also elevated in plasma from patients with breast cancer, a result in agreement with the association of high MST1 with poor prognosis in ER+ tumours69 (Fig. 4b and Supplementary Fig. 8d). Multiple parameters differed between healthy individuals and patients diagnosed with early-stage (T1) low-burden tumours, which demonstrated the early detection sensitivity of this method (Fig. 4b). Predictive power scores (PPS) revealed the contribution of the newly measured H4 PTMs, selected on the basis of the CyTOF analysis, which illustrates the value of matched tissue–plasma profiling (Fig. 4c). Principal component analysis (PCA) of predictive features separated healthy individuals from patients with breast cancer, which highlights the ability of EPINUC to capture differences between these groups (Fig. 4d).
We next applied machine-learning-based classifiers to diagnose luminal breast cancer from EPINUC data. SHAP analysis of XGBoost models trained on all patients, or only stage T1 cases, identified multiple histone PTMs and protein biomarkers as informative (Fig. 4e). Notably, both models emphasized combinatorial features, particularly H4K16ac and H4K20me3 co-occurrence, thereby highlighting the ability of EPINUC to quantify such combinations. In particular, H4K16ac activates transcription of transposable elements70, which reside in H4K20me3 heterochromatin71, and because transposable elements are often upregulated in cancer, elevated H4K16ac and H4K20me3 might be a cancer-associated phenomenon. Finally, we applied several classifiers to assess the diagnostic contribution of the expanded EPINUC panel in discriminating healthy individuals from patients with cancer. Use the original 20 EPINUC parameters28 produced an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.85 (Supplementary Fig. 9a), whereas the expanded 29-parameter panel achieved 0.95, including among patients with early-stage T1 cancer (Fig. 4f,g). Unlike mammography, the sensitivity of which declines with dense breast tissue72,73, the features and performance of EPINUC were unaffected by different BI-RADS breast density scores, including patients with heterogeneous and extremely dense breast scores (Supplementary Fig. 9b,c). To assess the robustness of the EPINUC-based classifier, we applied the model trained on the original cohort (MAYO-1; Fig. 4f) to an independent, separately processed set of plasma samples collected 6–12 months later (MAYO-2). Following batch correction (Methods), the pre-trained model accurately distinguished healthy from luminal breast cancer, achieving an AUC of 0.98 and high classification accuracy (Extended Data Fig. 10a,b).
It has been revealed that to generalize our findings, we analysed pretreatment plasma from patients with luminal breast cancer at two independent medical centres (Supplementary Table 6). EPINUC distinguished patients from healthy controls with high accuracy in both cohorts and highlighted comparable sensitivity and specificity in TNBC (Extended Data Fig. 10c–e). Pooling all luminal samples across centres (n = 188), a model trained on 75% of the data achieved an AUC of 0.96 and robustly classified the remaining 25% despite mixed sources and batches, a scenario that reflects real-world clinical settings (Fig. 4h, Extended Data Fig. 10f and Supplementary Fig. 10). Performance was similar for luminal A and luminal B tumours (Extended Data Fig. 10g). Although retrospective, these results support the use of high-resolution, multiparametric plasma epigenetic analyses for cancer diagnosis.
It has been revealed that MAYO-1 comprised preoperative samples with at least 5 years of clinical follow-up, which enabled stratification by 5-year recurrence (Fig. 5a). Already at diagnosis, several EPINUC features differed between patients who were disease-free and patients who had relapsed disease. H3K4 monomethylation and trimethylation, associated with the aggressive basal-like subpopulation, were elevated in plasma of patients developing recurrent disease (Fig. 5b). H3K27me3 and H3K9ac were also elevated, perhaps reflecting other aggressive tumour or microenvironmental states, such as cycling cells that were particularly high for histone acetylations (Extended Data Fig. 1b). Nucleosomes modified with both H3K9ac and H3K4me1 were higher in the recurrence group, a result that further demonstrates the power of EPINUC in capturing these combinations (Fig. 5b). ER or PR status did not associate with relapse (Fisher’s exact test, P > 0.05), and the epigenetic signature persisted in tumours with the following characteristics: comparable ER and PR levels; only luminal A tumours; low-burden T1–T2 or grade 1–2 disease; and tumours without lymphovascular invasion (LVI). No EPINUC feature was significantly associated with histological grade, which indicates that there is prognostic information beyond known clinical parameters (Extended Data Fig. 11a–f).
a, Schematic of the experiment. Blood samples were collected before surgery from patients with luminal breast cancer, with clinical follow-up of at least 5 years. Samples were stratified on the basis of disease outcome: disease-free (n = 44) or relapse (n = 33). b, Selected EPINUC features in the two outcome groups defined in a. Boxes show median and 25–75th percentiles, and whiskers extend to the most extreme values within 1.5× the IQR. Circles represent individual samples. Two-sided Wilcoxon test. c, Histone PTM-focused mass-spectrometry profiling of luminal tumours stratified by outcome (disease-free, n = 17; relapse, n = 4). Shown are differences in the mean levels of modifications relevant to the CyTOF or EPINUC panels between the two groups. Two-sided Welch’s test; *P < 0.05. Exact P values are provided in the source data. d, Scatter plot comparing mean histone PTM levels measured by CyTOF (tumour cells) with EPINUC measurements in matched plasma (n = 10). Spearman’s correlation coefficient and two-sided P values are indicated. Lines show Theil–Sen fit, shading indicates 95% CI. e, XGBoost classifier distinguishing disease-free (n = 44) and relapse (n = 33) groups using all EPINUC features. SHAP scores indicate the contribution of each epigenetic feature to classifier performance, ranked by importance. f–i, Recurrence prediction in patients with luminal breast cancer. f, ROC curve for the MAYO-1 cohort (disease-free, n = 44; relapse, n = 33; AUC = 0.81, 95% CI 0.71–0.90). g, AUC estimates for patients with complete clinical annotation (disease-free, n = 39; relapse, n = 28), using clinical prognostic variables (age, tumour stage, lymph-node stage, grade and luminal subtype), EPINUC features or both. h, ROC curve for the independent MAYO-2 cohort (disease-free, n = 20; relapse, n = 10; AUC = 0.92, 95% CI 0.79–1.00). i, ROC curves and AUC estimates using OncotypeDX score, EPINUC features, or both, among patients with available OncotypeDX measurements, comparing disease-free (n = 40) and relapse (n = 9). For ROC curves, shading indicates 95% CI; for AUC estimates, points and lines indicate AUC and 95% CI, respectively. Schematic in a created in BioRender; Furth, N. https://biorender.com/xg9gtix (2026).
To further explore the association between tumour and plasma epigenetic patterns, we analysed a small cohort of luminal tumours with histone PTM mass-spectrometry data39, which were similarly stratified by disease recurrence39. H3K4me1 and H3K9me2, which marked the basal-like cells in our CyTOF data, were significantly higher in patients who developed recurrence, a result that further links this subpopulation to aggressive tumour traits (Figs. 2e and 5c). Finally, for patients analysed in Figs. 1–3, we obtained preoperative blood samples, which enabled direct correlation of tumour (CyTOF) and blood (EPINUC) epigenetic patterns. Most histone PTMs correlated positively, with the recurrence-associated H3K4me1 and H3K9ac marks showing the strongest positive correlation, a result that provided further support for their prognostic value (Fig. 5d and Extended Data Fig. 11h). Although requiring larger validation, these data suggest that circulating nucleosomes report both the tumour presence and its epigenetic state, a finding with potentially important implications for clinical management.
It has been revealed that to examine the prognostic power of EPINUC to predict disease recurrence, we applied machine-learning classifiers on the multiparametric data. The best model achieved an AUC of 0.81, and outperformed predictions based on classical prognostic parameters such as stage, grade and subtype (Fig. 5e–g and Extended Data Fig. 11i). To assess reproducibility and to benchmark established assays, MAYO-2 was focused on samples with available OncotypeDX scores74. Despite its smaller size, EPINUC predicted recurrence with an AUC of 0.92 (Fig. 5h). Across patients with OncotypeDX data from both cohorts, scores did not differ between disease-free and relapsed groups, whereas EPINUC retained discriminatory power (Fig. 5i, Extended Data Fig. 11j and Supplementary Fig. 11). Combining assays did not improve performance, which indicated limited added value from OncotypeDX in this setting. Overall, the data suggest that epigenetic signatures of tumour cell subpopulations, such as basal-like cells, may be captured in blood and provide insight into disease biology beyond the static tissue-based prognostic window. Pending larger prospective validation, these findings provide support for the use of EPINUC for early diagnosis and recurrence-risk stratification.
Industry observers note that single-cell studies have revealed clinically relevant phenotypic diversity across cancers, yet the epigenetic mechanisms fuelling this heterogeneity remain poorly understood75,76. Our analysis of luminal breast tumours uncovered tumour cell diversity consistent with previous transcriptomic and proteomic approaches14,21,33,34,54. Quantitative mass-spectrometry also indicated differences in global histone modification levels between breast cancer subtypes, which provides support for the idea that chromatin regulates cell identity39,77,78. Altered H3K4 demethylation can drive loss of luminal identity40, which suggests that changes in ER signalling, even without ESR1 mutations, may promote luminal-to-basal plasticity. Here we performed single-cell profiling of histone PTMs in luminal breast tumours. By measuring multiple global chromatin modifications at single-cell resolution, we identified a recurrent epigenetic signature of K5hi basal-like cells across tumours, supported across modalities by single-cell genomic profiling of H3K4 methylation.
Sources indicate that reconstitution of the full heterogeneity spectrum in single-cell-derived MCF7 clones and independently grown PDX tumours provides support for epigenetically driven, interconverting states rather than genetically distinct clones. Subpopulation frequencies varied among patients and may be influenced by mutations that bias state acquisition, as reported in glioblastoma46. This plasticity may enable adaptation to therapeutic pressures, which then promotes resistance and progression. Accordingly, proteomic intratumoural heterogeneity increases with tumour grade independently of genomic heterogeneity, thereby implicating epigenetic mechanisms7. Whether epigenetic therapies can limit plasticity and state transitions remains to be tested.
It has been revealed that breast cancer prognosis depends strongly on early detection, yet accurate screening while minimizing false positives remains challenging79,80,81,82. Detection of molecular changes before clinical progression could guide treatment adaptation and maximize first-line benefit83. Tumour-level histone PTM signatures distinguished luminal breast cancer cell states, whereas EPINUC analysis of pretreatment plasma samples provided proof-of-concept for outcome prediction. Notably, H3K4 methylation marks were elevated in both basal-like tumour cells and in plasma from patients with recurrent disease, which suggests that there is a link between this subpopulation and disease outcome.
Unlike CyTOF, which resolves tumour cell populations, plasma measurements integrate signals from damage of healthy tissue, the tumour microenvironment and local and systemic immune responses29,84. Nevertheless, patient-matched histone PTMs analyses in tumours and blood revealed a positive correlation for most marks, with the highest correlation observed for the recurrence-associated marks H3K4me1 and H3K9ac, which provides support for their prognostic value. Overall, our tissue and plasma chromatin dataset reveals epigenetically driven intratumoural heterogeneity in breast cancer and supports the use of EPINUC as a potential approach for breast cancer diagnosis and prognosis.
Collection and analyses of breast cancer tissue samples and matching blood samples were approved by the Israeli Ministry of Health Ethics Committees (Helsinki applications KMC-0028-22), followed by approval of the Weizmann Institutional Review Board (IRB, 2314-3).
The breast cancer samples for histone PTM mass-spectrometry-based analysis, which comprise 21 tumours, were obtained from patients undergoing surgery at the European Institute of Oncology and are part of a study approved by the institute’s Ethical Committee (study UID 2550).
Recent findings suggest that plasma samples and data for luminal breast cancer patients were obtained from Mayo Clinic (IRB approval number 23-011311). Collection of plasma samples from breast cancer patients treated at the Sheba Medical Center was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB approval 7509-09). Plasma samples from healthy individuals were obtained from the Weizmann Institute of Science (IRB approval number 1850-1).
All studies were performed in accordance with the relevant guidelines and regulations, and informed consent was obtained from all participants. No direct identifying participant information is reported in this study. Participants’ information is detailed in Supplementary Tables 2 and 6. No statistical methods were used to predetermine sample sizes. No randomization or blinding was performed in the collection, processing, or analysis of human samples.
All animal studies were approved by the Weizmann Institute’s Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (IACUC), and they were performed in accordance with Israeli law. Mice were housed and handled in a pathogen-free, temperature-controlled (22 °C ± 1 °C) facility on a 12-h light–dark cycle. Animals were fed a regular chow diet (2018 Teklad Global 18% protein rodent diet) and given ad libitum access to food and water.
The TM00112 (PDX-1) and TM00386 (PDX-2) models were purchased from the Jackson Laboratory and implanted in 10-week-old female NSG mice (Jackson Laboratory). In brief, following euthanasia, tumours were removed from donor mice and cut into small fragments. A small pouch was made in the lower back of each mouse, and one fragment was inserted into the pouch. The wound was closed using a surgical clip. Clips were removed 4–5 days after surgery. Tumours were measured twice a week with a caliper, and body weight was measured once a week. The IACUC-approved maximum tumour size was 1,000 mm3. Mice were euthanized when tumours reached approximately 500 mm3, and tumours were collected for analyses. No statistical method was used to predetermine sample sizes. Animals were not randomized, and investigators were not blinded during the experiments.
MCF7 and MDA-MB-468 cell lines were obtained from the Tissue Culture Cell repository at the Weizmann Institute of Science. HCC70, HCC1937 and SUM149 cell lines were provided by I. Ben-Porath. HCC70 and HCC1937 cells were cultured in RPMI-1640 supplemented with 10% FBS, 1% L-glutamine and 1% penicillin–streptomycin. SUM149 cells were maintained in Ham’s F-12 medium supplemented with 5% FBS, 1 µg ml–1 hydrocortisone (Sigma-Aldrich, H0888), 0.5 µg ml–1 insulin (Sigma-Aldrich, I5500), L-glutamine and penicillin–streptomycin. MDA-MB-468 and MCF7 cells were cultured in DMEM (Thermo Fisher Scientific, 41965-039) supplemented with 10% FBS (Sigma-Aldrich, F7524), 1% L-glutamine (Sartorius, 03-020-1B) and 1% penicillin–streptomycin (Corning, 30-002-CI). All cells were maintained at 37 °C in a humidified atmosphere containing 5% CO2.
Single-cell-derived MCF7 clones and matching parental MCF7 cells were either provided by U. Ben-David89 or generated in-house by single-cell sorting into 96-well plates using a Sony SH800S cell sorter (Sony Biotechnology) and expanded for approximately 4 months before experiments.
Cell lines were not independently authenticated but were routinely tested for mycoplasma contamination and were negative.
Owing to the limited number of dissociated cells available from each tumour sample provided for research, we were unable to profile identical samples using all the different methods described in the paper. The single-cell CyTOF-based epigenetic analysis of human tumours was the priority for each tumour (besides tumour 23, which was used for WGBS and not profiled by CyTOF). For tumour 18, both WGBS and snCUT&Tag were performed owing to the high availability of tumour cells. For the remaining samples, we did not have sufficient cells to perform both methodologies. Notably, although the additional analyses were not conducted on identical samples, each was performed on three independent tumour samples, which ensured the reproducibility of the conclusions from each approach. The focus of the analysis was on identifying common patterns in tumours, rather than comparing between tumours and patients.
Patient and tumour information was extracted from pathological reports. To quantify ER positivity, formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tumour blocks prepared alongside sample collection for CyTOF analysis were retrieved, sectioned and stained for ER by IHC. Slides were scanned, and digital images containing DAB signals were analysed using QuPath software90. Tissue regions were first segmented using a pixel classifier to identify areas containing tissue (average channels < 245, sigma = 2, at 8.4 μm resolution). In these regions, epithelial and stromal compartments were segmented using a supervised pixel classifier, with a minimum object size of 1,000 µm2 and a minimum hole size of 5,000 µm2. The classifier was trained on representative regions from multiple slides using a multilayer perceptron (ANN_MLP) model implemented in QuPath, based on haematoxylin and DAB channels at 2.1 µm resolution and multiscale neighbourhood features (scales 1, 2, 4, 8 and 12). Cell nuclei in epithelial regions were segmented using Cellpose-SAM91. For each nucleus, the median DAB intensity was quantified. The distribution of nuclear DAB intensities was computed for each tumour sample and a per-sample thresholding was used to account for inter-slide staining variability. For each tumour, a kernel density estimate of the median nuclear DAB intensity was computed, constrained to the observed intensity range. Local maxima and minima of the density function were identified, and the threshold separating ER-negative and ER-positive nuclei was defined as the lowest local minimum between the two most prominent density peaks. Tumour-specific thresholds derived using this approach were applied to classify nuclei as ER-positive or ER-negative, and the percentage of ER-positive cells was calculated for each sample.
It has been revealed that DNA was extracted from FFPE blocks using a RecoverAll Total Nucleic Acid Isolation kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific) and stored at −20 °C. FFPE blocks were reviewed and annotated for tumour cellularity by a certified pathologist, with a minimum accepted tumour cellularity threshold of 20%. DNA concentrations were quantified using a Qubit 3 fluorometer using a dsDNA HS Assay kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific).
Sources indicate that libraries were prepared using a TruSight Oncology 500 (TSO500) assay (Illumina) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. In brief, 100 ng DNA from each sample was sheared using a Covaris M220 ultrasonicator (Covaris). Genomic libraries were prepared using a Hamilton Microlab STAR system (Hamilton) and sequenced on an Illumina NextSeq550 instrument with a High Output kit v.2.5 (300 cycles). Initial analysis was performed using DRAGEN TruSight Oncology 500 analysis software (v.2.6.2, Illumina).
Variants were annotated and classified according to AMP guidelines into tiers IA, IB, IIC, IID, III and IV92. Variants classified as tier IV, synonymous, non-coding or having no established biological impact were excluded using Velsera Clinical Genomics Workspace (CGW). Remaining variants were manually reviewed using in silico prediction tools (REVEL, CADD and SpliceAI) together with annotations from Franklin (Genoox), UCSC Genome Browser and Velsera CGW. Variants were reported only when sequencing coverage exceeded 100× and the variant allele frequency was >1%.
Sources indicate that the antibody panel combined breast-tissue-relevant cell identity markers33,34, histone PTMs spanning diverse chromatin states and the chromatin modifiers EZH2 and BMI-1 (Supplementary Table 1). The chromatin marks analysed were chosen on the basis of availability of highly specific and validated antibodies, and quantification of core histones was used for signal normalization.
According to recent reports, following surgery, a sample of the tumour tissue was kept in MACS Tissue storage solution (Miltenyi Biotec, 130-100-008), and dissociation into single cells was conducted using a human Tumour Dissociation kit (Miltenyi Biotec, 130-095-929) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. Red blood cells were removed using Red Blood Cell Lysis solution (10x, Miltenyi Biotec, 130-094-183) and CD45+ cells were depleted using human CD45 MicroBeads (Miltenyi Biotec, 130-045-801). The cell suspension was then washed with PBS and either further processed for CyTOF analysis or nuclei were extracted for snCUT&Tag analysis (when the number of cells was suitable). For cell lines, cells were dissociated using Accutase (Sigma-Aldrich, STC-07922) supplemented with DNase I (Merck, 4716728001).
Sources indicate that for CyTOF analysis, cells were washed with Maxpar CyTOF PBS (Standard BioTools) and stained with 1.25 μM cisplatin (Standard BioTools) for 1 min. Cisplatin was neutralized with warm 10% FBS–DMEM. Cells were washed with Maxpar Cell Staining buffer (Standard BioTools) and blocked using TruStain FcX, Fc Receptor Blocking solution, human (422301, BioLegend), followed by 30 min of incubation with a cocktail of extracellular antibodies (Supplementary Table 1). For tumour samples, cells were washed with PBS, mildly fixed (1.6% paraformaldehyde (PFA)–PBS) for 30 min and frozen in 10% DMSO–FBS. When the number of cells allowed, aliquots of frozen cells from this step were used for additional applications (flow-cytometry-based sorting or WGBS). For cell lines, samples were directly stained for intracellular markers without mild fixation and freezing.
For intracellular staining and CyTOF measurements, tumour samples were thawed, all samples were washed with staining buffer, fixed and permeabilized using Maxpar nuclear antigen staining buffer set (Standard BioTools) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. For multiplexed samples, barcoding was performed using a Cell-ID 20-Plex Pd Barcoding kit (Standard BioTools). In brief, each sample was resuspended in MaxPar Nuclear Antigen Staining Perm buffer (Standard BioTools) and mixed with freshly thawed barcode reagent. Samples were incubated for 60 min at room temperature with mixing every 15 min, washed twice with Perm buffer and all barcoded samples were combined into a single tube or well. Before antibody staining, cells were blocked using 10% FBS for 10 min and then incubated with the antibody cocktail (Supplementary Table 1) diluted in MaxPar Nuclear Antigen Perm buffer (Standard BioTools) for 30 min at room temperature. Cells were fixed with 4% PFA overnight. On acquisition day, samples were suspended in 4% PFA containing 125 nM Cell-ID Intercalator-Iridium (Standard BioTools), washed twice with staining buffer and twice with Maxpar Cell acquisition solution (201240, Standard BioTools). Samples were suspended in Maxpar Cell acquisition solution supplemented with 10% EQ Four Element Calibration Beads (201078, standard BioTools). Before acquisition on a CyTOF machine, cells were adjusted to about 300,000 cells per ml and filtered through a 35 μm mesh cell strainer. Data were acquired on a CyTOF Helios system (Standard BioTools).
Recent findings suggest that the CyTOF software by Standard BioTools was used for normalization. Several gates were applied using FlowJo software: normalization beads were gated out using the 140Ce channel; live single cells were gated using the cisplatin 195Pt, iridium DNA label in 193Ir, event length and the Gaussian parameters of width, centre, offset and residual channels. De-barcoding was done using CyTOF software93.
In a recent development, overall, 17 different tumour samples were analysed by CyTOF, with 5 samples analysed twice as either technical replicates in different batches to provide anchor information or with different antibody panels for the analysis of an additional cell-cycle marker (pRb). A total of 1,565,881 viable cells were measured (around 30,000–400,000 cells per sample; Supplementary Table 3). The remaining CD45+ cells were removed from the analysis. For PDX analysis, CD45+ cells were removed and only human cells were analysed by maintaining human CD298+ and mouse MHC class I-negative cells.
According to recent reports, as samples were measured in batches, anchor samples, identical tumour samples measured in different batches, were used to implement batch-effect correction. Batch effects were corrected using a Q-Q transformation based on the empirical cumulative distribution function (ECDF). This method non-linearly maps quantile values from one anchor sample to corresponding quantiles in another, which effectively aligns their distributions. This transformation was then applied to tumour samples in the first batch.
Notably, as Q-Q plot transformation is inherently restricted to the range of the anchor samples owing to its reliance on interpolation, for values outside this range, linear extrapolation—based on the mean and standard deviation of the samples—can approximate the transformation’s slope and intercept, which provides a reasonable estimate of the nonlinear mapping beyond the observed data range.
The transformation can be approximated by the following equation:.
Sources indicate that following batch correction, the full cohort was subsampled to roughly 10,000 cells per sample for subsequent analysis with stroma cells. Following the removal of stroma cells, the cohort was further subsampled to 5,000 cells per sample. Normalization and data scaling were performed on either all tumours as one batch or on individual tumours, as previously described22,23. In brief, cells were gated using the core histones (H3, H3.3 and H4), and the signals for intracellular proteins, including histone PTMs, was subsequently normalized using these core histone values to reduce systematic technical variation:.
Sources indicate that the coefficients were selected to minimize the sum of the variances of the core histones. UMAP representations show a random subset of data points (around 10%) to improve visualization.
To analyse the high-dimensional data generated from our CyTOF experiments, we first applied dimensionality reduction using UMAP94. This was followed by clustering with DBSCAN95. Clusters were then joined on the basis of similarity in expression patterns to define the three distinct cellular subpopulations: cycling, luminal and basal-like.
We quantified, for each cell and each predefined gene signature, whether the set was enriched relative to a competitive null that matches the signature size but samples features from the same cell’s remaining markers. The method returns per-cell z-scores, which were visualized on UMAP embedding.
Detailed computation is as follows:.
Let X ∈R(N × G) be the cell-by-feature matrix. For sets \(\,{\mathcal{S}}=\{{S}_{1},\ldots ,{S}_{S}\}\), each Ss has size m_s ms = |Ss|. Optional signed feature weights w{s,g} are supported (w{s,g} = 0 if g ∉ S_s).
We row-centred per cell to remove global level shifts as follows:.
Signed observed sum (unweighted) as follows:.
Signed observed sum (weighted) as follows:.
Absolute-magnitude observed sum (unweighted) as follows:.
Absolute-magnitude observed sum (weighted) as follows:.
Industry observers note that for competitive null (size-matched permutations or exact enumeration), for each set s, we formed a pool of competitor genes \({{\mathcal{P}}}_{{\rm{s}}}\). By default we used the complement in the current feature space, \({{\mathcal{P}}}_{s}=\{1,\ldots ,G\}\backslash {S}_{s}\) (exclude_set = True), enforcing a competitive null; if the complement was too small we fell back to all features. We then sampled m_s genes without replacement from \({{\mathcal{P}}}_{{\rm{s}}}\) to construct null sums for each cell:.
With b = 1,…,B permutations. When the number of combinations \(C(|{{\mathcal{P}}}_{s}|,{m}_{s})\) was below a threshold (default 5 × 104), we enumerated exactly in streamed chunks. For each cell and set, we estimated the null mean and variance (and analogues for the absolute variant) with numerically stable streaming updates; a small constant (10–6) was added to standard deviations to avoid division by zero.
Per-cell z-scores (signed and absolute) were calculated as follows:.
Right-tailed P values (two-sided optional) were calculated as follows:.
To summarize effect size while preserving direction, we defined:.
Thus, Z_dir is large and positive when the set is consistently up (large absolute signal with positive net direction), and large and negative when consistently down.
In a recent development, the framework supports signed feature weights w_{s,g} ∈ ℝ. Positive weights required higher expression, whereas negative weights encoded markers expected to be low in the target program. The null maintained the same size \({m}_{s}=\sum _{g}{\mathbb{1}}[w\{s,g\}\ne 0]\) by drawing m_s unweighted competitors from \({{\mathcal{P}}}_{s}\), preserving the competitive interpretation. Observed signed sums used w{s,g}, whereas absolute-magnitude sums used |w{s,g}|.
In a recent development, we used B = 2,000 permutations per set (10,000 for final figures), exclude_set = True (competitive null), two-sided P when depletion was relevant and FDR control at 5%. For scRNA-seq, we recommend computing on log-normalized counts after library-size normalization and optional regression of technical covariates; for CyTOF, arcsinh or z-score scaled channels work well.
In each tumour, a training set of cells was constructed, including only cells that were successfully classified as luminal, basal-like or cycling, keeping class-distribution and size equal between samples. From each tumour, 80% of these cells were randomly assigned to the training set, and the remaining 20% were used as the validation set. We used an XGBoost model35, with a learning rate of 0.1, a maximum depth of 10 and 1,000 estimators. The model achieved a prediction accuracy of 94% on the validation set. The trained model was subsequently applied to cells that were not assigned to a subpopulation by DBSCAN (cluster –1), and cells predicted with >95% confidence were assigned to the corresponding luminal, basal-like or cycling subpopulation for downstream analyses (Extended Data Fig. 3b). The contribution of each feature to the XGBoost classification was evaluated using SHAP scores30,31, which reflect feature contribution to the classification rather than relative expression levels.
In a recent development, vendi scores96 were computed based on the epigenetic CyTOF panel (histone PTM and chromatin modifiers). For each sample, cells were stratified by class label. To control for differences in cell number across classes, we repeatedly subsampled m = ⌊n_min/2⌋ cells without replacement from each class, where n_min was the smallest class size in that sample. Marker intensities were first normalized using a global z-score computed across a balanced sample of cells from all datasets. For each rarefaction, epigenetic marker values were discretized into 20 uniform bins, and the normalized dual Vendi score was computed on the resulting cell-by-marker matrix. Reported values correspond to the mean across 5,000 rarefactions, with uncertainty intervals defined by the 2.5th and 97.5th percentiles of the rarefied score distribution.
Sources indicate that sample preparation for mass spectrometry analysis was optimized to enable intracellular staining before FACS with limited input material. Mildly fixed (1.6% PFA) breast tumour single-cell suspensions prepared for CyTOF were thawed and washed with Maxpar CyTOF PBS. Cells were fixed and permeabilized using Maxpar nuclear antigen staining buffer set (201063, Standard BioTools) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Staining was done in 10% FCS/CyTOF Nuclear Antigen Staining Perm with the following antibodies: K5–AF546 (Cell Signaling, 71536, in-house fluorophore conjugation) and pan-keratin–AF647 (Cell Signaling, 4528). Following three washes with PBS, cells were transferred to a new well, to minimize residual detergent content. Samples were read using FACS (BD Aria III), with 200 cells of each population (K5hi and K5low; Supplementary Fig. 12a) sorted directly into freshly prepared 3 μl lysis buffer-containing wells in a 96-well plate format (Eppendorf twin.tec PCR plates). With a sorter droplet volume of 3.33 nl, the sorting process contributed an additional 0.66 μl to the total volume per well.
Industry observers note that the cell lysis buffer was prepared by combining 5 mM tris-(2-carboxyethyl) phosphine (TCEP) as a reducing agent, 20 mM chloroacetamide (CAA) alkylation agent, 100 mM triethylammonium bicarbonate (TEAB) and 0.1% n-dodecyl-β-D-maltoside (DDM). After sorting, the plate was briefly centrifuged to ensure cells settled into the lysis buffer. The plate was then sealed with PCR cap strips and incubated at 95 °C for 30 min in an Eppendorf ThermoMixer C, with the lid covered to prevent condensation. Following incubation, the plate was cooled, briefly centrifuged and 11 μl protein digestion buffer (50 mM ammonium bicarbonate buffer, 0.033 ng μl–1 sequencing grade modified trypsin (Promega) and 0.132 ng μl–1 Trypsin/Lys-C mix, mass spec grade (Promega)) was added to each well. The plate was resealed, briefly centrifuged and incubated overnight at room temperature for protein digestion. The next day, 20 μl solvent A (99.9% water and 0.1% formic acid) was added to each well to acidify the samples and halt the trypsinization process.
In a recent development, LC–MS analyses were performed on an Evosep1 liquid chromatography system (Evosep) coupled to the TimsTOF SCP mass spectrometer (Bruker). The samples were loaded onto a disposable Evotip C18 trap column (Evosep Biosystems) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. In brief, the workflow involved rinsing dry Evotips with 20 μl solvent B (99.9% acetonitrile and 0.1% formic acid), followed by centrifugation at 800g for 60 s. The tips were then conditioned by soaking in 100 μl 1-propanol until they appeared pale white. After conditioning, the tips were equilibrated with 20 μl solvent A, followed by centrifugation at 800g for 60 s. The protein samples were loaded onto the wet tips, followed by another centrifugation step at 800g for 60 s. To ensure cleanliness, the tips were washed with 20 μl solvent A, with centrifugation repeated. Finally, to maintain tip hydration, 100 μl solvent A was added, and the tips were centrifuged briefly at 800g for 10 s.
Industry observers note that peptides were separated on an Aurora Elite CSI 15 × 75 C18 UHPLC column (IonOpticks) using the Whisper 40 SPD method. Mass spectrometric acquisition was performed in a data-independent (DIA) PASEF mode. For the diaPASEF mode, the ion accumulation and ramp time was set to 100 ms, and precursors in an ion mobility range from 1/K0 = 1.45 V s–1 cm–2 to 0.64 V s–1 cm–2 were analysed over a mass to charge (m/z) range from 100 to 1,700. Precursor ions for MS/MS analysis were isolated based on diaPASEF window placement covering an ion mobility range from 1/K0 = 0.75 V s–1 cm-2 to 1.2 V s–1 cm–2 and a m/z range of 400–1,000. The estimated cycle time was 0.64 s with 1 MS ramp and 5 MS/MS ramps, resulting in 75 MS/MS windows. The collision energy was ramped from 20 eV at 1/K0 = 0.6 V s–1 cm–2 to 59 eV at 1/K0 = 1.6 V s–1 cm–2.
According to recent reports, DIA-NN (v.1.8.1) was used to analyse the mass spectrometric raw files97. Analyses of the files were performed using a library-based approach (spectral library provided by BRUKER containing 67,686 proteins and 13,827 genes). Library precursors were re-annotated using a FASTA database (FASTA files UP000000589_10090.fasta and UP000000589_10090_additional.fasta, version August 2022). Trypsin was selected as protease, with a maximum of one missed cleavage. DIA-NN default settings were used with the following exceptions: the charge range of precursors was set to 2–10, and the ‘unrelated runs’ option was selected. A total of 5,630 proteins were identified.
Functional enrichment analysis of differentially expressed proteins was done using the enricher function (clusterProfiler package98) comparing to MsigDB hallmark gene sets85.
According to recent reports, single-cell suspensions of mildly fixed (1.6% PFA) cells derived from luminal PDX tumours or MCF7 cultures were stained as described above. For PDX samples, cells were stained with K5–AF555 (Cell Signaling, 72825) and pan-keratin–AF647 (Cell Signaling, 4528). Pan-keratin-positive epithelial cells were sorted on the basis of K5 expression levels into K5hi and K5low populations. For MCF7 cells, staining was performed using K5–AF555 and GATA3–Brilliant Violet (BioLegend, 653814). Cells expressing high K5 and low GATA3 were defined as K5hi and compared with the remaining cell population (K5low). Cells were sorted using a Sony SH800S cell sorter (Sony Biotechnology) with single-stain controls for compensation and to establish gating thresholds.
According to recent reports, following sorting, H3K4me1 profiling was performed using a CUT&Tag-IT Express Assay kit (Active Motif, 53175) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. The H3K4me1 antibody (Cell Signaling, 5326) was used at a 1:50 dilution. Decrosslinking was performed by incubation for 1 h at 55 °C followed by 4 h at 65 °C. Libraries were sequenced on an AVITI platform (Element Biosciences) using paired-end 50 bp reads. Sequencing data were demultiplexed and aligned to the hg38 assembly. Peaks were called using MACS2 with the --keep-dup 1 parameter. Peaks unique to either K5hi or K5low samples were assigned to genes using the ChIPseeker R package. Functional enrichment analysis was performed using the enricher function from the clusterProfiler R package, using gene signatures detailed in Supplementary Table 4.
According to recent reports, EM-seq was adapted for low-input samples. Tumour single-cell suspensions were stained with K5 and pan-keratin antibodies as described above. In brief, 200 cells of each population (K5hi and K5low) were sorted directly into freshly prepared lysis buffer (10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8.0, 200 mM NaCl, 10 mM EDTA, 0.5% SDS and 0.3 mg ml–1 proteinase K) and frozen. For each condition, four replicates were analysed.
It has been revealed that lysed cells were incubated at 55 °C for 3 h, followed by overnight incubation at 60 °C to reverse crosslinking. Tris-HCl and NaCl were added to reduce the SDS concentration to 0.33% before PCI extraction. The aqueous phase was recovered, NaCl was adjusted to 300 mM and glycogen added to 0.13 mg ml–1 following DNA precipitation with 2.3 volumes of ice-cold ethanol at −20 °C overnight. DNA was pelleted by centrifugation (21,000g, 45 min, 4 °C), washed once with 70% ethanol and resuspended in 10 mM Tris-HCl, 0.1 mM EDTA (pH 8.0).
DNA samples were enzymatically fragmented using a NEBNext UltraShear kit (M7634S, Latest England Biolabs) for 25 min at 37 °C. Libraries were prepared using a NEBNext Enzymatic Methyl-seq v.2 kit (E8015S, New England Biolabs) and NEBNext LV Unique Dual Index Primers Set 2A (E3390S, New England Biolabs) according to section 3 of the NEBNext UltraShear user manual, with the following modifications: unmethylated lambda and CpG methylated pUC19 DNA controls were diluted 1:500. Libraries for replicates three out of the four replicates were prepared with conversion controls. DNA denaturation before cytosine deamination was performed with formamide (4401457, Thermo Fisher Scientific). Libraries were amplified for 12 PCR cycles and purified by 2 rounds of bead cleanup with NEBNext Sample Purification Beads at 0.8× ratio. Library quality and fragment size distribution were assessed on an Agilent TapeStation with a High Sensitivity D5000 kit, which produced an average fragment size of about 500 bp. Libraries were sequenced on AVITI high-output flow cells (Element Biosciences), which generated 150-bp paired-end reads.
It has been revealed that paired-end sequencing reads were subjected to adapter and quality trimming using cutadapt99 (v.4.4; parameters: --quality-cutoff 20 --overlap 5 --minimum-length 25; Illumina TruSeq adapter ‘AGATCGGAAGAGC’ clipped from both reads), followed by trimming of 10 and 5 nucleotides from the 5′ and 3′ end of the first read and 15 and 5 nucleotides from the 5′ and 3′ end of the second read. The trimmed reads were aligned to the human reference genome (hg19) using BSMAP100 (v.2.90; parameters: -v 0.1 -s 16 -q 20 -w 100 -S 1 -u -R). Duplicates were removed using the ‘MarkDuplicates’ command from GATK101 (v.4.6.2.0; --VALIDATION_STRINGENCY = LENIENT --REMOVE_DUPLICATES=true). Methylation rates were called using mcall from the MOABS package102 (v.1.3.9.6; default parameters). To assess similarity between sorted tumour populations, pairwise correlations of CpG methylation levels were calculated using only shared CpG present in all eight samples of a given tumour. Pearson’s correlation coefficients were calculated across these shared CpG sites.
In a recent development, differential methylation analysis comparing K5hi and K5low cells was conducted for each tumour separately, with replicates pooled to obtain higher coverage. WGBStools (https://doi.org/10.26508/lsa.202503514) was used to identify differentially methylated regions, which were assigned to genes based on promoter overlap (–2,000 to +500 from the transcription start site (TSS)). For each gene, promoter-associated methylation changes were aggregated, and only genes with an absolute difference >0.2 and FDR-corrected Fisher’s exact test <0.05 were considered. Genes were classified according to the predominant direction of methylation change.
Functional enrichment analysis was performed using the enricher function (clusterProfiler package), comparing to MsigDB hallmark gene sets or curated breast cancer cell identity signatures.
Replicate-pooled EM-seq methylation profiles were summarized at the CGI level for each tumour and state combination by calculating CGI methylation as the ratio of methylated reads to total coverage. TCGA BRCA DNA-methylation data (Illumina HumanMethylation450) were mapped to hg19 CGI coordinates, and CGI methylation for each tumour was defined as the mean β value across probes overlapping the corresponding CGI. A shared CGI feature space was constructed as the intersection between CGIs detected in EM-seq and those measurable in TCGA. In each sample (tumour 5 or tumour 23), differential methylation between K5hi and K5low states was calculated for each CGI, and CGIs showing concordant direction of change across the two samples were retained. The effect size for each retained CGI was defined as the median of the model-specific differences and used to assign a signed weight. TCGA CGI methylation values were standardized across tumours, and for each tumour, a signature score was computed as the weighted mean of standardized CGI methylation values across the retained CGIs. Signature scores were compared across PAM50 subtypes.
Recent findings suggest that read-level DNA methylation heterogeneity was quantified using the RLM tool103. For each replicate, BSMAP-aligned paired-end BAM files were analysed against the hg19 reference genome using parameters -m PE, -a bsmap, and -s all. Only loci with sequencing coverage ≥10 reads were retained for analysis. Entropy values from all loci were aggregated for each sample and compared between the K5hi and K5low in each tumour sample.
For bulk MARS-seq analysis, MCF7 cells were sorted into K5hiGATA3low and K5lowGATA3hi populations (as described above) to capture basal-like and extreme luminal subpopulations. Cells were dissociated using Accutase (Sigma-Aldrich, STC-07922) supplemented with DNase I (Merck, 4716728001), washed with PBS and viability assessment was conducted using Zombie Violet fixable viability dye (BioLegend, 423105 or 423113). Cells were incubated for 10 min on ice in the dark, followed by 2 washes with staining buffer (PBS containing 2% FBS and 2 mM EDTA). For intracellular staining, cells were fixed in 4% formaldehyde–PBS for 15 min at room temperature. The fixation reaction was quenched with glycine (final concentration 125 mM), and cells were centrifuged at 700g for 5 min at 4 °C, then washed once with ice-cold staining buffer and once with PBS. Cells were permeabilized with 0.1% Triton X-100 in PBS for 15 min at room temperature, washed twice with staining buffer, and blocked for 10 min on ice with blocking buffer (PBS containing 5% FBS and 2 mM EDTA). Cells were then stained with anti-GATA3-BV421 (1:10 dilution, BLG-653814) and anti-KRT5-Alexa Fluor 555 (1:20 dilution, CST-72825S) antibodies in staining buffer overnight at 4 °C protected from light, followed by two washes with sorting buffer. Flow cytometry was performed on a Sony SH800S Cell Sorter. Single viable cells were gated (Zombie dye exclusion). Intracellular GATA3 and KRT5 expression were quantified in viable cell populations using single-stain controls for compensation and to establish gating thresholds (Supplementary Fig. 12b).
It has been revealed that total RNA was extracted using a RNeasy Micro Kit (Qiagen, 74004) according to the manufacturer’s instructions and stored at −80 °C. Bulk MARS-seq libraries were prepared from extracted RNA following the published protocol104 and sequenced on a NextSeq 500 instrument using a NextSeq 500/550 High Output Kit v.2.5 (75 cycles). Differential expression analysis was conducted using UTAP transcriptome analysis pipeline105.
MCF7 cells were dissociated using Accutase (Sigma-Aldrich, STC-07922) supplemented with DNase I (Merck, 4716728001) and counted in culture medium. Cells were washed with PBS and viability assessment was conducted using Zombie NIR or Zombie Violet fixable viability dye (BioLegend, 423105 or 423113). Cells were incubated for 10 min on ice in the dark, followed by two washes with staining buffer (PBS containing 2% FBS and 2 mM EDTA). For surface marker staining, cells were incubated with anti-human CD74–FITC antibody (1:10 dilution in staining buffer; eBioscience, 11-0748-42, clone 5-329) for 45 min at 4 °C in the dark with intermittent mixing every 10 min, then washed twice with sorting buffer (PBS containing 1% FBS and 5 mM EDTA). Viable cells were sorted into collection medium containing 50% FBS and 50% DMEM supplemented with 1% penicillin–streptomycin. To enrich for cells of the basal-like population, the top 10% of cells with the highest CD74 expression (CD74hi) and, as a control, the bottom 10% of cells with the lowest CD74 expression (CD74low) were sorted based on CD74–FITC fluorescence intensity (Supplementary Fig. 12c). Cells were sorted using a Sony SH800S cell sorter (Sony Biotechnology) with single-stain controls for compensation and to establish gating thresholds.
Cell migration capacity was assessed using Transwell polycarbonate membrane inserts (6.5 mm diameter, 8.0 µm pore size; Corning, 3422) placed in 24-well plates. Sorted cells were seeded in complete culture medium and allowed to recover for approximately 20 h. Cells were then serum-starved in DMEM supplemented with 0.1% FBS for 5 h before the assay. Following serum starvation, cells were dissociated using Accutase, resuspended in DMEM with 0.1% FBS and counted. A total of 5 × 104 cells in 150 µl DMEM with 0.1% FBS were seeded into the upper chamber. The lower chamber was filled with 600 µl of medium containing 20% FBS and 100 ng ml–1 epidermal growth factor (EGF; PeproTech, AF-100-15) as a chemoattractant. Control wells contained DMEM with 0.1% FBS in both chambers to assess random migration.
Following a 20-h migration period, non-migrated cells on the top surface of the membrane were removed with a cotton swab, and migrated cells on the bottom surface were fixed with 4% formaldehyde (Thermo Fisher Scientific, 28906) for 15 min at room temperature and stained with 0.1% crystal violet (Sigma-Aldrich, C0775) in 20% methanol for 10 min. Membranes were washed with distilled water and air-dried. Owing to weak crystal violet signal intensity and high background noise that precluded accurate automated quantification, migrated cells were imaged using the Cy5 channel (excitation and emission of 640 and 670 nm, respectively) to detect crystal violet autofluorescence. This approach enabled reliable background subtraction and automated cell counting. The Cy5 signal revealed complete overlap with crystal-violet-positive cells, thereby confirming that autofluorescence accurately represented the migrated cell population. Quantification was performed using ImageJ software (v.1.53; National Institutes of Health), and results are expressed as the number of migrated cells per field.
Collective cell migration and wound closure were assessed using a two-dimensional wound-healing assay. Culture-Inserts 2 Well for self-insertion (ibidi, 80209) were placed in 6-well plates (Corning, CC-3516) under sterile conditions. Cells were seeded at 1 × 105 cells per well in 70 µl of complete growth medium and incubated for 24 h until a confluent monolayer formed. Culture inserts were carefully removed with sterile tweezers to create a defined cell-free gap of approximately 500 µm width. Wells were washed twice with PBS to remove non-adherent cells, and 2 ml of fresh medium was added. Images were acquired at 0 h, 20 h, 46 h and 54 h after wounding at ×10 magnification using an inverted microscope.
Wound areas were quantified from bright-field images using an interactive segmentation workflow based on the Segment Anything Model (SAM). For each image, the wound region was identified as the continuous cell-free area and segmented using user-guided point prompts placed in the wound and, when required, outside the wound to suppress surrounding tissue or background. The resulting binary mask was visually inspected and refined interactively until it matched the wound boundary. The wound area was then calculated as the number of pixels contained in the final mask. To account for differences in image size or field of view, the fractional wound area was computed for each image by dividing the wound-mask area by the total image area. When spatial calibration was available, pixel areas were converted to physical units (µm2) using the microscope pixel size. This procedure yielded both absolute and normalized wound-area measurements for comparison across experimental conditions.
According to recent reports, mildly fixed breast tumour single-cell suspensions prepared for CyTOF were thawed and DNA was extracted using a NucleoSpin Tissue kit. RNA was removed by the addition of 20 μl of 10 mg ml–1 RNase during the lysis step. The generation of dual-indexed libraries WGBS followed a modified protocol based on the NEBNext Ultra DNA Library Prep kit for Illumina (Newly introduced England BioLabs, E7442, E7445 and E7535), in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions. The library input was 500 ng gDNA, quantified using a Qubit BR assay (Invitrogen, Q32853), and 1% unmethylated Lambda DNA (Promega, D1521) was added as a control for bisulfite conversion efficiency. Fragmentation of input gDNA to achieve an average insert size of 350 bp was done with a Covaris S220 Focused-ultrasonicator. Size selection was performed using SPRIselect beads, isolating fragments in the 300–400 bp range. Bisulfite conversion after size selection was done using an EZ DNA Methylation-Lightning kit (Zymo, D5030), following the manufacturer’s guidelines. For amplification after bisulfite conversion, Kapa HiFi Uracil+ (Kapa Biosystems, KK282) polymerase was used under the following cycling conditions: 98 °C for 45 s, followed by 8 cycles of 98 °C for 15 s, 65 °C for 30 s, and 72 °C for 30 s, with a final extension step at 72 °C for 1 min. WGBS libraries were sequenced on an Illumina NovaSeq 6000 instrument using an S4 flowcell and a 150 bp paired-end dual indexed run, with 5% PhiX library control (Illumina). The resulting coverage ranged from 16.7× to 22.5×. The bisulfite conversion rate for unmethylated Lambda DNA averaged 99.8%.
Industry observers note that paired-end sequencing reads were pre-processed with Trim Galore! (v.0.6.5) before alignment with Bismark (v.0.24.2) and Bowtie2 (v.2.3.5.1)106 using the ‘non_directional’ option. A reference genome was generated for bisulfite-converted human hg19 (obtained from UCSC). The resulting alignment files were merged and sorted using Samtools (v.1.16.1) and further deduplicated with ‘deduplicate_bismark’, before calling of context-dependent methylation with ‘bismark_methylation_extractor’.
In a recent development, empirical entropy was calculated from read-level methylation patterns using ClubCpG package55. Read clustering of methylation patterns over 100 bp genomic bins was used to determine the observed empirical distribution of DNA methylation states, without imputation for reads that did not fully cover a given bin. As there is no reference methylation pattern for individual cell types in this dataset, we used an empirical entropy estimate to gauge the degree of cell type heterogeneity in each sample, using as the individual pattern probabilities the proportion of reads with that state, and normalizing Plog(P) over 2n, where n is the number of CpGs in the bin. Each bin was assigned a normalized entropy score. Genomic bins were associated with genes (±3 kb from the TSS) using ChIPseeker package107. A list of CGIs was downloaded from the UCSC table browser108 and bedtools intersect function was used to associate with genes (–1,000 bp from TSS – TES (transcription end site), n = 28,170)109. The average entropy was calculated for each CGI, and the functional enrichment for the associated genes was calculated using the enricher function (clusterProfiler package98) comparing with MsigDB genes sets85.
To deconvolute the DNA methylation data compared with the TCGA BRCA dataset51, the methylation status was calculated for each probe in the HumanMethylation450 array (Illumina) using the HumanMethylation450 v.1.2 Manifest File (https://emea.support.illumina.com/downloads/humanmethylation450_15017482_v1-2_product_files.html). The combined dataset (TCGA and this study) was then deconvoluted to different numbers of archetypes using the EDec package (https://github.com/BRL-BCM/EDec)110. The PAM50 information in the TCGA BRCA dataset was used to annotate tumours by subtype. The associated expression data available for the TCGA BRCA dataset were used to correlate expression patterns with each archetype. Genes were ranked according to the Pearson’s correlation coefficient for each archetype, which enabled us to associate each archetype with functional terms using GSEA and the MSigDB Hallmarks gene sets85,111,112.
Sources indicate that simultaneous profiling of chromatin accessibility and gene expression was performed using the Chromium Next GEM Single Cell Multiome ATAC + Gene Expression platform (10x Genomics) following the manufacturer’s protocol. Cryopreserved breast cancer cells were rapidly thawed, gradually diluted in RPMI supplemented with 10% FBS, washed in PBS containing 0.04% BSA and filtered through a 40 μm strainer. Nuclei were isolated using the 10x Genomics nuclei isolation workflow, washed in chilled nucleus wash buffer and resuspended in diluted nucleus buffer. Nucleus suspensions were filtered to remove aggregates and adjusted to the recommended concentration before loading. Approximately 500 nuclei per sample were loaded onto a Chromium controller for tagmentation, barcoding and GEM generation. Gene expression and ATAC libraries were generated according to the manufacturer’s protocol and indexed using 10x Genomics dual-index plates. Library quality and concentration were assessed using Qubit fluorometry and an Agilent TapeStation. Sequencing was performed on an Aviti platform according to 10x Genomics specifications. ATAC–seq data were processed with cellranger-arc (v.2.2.0) and mapped against human genome GRCh38. Gene expression data were processed using cellranger (v.10.0.0).
Previously published scRNA-seq and scATAC–seq data13 were analysed as described by the authors. Only cells annotated as cancer cells, as defined by RNA profiles, were included in the analysis. To visualize gene expression pattern, UCell scores for the indicated signatures were calculated. To account for dropout, the gene signatures were smoothed using a Gaussian kernel with a bandwidth set to the 5th percentile of the Euclidean distance of the point-to-point distances in the normalized gene space. For the basal–luminal index, the z-score difference between the down in luminal versus basal and the up in luminal versus basal signatures59 was computed. For the ATAC–seq data, peaks were called for each sample (only cancer cells) separately, and the WIP fraction was calculated. A lower WIP fraction, corresponding to a greater proportion of fragments outside called peaks, was interpreted as increased epigenetic noise58.
Following CD45 depletion, 1 × 106 cells were resuspended in antibody buffer (20 mM HEPES pH 7.5, 150 mM NaCl, 2 mM EDTA, 0.5 mM spermidine, 0.05% digitonin, 0.01% NP-40, protease inhibitors and 1% BSA), incubated on ice for 3 min and centrifuged for 3 min at 600g to extract nuclei as previously described113. Nuclei were resuspended in antibody buffer supplemented with 10% DMSO and cryopreserved for further analysis.
For CUT&Tag, all washes were made with 500 µl unless otherwise stated and all centrifugations were done using a swinging bucket centrifuge at 600g for 8 min at 4 °C. Around 50,000 to 100,000 nuclei were resuspended in 50 μl antibody buffer (EDTA 2 mM, 20 mM HEPES pH 7.2, NaCl 150 mM, spermidine 0.5 mM, BSA 2%, NP-40 0.01%, digitonin 0.01% and proteases inhibitor 1×) with 1:50 antibody dilution (anti-H3K4me1 D1A9, 5326 and anti-H3K4me3 C42D8, 9751, Cell Signaling) or 0.3 μg (anti-H3K9me2 D85B4 80806, Cell Signaling) and incubated overnight at 4 °C with rotation. Nuclei were washed the next day with Dig-Wash buffer and resuspended in 100 μl Dig-300 buffer (20 mM HEPES pH 7.2, 300 mM NaCl, 0.5 mM spermidine, 2% BSA, 0.01% NP-40 and 0.01% digitonin) together with protein A–Tn5 fusion (Diagenode, C01070001, 1:250) and incubated for 1 h at room temperature with rotation. Nuclei were washed 3 times with Dig-300 buffer, resuspended in 300 µl Tag-Buffer (20 mM HEPES pH 7.2, 300 mM NaCl, 0.5 mM spermidine, 2% BSA, 0.01% NP-40, 0.01% digitonin and 10 mM MgCl2) and incubated for 1 h at 37 °C. Tagmentation was stopped by addition of one volume of 1x diluted nuclei buffer (DNB, 10x Genomics) supplemented with 2% BSA and 12.5 mM EDTA. The nuclei were then centrifuged at 1,300g for 4 min at 4 °C and washed twice with 200 µl 1× DNB supplemented with 2% BSA. The nuclei were resuspended in 10–70 µl of DNB + 2% BSA. Nuclei were loaded on a 10x Chromium system using a 10X Chromium Single Cell ATAC–Seq kit v.2 (10x Genomics) as previously described113. GEM incubation, barcoding and amplification was performed according to the Chromium Single Cell ATAC Library kit manual with 17 PCR cycles. Libraries were amplified with 13 PCR cycles. snCUT&Tag libraries were sequenced on a NovaSeq 6000 (Illumina) in PE50 mode.
Raw sequencing files (Fastq files) were processed using an in-house pipeline (https://github.com/vallotlab/scCUT-Tag_10X) to generate fragment files and to count matrices. In brief, the barcodes are aligned to indexed reference libraries using Bowtie2 (v.2.5.4) and the genomic parts of the reads are aligned to the human reference genome (hg38) using STAR (v.2.7.8a). Duplicate reads, reads mapping to the ENCODE blacklisted regions and reads with low mapping quality (q20) were filtered out.
Next, 50-kb bin matrices were used to generate a joint UMAP representation of all three tumours samples. Tumour microenvironment and tumour cells were annotated based on H3K4me1 or H3K4me3 enrichment at known marker genes (Supplementary Table 7). Owing to the physical removal of CD45+ cells during tumour dissociation, no immune cells could be identified based on H3K4me1 or H3K4me3 profiles. Peaks were called using CallPeaks (Signac)114. Gene activity matrices were generated by aggregating counts across gene bodies and promoter regions extending (–2 kb from the TSS), following the standard Signac approach. These gene-level activity scores were used as features for dimensionality reduction and clustering. Count datasets were normalized using SCTransform115 for each tumour separately. Differential binding occupancies were calculated by two-sided Wilcoxon signed-rank test (FDR-corrected). Functional enrichment was conducted using the enricher function (clusterProfiler package98), with MsigDB gene sets85,116 as references. Epigenomic gene signature scores were computed using UCell117 for each gene set of interest, starting from SCTransform counts. For visualization of gene signatures in UMAP space, to account for dropout, epigenomic gene signature scores were smoothed using a Gaussian kernel with a bandwidth set to the 5th percentile of the Euclidean distance of the point to point distances in the normalized gene space.
To identify loci that contribute to epigenomic intratumour heterogeneity (either H3K4me3 or H3K4me1), the SHAP algorithm was used on a trained XGBoost classifier35. For each tumour, the most contributing genes that led to accurate classification (around 400 genes, about 90% accuracy) were compared against gene signatures from MSigDB85,116.
Recent findings suggest that pseudo-bulk coverage tracks were generated by aggregating fragment-level snCUT&Tag data from cells assigned to each cluster. For each sample and histone mark, fragments corresponding to the basal-like cluster and to all remaining clusters were pooled separately. To enable direct comparison, the non-basal-like group was downsampled to match the total fragment count of the basal-like population. Genome-wide coverage was computed from fragment intervals and normalized to counts per million (CPM), producing bedGraph files that were subsequently converted to bigWig format for visualization. Tracks were visualized using pyGenomeTracks.
Pseudobulk chromatin profiles were generated from single-cell data and used for peak calling with MACS3 (ref. 118), with narrow peak mode applied to H3K4me3 and broad peak mode to H3K4me1. Unified peak sets for each sample and histone modification were annotated using ChIPseeker107, and genomic feature distributions were summarized as percentages of total peaks per sample, with promoter subcategories merged before visualization. Differential association of peaks to clusters was evaluated in a one-versus-rest framework. For each peak, signal presence was binarized and detection fractions were compared between the target population (cluster) and remaining cells using a one-sided two-proportion z-test. Effect sizes were computed as log2 fold change of CPM-normalized mean signal. P values were adjusted using the Benjamini–Hochberg procedure, and peaks were considered significant at adjusted P ≤ 0.05, log2 fold change ≥ 0.25, and a minimum detection rate of 1%.
Recent findings suggest that motif enrichment analysis was performed using the Signac framework114 with transcription factor binding profiles obtained from the JASPAR database119. Motifs associated with a pre-defined list of EMT and basal-like state regulators, defined separately for enhancer (H3K4me1) and promoter (H3K4me3) signals, were examined, using a nominal significance threshold of P < 0.05. Multiple testing correction was computed using the Benjamini–Hochberg procedure in the subset of tested transcription factors per sample, which reflect the reduced hypothesis space.
To compare the read count with gene activity, for each tumour the number of counts per cell (‘nCount_RNA’) per cell was correlated (Pearson’s) with the epigenomic gene signature score (UCell computed on TFIDF normalized115 data).
Industry observers note that using scGLUE120, we performed multimodal integration of the H3K4me1 snCUT&Tag dataset with the CyTOF dataset. For each of the cell-identity markers present in the CyTOF antibody panel, we identified the relevant gene in the gene activity matrix and used those to form the weakly informative connection for scGLUE. After running scGLUE, we trained an XGBoost classifier on the CyTOF data in the joint latent space to predict the cell label and used the classifier to perform label transfer to the snCUT&Tag modality.
Industry observers note that for cell annotation of the H3K9me2 dataset, the complementary H3K4me1 dataset from the same nucleus extraction was used. In brief, 20-kb bin matrices were generated for both H3K4me1 and H3K9me2 datasets, keeping cell labels derived from the H3K4me1 analysis. A classifier was trained on the labelled H3K4me1 dataset, which achieved >95% accuracy, and applied to the inverted z-score matrix of H3K9me2, using the generally opposing genomic distributions of H3K4me1-associated regulatory chromatin and H3K9me2-associated repressive chromatin as an inference framework62,63.
It has been revealed that for gene association analysis, H3K9me2 was analysed without peak calling, as this mark forms broad repressive domains rather than sharp focal peaks. Instead, promoter regions (–2 kb to +200 bp relative to the TSS) were tiled into 200 bp windows, and fragment counts were quantified across these promoter-proximal tiles to generate a promoter occupancy matrix. The resulting matrix was normalized using SCTransform115 and used for UMAP embedding and clustering. Because H3K9me2 is a repressive histone mark, high gene-set scores were interpreted as increased repressive occupancy over the corresponding loci rather than increased transcriptional activity.
Recent findings suggest that blood samples were collected in EDTA tubes and transferred ambient for processing. Plasma was separated by centrifugation and stored at −80 °C.
It has been revealed that PEGylated-biotin-coated and PEGylated-poly(T)-coated microscope slides were prepared as previously described28,29. In brief, glass coverslips were cleaned extensively (sonication rounds with acetone and Alconox), hydroxylated by incubation in 1 M KOH and passivated with amino-silanization chemistry (3% 3-aminopropyltriethoxysilane, 5% acetic acid in HPLC ethanol). Surface functionalization along with the first passivation step was performed by applying mPEG: PEGylated-biotin/PEG-azide solution (10:1 ratio). PEGylated surfaces were further passivated with MS(PEG)4. Anchoring of dT50 to PEGylated-poly(T) surfaces was done via click chemistry (10 µM 5′heyxynyl-dT50 (IDT), 2 mM CuSO4).
Antibodies were labelled using a biotin conjugation kit (Abcam, ab201796) and Alexa Flour antibody-labelling kits (Thermo Fisher Scientific, A20181, A20183 and A20186) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. Labelled antibodies were further purified by size-exclusion chromatography using Bio-Spin 6 columns (Bio-Rad, 7326200). Antibodies are listed in Supplementary Table 5a.
Quantification of the five protein biomarkers was conducted as previously described28. PEGylated-poly(T)-coated coverslips were assembled into a ChipSop flowcell (chip 2-28 mini Luer platform Fl. 342, 30001180), which generated a 14-lane flowcell. Streptavidin solution (0.2 mg ml–1 in PBS) was added to the surface for 15 min and washed with IMB2 (10 mM MES pH 6.5, 60 mM KCl, 0.32 mM EDTA, 3 mM MgCl2, 10% glycerol, 0.1 mg ml–1 BSA and 0.02% Igepal). Biotinylated antibodies were incubated on the surface in IMB2 for 30 min, followed by washing with IMB2. Next, the plasma sample was added to the flowcell and incubated on the surface for 30 min, followed by three washes with IMB2 to allow binding of target proteins. Fluorescently labelled antibodies (detection antibodies) were introduced to the surface for 60 min, washed with IMB2 and imaged.
In a recent development, imaging was performed on a TIRF microscope manufactured by Nikon (Eclipse Ti2-E LU-N4 TIRF) with a CFI apochromat TIRF ×60 objective lens and TRF49904, TRF49909 and TRF89902 filter cubes (Chroma) for the 488 mm, 561 mm and 647 nm lasers, respectively. Images were taken with the ×1.5 magnification setting, which resulted in fields of view (FOVs) of 148 µm × 148 µm using an Andor Zyla 4.2 Plus camera. At least 50 FOVs were imaged per lane.
PEGylated-poly(T)-coated coverslips were assembled into an Ibidi flowcell (Sticky Slide VI hydrophobic, IBIDI), generating a 6-lane flowcell and further passivated with 5% BSA for at least 30 min.
In a recent development, plasma nucleosomes were processed as previously described28 with minor modifications. Nucleosomes were polyA tailed by the following reaction: 20 µl plasma was mixed with 10 µl of 10× Green buffer (Enzymatics), 416 µM CoCl2 (Enzymatics), 1:60 protease inhibitor cocktail (Sigma), 83.3 µM dATP (Thermo Fisher Scientific), 5 µl Klenow Fragment (3′→5′ exo-, NEB), 3 µl T4 polynucleotide kinase (NEB) and 4 µl terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT, Enzymatics). Following incubation at 37 °C for 1 h, TdT in the samples was inactivated by the addition of EDTA at final concentration of 5 mM.
Next, plasma samples containing polyA-tailed cell-free nucleosomes were incubated with antibodies (final concentration 1:60) for 30 min at room temperature to allow for the formation of antibody–cell-free nucleosome complexes. Next, samples were loaded on the surface and incubated for 15 min to allow hybridization of polyA tails to dT50 oligonucleotides. The flowcell was washed once with IMB (12 mM HEPES pH 8 (Thermo Fisher Scientific), 40 mM Tris pH 7.5 (Gibco), 60 mM KCl (Sigma), 0.32 mM EDTA (Invitrogen), 3 mM MgCl2 (Sigma), 10% glycerol (Bio-Lab), 0.1 mg ml–1 BSA (Sigma) and 0.02% Igepal (Sigma)), and cell-free nucleosomes were visualized by hybridizing 25 pM Cy3-dT23 in IMB to the free portion of polyA tails for 10 min. We supplemented Cy3-dT23 solution with TetraSpeck beads (Thermo Fisher Scientific), used as fiducial markers to allow correction for stage drift in image analysis. The flowcell was washed once with IMB, then filled with IMB, followed by time-lapse imaging of 5 cycles every 15 min with the 3 laser channels across all positions.
Industry observers note that imaging was performed on a TIRF microscope as described above obtaining 100 FOV (148 µm2) images per lane or on a high-throughput single-molecule imaging system at Epivision obtaining 100 FOVs (200 µm2) images per lane. The focus was maintained throughout the run using IR-assisted autofocus system.
Sources indicate that image analysis was performed with the open-source software CellProfiler (v.3.1.9; http://www.cellprofiler.org/) as previously described28. In brief, time-lapse images of antibody-binding events and TetraSpeck beads were aligned, stacked and summed to one image. Antibody spots can be differentiated from TetraSpeck bead spots based on spot size and intensity. Summed antibody images were aligned with cell-free nucleosome images to count colocalization events. For biomarkers analysis, antibody binding events were quantified. To minimize the surface batch effects, signals were normalized to the surface activity (average antibody signal across all lanes of the surface).
PPS analysis on the data was conducted using a previously published algorithm (https://github.com/8080labs/ppscore). In brief, by calculating a cross-validated decision tree (repeated (10,000) 4-fold cross-validation) for the target variable (for example, diagnosis) using only one of the markers, it is possible to determine which of the markers in the datasets contributes most to the target variable.
XGBoost classifier was applied to the data, using all features measured and their combinations. Feature contribution was assessed by SHAP.
It has been revealed that for ROC curves, for each classification task, the most important features were selected using the Boruta algorithm (with a random forest classifier)121. An additional feature engineering step was used to generate combinatorial combinations (multiplication, division and SQRT) of the selected features, and another round of feature selection was performed using Boruta. The final features selected were used either in a random forest classifier or in a soft voting classifier consisting of RF, XGBoost and LDA classifiers. The final classifier was used to generate a ROC curve with the associated confidence intervals using 10-fold cross-validation and 1,000 bootstrap repeats.
According to recent reports, to enable comparison across independently processed EPINUC cohorts, batch correction was applied to account for differences in antibody labelling degree. In brief, the reference dataset was subsampled to balance group sizes, and feature-wise means and standard deviations were calculated. The independently processed cohort was first standardized and subsequently rescaled to match the mean and variance of the reference dataset. This approach allowed alignment of feature distributions across cohorts while preserving relative differences between samples.
Recent findings suggest that histones were enriched from FFPE tissues as previously described122. Approximately 4 µg of histone octamer was mixed with an equal amount of heavy-isotope labelled histones, which were used as an internal standard123, and separated on a 17% SDS–PAGE gel. Histone bands were excised, chemically acylated with deuterated acetic anhydride and in-gel digested with trypsin124. The samples were separated by reversed-phase chromatography, acquired on a Q Exactive HF instrument (Thermo Fisher Scientific), and analysed using MaxQuant and QualBrowser, as previously described124. For each histone modified peptide, a percentage relative abundance (%RA) value for the sample (light channel) or the internal standard (heavy channel) was estimated. Light to heavy ratios (log2 transformed) of %RA were then calculated and are reported in Supplementary Table 8.
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article.
According to recent reports, raw CyTOF and EPINUC measurements are available at Zenodo (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15336152)125. Owing to protection of personal data requirements, the patient-derived sequencing data generated in this study have been deposited into the European Genome-phenome Archive, under controlled access, with accession ID EGAS50000002070. Access is subject to approval by the Weizmann Breast Cancer Epigenetics Data Access Committee, consistent with participant consent and ethical approvals. The MARS-seq and H3K4me1 CUT&Tag data of sorted cells have been deposited into the Gene Expression Omnibus under accession GSE334437. The MS histone PTM data have been deposited into the ProteomeXchange Consortium via the PRIDE126 partner repository with the dataset identifier PXD057150. Publicly available data and resources used in this study include the TCGA BRCA cohort (dbGaP Study Accession phs000178, Firehose stddata__2016_01_28, https://doi.org/10.7908/C11G0KM9), a breast cancer single-cell multiome dataset13 (GSE243526), JASPAR transcription-factor binding profiles119 and scRNA-seq data of human normal mammary epithelial cells50 (GSE180878). Source data are provided with this paper.
The code used for the analyses of WGBS, snCUT&Tag and EPINUC data is available at Zenodo (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15336152)125. The CyTOF analysis code is available at Zenodo (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21982487)127.
Siegel, R. L., Miller, K. D., Fuchs, H. E. & Jemal, A. Cancer statistics, 2022. CA Cancer J. Clin. 72, 7–33 https://doi.org/10.3322/caac.21708 (2022).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
Perou, C. M. et al. Molecular portraits of human breast tumours. Nature 406, 747–752 https://doi.org/10.1038/35021093 (2000).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, sørlie, T. et al. Gene expression patterns of breast carcinomas distinguish tumor subclasses with clinical implications. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 98, 10869–10874 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.191367098 (2001).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Laisné, M., Lupien, M. & Vallot, C. Epigenomic heterogeneity as a source of tumour evolution. Nat. Rev. Cancer 25, 7–26 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41568-024-00757-9 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Mazor, T., Pankov, A., Song, J. S. & Costello, J. F. Intratumoral heterogeneity of the epigenome. Cancer Cell 29, 440–451 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ccell.2016.03.009 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Baslan, T. et al. Novel insights into breast cancer copy number genetic heterogeneity revealed by single-cell genome sequencing. eLife 9, e51480 https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.51480 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, mardamshina, M. et al. Integrated spatial proteomic analysis of breast cancer heterogeneity unravels cancer cell phenotypic plasticity. Nat. Commun. 16, 10482 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-65477-6 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, rueda, O. M. et al. Dynamics of breast-cancer relapse reveal late-recurring ER-positive genomic subgroups. Nature 567, 399–404 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-019-1007-8 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that yeo, S. K. & Guan, J. L. Breast cancer: multiple subtypes within a tumor? Trends Cancer 3, 753–760 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.trecan.2017.09.001 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that kouzarides, T. Chromatin modifications and their function. Cell 128, 693–705 (2007).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Rivera, C. M. & Ren, B. Mapping human epigenomes. Cell 155, 39–55 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2013.09.011 (2013).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that strahl, B. D. & Allis, C. D. The language of covalent histone modifications. Nature 403, 41–45 https://doi.org/10.1038/47412 (2000).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Regner, M. J. et al. Defining the regulatory logic of breast cancer using single-cell epigenetic and transcriptome profiling. Cell Genomics 5, 100765 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.xgen.2025.100765 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Wu, S. Z. et al. A single-cell and spatially resolved atlas of human breast cancers. Nat. Genet. 53, 1334–1347 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41588-021-00911-1 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, buenrostro, J. D. et al. Single-cell chromatin accessibility reveals principles of regulatory variation. Nature 523, 486–490 https://doi.org/10.1038/nature14590 (2015).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that iglesia, M. D. et al. Differential chromatin accessibility and transcriptional dynamics define breast cancer subtypes and their lineages. Nat. Cancer 5, 1713–1736 https://doi.org/10.1038/s43018-024-00773-6 (2024).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Alcolea, M. P. et al. Cancer hallmarks: piecing the puzzle together. Cancer Discov. 14, 674–682 https://doi.org/10.1158/2159-8290.Cd-24-0097 (2024).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that grosselin, K. et al. High-throughput single-cell ChIP–seq identifies heterogeneity of chromatin states in breast cancer. Nat. Genet. 51, 1060–1066 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41588-019-0424-9 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that marsolier, J. et al. H3K27me3 conditions chemotolerance in triple-negative breast cancer. Nat. Genet. 54, 459–468 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41588-022-01047-6 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Harpaz, N. et al. Single-cell epigenetic analysis reveals principles of chromatin states in H3.3-K27M gliomas. Mol. Cell 82, 2696–2713 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2022.05.023 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Aylon, Y. et al. Breast cancer plasticity is restricted by a LATS1–NCOR1 repressive axis. Nat. Commun. 13, 7199 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-34863-9 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, furth, N. et al. Oncogenic IDH1mut drives robust loss of histone acetylation and increases chromatin heterogeneity. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 122, e2403862122 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2403862122 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Griess, O. et al. Mutant EZH2 alters the epigenetic network and increases epigenetic heterogeneity in B cell lymphoma. PLoS Biol. 23, e3003191 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pbio.3003191 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that lui, Y. Y. et al. Predominant hematopoietic origin of cell-free DNA in plasma and serum after sex-mismatched bone marrow transplantation. Clin. Chem. 48, 421–427 (2002).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, van der Pol, Y. & Mouliere, F. Toward the early detection of cancer by decoding the epigenetic and environmental fingerprints of cell-free DNA. Cancer Cell 36, 350–368 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ccell.2019.09.003 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Gezer, U. & Holdenrieder, S. Post-translational histone modifications in circulating nucleosomes as latest biomarkers in colorectal cancer. In Vivo 28, 287–292 (2014).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that snyder, M. W., Kircher, M., Hill, A. J., Daza, R. M. & Shendure, J. Cell-free DNA comprises an in vivo nucleosome footprint that informs its tissues-of-origin. Cell 164, 57–68 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2015.11.050 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Fedyuk, V. et al. Multiplexed, single-molecule, epigenetic analysis of plasma-isolated nucleosomes for cancer diagnostics. Nat. Biotechnol. 41, 212–221 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-022-01447-3 (2023).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, erez, N. et al. Single-molecule systems for the detection and monitoring of plasma-circulating nucleosomes and oncoproteins in diffuse midline glioma. Cell Rep. Med. 6, 101918 (2025).
Recent findings suggest that lundberg, S. M. et al. From local explanations to global understanding with explainable AI for trees. Nat. Mach. Intell. 2, 56–67 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42256-019-0138-9 (2020).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Lundberg, S. M. & Lee, S.-I. A unified approach to interpreting model predictions. In Proc. 31st International Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems 4768–4777 (Curran Associates, 2017).
It has been revealed that nielsen, T. O. et al. A comparison of PAM50 intrinsic subtyping with immunohistochemistry and clinical prognostic factors in tamoxifen-treated estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer. Clin. Cancer Res. 16, 5222–5232 https://doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.Ccr-10-1282 (2010).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Ali, H. R. et al. Imaging mass cytometry and multiplatform genomics define the phenogenomic landscape of breast cancer. Nat. Cancer 1, 163–175 https://doi.org/10.1038/s43018-020-0026-6 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, georgopoulou, D. et al. Landscapes of cellular phenotypic diversity in breast cancer xenografts and their impact on drug response. Nat. Commun. 12, 1998 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-22303-z (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that chen, T. & Guestrin, C. XGBoost: a scalable tree boosting system. In Proc. 22nd ACM SIGKDD International Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining 785–794 (Association for Computing Machinery, 2016).
In a recent development, parreno, V., Martinez, A.-M. & Cavalli, G. Mechanisms of Polycomb group protein function in cancer. Cell Res. 32, 231–253 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41422-021-00606-6 (2022).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Chang, C.-J. et al. EZH2 promotes expansion of breast tumor initiating cells through activation of RAF1–β-catenin signaling. Cancer Cell 19, 86–100 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ccr.2010.10.035 (2011).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, chan, H. L. & Morey, L. Emerging roles for Polycomb-group proteins in stem cells and cancer. Trends Biochem. Sci. 44, 688–700 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tibs.2019.04.005 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that noberini, R. et al. A histone-centric multi-omics study reveals that increased H3K4 methylation sustains triple-negative breast cancer phenotypes. Nat. Commun. 16, 8716 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-63745-z (2025).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Yamamoto, S. et al. JARID1B is a luminal lineage-driving oncogene in breast cancer. Cancer Cell 25, 762–777 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ccr.2014.04.024 (2014).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that haque, R. et al. Impact of breast cancer subtypes and treatment on survival: an analysis spanning two decades. Cancer Epidemiol. Biomarkers Prev. 21, 1848–1855 https://doi.org/10.1158/1055-9965.Epi-12-0474 (2012).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that parker, J. S. et al. Supervised risk predictor of breast cancer based on intrinsic subtypes. J. Clin. Oncol. 27, 1160–1167 https://doi.org/10.1200/jco.2008.18.1370 (2009).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, prat, A. & Perou, C. M. Deconstructing the molecular portraits of breast cancer. Mol. Oncol. 5, 5–23 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molonc.2010.11.003 (2011).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, barroso-Sousa, R. et al. Prevalence and mutational determinants of high tumor mutation burden in breast cancer. Ann. Oncol. 31, 387–394 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.annonc.2019.11.010 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, haricharan, S., Bainbridge, M. N., Scheet, P. & Brown, P. H. Somatic mutation load of estrogen receptor-positive breast tumors predicts overall survival: an analysis of genome sequence data. Breast Cancer Res. Treat. 146, 211–220 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10549-014-2991-x (2014).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that neftel, C. et al. An integrative model of cellular states, plasticity, and genetics for glioblastoma. Cell 178, 835–849 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2019.06.024 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Kwon, T. et al. Mechanism of histone lysine methyl transfer revealed by the structure of SET7/9–AdoMet. EMBO J. 22, 292–303 https://doi.org/10.1093/emboj/cdg025 (2003).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that xiao, B. et al. Structure and catalytic mechanism of the human histone methyltransferase SET7/9. Nature 421, 652–656 https://doi.org/10.1038/nature01378 (2003).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Black, J. C., Van Rechem, C. & Whetstine, J. R. Histone lysine methylation dynamics: establishment, regulation, and biological impact. Mol. Cell 48, 491–507 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2012.11.006 (2012).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Gray, G. K. et al. A human breast atlas integrating single-cell proteomics and transcriptomics. Dev. Cell 57, 1400–1420 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.devcel.2022.05.003 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that koboldt, D. C. et al. Comprehensive molecular portraits of human breast tumours. Nature 490, 61–70 https://doi.org/10.1038/nature11412 (2012).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sarrió, D. et al. Epithelial–mesenchymal transition in breast cancer relates to the basal-like phenotype. Cancer Res. 68, 989–997 https://doi.org/10.1158/0008-5472.Can-07-2017 (2008).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
Aleskandarany, M. A. et al. Epithelial mesenchymal transition in early invasive breast cancer: an immunohistochemical and reverse phase protein array study. Breast Cancer Res. Treat. 145, 339–348 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10549-014-2927-5 (2014).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Chung, W. et al. Single-cell RNA-seq enables comprehensive tumour and immune cell profiling in primary breast cancer. Nat. Commun. 8, 15081 https://doi.org/10.1038/ncomms15081 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, scott, C. A. et al. Identification of cell type-specific methylation signals in bulk whole genome bisulfite sequencing data. Genome Biol. 21, 156 https://doi.org/10.1186/s13059-020-02065-5 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that jones, P. A. Functions of DNA methylation: islands, start sites, gene bodies and beyond. Nat. Rev. Genet. 13, 484–492 https://doi.org/10.1038/nrg3230 (2012).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that riobo-Del Galdo, N. A., Lara Montero, Á & Wertheimer, E. V. Role of Hedgehog signaling in breast cancer: pathogenesis and therapeutics. Cells 8, 375 https://doi.org/10.3390/cells8040375 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that gamble, N. et al. Thymic epithelial cells amplify epigenetic noise to promote immune tolerance. Nature 646, 724–733 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-025-09424-x (2025).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Charafe-Jauffret, E. et al. Gene expression profiling of breast cell lines identifies potential new basal markers. Oncogene 25, 2273–2284 https://doi.org/10.1038/sj.onc.1209254 (2006).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Wu, S. J. et al. Single-cell CUT&Tag analysis of chromatin modifications in differentiation and tumor progression. Nat. Biotechnol. 39, 819–824 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-021-00865-z (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Raimundo, F., Prompsy, P., Vert, J.-P. & Vallot, C. A benchmark of computational pipelines for single-cell histone modification data. Genome Biol. 24, 143 https://doi.org/10.1186/s13059-023-02981-2 (2023).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Zylicz, J. J. et al. Chromatin dynamics and the role of G9a in gene regulation and enhancer silencing during early mouse development. eLife 4, e09571 https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.09571 (2015).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Wen, B., Wu, H., Shinkai, Y., Irizarry, R. A. & Feinberg, A. P. Large histone H3 lysine 9 dimethylated chromatin blocks distinguish differentiated from embryonic stem cells. Nat. Genet. 41, 246–250 https://doi.org/10.1038/ng.297 (2009).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that moisini, I., Zhang, H., D’Aguiar, M., Hicks, D. G. & Turner, B. M. L1CAM expression in recurrent estrogen positive/HER2 negative breast cancer: a novel biomarker worth considering. Appl. Immunohistochem. Mol. Morphol. 29, 287–292 https://doi.org/10.1097/pai.0000000000000909 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Doberstein, K. et al. L1CAM is expressed in triple-negative breast cancers and is inversely correlated with androgen receptor. BMC Cancer 14, 958 https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2407-14-958 (2014).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that li, J. et al. Tumor markers CA15-3, CA125, CEA and breast cancer survival by molecular subtype: a cohort study. Breast Cancer 27, 621–630 https://doi.org/10.1007/s12282-020-01058-3 (2020).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, wang, B. et al. Combined low levels of H4K16ac and H4K20me3 predicts poor prognosis in breast cancer. Int. J. Clin. Oncol. 28, 1147–1157 https://doi.org/10.1007/s10147-023-02378-y (2023).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, brown, R., Curry, E., Magnani, L., Wilhelm-Benartzi, C. S. & Borley, J. Poised epigenetic states and acquired drug resistance in cancer. Nat. Rev. Cancer 14, 747–753 https://doi.org/10.1038/nrc3819 (2014).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that li, X. et al. YAP inhibits ERα and ER+ breast cancer growth by disrupting a TEAD–ERα signaling axis. Nat. Commun. 13, 3075 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-30831-5 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that pal, D. et al. H4K16ac activates the transcription of transposable elements and contributes to their cis-regulatory function. Nat. Struct. Mol. Biol. 30, 935–947 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41594-023-01016-5 (2023).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
He, J. et al. Transposable elements are regulated by context-specific patterns of chromatin marks in mouse embryonic stem cells. Nat. Commun. 10, 34 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-018-08006-y (2019).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that boyd, N. F. et al. Mammographic density and the risk and detection of breast cancer. N. Engl. J. Med. 356, 227–236 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa062790 (2007).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that kerlikowske, K. et al. Identifying women with dense breasts at high risk for interval cancer: a cohort study. Ann. Intern. Med. 162, 673–681 https://doi.org/10.7326/m14-1465 (2015).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, paik, S. et al. A multigene assay to predict recurrence of tamoxifen-treated, node-negative breast cancer. N. Engl. J. Med. 351, 2817–2826 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa041588 (2004).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Boxer, E. et al. Emerging clinical applications of single-cell RNA sequencing in oncology. Nat. Rev. Clin. Oncol. 22, 315–326 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41571-025-01003-3 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, mcQuerry, J. A., Chang, J. T., Bowtell, D. D. L., Cohen, A. & Bild, A. H. Mechanisms and clinical implications of tumor heterogeneity and convergence on recurrent phenotypes. J. Mol. Med. 95, 1167–1178 https://doi.org/10.1007/s00109-017-1587-4 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Restellini, C. et al. Alternative digestion approaches improve histone modification mapping by mass spectrometry in clinical samples. Proteomics Clin. Appl. 13, e1700166 https://doi.org/10.1002/prca.201700166 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, noberini, R., Uggetti, A., Pruneri, G., Minucci, S. & Bonaldi, T. Pathology tissue-quantitative mass spectrometry analysis to profile histone post-translational modification patterns in patient samples. Mol. Cell. Proteomics 15, 866–877 https://doi.org/10.1074/mcp.M115.054510 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Siu, A. L. et al. Screening for breast cancer: U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommendation statement. Ann. Intern. Med. 164, 279–296 https://doi.org/10.7326/m15-2886 (2016).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, elezaby, M. et al. BRCA mutation carriers: breast and ovarian cancer screening guidelines and imaging considerations. Radiology 291, 554–569 https://doi.org/10.1148/radiol.2019181814 (2019).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that anaby, D. et al. ‘Earlier than early’ detection of breast cancer in Israeli BRCA mutation carriers applying AI-based analysis to consecutive MRI scans. Cancers 15, 3120 (2023).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, drukteinis, J. S., Mooney, B. P., Flowers, C. I. & Gatenby, R. A. Beyond mammography: upcoming frontiers in breast cancer screening. Am. J. Med. 126, 472–479 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amjmed.2012.11.025 (2013).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Bidard, F.-C. et al. First-line camizestrant for emerging ESR1-mutated advanced breast cancer. N. Engl. J. Med. 393, 569–580 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2502929 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, van den Ackerveken, P. et al. A novel proteomics approach to epigenetic profiling of circulating nucleosomes. Sci. Rep. 11, 7256 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-86630-3 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, liberzon, A. et al. The Molecular Signatures Database (MSigDB) hallmark gene set collection. Cell Syst. 1, 417–425 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cels.2015.12.004 (2015).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that van 't Veer, L. et al. Gene expression profiling predicts clinical outcome of breast cancer. Nature 415, 530–536 (2002).
Sources indicate that schuetz, C. S. et al. Progression-specific genes identified by expression profiling of matched ductal carcinomas in situ and invasive breast tumors, combining laser capture microdissection and oligonucleotide microarray analysis. Cancer Res. 66, 5278–5286 (2006).
Ben-Porath, I. et al. An embryonic stem cell–like gene expression signature in poorly differentiated aggressive human tumors. Nat. Genet. 40, 499–507 (2008).
Ben-David, U. et al. Genetic and transcriptional evolution alters cancer cell line drug response. Nature 560, 325–330 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-018-0409-3 (2018).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Bankhead, P. et al. QuPath: open source software for digital pathology image analysis. Sci. Rep. 7, 16878 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-017-17204-5 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Pachitariu, M., Rariden, M. & Stringer, C. Cellpose-SAM: superhuman generalization for cellular segmentation. Preprint at bioRxiv https://doi.org/10.1101/2025.04.28.651001 (2025).
Li, M. M. et al. Standards and guidelines for the interpretation and reporting of sequence variants in cancer: a joint consensus recommendation of the Association for Molecular Pathology, American Society of Clinical Oncology, and College of American Pathologists. J. Mol. Diagn. 19, 4–23 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmoldx.2016.10.002 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that bagwell, C. B. et al. Automated data cleanup for mass cytometry. Cytometry A 97, 184–198 https://doi.org/10.1002/cyto.a.23926 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
McInnes, L., Healy, J. & Melville, J. UMAP: uniform manifold approximation and projection for dimension reduction. Preprint at https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1802.03426 (2020).
Sources indicate that ester, M., Kriegel, H.-P., Sander, J. & Xu, X. A density-based algorithm for discovering clusters in large spatial databases with noise. In Proc. Second International Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining 226–231 (AAAI Press, 1996).
Friedman, J. & Dieng, A. B. 2023. The Vendi Score: a diversity evaluation metric for machine learning. Preprint at https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2210.02410 (2023).
Demichev, V., Messner, C. B., Vernardis, S. I., Lilley, K. S. & Ralser, M. DIA-NN: neural networks and interference correction enable deep proteome coverage in high throughput. Nat. Methods 17, 41–44 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41592-019-0638-x (2020).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Yu, G., Wang, L.-G., Han, Y. & He, Q.-Y. clusterProfiler: an R Package for comparing biological themes among gene clusters. OMICS 16, 284–287 https://doi.org/10.1089/omi.2011.0118 (2012).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Martin, M. Cutadapt removes adapter sequences from high-throughput sequencing reads. EMBnet J. 17, 10–12 https://doi.org/10.14806/ej.17.1.200 (2011).
Article Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that xi, Y. & Li, W. BSMAP: whole genome bisulfite sequence MAPping program. BMC Bioinformatics 10, 232 https://doi.org/10.1186/1471-2105-10-232 (2009).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that mcKenna, A. et al. The Genome Analysis Toolkit: a MapReduce framework for analyzing next-generation DNA sequencing data. Genome Res. 20, 1297–1303 https://doi.org/10.1101/gr.107524.110 (2010).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sun, D. et al. MOABS: model based analysis of bisulfite sequencing data. Genome Biol. 15, R38 https://doi.org/10.1186/gb-2014-15-2-r38 (2014).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that hetzel, S., Giesselmann, P., Reinert, K., Meissner, A. & Kretzmer, H. RLM: fast and simplified extraction of read-level methylation metrics from bisulfite sequencing data. Bioinformatics 37, 3934–3935 https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btab663 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Jaitin, D. A. et al. Massively parallel single-cell RNA-seq for marker-free decomposition of tissues into cell types. Science 343, 776–779 (2014).
Industry observers note that kohen, R. et al. UTAP: user-friendly transcriptome analysis pipeline. BMC Bioinformatics 20, 154 https://doi.org/10.1186/s12859-019-2728-2 (2019).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that krueger, F. & Andrews, S. R. Bismark: a flexible aligner and methylation caller for bisulfite-seq applications. Bioinformatics 27, 1571–1572 https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btr167 (2011).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that yu, G., Wang, L.-G. & He, Q.-Y. ChIPseeker: an R/Bioconductor package for ChIP peak annotation, comparison and visualization. Bioinformatics 31, 2382–2383 https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btv145 (2015).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Karolchik, D. et al. The UCSC Table Browser data retrieval tool. Nucleic Acids Res. 32, D493–D496 https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkh103 (2004).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, quinlan, A. R. & Hall, I. M. BEDTools: a flexible suite of utilities for comparing genomic features. Bioinformatics 26, 841–842 https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btq033 (2010).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that onuchic, V. et al. Epigenomic deconvolution of breast tumors reveals metabolic coupling between constituent cell types. Cell Rep. 17, 2075–2086 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2016.10.057 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, korotkevich, G. et al. Fast gene set enrichment analysis. Preprint at bioRxiv https://doi.org/10.1101/060012 (2021).
Subramanian, A. et al. Gene set enrichment analysis: a knowledge-based approach for interpreting genome-wide expression profiles. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 102, 15545–15550 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0506580102 (2005).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that bartosovic, M., Kabbe, M. & Castelo-Branco, G. Single-cell CUT&Tag profiles histone modifications and transcription factors in complex tissues. Nat. Biotechnol. 39, 825–835 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-021-00869-9 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that stuart, T., Srivastava, A., Madad, S., Lareau, C. A. & Satija, R. Single-cell chromatin state analysis with Signac. Nat. Methods 18, 1333–1341 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41592-021-01282-5 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, hao, Y. et al. Dictionary learning for integrative, multimodal and scalable single-cell analysis. Nat. Biotechnol. 42, 293–304 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-023-01767-y (2023).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that liberzon, A. et al. Molecular signatures database (MSigDB) 3.0. Bioinformatics 27, 1739–1740 https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btr260 (2011).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that andreatta, M. & Carmona, S. J. UCell: robust and scalable single-cell gene signature scoring. Comput. Struct. Biotechnol. J. 19, 3796–3798 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.csbj.2021.06.043 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that zhang, Y. et al. Model-based analysis of ChIP-Seq (MACS). Genome Biol. 9, R137 https://doi.org/10.1186/gb-2008-9-9-r137 (2008).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that castro-Mondragon, J. A. et al. JASPAR 2022: the 9th release of the open-access database of transcription factor binding profiles. Nucleic Acids Res. 50, D165–D173 https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkab1113 (2021).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Cao, Z.-J. & Gao, G. Multi-omics single-cell data integration and regulatory inference with graph-linked embedding. Nat. Biotechnol. 40, 1458–1466 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41587-022-01284-4 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Kursa, M. B. & Rudnicki, W. R. Feature selection with the Boruta package. J. Stat. Softw. 36, 1–13 https://doi.org/10.18637/jss.v036.i11 (2010).
Article Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that noberini, R., Restellini, C., Savoia, E. O. & Bonaldi, T. Enrichment of histones from patient samples for mass spectrometry-based analysis of post-translational modifications. Methods 184, 19–28 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ymeth.2019.10.001 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, noberini, R. & Bonaldi, T. A super-SILAC strategy for the accurate and multiplexed profiling of histone posttranslational modifications. Methods Enzymol. 586, 311–332 https://doi.org/10.1016/bs.mie.2016.09.036 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Noberini, R. et al. PAT-H-MS coupled with laser microdissection to study histone post-translational modifications in selected cell populations from pathology samples. Clin. Epigenetics 9, 69 https://doi.org/10.1186/s13148-017-0369-8 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Ron, G., Furth, N., & Shema, E. Epigenetic heterogeneity in breast tumors with implications for disease diagnosis and monitoring. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.15336152 (2025).
Recent findings suggest that perez-Riverol, Y. et al. The PRIDE database resources in 2022: a hub for mass spectrometry-based proteomics evidences. Nucleic Acids Res. 50, D543–D552 https://doi.org/10.1093/nar/gkab1038 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Ron, G. CyTOF analysis code for: epigenetic heterogeneity in breast tumors with implications for disease diagnosis and monitoring (version v1.0.0) [computer software]. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21982487 (2026).
Industry observers note that we thank U. Ben-David for sharing MCF7 single-cell-derived clones; I. Ben-Porath for sharing HCC70, HCC1937 and SUM149 cell lines; and V. Holiar, S. Lebon and M. Biton for their assistance with cell sorting.
Industry observers note that C.R. was supported by a postdoctoral fellowship from the Azrieli Foundation. This research was supported by grants from the European Research Council (ERC101115455 to E.S. and ERC101044574 to T.G.), The Israeli Science Foundation (1349/24 to E.S.), the German-Israeli Cooperation in Cancer Research (to E.S. and G.R.), Israel Cancer Research Fund-Diane and a Guilford Glazer Foundation Acceleration Grant (to E.S. and G.R.), ERA-NET Sustained collaboration of national and regional programmes in cancer research (to E.S.), TRANSCAN-3 Joint Transnational Call (EPIPROPER, to E.S., T.B. and C.V.), an Emerson Collective, Minerva Research grant, the Swiss Society Institute for Cancer Prevention Research, Magnus Konow in Honor of his mother Olga Konow Rappaport and the Fundación Alberto Palatchi (to E.S.).
These authors contributed equally: Noa Furth, Christina Riemenschneider, Yishai Arieli.
Department of Immunology and Regenerative Biology, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel.
Noa Furth, Christina Riemenschneider, Matan Avni, Michael-Yakov Povolotski, Hadas Yung, Nir Erez & Efrat Shema.
Racah Institute of Physics, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem, Israel.
Department of Molecular Cell Biology, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel.
Shiri Karagach, Ofir Atrakchi & Tamar Geiger.
Mass Cytometry Unit, Department of Life Sciences Core Facilities, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel.
Department of Experimental Oncology, European Institute of Oncology IRCCS, Milan, Italy.
Roberta Noberini & Tiziana Bonaldi.
UMR3244, Translational Department, Institut Curie, PSL University, Paris, France.
Adeline Durand, Grégoire Jouault & Celine Vallot.
Bioinformatics Unit, Department of Life Sciences Core Facilities, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel.
Department of Veterinary Resources, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel.
Department of Life Sciences Core Facilities, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel.
Department of Surgery A, Kaplan Medical Center, Rehovot, Israel.
The Center for Breast Health, Kaplan Medical Center, Rehovot, Israel.
Orli Friedman-Eldar, Hadas Kadar-Sfarad & Osnat Givon-Madhala.
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, Kaplan Medical Center, Rehovot, Israel.
Department of Pathology, Kaplan Medical Center, Rehovot, Israel.
Naama Ronel, Faisal Abu-Rmilah, Itai Moshe, Shahar Ish-Shalom & Ady Yosepovich.
Breast Oncology Institute, Sheba Medical Center, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Miriam Kaplan, Michal Bakalenik, Maya Dadiani & Einav Nili Gal-Yam.
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Johns Hopkins Whiting School of Engineering, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Rakel Tryggvadottir, Gabriel Shatkin & Andrew P. Feinberg.
Max Planck Institute for Molecular Genetics, Berlin, Germany.
In a recent development, mariam Hakobyan, Alexander Kovacsovics, Sebastian D. Mackowiak, Alexander Meissner & Efrat Shema.
Cancer Clinical Studies Unit, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL, USA.
Department of Surgery, Mayo Clinic, Jacksonville, FL, USA.
Epivision Genetics, Boston, MA, USA.
Ekaterina Andreishcheva, Abhijeet Shinde, Jiaren Zhang & Daniel Jones.
Department of Oncology and Haemato-Oncology, University of Milan, Milan, Italy.
Department of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Center for Epigenetics, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that N.F., G.R. and E.S. designed the study. N.F. and C.R. processed tumour samples and performed CyTOF experiments. Y.A. established the CyTOF analysis framework. C.R. conducted all cell culture experiments. M.A., M.-Y.P., H.Y., N.E., E.A., A.S., J.Z. and D.J. contributed to EPINUC analyses. S.K., O.A. and T.G. contributed to MS analysis of sorted tumour cells. T.M.S. assisted with CyTOF experiments. R.N. and T.B. contributed to MS analysis of histone PTMs. A.D., G.J. and C.V. contributed to snCUT&Tag analyses. B.D., R.T., G.S. and A.P.F. contributed to WGBS analysis. O.G. assisted with image analyses. M.H. and S.D.M. performed single-cell multiome analyses. M.H., A.K., S.D.M. and A.M. contributed to EM-seq analysis of sorted cells. M.Z. and R.O. provided PDX models. I.M. conducted the TruSight Oncology 500 assay. B.B.-Z., Y.M., O.F.-E., H.K.-S., S.G., O.G.-M., N.R., F.A.-R., S.I.-S., A.Y., A.A., S.M., M.K., M.B., M.D. and E.N.G.-Y. provided tumour and blood samples. N.F., Y.A., C.R., E.S. and G.R. analysed datasets. N.F., G.R. and E.S. wrote the manuscript.
Correspondence to Guy Ron or Efrat Shema.
Yeda Research and Development has filed a US Provisional patent application US-20240352538-A1: ‘Methods and Kits for Analyzing Nucleosomes and Plasma Proteins’, which are related to Figs. 4 and 5 of this paper, and describe the isolation and imaging of cell-free nucleosomes from plasma (the EPINUC technology). E.S., N.E., A.S., K.A. and D.J. are named inventors. Epivision Genetics holds exclusive licence to the patent application related to this work. The remaining authors declare no competing interests.
Nature thanks Michail Ignatiadis, who co-reviewed with Jana Jeschke; Lluis Morey, who co-reviewed with Liliana Garcia Martinez; Heather Parsons; and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
It has been revealed that (a) Tumors 4 and 7 analyzed as in Fig. 1h. Cells are colored by classification or the indicated feature levels. (b) Heatmap of mean feature levels in each subpopulation across all HR+ tumors analyzed by CyTOF (n = 14, including 3 anchor repeats, see Table S3). Rows present standardized values. (c) Two luminal PDX models analyzed by CyTOF after removal of mouse cells (human CD298-positive; mouse MHC class 1-negative), and classification into three subpopulations (Fig. 1j). PDX-1 comprised of six tumors, with equal cell sampling per tumor; PDX-2 comprised of one tumor. Heatmaps show the mean feature levels within each subpopulation for each model. (d) UMAP of MCF7 CyTOF data using all measured markers. Points are colored by cluster (left) or the indicated feature or signature (right).
(a) Distribution of DBSACN-defined cell subpopulations across independent MCF7 CyTOF experiments of MCF7 cells, showing consistent proportions of the different cell states. (b) UMAP representation and DBSCAN clustering of two different MCF7 parental cells or single-cell derived clones analyzed by CyTOF, using only epigenetic features. Points are colored by the classification of different subpopulations or the expression levels of the indicated feature or signature (PermCell). (c) The distribution of cells among the populations defined by DBSCAN clustering in the MCF7 parental (p) or single-cell derived clones (c). The single-cell derived clones recapitulate the entire spectrum of heterogeneity observed in the parental population. (d) UMAP representation of CyTOF analysis of six independently grown tumors from the PDX-1 model (n = 6 tumors, each grown in a different mouse), colored by subpopulations. Cells from each individual tumor are mapped onto the joint UMAP, and the distribution of cells among the three subpopulations for each tumor is shown.
(a) Confusion matrix of XGBoost model predictions for all 3 subpopulations across HR+ tumors (n = 14) using only epigenetic features, excluding cell identity markers. Rows were normalized to show predictions as percentages of cells within each true class. (b) Representative examples of XGBoost-based noise prediction procedure. UMAPs of individual tumors are shown before (left) and after (right) prediction. Points are colored by classification; non-clustered cells before prediction, or cells in which prediction confidence <95% are marked in gray. (c-d) XGBoost models distinguishing Cycling cells from all other tumor cells (c) or specifically the basal-like cells (d) within the HR+ CyTOF cohort. SHAP scores show feature contributions to classification, ranked in descending order. (e) Percentage of proliferating cells (assessed by the levels of pRb, as in Fig. S3) in each epigenetic sub-populations (Cycling, luminal and basal-like). The basal-like and luminal sub-populations do not differ due to differences in the proliferative state. (f) The differences in the average levels of the indicated features between the basal-like and luminal sub-populations in the luminal PDX models. Basal-like cells show a recurrent pattern of both up and downregulated histone PTMs, highly similar to the pattern observed in fresh human tumors.
(a) UMAP of CyTOF data from tumors (as in Fig. S4), colored by the assigned clusters (top) or the basal-like epigenetic signature (basal PermCell score, bottom), which is derived solely from histone modifications. (b) UMAP of two MCF7 parental cultures and three single-cell-derived clones analyzed by CyTOF using only epigenetic features, colored by assigned clusters (top) or the basal-like epigenetic signature (bottom).
In a recent development, (a) Scatter plot comparing basal-like cell fraction with estrogen receptor (ER) positivity by IHC across tumors (n = 11). Spearman correlation coefficient and two-sided p-value are indicated. (b,c) Basal-like cell fraction in HR+ tumors stratified by progesterone receptor (PR) IHC (b; 100% PR-positive, n = 7; lower PR positivity, n = 4) or TP53 status (c; wild-type, n = 8; mutant, n = 3). Two-sided Wilcoxon tests. Boxes show median and 25th–75th percentiles; whiskers extend within 1.5xIQR. (d) Differential protein abundance between K5High and K5Low populations in tumor 19. Axes show protein intensity difference (K5High-K5Low) and -log10(p-value), respectively. Two-sided Student’s t-tests with FDR correction; Green and pink dots depict proteins significantly deregulated (Fold change>1.5, q-value < 0.05). Labeled are chromatin regulators differentially expressed between the two populations. (e) Principal component analysis (PCA) of RNA-seq profiles from sorted MCF7 subpopulations. Basal-like cells (K5High GATA3Low, n = 3), extreme luminal cells (K5Low GATA3High, n = 3), and bulk MCF7 cells (n = 2). Points represent independently sorted population. Axes indicate variance explained. (f) Differential gene expression between basal-like (K5High GATA3Low, n = 3) and bulk MCF7 cells (n = 2). Significantly upregulated (pink) and downregulated (green) genes are indicated (DESeq2, Benjamini–Hochberg-adjusted p-value < 0.05, log2FC > 1). EMT-associated genes (hallmark epithelial-mesenchymal transition gene set) are enriched among upregulated transcripts in the basal-like population and highlighted with a black outline. CD74, a membrane-bound protein upregulated in the basal-like cells, is marked in dark pink. (g) CD74 expression across basal-like (n = 3), bulk (n = 2), and extreme luminal (n = 3) MCF7 populations. Points represent independently sorted population; expression is shown as rld values. Statistical significance was derived from DESeq2 differential expression analysis with Benjamini–Hochberg correction for multiple testing. (h) Representative wound-healing assay images of sorted CD74Low and CD74High MCF7 cells at the indicated times. Three independently recovered sorted populations from the same sort were analyzed. The gap area is highlighted in green. Scale bar = 300 μm.
(a) TCGA-BRCA DNA-methylation dataset (n = 782)51 was deconvoluted into three archetypes. Dots show tumor archetype composition and colored by PAM50 subtype. The archetype V3 is associated with basal-like triple-negative tumors. The composition of archetypes within the three tumors analyzed in this study (T18, T19, and T23, highlighted) clusters with luminal breast tumors from the TCGA cohort. (b) Genes were ranked by correlation between methylation archetypes and matched TCGA-BRCA expression, followed by GSEA111 against MSigDB hallmark gene sets (Table S4b). V1 and V2 archetypes are associated with luminal transcriptional programs while V3 archetype is enriched for the EMT program. Normalized Enrichment Scores (NES) of representative terms are shown. Black outline denotes BH-adjusted p-value < 0.05. See Fig. S5a for all terms. (c-d) K5High and K5Low sorted cells from tumors 5 and 23 were subjected to enzyme-mediated methylation sequencing (EM-seq, n = 4 replicates, 200 cells/replicate), and differentially methylated gene promoters were identified. For each sample, functional enrichment analysis was performed separately for genes with hypermethylated or hypomethylated promoters. Shown are the top 10 enriched terms from the MSigDB Hallmark gene set collection (c) or a curated list of breast cancer cell identity signatures (d) with nominal p-value < 0.05 (one-sided hypergeometric test). Circle size represents the number of genes from the input list overlapping each gene set, and transparency reflects -log10(p-value). (e) A CpG-island (CGI) methylation signature distinguishing K5High and K5Low states, derived using CGIs showing concordant differential methylation between the states in both tumor 5 and 23. Shown is the projection of this signature into DNA methylation profiles from the TCGA-BRCA dataset. Positive scores indicate greater similarity to the EM-seq-derived K5High methylation program, whereas negative scores indicate similarity to the K5Low state. Boxplots show the distribution of signature scores across basal-like (n = 96) or luminal (n = 418) tumors with points representing individual tumors. Boxes show median and 25th–75th percentiles; whiskers extend to the largest/smallest value within 1.5×IQR. The K5High methylation program is enriched in basal-like breast tumors. Two-sided Mann–Whitney U test. (f) TCGA-BRCA DNA-methylation dataset deconvoluted into three archetypes as in a, with K5high and K5low-sorted populations from tumors 5 and 23 projected onto the archetype space. K5high populations are shifted toward the V3 archetype, consistent with enrichment for basal/EMT-associated methylation programs. (g) Representation of tumors from the TCGA-BRCA cohort based on the four-archetype decomposition described in Fig. 3a, colored by V1 contribution. K5high and K5low-sorted populations from tumors 5 and 23 are projected onto the UMAP embedding. K5high populations are localized to regions characterized by higher V1 contribution, consistent with the EMT-associated methylation programs.
According to recent reports, (a) WGBS reads were clustered by DNA methylation patterns over 100 bp bins55, and each bin was scored for entropy, reflecting DNA methylation pattern heterogeneity; bins containing one pattern have zero entropy. Illustration, rows represent methylation patterns, filled/open circles indicate methylated/unmethylated CpGs and #r denotes supporting reads. Histograms show mean entropy scores of CGIs in tumor 19 (n = 17,434), tumor 18 (n = 20,845) and tumor 23 (n = 22,440). Most CGIs are unmethylated and have zero entropy scores. The intermediate and high-entropy bins are marked in pink and red. (b) Intermediate- and high-entropy CGIs (entropy>0) were linked to genes and analyzed for enrichment against MSigDB Hallmark genesets85. Pathways significantly enriched in all three tumors are shown (one-sided hypergeometric test, nominal p-value < 0.05). Dot size indicates overlapping genes; color indicates -log10(p-value). Variable CGIs are significantly enriched for genes related to EMT. (c) The Basal-luminal index was used to score the transcriptional identity of tumor cells13, and cells from each tumor were divided into quartiles; a low index score corresponds to expression of luminal identity genes (Q1) and a high index score corresponds to expression of basal-like identity genes (Q4). Cell-to-cell distance was calculated within each quartile to assess transcriptional heterogeneity; medians are shown for each sample. Bottom, representative UMAP and quartile definition for tumor 12-R. (d) Vendi score96 was used to calculate epigenetic heterogeneity within luminal or basal-like subpopulation (as defined in Figs. 1, 2, across n = 11 luminal tumors) using single-cell CyTOF histone PTMs measurements. Points show the mean across 5,000 rarefactions; error bars indicate uncertainty intervals (2.5th–97.5th percentiles) of the rarefied score distribution. Histone PTM levels are more variable in basal-like cells.
Recent findings suggest that (a) UMAPs of H3K4me1 (left, n = 17,062 cells) and H3K4me3 (right, n = 12,883 cells) snCUT&Tag 50 kb bins matrices from three tumor samples (PC1 representing read counts excluded; CD45-negative cells). Shared stroma clusters are outlined. (b) UMAPs as in a, colored according to H3K4me1 or H3K4me3 enrichment over fibroblast identity genes: FAP, COL3A1 and DCN (left) or endothelial identity genes: EMCN, PECAM1 and NOTCH3 (right). Higher UCell scores indicate stronger enrichment at genes associated with the corresponding stromal identity. (c,d) H3K4me1 (c) or H3K4me3 (d) UMAPS from all three tumors (50k bins matrix), colored by cluster. The portion of cells from each tumor that constitutes the clusters is shown below. Shared clusters were classified as stroma, as verified by gene activity; Boxed tumor clusters were analyzed further. For H3K4me3, limited number of cells passed quality control thresholds for tumor 8, thus data quality for this sample is lower. (e) Genomic annotation of H3K4me1 and H3K4me3 snCUT&Tag pseudo-bulk peaks, after stoma removal. Stacked bar plots show percentage of peaks assigned to genomic features. (f) For each tumor sample, removing the stroma compartment, a scTransform-normalized H3K4me3 gene activity was generated (excluding read counts information), represented by UMAP and clustered using Louvain clustering. Cell numbers are indicated. (g) Tumor 8 H3K4me1 UMAP (Fig. 3e), colored by UCell scores derived based on the genes contributing to the enrichment of the indicated terms. Cluster 2 shows high H3K4me1 signal on genes associated with basal-like cell identity. While the EMT signature was not significantly enriched for this cluster (FDR-adjusted p-value > 0.05), the corresponding UCell score is shown for comparison using EMT-associated genes contributing to the cluster. (h) Differentially H3K4me3-bound genes identified for each cluster shown in f (two-sided Wilcoxon signed-rank test, log2FC > 1, adjusted p-value < 0.01) were tested against MSigDB Hallmark and Breast-related genesets (Table S4). Terms enriched in cluster 1 in all three tumors are shown (one-sided hypergeometric test, FDR-adjusted P < 0.05). (i) Pseudu-bulk H3K4me1 and H3K4me3 genome-browser tracks from basal-like clusters (pink) or equal numbers of cells sampled from all other clusters (green) at representative genomic regions.
Sources indicate that (a,b) H3K4me1 or H3K4me3 reads per cell versus negative ER-signaling score in tumor 15 (a) or positive ER-signaling score in tumor 18 (b). Points represent cells; r is Pearson’s correlation coefficient. (c) H3K4me1 snCUT&Tag UMAPs from tumors 15 and 18 (Fig. 3e), colored by CyTOF-derived labels (top), with predicted-label composition per snCUT&Tag cluster (middle) and UCell scores for the ‘Down in Luminal vs. Basal (Charafe)’ signature (bottom). (d) Cells were classified as luminal or basal-like by CyTOF label transfer as in c. Differences in mean UCell scores for the indicated signatures between basal-like and luminal cells are shown across three tumors. EMT and basal-like-associated gene signatures show higher H3K4me1 deposition in the CyTOF-predicted basal-like group. (e) K5High and K5Low sorted cell populations from the luminal PDX model or MCF7 cells were subjected to H3K4me1 CUT&Tag. Peaks unique to each population were assigned to genes and compared to the indicated gene signatures. Shown is the difference in the GeneRatio (overlap count divided by the total number of peak-associated genes in that population) for each population, with positive values indicating increased overlap in K5High (basal-like) cells, whereas negative values indicate increased overlap in K5Low (luminal) cells. (f) Tumor 8 H3K9me2 snCUT&Tag UMAP from a 20kb-bin matrix, clustered by Leiden clustering (left). Stroma percentages per cluster, based on the H3K4me1-trained classifier, are shown on the right. (g) Following removal of the stromal compartment described in f, a normalized promoter-proximal H3K9me2 occupancy matrix was generated, and Leiden clustering was applied (n = 4,419 cells, see Methods). (h) Percentage of basal-like cells (cluster 2 in Fig. 3e) within each cluster in g, based on the H3K4me1-trained classifier. (i) Left: Differentially H3K9me2-bound genes in cluster 4, shown in g (two-sided Wilcoxon signed-rank test, log2FC > 0.6, adjusted p-value < 0.01), were tested against MSigDB Hallmark and Breast-related signatures. Shown are the top 5 terms significantly enriched (nominal p-value < 0.05) for genes with upregulation of H3K9me2 on their promoters. Right: UMAP as in g colored according to UCell gene-signature scores for the indicated gene sets. Cluster 4 highlights elevated H3K9me2 occupancy over luminal-associated genes. (j) Read count per cell (nCount) by cluster (panel g). Violin plots show the distribution of individual cells, with the median denoted by a white dot and n indicated for each cluster. Cluster 4 shows the highest number of reads per cell, possibly corresponding to higher global levels of this mark in basal-like cells.
(a,b) Classifier performance in an independently processed, batch-corrected cohort of healthy individuals (n = 19) and luminal BC patients (n = 30), using the model trained on the original cohort in Fig. 4f. (a) ROC curve (AUC = 0.98; shading, 95% CI). (b) Confusion matrix with specificity set to 0.9. (c,d) ROC curve discriminating healthy individuals (n = 32) from luminal BC patients, diagnosed at the SHEBA medical center, Israel (c, n = 16, AUC = 0.96) or Kaplan medical center, Israel (d, n = 14, AUC = 0.99). Shading indicates the 95% CI. (e) ROC curve discriminating healthy individuals (n = 32) and triple-negative BC patients (n = 22, AUC = 0.98, shading indicates the 95% CI). (f) Healthy (n = 51) and luminal BC samples from three medical centers (n = 137) were pooled and stratified into 75% training cohort and a 25% test cohort. ROC curves are shown for training (left, n = 38 healthy vs. 103 luminal BC samples, AUC = 0.96) and the test cohort (right, n = 13 healthy vs. 34 luminal BC patients, AUC = 0.94). Shading indicates the 95% CI. (g) AUC estimates for discrimination of healthy individuals (n = 51) from luminal A (n = 98), luminal B (n = 31), or all luminal BC patients (n = 137) across the three medical centers. Points and lines indicate AUCs and 95% CIs, respectively.
(a-f) Selected EPINUC features in disease-free versus recurrent-disease groups within clinically defined subsets (see Fig. 5a): >50% ER-positive (a, n = 39 vs. 28), >50% PR-positive (b, n = 33 vs. 18), luminal A BC (c, n = 35 vs. 23), T1-T2 staged tumors (d, n = 43 vs. 20), grade 1-2 tumors (e, n = 36 vs. 18), and no LVI at diagnosis (f, n = 34 vs. 14). Two-sided Wilcoxon tests. (g) Distribution of 29 EPINUC features across luminal BC patients stratified by histological grade (grade 1, n = 29; grade 2, n = 67; grade 3, n = 36). Points represent individual patients. Kruskal-Wallis p-values were Benjamini-Hochberg-corrected across the 29 features. (h) Spearman correlations between mean histone PTM levels measured by CyTOF in tumor cells and EPINUC measurements in matched plasma (n = 10). Correlations with r > 0.2 are pink; P < 0.05 is bold (two-sided Spearman correlation test). H3K4me3 and H3K27me3 scatter plots are shown below, with Theil-Sen fits and 95% CIs. (i) Individual PPS analysis distinguishing disease-free (DF) from relapse (R, left column), or between healthy individuals (H) and each of the luminal outcome group. Color indicates PPS, reflecting predictive power of each individual feature. (j) OncotypeDX scores for patients in cohorts MAYO-1 and MAYO-2 with available measurements (disease-free, n = 40; relapse, n = 9, n.s., non-significant, two-sided Wilcoxon test). In a–g,j, boxes show median and 25th–75th percentiles; whiskers extend to the largest/smallest value within 1.5×IQR.
This file contains legends for Supplementary Tables 1–8, Supplementary Figs. 1–12, Supplementary Discussion and Supplementary References.
Supplementary Tables 1–8; see Supplementary Information for titles.
Furth, N., Riemenschneider, C., Arieli, Y. et al. Epigenetic heterogeneity in breast tumours informs diagnosis and prognosis. Nature (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11230-y.
Version of record: 11 November 2026.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11230-y.
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:.
Sorry, a shareable link is not presently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (17 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Get the full Derby County Premium experience for less than 50p per week.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (31 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County head to Southampton this weekend in what is their first game after the international break as they look to build on their win over Bolton.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (697 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Barnsley, Reyes Cleary, Sheffield United, and Derby County could all become central to an interesting January transfer situation, with the talented winger attracting attention from higher up the football pyramid.
Reyes Cleary has emerged as one of the most exciting attacking players in League One with Barnsley, and it is hardly surprising that Championship clubs are monitoring his situation again after having interest in the 22-year-old in the summer.
Industry observers note that both Sheffield United and Derby County have reason to strengthen their attacking options, while Barnsley face an increasingly important period in their own campaign. There could be some significant developments at Oakwell over the coming weeks ahead of January.
Reyes Cleary is arguably one of the most exciting and explosive wide players in League One, so it is little surprise that the likes of Sheffield United, Derby, and Bristol City have been credited with an interest in securing his services.
It's evident that he has the individual quality to make the step up to the Championship and would represent an exciting addition for any of the sides keen on him at a higher level.
However, Barnsley's latest defeat to Wigan Athletic has made their league position even more precarious, with the threat of relegation to League Two becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.
That could have significant implications for Cleary's future. Barnsley adopted a hardball stance during the summer and priced interested clubs out of a move, but their current predicament makes that approach considerably harder to justify.
According to recent reports, cleary might be vital to their survival hopes, but they cannot necessarily expect to retain him on their terms if Championship interest intensifies in January. Barnsley are now second-bottom and three points off safety, albeit with games in hand on some of the sides above them.
Barnsley deserve considerable credit for identifying Cleary's potential in the first place. He had shown promise during his time with Hartlepool United in the National League, but not many League One clubs would have taken the gamble of recruiting somebody two divisions higher and backing him to make the step up.
It has proved to be an inspired decision, although Barnsley now face a difficult situation with just 18 months remaining on his contract come January. Sheffield United and Derby are unlikely to be the only Championship clubs interested, either, with Bristol City also keen.
West Bromwich Albion should also have serious regrets about allowing Cleary to leave as early as they did. He looks every bit a player capable of establishing himself in the Championship, and a return to The Hawthorns could even be something worth exploring if they recognise their previous mistake.
Recent findings suggest that that said, Barnsley have to be braced for offers and interest again, with it becoming increasingly to stand in the player's way if he is determined to test himself in the second tier. That said, Barnsley will be desperate to keep hold of arguably their best player.
There is, of course, another side to this argument. If Barnsley cannot turn their fortunes around and ultimately suffer relegation to League Two, Cleary's market value could fall considerably for clubs like Derby and Sheffield United, particularly with only 12 months remaining on his contract next summer.
From a financial perspective, January might just be their best opportunity to secure a substantial fee. However, selling him could also be a grave sporting mistake, too. Cleary is arguably Barnsley's most talented player and possesses the individual quality to help drag them away from the relegation places.
How likely is Reyes Cleary to remain at Barnsley after January? Comment below!
Losing that sort of match-winner midway through a difficult campaign could make an already challenging situation considerably worse. The Tykes have to weigh up the financial benefits of cashing in against the very real possibility that they need Cleary more than ever to preserve their League One status.
There are only three players with more than three goal involvements for Barnsley in all competitions this season, including Vimal Yoganathan with five, as well as both Cameron McGeehan and Cleary with nine apiece. No one can better Cleary's three assists, either.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (291 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Today, RedBird Capital Partners have unveiled the creation of a upcoming organization that will focus specifically on AC Milan.
This season, Gerry Cardinale’s commitments to Milan have been seen much more. The American has been at every game in Serie A, proving his desire to be closer to the team and it feels like his relationship with the club (and fans) is growing deeper.
Sources indicate that read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
He’s still got room to learn, but it’s a substantial improvement from recent years and now, he’s taken a new step forward.
As MilanNews relays, RedBird Capital Partners have now launched a upcoming holding tech giant for anything and everything related to the Rossoneri, calling ‘Milan Sports & Entertainment’, MSE for short.
This company will ‘consolidate RedBird’s Milan-based investments in sports, infrastructure, and entertainment’ and organise individual assets into a ‘multi-sport platform’.
The report continues, stating that MSE will help to further transform Milano into one of the ‘most influential sports and entertainment markets in the world’ by combining its importance in fashion, design, culture, sports and entertainment.
Above all, though, it’s another representation of RedBird’s long-term investment and commitment to the club (and the city).
San Donato is also referenced, with MSE making a commitment to the area, and there are intends to create a stadium and arena management business, which could eventually culminate in the Rossoneri’s NBA team.
Finally, RedBird have formed a latest leadership team for the group, with Brett Yormark appointed the CEO of the company. He will report directly to Cardinale and will lead the ‘development and implementation of MSE’s strategy, overseeing current portfolio businesses and evaluating future investment opportunities.’.
📅 16 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (26 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County head to Southampton this weekend as they look to build on their 3-1 win over Bolton before the international break.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (33 words, ⚡ Quick Read) | Source: Co
Derby County don’t yet know what division they will be playing in next season but Rams chiefs face a number of tricky decisions ahead of the January transfer window.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 6 min read (1258 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

There are rumours that Bradford City could be up for sale, but any prospective newly introduced buyers of the club should be warned that any purchase of the club could come with one significant complication.
For several seasons, it looked rather as though Bradford City were living in some sort of footballing purgatory. Trapped in League Two and watched by huge crowds for that division despite barely challenging for promotion, the club seemed stuck in a loop which was proving extremely difficult to escape from.
According to recent reports, at the end of the 2024-25 season, though, that run came to an end. Bradford were promoted back to League One following an absence of six years, and they marked their first season back by finishing in fourth place and securing a play-off place, where they lost 2-0 over two legs to Bolton Wanderers.
Sources indicate that that form has broadly followed them into League One this season. The departure of manager Graham Alexander to Preston North End at the start of October was a major loss, and their form has dipped since then. Prior to that, though, the Bantams soared to the top of League One, again demonstrating that this is a club with untapped potential, and this in turn has reportedly attracted the interest of investors from abroad.
Recent reports from journalist Alan Nixon have confirmed that there is interest in buying Bradford City from a consortium of Thai investors who are seeking a route into the English game, with Nixon writing that, "Bradford could be for sale at the right price and the Thais, who have an intermediary with inside knowledge, are considering an official offer.".
Recent findings suggest that stefan Rupp has been the public face of the club's ownership since 2016, and Rupp has been clear that he will only sell to the right buyer. Speaking to the Bradford Telegraph & Argus after the end of the 2025-26 season, Rupp said, "I'm the keeper of the keys and I would never hand it over to somebody where I have the impression he can't do any better.".
According to recent reports, how would you redevelop Valley Parade further to match Bradford City's growing ambitions? Let us know in the comments below!
Industry observers note that on the surface, there are plenty of good reasons to have an interest in buying Bradford City. The days of them being underachievers in League Two already feel like a rapidly fading memory, and even though they've had a dip in form since the departure of Alexander, they remain one of the promotion contenders in League One again this season.
Crowds remain extremely healthy, at just shy of 20,000, and Valley Parade is a stadium which hosted Premier League football for two seasons at the turn of the century, representing a city of half a million people in which they remain the only professional football club.
But when The Athletic's Matt Slater reported on the possibility of the Bantams being sold in March 2026, he mentioned a potential sale price of around £10 million. This seems very low for an upwardly mobile League One club, but there's a very good reason for this modest valuation, and it comes down to what the club doesn't own.
In an era during which a Championship striker is having a £70 million price tag slapped on his head to deter predators, spending £10 million to buy an entire football club sounds like a bargain, but with the sale of any football club it can be beneficial to pay attention to the detail of what's actually being bought or sold.
Sources indicate that and in the case of Bradford City, the club owns neither Valley Parade nor their training ground. Valley Parade belongs to former chairman Gordon Gibb's family pension fund. Bradford reportedly pay more than £500,000 annually to lease the ground, with the existing agreement due for renewal in 2028. Bradford have been giving consideration to possibly leaving the ground over the cost of the rent for at least a decade and a half.
And in the lower reaches of the EFL, the pure real estate value of the ground can be the biggest single cost aspect of any potential takeover. Without that, any newly introduced owner is essentially buying the player and staff contracts along with a license to operate the club in the EFL, and Bradford City, like the overwhelming majority of clubs, are not a profitable enterprise, with the last available set of manufacturer accounts showing a £3 million loss on a revenue of £8.6 million.
Earlier this year, the Bantams Supporters Trust entered into a consultation period with fans over what to do about the stadium, with a valuation of it put at between £8 million and £10 million. It's not known whether there are covenants limiting its use. But regardless of this, the Trust confirmed that they believe that the club's intention is to seek to continue to lease the stadium when that renewal comes up.
In a recent development, it would be advantageous to any new owners to take ownership of the ground itself. To do so would save them more than they're paying their highest-earning player every year, while its value would increase as land prices increase, and it would allow the club to redevelop the site more easily if they were looking to increase their revenues another way round.
But throwing the ground into the sale mix could double that original £10 million valuation, and although that would still represent stunning value for money were the club able to fight their way back to the Premier League, sale prices can vary wildly even within League One.
Recent findings suggest that when Rob Couhig bought Reading from Dai Yongge in May 2025, for example, it was reported that the sale price was £30 million, but this included the Select Car Leasing Stadium and the club's training ground. But when Leicester City were put up for sale in September 2026, it was for a staggering £224 million, though this did include state-of-the-art training facilities, land around the stadium for redevelopment, and Leicester's Belgian sister club, OH Leuven.
Buying a football club at any level of the game can be a gamble, and the recent IFR report into the state of football finances stated that two-thirds of club have liabilities which exceed their assets and rely on owner funding to survive - making them technically insolvent - while only seven of the 116 professional clubs in the top five men’s divisions did not record a loss for the last available financial year.
According to recent reports, all of this means that, while £10 million to buy a football may sound like a bargain, it's almost certain that this price is reflective of the extreme likelihood being that the cost to any new owner wouldn't end at that point. In the case of Bradford City, it wouldn't include the stadium itself, and this would likely double that price, while the new owner would also be on the hook for covering the club's losses, which at the last available count amounted to £3 million for one year.
According to recent reports, even at a sale price of £20 million to £30 million, buying Bradford City could prove to be a bargain. But so lop-sided are the finances of the majority of English football clubs that they may have to get the club all the way to the Premier League to turn a serious profit on their investment.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 6 min read (1130 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

By JOHN MCGARRY, SCOTTISH CHIEF SPORTS FEATURE WRITER.
Published: 17:30 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 18:01 EST, 14 November 2026.
Whatever concerns there may legitimately be about the limited progress seen in Sebastien Pocognoli’s brief time in charge of Scotland, the Belgian has hardly been blessed with good fortune.
Industry observers note that in five matches to date in the Nations League, the manager has not yet been able to select the same back-three in two consecutive outings. Injuries and suspensions have seen to that.
For all that, you sense that even if he’d had a full quota of players to choose from, Pocognoli would still be figuring out his preferred defensive grouping.
In a recent development, this does feel like a time of opportunity for those who are fresh on the scene. Catch the eye and there’s a real chance to become established as a mainstay of the team moving forward.
Luke Graham did his chances of doing just that no harm at all in his first start and second cap for his country on Friday.
Playing in between Ryan Porteous and Kieran Tierney, the Stoke City man made a compelling case to stay there with a strong and diligent display.
Luke Graham enjoyed a composed debut for Scotland as they recorded a much-needed win.
On the back of a summer move from Dundee to the English Championship, Graham appears to have taken the step-up to international level in his stride.
‘It’s something I’ve always wanted to do since I was growing up, so I have to be ready for the moment and take it when it comes,’ he said.
Recent findings suggest that ‘I think there’s good competition. We have a lot of good centre-halves. Obviously, it was unfortunate for Welshy (Stephen Welsh) and Binksy (Luis Binks) to go out with injury, but that opens up a space for me to come in and try to cement a place.
Recent findings suggest that ‘When you’re out on that pitch, you have to do everything you can to try and stay in the team. I gave my all and I’ll just need to wait and see what happens going forward.’.
According to recent reports, timing can be vital in football. And it’s conceivable that Graham’s might just propel him to become a Scotland regular.
While playing at Dens Park saw him mentioned in dispatches with regards to a call-up, his move to England, coming just before Pocognoli was announced as Steve Clarke’s successor, has seen his dream swiftly become reality.
‘I’ve always mentioned that one thing I wanted to do in my career was play for Scotland, so to get it over the line was pretty special,’ he reflected.
Former Dundee defender Graham proudly belts out the national anthem ahead of kick-off.
‘Not much is going wrong for me at the moment, so it’s just about maintaining that and keeping it going every week.
‘I wouldn’t say I merited a start as we have a lot of good players in the camp. It’s up to the manager to pick the team and, luckily, he gave me the chance.
Recent findings suggest that ‘He just said to go out and enjoy it and do what you’re doing every week at Stoke. I think I did all right.’.
Notwithstanding how limited the North Macedonians were on the night, Pocognoli was entitled to take encouragement from the way the back three acquitted themselves.
According to recent reports, playing closer to each other than we’d seen in the previous matches, they were rarely unpicked by balls through the middle. Angus Gunn was not overworked in goal. Tellingly, the only concession of the night came when Scott McTominay lost his man at a corner.
‘I think a lot of it is just being brave,’ Graham reflected. ‘It’s about bravery in going man-to-man with the striker, being brave on the ball, trying to break the lines and keeping possession.
‘So, I think bravery is the main thing and concentration as well.’.
Graham keeps a close eye on North Macedonian danger man Elmin Rastoder at Hampden.
Industry observers note that with the defence solid enough, Pocognoli had a platform for a much-needed win. While the narrow scoreline made the final moments more anxious than they should have been, on balance, Scotland were deserved winners.
According to recent reports, ‘It’s just about winning games at this stage of the competition, so that was good,’ said Graham. ‘I think, if I’m being harsh, we should have killed the game off before it got to 1-1. We had a few good chances to put them to bed.
‘Then we kinda shot ourselves in the foot by conceding from a set piece. But Ben Gannon-Doak does well for the penalty and for us to go 2-1 up and see it out was good.’.
No one would dispute that the display was a long way from perfect. There’s significant room for improvement ahead of the concluding group match with Switzerland on Monday.
Recent findings suggest that ‘We’re going through a bit of a transitional spell at the minute, so it’s not going to be all smooth sailing from the get-go,’ Graham said. ‘It’s about adjusting and trying to build on performances in every game. I think it’s going to take time.
‘It’s a different style, a different manager and we just have to keep being patient. You look at the squad now and there’s a lot of new, young players coming through. It’s just about encouraging us young boys and showing we can get a place in the squad.
‘It is going to take time but, once we get there, we’re going to do really well and compete right at the top of the game.’.
Graham has been a huge success in Stoke's flying start to the Championship season.
Industry observers note that graham does look like he’s moving in the right direction. From watching Scotland compete at the World Cup on licensed premises five months ago, he hopes he too can be the toast of the nation one day.
‘I didn’t go. It was too expensive for me,’ he explained. ‘I think I was just like everyone else, watching in the pub with their mates. It was pretty amazing and hopefully I can be part of something like that one day.
It has been revealed that ‘I wasn’t too far away (previously), I think. Steve Clarke, the former manager, told me that. It’s just about trusting myself now and hopefully getting there one day.
‘There’s been a lot of hard work and dedication which has led me to this point. I’m very grateful to a lot of people who have helped me in my career so far and just to get this chance is amazing.’.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (453 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

With the news of the latest company leading AC Milan, Gerry Cardinale has offered a few words about what it means for the project.
It has been revealed that in recent minutes, RedBird have announced a latest parent tech giant for Milan, aptly named ‘Milan Sports & Entertainment’. It’s a project that aims to put all of the club’s investments under one umbrella, whilst also allowing further investment into the city.
The new stadium is believed to have played a big part in this decision, and the Rossoneri will hopefully benefit significantly from this move.
As MilanNews relays, Cardinale offered some words in the announcement about the creation of the organization, what it means to the city and for Rossoneri fans, what it means for the club.
“Over the past 25 years, we have worked alongside rights holders in the sports and media sectors to create innovative businesses that have transformed their respective industries.
“This evolution is based on a deep respect for the intellectual property assets that underpin these businesses, a long-term partnership with rights holders, and the ambition to fully unlock the potential of these teams and leagues, both on and off the pitch.
It has been revealed that “Milan Sports & Entertainment represents the culmination of this journey and the work we have carried out since we first invested in AC Milan four years ago. Becoming a club owner has given us an even deeper understanding of what creates long-term value: winning, serving fans, and investing in the communities that give these institutions meaning.
Sources indicate that “Today, we apply this experience on a different scale: not just to a single club, a single sport, or a single facility, but to an entire city and a portfolio that spans sports, lifestyle, and entertainment. I have known Brett Yormark and worked with him for 25 years.
“We’ve been working with Milan for years, and I can’t imagine a better executive in the international sports industry to help execute this strategy. Thanks to Brett, we can bring the best of American sports and live entertainment to Milan, helping write a new chapter in the city’s growth and international success.
“With AC Milan as our cornerstone, which will always be the driving force behind all our initiatives, we intend to build a world-class sports and entertainment platform capable of shaping the future of Milan and European sports, and bringing it back to the forefront of the global stage.”.
Considering how much attention Cardinale has paid to the future of the Diavolo, and taking them back to the top level, it’s nice to hear it referenced once again in his latest statement. Hopefully this move is another step towards that.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (627 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Swansea City are facing another fight to retain the services of head coach, Vitor Matos, with it emerging that French top-flight side, RC Strasbourg, have approached the Welsh side for his services.
The Swans have enjoyed an impressive start to the Championship season, as they sit sixth in the table after 15 games on 26 points, despite losing three of their last five encounters.
Matos' side were narrowly defeated before the November international break by current leaders, Birmingham City, at St. Andrew's @ Knighthead Park despite being a man down for the vast majority of the contest, and it may transpire that the loss in the West Midlands could be the 38-year-old's final game in charge.
Speculation involving the former Liverpool coach is nothing new to supporters in this part of South Wales in recent weeks, but one positive has emerged should Matos decide to move on to a third managerial role within the space of 12 months.
Matos was appointed by Swansea on November 24th of last year, three weeks after the Welsh outfit parted organization with Alan Sheehan.
Jürgen Klopp's former Anfield assistant was lured from Maritimo through a reported £880,000 compensation fee, and subsequently transformed the Swans' form for the remainder of the season as they finished 11th - nine points outside the play-offs whilst boasting Golden Boot winner, Zan Vipotnik.
Having signed a one-year contract extension until June 2030 on July 31st, a strong first pre-season and summer transfer window has been backed up by a positive start, but it emerged on Monday that Strasbourg have approached Swansea over the potential appointment of Matos, with his compatriot, Hugo Oliveira, under pressure after just three wins this season.
Strasbourg are 13th in Ligue 1 at present, but would be forced to part with a significant sum of cash if they were to instill the highly-rated head coach at the Stade de la Meinau, and it has since been suggested that the figure being negotiated is in the region of £4m as Matos braces for his latest managerial change.
Matos won 22 of his first 47 matches in charge of Swansea, boasting a win percentage of 47%, following on from a 54% total in just 13 matches at his previous employers, Maritimo.
It is a testament to the work put in by the Portuguese that clubs are looking to poach him away from Swansea, and that recently included the Premier League's bottom club, Crystal Palace.
The Eagles were recently credited with interest in the Portuguese and Middlesbrough head coach, Kim Hellberg, before opting to confirm Thomas Frank as Pierre Sage's replacement at Selhurst Park on Monday afternoon.
Despite losing Ethan Galbraith to Stoke City for £10m, Matos changed the outlook of his Swansea side with 11 newly introduced recruits, with the likes of Joseph Opoku, Moussa Yeo and Stephen Welsh, already earning rave reviews.
Such a strong recruitment drive came after the penning of Matos' contract extension, after which he explained his sudden connection towards all aspects of the club as he aimed to drive the Swans forward.
"From the moment I arrived here, I have sensed how powerful the connection between Swansea City and the fans and community is," Matos remarked.
"This is something very special, it is a feeling myself and the players love, and the desire to keep building that and sharing great moments together is one of the key motivations in extending my contract with the club.".
Swansea fans, what do you make of the constant speculation concerning Vitor Matos? Comment below!
Swansea fans will be frustrated that, after such words, it appears Matos will not be committing to the club's current project, regardless of how appealing working in the French top-flight would be to many managers.
📅 11 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 4 min read (716 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readmanutd

According to recent reports, manchester United drew 1-1 at home to Tottenham despite having an extra man advantage. The Reds saw Mbeumo put them in front, but Solanke scored a late leveller in injury time after Bentancur was shown a red card for headbutting Luke Shaw.
In a recent development, manchester United’s worrisome season continues after accumulating just six points off the first six games, their first start in 40 years. But more than the results, what worries Manchester United is their midfield pairing.
United spent massively on their midfield rebuild and somehow can’t find the best combination in the midfield. Michael Carrick has gone with the Mainoo-Tielemans partnership, but they have failed to control the midfield. Individually, they both come with decent numbers, but collectively they fall short.
Recent findings suggest that mainoo and Tielemans struggled against Tottenham while closing the midfield and at times revealed a lack of energy. On the day when nothing clicked for United, the Mainoo-Tielemans partnership particularly raised eyebrows.
Gary Neville has also raised serious concerns about Manchester United’s Mainoo-Tielemans partnership.
Neville was particularly unimpressed by the midfield balance, arguing that the problems went beyond one disappointing performance.
The former United captain stopped short of ruling out the combination altogether, but he suggested he has serious doubts about its suitability.
“Tielemans and Mainoo, I’m not calling time on it, that’s probably too drastic, but I’ve seen enough of it to think that’s not a midfield that’s dynamic enough to play at this football club in the Premier League.”.
Former Spurs midfielder Redknapp felt United struggled to connect their midfield with the rest of the team during the opening stages.
Industry observers note that he added: “I didn’t see enough connections in that midfield in the first hour. Baleba came on and did OK and highlighted a bit more.
“They look devoid of any confidence, any idea, any patterns of play, playing out from the back. Tottenham were much better than them in every single department.”.
While Carlos Baleba was a particular highlight on the day, he indicated great potential when brought on. He brought a new sense of energy in the midfield and sent a few balls over the top for a couple of quick counterattacks as well.
Redknapp also pointed to the physical demands of modern Premier League football, arguing that United cannot afford to be outworked by their opponents.
Tottenham ran a staggering 5 km more than Manchester United, something Redknapp felt was a pattern.
"Spurs ran 5km more than Man United… it's like that EVERY GAME!"Jamie Redknapp is less than impressed with the lack of ground covered this season by Manchester United 😬 pic.twitter.com/BxWkFuyGJ1.
“There is a pattern that I don’t really like when I watch teams, and that’s when every time the stats don’t lie and the other team runs more than you.
According to recent reports, “I feel in Premier League football right now there are a couple of non-negotiables, and one is you have to run more than the other team if you want to win or at least get close enough. Tonight Spurs ran 5km more than Manchester United.”.
He believes Tottenham’s pressing exposed the lack of pace in United’s midfield, making it difficult for the hosts to move the ball safely through the centre.
“In terms of how they played today, I think they have an problem with Tielemans and Mainoo in midfield. I don’t see enough energy in there. Baleba will add a lot and will give them a tremendous amount of energy but right now, when things aren’t going well… and Tottenham knew it!
“Every time United played the ball out from the back they pounced. They pressed them because they knew United don’t have the pace and speed in midfield to get away.”.
Industry observers note that “In isolation, one of them is absolutely fine, the two of them together doesn’t work for me. They haven’t got the pace or the energy to get around the pitch for 90 minutes.”.
Recent findings suggest that shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 11 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (433 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Senne Lammens believes Manchester United must learn to finish games off after their late collapse against Tottenham Hotspur.
The result left the goalkeeper frustrated at Old Trafford despite leading the game and with a player more on the field.
Manchester United looked set for three points after Bryan Mbeumo put them ahead in the second half, but Dominic Solanke’s stoppage-time equaliser denied Michael Carrick’s side a much-needed victory.
Speaking to MUTV, Senne Lammens admitted the team had struggled early on but had done enough after the break to put themselves in a winning position.
“Football can be a bit cruel at times,” the Belgian goalkeeper stated. “There are a lot of ups and downs, especially in a game like that.”.
Senne Lammens felt United failed to take advantage of Tottenham’s red card, allowing the visitors too much space to find a late equaliser.
“We’ve won a lot of games against 10 men [in the past], but you also know there can be a tricky situation when you’re playing against 10 men, because they have nothing to lose and they know that.”.
He added that United should have scored again to put the result beyond doubt or, at the very least, prevented Tottenham from creating further chances.
“I think that’s what we did wrong. We gave them a little bit too much breathing room to create those chances, and then one ball has to go right for them, one bounce has to go their way, and they can score like that.”.
The goalkeeper also pointed to similarities with United’s earlier disappointment against Everton, where points slipped away late in the match.
“You feel like those games just slip away from you, and there are one or two situations where you don’t really have control,” he said.
Industry observers note that “I think there’s a lot to learn from today. It wasn’t all negative, not at all, but especially the way it ended left a very bad feeling.”.
“I think the easy answer is that we have to be able to kill the game faster and not put ourselves in that position to give them a chance.”.
Despite the frustration, Lammens mentioned there were positives to take from the performance. However, the late goal had left a bitter feeling, and United now need to turn those lessons into better results.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (628 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Former Wolves midfielder Rúben Neves has revealed he is looking forward to playing at the Cardiff City Stadium again, as he reflected on a ‘crazy’ 1-0 win over the Bluebirds earlier in his career.
The 29-year-old is currently playing for Al-Hilal, with the move to Saudi Arabia coming after six years at Wolves. Neves had a remarkable time at Molineux, initially joining the club from Porto when they were in the Championship.
Despite the risk, it was a move that worked out, as he starred for Nuno Espírito Santo’s side as they won the title in the second tier, before recording consecutive 7th-placed finishes in the Premier League.
Neves would ultimately make over 250 appearances in Old Gold, and his quality, leadership and loyalty means he is regarded as a modern-day legend at the club.
During that period, there were many high points for Wolves and Neves, and one of the standout moments came during the 2017/18 campaign, when Wanderers won the Championship title.
In April of that season, Nuno’s side made the trip to take on fellow promotion rivals Cardiff, and the two teams played out one of the most remarkable games in Championship history.
According to recent reports, neves had given the visitors the lead with a trademark free-kick, but Cardiff missed the chance to equalise in stoppage time when Gary Madine saw his effort saved by John Ruddy. Incredibly, the Bluebirds would be awarded another spot-kick, but Junior Hoilett hit the bar with the last kick of the game.
That prompted wild celebrations, with Cardiff boss Neil Warnock famously snubbing Nuno’s offer of a handshake after the game.
So, it’s a stadium that will hold many memories for all Wolves fans, and Neves is back in the Welsh capital with Portugal, as Jorge Jesus’ side prepare to take on the Dragons in the Nations League.
Inevitably, Neves was questioned about coming back to the Cardiff City Stadium, and he told BBC Wales that it remains one of the ‘craziest’ games he has ever been involved in.
In a recent development, “I remember (it) very well! It was a crazy match, one of the craziest matches in my life, and fortunately we won that match.
“I scored a free-kick, and then in the last minutes they had two penalties, they missed both penalties, and of course, after that there was a bit of confusion on the pitch because the emotions were high.
“But it was a fantastic match, and it’s a stadium that brings me good memories.”.
This is nice for Wolves fans to hear, as they still love Neves, and it will be great for them to see that he still looks back on his time at the club fondly, with all supporters hoping that he might one day return for a second spell at some point before he retires.
Obviously, the Cardiff game is one that will live long in the memory, and it’s no exaggeration to say that it was an ending to a match that you rarely ever see.
It was a huge disappointment for Cardiff at the time, but, to their credit, the Bluebirds did manage to put the defeat behind them, as they went up automatically with Wolves - and they did actually beat them at home in the top flight.
It has been revealed that what is the craziest match you have seen? Let us know in the comments below.
But, that night was pivotal for Wolves, and, even after everything Neves went on to achieve at the club, and in his career, it was clearly a game that stands out.
So, he will have fond memories of Cardiff, and Neves will hope to leave with another win with Portugal against Wales on Tuesday night.
📅 11 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 4 min read (732 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readmanutd

Manchester United endured another embarrassing draw against 10-man Tottenham after failing to register their second win despite bringing in a plethora of players.
Manchester United invested heavily last season in their attacking options, bringing in Bryan Mbeumo and Matheus Cunha.
Sources indicate that this season, they overhauled their midfield. United spent massively on Carlos Baleba, Youri Tielemans and Andrey Santos. Despite spending massively, they have failed to produce the control they would have expected in the midfield. The lack of control was evident in the recent Tottenham game, where Mainoo-Tielemans partnership failed to control the game collectively.
The midfield question was covered in our recent report as well, highlighting a lack of control and carried comments from Gary Neville and Jamie Redknapp.
Industry observers note that the bigger question is when United will strengthen their defence. As per our previous report as well, Manchester United are planning to overhaul their defence in the upcoming transfer windows.
Sources indicate that united were heavily linked with several left backs but eventually failed to bring any one. The situation left Luke Shaw as the only senior option in the position, while Patrick Dorgu is used upfront by Michael Carrick.
It has been revealed that harry Amass is another option for Michael Carrick, but he is only here because of a failed transfer move. He has been rarely used at left back as Dalot and Mazraoui get the nod in the position ahead of him.
The situation at right-back isn’t all good either. Diogo Dalot is the first option there, but he rarely provides the assurance that puts Michael Carrick at ease. Noussair Mazraoui is the second choice at right-back, but his attacking numbers aren’t great either.
In a recent development, harry Maguire and Lisandro Martinez form up United’s centre-back pairing while Leny Yoro and Ayden Heaven are used all over the defensive line in rotation when needed. Yoro was used at right-back against Tottenham while Heaven arrived as left-back towards the end of the game.
Manchester United’s season hasn’t been defensively strong or anywhere near being good. They have conceded goals in all Premier League games and only kept one clean sheet against Sabah in the Champions League.
According to recent reports, lisandro Martinez has come under scrutiny after errors on four occasions. Against Ipswich Town, Manchester United won 5-2, but his error resulted in Ipswich’s second goal.
His own goal against Fulham gave away two points at Craven Cottage in the 1-1 draw. Another error led to Solanke’s goal against Tottenham, when he took his eyes off the ball.
His injury concerns are another aspect, and maybe Michael Carrick needs to make a decision.
Manchester United’s success depended heavily on youth over the years. When pundits questioned them, Sir Alex Ferguson gave them the chance to prove them wrong. Alan Hansen made the famous quote “You can’t win anything with kids” on the BBC’s Match of the Day on August 19, 1995. United did exactly that, played youth and went on to win everything.
Industry observers note that michael Carrick needs to do exactly that. He needs to trust youth and allow them to make mistakes. Leny Yoro and Ayden Heaven arrived as massive potentials, but they haven’t been given the license to express themselves, without fearing for their places. Both the youngsters have rarely started together or in a stretch of games. It is maybe time for them to take their chances.
In a recent development, michael Carrick needs to keep Harry Maguire as a senior experienced figure around them. There is no doubt over Martinez’s ability, but he is not the answer to United’s long-term problem. United need to blend youth with experience as their identity moving forward. Lisandro Martinez perhaps isn’t the answer to United’s problem.
Sources indicate that A defensive revival expected in the upcoming transfer windows needs to happen now. It must happen with chances to the Youth. Michael Carrick needs to be brave enough and throw the youngsters in the mix. What it will bring is a long-term solution. They need to experience the errors and pressures that will shape them in football.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (386 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Last night, AC Milan’s Adrien Rabiot returned to San Siro – alongside Mike Maignan – as the French national team were beaten by Italy.
There was talk in the last international break that Zinedine Zidane wasn’t a huge fan of Rabiot. Yet, the midfielder was awarded the armband at San Siro. With this, a statement was made that the Frenchman needed to impress, but the trust was there for him to do so.
Sources indicate that read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
Whilst he could not lead his team to victory, though, there were several positives to take from the game, with one outlet giving him a 7/10.
It’s a frustrating defeat for Les Bleus – and a rare one for Rabiot and Maignan at San Siro – but it reveals that they still have a lot to do with Zidane. After all, it’s better for these defeats to come now, rather than in a major tournament.
Speaking to Sky Sport (via MilanNews) after the game at San Siro, Rabiot praised the opposition goalkeeper – a remark made after an incredible save against him – as well as looking at where France stand after a few games under Zidane.
It has been revealed that A leader of Milan and France. How much does this defeat weigh on the standings?
“It will be a tough game to play, the last one, because we need to win. The coach told us it’s part of the journey. We’re on a new path and we’re doing some things well, others a little less so. Tonight was a great game to watch.
“We did some very good things, but not so much in the second half. They showed a little more determination and deserved to win.”.
What made the difference tonight?
Sources indicate that “Donnarumma did well. We could have closed the game out in the first half because we were in a better position than them. In the second half, it was the opposite, even though he made two or three incredible saves. That’s part of football. They played a good game. They have strong, new players.
“It’s not easy, but I wish them the best because there’s a lot to do. It was an exciting match.”.
📅 11 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (434 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Manchester United are reportedly looking at options beyond Michael Carrick after the club believes he is not the right option for United.
Former Germany manager Julian Nagelsmann is among the names linked with a possible move to Old Trafford if United.
Industry observers note that indykaila, a famous insider account on X, reported that Manchester United have started the process of finding their next head coach. Nagelsmann’s representatives are mentioned to be willing to hear what the club has planned before deciding whether the project would suit the German manager.
Exclusive 💣Manchester United begin process to identify next head coach, sources indicate.Club sources have confirmed that Manchester United have started formal progress on appointing a new manager.Representatives of Julian Nagelsmann are open to listening to the club’s….
United have not unveiled any change in their managerial aims, so the report remains unconfirmed. Carrick is still in charge, but his results at the start of the new season have given the club plenty to think about.
According to recent reports, michael Carrick did enough during his interim spell last season to earn the job permanently. After taking over following Ruben Amorim’s departure in January, he won 11 of his 16 matches and guided United to third place in the Premier League, securing Champions League qualification.
That run convinced the club to hand him a two-year contract in May. The new campaign, though, has been a disappointing story so far. United have picked up just six points from their first six league games, their worst start since 1985/86.
In a recent development, their latest setback came against Tottenham on Saturday. Bryan Mbeumo put United ahead, and Rodrigo Bentancur’s red card left Spurs with ten men, yet Dominic Solanke scored in stoppage time to make it 1-1.
Dropping points in those circumstances will only add to the pressure on Carrick, who needs a response from his players promptly.
Recent findings suggest that julian Nagelsmann has previously been linked with the Old Trafford job, and the latest report has brought his name back into the conversation. The 39-year-old’s representatives are reportedly open to hearing United’s plans, but there is no confirmed agreement or evidence that formal negotiations have taken place.
Carrick’s achievements last season bought him the permanent role, but the opening weeks of this campaign have left little room for further slip-ups.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (645 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

Published: 17:31 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 18:01 EST, 14 November 2026.
Sebastien Pocognoli has backed Ben Gannon-Doak to find his killer instinct in the final third and establish himself as Scotland’s main man.
The Bournemouth youngster had an up-and-down evening in Friday’s 2-1 Nations League win over North Macedonia, getting into numerous promising positions on the right flank and winning the penalty – dispatched by John McGinn – which decided the game.
But, as has been the case throughout his Scotland career, the 21-year-old’s final ball in key moments left a lot to be desired.
Pocognoli is under no illusions that Gannon-Doak still has plenty to improve on, but insists that it won’t be long before things start to click for the talented youngster.
‘As long as he is high on the pitch and is creating one v ones I am happy,’ mentioned the Belgian. ‘With Ben, we know that he is at a young age and needs to work on specific things.
Sources indicate that ‘On Friday, he had great opportunities. We know that he needs to improve on the end product, but he created a penalty and against Slovenia and North Macedonia away he created a number of unbelievable one v ones.
Scotland boss Sebastien Pocognoli greets Ben Gannon-Doak as he is substituted at Hampden.
It has been revealed that ‘He did that last night as well. We know he can be good if we dominate the game and he can get in good positions if we control the ball. I am happy with his performance.
‘He is a young lad, just 21. Okay, he has become more mature than he was, but I believe in one moment he will have a click about decision making.
‘I believe if he is playing every game he can make many decisions. He will know that in the next game he will have to do it again.
‘If he knows that he only has to play a game every two weeks, sometimes he can think, “This is my moment”.
Industry observers note that ‘It is a process. He will become older and at some point will become relaxed in his decision making, but at this very young age what he is producing is very good.
‘I say exactly the same thing to him after training on the pitch. I say, “Ben, this is the next step”. He knows that and it is vital he knows that.’.
Scotland conclude their Nations League campaign in Switzerland on Monday knowing that only a victory against the group winners will be enough if they are to have any chance of leapfrogging Slovenia – currently one point better off ahead of their trip to North Macedonia – into second spot.
Pocognoli admits Gannon-Doak's end product has to improve after another frustrating show.
Should that happen, Scotland would have a crack at earning promotion to League A via a play-off in March, and also crucially guarantee their place as a Pot 2 side for the upcoming Euro 2028 qualifying draw.
According to recent reports, ‘We are still alive in this competition,’ remarked Pocognoli, who celebrated his first win at Hampden on Friday at the third time of asking. ‘We know we have to do more than this competition. This competition is about trying to build something.
‘But it is nice to have that possibility on Monday to try to create something against one of the top 20 teams in the world.
‘We need to try to be brave. Switzerland have already qualified so let’s go there and be smart because they are a good team.
‘It is part of the process to play away against a top team. That is not something we have done yet. The approach will be different and, for me as a coach, it is a game with a lot of responsibility.’.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (665 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Swindon Town have been tipped to potentially part ways with experienced manager, Ian Holloway, after the Robins were defeated heavily by his former employers, Grimsby Town, at the County Ground on Saturday afternoon.
The Robins are presently 16th in League Two having taken 19 points from their first 15 matches, but have won just twice in their last 14 encounters across all competitions.
Saturday's 4-1 loss against the high-flying Mariners was also Swindon's third on the spin, having been eliminated from the FA Cup against League One side, MK Dons, as well as losing in the EFL Trophy to Plymouth Argyle.
Supporters in Wiltshire have grown increasingly frustrated with the club's recent situation, as the club have continued to stagnate in the fourth tier in the five years of Clem Morfuni's ownership.
Holloway recently surpassed two years in charge at the County Ground, but after finishing 12th in his first full season last term, there are concerns as to whether his team can show any signs of progress based on their recent form.
Holloway is, arguably, the EFL's most experienced manager at present, having taken charge at matches across all levels for 30 years, including Premier League spells with Blackpool and Crystal Palace.
The 63-year-old has gained a strong reputation for various incidents over time, and this season, that has been no exception for the Swindon boss.
Recent findings suggest that after slamming Manchester City for their alleged financial misconduct, Holloway claimed last month he was a "Dead. Man. Walking," within a viral interview clip, which he was reminded about by the supporters of his former club as David Artell's side ran riot, with Aaron Drinan's goal for the hosts a mere consolation after strikes from Andy Cook, Josh Andrews and a brace from Iwan Morgan.
Hollowaytook charge of Grimsby between December 2019 and 2020, winning 13 of his 39 matches in charge, accumulating a 33 percent win ratio in the process.
The experienced figure resigned at Blundell Park following a 2-1 loss to Bradford City which had the club lying 20th in League Two at the time, and the Mariners were eventually relegated back to the National League months later, albeit for a solitary season.
As such, the North Lincolnshire fanbase are not particularly fond of Holloway, who, in return, criticised their actions in his post-match interview.
“On that performance, it is what we deserved, and that hurts me bitterly, because that was a club that I used to work for," he said.
“You wouldn’t think so, would you? The use of language [from their fans] was disgusting, in my opinion, but that is what happens in modern-day football.
It has been revealed that “They didn’t say a word when we beat them 4-0 up there two years ago, did they? It is what it is," he added.
Discussing the action in League One and League Two from across the weekend, EFL pundits, Tom Garratt and Callum Fowler, were amongst those debating whether Holloway's future in the Swindon job is presently jeopardised.
According to recent reports, "Another man who should be under pressure, Ian Holloway. Swindon 1-4 Grimsby," said Garratt on the Pyramid podcast.
"He's just a 'dead man walking', that's what the Grimsby fans were singing to him," Fowler immediately responded.
"Swindon's four-game unbeaten run ends at the hands of Grimsby who have won their last three, scoring 13 goals in that time.".
Recent findings suggest that later discussing Holloway's immediate future, Garratt asked: "is he under pressure?" to which Fowler added: "100%. He's a nutter.".
In a recent development, "I'm amazed he's still got a job. Get him gone," the former then stated.
Industry observers note that swindon fans, is Ian Holloway the right man to lead the Robins forward? Comment below!
It remains to be seen where the Robins go from here, with the next opportunity for Holloway to turn the tide being Saturday's trip to Newport County, who sit two places above Swindon on goal difference.
📅 11 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (306 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Manchester United could face an expensive battle to sign Fulham youngster Josh King, with offers exceeding £50million potentially enough to persuade the London club to consider a sale.
The 19-year-old has attracted attention with his performances this season, despite Fulham’s difficult results.
Manchester United are among several clubs monitoring his progress, alongside Liverpool, Arsenal, Borussia Dortmund and Barcelona.
Speaking on the Transfer Insider podcast, Pete O’Rourke explained that King’s growing reputation has put him on the radar of several major clubs.
“Josh King will be on the radar for a number of clubs because of his performances for Fulham so far this season,” O’Rourke said.
“It’s not just Liverpool, there’s been talk of the likes of Manchester United, Arsenal, Borussia Dortmund and even Barcelona looking at Josh King.”.
It has been revealed that fulham are not actively planning to let the teenager leave in the near future as he is under contract until 2029. The contract length gives Fulham an upper hand, while interest from multiple clubs indicates a concession is not expected.
“Fulham are not planning for any early departure for Josh King. He is still under contract until 2029, and obviously they’ll want to keep him.”.
In a recent development, the reporter also pointed to Fulham’s league position as a factor that could influence their decision. If they become embroiled in a relegation battle, losing one of their best performers would be a major risk.
“If Manchester United or any other club wanted to make an offer, he’s going to be worth in excess of £50million probably right now.”.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 14 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (430 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

The Glazers took control of Manchester United in 2005. That takeover has since caused so many disruptions and protests by the fans over massive debts and insufficient backing of the team in the transfer market, despite successful periods in the Premier League and Europe.
Now Manchester United need to think about who should control the club in the future. Laurie Whitwell has now shared his views on why Manchester United need an ownership change. He simply wants the Glazers gone from Old Trafford. However, he also recognizes that replacing the current ownership doesn’t automatically mean things will improve for United.
The journalist believes the change in ownership has had a lasting effect on United, with the club still feeling its consequences today. A fresh start might be welcome, but the identity of the next owners would matter just as much as the departure of the existing ones.
“Personally, I would like to see the Glazers gone from Manchester United,” Laurie Whitwell mentioned on The Rest is Football podcast with Gary Lineker.
“That change, you know, just really affected and still impacts United now.”.
The desire for different ownership is one thing, but finding people capable of taking the club forward is another.
Whitwell admitted there is no perfect answer when it comes to who should take charge.
That leaves United facing a difficult choice. A sale could offer the chance to change how the club is run, but simply bringing in a latest owner would not guarantee better decisions or a brighter future.
Industry observers note that whitwell also raised the idea of United supporters having a greater say in the club’s ownership and decisions, much like the Barcelona model where fans own the club itself. However, he highlighted that the Barcelona model isn’t ideal either and has its own shortcomings.
Changing the names at the top would only be one part of the change. The club would also need an ownership structure capable of making sound decisions and providing a direction.
The problem of ownership goes beyond whether the Glazers should stay or leave. Manchester United needs to find the right people and the right model to secure the club’s future. Getting that decision wrong could leave them facing the same circus the fans are enduring under the Glazers.
It has been revealed that shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 94 min read (18894 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Nature

Recent findings suggest that brown adipocytes (BAs) are thermogenic cells that regulate energy homeostasis, and age-related declines in thermogenesis contribute to cold sensitivity1,2,3,4,5. We previously identified a BA subpopulation with low UCP1 expression (hereafter, BA-L cells) that coexists with the classical, high-UCP1-expressing BAs (hereafter, BA-H cells)6. Here we show that IL-1β secreted by neutrophils and macrophages stabilizes nearby BAs in the BA-L state. Specifically, IL-1β stabilizes hexose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (H6PD) protein from degradation to ensure the generation of active glucocorticoids, which activate the glucocorticoid receptor (GR, encoded by Nr3c1) and increase the expression of its target gene, regulator of G-protein signalling 2 (Rgs2), thereby suppressing UCP1 expression. Cold exposure reduces IL-1β levels, depending on sympathetic innervation, leading to H6PD degradation and the conversion of BA-L cells to BA-H cells, thereby enhancing UCP1-dependent thermogenesis. Rising environmental temperatures trigger the opposite events. BA-specific inducible deletion of Nr3c1 during cold exposure locks these cells in the BA-H state, leading to persistent thermogenesis and increased energy expenditure days after the mice return to room temperature. Notably, IL-1β is elevated in aged brown adipose tissue, resulting in a locked low BA-H/BA-L ratio and cold intolerance. Suppressing GR in aged mice restores the BA-H/BA-L ratio, resumes thermogenesis and increases energy expenditure. Our findings reveal a spatiotemporal neuronal–immune regulation of BA heterogeneity that governs thermogenesis and offers a fundamental understanding of the mechanisms underlying increased cold sensitivity in older individuals.
Recent findings suggest that functional cellular heterogeneity is well documented in hepatocytes, driven by liver zonation7, and in muscle fibres, shaped by local environmental cues, particularly motor neuron activity8. Single-cell technologies have revealed extensive latest patterns of heterogeneity of specific cell types within the same tissue9, yet their biological importance remains largely undetermined.
Thermogenic adipose tissue undergoes adaptive thermogenesis and is crucial for energy expenditure and thermoregulation1,2. Its specialized metabolism and precise responses to environmental and physiological stimuli make it an ideal model for studying functional cellular heterogeneity. Thermogenic capacity declines substantially with age in rodents and humans, leading to age-related cold sensitivity and metabolic disorders3,4,5, yet the underlying mechanisms remain unclear.
According to recent reports, BAs and beige adipocytes mediate UCP1-dependent non-shivering thermogenesis10. Although substantial progress has been made in identifying the key pathways that activate thermogenesis, most studies have been conducted at the whole-tissue level, leaving the mechanisms governing its activation, maintenance and deactivation incompletely understood.
Recent findings suggest that the heterogeneity of BAs within the same brown adipose tissue (BAT) and beige adipocyte cluster within inguinal white adipose tissue (iWAT) has been characterized by our group6 and others5,11,12,13,14. We found that BAs heterogeneously express UCP1 and classified those with low expression as BA-L cells and those with high expression as BA-H cells6. At room temperature, BA-H cells constitute 30–50% of all BAs; BA-H cells predominate after cold exposure, whereas BA-L cells predominate under thermoneutral conditions6. This raises questions of why BA heterogeneity exists, and whether it reflects random variation along a thermogenic continuum or spatially organized, tightly regulated states within the tissue.
Here we identify dynamic bistable regulation of BA heterogeneity controlled by the spatial proximity of BAs to IL-1β puncta through a neuronal–immune regulatory mechanism. This regulation becomes dysfunctional during ageing, leading to cold intolerance in older adults. These findings highlight how different cell types collectively control cellular heterogeneity in a spatiotemporal manner, integrating environmental and internal cues to regulate tissue metabolism and function.
Reanalysis of our previous single-cell RNA-sequencing (scRNA-seq) dataset6 revealed enrichment of glucocorticoid signalling and GR-target genes in BA-L cells (Extended Data Fig. 1a–c). Top BA-L-cell-enriched genes include H6pd, Rgs2 and thioredoxin-interacting protein (Txnip), whereas BA-H cells were enriched for thermogenesis-related genes, including Ucp1 and cytochrome c oxidase 6B1 (Cox6b1) (Extended Data Fig. 1a,b,d–f). Nr3c1 was similarly expressed in BA-H and BA-L cells (Extended Data Fig. 1e,f).
It has been revealed that we generated Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice for inducible labelling of Ucp1+ cells by crossing the Ucp1-rtTA, TRE-cre and Rosa-stop-mT/mG mouse lines (Extended Data Fig. 2a). After 1 week of feeding on a doxycycline diet at room temperature (24 °C), GFP+ and GFP− BAs revealed a patchy distribution (Fig. 1a), consistent with BA heterogeneity in AdipoChaser mice6. The Ucp1-rtTA mice used a relatively weak 5 kb Ucp1 promoter15 so GFP is only expressed in UCP1high-expressing BAs (BA-H cells), while Ucp1-cre mice have a strong bacterial artificial chromosome-based Ucp1 promoter that drives Cre expression in all BAs16. Immunofluorescence (IF) staining confirmed selective H6PD expression in BA-L cells (Fig. 1a); 50% of BAs were UCP1+(GFP+)H6PD−, 45% were UCP1−(GFP−)H6PD+ and 5% were UCP1+(GFP+)H6PD+ (Fig. 1b). Similar heterogeneity was observed in iWAT after 1 week of cold exposure (6 °C) (Fig. 1c), with 45% of these beige adipocytes being UCP1+H6PD−, 49% UCP1−H6PD+ and 6% UCP1+H6PD+ (Fig. 1d). Human BAT showed a similar reciprocal UCP1 and H6PD pattern in multilocular brown–beige adipocytes (Fig. 1e), 45% of BAs were UCP1+H6PD−, 47% were UCP1−H6PD+ and 8% were UCP1+H6PD+ (Fig. 1f). Western blotting confirmed more than twofold higher H6PD in BA-L cells than in BA-H cells and more than fourfold higher UCP1 in BA-H cells than in BA-L cells, while H6PD was enriched in mature BAs relative to in the stromal vascular fractions (SVFs) (Extended Data Fig. 2b,c). Together, these data identify H6PD as a BA-L marker.
In a recent development, a,b, Male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice (aged 10 weeks) were fed a doxycycline chow diet for 1 week at 24 °C. Representative images of BAT IF staining for GFP (green), H6PD (red), perilipin (white) and DAPI (blue) (a), and quantification of the relative percentage of BAs positive for GFP+(UCP1+) only, H6PD+ only or both (b). n = 6 per group. c,d, Male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice aged 10 weeks were fed a doxycycline chow diet for 3 days or 1 week at 6 °C. c, Representative images of IF staining for GFP (green), H6PD (red) and DAPI (blue) in iWAT. d, Quantification of the relative percentage of BAs positive for GFP+(UCP1+) only, H6PD+ only or both. n = 4 per group. e, Representative IF staining for UCP1 (green), H6PD (red), perilipin (white) and DAPI (blue) in human supraclavicular BAT. f, Quantification of the relative percentage of BAs that are positive for UCP1+ only, H6PD+ only or both. n = 5 per group. g, BAs differentiated from primary BAT SVFs from WT mice were reverse-transfected with H6pd Dicer-substrate small interfering RNAs (dsiRNAs) or control dsiRNAs and collected after 2 days. RT–qPCR analysis of H6pd, Rgs2, Hsd11b1 and Ucp1 mRNA levels. n = 3 per group. h–j, 10-week-old male Ucp1-mGFP mice were injected with lentivirus overexpressing H6PD or mCherry as a control into BAT. h, After 2 weeks, H6PD and β-actin protein levels were analysed using western blotting (WB). i, Representative IF staining of BAT for GFP (green), perilipin (red) and DAPI (blue). j, Quantification of the BA-H cell percentage. For j, n = 5 (mCherry) and n = 4 (H6PD). Statistics were computed using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Tukey’s multiple-comparison test (b, d and f), unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-tests (g (H6pd and Hsd11b1)) or unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-tests (g (Rgs2 and Ucp1) and j); *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01, ****P < 0.0001. For b, d, f, g and j, data are mean ± s.e.m. Scale bars, 25 μm (a (right), c (bottom)), 50 μm (a (left), c (top) and e) and 100 μm (i).
It has been revealed that to enable real-time labelling of BA-H cells, we generated Ucp1-mGFP knock-in mice by inserting a P2A-mGFP cassette after Ucp1 exon 6, immediately upstream of the stop codon (Extended Data Fig. 2d). These mice displayed robust BAT GFP fluorescence without altered UCP1 expression (Extended Data Fig. 2e,f). GFP IF staining revealed a heterogeneous distribution of GFP+ and GFP− BAs (Extended Data Fig. 2g). In vitro-cultured BAs and beige adipocytes revealed selective H6PD expression in GFP− BA-L cells (Extended Data Fig. 2h), validating our in vivo findings.
Sources indicate that we next investigated UCP1-independent thermogenesis through the futile creatine cycle17,18,19,20,21. Tissue-non-specific alkaline phosphatase (TNAP) and creatine kinase B (CKB) protein levels increased 4.8-fold and 2.5-fold, respectively, in BAT during cold exposure and were enriched 2.9-fold and 2.0-fold in BA-L cells versus in BA-H cells (Extended Data Fig. 3a,b), consistent with higher Ckb mRNA in BA-L cells6. IF staining further highlighted TNAP enrichment in BA-L cells (H6PDhigh BAs) in BAT and H6PDhigh beige adipocytes in cold-exposed iWAT (Extended Data Fig. 3c,d). In vitro-differentiated BAs also displayed selective TNAP expression in BA-L cells (GFP− BAs) (Extended Data Fig. 3e), indicating that the futile creatine cycle is more active in BA-L cells.
Regarding the metabolic differences between BA-L cells and BA-H cells, BA-L cells have half the basal respiration, but similar maximal respiration compared to BA-H cells, indicating similarly high mitochondrial potential6. Using in vivo [U-13C]glucose tracing22, we recently highlighted that BAT has the most active glucose oxidation among metabolically active tissues, while in vitro tracing confirmed active glucose oxidation in differentiated BAs23. To characterize BA-L metabolism, we performed [U-13C] glucose and [U-13C] palmitate tracing in freshly isolated BA-H cells and BA-L cells, followed by gas chromatography–mass spectrometry (GC–MS) analysis (Extended Data Fig. 4a). Fully labelled (m+16) free palmitate (C16:0) was about twofold higher in BA-L cells, indicating greater fatty acid uptake (Extended Data Fig. 4b), while fully labelled total palmitate was sixfold higher, suggesting preferential fatty acids storage in BA-L cells (Extended Data Fig. 4c). BA-L cells also showed lower citrate enrichment from both tracers, indicating lower glucose and fatty acid oxidation (Extended Data Fig. 4d). Thus, BA-L cells exhibit greater fatty acid uptake and accumulation but lower fatty acid and glucose oxidation, consistent with their lower basal respiration6.
We next examined whether H6PD is a functional marker of BA-L cells. H6PD depletion in BAs differentiated from BAT SVFs of Ucp1-mGFP mice increased Ucp1 expression sixfold (Fig. 1g), indicating that H6PD negatively regulates Ucp1. Conversely, H6pd overexpression by lentiviral injection into BAT of Ucp1-mGFP mice (Fig. 1h and Extended Data Fig. 4e,f) significantly reduced the proportion of BA-H cells (Fig. 1i,j). Thus, H6PD is a functional marker of BA-L that regulates UCP1 expression and BA heterogeneity.
In a recent development, H6PD localizes to the endoplasmic reticulum lumen and generates endoplasmic reticulum-resident NADPH, distinct from cytosolic glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PD)24. H6PD primarily determines the reductase activity of endoplasmic reticulum-localized 11β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase (HSD11B1), which converts inactive cortisone to active cortisol25. GR protein levels were similar between BA-H cells and BA-L cells, indicating that GR signalling is not regulated by receptor abundance (Extended Data Fig. 3b). We next investigated whether GR signalling regulates UCP1 expression. Simultaneous treatment of BAs differentiated from the SVFs of wild-type (WT) mice with 11-dehydrocorticosterone (11-DHC), a natural substrate for active glucocorticoid biosynthesis25, and noradrenaline (NA) substantially increased UCP1 protein (Fig. 2a). However, 24 h 11-DHC pretreatment blunted NA-induced UCP1 expression (Fig. 2b). Thus, prolonged activation of GR signalling suppresses BA responsiveness to NA, maintaining BA-L cells in a stable, low-thermogenic status.
a–c, BAs differentiated from primary BAT SVFs of WT mice were treated with NA ± 11-DHC for 24 h (a) or pretreated with vehicle or 11-DHC for 24 h, followed by NA (b) or forskolin (c) treatment for 24 h. UCP1 and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. n = 3 independent cultures. Co-treat, co-treatment; pretreat, pretreatment. d–f, BAs were pretreated with vehicle or 11-DHC for 48 h, followed by NA (d), forskolin (e) or 8-BrcAMP (f) treatment for 30 min. Immunoblots and quantification of phosphorylated PKA substrates and β-actin are shown. n = 3 independent cultures. g, BAs were pretreated with vehicle or RU-486 for 1 h, followed by NA with or without DEX treatment for 24 h. Immunoblots and quantification of UCP1 and β-actin are shown. n = 4 independent cultures. h, Male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice (aged 10 weeks) were on a doxycycline chow diet for 1 week at 24 °C. BAT IF staining for GFP (green), RGS2 (red), perilipin (white) and DAPI (blue), and quantification of single- or double-positive BAs are shown. n = 4 per group. i, BAs were treated with vehicle or DEX for 2 h and subjected to ChIP using anti-GR antibody or control IgG. ChIP–qPCR analysis of Rgs2 promoter (−92 bp to +53 bp), presented as the percentage of input DNA. n = 4 per group. j, RT–qPCR analysis of Rgs2 in three-dimensionally cultured primary BAs, treated with vehicle, DEX, CL-316,243 or DEX + CL-316,243 for 24 h. n = 3 per group. k–m, BAs were reverse-transfected with Rgs2 or control dsiRNAs. k, Rgs2 mRNA was analysed 2 days after. Cells were then pretreated with 11-DHC for 24 h and stimulated with NA for 30 min. l,m, Immunoblots (l) and quantification (m) of phosphorylated PKA substrates and β-actin. n = 3 per group (k) and n = 4 per group (m). Statistical analysis was performed using one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparison test (a–h, j and m), unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-tests (i (GR) and k) and unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-tests (i (IgG)); ***P < 0.001. NS, not significant. For a–g, i–k and m, data are mean ± s.e.m. Scale bar, 50 μm (h).
Forskolin activates adenylyl cyclase (AC) to generate cAMP26. 11-DHC pretreatment also blocked forskolin-induced UCP1 expression (Fig. 2c), suggesting inhibition of AC activity or downstream cAMP signalling. To determine where GR signalling acts within the canonical β-adrenergic receptor–cAMP–PKA pathway that controls UCP1 expression27, we measured PKA activity in in vitro-differentiated BAs after 24 h of 11-DHC pretreatment, followed by NA, forskolin or 8-BrcAMP (a cAMP derivative). 11-DHC pretreatment markedly reduced NA- or forskolin-induced PKA activity (Fig. 2d,e), but not the response to 8-BrcAMP (Fig. 2f), indicating that downstream cAMP signalling is not affected by GR activation. Thus, GR signalling potentially suppresses UCP1 expression by inhibiting AC-mediated cAMP production.
Recent findings suggest that whereas 11-DHC requires conversion to active glucocorticoids, dexamethasone (DEX) directly activates GR. In contrast to the delayed effect of 11-DHC, DEX suppressed NA-induced UCP1 expression after co-treatment (Fig. 2g), an effect that was abrogated by the GR antagonist mifepristone (RU-486) (Fig. 2g). Similarly, in the in vitro-differentiated BAs, CL-316,243 increased Ucp1 expression about 3-fold, whereas DEX pretreatment reduced this induction to about 1.6-fold (Extended Data Fig. 5a). Together, these data support the conclusion that GR activation maintains BA-L cells in a low-UCP1-expressing state by suppressing cAMP production.
Recent findings suggest that we next investigated how GR signalling regulates BA heterogeneity. DEX is commonly used in adipogenic differentiation cocktails; its withdrawal increased the BA-H/BA-L ratio by 2.8-fold in BAs differentiated from BAT SVF of Ucp1-mGFP mice (Extended Data Fig. 5b,c). Conversely, 11-DHC and the active glucocorticoid corticosterone decreased the BA-H/BA-L ratio compared with in the DEX-free control, independent of differentiation efficiency (Extended Data Fig. 5b–d). In WT mice, DEX induced BAT whitening and reduced the BA-H/BA-L ratio by 74% (Extended Data Fig. 5e,f). Thus, manipulating GR signalling alters BA heterogeneity both in vitro and in vivo.
In a recent development, to determine how GR signalling inhibits cAMP production, we examined other BA-L-enriched genes. Rgs2 was highly expressed in BA-L cells (Extended Data Fig. 1a,b,e,f). RGS2 binds to the C1 domain of AC III, V and VI, attenuating Gαs-dependent cAMP accumulation28. IF staining confirmed selective RGS2 expression in BA-L cells, with 40% of BAs being UCP1+(GFP+)RGS2−, 55% UCP1−(GFP−)RGS2+ and 5% UCP1+(GFP+)RGS2+ (Fig. 2h). RGS2 was also selectively expressed in GFP− BA-L cells in in vitro-differentiated BAs (brown and beige) (Extended Data Fig. 5g,h). Analysis of published GR chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) followed by sequencing datasets29 identified GR occupancy within the promoter and intronic regions of Rgs2 (Extended Data Fig. 5i). ChIP–quantitative PCR (qPCR) in in vitro-differentiated BAs confirmed GR binding at the Rgs2 promoter, which was enhanced by DEX (Fig. 2i). Lastly, DEX increased Rgs2 mRNA 2.2-fold in freshly isolated BAs (Fig. 2j), supporting Rgs2 as a GR target. Thus, RGS2 is a GR target in the BAs that inhibits cAMP production. Knocking down Rgs2 in in vitro-differentiated BAs (Fig. 2k) did not affect PKA activity in response to NA alone (Extended Data Fig. 5j,k). However, Rgs2 knockdown abrogated the inhibitory effect of 11-DHC pretreatment on NA-induced PKA substrate phosphorylation (Fig. 2l,m). Rgs2 is therefore a GR target in BAs that suppresses Ucp1 expression by inhibiting AC activity, and BA-L cells are stabilized in the low-thermogenic state through the GR–RGS2–AC signalling axis.
H6PD protein levels in BAT changed inversely with UCP1 across environmental temperatures, while GR protein was only slightly elevated at thermoneutrality (30 °C) (Extended Data Fig. 6a). Cold exposure reduced H6PD protein by 1.8-fold in iWAT, but not in gonadal white adipose tissue (gWAT) (Extended Data Fig. 6b,c), suggesting thermogenic-depot-specific regulation. CL-316,243 similarly decreased H6PD and increased UCP1 protein levels in BAT (Extended Data Fig. 6d). H6pd mRNA decreased rather than increased with rising temperature in BAT (Extended Data Fig. 6e), indicating post-transcriptional regulation. Thus, H6PD protein levels, but not mRNA levels, change dynamically in BAT in response to fluctuating environmental temperatures, which may be essential for altering the BA-H/BA-L ratio in response to thermogenic demand.
It has been revealed that sympathetic neurons secrete NA to activate BA thermogenesis. We next tested whether sympathetic innervation mediates cold-induced H6PD protein reduction using unilateral BAT denervation, validated by reduced tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) protein (Fig. 3a). Cold exposure increased BA-H cells from 31.1% to 85.6% (Fig. 3b), as previously reported6. Denervation prevented the cold-induced reduction of H6PD (Fig. 3a), and although there was an increase in the BA-H/BA-L ratio, the proportion of BA-H cells was 66% lower than the sham group during cold exposure (29.1% versus 85.6%) (Fig. 3b). The low BA-H/BA-L ratio was accompanied by BA whitening (Extended Data Fig. 6f), a feature associated with impaired thermogenesis30. Notably, H6PD consistently labelled BA-L cells regardless of the variable BA-H/BA-L ratio at different environmental temperatures (Fig. 3b). Thus, sympathetic innervation is required to reduce H6PD protein and raise the BA-H/BA-L ratio after cold exposure.
a,b, Male WT (a) or Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG (b) mice (aged 8 weeks) underwent sham (S) or unilateral BAT denervation (D). After 2 weeks of recovery, the mice were housed at 24 °C or 6 °C for 1 week (Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice received a doxycycline diet). a, Immunoblots and quantification of H6PD, TH, UCP1 and β-actin in BAT. b, BAT IF staining for GFP (green), H6PD (red) and DAPI (blue), and BA-H quantification. n = 3 per group (a) and n = 4 per group (b). c, Male WT mice (aged 10 weeks) were housed at 6 °C for 1 week, with or without subsequent housing at 30 °C for 1 week. Immunoblots and quantification of UCP1, H6PD, GR and β-actin are shown. n = 3 per group. d–k, After doxycycline (dox) diet feeding, Ucp1-Nr3c1flox/flox (Ucp1-rtTA;TRE-cre;Nr3c1flox/flox) mice become Ucp1-Nr3c1−/− (Ucp1-rtTA;TRE-cre;Nr3c1−/−), with Nr3c1 deleted in BA-H cells. TRE-Cre-negative littermates were used as controls. d, Male mice (aged 9 weeks (w)) were housed at 6 °C for 1 week, then fed a doxycycline diet at 6 °C for 1 week and then returned to 24 °C with continued feeding on a doxycycline diet. e, BAT IF staining for perilipin (green), GR (red) and DAPI (blue). The white, red and yellow arrows indicate representative GR+ BAs, GR− BAs and non-adipocytes, respectively. f, GR, RGS2 and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. g, BAT and WATs (iWAT and gWAT) in PBS buffer. Ucp1-Nr3c1−/− BAT exhibits a higher density and sinks. h, Haematoxylin and eosin (H&E) staining of BAT and iWAT. i, BAT IF staining for perilipin (green), UCP1 (red) and DAPI (blue). j,k, Energy expenditure (j) and body weight (k). n = 3 per group (f) and n = 7 per group (j and k). Statistics were computed using two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparison test (a and b), unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-tests (c, f, j (average) and k) and two-way ANOVA with Šídák’s multiple-comparison test (j (time-course curves and day–night)). For a–c, f, j and k, data are mean ± s.e.m. Scale bars, 50 μm (b, e, h (left) and i) and 1.2 mm (h (right)).
Recent findings suggest that cold exposure also downregulated GR target genes, including Rasd1, Fkbp5, Pik3r1, Tsc22d3 and Rgs2 in BAT, whereas denervation blunted these effects (Extended Data Fig. 6g), supporting the involvement of GR signalling in raising the BA-H/BA-L ratio. We next tested whether the opposite occurred when shifting mice from cold to thermoneutrality. H6PD protein increased 2.1-fold in BAT, while GR protein remained unchanged (Fig. 3c). Transitioning cold-exposed mice to 30 °C also restored GR target gene expression in BAT (Extended Data Fig. 6h), indicating that H6PD and GR signalling dynamically respond to temperature fluctuations to regulate BA heterogeneity.
We next tested whether blocking GR during the transition from cold to warmer temperatures prevents BA-H cells from switching to BA-L cells. We generated a BA-H-specific, inducible Nr3c1-knockout model by crossing Ucp1-rtTA, TRE-cre and Nr3c1flox/flox mice (Fig. 3d). Mice were first exposed to 6 °C for 1 week to raise the BA-H/BA-L ratio, followed by 1 week of doxycycline diet under cold conditions to induce Nr3c1 deletion in BA-H cells (Ucp1-Nr3c1flox/flox turning into Ucp1-Nr3c1−/−), and were then returned to room temperature with the doxycycline diet for another week. One week is long enough for the mice to reduce thermogenesis according to the rise in environmental temperature. IF staining confirmed Nr3c1 deletion in most BAs (Fig. 3e), consistent with 86% of BAs being BA-H cells during cold exposure (Fig. 3b), and western blotting highlighted reduced GR and RGS2 in isolated BAs (Fig. 3f). We previously showed that BA-H cells contain smaller lipid droplets and therefore have higher density, whereas BA-L cells have larger lipid droplets, lower density and float after mild centrifugation (like white adipocytes)6. Notably, BAT from Ucp1-Nr3c1−/− mice sank in PBS, whereas control BAT floated (Fig. 3g), suggesting a higher density and a higher BA-H/BA-L ratio. Consistently, Ucp1-Nr3c1−/− mice showed browner BAT with smaller lipid droplets, increased iWAT beiging (Fig. 3h) and a higher proportion of BA-H cells (Fig. 3i). Metabolic cage studies further showed increased energy expenditure and oxygen consumption in Ucp1-Nr3c1−/− mice, without changes in body weight (Fig. 3j,k and Extended Data Fig. 6i), body composition, food intake, respiratory exchange ratio or locomotor activity (Extended Data Fig. 6j–n). As the controls were metabolically healthy young adults, Ucp1-Nr3c1−/− mice showed no further improvements in glucose tolerance or insulin sensitivity (Extended Data Fig. 6o,p). These data highlight stage- and cell-subtype-specific requirements for GR signalling to regulate bistable BA states and thermogenesis. Inhibition of GR reactivation during the transition from cold to room temperature preserved a high BA-H/BA-L ratio and persistent thermogenesis despite reduced environmental thermogenic demand. These data not only confirm that we can block the BA-H-to-BA-L switch by inhibiting GR signalling, but also indicate that manipulating BA heterogeneity can increase thermogenesis and significantly boost whole-body energy expenditure.
In a recent development, to elucidate the sympathetic regulation of H6PD protein, we treated in vitro-differentiated BAs with NA but observed no change in H6PD protein (Fig. 4a), suggesting that other cell types and factors are involved in sympathetic regulation of H6PD. We next assessed cytokine expression in BAT and found that Il1b exhibited the greatest reduction (by 53%) after cold exposure (Fig. 4b and Extended Data Fig. 7a), and the greatest induction (by 3.3-fold) when mice were shifted from cold to thermoneutrality (Fig. 4c and Extended Data Fig. 7b). Cold-induced Il1b suppression was blunted by BAT sympathetic denervation (Fig. 4b), while NA reduced Il1b expression in BAT explants (Extended Data Fig. 7c). Il1b was predominantly expressed in SVFs rather than in mature adipocytes (Fig. 4d) and its expression changed with environmental temperature (Fig. 4d). qPCR with reverse transcription (RT–qPCR) analysis further confirmed the predominant expression of Il1b in CD45+ SVFs (Fig. 4e), indicating an immune cell source. By contrast, systemic IL-1β levels remained unchanged across environmental temperatures, suggesting local regulation of IL-1β levels in BAT (Extended Data Fig. 7d).
Sources indicate that a, BAs differentiated from primary BAT SVFs were treated with NA for 24 h. Immunoblots and quantification of H6PD and β-actin are shown. n = 3 independent cultures. b,c, Male WT mice (aged 8 weeks) underwent sham or unilateral BAT denervation, recovered for 2 weeks and were then housed at 24 °C or 6 °C for 1 week (b) or were housed at 6 °C for 1 week, with or without subsequent housing at 30 °C for 1 week (c). BAT Il1b was analysed using RT–qPCR. n = 4 per group. d, Il1b RT–qPCR in BAT SVFs and mature adipocytes (10-week-old male mice). n = 4 per group. e, Ucp1, Ptprc, Pdgfra and Il1b mRNA in BAT mature adipocytes, and CD45+ and CD45− SVFs. n = 4, 3 and 3, respectively. f, Male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice (aged 10 weeks) received a doxycycline diet at 24 °C for 1 week. BAT IF staining for GFP (green), IL-1β (purple) and DAPI (blue). The dashed and solid yellow lines circle representative BA-L (GFP−) and BA-H (GFP+) cell clusters, respectively. g–i, BAs were treated with TNF, IL-1β, IFNγ or their combination for 48 h (g); IL-1β for 0–48 h (h); or were pretreated with IL-1β or vehicle for 4 h followed by CHX for 0–12 h (i). H6PD and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. n = 4 per group (g and h) and n = 3 per group (i). j,k, Male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice (aged 10 weeks) received intra-BAT lentivirus overexpressing IL-1RA or mCherry, followed by 2 weeks of recovery and 1 week of doxycycline diet. BAT IF staining for GFP (green), perilipin (red) and DAPI (blue) (j) and BA-H quantification (k). n = 3 per group. Statistical analysis was performed using unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-tests (a and k), one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparison test (b and h), unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-test (c), two-way ANOVA with Šídák’s multiple-comparison test (d and i) and one-way ANOVA with Dunnett’s T3 multiple-comparison test (g). For a–d, g–i and k, data are mean ± s.e.m. Scale bars, 50 μm (f) and 100 μm (j).
Notably, IF staining revealed that BA-L cells clustered around IL-1β puncta, whereas BA-H cells formed clusters further away (Fig. 4f and Extended Data Fig. 7e), a pattern that was observed across room temperature, during cold exposure and after denervation (Extended Data Fig. 7e). Quantification indicated that IL-1β puncta and GFP+ cells (BA-H cells) show a significant negative Pearson correlation coefficient (PCC = −0.5 ± 0.1), suggesting a mutually exclusive pattern between these two factors at room temperature (Extended Data Fig. 7f). During cold exposure, this pattern persisted but was weaker (PCC = −0.2 ± 0.1), as fewer IL-1β puncta were available for quantification (Extended Data Fig. 7f). BAT denervation prevented the reduction in IL-1β puncta, maintained a low BA-H/BA-L ratio and preserved a strong negative correlation with GFP+ cells (BA-H cells) (PCC = −0.45 ± 0.1). Thus, across all three conditions, BA-L cells were consistently close to IL-1β puncta, indicating a strong correlation between IL-1β and BA heterogeneity.
Sources indicate that we next tested whether IL-1β regulates H6PD protein levels in BAs. Among the proinflammatory cytokines tested, TNF and IL-1β increased H6PD protein levels by 1.8- and 3.5-fold, respectively (Fig. 4g), without increasing H6pd mRNA (Extended Data Fig. 7g), confirming a post-transcriptional regulation of H6PD. Combined IL-1β, TNF and IFNγ treatment did not further increase H6PD protein beyond the effect of IL-1β alone (Fig. 4g). IL-1β increased H6PD protein in a time-dependent manner (Fig. 4h). During cycloheximide (CHX) treatment, H6PD abundance decreased by 30% and 50% at 6 and 12 h, respectively, whereas IL-1β prevented this decline (Fig. 4i), indicating increased H6PD protein stability from degradation. IL-1β is known to activate multiple downstream pathways, including JNK, MEK–ERK, p38–MAPK and IKK–NF-κB. Among inhibitors targeting these pathways, only the MEK and ERK inhibitor U0126 attenuated IL-1β-induced H6PD upregulation (Extended Data Fig. 7h,i), indicating that MEK–ERK mediates IL-1β-induced H6PD stability.
We next examined whether IL-1β regulates UCP1 expression. IL-1β did not alter UCP1 expression in the in vitro-differentiated BAs in the absence of 11-DHC, but reduced UCP1 protein levels by 53% in the presence of 11-DHC (Extended Data Fig. 7j,k), indicating that IL-1β suppresses UCP1 through GR signalling.
Industry observers note that adipose-tissue-resident immune cells can regulate sympathetic innervation31,32,33. However, TH and synaptophysin staining showed similar sympathetic innervation of BA-H cells and BA-L cells (Extended Data Fig. 7l,m), indicating that IL-1β regulates BA heterogeneity independently of differential sympathetic innervation.
It has been revealed that to identify the immune cells that secrete IL-1β in BAT, we integrated multiple published BAT scRNA-seq datasets14,34,35,36,37 (Extended Data Fig. 8a). β-Adrenergic receptors were expressed in CD45+ immune cells (Extended Data Fig. 8a,b), suggesting potential sympathetic regulation. Subclustering analysis revealed that Il1b was enriched in neutrophils (CD45+CD11b+F4/80−CXCR2+), monocytes (CD45+CD11b+F4/80−Ly6C+), and macrophages (CD45+CD11b+F4/80+) (Extended Data Fig. 8c–e). Flow cytometry confirmed that IL-1β was mainly produced by CD45+ immune cells (Extended Data Fig. 9a,b), with IL-1β+ cells predominantly comprising neutrophils and macrophages, but not monocytes (Extended Data Fig. 9c–e). IL-1β+ cells represented 10% of neutrophils and 1% of macrophages, indicating that IL-1β production is restricted to specific subsets (Extended Data Fig. 9d). Despite the low frequency, the greater abundance of macrophages resulted in substantial numbers of IL-1β+ macrophages, with IL-1β+ neutrophils only 1.7-fold more abundant (Extended Data Fig. 9e), indicating that both cell types are major IL-1β sources. IF staining further confirmed IL-1β colocalization with subsets of CXCR2+ neutrophils and F4/80+ macrophages in BAT (Extended Data Fig. 9f,g).
Recent findings suggest that depletion of CD45+ immune cells from BAT SVFs increased the BA-H/BA-L ratio by 2.7-fold without affecting overall differentiation efficiency (Extended Data Fig. 9h–j), supporting a role for immune cells in regulating BA heterogeneity. To further confirm the role of local IL-1β in thermogenic regulation, we injected lentivirus encoding Il1rn (encoding IL-1RA), a naturally occurring inhibitor of IL-1 receptor signalling, or an mCherry control directly into BAT (Extended Data Fig. 10a). IL-1RA increased the BA-H/BA-L ratio twofold in mice housed at room temperature (Fig. 4j,k). In in vitro-differentiated BAs, Il1r knockdown attenuated IL-1β-mediated suppression of UCP1 expression, indicating a direct effect of IL-1β on BAs (Extended Data Fig. 10b). Moreover, in vivo pharmacological inhibition of IL-1β production using the caspase-1 inhibitor VX-765 increased the BA-H/BA-L ratio by 2.2-fold (Extended Data Fig. 10c,d), further demonstrating a functional role for IL-1β in regulating BA heterogeneity.
In a recent development, we next investigated how temperature fluctuations regulate IL-1β in BAT. Il1b expression in primary BAT SVFs was temperature-dependent (Fig. 4d), whereas IL-1β+ immune cell numbers remained unchanged across housing temperatures (Extended Data Fig. 10e–h), indicating regulation independent of immune cell recruitment. NA directly suppressed Il1b expression in BAT-derived CD45+ immune cells (Extended Data Fig. 10i), suggesting adrenergic regulation of IL-1β production. Consistent with adrenergic receptor expression in CD45+ immune cells (Extended Data Fig. 8a,b), scRNA-seq analysis showed selective expression of Adrb1 and Adrb2, but not α-adrenergic receptor genes, in Il1b-expressing immune cell populations (Extended Data Fig. 11a). We further examined adrenergic regulation of Il1b using bone marrow-derived neutrophils. Lipopolysaccharide (LPS) induced Il1b expression dose dependently (Extended Data Fig. 11b), whereas NA pretreatment suppressed this induction in a dose- and time-dependent manner (Extended Data Fig. 11c,d). This effect was reversed by the non-selective β-adrenergic receptor antagonist propranolol, but not by the non-selective α-adrenergic receptor antagonist phenoxybenzamine (Extended Data Fig. 11e,f). Consistently, propranolol administration, but not phenoxybenzamine, increased Il1b expression in BAT in vivo (Extended Data Fig. 11g,h), supporting β-adrenergic suppression of IL-1β production.
Decreased BA thermogenesis has been reported with obesity38 and ageing3. However, high fat diet- (HFD)-induced obese mice were completely cold-tolerant, with 100% survival after 7 days of cold exposure (Fig. 5a,b). HFD feeding decreased H6PD and increased UCP1 protein levels (Fig. 5c), indicating preserved BAT thermogenic potential. By contrast, aged mice exhibited cold intolerance, with reduced body temperature and a 25% mortality within the first 2 days (Fig. 5d,e), suggesting impaired thermogenesis. Aged mice indicated a 2.3-fold increase in H6PD and a 40% decrease in UCP1 (Fig. 5f), suggesting a reduced BA-H/BA-L ratio. GR was modestly reduced by HFD feeding but unchanged with ageing. These differences suggest that cold-induced thermogenesis is more severely impaired with ageing than with obesity at a young age, and that the molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying impaired thermogenesis may differ substantially.
a–f, Male WT mice (aged 8 weeks) were fed chow or HFD for 10 weeks (a–c), or 10-week-old (young) and 75-week-old (aged) male mice (d–f) were exposed to 6 °C. Rectal temperatures (a,d), Kaplan–Meier survival curves (b,e), and H6PD, GR, UCP1 and β-actin immunoblots and quantification (c,f) are shown. n = 6 per group (a), n = 7 per group (b and d), n = 4 per group (c), n = 37 (young) and n = 38 (aged) (e) and n = 3 per group (f). g,h, Young (aged 8 weeks) and old (aged 74 weeks) male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice received a doxycycline diet for 1 week, then 6 °C for 1 and 3 days with continued doxycycline feeding. g, BAT IF staining for GFP (green), H6PD (red) and DAPI (blue). h, BA-H quantification. n = 3 per group. i, Male WT mice aged 10 weeks were housed at 24 °C or 6 °C for 1 or 3 days. H6PD and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. n = 3 per group. j–m, Male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice aged 72 weeks received vehicle or RU-486 (60 mg per kg per day, subcutaneous) with doxycycline diet for 1 week and were maintained at 24 °C (j,k) or exposed to 6 °C for 1 day (l,m). BAT IF staining for GFP (green), perilipin (red) and DAPI (blue) (j,l), and BA-H quantification (k,m). n = 4 per group. n, Male WT mice aged 75 weeks received vehicle or RU-486 (60 mg per kg per day, subcutaneous injection) for 1 week. H&E staining of BAT was performed. Statistics were computed using two-way ANOVA with Šídák’s multiple-comparison test (a and d), log-rank tests (b and e), unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-tests (c (H6PD), f (H6PD) and k), unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-tests (c (GR and UCP1), f (GR and UCP1) and m), one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparison test (i) and two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparison test (h). For a, c, d, f, i, k and m, data are mean ± s.e.m. Scale bars, 50 μm (j and l) and 100 μm (g and n).
Sources indicate that in young Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice, BA-H cells increased from 28.8% at 24 °C to 61.7% and 89.7% after 1 and 3 days of cold exposure, respectively. In aged mice, the baseline BA-H/BA-L ratio at 24 °C was extremely low (0.31%), and BA-H cells increased to 15% and 50.9% after 1 and 3 days of cold exposure, respectively (Fig. 5g,h), suggesting delayed BA bistable regulation in response to cold stimulation. H6PD progressively decreased during cold exposure in both young and aged mice (Fig. 5i and Extended Data Fig. 11i), but its level at cold exposure in aged mice was comparable to that in young mice at 24 °C (Extended Data Fig. 11i). UCP1 was also reduced in aged mice, consistent with the lower BA-H/BA-L ratio (Extended Data Fig. 11i). Despite increased BA-L abundance, cold-induced TNAP expression was also blunted with age, although TNAP remained enriched in BA-L cells (Extended Data Fig. 11j), suggesting impaired futile creatine cycle activation. Aged mice also exhibited a 1.8-fold increase in BAT corticosterone (the active form of glucocorticoid in mice) in BAT, but not serum corticosterone (Extended Data Fig. 11k,l), and a sixfold increase in BAT Il1b expression arising from SVFs (Extended Data Fig. 11m,n). Together, these results suggest that elevated local IL-1β and H6PD-mediated overactivation of the GR–RGS2–AC axis lower the BA-H/BA-L ratio, therefore impairing cold-induced thermogenesis in aged mice.
Lastly, we investigated whether GR inhibition could restore BA bistable regulation and thermogenesis in aged mice. One week of RU-486 treatment increased the proportion of BA-H cells in aged mice from 0.5% to 8.3% at room temperature and from 10.6% to 32.8% after 1 day of cold exposure (Fig. 5j–m). RU-486 also reduced lipid droplet accumulation within BAs and improved BAT whitening (Fig. 5n), increased rectal temperature during the cold tolerance test and reduced body weight in the first few days of cold exposure (Extended Data Fig. 11o,p). Metabolic cage studies revealed that RU-486 treatment increased energy expenditure and oxygen consumption across the day–night cycle, without changes in respiratory exchange ratio, locomotor activity or food intake (Extended Data Fig. 11q–u). Thus, GR antagonism increases energy expenditure in aged mice, potentially due to elevated UCP1-dependent thermogenesis in BAT.
We found that the two BA subtypes are spatially organized and tightly regulated. IL-1β stabilizes surrounding BAs in the low-thermogenic state (BA-L cells) by extending H6PD protein half-life. H6PD facilitates active glucocorticoid production, which suppresses UCP1 expression through the GR–RGS2–AC axis (Extended Data Fig. 12a). BAs further from IL-1β puncta are stabilized in the high-thermogenic state (BA-H cells) with low H6PD protein levels (Extended Data Fig. 12b). During cold stimulation, activated sympathetic neurons secrete NA, which suppresses IL-1β production by immune cells. Low IL-1β levels promote H6PD degradation and switch BA-L cells into BA-H cells (Extended Data Fig. 12a,b). After cold stimulation, this process is reversed, restoring a lower BA-H/BA-L ratio. Age impairs the flexibility to alter BA heterogeneity due to IL-1β overload in BAT, which significantly contributes to the age-related decline in thermogenesis (Extended Data Fig. 12b).
Recent findings suggest that the advantages of this spatiotemporal neuronal–immune regulation of BA heterogeneity are multifaceted. First, it enables a dual-layered response: an immediate, acute response through readily active BA-H cells, and a longer-term, chronic response that involves shifting cellular heterogeneity. Second, it facilitates communication between different cell types through spatial proximity, thereby integrating stimuli from multiple systems, combining environmental and internal cues, and enabling precise regulation of cell states. Third, shifting between BA-H and BA-L states preserves BAs from oxidative damage associated with sustained high thermogenesis.
Although this study primarily focused on UCP1-dependent thermogenesis, UCP1-independent mechanisms are also critical for thermogenic adipose tissue function and whole-body metabolic homeostasis39,40,41. We observed that TNAP, a key component of the futile creatine cycle, is enriched in BA-L cells. Cold exposure increased the proportion of BA-H cells while inducing CKB and TNAP expression in BAT42, reflecting enhanced futile creatine cycle activity either specifically in BA-L cells or across all BAs, with BA-L cells retaining higher activity. Importantly, cold-induced TNAP expression was compromised with age, while remaining enriched in BA-L cells. These results suggest that both UCP1- and futile creatine cycle-dependent thermogenesis are impaired with age.
According to recent reports, BAT has long been recognized as a target organ for glucocorticoids, but their precise role remains unclear. Some studies indicate that glucocorticoids suppress UCP1 expression and/or BAT activity43,44,45,46, whereas others reach the opposite conclusions47,48,49. Glucocorticoids have also been implicated in warm-induced beige adipocyte whitening50. This study highlights that GR signalling in BAT regulates BA heterogeneity by locking BAs in the BA-L state and reducing their responsiveness to NA. Active glucocorticoid levels are regulated locally, independent of systemic levels25. Thus, systemic glucocorticoid treatments may not alter active glucocorticoid levels in individual BAs, potentially explaining previous conflicting observations. Importantly, inducible GR deletion in BAs during the transition from cold to room temperature sustained the high BA-H/BA-L ratio and thermogenesis. The stage- and cell-subtype-specific requirement of GR signalling explains why Nr3c1-knockout mice do not exhibit altered BAT development or thermogenesis51,52, and indicates that targeting GR at selective timing could profoundly manipulate thermogenic activity.
Our study highlighted that BA heterogeneity is determined by communication from sympathetic neurons to immune cells, rather than by direct communication from sympathetic neurons to BAs. NA, the primary neurotransmitter from sympathetic nerves, has been shown to modulate immune cell response by regulating cytokine production by immune cells in the liver and adipose tissue53,54. We found that NA directly suppresses Il1b production in immune cells through β-adrenergic signalling, thereby modulating BA heterogeneity. Notably, a recent study showed that cold-induced β3-adrenergic activation transiently recruits neutrophils predominantly to white adipose tissue (WAT), particularly the visceral depot55. These infiltrating neutrophils produce IL-1β, which suppresses local lipolysis by attenuating cAMP-dependent signalling, thereby limiting excessive lipid mobilization. Based on our findings in BAT, IL-1β may similarly suppress lipolysis through the H6PD–GR–RGS2–AC axis in white adipocytes. Notably, Il1b expression in WAT exhibits transient kinetics, peaking at 12 h after stimulation and returning to basal levels at 24 h. Given that NA suppresses Il1b expression in BAT, it may similarly suppress Il1b expression in newly infiltrated neutrophils in WAT.
It has been revealed that it remains unclear why in vitro-differentiated BAs exhibit heterogeneity. BAs may intrinsically differentiate into cells with varying UCP1 levels to preserve thermogenic flexibility or maintain metabolic balance. Cross-talk between BAs and IL-1β+ immune cells in vivo may further reinforce and spatially organize this heterogeneity. Alternatively, IL-1β+ immune cells in SVFs during differentiation may influence the local environment. Indeed, depletion of CD45+ immune cells from SVFs before differentiation substantially increased the proportion of BA-H cells, suggesting that SVF immune cells reduce the BA-H/BA-L ratio. Future efforts with cell type-specific receptor knockout mouse models will help to validate and further elucidate how sympathetic innervation regulates IL-1β secretion and how IL-1β regulates H6PD protein stability.
In a recent development, decline of thermogenesis and age-related adiposity56 contribute to age-related metabolic disorders. Previous studies suggest that reduction in thermogenic activity may be due to impaired beige adipogenesis5,57, declined mitochondrial fuel oxidation3, reduced adrenergic receptors, altered other master regulators of thermogenesis58 and compromised sympathetic innervation due to infiltration of senescent immune cells59. Our study revealed that Il1b is increased in aged BAT, consistent with previous studies reporting increased immune cell infiltration and upregulated cytokines in aged BAT59. Increased IL-1β stabilized large amounts of BAs in the BA-L state and suppressed thermogenesis in aged mice. Importantly, pharmacological inhibition of GR signalling by a GR antagonist raised the BA-H/BA-L ratio and improved cold-induced thermogenesis in aged mice, indicating that BA-specific GR signalling could be targeted to correct age-related cold intolerance and significantly increase basal metabolism. However, given the systemic effects of RU-486 (ref. 60), other tissues and cell types may also contribute. Future efforts will focus on the effects of targeted inhibition of GR signalling specifically in thermogenic cells.
All animal experiments were approved by the Institutional Animal Care and Use Committees of City of Hope (protocol 17014). Mice were maintained under a 12 h–12 h dark–light cycle in a temperature-controlled facility with ad libitum access to water and food. The diets included a standard chow diet (5053, Lab diet), an HFD (D12492, Research Diets) and a chow diet supplemented with 600 mg per kg doxycycline (S4107, Bio-Serv), as described for individual experiments. The Ucp1-rtTA mouse line was generated as previously described15,61. The Ucp1-mGFP knock-in mouse line was created by Biocytogen through microinjection of CRISPR components and a donor vector into C57BL/6J zygotes. The single guide RNA targeted the junction of the exon 6 coding region and 3′ untranslated region (UTR) (CTTCCTCCAAGTTGCTTATG + TGG) of the Ucp1 gene, and a P2A-mGFP cassette was inserted at the 5′ end of the 3′ UTR, immediately upstream of the Ucp1 gene stop codon. TRE-Cre (B6.Cg-Tg(tetO-cre)1Jaw/J, 006234), Rosa26-loxp-STOP-loxp-mT/mG (B6.129(Cg)-Gt (ROSA)26Sortm4(ACTB-tdTomato,-eGFP) Luo/J, 007676) and Nr3c1-floxed (B6.Cg-Nr3c1tm1.1Jda/J, 021021) mouse lines were purchased from the Jackson Laboratories. To generate mice lacking GR proteins selectively in BAs, Ucp1-rtTA and TRE-Cre mice were crossed with Nr3c1-floxed mice. Littermates lacking TRE-Cre were used as control mice. All mice were maintained on a pure C57BL/6J background. The sample sizes for animal experiments were determined based on previous studies. Experimental groups were randomly assigned. Investigators were blinded to group allocation during rectal temperature measurement, but blinding was not feasible for other experiments.
Unilateral denervation of BAT was performed as previously described62. In brief, 8-week-old male mice were anaesthetized with 5% isoflurane and placed onto a warm surgical platform. The interscapular surgical region was shaved and sterilized with 70% isopropyl rubbing alcohol and iodine. A 1 cm lateral incision was made from the scapula to the neck, and the interscapular BAT depot was carefully detached from the underlying muscle layer and retracted cranially over the head using toothed forceps. Five branches of the intercostal sympathetic nerve bundles innervating the left and right BAT lobes were exposed. Unilateral denervation was achieved by cutting the nerve bundles on the left side, while the right nerve bundles were exposed and touched as a sham-operated control. The BAT lobes were repositioned, and the incision was closed using absorbable 5.0 sutures. Mice were allowed to recover for 2 weeks before undergoing further experimental procedures.
Industry observers note that to construct the H6pd-expressing lentiviral vector, the mouse H6pd complementary DNA (cDNA) (NM_173371.4) was amplified using primers with 5′ BamH I and 3′ Sal I restriction sites. To construct the Il1rn-expressing lentiviral vector, the mouse Il1rn cDNA (NM_031167.5) was amplified using primers with 5′ BamH I and 3′ Sal I restriction sites. The PCR products were cleaved with BamH I and Sal I and ligated into the pLenti-mCherry vector (36084, Addgene) to generate the pLenti-mH6pd lentiviral vector or pLenti-mIl1rn lentiviral vector. Lentiviral particles were produced by co-transfecting HEK293T (ATCC) cells with the pLenti-mCherry, pLenti-mH6pd, or pLenti-mIl1rn transfer plasmids, along with the packaging psPAX2 (12260, Addgene) and envelope plasmids pMD2.G (12259, Addgene) at a 1:1:1 ratio, using PEI (1 μg DNA to 3 µl PEI). HEK293T cells were not independently authenticated but were regularly tested for mycoplasma contamination, with negative results. After 72 h, the supernatant containing lentiviral particles was collected, filtered through a 0.45-μm PES filter and concentrated using the Lenti-X concentrator (631232, Takara Bio). The concentrated lentivirus was resuspended in PBS, stored at −80 °C and titrated using an RT-PCR Titration kit (631235, Takara Bio). Lentivirus administration in BAT was performed as described previously63. In brief, 10-week-old male Ucp1-mGFP or Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice were anaesthetized with 5% isoflurane. A small lateral incision (~0.5–0.8 cm) was made in the interscapular area to expose BAT. Then 10–20 μl of either pLenti-mH6pd lentivirus, pLenti-mIl1rn lentiviral or a negative control lentivirus (109 IFU ml−1) was directly injected at three distinct sites into each interscapular BAT lobe.
For three-dimensional fluorescence imaging of BAT, we used the Adipo-Clear method as described previously64. In brief, 8-week-old male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice were fed a doxycycline diet for 3 days at 24 °C. Mice were anaesthetized and perfused with cold PBS containing 100 U ml−1 heparin (H3149, Sigma-Aldrich), followed by ice-cold 4% PFA. The BAT was then dissected and post-fixed in 4% PFA at 4 °C overnight. After fixation, the tissue was washed with PBS, trimmed and delipidated using a graded series of methanol–B1n buffer, followed by 100% dichloromethane. After delipidation, the BAT was washed with a graded series of methanol–B1n buffer, followed by PTwH buffer. The sample was then incubated with primary rabbit anti-TH polyclonal antibody (1:200, ab152, Abcam) or rabbit anti-synaptophysin antibody (1:200, ab32127, Abcam) along with chicken anti-GFP antibody (1:200, ab13970, Abcam), diluted in PTxwH buffer at room temperature for 3 days. After incubation with primary antibodies, the sample was washed with PTxwH buffer and then incubated with secondary antibodies: Alexa Fluor 647-conjugated donkey anti-rabbit IgG(H+L) (A31573, Thermo Fisher Scientific) and Cy3 AffiniPure F(ab′)2 fragment donkey anti-chicken IgY (IgG) (H+L) (703-166-155, Jackson Immuno Research) secondary antibodies at room temperature for 3 days. The sample was dehydrated through a series of methanol and 100% dichloromethane and then cleared with dibenzyl ether. Three-dimensional imaging of the cleared BAT was performed using tile scanning with a confocal laser-scanning microscope (LSM 880, Zeiss) at ×10 and ×20 magnifications, with image acquisition and analysis conducted using the Zeiss Zen black software.
The SVF of BAT was isolated from the interscapular BAT of mice on postnatal day 7, while the SVF from iWAT was obtained from 5-week-old male mice. In brief, dissected BAT or iWAT was minced and digested for 45 min at 37 °C in a digestion buffer containing 1.5 mg ml−1 collagenase D (11088882001, Sigma-Aldrich) in an isolation buffer (0.123 M NaCl, 5 mM KCl, 1.3 mM CaCl2, 5 mM glucose, 100 mM HEPES and 4% BSA). The cell–tissue mixture was filtered through a 70-μm cell strainer (08-771-2, Thermo Fisher Scientific) to remove undigested fragments, then centrifuged for 5 min at 300g at 4 °C. The resulting cell pellet was resuspended in growth medium (DMEM, 10566016 Life Technologies; 1% penicillin–streptomycin, SV30010 Hyclone; 0.1% gentamicin, 1855724 Life Technologies and 20 mM HEPES, Sigma-Aldrich, H3537) containing 20% FBS (16H328, Sigma-Aldrich) and filtered again through a 40-μm cell strainer (08-771-1, Thermo Fisher Scientific) to remove clumps and adipocytes. The flow-through was centrifuged for 5 min at 300g at 4 °C, and the SVF pellet was resuspended in SVF growth medium and plated onto a 12-well tissue culture plate for RNA and protein extraction or onto a 35 mm glass-bottom tissue culture dish for IF staining. For differentiation into brown and beige adipocytes, SVF cells were switched to fresh induction medium (DMEM plus DEX (1 μM), insulin (0.12 μg ml−1), isobutylmethylxanthine (0.5 mM), T3 (1 nM), indomethacin (0.125 mM), 20 mM HEPES, 1% penicillin–streptomycin and 0.1% gentamicin) containing 10% FBS on day 0 (2 days after reaching confluence). After 2 days, the medium was replaced with maintenance medium (DMEM with insulin (0.12 μg ml−1), T3 (1 nM), 20 mM HEPES, 1% penicillin–streptomycin and 0.1% gentamicin) containing 10% FBS, and this maintenance medium was changed every 2 days until further use.
For glucocorticoid treatment, SVF cells from the BAT of Ucp1-mGFP mice were cultured and differentiated as described. During differentiation, cells were treated with or without 1 μM corticosterone (16063, Cayman Chemical), 1 μM DEX (D4902, Sigma-Aldrich) or 1 μM 11-DHC (32907, Cayman Chemical) in the induction medium. On differentiation day 6, the density of GFP fluorescence was assessed under a microscope (BZ-X710, Keyence) to quantify the BA-H/BA-L ratio. For the PKA activity assay, on differentiation day 6, primary BAs differentiated were pretreated with 1 μM 11-DHC or vehicle for 48 h, followed by incubation with 1 μM NA (A0937, Sigma-Aldrich), 10 μM forskolin (F6886, Sigma-Aldrich) or 500 μM 8-Br-cAMP (B7880, Sigma-Aldrich) for 30 min. PKA activity was measured by western blot analysis using antibodies specific to phosphorylated PKA substrates. For the H6PD half-life assay, BAs differentiated from primary BAT SVFs were pretreated with 10 ng ml−1 IL-1β (401-ML-005, R&D Systems) or vehicle for 4 h, followed by exposure to 50 µg ml−1 CHX (C1988, Sigma-Aldrich) with IL-1β or saline for various timepoints (0, 3, 6 and 12 h) at 37 °C, with H6PD quantified by western blot analysis. For cytokine treatment, on differentiation day 6, primary BAs were treated with saline, 10 ng ml−1 IL-1β, 20 ng ml−1 TNF (410-MT-010, R&D Systems) and 10 ng ml−1 IFNγ (485-MI-100, R&D Systems) alone or in combination for 48 h. For IL-1β signalling inhibition, BAs were treated with saline, 10 ng ml−1 IL-1β or IL-1β in combination with 10 μM p38 kinase inhibitor SB203580 (559395, Sigma-Aldrich), 5 μM NF-κB inhibitor BAY11-7082 (196871, Sigma-Aldrich), 10 μM JNK inhibitor SP600125 (420119, Sigma-Aldrich), 10 μM ERK inhibitor U0126 (662005, Sigma-Aldrich) or 5 mM IKKβ inhibitor aspirin (A5376, Sigma-Aldrich) for 48 h, with inhibitors administered 1 h before IL-1β treatment. To test the effect of IL-1β on UCP1 expression, BAs on day 6 were switched to culture medium containing charcoal-stripped FBS and then treated with vehicle or 10 ng ml−1 IL-1β for 48 h in the absence or presence of 1 μM 11-DHC. For DEX and RU-486 treatment, the BAs on day 6 were pretreated with vehicle or 10 μM RU-486 for 1 h, followed by treatment with 1 μM NA in the presence or absence of 1 μM DEX for 24 h. The concentrations of UCP1, H6PD and β-actin were quantified by western blot analysis. To assess the effect of immune cells on BAs heterogeneity, SVF cells from the BAT of Ucp1-mGFP mice were cultured and differentiated as described, with or without CD45+ immune cells. CD45+ immune cells were depleted from SVFs using PE-anti-CD45 antibody (103106, BioLegend) and EasySep Reagents (17656, StemCell Technologies).
Mature BAs from the interscapular BAT of 10-week-old male mice were obtained as described before. In brief, BATs were dissected, cleaned of contaminating muscle and WAT, minced into small pieces, and digested in collagenase-dispase buffer (17703034, Gibco) for 1 h at 37 °C with shaking at 110 r.p.m. The cell suspension was filtered through 100-μm cell strainers (08-771-19, Thermo Fisher Scientific) to remove undigested tissues, washed with 3 volumes of DMEM/F12 medium (10565018, Life Technologies) containing 10% FBS and centrifuged at 100g for 5 min at room temperature. The floating BAs were transferred and resuspended in PBS wash buffer three times. After quantification, 5 × 105 BAs were suspended in Matrigel (Corning, CB-40234C) at a 1:1 volume ratio and seeded into 6-well tissue culture dishes. The plates were incubated at 37 °C for 15 min to induce gel formation. Maintenance medium (DMEM with insulin (0.12 μg ml−1), T3 (1 nM), 20 mM HEPES, 1% penicillin–streptomycin and 0.1% gentamicin) containing 10% FBS was then added to the wells with either vehicle, 1 μM DEX, 10 μM CL-316,243 (C5976, Sigma-Aldrich) or 1 μM DEX combined with 10 μM CL-316,243 for 24 h. For the separation of BA-H and BA-L cells, we modified our previous protocol6 by adding additional steps to further deplete contaminating SVFs in BA-L cells. In brief, floating BAs were collected as BA-L cells, and the pellet containing BA-H cells and SVF was further separated using the EasyPlate magnet-based method. The cell suspension was incubated with PE-conjugated antibodies against immune cells (PE-anti-CD45, 103106, BioLegend), endothelial cells (PE-anti-CD31, 102408, BioLegend), fibroblasts (PE-anti-CD140a, 135905, BioLegend) and pericytes (PE-anti-CD146, 134704, BioLegend) and processed using EasySep reagents (17656, StemCell Technologies) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Freshly isolated BA-H and BA-L cells (1 × 105 per condition) were incubated in tracing medium (D5030, Sigma-Aldrich) containing either 5 mM [U-13C]glucose or 0.5 mM [U-13C]palmitate for 2 h and 6 h. After incubation, cells were washed with NaCl and collected with cold 50% methanol as before22,23. Metabolites were extracted and analysed by GC–MS.
Recent findings suggest that mice were anaesthetized and perfused with PBS, followed by 10% formalin fixative buffer. The interscapular BAT, iWAT and gWAT were carefully dissected and post-fixed in 10% formalin buffer overnight at 4 °C. After dehydration, paraffin embedding and sectioning, tissue sections were stained with haematoxylin and eosin (H&E).
Sources indicate that for human samples, adipose tissue was collected during thyroid surgery. Written informed consent was obtained from all patients. Supraclavicular adipose tissue was removed as waste biological material from subjects undergoing surgery at the General Hospital (AOU; Ancona, Italy) for thyroid diseases. Ethical approval was obtained from the specific Commission within the Azienda Ospedaliero Universitaria delle Marche (University Hospital of the Marche Region). The ethical approval protocol code is 208156. Immediately after removal, tissue pieces were fixed overnight at 4 °C by immersion in 4% paraformaldehyde in 0.1 M phosphate buffer (pH 7.4). They were then dehydrated, cleared and paraffin embedded. Sections from three levels (100 μm apart) were stained with H&E to assess morphology and BAT presence for UCP1-immunohistochemistry.
According to recent reports, for IF staining of mouse and human tissues, paraffin-embedded sections of Ucp1-mGFP and Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice and human BAT slides were deparaffinized in xylene and rehydrated using a graded ethanol series to double-distilled H2O. The slides were immersed in 10 mM sodium citrate buffer (C9999, Sigma-Aldrich) and boiled for 30 min for antigen retrieval, then blocked in PBST containing 0.3% Triton X-100 and 5% BSA. Primary antibodies used were as follows: perilipin (1:500, NB100-60554, Novus and ab61682, Abcam), UCP1 (1:200, ab23841, Abcam and MAB6158, R&D Systems), GFP (1:200, ab13970, Abcam; and 2956S, Cell Signaling Technology), mCherry (1:200, ab167453, Abcam), H6PD (1:200, ab170895, Abcam; and 15255-1-AP, Proteintech), TNAP (1:200, AF2910, R&D Systems), GR (1:200, 12041S, Cell Signaling Technology), RGS2 (1:200, NBP1-32284, Novus), IL-1RA (1:100, MA5-35068, Thermo Fisher Scientific), IL-1β (1:50, AF-401-NA, R&D Systems), F4/80 (1:100, ab6640, Abcam) and CXCR2 (1:100, 20634-1-AP, Proteintech). Secondary antibodies (1:200 dilution) used were Alexa Fluor 647-conjugated donkey anti-mouse IgG (H+L) (A31571, Thermo Fisher Scientific), Alexa Fluor 555-conjugated donkey anti-rabbit IgG(H+L) (A31572, Thermo Fisher Scientific), Alexa Fluor 647-conjugated donkey anti-rabbit IgG(H+L) (A31573, Thermo Fisher Scientific), Alexa Fluor 488-conjugated donkey anti-goat IgG (H+L) (A32814, Thermo Fisher Scientific), Alexa Fluor 555-conjugated donkey anti-rat IgG (H+L) (A48270, Thermo Fisher Scientific), Alexa Fluor 647-conjugated donkey anti-goat IgG (H+L) (A21447, Thermo Fisher Scientific) and Cy3 AffiniPure F(ab′)2 fragment donkey anti-chicken IgY (IgG) (H+L) (703-166-155, Jackson Immuno Research). Slides were counterstained with 1 μg ml−1 DAPI (D9542, Sigma-Aldrich) and mounted with prolonged Anti-Fade mounting medium (P36931, Invitrogen). Bright-field and fluorescence images were acquired using an inverted fluorescence phase-contrast microscope (BZ-X710, Keyence).
Fluorescence microscopy images were acquired for three experimental conditions: room temperature, cold exposure and cold exposure with denervation. For each condition, dual-channel fluorescence images were collected with UCP1 labelled in the green channel and IL-1β labelled in the magenta channel, along with corresponding autofluorescence reference images for cellular region identification. All image analysis was performed using custom Python scripts using the tifffile, numpy, scipy and pandas libraries. To restrict analysis to cellular regions and exclude background artifacts, autofluorescence images were Gaussian-smoothed and used to generate binary masks with a threshold of 50 arbitrary units applied to autofluorescence intensity values65, ensuring that correlation analysis was performed exclusively on biologically relevant areas. To eliminate low-intensity noise and focus analysis on meaningful fluorescence signals, intensity-based thresholds were applied to both channels: UCP1 (green channel) at 70 arbitrary units and IL-1β (magenta channel) at 20 arbitrary units. Pixels were retained for analysis if they exceeded the threshold in either channel, using a logical OR to preserve regions with specific labelling while maintaining sensitivity to differential expression patterns. Co-localization between UCP1 and IL-1β was quantified using the Pearson correlation coefficient (PCC), calculated pixel-wise across filtered cellular regions66. After masking and thresholding, images were vectorized by flattening two-dimensional pixel arrays into one-dimensional arrays. The PCC was computed using scipy.stats, providing both the correlation coefficient and associated P value for each image pair. Statistical comparisons between experimental conditions were performed using Welch’s t-tests for independent samples with unequal variances. This approach accounts for potential differences in variance between experimental groups while providing robust statistical inference. Results were compiled into structured data frames and visualized using bar plots with error bars.
Total RNA was extracted from tissues or cultured cells using either TRIzol reagent (15596026, Thermo Fisher Scientific) or RNAqueous-Micro Total RNA Isolation Kit (AM1931, Thermo Fisher Scientific). The first-strand cDNA was synthesized using the iScript cDNA synthesis kit (1708891, Bio-Rad) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. qPCR was performed using the SYBR Green PCR system (A25742, Applied Biosystems) with Tbp as the internal control. A list of all of the primer sequences is provided in Supplementary Table 1.
In a recent development, adipose tissues, cultured adipocytes and isolated mature BAs were collected and lysed in radioimmunoprecipitation assay (RIPA) buffer (20-188, Sigma-Aldrich) containing protease inhibitor cocktails (11836170001, Sigma-Aldrich) and phosphatase inhibitor cocktails (P5726, P0044, Sigma-Aldrich). The extracted protein samples were loaded onto and separated on a 4–15% gradient SDS–PAGE TGX stain-free gel (4568086, Bio-Rad) and transferred to a PVDF membrane (1620177, Bio-Rad). The membranes were incubated with specific primary antibodies against H6PD (ab170895, Abcam and 15255-1-AP, Proteintech), UCP1 (ab23841, Abcam), GFP (2956S, Cell Signaling Technology), phosphorylated PKA substrates (RRXS*/T*) (9624S, Cell Signaling Technology), TH (ab152, Abcam), TNAP (AF2910, R&D Systems), CKB (18713-1-AP, Proteintech), GR (12041S, Cell Signaling Technology), IL-1R1 (PA5-97866, Thermo Fisher Scientific) and β-actin (4970 and 58169, Cell Signaling Technology). HRP-conjugated goat anti-rabbit IgG (1706515, Bio-Rad) and HRP-conjugated goat anti-mouse IgG (1706516, Bio-Rad) were used as secondary antibodies. The immunoreactive signals were detected using the Pierce ECL Western Blotting Substrate (32209, Thermo Fisher Scientific) and SuperSignal West Pico PLUS Chemiluminescent substrate (34577, Thermo Fisher Scientific).
Industry observers note that mature BAs were reverse-transfected with dsiRNA as described previously67. In brief, on differentiation day 5, BAT-derived primary BAs were trypsinized using 0.25% trypsin (25200, Thermo Fisher Scientific) for 15 min. The cells were then resuspended in culture medium and seeded onto gelatin-coated cell culture plates that had been pre-incubated with a pool of 50 nM H6pd dsiRNAs, 50 nM Rgs2 dsiRNAs, 50 nM Il1r1 dsiRNAs or relevant control dsiRNAs (Integrated DNA Technologies), mixed with 5 μl ml−1 of Lipofectamine RNAiMAX (13778075, Thermo Fisher Scientific) diluted in Opti-MEM medium (31985070, Thermo Fisher Scientific). The final density of BAs was 2.5 × 105 cells per cm2 of culture plate. Mature BAs were treated or collected 2 days after transfection. A list of all of the dsiRNA sequences is provided in Supplementary Table 1.
It has been revealed that mice were housed individually in temperature- and light-controlled rodent incubators (Powers Scientific) set to either thermoneutrality (30 °C) or cold (6 °C), with ad libitum access to food and water. For the β3-adrenoceptor agonist treatment experiment, mice were maintained at thermoneutrality for 1 week, followed by daily intraperitoneal injections of CL-316,243 in PBS at 1 mg per kg body weight for an additional 7 days. For adrenoceptor antagonist treatment, mice were exposed at 6 °C for 16 h, followed by intraperitoneal injections of propranolol (10 mg per kg; P0884, Sigma-Aldrich) or phenoxybenzamine hydrochloride (5 mg per kg; HY-B043A, MedChemExpress) in PBS for 4 h.
Sources indicate that for flow cytometry analysis, SVF cells were blocked with anti-mouse-CD16/32 (1:500, 101302, BioLegend) for 10 min, and then stained with anti-mouse-CD45-BV605 (1:400, 103155, BioLegend), anti-mouse-CD11b-APC (1:100, 101212, BioLegend), anti-mouse-F4/80-488 (1:100, 123120, BioLegend), anti-mouse-Ly6C-PE/Cy7 (1:400, 128018, BioLegend), anti-mouse-CXCR2-PE (1:20, 149304, BioLegend), anti-mouse-CD3-488 (1:100, 100210, BioLegend) and anti-mouse-CD19-PE (1:200, 152408, BioLegend) for individual experiments for 20 min on ice. After antibody incubation, the cells were washed once with 2% FBS–PBS. For intracellular staining, cells were stained with LIVE–DEAD fixable dead cell stain (65-0868-14, Invitrogen) for 30 min on ice. After washing with PBS, cells were fixed and permeabilized using a fixation/permeabilization kit (554714, BD bioscience) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. In brief, cells were fixed with fixation–permeabilization solution for 15 min on ice, followed by a wash with PBS and 1× perm–wash buffer. Cells were stained with anti-mouse-IL-1β-APC/eFluor 780 (1:80, 47-7114-82, Invitrogen) in 1× perm–wash buffer for 30 min on ice. After staining, cells were washed once with 1× perm–wash buffer and analysed by BD Fortessa cytometer. The flow plots were analysed by FlowJo (v.10).
In a recent development, eight-week-old male C57BL/6J mice were subcutaneously (s.c.) injected with either vehicle or 5 mg per kg per day water-soluble DEX (D2915, Sigma-Aldrich) dissolved in PBS for 2 weeks. Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice aged 10 weeks were maintained on doxycycline chow diet and administered vehicle or VX-765 (HY-13205, MedChemExpress, 50 mg per kg per day), dissolved in 20% (v/v) Cremophor EL, through daily intraperitoneal injection for 1 week. Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG or WT mice aged 70–75 weeks were injected s.c. with 60 mg per kg mifepristone (RU-486) (HY-13683, MedChemExpress) dissolved in DMSO–corn oil or with DMSO–corn oil alone daily as controls for 1 week. Body temperature was recorded daily throughout the treatment period. After the final RU-486 or vehicle injection, mice were individually housed and exposed to a cold environment (6 °C). Rectal temperatures were measured at the indicated timepoints using a rodent thermometer (Bioseb, TK8851). For metabolic phenotyping, 72-week-old male WT mice were s.c. injected with either vehicle or RU-486 (60 mg per kg per day) for 1 week, followed by metabolic phenotyping with continuing daily vehicle or RU-486 injection for an additional 3 days. During the metabolic cage study, energy expenditure, oxygen consumption, RER, locomotor activity and food intake were recorded. At the end point, the mice were perfused with PBS and 10% formalin and processed for H&E and IF staining as described above.
Sources indicate that male Ucp1-rtTA;TRE-cre;Nr3c1flox/flox or control littermates aged 10 weeks were fed a doxycycline diet at 6 °C for 1 week, then continued for an additional week after being moved back to 24 °C, followed by glucose tolerance tests and insulin tolerance tests. For the glucose tolerance test, mice were fasted for 12 h before intraperitoneal injection of glucose (2 g per kg body weight). For the insulin tolerance test, mice were fasted for 6 h before intraperitoneal injection of insulin (0.75 U kg−1, Eli Lilly). Tail vein blood samples were collected at 0, 15, 30, 60, 90 and 120 min after injection, and blood glucose levels were measured using a Contour glucometer (Bayer).
In a recent development, BAT depots were dissected from the interscapular BAT of male C57BL/6J mice exposed to 30 °C for 1 week and minced into 1–2 mm3 explants. The explants were washed three times with PBS and transferred to a six-well plate containing DMEM with 10% FBS. BAT SVFs were isolated as described above, and CD45+ immune cells were enriched using PE-anti-CD45 antibody (103106, BioLegend) and EasySep Reagents (17656, StemCell Technologies). Explants were incubated in saline or 10 mM NA (A0937, Sigma-Aldrich) for 24 h and CD45+ immune cells were treated with saline or NA (1 μM) for 4 h. After incubation, explants and CD45+ cells were collected for RNA extraction.
Bone marrow neutrophils were isolated from 10-week-old male WT mice. In brief, femurs and tibias were flushed with PBS containing 2 mM EDTA and 2% FBS using a 23-gauge needle, and the cell suspension was filtered through a 70-μm strainer. Cells were centrifuged at 400g for 5 min, and the pellet was resuspended in red blood cell lysis buffer (R7757, Sigma-Aldrich) for 1 min at room temperature, followed by neutralization with PBS containing 2% FBS. Neutrophils were enriched using PE-anti-Ly6G antibody (127608, BioLegend) and EasySep Reagents (17656, StemCell Technologies). Neutrophils were cultured in RPMI 1640 supplemented with 2% FBS. Neutrophils were stimulated with LPS (0–1,000 ng ml−1; L4391, Sigma-Aldrich) for 6 h or pretreated with NA (0–10 μM) for 30 min before 100 ng ml−1 LPS stimulation. For time-dependent experiments, neutrophils were treated with LPS with or without 1 μM NA pretreatment for 1–9 h. For adrenergic blockade experiments, neutrophils were pretreated with 1 μM propranolol (P0884, Sigma-Aldrich) or 1 μM phenoxybenzamine (HY-B0431A, MedChemExpress) for 60 min, followed by 1 μM NA and 100 ng ml−1 LPS stimulation. For IL-1β measurement, 10 μM nigericin (HY-100381, MedChemExpress) was added 30 min before sample collection. Neutrophils were collected for RNA extraction, and the supernatants were collected for enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) analysis.
Sources indicate that blood samples were collected between 08:00 and 10:00, then centrifuged at 2,000g and 4 °C for 20 min to separate the serum. BAT was homogenized in a TissueLyser with 1 ml of 80% methanol on ice. The samples were then subjected to 3–5 freeze–thaw cycles and centrifuged at 4 °C and 13,000 r.p.m. for 15 min. The supernatant, which contains sterols, was collected, evaporated and dissolved in an assay buffer. Serum and tissue corticosterone levels were measured using a corticosterone ELISA kit (ADI-900-097, Enzo Biochem). Serum IL-1β levels were measured using an IL-1β ELISA kit (ab197742, Abcam). Neutrophil supernatant IL-1β was measured using an IL-1β ELISA kit (MLB00C-1, R&D Systems).
scRNA-seq data from the non-adipocyte fraction of BAT of C57BL/6J mice maintained at room temperature were obtained and selected from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) database under accessions GSE207707, GSE177635, GSE160585 and GSE161447. Data processing and analysis were conducted using Seurat v.4.0.6 in R v.4.1.2. Each dataset was imported, converted to Seurat objects, normalized and then variable features were identified. Integration anchors were computed to merge the datasets into a unified Seurat object. Quality control involved filtering out cells with fewer than 200 detected features and those with mitochondrial gene content exceeding 10%. The integrated data were scaled, and principal component analysis was performed. Clustering was performed using the Louvain algorithm with a resolution of 1.0. For visualization, t-distributed stochastic neighbour embedding was used to depict cell clusters. Identification of each cell type was determined by comparing cell cluster-specific marker genes with known cell type-specific markers from the literature. Immune cell clusters were further identified and subclustered based on the expression of Ptprc, and non-immune cell types, including erythrocytes (Hba-a1 and Hba-a2), capillary endothelial cells (Pecam1 and Gpibp1), smooth muscle cells (Acta2) and adipose progenitor cells (Pdgfra and Col3a1), were excluded from the analysis.
Industry observers note that to identify differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and enriched pathways between BA-L and BA-H cells, scRNA-seq data deposited in the NCBI GEO database under accession number GSE125269 were analysed. Adipocyte clusters were selected based on Plin1 expression, while contaminating endothelial cells (Pecam1) were excluded from the analysis. BA-L and BA-H cell populations were identified as described previously6. These populations were further compared to identify DEGs using the FindMarker function, which applied the Wilcoxon rank-sum test, with a log-transformed fold change threshold of 0.25 and a minimum detection fraction (min.pct) of 25%. To control the false discovery rate, P values were adjusted using the Benjamini–Hochberg method, and genes with an adjusted P of <0.05 were considered statistically significant. Visualization of the top 50 upregulated DEGs in both BA-L and BA-H cells was generated using the DoHeatmap function. Pathway enrichment analysis was performed on the top 75 upregulated and downregulated DEGs in BA-L cells using Gene Ontology Biological Processes. The analysis used Benjamini–Hochberg-adjusted P values to identify significantly enriched pathways. Pathways with an adjusted P of <0.05 and containing at least three enriched genes were considered significantly enriched. The top 20 enriched pathways were determined based on adjusted P values. Dot plots of these pathways were generated to visualize the enrichment results, with specific pathways of interest highlighted for enhanced interpretability.
After the vehicle and DEX treatment, in vitro-differentiated BAs were cross-linked with 1% formaldehyde (15714-S, Electron Microscopy Sciences) for 10 min at room temperature and quenched with 125 mM glycine for 10 min. Cells were then incubated with ice-cold nucleus preparation buffer (10 mM HEPES, pH 7.5, 1.5 mM MgCl2, 10 mM KCl, 250 mM sucrose, 0.1% NP-40, 0.2 mM DTT, protease inhibitor cocktails) and homogenized using a KIMBLE Dounce tissue grinder (D8938, Sigma-Aldrich). The nuclei were collected by centrifugation at 1,000g for 10 min, washed with PBS containing protease inhibitor cocktails (11836170001, Sigma-Aldrich) and then resuspended in 250 μl nuclear lysis buffer (10 mM Tris, pH 8, 1 mM EDTA and 0.1% SDS). The chromatin was fragmented using the Bioruptor sonicator (Diagenode) for 30 cycles, 30 s on–30 s off with the maximum power setting to generate DNA fragments of 200–500 bp. The sheared chromatin was centrifuged at 13,000 r.p.m. for 10 min at 4 °C to remove debris and diluted tenfold with ChIP dilution buffer (16.7 mM Tris (pH 8), 1.2 mM EDTA, 167 mM NaCl, 1.1% Triton X-100, 0.01% SDS, protease inhibitor cocktail), with 10 μg chromatin for each ChIP. An aliquot of 10% was used for the input control. Then, 5 μg anti-GR antibody (NBP2-42221, Novus Biologicals) or normal rabbit IgG (2729S, Cell Signaling Technology) was added for overnight rocking at 4 °C. Next, 40 μl protein A/G Dynabeads (26162, Thermo Fisher Scientific) was added to the ChIP samples and rotated for 2 h at 4 °C. The Dynabeads were washed in low-salt wash buffer (20 mM Tris-HCl (pH 8.0), 2 mM EDTA, 150 mM NaCl, 1% Triton X-100, 0.1% SDS), high-salt wash buffer (20 mM Tris (pH 8), 2 mM EDTA, 500 mM NaCl, 1% Triton X-100, 0.1% SDS), LiCl wash buffer (10 mM Tris (pH 8), 1 mM EDTA, 1% NP-40, 1% sodium deoxycholate, 250 mM LiCl) and TE buffer (10 mM Tris (pH 8), 1 mM EDTA) twice at each step. The antibody–chromatin complex was eluted and reverse-cross-linked in 200 μl elution buffer (10 mM Tris (pH 8), 50 mM EDTA, 0.1% SDS, 300 mM NaCl, 0.8 mg ml−1 proteinase K and 10 μg ml−1 RNase A) by incubating at 50 °C for 2 h and subsequently at 65 °C for 8 h. The immunoprecipitated DNA fragments were purified using the MiniElute PCR Purification Kit (28004, Qiagen). ChIP–qPCR was performed using the primers listed in Supplementary Table 1. ChIP enrichments were calculated relative to the input DNA control.
Statistical analyses were performed using GraphPad Prism v.10. Results are presented as mean ± s.e.m. All measurements were obtained from individual samples. For each two-group comparison, equality of variances was first assessed using the F test. An unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test was used when the F test indicated equal variances, whereas Welch’s t-tests were used when the assumption of equal variances was not met. For one-way ANOVA, Tukey’s multiple-comparison test was used when variances were equal, whereas Dunnett’s T3 multiple-comparison test was used when variances were unequal. For two-way ANOVA, Tukey’s or Šídák’s multiple-comparison test was selected according to the experimental design. The statistical tests used are specified in the corresponding figure legends. P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Exact P values for all statistical comparisons are provided in Supplementary Table 2.
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article.
According to recent reports, integration of scRNA-seq datasets of the non-adipocyte fraction of BAT was obtained and selected from the NCBI GEO database under accessions GSE207707, GSE177635, GSE160585 and GSE161447. DEGs and enriched pathways between BA-L and BA-H cells were obtained from the publicly available GEO database (GSE125269). Source data are provided with this paper.
Source code for data analysis is available at GitHub and archived on Zenodo68 (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22804953).
Cannon, B. & Nedergaard, J. Brown adipose tissue: function and physiological significance. Physiol. Rev. 84, 277–359 https://doi.org/10.1152/physrev.00015.2003 (2004).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Lowell, B. B. & Spiegelman, B. M. Towards a molecular understanding of adaptive thermogenesis. Nature 404, 652–660 https://doi.org/10.1038/35007527 (2000).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Tajima, K. et al. Mitochondrial lipoylation integrates age-associated decline in brown fat thermogenesis. Nat. Metab. 1, 886–898 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42255-019-0106-z (2019).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that cypess, A. M. et al. Identification and importance of brown adipose tissue in adult humans. N. Engl. J. Med. 360, 1509–1517 https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa0810780 (2009).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that holman, C. D. et al. Aging impairs cold-induced beige adipogenesis and adipocyte metabolic reprogramming. eLife 12, RP87756 https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.87756 (2024).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Song, A. et al. Low- and high-thermogenic brown adipocyte subpopulations coexist in murine adipose tissue. J. Clin. Invest. 130, 247–257 https://doi.org/10.1172/jci129167 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, jungermann, K. & Katz, N. Functional hepatocellular heterogeneity. Hepatology 2, 385–395 https://doi.org/10.1002/hep.1840020316 (1982).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Blaauw, B., Schiaffino, S. & Reggiani, C. Mechanisms modulating skeletal muscle phenotype. Compr. Physiol. 3, 1645–1687 https://doi.org/10.1002/cphy.c130009 (2013).
Article PubMed Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that emont, M. P. et al. A single-cell atlas of human and mouse white adipose tissue. Nature 603, 926–933 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-04518-2 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Harms, M. & Seale, P. Brown and beige fat: development, function and therapeutic potential. Nat. Med. 19, 1252–1263 https://doi.org/10.1038/nm.3361 (2013).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Lundgren, P. et al. A subpopulation of lipogenic brown adipocytes drives thermogenic memory. Nat. Metab. 5, 1691–1705 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42255-023-00893-w (2023).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that sun, W. et al. snRNA-seq reveals a subpopulation of adipocytes that regulates thermogenesis. Nature 587, 98–102 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2856-x (2020).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Zhang, X. et al. Depletion of JunB increases adipocyte thermogenic capacity and ameliorates diet-induced insulin resistance. Nat. Metab. 6, 78–93 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42255-023-00945-1 (2024).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Shamsi, F. et al. Vascular smooth muscle-derived Trpv1+ progenitors are a source of cold-induced thermogenic adipocytes. Nat. Metab. 3, 485–495 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42255-021-00373-z (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that sun, K. et al. Brown adipose tissue derived VEGF-A modulates cold tolerance and energy expenditure. Mol. Metab. 3, 474–483 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molmet.2014.03.010 (2014).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that kong, X. et al. IRF4 is a key thermogenic transcriptional partner of PGC-1α. Cell 158, 69–83 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2014.04.049 (2014).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that bunk, J. et al. The futile creatine cycle powers UCP1-independent thermogenesis in classical BAT. Nat. Commun. 16, 3221 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-58294-4 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that bertholet, A. M. et al. Mitochondrial patch clamp of beige adipocytes reveals UCP1-positive and UCP1-negative cells both exhibiting futile creatine cycling. Cell Metab. 25, 811–822 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2017.03.002 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that kazak, L. et al. A creatine-driven substrate cycle enhances energy expenditure and thermogenesis in beige fat. Cell 163, 643–655 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2015.09.035 (2015).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that rahbani, J. F. et al. Creatine kinase B controls futile creatine cycling in thermogenic fat. Nature 590, 480–485 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03221-y (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that sun, Y. et al. Mitochondrial TNAP controls thermogenesis by hydrolysis of phosphocreatine. Nature 593, 580–585 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03533-z (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, jiang, L. et al. Reductive carboxylation supports redox homeostasis during anchorage-independent growth. Nature 532, 255–258 https://doi.org/10.1038/nature17393 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that wang, Z. et al. Chronic cold exposure enhances glucose oxidation in brown adipose tissue. EMBO Rep. 21, e50085 https://doi.org/10.15252/embr.202050085 (2020).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, lewis, C. A. et al. Tracing compartmentalized NADPH metabolism in the cytosol and mitochondria of mammalian cells. Mol. Cell 55, 253–263 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.molcel.2014.05.008 (2014).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Chapman, K., Holmes, M. & Seckl, J. 11β-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenases: intracellular gate-keepers of tissue glucocorticoid action. Physiol. Rev. 93, 1139–1206 https://doi.org/10.1152/physrev.00020.2012 (2013).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, seamon, K. B., Padgett, W. & Daly, J. W. Forskolin: unique diterpene activator of adenylate cyclase in membranes and in intact cells. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 78, 3363–3367 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.78.6.3363 (1981).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that cao, W. et al. p38 mitogen-activated protein kinase is the central regulator of cyclic AMP-dependent transcription of the brown fat uncoupling protein 1 gene. Mol. Cell. Biol. 24, 3057–3067 https://doi.org/10.1128/MCB.24.7.3057-3067.2004 (2004).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that sinnarajah, S. et al. RGS2 regulates signal transduction in olfactory neurons by attenuating activation of adenylyl cyclase III. Nature 409 1051–1055 https://doi.org/10.1038/35059104 (2001).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that soccio, R. E. et al. Genetic variation determines PPARγ function and anti-diabetic drug response in vivo. Cell 162, 33–44 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2015.06.025 (2015).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that minokoshi, Y., Saito, M. & Shimazu, T. Metabolic and morphological alterations of brown adipose tissue after sympathetic denervation in rats. J. Auton. Nerv. Syst. 15, 197–204 https://doi.org/10.1016/0165-1838(86)90063-9 (1986).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, wang, Y. N. et al. Slit3 secreted from M2-like macrophages increases sympathetic activity and thermogenesis in adipose tissue. Nat. Metab. 3, 1536–1551 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42255-021-00482-9 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Wolf, Y. et al. Brown-adipose-tissue macrophages control tissue innervation and homeostatic energy expenditure. Nat. Immunol. 18, 665–674 https://doi.org/10.1038/ni.3746 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, hu, B. et al. γδ T cells and adipocyte IL-17RC control fat innervation and thermogenesis. Nature 578, 610–614 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2028-z (2020).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that shamsi, F., Zheng, R., Ho, L.-L., Chen, K. & Tseng, Y.-H. Comprehensive analysis of intercellular communication in the thermogenic adipose niche. Commun. Biol. 6, 761 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42003-023-05140-2 (2023).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that gallerand, A. et al. Brown adipose tissue monocytes support tissue expansion. Nat. Commun. 12, 5255 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-25616-1 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Burl, R. B., Rondini, E. A., Wei, H., Pique-Regi, R. & Granneman, J. G. Deconstructing cold-induced brown adipocyte neogenesis in mice. eLife 11, e80167 https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.80167 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that karlina, R. et al. Identification and characterization of distinct brown adipocyte subtypes in C57BL/6J mice. Life Sci. Alliance 4, e202000924 https://doi.org/10.26508/lsa.202000924 (2021).
Jung, R. T., Shetty, P. S., James, W. P., Barrand, M. A. & Callingham, B. A. Reduced thermogenesis in obesity. Nature 279, 322–323 https://doi.org/10.1038/279322a0 (1979).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, kazak, L. et al. Ablation of adipocyte creatine transport impairs thermogenesis and causes diet-induced obesity. Nat. Metab. 1, 360–370 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42255-019-0035-x (2019).
Article CAS PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Ikeda, K. et al. UCP1-independent signaling involving SERCA2b-mediated calcium cycling regulates beige fat thermogenesis and systemic glucose homeostasis. Nat. Med. 23, 1454–1465 https://doi.org/10.1038/nm.4429 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, cohen, P. & Kajimura, S. The cellular and functional complexity of thermogenic fat. Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 22, 393–409 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41580-021-00350-0 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that rahbani, J. F. et al. ADRA1A-Gα signalling potentiates adipocyte thermogenesis through CKB and TNAP. Nat. Metab. 4, 1459–1473 https://doi.org/10.1038/s42255-022-00667-w (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Lin, J. Z. & Farmer, S. R. LSD1-a pivotal epigenetic regulator of brown and beige fat differentiation and homeostasis. Genes Dev. 30, 1793–1795 https://doi.org/10.1101/gad.288720.116 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Thuzar, M. et al. Glucocorticoids suppress brown adipose tissue function in humans: a double-blind placebo-controlled study. Diabetes Obes. Metab. 20, 840–848 https://doi.org/10.1111/dom.13157 (2018).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that tholen, S. et al. Flattening of circadian glucocorticoid oscillations drives acute hyperinsulinemia and adipocyte hypertrophy. Cell Rep. 39, 111018 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2022.111018 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, masuzaki, H. et al. A transgenic model of visceral obesity and the metabolic syndrome. Science 294, 2166–2170 https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1066285 (2001).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Ramage, L. E. et al. Glucocorticoids acutely increase brown adipose tissue activity in humans, revealing species-specific differences in UCP-1 regulation. Cell Metab. 24, 130–141 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2016.06.011 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that scotney, H. et al. Glucocorticoids modulate human brown adipose tissue thermogenesis in vivo. Metabolism 70, 125–132 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.metabol.2017.01.024 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that bel, J. S., Tai, T. C., Khaper, N. & Lees, S. J. Chronic glucocorticoid exposure causes brown adipose tissue whitening, alters whole-body glucose metabolism and increases tissue uncoupling protein-1. Physiol. Rep. 10, e15292 https://doi.org/10.14814/phy2.15292 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Roh, H. C. et al. Warming induces significant reprogramming of beige, but not brown, adipocyte cellular identity. Cell Metab. 27, 1121–1137 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2018.03.005 (2018).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Glantschnig, C. et al. The glucocorticoid receptor in brown adipocytes is dispensable for control of energy homeostasis. EMBO Rep. 20, e48552 https://doi.org/10.15252/embr.201948552 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Park, Y.-K. & Ge, K. Glucocorticoid receptor accelerates, but is dispensable for, adipogenesis. Mol. Cell. Biol. 37, e00260-16 https://doi.org/10.1128/mcb.00260-16 (2017).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that liu, K. et al. Metabolic stress drives sympathetic neuropathy within the liver. Cell Metab. 33, 666–675 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2021.01.012 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Tang, L. et al. Sympathetic nerve activity maintains an anti-inflammatory state in adipose tissue in male mice by inhibiting TNF-α gene expression in macrophages. Endocrinology 156, 3680–3694 https://doi.org/10.1210/EN.2015-1096 (2015).
Sources indicate that son, S. et al. Neutrophils preserve energy storage in sympathetically activated adipocytes. Nature 650, 718–726 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-025-09839-6 (2026).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that wang, G. et al. Distinct adipose progenitor cells emerging with age drive active adipogenesis. Science 388, eadj0430 https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adj0430 (2025).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that wang, W. et al. A PRDM16-driven metabolic signal from adipocytes regulates precursor cell fate. Cell Metab. 30, 174–189 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2019.05.005 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Qiang, L. et al. Brown remodeling of white adipose tissue by SirT1-dependent deacetylation of Ppargamma. Cell 150, 620–632 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2012.06.027 (2012).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Feng, X. et al. Senescent immune cells accumulation promotes brown adipose tissue dysfunction during aging. Nat. Commun. 14, 3208 https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-023-38842-6 (2023).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Dodd, G. T. et al. Intranasal targeting of hypothalamic PTP1B and TCPTP reinstates leptin and insulin sensitivity and promotes weight loss in obesity. Cell Rep. 28, 2905–2922 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.celrep.2019.08.019 (2019).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Sun, K. et al. Dichotomous effects of VEGF-A on adipose tissue dysfunction. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 109, 5874–5879 https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1200447109 (2012).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that shen, H., Jiang, L., Lin, J. D., Omary, M. B. & Rui, L. Brown fat activation mitigates alcohol-induced liver steatosis and injury in mice. J. Clin. Invest. 129, 2305–2317 https://doi.org/10.1172/JCI124376 (2019).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Balkow, A. et al. Direct lentivirus injection for fast and efficient gene transfer into brown and beige adipose tissue. J. Biol. Methods 3, e48 https://doi.org/10.14440/jbm.2016.123 (2016).
Article PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Chi, J. et al. Three-dimensional adipose tissue imaging reveals regional variation in beige fat biogenesis and PRDM16-dependent sympathetic neurite density. Cell Metab. 27, 226–236 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cmet.2017.12.011 (2018).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that dunn, K. W., Kamocka, M. M. & McDonald, J. H. A practical guide to evaluating colocalization in biological microscopy. Am. J. Physiol. Cell Physiol. 300, C723–C742 https://doi.org/10.1152/ajpcell.00462.2010 (2011).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that bolte, S. & Cordelieres, F. P. A guided tour into subcellular colocalization analysis in light microscopy. J. Microsc. 224, 213–232 https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2818.2006.01706.x (2006).
Article MathSciNet CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that isidor, M. S. et al. An siRNA-based method for efficient silencing of gene expression in mature brown adipocytes. Adipocyte 5, 175–185 https://doi.org/10.1080/21623945.2015.1111972 (2016).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Song, A. et al. Code for ‘Bistable regulation of adipocyte heterogeneity governs thermogenesis’. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22804953 (2026).
We thank P. Scherer, X. Yang, Y. Zhao, R. Liu, R. Gupta, M. Liu, J. Wu, A. Riggs, S. Wilkinson, D. Thurmond, Y. Yang, B. Armstrong, P. Pirrotte and N. Arias for discussions and comments; and the staff at the City of Hope Animal Resource Center, the Integrative Genomics Core, the Light Microscopy Core, the Pathology (Solid Tumor) Core and the City of Hope Comprehensive Cancer Center for their assistance.
Industry observers note that this research was supported by the COH startup and salary-saving funds, as well as the Caltech-COH Initiative Award. S.P. was supported by the National Institutes of Health Cancer Metabolism Training Program (CMTP) T32 CA221709. The Pathology (Solid Tumor) Core was supported by NIH P30CA033572.
Present address: State Key Laboratory of Metabolism and Regulation in Complex Organisms, TaiKang Medical School (School of Basic Medical Sciences), Taikang Center for Life and Medical Sciences, Wuhan University, Wuhan, China.
Department of Molecular and Cellular Endocrinology, Arthur Riggs Diabetes and Metabolism Research Institute, Beckman Research Institute, City of Hope Medical Center, Duarte, CA, USA.
Anying Song, Yifan Wang, Guan Wang, Marie Bae, Zhichao Wang, Geming Lu, Jiayu Yu, Soojin Park, Adolfo Garcia-Ocaña, Patrick T. Fueger, Lei Jiang & Qiong A. Wang.
Division of Biology and Bioengineering, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA.
Hubei Key Laboratory of Cell Homeostasis, College of Life Sciences, Institute for Advanced Studies, Wuhan University, Wuhan, China.
Children’s Nutrition Research Center, Department of Pediatrics, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, TX, USA.
Comprehensive Metabolic Phenotyping Core, Beckman Research Institute, City of Hope Medical Center, Duarte, CA, USA.
Comprehensive Cancer Center, Beckman Research Institute, City of Hope Medical Center, Duarte, CA, USA.
Patrick T. Fueger, Lei Jiang & Qiong A. Wang.
Department of Life and Environmental Sciences, Marche Polytechnic University, Ancona, Italy.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, Q.A.W. and A.S. designed the experiments. Q.A.W. and A.S. wrote the manuscript. Q.A.W., A.S. and Y.W. assembled the figures. A.S., Y.W. and G.W. handled mouse experiments. A.S., Y.W. and M.B. performed genotyping and western blotting. A.F. and L.R. provided the human BAT sections. A.S., Y.W. and M.B. performed IF staining and imaging. A.S. analysed the scRNA-seq data. G.G. performed Pearson correlation analysis of the fluorescence images. Z. Wang and L.J. performed the 13C-glucose and 13C-palmitate tracing experiments. A.S. and G.W. performed flow cytometry experiments. A.S. performed all in vitro culture experiments. A.S. and G.W. performed BAT tissue clearing and three-dimensional IF imaging. Z. Wu and Y.L. contributed to scientific discussion. G.L., J.Y., S.P., J.M., P.T.F., A.G.-O., L.J. and Y.Z. contributed to experimental design and discussion.
Correspondence to Anying Song or Qiong A. Wang.
The authors declare no competing interests.
According to recent reports, nature thanks the anonymous reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
a, Heatmap of genes differentially expressed in BA-L cells and BA-H cells in BAT, with H6pd, Rgs2, and Ucp1 highlighted with a red asterisk. Data were obtained from the NCBI Gene Expression Omnibus (GEO) (accession GSE125269). b, Heatmap of genes related to thermogenesis and GR signalling that are differentially expressed in BA-L cells and BA-H cells, with Ucp1 and H6pd highlighted in red. c, Top pathway enrichment analysis for BA-L cells compared with BA-H cells, including upregulated and downregulated biological processes, with glucocorticoid-related pathways highlighted in red. The “Gene Ratio” represents the ratio of the number of input (differentially expressed) genes associated with a given pathway to the total number of input genes. p-values are shown in standard scientific notation; dot colour indicates the adjusted p-values (the brighter red indicating greater significance), and the dot size reflects the number of enriched genes. d, UMAP plots of the adipocyte fraction from BAT of WT mice maintained at room temperature. e, Distribution of the expression of Ucp1, Cox6b1, H6pd, Rgs2, Txnip and Nr3c1 within UMAP plots. f, Violin plots showing the expression and distribution of Ucp1, Cox6b1, H6pd, Rgs2, Txnip and Nr3c1.
It has been revealed that a, The Ucp1-Chaser-mTmG mouse model is generated by crossing Ucp1-rtTA transgenic mice with TRE-Cre and Rosa26-loxP-STOP-loxP-mT/mG transgenic mice. In Ucp1-Chaser-mTmG mice, all cells express tdTomato. When mice are put on a doxycycline diet, UCP1-high-expressing cells will start rtTA expression; rtTA will then bind to the TRE promoter, inducing Cre expression. Cre will specifically excise the floxed membrane-localizing Tomato (mTomato) sequence, initiating expression of membrane-localizing GFP (mGFP). b, BA-L cells and BA-H cells were freshly isolated from the BAT of WT mice. H6PD and UCP1 immunoblots and quantification normalized to Ponceau S staining. Representative Ponceau S-stained membrane as shown as loading controls. n = 4 per group. c, SVFs and BAs were freshly isolated from the BAT of WT mice. PDGFRα, UCP1, H6PD, and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. n = 4 per group. d, Ucp1-mGFP knock-in (KI) generation strategy: A P2A-mGFP cassette was inserted into the 5′ end of 3′UTR, immediately upstream of the STOP codon of Ucp1 gene. e, Representative GFP fluorescent images of whole BAT from 10-week-old male Ucp1-mGFP (left) and WT (right) littermates, demonstrating GFP expression exclusively in Ucp1-mGFP mice. f, GFP, UCP1, and β-actin immunoblots and quantification in whole BAT from 10-week-old male Ucp1-mGFP mice and WT littermates. n = 6 per group. g, IF staining showing the pattern of GFP (green) expression in the BAT of 10-week-old male Ucp1-mGFP mice. h, IF staining for GFP (green), H6PD (red), perilipin (white), and DAPI (blue) in vitro-differentiated brown adipocytes and beige adipocytes derived from Ucp1-mGFP mice BAT SVFs and iWAT SVFs. Statistics were computed by unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test [b, f (UCP1)] or unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-test [c, f (GFP)]. **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. For b, c, and f, data are mean ± s.e.m.
a, 10-week-old Male WT mice were housed at 24 °C or 6 °C for 1, 3 or 7 days. TNAP, CKB, and β-actin immunoblots and quantification in BAT. n = 4 per group. b, TNAP, CKB, GR, and β-actin immunoblots and quantification in freshly isolated primary BA-L cells and BA-H cells from 10-week-old male WT mice. n = 3 per group. c, Representative IF staining for H6PD (red), TNAP (green), DAPI (blue), merged with autofluorescence signal (white), in BAT from 10-week-old male WT mice housed at 24 °C. Quantification of the relative percentage of BAs positive for H6PD+ only, TNAP+ only, or both. n = 4 per group. d, Representative IF staining for H6PD (red), TNAP (green), DAPI (blue), merged with autofluorescence signal (white), in iWAT from 10-week-old male WT mice housed at 6 °C for 7 days. Quantification of the relative percentage of multilocular beige adipocytes positive for H6PD+ only, TNAP+ only, or both. n = 4 per group. e, Representative images of IF staining for GFP (green), TNAP (red), perilipin (white), and DAPI (blue) in BAs differentiated from BAT SVFs. Statistics were computed by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (a, c, d) or unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test (b). *p < 0.05, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. For a–d, data are mean ± s.e.m.
a, Freshly isolated BA-H cells and BA-L cells (1 × 105 cells) from 10-week-old male WT mice were incubated with either 5 mM [U-13C] glucose or 0.5 mM [U-13C] palmitate tracing media for 2 h and 6 h. Illustration of carbon transition from extracellular glucose and palmitate. n = 3 per group. b, The relative abundance of fully labelled (m + 16) free palmitate C16:0 in BA-H cells and BA-L cells cultured with [U-13C] palmitate at 2 h. n = 3 per group. c, The relative abundance of fully labelled (m + 16) total palmitate C16:0 in BA-H cells and BA-L cells cultured with [U-13C] palmitate at 2 h. n = 3 per group. d, The citrate enrichment demonstrates the glucose oxidation and fatty acid oxidation in BA subpopulations at 2 or 6 h (2 h, 6 h). n = 3 per group. e, f, 10-week-old male Ucp1-mGFP mice were injected with lentivirus overexpressing H6pd or mCherry as a control in BAT. After 2 weeks of recovery. Representative IF staining for H6PD (green), perilipin (red), and DAPI (blue) in BAT (e). Representative IF staining for mCherry (green), perilipin (red), and DAPI (blue) in BAT (f). Statistics were computed by unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test (b), unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-test (c), or two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (d). *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. For b–d, data are mean ± s.e.m.
Sources indicate that a, BAs differentiated from the BAT SVFs from WT mice were pretreated with 1 μM DEX for 12 h, followed by 10 μM CL-316,243 treatment for 24 h. RT–qPCR analysis of Ucp1 mRNA levels. n = 3 per group. b–d, BAs differentiated from the primary BAT SVFs from Ucp1-mGFP mice were cultured with or without DEX, 11-DHC, or CORT throughout the adipogenic differentiation period. GFP fluorescence reflects real-time UCP1 (green) and perilipin (red) expression (b). Quantification of GPF+ BA-H percentage (c). RT–qPCR analysis of mRNA levels of Ucp1, Pparg, and Fabp4 (d). n = 4 per group for (c) and n = 3 per group for (d). e, f, 10-week-old male WT mice were injected with vehicle or DEX for 2 weeks. H&E and IF staining for UCP1 (green), perilipin (red), and DAPI (blue) in BAT (e). Quantification of BA-H percentage (f). n = 4 per group. g, h, IF staining for GFP (green), RGS2 (red), perilipin (white), and DAPI (blue) in BAs differentiated from BAT SVFs of Ucp1-mGFP mice (g) or beige adipocytes differentiated from iWAT SVFs of Ucp1-mGFP mice (h). i, GR binding at the Rgs2 locus in white adipocytes visualized by IGV. Data sourced from the study by Soccio et al.29. j, k, In vitro-differentiated BAs from the primary BAT SVFs from WT mice were reverse-transfected with Rgs2 or control DsiRNAs. 2 days post-transfection, BAs were treated with vehicle or NA for 30 min. Phosphorylated PKA substrate and β-actin immunoblot (j) and quantification (k). n = 4 per group. Statistics were computed by two-way ANOVA with factors for DEX and CL-316,243 treatment, followed by Fisher’s LSD multiple-comparisons test (a), one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (c, d, k) or unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test (f). **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. For a, c, d, f, and k, data are mean ± s.e.m.
In a recent development, a, 10-week-old male WT mice were housed at 6 °C, 24 °C, or 30 °C for 7 days. UCP1, H6PD, GR, and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. n = 3 per group. b, c, 10-week-old male WT mice were housed at 24 °C or 6 °C for 1, 3 or 7 days. H6PD, UCP1, and β-actin immunoblots and quantification in iWAT (b) and gWAT (c). n = 4 per group. d, 10-week-old male WT mice were housed at 30 °C for 1 week, followed by i.p. injections with vehicle or CL-316,243 (1 mg kg−1), and an additional week of housing at 30 °C. H6PD, UCP1, GR, and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. n = 4 per group. e, 10-week-old male WT mice were housed at 6, 24, or 30 °C for 7 days. RT–qPCR analysis of mRNA levels of Ucp1 and H6pd in BAT. n = 5 per group. f, g, 8-week-old Ucp1-Chaser-mTmG male mice underwent sham surgery or unilateral denervation of BAT. After 2 weeks of recovery, mice were housed at 24 °C or 6 °C for 1 week (with doxycycline treatment in f). (f) H&E staining of BAT. (g) RT–qPCR analysis of mRNA levels of glucocorticoid signalling target genes in BAT. n = 4 per group. h, 10-week-old male WT mice were housed at 6 °C for 1 week or housed at 6 °C for 1 week and then 30 °C for 1 week. RT–qPCR analysis of mRNA levels of glucocorticoid signalling target genes in BAT under different temperature conditions. n = 4 per group. i–p, 10-week-old male Ucp1-rtTA/TRE-cre/Nr3c1flox/flox or control littermates were fed a doxycycline diet at 6 °C for 1 week, followed by 1 week at 24 °C with continued dox diet treatment. Oxygen consumption (i), RER (j), physical activity (k), and food intake (l) were measured by the metabolic cage. Fat (m) and lean (n) compositions were measured by NMR (Nuclear Magnetic Resonance). Glucose tolerance test (o) and insulin tolerance test (p) were conducted in another cohort. n = 7 per group for (i-n) and n = 4 per group for (o, p). Statistics were computed by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (a, b (H6PD), c, e), one-way ANOVA with Dunnett’s T3 multiple-comparisons test (b (UCP1)), unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test [d, h, i (Average), l–n], unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-test [h (Txnip)], two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (g), or two-way ANOVA with Šídák’s multiple comparisons test [i (time-course curves and Day/Night), j, k, o, p]. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. For a–e, and g–p, data are mean ± s.e.m.
It has been revealed that a, 8-week-old male WT mice underwent sham surgery or unilateral denervation of BAT. After 2 weeks of recovery, mice were housed at 24 °C or 6 °C for a week. RT–qPCR analysis cytokine gene expression in BAT. n = 4 per group. b, 10-week-old male WT mice were housed in 6 °C for 1 week or housed in 6 °C for 1 week and then 30 °C for 1 week. RT–qPCR analysis cytokine gene expression in BAT. n = 4 per group. c, RT–qPCR analysis of Il1b and Tnfa mRNA levels in BAT explants incubated with vehicle or NA. n = 4 per group. d, Serum IL-1β levels measured by ELISA in 10-week-old male WT mice housed at 30 °C, 24 °C, or 6 °C for 1 or 3 days. n = 8 per group. e, f, 8-week-old male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice underwent sham surgery or unilateral denervation of BAT. After 2 weeks of recovery, mice were housed at 24 °C or 6 °C with doxycycline treatment for 1 week. Representative IF staining for GFP (green), IL-1β (purple), and DAPI (blue) in BAT (e). The yellow dashed lines circle the BA-L (GFP−) clusters, where IL-1β puncta are enriched; the yellow solid lines circle the BA-H (GFP+) clusters, where IL-1β puncta are not enriched. Pearson correlation coefficient of co-localization between UCP1 and IL-1β (f). n = 4 per group. g, RT–qPCR analysis of H6pd and Nr3c1 mRNA levels. n = 3 per group. h, i, BAs differentiated from primary BAT SVFs of WT mice were pretreated with the following inhibitors: BAY11-7082 (NF-κB inhibitor, 5 µM), Aspirin (IκB inhibitor, 5 µM), SB203580 (p38 MAPK inhibitor, 10 µM), SP600125 (JNK inhibitor, 10 µM), or U0126 (MEK/ERK inhibitor, 10 µM) for 30 min, followed by IL-1β treatment (10 ng ml−1) for 48 h. H6PD and β-actin immunoblots (h) and quantification (i). n = 4 per group. j, k, BAs differentiated from primary BAT SVFs of WT mice were switched on day 6 to culture medium containing charcoal-stripped FBS (lacking basal corticosterone) and then treated with vehicle or 10 ng ml−1 IL-1β for 48 h in the absence (j) or presence (k) of 1 μM 11-DHC. UCP1 and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. n = 4 per group. l, m, Ucp1-Chaser-mTmG male mice were maintained on standard chow until 8 weeks of age, then switched to a doxycycline chow diet for 3 days at 24 °C. BAT was processed using the Adipo-Clear method and immunolabeled for GFP (green) with the synaptic marker synaptophysin (red) (l) or sympathetic neuron marker tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) (red) (m). Images are representative of 3 independent experiments. Statistics were computed by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (a, d, g), two-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (i), unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-test [b (Tnfa)], or unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test [b (all other genes), c, j, k]. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. For a–d, and f–k, data are mean ± s.e.m.
It has been revealed that a, t-SNE plots of the non-adipocyte fraction from BAT of C57BL/6J mice maintained at room temperature. Data were sourced from the NCBI GEO database under identifiers GSE207707, GSE177635, GSE160585, and GSE161447. b, t-SNE plots displaying the expression and distribution of Ptprc, Adrb1, Adrb2, and Adrb3 genes in BAT non-adipocyte fraction. c, t-SNE plots of immune cells from BAT of C57BL/6J mice maintained at room temperature. Immune cell clusters were identified based on the expression of Ptprc and were filtered to exclude contaminating erythrocytes (Hba-a1, Hba-a2), capillary endothelial cells (Pecam1, Gpibp1), smooth muscle cells (Acta2), and adipose progenitor cells (Pdgfra, Col3a1). Data was sourced from the NCBI GEO database under identifiers GSE207707, GSE177635, GSE160585, and GSE161447. d, e, t-SNE plots displaying the expression and distribution Il1b genes (d) and Ptprc (CD45, immune cells), Cd19 (CD19, B cells), Cd3e (CD3, T cells), Itgam (Integrin alpha M, CD11b, Myeloid cells), Lyz2 (Lysozyme 2, LyZ2, Myeloid cells), Adgre1 (Adhesion G protein-coupled receptor E1, F4/80, Macrophages), Mrc1 (Mannose receptor, c type 1, CD206, anti-inflammatory macrophages), Ly6g (Lympthocyte antigen 6 complex, locus G, Ly6G, Neutrophils), Csf3r (Colony stimulating factor 3 receptor, G-CSFR, Neutrophils), Cxcr2 (Chemokine (C-X-C motif) receptor 2, CXCR2, Neutrophils), Ly6c1 (Lympthocyte antigen 6 complex, locus C1, Ly6C, Monocytes) in BAT immune cells (e).
Industry observers note that a, Flow cytometry gating strategy for CD45+, T cell, and B cell in BAT SVFs from 10-week-old male WT mice. Doublets and nonviable cells were excluded, followed by gating on CD45+ lymphocytes. T cells and B cells were subsequently selected based on CD3+ or CD19+ expression. b, Percentage of IL-1β+ cells within CD45+ lymphocytes and CD45− non-immune cells. c, Flow cytometry gating strategy for neutrophils, monocytes, and macrophages. Doublets and nonviable cells were excluded from SVFs, followed by gating on CD45+ CD11b+ myeloid. Macrophages were identified by F4/80+ expression, while F4/80− cells were further classified as neutrophils and monocytes based on CXCR2+ and Ly6C+ expression. d, Percentage of IL-1β+ cells within each immune cell type, including macrophage, neutrophils, monocytes, B cells, and T cells. n = 6 per group. e, Absolute number of IL-1β+ cells per gram of brown adipose tissue within each immune cell type. n = 3 per group. f, g, Representative images of IF staining for CXCR2 (red) or F4/80 (red), IL-1β (green), and DAPI (blue) in BAT. h–j, BAs differentiated from primary BAT SVFs, with or without CD45+ immune cells, from Ucp1-mGFP mice. GFP fluorescence reflects real-time UCP1 expression in the brightfield images. Representative IF staining for GFP (green), perilipin (red), and DAPI (blue) (h). Quantification of GPF+ BA-H percentage (i). RT–qPCR analysis of Pparg and Fabp4 mRNA levels (j). n = 3 per group for (i) and n = 4 per group for (j). Statisticswere computed by unpaired two-tailed Welch’s t-test (b), unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test (i, j), or one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (d, e). **p < 0.01, ****p < 0.0001. For b, d, e, i, and j, data are mean ± s.e.m.
According to recent reports, a, 10-week-old male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice were injected with lentivirus overexpressing IL-1RA or mCherry (control) into BAT. Following a 2-week recovery period, mice were housed at 24 °C with doxycycline treatment for a week. Representative images of IF staining for IL-1RA (red), GFP (green), perilipin (white), and DAPI (blue) in BAT. b, BAs differentiated from the primary BAT SVFs from WT mice were reverse-transfected with Il1r1 or control DsiRNAs. 2 days post-transfection, cells were cultured in charcoal-stripped medium and treated with vehicle or 10 ng ml−1 IL-1β for 48 h in the presence of 1 μM 11-DHC. Western blot and quantifications of UCP1 and IL-1R1 protein levels. n = 4 per group. c, d, 10-week-old male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice were maintained on a doxycycline chow diet and administered vehicle or VX-765 (50 mg per kg per day) via daily i.p. injection for 1 week. (c) Representative IF staining of BAT for GFP (green) and perilipin (red), and DAPI (blue) in BAT (d). Quantification of BA-H percentage. n = 3 per group. e–h, 10-week-old male WT mice were housed at 24 °C or 30 °C for 1 week. The percentage of IL-1β+ cells were quantified across immune cell types, including CD45+ lymphocytes, CD45− non-immune cells (e), and CD45+CD11b+ myeloid cells and CD45+CD11b− leukocytes (f). The absolute number of IL-1β+ cells per gram of BAT (g) and per BAT fat pad (h) was quantified. n = 5 per group. i, RT–qPCR analysis of Il1b mRNA in CD45+ immune cells isolated from BAT of 10-week-old male WT mice, followed by incubation with vehicle or 1 µM NA for 4 h. n = 3 per group. Statistics were computed by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (b), unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test (d, g, h, i), or two-way ANOVA with Šídák’s multiple-comparisons test (e, f). *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ****p < 0.0001. For b, and d–i, data are mean ± s.e.m.
Industry observers note that a, t-SNE feature plots displaying the expression and distribution of α- and β-adrenergic receptor genes in BAT immune cells. b, c, Bone marrow neutrophils isolated from 10-week-old male WT mice were stimulated with different doses of LPS (0, 0.1, 1, 10, 100, 1000 ng ml−1) for 6 h (b), or pretreated with different doses of NA (0, 0.1, 1, 10 µM) for 30 min, followed by LPS treatment (100 ng ml−1) for 6 h (c). RT–qPCR analysis of Il1b mRNA levels. n = 3 per group for (b) and n = 4 per group for (c). d, Bone marrow neutrophils isolated from 10-week-old male WT mice were treated with LPS (100 ng ml−1) alone or pretreated with NA (1 µM) for 30 min prior to LPS stimulation for 1, 2, 4, 6, 9 h. RT–qPCR analysis of Il1b mRNA levels. n = 3 per group. e, f, Bone marrow neutrophils isolated from 10-week-old male WT mice were pretreated with propranolol (1 µM) or phenoxybenzamine (1 µM) for 60 min, followed by NA (1 µM) for 30 min prior to LPS (100 ng ml−1) stimulation. (e) Neutrophils were collected 6 h after LPS treatment for RT–qPCR analysis of Il1b mRNA levels. (f) Nigericin (10 µM) was added 30 min before sample collection, and supernatants were collected at 9 h for ELISA analysis of IL-1β levels. n = 4 per group. g, h, 10-week-old male WT mice were cold-exposed at 6 °C for 16 h then treated with propranolol (10 mg kg−1) (g), phenoxybenzamine hydrochloride (5 mg kg−1) (h), or PBS via i.p. injection. BAT was harvested 4 h later for RT-qPCR analysis of Il1b mRNA levels. n = 4 per group. i, 10-week-old (young) and 68-week-old (aged) male mice were housed at 24 °C or 6 °C for 1 week. H6PD, UCP1, and β-actin immunoblots and quantification. n = 3 per group. j, 8-week-old (young) and 74-week-old (aged) male Ucp1-Chaser-mT/mG mice were fed a doxycycline chow diet for 1 week, followed by exposure at 6 °C for 1 day while continuing the doxycycline diet. Representative IF staining of BAT for GFP (green), TNAP (red), and DAPI (blue), merged with autofluorescence signal (white). k, l, Corticosterone levels in serum (k) and BAT (l) of 10-week-old (young) and 68-week-old (aged) male WT mice. n = 9 (young) and n = 8 (aged). m, RT-qPCR analysis of Il1b, Tnf, Retnla, Il1a, and Tgfb mRNA levels in BAT of male WT mice at 8, 24, 48, 72, and 96 weeks of age. n = 3per group. n, RT-qPCR analysis of Il1b mRNA levels in SVFs and mature adipocytes isolated from BAT of 10-week-old (young) and 72-week-old (aged) male WT mice. n = 4 per group. o, 70 to 75-week-old male WT mice were s.c. injected with vehicle or RU-486 (60 mg per kg per day) for 1 week and then exposed to 6 °C for 8 h. Rectal temperatures were recorded over time. n = 8 per group. p, 75-week-old male WT mice were s.c. injected with vehicle or RU-486 (60 mg per kg per day) for 1 week. Body weight changes were recorded at the indicated time points. n = 8 per group. q–u, 72-week-old male WT mice were s.c. injected with either vehicle or RU-486 (60 mgper kgper day) for 1 week, followed by metabolic phenotyping, with daily vehicle or RU-486 injection continued throughout. Energy expenditure (q), oxygen consumption (r), RER (s), locomotor activity (t), and food intake (u). n = 7 (vehicle) and n = 8 (RU-486). Statistics were computed by one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s multiple-comparisons test (b, f, i, n), one-way ANOVA and Dunnett’s T3 multiple comparisons test (c, e, m), two-way ANOVA with Šídák’s multiple-comparisons test [d, o, p, q, r (time-course curves and Day/Night), s, t], or unpaired two-tailed Student’s t-test [g, h, k, l, q, r (Average), u]. *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. For b–i, and k–r, data are mean ± s.e.m.
In a recent development, a, Molecular mechanism for the maintenance of the BA-L state. BA has two stable states, low and high thermogenesis, based on UCP1 expression. BA states are governed by their spatial proximity to IL-1β+ immune cells (mainly neutrophils and macrophages), which integrate signals from sympathetic neurons and immune cells to determine whether H6PD protein levels should be stabilized or degraded. Green arrows illustrate how BA-L cells are stabilized in a low-thermogenic state: IL-1β enhances the protein stability of H6PD in thermogenic adipocytes, thereby boosting the production of active glucocorticoids. Glucocorticoid activates the expression of its target RGS2, which inhibits adenylyl cyclase and reduces cAMP production, thereby reducing UCP1 expression. Red arrows illustrate how BA-L cells switch into BA-H cells upon cold exposure: cold stimulation activates sympathetic neurons, which decrease local BAT IL-1β levels; lower IL-1β levels lead to H6PD protein degradation, turning BA-L into BA-H. The purple arrow illustrates that in aged individuals, IL-1β is elevated in BAT. High IL-1β levels persistently prevent H6PD degradation, desensitizing BAs’ cold response by locking them in BA-L states. Illustration created with BioRender; Wang, Q. https://BioRender.com/basqx8x (2026). b, Bistable regulation of BA heterogeneity in a spatiotemporal manner governs thermogenic activity. We report that IL-1β-secreting immune cells, mainly neutrophils and macrophages, stabilize the surrounding BAs in a low-thermogenic state by preventing H6PD degradation; BAs farther from IL-1β+ cells are stabilized in a high-thermogenic state. Specifically, H6PD is a functional marker of BA-L cells and boosts the production of active GC. GC then activates the expression of its target, RGS2, which inhibits adenylyl cyclase, reducing cAMP production and, in turn, UCP1 expression. This bistable regulation dynamically and precisely controls cellular heterogeneity in response to signalling from sympathetic nerves and the immune system, managing thermogenesis at the tissue level. Increased IL-1β levels in the BAT of aged individuals lock BAs in a low-thermogenic state, thereby lowering thermogenic activity and leading to cold intolerance. Illustration created with BioRender; Wang, Q. https://BioRender.com/mj195m9 (2026).
Supplementary Fig. 1 and Supplementary Tables 1 and 2. Supplementary Fig. 1: gel source data. Uncropped images corresponding to the main figures and extended data figures. The solid-line boxes indicate the regions shown in the cropped versions used in the main figures and Extended data figures. Supplementary Table 1: sequences of oligos used in this study. Supplementary Table 2: P values for each panel.
Song, A., Wang, Y., Wang, G. et al. Bistable regulation of adipocyte heterogeneity governs thermogenesis. Nature (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11308-7.
Version of record: 11 November 2026.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11308-7.
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:.
Sorry, a shareable link is not at the moment available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative.
📅 26 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 15 min read (2943 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Scotland’s ramped-up second-half performance offered some cause for optimism as Sébastien Pocognoli’s tenure as head coach began with a goalless draw with Slovenia in Ljubljana.
The 39-year-old Belgian head coach, appointed in August as Steve Clarke’s successor, refreshed the side for the Nations League Group B1 opener in the Stozice Stadium, but they were fortunate on a couple of occasions at least not to fall behind before rallying before the break.
Scotland had been insipid and uninspiring for most of the first half but after the interval they played with pace and purpose as Slovenia captain and goalkeeper Jan Oblak became a key figure, making saves from Oli McBurnie and Kieron Bowie.
Oli McBurnie spurns a chance for Scotland.It remains goalless between Slovenia and Scotland.📺 Watch on BBC One pic.twitter.com/sldzhNCGGb.
“It took us a bit of getting used to in the first half, the way the gaffer wants to play,” McBurnie told BBC Scotland.
Recent findings suggest that “We created enough chances to win the game. I should have scored. I was asked to play a different position and I enjoyed it. I’d rather be getting in the positions than not getting chances.
It has been revealed that “Second half was a lot more of what the manager wanted from us. It was waves of pressure and the only thing missing was a goal or two.”.
However, the goal that would have made the former Union Saint-Gilloise and Monaco manager’s debut as an international boss more memorable ultimately failed to arrive.
In this extended international break, the Scots will host Switzerland at Hampden on Tuesday and then travel to North Macedonia before taking on Slovenia in Glasgow, with the Tartan Army hoping to see further improvement – and goals.
September 29: Scotland vs Switzerland.
October 3: North Macedonia vs Scotland.
October 6: Scotland vs Slovenia.
November 13: Scotland vs North Macedonia.
November 16: Switzerland vs Scotland.
Speaking to BBC Scotland, the debutant remarked: “Thought we struggled to get into the game first half, but second half we completely dominated the game.
“They’ve got a top goalie who made really good saves. So many positives to take and a clean sheet as well.
“We changed shape a wee bit at half-time to get more control and that did really well for us.
“It’s a substantial game again on Tuesday so it’s important to recover now and go again.
“I’ve played on the left-hand side for a couple of years now, so I’m comfortable doing that.
According to recent reports, “We’ve had a great week. A new manager, new way of playing and new faces in camp. It’s just the chances we need to take - the fact we’re creating the chances stands us in good stead.”.
The striker told BBC Scotland: “It took us a bit of getting used to in the first half, the way the gaffer wants to play.
“We created enough chances to win the game. I should have scored.
Industry observers note that “I was asked to play a different position and I enjoyed it. I’d rather be getting in the positions than not getting chances.
“Second half was a lot more of what the manager wanted from us. It was waves of pressure and the only thing missing was a goal or two.”.
Recent findings suggest that pocognoli’s first game in charge of Scotland ends in a goalless draw. The visitors produced a dominant second-half display, but their final ball and end-product was severely lacking in crucial moments. Ure, Hickey, Gilmour, McBurnie and Bowie all came close to scoring, but no one could break the deadlock.
In a recent development, scotland cannot find a way past the impenetrable Oblak. There will be just two minutes of added time for the visitors to possibly score a late winner.
Industry observers note that lovric clatters into Gilmour and is cautioned. Slovenia can’t get out. It’s wave after wave of Scottish pressure.
In a recent development, oblak comes out and fails to claim Robertson’s free-kick. The ball is recycled and the Tottenham full-back whips a second cross into the box and Slovenia fail to clear. Welsh is waiting for it, but lashes a first-time volley over the bar.
Karnicnik catches Robertson with a late lunging tackle and receives a yellow card, giving Scotland a chance to get the ball into the box.
The hosts make their fifth alteration of the afternoon, with Cerin withdrawn and Lovric on instead.
According to recent reports, how has Bowie missed?! Gilmour finds Bowie with an outstanding pass through the centre of Slovenia’s defence. The substitute takes a touch then scuffs a rushed finish wide. Bowie has to do better there!
Another change is here for Scotland, with Gannon-Doak on to replace Hickey.
Another big chance for Scotland. This time Sassuolo's Kieron Bowie goes close.Slovenia 0-0 Scotland - watch the closing stages on BBC One. pic.twitter.com/xMe5gRNgEr.
Recent findings suggest that from the resulting corner, Oblak is there again to thwart McBurnie’s point-blank header. The referee then blows his whistle to relieve the pressure on Slovenia. Somehow, the scoreline remains goalless.
The hosts make another double change as Sporar and Brekalo depart for Vipotnik and Balkovec.
Welsh spots Bowie’s run and threads a perfectly-weighted pass through to the forward. From an unfavourable angle, the substitute’s one-on-one attempt is blocked by Oblak.
Another massive chance for Scotland! McGinn’s searching corner is met by Hickey, who flicks a header wide of the far post. Scotland’s second-half performance deserves a goal.
Pocognoli orders Scotland’s first alteration of the game, with Bowie replacing Ure up top.
Hickey finds himself very high up the pitch and tries to tee up Ure with a cushioned header, but there isn’t enough power on the pass.
Gilmour and Ure link up effectively on the counter, but the latter’s pull-back is intercepted by Drkusic.
Slovenia then make two changes as Zabukovnik and Zec replace Elsnik and Drkusic.
It has been revealed that mcGinn strides forward and tries to find Ure, but Slovenia rush back to scramble it clear. Scotland are really pushing for the opening goal.
Recent findings suggest that gilmour and McBurnie play a devastating one-two, allowing the midfielder to advance into the penalty area. He shoots and aims for the far corner, but his placed effort is collected impressively by Oblak, who makes another crucial intervention.
Industry observers note that the second half has started as the first ended, with Scotland applying all of the pressure. Slovenia have Oblak to thank for the goalless scoreline.
McBurnie and Oblak both challenge for the ball, with the Scotsman bumping into the goalkeeper, giving Slovenia a goal kick. The decision is met by a chorus of boos from the away fans.
Sources indicate that mcBurnie latches onto a loose ball and skips away from Drkusic’s sliding challenge. One-on-one, the striker tries to round Oblak, but the Slovenian goalkeeper does sensationally to apprehend him. Upon reflection, it looks like McBurnie should have just shot and tried to put the ball between Oblak’s legs. He did the hard part, but lacked a clinical finish.
Oli McBurnie spurns a chance for Scotland.It remains goalless between Slovenia and Scotland.📺 Watch on BBC One pic.twitter.com/sldzhNCGGb.
McGinn brilliantly turns Drkusic on the halfway line and then tees up Gilmour. The Napoli midfielder tries to float a pass over to the onrushing Robertson, but he hits the switch of play straight out for a throw-in. In defence of Gilmour, the pitch really doesn’t look in the best condition, with various players struggling regarding their weight of pass.
Industry observers note that we are back under way for the second half. Both sides are unchanged at the break.
Pocognoli’s Scotland finished the half as the better side, but an opening goal has proved to be elusive. At times, they’ve looked suspect defensively and have lacked rhythm going forward. However, Pocognoli’s squad have only been together for a few days and are playing in a fresh system. Can they produce a more inspired second-half performance?
In a recent development, despite Scotland’s late push for an opening goal at the end of the first half, the two sides head in level at the break. Slovenia started on the front-foot, with Sporar and Drkusic both going close for the hosts, before Ure struck the post to be denied a dream debut goal.
HALF TIME: Slovenia 0-0 Scotland.No goals at the break in Ljubljana.#SVNSCO pic.twitter.com/6VGFRprBiz.
In a recent development, ure strikes the woodwork! The Sevilla striker is agonisingly close to a debut goal for his country. He cuts inside to work some space and fires a low effort at goal, but his shot hits the post.
Scotland's best chance of the game so far 😯 Sevilla striker and debutant Robbie Ure strikes the post just before half-time.However, it remains goalless at the break.📺 Watch Slovenia v Scotland on BBC One 🇸🇮 🏴 pic.twitter.com/fm1wH2fOej.
Much better from Scotland! McGinn turns his marker and clips a wonderful pass over to Ure, who has drifted out wide. The ball is then delivered into the box toward McGinn, whose header bounces off McBurnie. Hickey is arriving to pounce on the loose ball, but the wing-back’s effort is blocked by the Slovenian defence.
Robertson picks up the game’s first yellow card for an off-the-ball incident. The Scotland captain is clearly very unhappy with the decision as we await to see a replay. Nevertheless, the action resumes with a Slovenia free-kick.
In a recent development, slovenia go close again as a corner is whipped in. Drkusic wins the header at the near post and it bounces off the outside of the near post. That is definitely another warning sign for Scotland.
It has been revealed that matko goes on the outside of Welsh, and from a tight angle, he shoots, but his fizzed effort saves the side netting of the near post. Some fans behind the goal cheer because they think it’s gone in, but their view has really deceived them.
It has been revealed that it’s been a quiet afternoon for both goalkeepers so far, with neither yet to make a noteworthy save. On a couple of occasions, Slovenia have had encouraging opportunities to get the ball into the Scotland’s box, but the deliveries have been overhit and poorly executed.
It has been revealed that similarly to Scotland, Slovenia are also playing a tremendously high-line. Unlike Slovenia, Scotland have been unable to find the right pass in behind the home side’s defence. Gilmour then carelessly gives the ball away as Scotland’s latest spell of possession ends.
Since Slovenia wasted that 14th-minute chance, Scotland have grown into the contest and are beginning to look comfortable in possession. However, they’re still waiting to craft their first notable opening here.
The hosts miss a huge chance! Once again, Sturm gets in behind Scotland’s incredibly high line and then fires a low cross into the penalty area. Sporar then beats McKenna to the delivery, but taps his close-range effort wide of the far post from inside the six-yard box. That’s a massive let-off for Scotland...
Matko is unleashed by a drilled pass then pierces through a gap between Robertson and Welsh. The Slovenia winger drives into the penalty area and tries to find either Sturm or Sporar with a cross, but Hendry does magnificently to make a last-ditch clearance.
Slovenia have the ball in the net, but the offside flag is up. Sturm gets in behind Scotland’s defence and slides a low cross into Sporar’s path. The striker then sweeps a composed first-time effort into the top corner. It’s a brilliant finish, but Sturm was miles offside in the build-up.
Gunn comes out confidently to collect a looping cross, before the ball is released forward in McBurnie’s direction. The Hull City striker and Ure are playing really close to each other, very much like an old-school front-two.
Industry observers note that slovenia forward Sturm is wiped out by Hendry’s wild early challenge. The Scotland defender is perhaps lucky to avoid a booking. Welsh then heads the resulting set-piece away and out for a corner.
Industry observers note that the hosts get us underway in the Slovenian capital. Can Pocognoli begin his Scotland tenure with a Nations League victory?
Both teams are out on the pitch in Ljubljana. We are moments away from the start of the Pocognoli era.
Fresh Scotland manager Sebastien Pocognoli sings Flower of Scotland as he takes charge of the national side for the first time 🎶 🇸🇮 Slovenia v Scotland 🏴 is live on BBC One now.#BBCFootball #NationsLeague pic.twitter.com/I2aeqYkNGB.
With just over 10 minutes until kick-off, here’s a reminder of both teams’ line-ups.
Slovenia: Oblak, Brekalo, Bijol, Drkusic, Janza, Karnicnik, Cerin, Elsnik, Matko, Sturm, Sporar.
Subs: Vidovsek, Leban, Balkovec, Zabukovnik, Kuzmic, Begic, Lovric, Celar, Svetlin, Zec, Vipotnik, Horvat.
Scotland: Gunn, Hendry, McKenna, Welsh, Hickey, Gilmour, Ferguson, Robertson, McGinn, Ure, McBurnie.
Subs: Kelly, Bain, Binks, Doig, Christie, Miller, McPake, Doak, Graham, Bowie, Patterson, Montgomery.
"Let's go!" 👏#SVNSCO pic.twitter.com/HBvPJdFkFb.
It has been revealed that luis Binks of Brondby, as well as Colby Donovan and Josh McPake, who play for Celtic and Hearts respectively, are all amongst the substitutes. This hopeful trio are all in line for their Scotland debuts if they enter the action later this afternoon.
Slovenski navijači se že zbirajo 👊🇸🇮#SrceBije 🇸🇮 pic.twitter.com/dM9UArGgl3.
How much do the Tartan Army really know about newly introduced Scotland boss Sebastien Pocognoli? 🤔 We sent Jonathan Sutherland around Ljubljana to find out.📺 Watch 🇸🇮 Slovenia v Scotland 🏴 on Saturday on BBC One from 13:45 BST. pic.twitter.com/KSurjSmKwL.
'We're not going to be perfect right away but we still demand results'Scotland's Lewis Ferguson as the team begins a latest era under Sebastien Pocognoli 🏴#BBCFootball pic.twitter.com/42WCJh66gc.
Slovenia: Oblak, Brekalo, Bijol, Drkusic, Janza, Karnicnik, Cerin, Elsnik, Matko, Sturm, Sporar.
Subs: Vidovsek, Leban, Balkovec, Zabukovnik, Kuzmic, Begic, Lovric, Celar, Svetlin, Zec, Vipotnik, Horvat.
Scotland: Gunn, Hendry, McKenna, Welsh, Hickey, Gilmour, Ferguson, Robertson, McGinn, Ure, McBurnie.
Subs: Kelly, Bain, Binks, Doig, Christie, Miller, McPake, Doak, Graham, Bowie, Patterson, Montgomery.
On paper, it looks like Sebastien Pocognoli has opted for a five-back formation, with Swansea City defender Stephen Welsh making his Scotland debut as one of the centre backs.
Captain Andy Robertson and Brentford’s Aaron Hickey will operate as the wing-backs, with Billy Gilmour, Lewis Ferguson and John McGinn forming a midfield three.
A newly introduced-look attack is spearheaded by the returning Oli McBurnie and 22-year-old Robbie Ure, who like Welsh, will also make his Scotland debut.
Angus Gunn remains his country’s first-choice goalkeeper.
Sebastien Pocognoli's first Scotland XI to take on Slovenia 🏴Watch the game live on BBC One Scotland from 13:45 BST 📺#BBCFootball pic.twitter.com/OnfWR7Gp8C.
The squad's here 🏟️#SVNSCO pic.twitter.com/IUiWhTHUT4.
According to recent reports, 🚨 Znana je začetna enajsterica Slovenije za tekmo s Škotsko! 👊🇸🇮#SrceBije 🇸🇮 | #NationsLeague 🇪🇺 pic.twitter.com/rjEdMyyYGO.
Debutants Robbie Ure and Stephen Welsh are each poised for their first international cap. Billy Gilmour returns to the starting XI after missing the World Cup through injury and Oli McBurnie will make his first appearance for Scotland since 2021.
Sébastien Pocognoli's first Scotland starting XI 🏴#SVNSCO pic.twitter.com/JC6RGOq1QJ.
“The first game is always a special game so you have to bring the mental aspect in for the players and for the staff.
Recent findings suggest that “A good result can help but the most important thing is we see things that we work on through the week. I hope is we apply that well then we will get the result which will be the perfect mix.
“I hope we can bring a good game, and a good exciting principle on the pitch. I think we need the support from the supporters because there’s a lot of latest players.
“We need to create a good energy but it’s up to us on the pitch to create this. So then we can be hand in hand with the supporters.”.
Good afternoon and welcome to our live coverage of this UEFA Nations League B, Group 1 match as Slovenia host Scotland at Stozice Stadium in Ljubljana.
Scotland qualified for their first World Cup in 28 years this summer, but they exited the tournament with a whimper after failing to finish as one of the best third-place group sides. Steve Clarke’s men beat tournament debutants Haiti 1-0 in their opening match, before falling to defeats without scoring against Morocco and Brazil.
Following the World Cup, Clarke stepped down as Scotland’s head coach, ending a seven-year tenure, and was replaced by Belgian manager Sebastien Pocognoli. The former Monaco boss will take charge of his first game in his fresh role today and will be itching to make an encouraging start in a new era for Scottish football.
Over this extended international break, Pocognoli’s side will also face Switzerland and North Macedonia, as well as a return fixture against Slovenia in Scotland on October 6 to round off a busy period.
While Scotland took part in the World Cup, Slovenia were reflecting on their hugely disappointing qualification performance, where they finished third in their group behind Switzerland and Kosovo without winning and netting just three goals across six matches.
Manchester United striker Benjamin Sesko – Slovenia’s star man and most well-known player – withdrew from Bostjan Cesar’s squad earlier this week after the recurrence of a shin injury caused the 23-year-old to completely miss the 1-1 draw against Fulham last Sunday.
Scotland have a few notable absences, with Scott McTominay, Che Adams and Lawrence Shankland all unavailable, but Billy Gilmour returns to the fold after missing the World Cup through injury, Oli McBurnie has been recalled and Sevilla striker Robbie Ure has received his first senior call-up.
Kick-off is at 14:00, with team news coming shortly.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (235 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Recent findings suggest that fikayo Tomori suffered a thigh tear against Bologna, and AC Milan are awaiting updates about his recovery. However, some good news has arrived.
The international break couldn’t have come at a better time for Tomori. It allows him to recover at Milanello without missing valuable training time with the team. Given 13 players have been called up this week, he’s hardly in a ‘proper’ environment right now.
Read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
So, it allows him the chance to work and potentially return at the same time as many of his teammates.
Sources indicate that this morning, MilanNews have provided an enhancement on Tomori’s injury, with the defender working at Milanello on recovery. In fact, he’s progressing well and ‘key news’ regarding his return is expected in the upcoming days.
Industry observers note that another check-up is scheduled for early next week to assess the progress of the injury recovery, and if that goes smoothly, he could begin training on the pitch again. It is possible, therefore, that he could be back on the pitch against Frosinone on November 22.
Given the shortness at the back, Ruben Amorim will have to balance the need to have him back and his ability to offer minutes. He can’t be rushed back, especially with the risk of worsening the injury.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 4 min read (865 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Tony Mowbray has stepped down as Blackburn Rovers head coach due to health issues, and the hunt for his replacement has begun at Ewood Park.
Just a couple of years after stepping down as the head coach of Birmingham City to battle bowel cancer, Mowbray has had to make the unfortunate decision to step down from his role as Blackburn boss due to health issues.
Mowbray issued a heartfelt message to Rovers supporters upon the announcement of his resignation, which can only be described as an incredibly difficult situation for everyone involved, as we at Football League World wish him the best.
Blackburn travel down the road to Burnley next for an enthralling encounter at Turf Moor, with Damien Johnson and Mike Dodds taking charge of first-team duties until a newly introduced head coach can be appointed.
As the hunt for a upcoming boss begins, FLW has taken a look at five potential candidates who could realistically assume control at Ewood Park next.
Former Irish forward Damien Duff began his coaching career with Shamrock Rovers in his native country before working as an assistant coach for both Celtic and the Republic of Ireland men's national team.
He took his first steps as a head coach with Shelbourne in 2021, spending three and a half years in charge of the club and guiding them to a first league title in 18 years in 2024.
Duff, who made 220 appearances for Blackburn during his playing career, more than any other club he represented, joined Keith Andrews' coaching staff at Brentford in the summer of 2026, but would surely be tempted by the Blackburn job.
Someone who knows the club inside and out and can seamlessly take the wheel from Mowbray, Duff could be an excellent fit for Blackburn, and simply must be considered.
Austrian coach Gerhard Struber began his career on the touchline in his native country with RB Salzburg, their feeder club, FC Liefering, before joining Wolfsberger and then Barnsley in November 2019.
He would help to keep the Tykes in the Championship in dramatic fashion before leaving Oakwell for the Substantial Apple with Latest York Red Bulls just 11 months later, as spells back in Salzburg and then FC Köln preceded his move to Bristol City in the summer of 2025.
After starting bright at Ashton Gate, things rapidly derailed, and he was dismissed in March 2026; he has been out of work since, and though likely not a standout candidate for the Blackburn job, he would certainly make for an interesting pick, to say the least.
A name that will be well-known to supporters of Middlesbrough, Nottingham Forest, and Birmingham City, Aitor Karanka is a fairly left-field suggestion, though his connection with Blackburn's current Head of Football Operations, Rudy Gestede, makes him an interesting candidate.
The Spaniard helped to guide Middlesbrough to the top flight in 2016, as spells with Forest, Birmingham, Granada, and Maccabi Tel Aviv followed, where he now works as a Director of Development for the Spanish national team, taking that role in 2025.
Whether he would be open to a return to management at this stage, especially in the Championship, remains to be seen, but his connection with Gestede during their time together with Boro makes him an interesting candidate.
Rob Edwards is a name that will be linked with almost all Championship jobs that become available until he eventually takes on another role, having been dismissed from his post at Wolverhampton Wanderers unexpectedly over the summer.
The Welshman has spent time in charge of the likes of Forest Green Rovers, Watford, Luton Town, Middlesbrough, and Wolves throughout his coaching career, helping to guide Luton to the Premier League in 2023, which remains his most notable achievement in the technical area at this stage.
Edwards reportedly turned down the opportunity to take the Burnley job over the summer, and should he decide that Ewood Park is his next destination, he will almost immediately have the backing of Rovers supporters for his previous decision to reject the Clarets.
Having taken charge of Luton in November 2022 before guiding them to the top flight, Edwards has the opportunity to do the same with Blackburn, and his name will surely be touted for the position.
What do you make of Mowbray's decision to step down? Who would you like to see in charge of Blackburn following this news? Share your thoughts below!
David Wagner is a name that will put a smile on the faces of many Huddersfield Town supporters, having guided the Terriers to a historic promotion to the Premier League in 2016 before keeping them up against the odds the following campaign.
The German, who was the best man to Jürgen Klopp at the former Liverpool boss' wedding, would spend time with Schalke and Young Boys after Huddersfield before landing at Norwich City in January 2023, helping the Canaries to the Championship play-offs in 2024 before missing out to Leeds United.
He left shortly after the defeat and has been an academy manager at RB Leipzig since 2025, but with an excellent record in the Championship, he would make an interesting candidate and one Blackburn must consider.
📅 16 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (456 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

The Argentinian defender has also apologized to the United higher ups as well over his comments, as shared by Fabrizio Romano.
Lisandro Martinez has held discussions with Jason Wilcox and Michael Carrick after speaking out following United’s 2-0 defeat to Atletico Madrid.
Martinez had questioned whether Carrick was backed enough in the summer and suggested the club needed changes.
Fabrizio Romano has now confirmed that United consider the matter resolved for now and expect Martinez to remain available for selection.
Speaking about the situation on his YouTube channel, as quoted by Football 365, Romano explained why Martinez’s comments caused concern inside the club.
Industry observers note that “He spoke very strongly after the game against Atletico Madrid, which Man Utd lost. It was a very negative moment for the Red Devils. We know that Licha was very strong in his comments. He said that Michael Carrick was not backed enough during the summer transfer window.”.
Romano added that Martinez had spoken directly to those at the club after the incident.
“Licha apologised to Man Utd as a club. He spoke to the directors, he spoke to Jason Wilcox, and he spoke to Michael Carrick, who was also involved in this conversation.”.
Recent findings suggest that “So, the underlying message remains the same. Lisandro is apologising for the way he expressed himself after a game during a difficult moment for Man Utd, but there was a discussion about the substance of what he stated.”.
Sources indicate that romano also revealed that United had imposed a financial penalty on the centre-back. However, the punishment does not appear to involve removing him from the squad.
“According to the information available tonight, Lisandro Martinez has been fined.”.
He added that Martinez is expected to return to the squad as normal, with the fine considered sufficient punishment for the incident.
Recent findings suggest that “The internal discussion also helped to resolve all the concerns. For Man Utd, the case is closed.”.
That should bring some immediate clarity to the situation, although questions remain about how the episode could affect Martinez’s longer-term position at Old Trafford.
Romano also pointed towards Martinez’s contract, which expires next summer, with United holding an option to extend it.
“So, let’s see what is going to happen there. For sure, this is the kind of situation that will have an impact on the situation surrounding Lisandro, but we have to see what happens next in terms of future transfers and everything else.”.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 16 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (372 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Lisandro Martinez could return to Manchester United’s starting line-up against Leeds United this weekend, with the defender reportedly available for selection after the controversy surrounding his comments about the club’s summer transfer business.
According to recent reports, TEAMtalk transfer insider Graeme Bailey has suggested Michael Carrick could bring the Argentine straight back into the team for the trip to Elland Road. The fixture is expected to be a hostile occasion, making Martinez’s potential involvement an interesting one.
“I am told that Martinez is available for selection this weekend, and there is every chance Michael Carrick starts him,” Bailey said.
The defender recently found himself in trouble after questioning whether Manchester United had done enough in the summer transfer window. He apologised to the club’s hierarchy and was fined, but the incident has not apparently created a divide between him and the manager.
Bailey also dismissed suggestions that Martinez’s comments were an attack on Michael Carrick, insisting the defender and his teammates continue to support the head coach.
Recent findings suggest that “Martinez was not critical of Carrick – far from it. This isn’t a repeat of something like Mo Salah criticising Arne Slot last season. It is almost the opposite.”.
Sources indicate that according to Bailey, the United dressing room remains firmly behind Carrick despite the team’s disappointing start to the campaign. Senior players reportedly believe the current manager is still the right person to lead the team, rather than bringing in another face to replace him.
It has been revealed that “Martinez and the squad are 100% behind Carrick. They know there is pressure after a poor start to the season, but they do not want to see a change.”.
Bailey went on to suggest that the fallout may have strengthened the bond between the players and their manager.
“Martinez and the senior players firmly believe nobody can come in and do a better job than Carrick. If anything, this has brought the group closer together.”.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 17 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (461 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Leeds United welcome Manchester United to Elland Road on Sunday, with both sides looking to put a difficult run of results behind them and get their Premier League season on track.
Leeds United suffered a 2-1 defeat away to Arsenal last weekend despite James Justin scoring to put them in front in the 55th minute.
Manchester United also dropped points in the Premier League, drawing 1-1 with Tottenham, before losing 2-0 to Atletico Madrid in the Champions League away from home.
It has been revealed that michael Carrick’s side have struggled to find consistency in recent weeks and have come under immense pressure to get in results. The Whites meanwhile will hope that home advantage can make the difference when United face their bitter rivals on Elland Road.
Leeds have recorded one win, two draws and two defeats in their last five matches in all competitions. Their best result came against Newcastle, where they won, but a 6-3 defeat to Chelsea in the Carabao Cup and the loss to Arsenal have left them searching for a response.
According to recent reports, manchester United have also won just once in their last five matches. Their 4-0 Champions League victory over Sabah FK was the only comfortable win, but defeats to Manchester City and Atletico Madrid, alongside draws against Fulham and Tottenham, have raised questions about their form and Michael Carrick.
Leeds are waiting on Dan James, who returned from international duty with a back problem and missed the Arsenal game. Joe Rodon remains sidelined with a hamstring injury and is not expected back in full training until next month. Harry Wilson could return after being an unused substitute last weekend. Mateo Joseph is also among Leeds’ absentees.
Manchester United have their own concerns. Luke Shaw and Kobbie Mainoo are doubts after picking up concerns against Tottenham and missing Tuesday’s trip to Madrid. Benjamin Sesko remains unavailable with a recurring shin problem, while Patrick Dorgu is expected to be out until late November. Manuel Ugarte is recovering from knee surgery, and Noussair Mazraoui is a doubt with a back problem.
There is better news regarding Matthijs de Ligt, who could return to contention. Leny Yoro is also available for selection despite his Champions League suspension.
Industry observers note that the match takes place at Elland Road on Sunday, October 18. Kick-off is scheduled for 2 pm BST (1pm GMT).
UK viewers can watch the game live on Sky Sports Main Event, with coverage beginning at 1 pm BST.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 5 min read (983 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Swansea City fans were rocked by the news on Monday night that Vitor Matos was being looked at by Ligue 1 club Strasbourg, with pressure mounting on current manager Hugo Oliveira.
The Portuguese boss was recently linked with the Crystal Palace post, but after Swansea's form dipped with four defeats in five, and the Eagles appointed Thomas Frank to replace Pierre Sage, Swans supporters felt they'd be able to appreciate Matos a little longer.
Strasbourg's official approach to Matos indicates that the drop in form in the league hasn't impacted his standing amongst managerial circles, and the Ligue 1 side, who are sitting 13th with just three wins from 10, are keen on bringing him in if they pull the trigger on Oliveira.
It's not an ideal scenario for any club to be in, but after a strong start to the Championship campaign, with the South Wales side sitting sixth after 15 games, Swansea will need to act fast to bring someone fresh in if Matos decides to leave.
These four coaches should be in line to take the reins.
With Swansea's recruitment drive shifting to more of a project-based outcome in the summer, following their partnership with Tony Bloom-led Jamestown Analytics, there could be a more project-heavy hire in the dugout if Matos departs.
However, if the Swans want to keep the momentum from the first 15 games high and hire someone set to continue this promotion push immediately, Carlos Corberan should be right at the top of their list.
The Spaniard has been out of work since leaving Valencia in September. He's helped his boyhood club improve after slow starts and secure a mid-table finish in 2024/25 and 2025/26, and in the Championship, he forged a reputation as one of the better coaches in the division with both Huddersfield Town and West Brom.
Corberan took both of those to the play-offs, despite them being rather worse for wear beforehand, and at the Hawthorns, especially, had his sides playing some of the best football in the division, per the underlying numbers.
There's still plenty of room to improve in this Swansea squad, despite their position, and Corberan could be the missing piece to do so. Plus, the 43-year-old could finally become a Premier League boss in South Wales, something which has eluded him so far in his career.
Perhaps not the most popular choice among the four, but Steve Cooper was the last manager to oversee something close to a successful period at Swansea, finishing in the top six in consecutive seasons between 2019 and 2021.
According to recent reports, since then, the Swans haven't finished any higher than 10th. No parachute payments have helped, but perhaps the numerous changes in managers haven't either.
Recent findings suggest that swansea fans weren't totally enamoured with the football being played; others were totally fine with it. What's crucial, though, is that it brought about results at this level, and for a Swans side who want to maintain this play-off finish, bringing in someone who hasn't finished below the top six at this level wouldn't be a bad decision.
Cooper knows how to come in midway through a campaign and oversee results, too, having taken Nottingham Forest from the bottom of the division to play-off success in the space of eight months.
The task isn't as drastic back in South Wales, so he should be able to achieve some success.
In Matos, Swansea found success with a young, up-and-coming coach from a foreign league. Perhaps they could do so again, but this time with a name they know all too well from his time as a player in South Wales.
What Pablo Hernandez is doing in his first managerial role with boyhood club Castellón in the Spanish second tier is massively going under the radar.
He took over as interim boss in September last year, oversaw their best finish in nearly 20 years, and now has them second with nine wins in 13 games. They've conceded just five goals, which is quite remarkable, and they could be on their way to La Liga for the first time since the 1990/91 campaign.
The 41-year-old already has that connection with Swansea, spending two seasons there as a player and helping them win the EFL Cup in 2013, so he knows what it's like for the South Wales side to be in the top flight and competing regularly.
It may be difficult to persuade him to leave this project at his boyhood club, but the possibility of helping bring a team back to the Premier League could be tempting enough.
Another project-based manager could see Jack Wilshere make the step-up into the Championship after a year cutting his teeth in League One with Luton Town.
It has been revealed that the 34-year-old was unable to help the Hatters earn promotion in his first half-season in charge, but his side did show signs of excellence in the latter stages once things started to properly click. Luton went 12 games unbeaten to end the year, winning the EFL Trophy along the way.
Recent findings suggest that who do you think should replace Vitor Matos if he leaves for Strasbourg, Swans fans? Let us know in the comments.
Now, this season, Wilshere has his side playing good football; the underlying numbers have them among the best teams in the division, and they currently sit fourth, five points off Stockport County in second and with a game in hand.
Swansea haven't shied away from hiring out of the third tier. They did so with Russell Martin in the summer of 2021, and that came after he'd overseen mid-table finishes at MK Dons.
Wilshere is in a much better position as a manager now, and is one of the more promising young coaches in the EFL. He has Championship potential, and Swansea could be the side to harness that.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (381 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Daniele De Rossi has looked back at Genoa’s defeat to AC Milan and how he wasn’t frustrated with his team afterwards.
Recent findings suggest that milan entered the international break with a much-needed victory against Genoa, but it wasn’t the easiest result of the season. After a disappointing defeat to Ferencvaros – which extended the midweek run of defeats – they couldn’t afford to drop points, and they succeeded, even if it wasn’t without flaw.
Recent findings suggest that with two goals inside 20 minutes, you’d be forgiven for expecting Milan to win by more than a couple. However, that was the end of their goalscoring for the afternoon and although Genoa pulled one back, they didn’t grab more than a consolation goal.
Speaking to Sky Sport – in the latest series ‘Radici’ – De Rossi looked back on the defeat to the Rossoneri, as well as a comment that stuck with him from Diego Moreira, as MilanPress have relayed today.
We indeed lost against Milan, but we lost ‘well.’ We didn’t deserve it. Three or four weeks ago, the latest results seemed like a pipe dream. I thank the players, staff, and my club for giving me faith and patience at a time when other clubs wouldn’t have had it.
“They remembered how good we did last year. I’m happy to have emerged from a difficult period and to be Genoa’s coach; I’m really happy there.”.
Industry observers note that “I’m passionate about the fans and the supporters. I’m part of a club that, in terms of fan base, is among the best in Europe. I’m passionate; I don’t punch a clock. I spend two hours with the stockman or the waitress with the same enthusiasm I spend time with the team captain. Experiencing it like that, you realise that Genoa is a great team.
“Genoa is full of Genoese fans who remind you every second how much they love their club, the pride of being the top club in Italy. The architecture of the stadium and the warmth of the fans… I’m not saying this to be a sycophant, but on Sunday Moreira came to me and mentioned, ‘I’ve never seen anything like this here in Italy.’ It’s a reality that even our opponents notice.”.
📅 18 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (384 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Leeds United welcome Manchester United to Elland Road on Sunday, with both sides looking to put a difficult run of results behind them and get their Premier League season on track.
Leeds United suffered a 2-1 defeat away to Arsenal last weekend. Manchester United also dropped points in the Premier League, drawing 1-1 with Tottenham, before losing 2-0 to Atletico Madrid in the Champions League away from home.
It has been revealed that michael Carrick’s side have struggled to find consistency in recent weeks and have come under immense pressure to get in results. The Whites meanwhile will hope that home advantage can make the difference when United face their bitter rivals on Elland Road.
Michael Carrick has made his selection for the trip to Elland Road, with Matheus Cunha the notable name left out of the starting XI. Lisandro Martinez starts alongside Maguire despite an explosive rant against the club hierarchy after the Champions League loss to Atletico Madrid.
Senne Lammens starts in goal, with Leny Yoro, Harry Maguire, Lisandro Martinez and Diogo Dalot named in defence.
Andrey Santos and Carlos Baleba will feature in midfield, while Bruno Fernandes and Youri Tielemans start together again.
Amad Diallo and Bryan Mbeumo complete the starting lineup, with Carrick opting for Bruno Fernandes to start on the left wing and Tielemans in the no. 10 role.
Lammens; Yoro, Maguire, Martinez, Dalot; Santos, Baleba, Bruno Fernandes, Tielemans; Amad, Mbeumo.
Cunha’s absence from the starting lineup is the main talking point ahead of kick-off. The Brazilian has been left out as Carrick makes changes for a match United badly need to win. Noussair Mazraoui also returns to the bench after recovering from the injury he picked up during the international break.
In a recent development, united have struggled to put together a consistent run of results, and Sunday’s derby presents another test for Carrick. With Leeds also looking to respond after their defeat to Arsenal, United will need a strong performance to leave Elland Road with all three points.
Recent findings suggest that shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 28 Jun 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (255 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readchelsea

Chelsea’s wide-player search has moved back into focus after the Guardian reported that the club are monitoring West Ham pair Jarrod Bowen and Crysencio Summerville.
The upgrade lands during a busy early market for Xabi Alonso’s incoming rebuild.
The Guardian’s latest transfer round-up states that Chelsea like both West Ham forwards, while an earlier report noted Chelsea and Manchester United had tracked Summerville.
That same earlier update also said Aston Villa, Chelsea and Everton had expressed interest in Bowen.
According to recent reports, west Ham pulling away at Stamford Bridge 👀Jarrod Bowen stuns Chelsea early before Crysencio Summerville doubles the lead. pic.twitter.com/Ktwr4pKZGH.
Alonso officially begins work on July 1, with Chelsea confirming he has signed a four-year contract to lead the men’s team.
Industry observers note that the winger search is not just about adding more attacking names. It is about identifying profiles who can rapidly give Chelsea sharper final-third decisions.
Bowen would offer immediate Premier League output, penalty-box timing and a direct threat from the right.
Summerville, meanwhile, fits the younger, explosive one-v-one profile that would sit neatly inside Alonso’s longer-term wing plan.
Read Chelsea has already tracked the separate Summerville angle, but this latest dual link sharpens the picture.
Chelsea appear to be testing two different solutions to the same problem: proven reliability or higher-upside acceleration.
With pre-season closing in, that is exactly the sort of market check Alonso needs before deciding how much of Chelsea’s attacking rebuild should lean on speed, touchline width and more ruthless wide output.
📅 18 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (440 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

In a recent development, manchester United had a difficult evening once again as they were held to a 1-1 draw at Leeds United. Pressure mounts on Michael Carrick as United have just 7 points from 7 games.
Industry observers note that manchester United took the lead through Bryan Mbeumo in the first half, with the forward finishing Youri Tielemans’ excellent cross from the right. However, the visitors couldn’t hold on to their advantage as Dominic Calvert-Lewin equalised for Leeds United from a corner.
The draw extended United’s frustrating run of results, leaving Michael Carrick still searching for the consistency his side need.
Carragher, though, believes there were positives to take from the trip, particularly one performance at the back.
Jamie Carragher has singled out Harry Maguire for praise after Manchester United drew 1-1 with Leeds United at Elland Road on Sunday.
Speaking on Sky Sports, the former Liverpool defender admitted that picking up a point at Elland Road was not necessarily a bad result in isolation, even if United’s recent form made it feel like a missed opportunity.
“Going away to Leeds is going to be tricky for any team except for Manchester City and Arsenal at the moment,” Carragher said.
“A lot of teams will take a point at Leeds this season but the problem for Manchester United is the results have been so poor that they need to start winning games so it almost feels like two points dropped.”.
Carragher then turned his attention to Maguire, who he felt played a major role in keeping United in the game when Leeds began to push for a winner.
According to recent reports, “But in isolation, getting a point at Leeds is a decent result. I thought Harry Maguire was fantastic, especially in the second half.”.
Leeds United grew into the contest after Calvert-Lewin brought them level, putting United under pressure during the closing stages. Carragher felt Maguire’s efforts in defence helped prevent the visitors from falling apart.
Industry observers note that “After Leeds got that goal back there was a stage of the game where it felt like Man United could go under, but Maguire at the back held it together for them. He was fantastic.”.
The result may feel like another opportunity missed for Carrick, but Maguire’s performance gave United something positive to take away from Elland Road.
It has been revealed that shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (654 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

Bolton Wanderers have had a rollercoaster first third of the campaign upon their return to the Championship, and though the Trotters have impressed at the top end of the pitch, a lot has been left to desire at the back.
Bolton, following their return to the Championship for the first time since 2019, endured an incredibly busy summer transfer window orchestrated by head coach Steven Schumacher, with as many as 13 fresh arrivals heading to the Toughsheet Community Stadium.
Among those was an almost entirely newly introduced forward line, as the likes of Jayden Nelson, Ryan Hardie, Thelonius Bair, Kylianne Dong, and Samuel Iling-Junior joined the club.
Sources indicate that bolton have hit 20 goals in 15 league matches so far - a steady record. However, with 29 shipped in the other direction, improvements must be made at the back, as an EFL expert has shared their thoughts on the situation.
Former West Bromwich Albion, Sunderland, and Wolverhampton Wanderers striker Don Goodman has delved into punditry since his retirement from professional football, and has garnered a reputation as an expert on everything in the EFL.
The 60-year-old is not afraid to say exactly what he thinks about the ongoing situations at clubs across the 72, and has shared his thoughts and concerns right now at Bolton, saying: "If you go to watch Bolton Wanderers, you know you're in for a terrific match.
They have been all season. They're a great watch.
"I suspect Steven Schumacher wants them to be entertaining, but here's the issue. They are conceding way too many goals. That will prove costly over a 46-game season.
"They've conceded 29 goals in 15 games. That's almost two goals a game. It means you have to score three goals to win a match. That might happen occasionally, like when they won 4–3 away at Norwich, but it's rare you can rely on scoring three every week.
"They have to become harder to score against. If they don't, I fear they could end up straight back in League One. They're great fun to watch, but they must tighten up defensively.".
Only the bottom three of Preston North End, Burnley, and Derby County have shipped more goals than Bolton at this stage of the season, as it has become crystal clear exactly where Steven Schumacher's side needs to address if they are to be successful this year.
Despite this, only Stoke City, Sheffield United, Birmingham City and Swansea City have kept more clean sheets than the Trotters' four after 15 games, as when Bolton concede, it tends to come in waves.
They have conceded three or more goals in seven games this season, as Schumacher simply must find a way to keep the scoreline to a minimum if his side is to pick up enough points for survival come the end of the campaign.
A seven-point buffer separates them from the relegation zone right now, but it could take just a couple of weeks for that to change, as Bolton cannot afford to continue to ship goals at the rate they have been.
Recent findings suggest that what have you made of Bolton Wanderers this season? Is Don Goodman's assessment of the Trotters correct? Share your thoughts below!
Schumacher has worked his way up the league to establish himself as one of the best young coaches in the EFL, having earned promotion to the Championship with Plymouth Argyle and Bolton, whilst keeping Stoke afloat in the second tier against the odds.
Now, he must try and establish the Trotters back in the second tier after seven years away, and whilst on track to do just that as things stand, if the defensive record doesn't improve sooner rather than later, he runs the risk of slipping down the table.
Goodman's warning must be taken into account by Schumacher, who should use the recent international break as an opportunity to do just that.
📅 28 Jun 2026 | ⏱️ 1 min read (206 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readchelsea

Ecuador’s late World Cup surge has given Chelsea a useful development signal through Moises Caicedo and Kendry Paez before Xabi Alonso’s first pre-season friendly on 28 July.
Chelsea confirmed that Caicedo and Paez reached the Round of 32 after Ecuador’s dramatic 2-1 win over Germany.
For Alonso, the contrast between the two Chelsea midfielders matters as much as the result.
Caicedo captained Ecuador through the pressure game, with We Ain’t Got No History highlighting the Chelsea midfielder’s leadership role in a win that rescued their tournament.
Paez, meanwhile, sits in a different phase of his rise.
According to recent reports, that should not worry Chelsea. FIFA identified Paez as one of the tournament’s wonderkids, but Chelsea’s bigger win is that he can absorb elite-tournament preparation without carrying a defining role too soon.
Read Chelsea has already looked at how Alonso must handle Paez’s development curve, and this knockout place sharpens that argument.
Alonso inherits a midfield loaded with senior names, transfer noise and immediate pressure.
In a recent development, caicedo gives Chelsea the proven pillar. Paez gives them the controlled upside.
Ecuador’s run now gives Chelsea both at once.
For Chelsea, that is the ideal succession picture: leadership today, patience for tomorrow.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (321 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

AC Milan are expected to hire Markus Krösche in the next few weeks, and a report has looked a little more at his work today.
Recent findings suggest that between Eintracht Frankfurt and Milan, there are plenty of differences. From the finances available to how they’re spent, even to the way in which the structure of the club ticks over. So, Krösche will have to learn with the Rossoneri.
Industry observers note that read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
However, it won’t be a one way street, with the Diavolo needing to learn plenty too.
As Gazzetta dello Sport writes, Krösche methods are very linear; it’s about arriving and leaving at the right time, having the knowledge to enter and the courage to step away when the time is right.
His belief is that the club will always hold more weight than the manager, which has been shown in the past few months by Gerry Cardinale and there is no shortage of exciting signings on his CV.
What is also worth remembering is that he’s not one to step away from his methods. In 2022, he was given a chance to sign Cristiano Ronaldo. However, it didn’t make sense for him or Frankfurt, so they never made their move.
If it happens his way, Timmo Hardung will arrive alongside the German. The pair met at RB Leipzig and their relationship has only grown since then and Krösche eventually led a team of 70 people at Frankfurt. In other words, he won’t be out of place at the top of the Milan football organisation.
Industry observers note that gazzetta even suggests that it’s ‘no secret’ that his desire is to move to Italy to work under Krösche once again. Given their successes together, it makes sense why all parties are hoping to keep that relationship under the same roof.
📅 28 Jun 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (650 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readchelsea

Chelsea’s World Cup contingent has moved from a group-stage watchlist into a genuine Xabi Alonso planning problem.
Chelsea’s own tournament enhancement confirms that Enzo Fernandez, Mike Penders, Moises Caicedo, Kendry Paez, Malo Gusto and Jorrel Hato have reached the Round of 32.
England have also progressed after their final Group L win over Panama, which keeps Reece James and Trevoh Chalobah inside the wider knockout picture.
Industry observers note that for supporters, that is a status marker. For Alonso, it is where summer pride starts to become pre-season compression.
The concern is not simply volume. It is where the minutes are landing.
Enzo has not missed a minute for Argentina, while Caicedo has remained central for Ecuador and captained them in the 2-1 win over Germany.
Those are not fringe workloads. They are the two midfield profiles Chelsea have built large parts of their control game around.
Alonso’s first Chelsea pre-season was always going to demand clarity through the middle of the pitch.
Instead, the players most central to that reset are still operating in knockout football.
Industry observers note that caicedo’s Ecuador role is the cleanest example. Read Chelsea has already assessed how his captaincy display against Germany strengthened his leadership case, but the next layer is more complicated.
Every additional knockout tie gives him more tournament rhythm, more authority and more fatigue.
Enzo brings a different tension.
Argentina’s route against Cape Verde keeps him on a glamorous stage at exactly the moment Chelsea need to settle his role, mood and tactical responsibilities under Alonso.
If Madrid-related noise continues around him, the club cannot afford a sluggish July handover.
Then there is the defensive side.
Reece James started England’s first two matches before a hamstring issue ruled him out of the Panama game, according to the Guardian.
England still topped the group and moved into a last-32 tie with DR Congo, but James’ situation is exactly the kind of detail Chelsea’s medical team will monitor closely.
Chelsea have already had to plan around a large World Cup group.
The broader concern was clear in Read Chelsea’s earlier pre-season workload piece, but the knockout stage sharpens it because the returns will now be staggered.
Enzo brings a maximum group-stage load. Caicedo brings captaincy responsibility and heavy Ecuador minutes.
James brings knockout qualification mixed with another hamstring-management question.
Gusto and Hato remain tied to France and the Netherlands, while Penders and Paez are still absorbing tournament environments before club reintegration.
That is a spine glitch, not a fringe issue.
Alonso needs automatisms in possession, spacing around the double pivot, clearer full-back behaviour and pressing triggers from midfield.
Those details do not bed in properly when key players arrive in drips after a major summer tournament.
Players returning from knockout football can bring competitive sharpness that closed-door friendlies cannot replicate.
Industry observers note that caicedo captaining Ecuador through pressure games matters. Enzo playing high-leverage minutes for Argentina matters.
Gusto and Hato absorbing tournament detail also helps Chelsea’s defensive reset.
But Chelsea cannot treat every tournament minute as clean preparation.
Alonso must decide who returns straight into tactical work, who needs a genuine pause and who can handle August without creating an avoidable injury bill by September.
That is where the James situation feels central.
If Chelsea’s captain carries a World Cup hamstring warning, the club’s right-sided structure becomes more than a selection debate.
It becomes an availability question that touches Gusto, the wider defensive rebuild and the need for control from midfield.
Read Chelsea has already looked at James’ captaincy test under Alonso, and the injury layer now makes that test sharper.
This is the hidden cost of a strong international footprint.
Chelsea want players good enough to survive deep into tournaments.
Alonso now has to make sure that status does not leave his first league weeks short of the very control those players are meant to provide.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 6 min read (1109 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

By JOHN MCGARRY, SCOTTISH CHIEF SPORTS FEATURE WRITER.
Published: 17:42 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 18:03 EST, 14 November 2026.
Amid the clamour for a change at the helm following another poor showing at a major tournament, it was easy to lose sight of the reality of the situation.
Steve Clarke didn’t crash and burn in the US because a raft of world-class talents failed to turn up on the biggest stage. It happened primarily because a limited squad was unable to outperform two top-ten nations in Brazil and Morocco who could call upon infinitely superior footballers.
Sebastian Pocognoli has since arrived on the scene having earned a stellar reputation from his title success with Union Saint-Gilloise and his less feted spell at Monaco. But he has not come armed with a magic wand.
In opening the door to a string of fresh faces and advocating the more attacking approach which so many craved, the turbulence he’s experienced to date should only have been expected.
Limited by both the standard of players who are eligible for Scotland and the time he has to work with them, only the blissfully naïve would have seen his appointment as a quick fix.
While there were some positives to be taken from the game with North Macedonia – primarily the result – it’s likely the nation will have to endure more short-term pain for long-term gain.
Scotland boss Sebastien Pocognoli greets his players after a satisfactory evening at Hampden.
This was always going to take time, perhaps, in the view of John McGinn, more than many may have imagined.
Sources indicate that ‘The manager’s got a great reputation, a good record at both places he’s been,’ said the Aston Villa captain. ‘The most key thing now in football is individuals don’t win you games. It’s unity, teamwork and everyone being on the same page.
It has been revealed that ‘You see how successful clubs and successful countries do it. And we want to be one of them.
‘It’s not going to happen overnight. There’s a lot to learn but we did create significant chances against North Macedonia where we could have scored three, four or five and it could be a different story.
Sources indicate that ‘But this isn’t something that gets fixed in March or even next September. It will start to build over the next 18 months.’.
Sources indicate that if that predicted time frame might raise an eyebrow or two, McGinn makes no apology for it. Call it managing expectations from the midfielder if you please. But without a degree of patience from the Tartan Army, he feels Pocognoli’s ideas won’t take root.
‘I understand it’s frustrating,’ he added. ‘It’s freezing and you want to see four, five, six goals, but the balance has got to be there.
McGinn sends his penalty home to give Scotland a deserved lead against North Macedonia.
‘They’re entitled to their opinion, but there’s got to be a mixture of patience.
‘The supporters are entitled to say whatever they like. But just as long as they hurl anything they want to shout at the experienced boys and just let the young ones flourish and try and settle into the team.’.
Sources indicate that give credit where it’s due. With Clarke accused of causing stagnation by selecting the same old faces, Pocognoli has capped five players for the first time while recalling the likes of Oli McBurnie.
The sages in the stands can’t have it both ways. If the squad was going to evolve, it was never going to be a smooth ride.
Industry observers note that ‘I think the young players are starting to show more now,’ McGinn stressed. ‘Luke Graham on Friday night, I thought he was brilliant. It’s not easy playing in the middle of a back three. He’s been waiting for his chance and the manager’s shown that if you deserve your chance you’re going to get put in there.
Industry observers note that ‘We’ve got so many players that can step up and they will. We just need to show that belief and take it to the pitch.’.
Even in victory, McGinn doesn’t dispute that there is significant scope for improvement. He’s convinced, however, that this will all come good in the end.
McGinn insists it's vital the entire Scotland squad buy into the methods of manager Pocognoli.
According to recent reports, ‘We need to play slightly better,’ he said. ‘We know that, but we’re going through a period which I’ve been used to at club level, a lot of changes, a lot of detail that we need to try and remember and get used to.
‘And it’s about sticking at it. We’re keen to play a style of football that’s not easy but is going to get bums off seats. It’s important that everyone believes in it because if one person drops off or doesn’t believe in it, that’s when it all starts to fall apart.’.
Industry observers note that friday was another memorable night on a personal level for McGinn. Having broken the tension with the opener only to see North Macedonia level, he held his nerve to put Scotland back from the penalty spot.
The brace put him on 24 international goals, now within six of Denis Law and Kenny Dalglish. But all of that is for another day.
It has been revealed that ‘It feels a bit strange, but at the minute that’s gone to the back burner,’ he stressed. ‘I had a wee chat with Scott (McTominay) about the penalties. I was designated penalty taker but, to be fair, he’s not missed one I don’t think in his career.
‘So, we had a wee chat and I think we both mentioned the most key thing was just no matter who hit it, hit the back of the net.’.
McGinn is eyeing three points against Switzerland in St Gallen to close the campaign on a high.
Recent findings suggest that tomorrow, the equation is clear. To finish second in the Nations League group and secure a place in pot two for the Euro draw, Scotland must beat the Swiss and hope that Slovenia don’t beat North Macedonia.
Even if everything clicks for Pocognoli’s side, it will be the tallest of orders.
‘Difficult,’ remarked McGinn. ‘I know they drew on Friday night (with Slovenia) but they’ve got a couple of players back that they were missing last time.
Industry observers note that ‘It is a tough one but we want to be competing against these teams away from home. It’s not going to be perfect for a while, but we’ll stick at it.’.
📅 19 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (459 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Manchester United travel to Italy on Wednesday, looking for their first win since September 10, when they face Como in the Champions League.
Recent findings suggest that michael Carrick’s side have struggled to build any momentum this season. Sunday’s 1-1 draw against Leeds extended their winless run to six matches in all competitions, leaving United with just seven points from their opening seven Premier League games.
The pressure on Carrick continues to grow. A win in Europe would offer some relief, but Como will not make life easy for Manchester United.
According to recent reports, manchester United began their Champions League campaign with a convincing 4-0 win over Sabah FK but lost 2-0 to Atletico Madrid in their next match. They have since drawn with Leeds, having also failed to beat Fulham and Tottenham in the Premier League.
Their last six matches across all competitions have produced three draws and three defeats. Michael Carrick is in pressure of his own and needs a response from his players, particularly with United sitting 13th in the Premier League and 13th in the Champions League standings.
It has been revealed that como have shown more promise. Cesc Fabregas’ side beat RB Leipzig 4-1 in Europe before losing 3-2 to Feyenoord. They returned to winning ways against Fiorentina, claiming a 3-1 victory that moved them up to fifth in Serie A, with 14 points from seven games.
Como have scored 11 goals and conceded eight across their last six matches in all competitions. United have struggled, with their only clean sheet of the season coming against Sabah FK.
In a recent development, united have several confirmed absentees ahead of the trip to Italy. Patrick Dorgu, Manuel Ugarte and Benjamin Sesko are ruled out, while Leny Yoro is suspended for the European fixture after picking a red against Atletico Madrid.
Recent findings suggest that lisandro Martinez is a major concern after coming off at half-time against Leeds with a thigh problem. Ayden Heaven, Luke Shaw and Kobbie Mainoo are all doubtful for the game.
Como will be without Assane Diao, who is sidelined with a thigh injury. Moise Kean has a shin problem and is a doubt, while Trevoh Chalobah is also a fitness concern with a muscular issue.
The match takes place at the Stadio Giuseppe Sinigaglia on Wednesday, October 21, with kick-off at 5:45 pm BST.
UK viewers can watch the Champions League fixture live on TNT Sports 2 and HBO Max.
It has been revealed that shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 28 Jun 2026 | ⏱️ 4 min read (766 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readchelsea

Sources indicate that malo Gusto’s World Cup has suddenly become more than a France subplot for Chelsea. It is now a live assessment of whether Xabi Alonso inherits a right-back worth protecting, reshaping or trading at the peak of his market.
Industry observers note that chelsea’s own interview with Gusto this week underlined the human part of that equation. The 23-year-old spoke about learning from N’Golo Kante, calling the former Blue one of the best midfielders France have produced and stressing the value of his example on and off the pitch.
It has been revealed that that matters because Kante is not just a nostalgic reference point. He remains the standard Chelsea supporters still use when judging humility, intensity and reliability in a high-pressure dressing room.
For Gusto, those qualities arrive at a decisive moment. Reports around the player’s future claim Chelsea value him at around £75million, with the imminent Marco Palestra deal creating a more crowded full-back picture.
That number looks aggressive, but the logic is clear. Gusto is young, capped by France, under contract, Premier League-tested and capable of playing in several defensive structures.
Sources indicate that 🚨🚨| NEW: Chelsea are open to selling Malo Gusto this summer, with his agent already in 𝐓𝐀𝐋𝐊𝐒 with Manchester City and Inter. Chelsea will only sell if their valuation is met.{@siphillipssport} pic.twitter.com/vNR2bWud9F.
In a recent development, the easiest reading of Gusto’s Kante comments is sentimental. It should not be.
For Alonso, who officially begins work on July 1, the notable detail is what those comments say about the player Chelsea have been developing.
In a recent development, gusto has not always looked completely settled at Stamford Bridge. His best games have carried thrust, speed and recovery power, while his less convincing spells have raised questions about final-ball quality and defensive concentration.
That uncertainty is exactly why the next coach matters.
Recent findings suggest that alonso’s previous teams have leaned heavily on wide players who can receive under pressure, attack space early and still protect the back line when possession breaks down. Gusto has the athletic base for that job.
The test is whether his decision-making can be refined enough to make him a structural piece rather than a rotation asset.
That is where the Kante reference lands with force. Chelsea do not need Gusto to imitate Kante’s position. They need him to absorb the same professional standard: repeat actions, clean defensive choices, no wasted emotion and total commitment to the collective rhythm.
The Marco Palestra deal changes the right side of Chelsea’s squad immediately. Read Chelsea has already examined how Palestra’s arrival offers a tactical clue over Alonso’s defensive looks, and that pressure is now sharpened by market noise around Gusto.
Chelsea can frame the situation in two ways.
Recent findings suggest that one is profit-led. If a club comes close to the reported £75million level, selling a player signed from Lyon for a much lower fee becomes a powerful PSR lever.
The other is football-led. If Alonso sees Gusto as a high-upside wing-back who fits his model, selling him just as the coaching environment becomes more suitable would carry long-term risk.
The complication is Reece James. The captain’s fitness issues, including his current England hamstring concern, mean Chelsea still need genuine right-sided depth.
Sources indicate that palestra may be part of the future, but Gusto is already part of the present. Chelsea have too often needed emergency solutions in that area to treat proven depth lightly.
According to recent reports, that is why Read Chelsea’s recent look at James awaiting hamstring scan results matters in this debate. Right-back remains one of the most talented areas of the squad, but also one of the least straightforward.
This is why Gusto’s France rhythm is more valuable than a simple tournament diary entry. Chelsea are watching a player operate inside an elite international camp, learn from a club legend and handle a public transfer valuation that can change his status overnight.
Alonso’s first decision does not have to be final, but it does have to be clear.
If Gusto stays, he needs a defined role early in pre-season and a pathway that makes sense alongside Palestra and James. If Chelsea sell, they need to do it at a number that justifies weakening one of the few squad areas where youth, speed and top-level experience already overlap.
Gusto’s Kante lesson, then, is not just a feel-good Chelsea connection. It is a reminder of the standard Alonso must demand before deciding whether £75million is a price to accept or a warning sign that Chelsea should hold firm.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 6 min read (1216 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

A York City star could be facing the threat of potential jail time for a shock incident that actually occurred on the pitch - and it's causing quite the reaction as a controversial legal battle begins to gather pace.
York finally ended their ten-year exile from the EFL in emphatic fashion at the end of the previous campaign by finishing at the summit of the National League table on 108 points and just two clear of second-placed Rochdale, who would resort to gaining promotion through the play-offs following a dramatic final-day clash for the ages between the two sides.
With the league title on the line for the victors, the encounter played out on a knife-edge at the Crown Oil Arena and 95 minutes of football were played before the deadline was broken when Emmanuel Dierseruvwe appeared to have won the contest for the hosts when he struck past York's Harrison Male.
The Ministermen only needed a point from proceedings, though, and capped off one of English football's most pulsating final-day showdowns after Josh Stones buried an all-important equaliser in the last kick of the game to shatter Rochdale hearts and take the fifth-tier title back to Yorkshire instead.
However, a major flashpoint emerged prior to Stones' leveller in the wake of Dieseruvwe's opening strike, which led Rochdale supporters to believe that they had won the affair in the very closing stages.
Dale fans promptly stormed the pitch in celebration, and in all the commotion, one of York's promotion heroes in Hiram Boateng appeared to have been pushed to the ground before retaliating in a manner that now leaves the midfielder shrouded in legal trouble.
Widely-shared social media footage at the time revealed Boateng on the floor in the wake of Rochdale's goal, with the 30-year-old having seemingly been pushed over and subsequently goaded by celebrating supporters - and pinned down on the floor, too, it has been claimed.
The scenes were unsavory to say the least, as Rochdale fans invaded the pitch to taunt and antagonise York players despite the game still having numerous minutes of additional time to be played out.
As stewards acted to break up the fracas, Boateng responded by punching a home fan, who promptly fell to the floor himself.
It was promptly disclosed afterwards that the FA would be investigating the matter, and proceedings have now been taken up a notch.
That's because a fresh report published by The Sun on Monday evening has revealed that Boateng, who has made just four appearances for Scott Lindsey's side in League Two so far this season, could face jail after being charged with a criminal offence.
The investigation has been taken to court, where Boateng has been charged with using threatening, abusive or insulting behavior with intent to cause fear of or provoke violence.
It's stated that the Crystal Palace academy product's case was heard with no pleas on Monday morning at Manchester magistrates' court, with the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) confirming the charges brought against the player in question.
Whether Boateng will actually spend time behind bars remains to be seen, of course, but the legal battle remains at large and it's caused quite the reaction from the many backers he has in his corner at York.
The former Exeter City and MK Dons star has retained the full backing of everybody at the LNER Community Stadium since the altercation, and club chairman Matt Uggla is among those to have spoken out in support of the popular midfielder.
Boateng, having joined York in the summer of 2025 following his departure from League One outfit Mansfield Town, played a leading role in the Ministermen's successful title charge during his debut campaign and has barely kicked a ball in anger this time around, with injuries limiting the well-travelled midfielder to just two fourth-tier starts.
Ironically, however, York faced Rochdale for the first time since the promotion-defining battle back in April, and with the fixture having been carried out in Greater Manchester, Lindsey's side would come out on top when Ollie Pearce scored the only goal of the game after 56 minutes, and Boateng himself was in the starting lineup.
Now, with the investigation against Boateng beginning to intensify following fresh developments, Uggla has responded to show his support and dismay at the charges being brought against the City starlet.
Speaking via his X account yesterday evening, Uggla wrote: "A fan runs onto the pitch to deliberately antagonise a player, yet it's Hiram who ends up facing a criminal charge.
"Where's the accountability for the person who invaded the pitch and provoked the situation? Absolutely ridiculous.
Uggla, of course, is far from the only figurehead to reserve strong backing for Boateng, who many believe was firmly within his right to retaliate after Rochdale supporters had committed a criminal offense in the first place by invading the field of play to antagonise opposition players.
Echoing the school of thought of many, this one fan called for the case to simply be thrown out of court in argument of injustice towards Boateng.
Another referred to the situation as "scandalous", citing the inarguable fact that one person had the right to be on the pitch and the other simply did not.
Indeed, the case has prompted cries for an enhanced systemic approach towards player safety and welfare in which greater protection and prevention from such events is provided, with several fans asking why the Dale supporter has not been identified and publicised for their own offences.
An Oldham Athletic supporter, meanwhile, has called for the fan to feel the same legal repercussions in an impassioned rant.
Whether or not Boateng was right for hitting out a fan has been hotly-debated online - and will be in the courts, of course - but this punter feels as though the midfield man did nothing wrong in the first place and the pitch-invader received just what they deserved in an act of "self defence" from York's promotion-winner.
However, not everybody has spoken in defence and support of Boateng.
It's clearly the general consensus, though others have argued that Boateng did not need to retailiate in such a fashion.
What do you make of the case? Was Hiram Boateng in the right here and should the York City midfielder's actions go unpunished, or does he deserve the legal charges? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.
Rather interestingly, one York fan hopped over the other side of the fence and, in a claim that has not gone down too well among the City faithful, explained how Boateng's punch was unnecessary in spite of the wrongs of the aggravating supporter.
Whereas some Rochdale fans have slammed the behaviour of one of their own, others have taken a less-sympathetic stance towards Boateng and believe that his actions - regardless of whether the supporter was right to be on the pitch or not - cannot be allowed to go unpunished.
It's a controversial old case, and the direction of its travel will only be determined in due course.
For now, at least, all York supporters and power-brokers alike will intend on doing is continuing to defend the well-liked midfielder against the charges, which the overwhelming majority believe to be unjustified in light of what led to his actions.
📅 19 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (361 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Rio Ferdinand has admitted he is disappointed that Manchester United failed to sign Ayyoub Bouaddi, with the highly-rated midfielder now making an impression at Manchester City.
Manchester City beat several rivals to secure Bouaddi’s signature over the summer in a deal worth £86 million. The Morocco international became the Premier League’s most expensive teenager, and Rio Ferdinand believes Manchester United missed out on a special talent.
The former United defender was particularly impressed by Bouaddi’s second-half cameo during City’s Champions League defeat to Paris Saint-Germain last week. His performance reminded Rio Ferdinand why he had been talking about the youngster throughout the previous year and during the summer transfer window.
Speaking on his YouTube channel, Ferdinand highlighted how Bouaddi was the highlight of the game against PSG and who they missed.
“He came on and showed PSG that they may have missed out on someone who was on their doorstep when he was playing in France,” Ferdinand said.
The former England international also confirmed that Manchester United had been interested in bringing the midfielder to Old Trafford, but the transfer fee was too expensive.
“Manchester United were in for him, 100%, but the fee was just too much,” he added.
Ferdinand was left frustrated by what he saw from the teenager, who turned 19 this month.
“Just that little cameo against PSG makes you go, ‘oh, I can’t believe we missed out on that. I can’t believe it.’ I’m so gutted, so gutted. He’s bad! He’s so calm under pressure.”.
Rio Ferdinand suggested Bouaddi’s quality could soon make the midfield position in a packed Manchester City his regular role.
City already have Elliot Anderson and Enzo Fernandez among their midfield options, but Ferdinand believes Bouaddi has the ability to stand out alongside them.
“They’ve got Elliot Anderson and Enzo Fernandez in that midfield as well but this kid could be the best of the three, easily.”.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 28 Jun 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (688 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readchelsea

Chelsea’s World Cup watch has moved beyond simple minutes management.
Senegal’s Round-of-32 meeting with Belgium now gives Xabi Alonso a live read on two very different development tracks.
Recent findings suggest that nicolas Jackson’s attacking authority is the immediate question. Mamadou Sarr’s defensive readiness is the longer-term one.
Chelsea confirmed that Senegal kept their knockout hopes alive with a 5-0 win over Iraq, with Jackson featuring from the bench.
Senegal have since moved into the knockouts, where they face Belgium in Seattle on Wednesday 1 July.
Jackson and Sarr travel into that game with contrasting club questions attached. Both still carry clear Chelsea relevance.
Welcome to Chelsea, Mamadou Sarr! 🔵.
Sarr has not been the loudest Chelsea story of the tournament.
That may actually make this test more useful.
The 20-year-old is still moving through the awkward stage between prospect, squad option and saleable BlueCo asset.
Knockout football against Belgium can sharpen that picture quickly.
Recent findings suggest that the timing is awkward in the best possible way for Chelsea. Alonso steps into a squad with expensive centre-backs, academy-trained options and a board still comfortable using the market aggressively.
Industry observers note that A disciplined Sarr performance would not end that search. It would give the recruitment team a stronger internal benchmark before committing another major fee.
Tactically, that benchmark is clear.
Chelsea need defenders who can hold a high line, cover wide channels and still pass through pressure. Belgium should ask those questions more directly than most group-stage opponents.
In a recent development, the context matters. Chelsea’s recall note recorded that Sarr returned from Strasbourg after 18 appearances across Ligue 1 and the Conference League.
The club also noted that he had already earned his first Senegal cap.
That is a different profile from an academy player being carried by reputation alone.
It has been revealed that there is a statistical base behind the interest too. When Chelsea completed the deal, beIN SPORTS noted that Sarr made 27 Ligue 1 appearances in his first Strasbourg season.
He helped them keep 10 clean sheets. He also produced a team-high 20 blocks and made 25 interceptions.
Those numbers explain why this Belgium game is not just a sentimental World Cup subplot.
Alonso’s Chelsea defence is already crowded with Levi Colwill, Wesley Fofana, Trevoh Chalobah and external targets still orbiting the proposal.
ReadChelsea has already looked at why Colwill’s recovery story gives Alonso a defensive test. Sarr’s value is different.
He is still being evaluated as a physical, long-range defensive project.
Jackson’s role changes the editorial weight of the tie.
It has been revealed that chelsea’s striker picture has been messy for long enough. Any high-pressure international performance now carries wider meaning.
ReadChelsea has already framed the forward’s tournament as a live Senegal striker audit for Chelsea.
Belgium should stress both Chelsea questions at once.
Jackson has to offer penalty-box threat and transition security. Sarr, if trusted, has to defend space against a technically cleaner opponent.
He also has to show whether his recovery pace and frame translate under tournament pressure.
In a recent development, sarr’s own mentality profile is worth noting. In a Chelsea World Cup Q&A, he named Lionel Messi, Sadio Mane and Paul Pogba as his tournament heroes.
His answer on Pogba focused on leadership and group mentality.
In a recent development, that lands neatly with the exact question Chelsea now need answered. Is there enough presence to go with the physical tools?
This is why Belgium feels like a pathway check rather than a routine World Cup watch item.
Chelsea do not need Sarr to solve the defence in July. They need clearer evidence on whether he belongs in Alonso’s first pre-season group.
According to recent reports, he could need another loan. He could also become part of the club’s centre-back market arithmetic.
In a recent development, for Jackson, the question is more immediate. For Sarr, it is more structural.
Together, Senegal’s knockout tie gives Chelsea a rare clean look at two players on opposite ends of the same squad-building argument.
Who can help now, and who is worth protecting for later?
📅 30 Jun 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (672 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readchelsea

Michael Olise has moved from former Chelsea academy footnote to genuine Ballon d’Or conversation piece.
That should land at Cobham as more than a wistful what-if.
Bavarian Football Works relayed comments from former Chelsea and France winger Florent Malouda, who described the Bayern Munich forward as a live Ballon d’Or contender if France turn their World Cup run into silverware.
According to recent reports, the point is not simply that Chelsea once had Olise in the building. It is that his rise provides a hard benchmark for the type of final-third specialist Xabi Alonso must either develop or buy.
Sources indicate that chelsea have spent heavily on attacking upside. Olise’s rise is a reminder that the real separator is not potential, but repeatable elite production.
Bayern’s own season review underlines why the conversation has accelerated.
Industry observers note that the German champions confirmed Olise finished 2025/26 with 25 goals and 28 assists from 57 competitive appearances. He was also named Bayern’s Player of the Season for a second straight year, finishing ahead of Harry Kane and Luis Diaz in the fan vote.
That is elite production from a wide creator who does not play like a chalk-on-boots winger.
Olise can receive wide, drift inside, manipulate the half-space and still deliver the last pass at match-winning speed. Chelsea have bought attackers with pieces of that profile, but few have joined the dots with that level of consistency.
There is an obvious recruitment lesson here.
Industry observers note that the market will now price that blend of creativity, ball security and goal threat close to superstar territory. If Chelsea want an Alonso attack that controls games rather than simply runs through them, the next winger decision cannot be judged on pace or upside alone.
It has to be judged on game control, final-third calm and repeat output.
The World Cup has sharpened the comparison.
Chelsea’s official France preview noted that Malo Gusto was in the same squad as N’Golo Kante and former Blues academy player Olise. It was a neat reminder of how many Chelsea strands sit inside Didier Deschamps’ group.
Bundesliga’s tournament analysis was even more revealing. It noted that Olise had reached 10 France goal involvements in 18 appearances and was named Player of the Match on his World Cup debut against Senegal.
That same analysis highlighted the tactical adjustment that moved Olise closer to Kylian Mbappe after half-time. His passing range then became the lever that changed the game.
Recent findings suggest that that matters for Chelsea because Alonso’s best Bayer Leverkusen sides were built around players who could receive between lines without killing the tempo. Cole Palmer already gives Chelsea one version of that.
The wider question is whether the squad has another attacker who can bend matches from the opposite side without turning every possession into a one-v-one.
Sources indicate that olise’s Chelsea connection can easily become sentimental. The sharper editorial point is structural.
This is the calibre of player who once passed through the academy pathway and later became a global-level attacker elsewhere. Chelsea cannot change that history, but they can use it to stress-test the next wave of decisions.
That matters for Tyrique George, Kendry Paez, Estevao and any new wide signing.
Sources indicate that readChelsea has already looked at how Tyrique George’s likely Everton return gives Alonso a fresh winger audit. Olise’s current standing raises the standard of that discussion.
Industry observers note that he is no longer just a former academy name or a missed Premier League target. He is evidence of what happens when technical security, role clarity and patience meet elite coaching.
For Alonso, that is the real value of the Olise noise.
According to recent reports, chelsea do not need to turn every academy exit into regret. They do need to recognise the standard now being set by one of Cobham’s former pupils.
The next wide forward who gets serious minutes at Stamford Bridge has to be assessed against that ceiling, not against the safer language of potential.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 5 min read (1006 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

West Ham United have had quite a rocky introduction to life back in the Championship, sitting outside the play-offs completely after 15 games.
The Hammers came down to the second tier with some of the best individuals that the division has ever seen, and they've proven their quality going forward, with their 37 goals an EFL best and a couple of six-goal hauls already.
It has been revealed that however, there are some concerns about the overall balance of the side and a lack of a strong spine in the squad. Scott Parker has replaced Nuno Espírito Santo to try and fix that, and the international break couldn't have come at a better time to try and implement an identity.
The upcoming January transfer window can help with that, too, with a focus on bringing in players who can make a long-term impact in the side, both in the rest of this season and then in what is hoped to be Premier League campaigns in the future.
Industry observers note that with 2026 drawing to a close, fans across the EFL are starting to think about what an ideal transfer window would look like in January. For West Ham, FLW's Hammers fan pundit, Ryan Horn, wants to see the spine of the midfield fixed.
West Ham broke the Championship transfer record by signing midfielder Arne Engels from Celtic for £22 million, but in terms of out-and-out defensive options, they don't have many available.
Tomas Soucek is still on his way back to full fitness, but he turns 32 in February, while Edson Alvarez hasn't been seen all season and, up until Parker's first game in charge at Cardiff City, neither had Soungoutou Magassa.
"Hopefully, by the time January comes, we'll be a lot closer to the top of the table, but there is a midfielder I'd really like us to sign, who'd solve all our challenges," Horn noted.
Recent findings suggest that "With the future of Magassa and Alvarez in doubt at the moment, and with Soucek only just coming back from injury and getting on a bit in age, our midfield is lacking. There's this young midfielder I really like called Luca Weinhandl, who plays in the Austrian Bundesliga for Sturm Graz.".
Recent findings suggest that 2009-born Weinhandl has been one of the key parts of Fabio Ingolitsch's side since he took charge on January 1st this year. The 17-year-old was handed his debut by the current boss, and this season, he's been one of their most consistent players.
He's started all but one league game for Sturm Graz, and all but one in their Europa League campaign, too, assisting in their 1-0 win over Marseille last month.
"He's 17, six-foot-three and doing brilliant there," Horn continued. "He'd just be one of those sort of niche signings that clubs such as Brighton and Brentford pick up out of nowhere and turn into £70 million, £80 million players.
"Bournemouth are buying players for good money now, but they, like Brighton, are competing at the top and in Europe, while Brentford have had a lot of good seasons in the Premier League now.
"But it's the modern-day football approach, and one that West Ham need to take. Weinhandl would be that kind of player.".
With Weinhandl not turning 18 until mid-January, he has the entirety of his career ahead of him. If he continues on his current path, he could end up playing right at the top of the game.
The midfielder is one of the tougher-tackling engine room men in the Austrian Bundesliga this season, winning the most duels in the division and sitting inside the top 13% of defensive midfielders for tackles won, according to FotMob.
However, he's also right near the top for the number of dribbles he's completed and the number of fouls he's won. He has plenty of strings to his bow already, and could be a vital player in the future of any football club. Horn hopes it's with West Ham.
"He could form a solid spine next to Engels, or Kante and Magassa in front of him and be a key part of it for years to come, and then we don't have to worry about our midfield every single year," the fan pundit continued.
"Last year it was overrun, then we sold Potts, and this year, we have key players who have first-team and Champions League experience not being picked because of off-field challenges.
Recent findings suggest that "Having a younger player coming in, under Parker and [Mark] Noble, as well as Soucek, [Jarrod] Bowen and other experienced players, it'd be a dream. He's definitely one I'd sign. I don't think we will, but that's my realistic pick.".
While Weinhandl would be a brilliant pickup for any English side looking to grow and develop a young midfielder, the 17-year-old may already have too much potential to be signed by a team in the Championship.
Murmurs in mid-September had the Australian linked with moves to Aston Villa, Brighton and Arsenal, so if he did move to the second-tier, it may be via a loan move after being signed by a side further up the pyramid.
It has been revealed that do you think Luca Weinhandl has the Premier League in his future? Let us know in the comments.
Weinhandl isn't as much of a hidden gem anymore, having been called up to the Austrian senior squad for the first time for the ongoing break. Ralf Rangnick opted not to debut him against the Republic of Ireland, but could do so on Tuesday night against Israel.
The 17-year-old is a Graz native, too, and growing up through the academy to become a club legend there could appeal to him and seeing a possible move from a side like West Ham seem impossible.
He's definitely one to watch, and it wouldn't be a surprise to see him in the Premier League in the future, but for now, the Hammers may find it difficult to tempt this wonderkid over.
📅 27 Oct 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (446 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Michael Carrick has come under immense pressure as a disjointed Manchester United sit just two places above the relegation places.
Despite the scrutiny and the news of a possible sacking, Michael Carrick has been given another chance at Manchester United.
Michael Carrick will remain in charge of Manchester United for their Premier League trip to Chelsea on Saturday after the club decided to give their under-pressure head coach another opportunity to turn things around.
United have gone eight games without a win in all competitions, with Sunday’s humiliating 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth leaving them 16th in the Premier League table, just one point above the relegation zone.
Carrick’s position looked increasingly uncertain after the Bournemouth loss. As a result, United chief executive Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox were at Carrington on Monday to discuss the situation.
It has been reported by Sky Sports that United have considered other options internally as well to replace Micahel Carrick but for the weekend, they are sticking with Michael Carrick.
Carrick took training on Tuesday and the decision means he has at least one more match to convince the club’s hierarchy that he can get United back on track.
Gary Neville admitted he was surprised that Carrick had survived the immediate threat of losing his job, although he welcomed the decision.
“I am surprised, but I am happy because I was absolutely certain that what I witnessed on Sunday would be the end of Michael,” Neville mentioned in Sky Sports.
The former United captain explained that Carrick’s actions after the Bournemouth defeat had made him think the manager was preparing to say goodbye to the supporters.
“It looked like he was walking round at the end on his own with the players behind him, like it was almost a goodbye lap,” Neville added.
Fans continued singing the manager’s name after the final whistle, while the rest of the team drew boos.
Despite his surprise, Gary Neville hopes Micahel Carrick can use the extra time to get a response from his squad.
“I hope he can somehow get those players to start playing for him again because they haven’t played for him in the last few weeks,” he said.
The trip to Chelsea now becomes a crucial test for Micahel Carrick but United need a result and a far better performance to ease the pressure at Old Trafford.
Recent findings suggest that shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 28 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 4 min read (712 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readchelsea

According to recent reports, chelsea fans have followed Manchester City’s financial rules case for years. Everyone at Stamford Bridge knows a guilty verdict could cost City serious money, and much of it could end up with rivals lower down the table.
Recent findings suggest that reports now suggest an independent panel has reached a decision. If that holds up, the scale of any Chelsea Manchester City compensation payout could run into tens of millions of pounds for the Blues alone.
Recent findings suggest that the Premier League charged Manchester City with 115 alleged breaches of financial regulations in February 2023. That followed a four-year investigation into the club’s accounts. The case has hung over the competition ever since. Every top-flight club knows the outcome could change how recent Premier League seasons are remembered.
This matters directly to Chelsea. If City are found to have broken spending and disclosure rules, clubs who finished below them could argue they lost out on prize money and European qualification. Chelsea have competed directly with City for top four places and cup competitions throughout that period.
In a recent development, according to The Athletic, Manchester City were found guilty on all but one of the 115 charges by the independent panel. The Premier League has not confirmed the verdict or issued a statement.
Manchester City have not accepted any suggestion of guilt. The club released a statement addressing the ongoing process directly.
Industry observers note that “The Premier League process remains ongoing, with significant elements to be completed, and subject to strict confidentiality. As such, Manchester City FC’s position remains consistent with the Club’s statement of February 2023. ‘The Club has diligently respected due process for eight years on the basis that the Premier League Board and Executive would behave as an independent, impartial and fair-minded regulator, free from partisan influence.'”.
That statement makes clear the club does not see the case as settled. Until the Premier League confirms a result, the reported verdict will linger on for official sentencing.
According to recent reports, data specialists at OLBG have estimated the potential Chelsea Manchester City compensation windfall if City are found guilty. They believe City could owe domestic rivals well over £500m in lost Premier League prize money if the charges are proven.
According to recent reports, within that total, London clubs are remarked to be due around £164m between them. Chelsea, Arsenal and Tottenham Hotspur are among the clubs who could be entitled to a share. Other Premier League sides could benefit too, depending on where they finished compared with City in the seasons in question.
Industry observers note that prize money in the Premier League is tied closely to league position. If City gained points unfairly, that would have pushed a rival down the table and cost them money too. That is the basis for the OLBG figures, and it explains why the sums involved are so large.
In a recent development, for Chelsea, even a share of that £164m pot would be a big boost. It could help fund fresh signings, or simply ease the pressure around the kind of transfer valuations at Stamford Bridge the club faces every window.
Industry observers note that city chairman Khaldoon Al Mubarak has already made clear the case is far from finished. He described the process as having “a long way to run.” That points to appeals and further legal steps, whatever the panel has decided.
According to recent reports, chelsea, for their part, carry on with life under Xabi Alonso regardless of how the case unfolds. Attention stays on squad rotation and Xabi Alonso’s squad management strategy, not on any potential windfall. The financial case will not change anything on the pitch in the short term.
According to recent reports, the Premier League has stayed silent on the reported verdict, and confidentiality remains strict around the process, according to reports from Football.London. Chelsea fans should expect a long wait before any compensation, if it comes at all, reaches the club’s accounts.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 17 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 38 min read (7530 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Nature

Accessing reversible four-electron iodine redox chemistry in aqueous metal–iodine batteries offers a promising route towards high-energy aqueous energy storage, but has conventionally relied on highly concentrated, corrosive halogen-containing electrolytes to stabilize reactive hypervalent iodine cations through interhalogen complexation1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9. Here we show a kosmotropic anion–polar anion–nucleophilic species (Nuc) electrolyte framework that harnesses anionic chemistry to coordinate the interfacial microenvironment and molecular interactions, enabling reversible four-electron iodine conversion in halogen-free aqueous electrolytes. Polar anions establish a water-deficient, anion-enriched interfacial microenvironment, whereas kosmotropic anions regulate water–Nuc interactions to increase the availability of Nuc for stabilizing hypervalent iodine cations through Nuc–I+–Nuc halogen bonds. This electrolyte framework is validated across diverse Nuc and in both aqueous Zn–I2 and Al–I2 batteries. Moving beyond conventional interhalogen stabilization, these findings establish a distinct electrolyte chemistry framework and represent a mechanistic shift for reversible multi-electron iodine chemistry in aqueous environments.
The increasing integration of renewable energy calls for sustainable electrochemical energy storage systems beyond lithium-ion batteries1. Aqueous metal–iodine batteries offer a promising platform for large-scale energy storage by combining earth-abundant electrode materials, aqueous electrolytes and conversion-type iodine chemistry2,3. Unlike intercalation-type positive electrodes, iodine positive electrodes store charge by reversible valence-state changes, offering access to multi-electron redox chemistry with increased capacity and redox potential4. Most studies have focused on the two-electron I−/I0 redox couple, with a theoretical capacity of 211 mAh g−1 at a redox potential of 0.54 V versus the standard hydrogen electrode10. Extending iodine conversion to the successive I−/I0/I+ redox couples doubles the theoretical capacity to 422 mAh g−1 while introducing the I0/I+ redox process at a higher redox potential of 1.07 V versus the standard hydrogen electrode11. However, despite this potential, achieving reversible four-electron iodine conversion in aqueous environments remains a fundamental challenge3,7.
Industry observers note that the crux of iodine conversion chemistry lies in interfacial reactions, where electrolyte composition and interfacial microenvironment govern reaction pathways. Electron-deficient I+ is strongly electrophilic and susceptible to nucleophilic attack by water, resulting in hydrolysis and poor reversibility in aqueous environments9,12. Previous studies have achieved four-electron iodine conversion in aqueous Zn–I2 and Al–I2 batteries by stabilizing reactive I+ through interhalogen complexes (for example, ICl2 or IBr2) in highly concentrated chloride- or bromide-containing electrolytes5,6,13. In these systems, electrophilic I+ coordinates with two nucleophilic halide ions (Cl− or Br−) through non-covalent interactions8,14. However, at water-enriched interfaces, hydration of nucleophilic species (Nuc) competes with these interactions and destabilizes I+ complexes (Fig. 1a). Highly concentrated, halogen-containing electrolytes mitigate this competition by reducing water activity and increasing halide availability, but their high salt contents and corrosivity constrain broader implementation (Fig. 1b and Supplementary Fig. 1), necessitating new electrolyte chemistry and a mechanistic framework that move beyond reliance on halogen-containing electrolytes and conventional interhalogen stabilization5,8.
a, The mechanism of the competition between halogen bond and hydrogen bond. b, The conventional interhalogen stabilization mechanism in highly concentrated, halogen-containing electrolytes. c, The KA–PA–Nuc framework levering anionic chemistry and halogen-bond stabilization in halogen-free electrolytes. IHP, inner Helmholtz plane; OHP, outer Helmholtz plane.
Given the competition between I+ stabilization and hydration at water-enriched interfaces, overcoming this challenge requires simultaneous regulation of the interfacial environment and water–Nuc interactions. Anionic chemistry offers a powerful lever to coordinate these interfacial and molecular interactions15,16,17,18. Herein we establish a kosmotropic anion (KA)–polar anion (PA)–Nuc electrolyte framework for reversible I−/I0/I+ conversion in halogen-free aqueous electrolytes (Fig. 1c). Systematic experiments and theoretical calculations reveal how the synergistic effects of PAs and KAs coordinate the interfacial microenvironment and molecular interactions, thereby stabilizing interfacial electrochemical behaviour and promoting reversible four-electron iodine conversion. The applicability of this electrolyte framework is demonstrated across four halogen-free Nuc (urea, acetamide, pyridine and nicotinamide) and in both aqueous Zn–I2 and Al–I2 batteries (Supplementary Fig. 2 and Supplementary Tables 1 and 2). Beyond establishing a halogen-free electrolyte chemistry, this work reveals how electrolyte chemistry governs iodine conversion across interfacial, molecular and electrochemical scales, providing a mechanistic basis for reversible multi-electron iodine chemistry in aqueous environments.
Stabilizing I+ against hydrolysis is essential for reversible four-electron iodine conversion in aqueous electrolytes. Previous studies have relied on highly concentrated, corrosive halogen-containing electrolytes for interhalogen stabilization19,20, whereas more recent studies have explored specific additive-halogen nucleophilic substitution reactions21,22. These approaches primarily address I+ stabilization through specific molecular interactions, whereas how electrolyte chemistry collectively regulates the interfacial microenvironment, molecular stabilization and the resulting iodine conversion pathways remains less understood. This work establishes a mechanistic framework that integrates anionic chemistry with halogen-bond stabilization in halogen-free aqueous electrolytes. As illustrated in Fig. 2a, strong PAs establish a water-deficient, anion-enriched interface, whereas KAs weaken Nuc–water hydrogen bonding to facilitate halogen-bond stabilization of I+. These complementary effects underpin the halogen-free KA–PA–Nuc electrolyte framework, whose composition was subsequently optimized (Supplementary Figs. 3 and 4) and exhibits sufficient electrochemical stability (Supplementary Fig. 5) for four-electron iodine conversion.
a, Molecular interplay governed by anionic chemistry and halogen bonding. b, Cyclic voltammetry profiles of iodine conversion reaction using urea as Nuc at 0.6 mV s−1. c, Cyclic voltammetry profiles using acetamide as Nuc at 0.6 mV s−1. d, Cyclic voltammetry profiles using nicotinamide as Nuc at 0.6 mV s−1. e–g, Corresponding GCD profiles for b–d at 1 A g−1, respectively. All electrochemical measurements were performed in Zn–I2 coin cells with an iodine mass loading of 2.2 mg cm−2.
Industry observers note that the KA–PA–Nuc electrolyte framework was validated in aqueous Zn–I2 batteries across four different Nuc (Supplementary Fig. 6). Electron-deficient I+ can interact with two electron-rich Nuc molecules to form linear Nuc–I+–Nuc halogen bonds. These halogen bonds provide the molecular basis for I+ stabilization, as supported by Nuc-free controls, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and theoretical calculations23 (Supplementary Figs. 7–11). Using urea (U) as a representative Nuc, KA–U exhibits only the I−/I0 redox process, whereas PA–U enables further I0/I+ oxidation but with poor reversibility (Fig. 2b,e). The excessive capacity at the second charge plateau is attributed to irreversible iodine oxidation coupled with parasitic water oxidation (Supplementary Figs. 12 and 13). Combining KA and PA in KA–PA–U produces two reversible redox peaks and corresponding charge–discharge plateaus, demonstrating their synergistic role in enabling reversible I−/I0/I+ conversion (Supplementary Fig. 14). Replacing U with acetamide (AE), nicotinamide (NA) or pyridine (PD) shows the same phenomenon, with reversible I−/I0/I+ conversion achieved only in the KA–PA–Nuc electrolytes, including under identical ionic strength conditions, indicating the broad applicability of this electrolyte framework (Fig. 2c,d,f,g and Supplementary Figs. 15–18).
According to recent reports, to isolate the role of PAs in the KA–PA–Nuc electrolyte framework, SO42− was maintained as the KA, whereas structurally related CF3SO3−, CF3COO− or CH3COO− was introduced as the second anion. Density-functional-theory calculations reveal a polarity sequence of CH3COO− > CF3COO− > CF3SO3− (Supplementary Fig. 19), providing a basis for examining how anion polarity influences interfacial behaviours24,25. Molecular-dynamics simulations show similar water-enriched bulk environments across the three electrolytes (Supplementary Figs. 20–22), but distinct interfacial structures (Fig. 3d). CH3COO− reduces the interfacial water density while increasing anion enrichment, whereas CF3COO− and CF3SO3− retain high interfacial water intensity (Fig. 3e,f). In situ attenuated total reflection infrared (ATR-IR) spectroscopy further supports this interfacial redistribution. The δ-HOH vibration at 1,640 cm−1 remains pronounced with CF3SO3− or CF3COO− (Fig. 3g,h and Supplementary Fig. 23), but is suppressed with CH3COO− alongside pronounced anion-associated signals26,27,28,29 (Fig. 3i). Notably, highly concentrated ZnCl2 retains a water-enriched interface despite its water-deficient bulk environment (Supplementary Figs. 24 and 25). Differential capacitance measurements indicate stronger interfacial adsorption of CH3COO− than of CF3COO− and CF3SO3− (Supplementary Figs. 26 and 27), linking preferential adsorption of strongly PAs to the formation of a water-deficient, anion-enriched interfacial microenvironment30.
Recent findings suggest that a, Cyclic voltammetry profiles in electrolytes with different anions. b, GCD profiles in electrolytes with different anions. The rising and falling voltage curves correspond to charging and discharging processes, respectively. c, Cycling stability in electrolytes with different anions, with upper and lower curves representing Coulombic efficiency and specific capacity, respectively. Electrochemical measurements were performed in Zn–I2 coin cells with an iodine mass loading of 2.2 mg cm−2. d, Schematic snapshot of the interfacial structure in the electrolyte with CH3COO−. e, Corresponding interfacial cumulated density profiles of H2O in electrolytes with different anions, with the grey shaded region highlighting interfacial variations. f, Corresponding interfacial cumulated density profiles of anions in electrolytes with different anions, with the pink shaded region highlighting interfacial variations. g–i, In situ ATR-IR spectra in the electrolytes with CF3SO3− (g), CF3COO− (h) and CH3COO− (i).
In a recent development, these polarity-dependent interfacial structures lead to distinct iodine conversion behaviour. CF3SO3− reveals a negligible I0/I+ process, whereas CF3COO− enables I0/I+ oxidation but with limited reversibility. By contrast, CH3COO− supports reversible I−/I0/I+ conversion with improved stability and capacity (Fig. 3a–c and Supplementary Fig. 28). In situ ultraviolet–visible spectra and micro-computed-tomography analyses further link these differences to iodine species distribution, showing that CH3COO− confines iodine species within the electrode and suppresses their migration into the bulk electrolyte (Supplementary Figs. 29 and 30). Together, these results establish a mechanistic relationship between anion polarity and the resulting water-deficient, anion-enriched interfacial microenvironment that governs the reversibility of four-electron iodine conversion.
Building on the understanding of PAs, the critical role of KAs in the KA–PA–Nuc framework was further explored. Nuc stabilize I+ through electron-rich nitrogen or oxygen centres, which also interact with water through hydrogen bonding and therefore compete with halogen-bond formation (Supplementary Fig. 31). Inspired by anion-specific effects on water–solute interactions, SO42−, CH3COO−, NO3−, CF3SO3− and ClO4− were compared in the same PA–Nuc baseline31,32,33,34 (Supplementary Fig. 32). Although these anions have little effect on the initial capacity, they produce different cycling stability (Supplementary Fig. 33). SO42− maintains nearly overlapping galvanostatic charge–discharge (GCD) profiles, whereas CH3COO− and CF3SO3− show intermediate cycling stability and ClO4− undergoes rapid deterioration (Fig. 4a–c and Supplementary Fig. 34), giving a stability sequence of SO42− > CH3COO− > CF3SO3− > ClO4−. NO3− deviates from this sequence owing to its limited electrochemical stability within the applied voltage range35 (Supplementary Fig. 35a,b).
a, GCD profiles in the electrolyte containing SO42− at different cycles. b, GCD profiles in the electrolyte containing CF3SO3− at different cycles. c, GCD profiles in the electrolyte containing ClO4− at different cycles. Electrochemical measurements were performed in Zn–I2 coin cells with an iodine mass loading of 2.2 mg cm−2. d, 2H NMR spectra of electrolytes containing different anions. e, 1H NMR spectra of electrolytes containing different anions. f, 13C NMR spectra of electrolytes containing different anions. g, Two-dimensional 1H–15N HMBC NMR spectrum of the electrolyte containing SO42−. h, Two-dimensional 1H–15N HMBC NMR spectrum of the electrolyte containing CF3SO3−. i, Two-dimensional 1H–15N HMBC NMR spectrum of the electrolyte containing ClO4−.
NMR spectroscopy and molecular-dynamics simulations reveal the molecular origin of these electrochemical differences. The 2H chemical shift follows SO42− > CH3COO− > NO3− > CF3SO3− > ClO4− (Fig. 4d), indicating progressively stronger anion-induced water polarization and restructuring of the aqueous hydrogen-bond network36,37. These differences in water–anion coordination translate into distinct water–Nuc interactions. The corresponding 15N chemical shifts, together with the inverse trends observed in 1H and 13C chemical shifts, indicate that KAs such as SO42− polarize hydration water and thereby weaken Nuc–water hydrogen bonding, whereas chaotropic anions such as ClO4− interact directly with the Nuc backbone and facilitate Nuc hydration32 (Fig. 4e,f, and Supplementary Figs. 32 and 36–38). Nuc solubility measurements, two-dimensional 1H–15N heteronuclear multiple bond correlation (HMBC) NMR spectra, and calculated Nuc–water distances and hydrogen-bond populations further support this interpretation (Fig. 4g–i, and Supplementary Figs. 35c, 39 and 40). By weakening Nuc–water interactions, SO42− increases the availability of Nuc for halogen-bond stabilization of I+, thereby promoting reversible iodine conversion. These results reveal how anionic chemistry regulates molecular water–Nuc interactions to govern the reversibility of four-electron iodine conversion.
In a recent development, having established the complementary roles of PA and KA in interfacial and molecular regulation, we next examined how these effects manifest in the electrochemical processes governing iodine conversion. In situ electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) combined with distribution of relaxation times (DRT) analysis was used to decouple the complex impedance response and identify individual electrochemical processes38,39,40 (Supplementary Figs. 41–43). In the absence of either KA or PA, the DRT responses evolve distinctly with additional competing interfacial processes, whereas their combined presence maintains stable interfacial electrochemical behaviour throughout iodine conversion41,42 (Extended Data Fig. 1). Rate-dependent analysis identifies charge transfer, rather than ion transport, as the dominant kinetic contribution to iodine conversion in the KA–PA–Nuc electrolyte (Supplementary Figs. 44–50). In situ Raman spectroscopy further links these electrochemical processes to iodine chemistry, revealing the reversible evolution of the Nuc–I+–Nuc species during cycling (Supplementary Figs. 51 and 52).
According to recent reports, the KA–PA–Nuc framework supports four-electron iodine conversion across different operating conditions and cell configurations. Zn–I2 cells retain 96% of their capacity after 1,000 cycles at 1 A g−1 and 94% after 2,000 cycles at 2 A g−1, while sustaining four-electron conversion at iodine loadings up to 12.2 mg cm−2 (Supplementary Figs. 53–55, 58a and 59). This electrolyte framework is also compatible with different current collectors and pouch-cell configurations and extends to aqueous Al–I2 cells using Al–Zn alloy negative electrodes (Supplementary Figs. 56–58b,c, 60 and 61). A techno-economic analysis under standardized modelling assumptions further illustrates its theoretical cost-reduction potential by avoiding highly concentrated, halogen-containing electrolytes and costly current collectors (Supplementary Fig. 58d–f and Supplementary Tables 3 and 4). Mechanistic and post-mortem analyses further reveal that the apparent low Coulombic efficiency and capacity fading involve coupled reversible and irreversible iodine inventory loss, with the latter becoming more pronounced at increased iodine loading (Supplementary Figs. 62–67 and Extended Data Figs. 2–4). Together, these results clarify the iodine conversion pathways while defining the applicability and remaining limitations of the KA–PA–Nuc framework, showing that sustained reversible four-electron iodine conversion requires not only stabilization of hypervalent iodine species but also broader management of the entire iodine inventory.
It has been revealed that all chemicals were used as received without further purification unless otherwise stated. The manufacturer and purity of each material are specified at its first occurrence in Methods and are not repeated thereafter unless a different source or purity was used.
The KA–PA–Nuc electrolytes were prepared by dissolving KA, PA and Nuc into deionized water at room temperature. For aqueous Zn–I2 batteries, KA and PA were 1.5 M ZnSO4 (>99%, Sigma-Aldrich) and 0.5 M Zn (CH3COO)2 (>98%, Sigma-Aldrich), respectively. To demonstrate the broad applicability of the KA–PA–Nuc framework, various Nuc were used, including 2 M urea (>99.5%, Sigma-Aldrich), 2 M acetamide (>99%, Sigma-Aldrich), 0.2 M pyridine (>99%, Sigma-Aldrich) or 0.4 M nicotinamide (>99.5%, Sigma-Aldrich). To explore the role of PAs, a baseline electrolyte containing 1.5 M ZnSO4 and 0.4 M nicotinamide was prepared. Zn(CH3COO)2, Zn(CF3COO)2 (purity not specified, Sigma-Aldrich) or Zn(CF3SO3)2 (>98%, Sigma-Aldrich) was then added at a concentration of 0.5 M to obtain electrolytes containing different PAs. To evaluate the role of KAs, a baseline electrolyte containing 0.5 M Zn(CH3COO)2 and 0.4 M nicotinamide was prepared. ZnSO4, Zn(NO3)2 (>99%, Sigma-Aldrich), Zn(CF3SO3)2 or Zn(ClO4)2 (purity not specified, Sigma-Aldrich) was then added at a concentration of 1.5 M for comparative analysis. To compare electrolytes performance under a standardized ionic strength condition, the ionic strength of each electrolyte was calculated according to the equation:.
According to recent reports, where Ci and Zi represent the molar concentration and charge number of ion i, respectively. For aqueous Al–I2 batteries, the KA–PA–Nuc electrolyte was prepared by dissolving 1.5 M Al2(SO4)3 (>99%, Sigma-Aldrich), 0.5 Mg (CH3COO)2 (>99%, Sigma-Aldrich) and 0.5 M nicotinamide into deionized water.
Industry observers note that iodine-activated carbon (I2–AC) composites were prepared using an evaporation–adsorption method. In brief, 0.5 g iodine (>99.5%, Thermo Scientific Acros) and 0.5 g activated carbon (AC; YP-80F, purity not specified, Kuraray) were manually ground in an agate mortar with a pestle for 10 min under ambient conditions. The resulting mixture was sealed in a Teflon reactor and heated at 120 °C for 6 h. For the preparation of iodine positive electrodes using titanium (80 mesh, >99.5%, Hebei Conway Metal Products) or stainless steel mesh (80 mesh, 316L, Hebei Conway Metal Products) as the current collector, I2–AC, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE, 60 wt% dispersion H2O, Sigma-Aldrich) and Super P (purity not specified, Canrd) were combined at a mass ratio of 8:1:1. For each batch, 40 mg I2–AC, 5 mg Super P and 5 mg PTFE (calculated on a dry-PTFE basis) were manually mixed with deionized water using an agate mortar and pestle under ambient conditions. The resulting mixture was rolled into a self-standing film using a roller press (Etelux) and subsequently dried in an oven at 60 °C for 3 h in air. The areal iodine loading was controlled by adjusting the thickness of the composite film. The dried film was then pressed onto the titanium or stainless steel mesh using the roller press. The resulting electrodes were punched into 12 mm disks using a manual disk punch (T07, Hefei Kejing Material Technology).
For iodine positive electrodes using carbon paper (TGP-H-060, Toray) as the current collector, I2–AC, polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF, weight-average molecular weight, Mw ≈ 534,000 g mol−1 by gel permeation chromatography, powder, Sigma-Aldrich) and Super P were combined at a mass ratio of 8:1:1. For each batch, 160 mg I2–AC, 20 mg PVDF and 20 mg Super P were manually mixed with N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (>99.5%, Thermo Scientific Acros) using an agate mortar and pestle in ambient conditions. The resulting slurry was manually and uniformly spread onto the carbon paper using a laboratory spatula. The coated electrodes were dried in a vacuum oven at 60 °C for 8 h and subsequently cut into 12-mm disks using the manual disk punch. Commercial Zn foils (70 µm, >99.99%, Qinghe Haoxuan Metal Materials) were used as negative electrodes as received.
To assess the potential of the KA–PA–Nuc electrolyte framework in multi-electron aqueous Al–I2 batteries, a Ag/AgCl electrode in saturated KCl (Beijing Jingke Instrument Science Instrument) was used as the reference, and AC electrodes were prepared as the counter electrode. The measured potentials are reported directly versus the Ag/AgCl reference electrode. For the preparation of AC electrodes, AC, PTFE and Super P were combined at a mass ratio of 8:1:1. For each batch, 160 mg AC, 20 mg Super P and 20 mg PTFE (calculated on a dry-PTFE basis) were manually mixed with deionized water using an agate mortar and pestle at ambient conditions. The resulting mixture was rolled into a self-standing film using the roller press and subsequently dried in an oven at 60 °C for 3 h in air. The dried film was then pressed onto titanium mesh using the roller press. By adjusting the electrode thickness, the capacity of the AC electrode was controlled to be much higher than that of the iodine working electrode, ensuring its capability as the counter electrode for evaluating the electrochemical performance of the KA–PA–Nuc electrolyte. To further validate the applicability of the KA–PA–Nuc electrolyte framework in multi-electron aqueous Al–I2 batteries, Al–Zn alloys were fabricated as negative electrodes following a previous study43. In brief, symmetric cells were assembled using Zn foils (70 µm, 16 mm in diameter) as electrodes and 2 M Al (CF3SO3)3 (>99.9%, Sigma-Aldrich) as the electrolyte. During charging, Al3+ in the electrolyte deposited on and reacted with the metal Zn substrate, forming the Zn-supported Al–Zn alloys.
Halogen-bond complexes were synthesized via a cation-exchange reaction using corresponding silver analogues, following a previously reported procedure with some modifications44. All operations were carried out under a standard Schlenk line. In a typical synthesis, 0.94 mmol of the corresponding silver salt (Ag2SO4, >99%, Sigma-Aldrich; AgCH3COO, >99%, Sigma-Aldrich; AgCF3COO, >98%, Sigma-Aldrich; AgCF3SO3, >99%, Sigma-Aldrich; AgNO3, >99%, Sigma-Aldrich; or AgClO4, >97%, Sigma-Aldrich) was added to a 20-ml vial equipped with a stir bar. The vial was sealed with a rubber septum and evacuated. Subsequently, 6.0 ml dry CH2Cl2 (purity not specified, VWR Chemicals) and 1.90 mmol pyridine (3.80 mmol for Ag2SO4) were added at room temperature under a nitrogen atmosphere. The mixture was stirred for 10 min to form the Ag(I)–pyridine bis-coordination complex. Next, 2.00 mmol of iodine (4.00 mmol for Ag2SO4) was added, and the reaction was allowed to proceed for an additional 20 min under continuous stirring. The supernatant was then carefully transferred to another vial via cannula filtration, followed by the addition of 15 ml dry n-hexane (>99%, Macron Fine Chemicals) to induce precipitation of the halogen-bond complex. The mixture was stored at −20 °C overnight to complete precipitation. Afterwards, the supernatant was removed using a syringe, and the resulting solid was washed with 20 ml dry n-hexane to remove any residual I2. Finally, the product was dried under vacuum on the Schlenk line.
In a recent development, in situ ATR-IR spectra were recorded by a Thermo Scientific Nicolet iS50 spectrometer equipped with a liquid nitrogen-cooled MCT-A detector. Gold-coated silicon plates were used as working electrodes, with Zn foils (70 µm, 10 mm in diameter) and glass fibre (GF/D, 12 mm in diameter, Whatman) used as reference electrodes and separators, respectively. To assess the critical role of the PA in the interfacial environment, 1.5 M KA electrolyte was maintained as the baseline, and 0.5 M Zn(CH3COO)2, 0.5 M Zn(CF3COO)2 or 0.5 M Zn(CF3SO3)2 was separately added. An electrolyte volume of 500 μl was used for each measurement. During tests, the assembled batteries were connected to a Gamry Interface 1000 potentiostat to run a cyclic voltammetry programme at a scan rate of 0.2 mV s−1 for a full charge and discharge cycle. All spectra were collected at a resolution of 4 cm−1, with 50 scans per measurement. Measurements were performed at an ambient laboratory temperature of approximately 18–25 °C.
Raman spectra were recorded using a Bruker Senterra II Raman spectrometer with a 532-nm excitation wavelength. The in situ Zn–I2 cell comprised an iodine positive electrode (12 mm in diameter, iodine mass loading 2.2 mg cm−2), a Zn negative electrode (70 µm, 12 mm in diameter) and a glass fibre (GF/D, 12 mm in diameter). An electrolyte volume of 200 μl was used. Raman spectra were collected during GCD cycling using an external Gamry Interface 1000 potentiostat. Measurements were performed at an ambient laboratory temperature of approximately 18–25 °C.
FTIR spectra of various electrolytes were obtained using an ATR-FTIR spectrometer (BRUKER, Platinum-ATR). Scanning electron microscopy characterization of electrodes was performed using a JEOL 7600 microscope. Ultraviolet–visible measurements were conducted on a Shimadzu UV-3600i Plus spectrophotometer. For in situ ultraviolet–visible measurements, a two-electrode Zn–I2 cuvette cell was connected to a Neware battery test system for GCD cycling. NMR analyses, including 1H, 13C and 1H–15N HMBC spectra, were carried out on a Bruker NMR instrument (Avance Neo 500). 15N spectra were collected using a Bruker NMR instrument (Avance Neo 700). Deuterium oxide (>99.9%, Fluorochem) was used as the solvent for electrolyte characterization, and dideuteromethylenechloride (>99.9%, Sigma-Aldrich) was used as the solvent for characterizing halogen-bond complexes. Micro-computed-tomography imaging was conducted using a Zeiss Xradia 620 Versa system with a ×4 objective, operating at a tube voltage of 80 kV and an exposure time of 8 s, achieving a voxel resolution of 0.8 μm. For each sample, a disk with a diameter of 2 mm was prepared to balance X-ray attenuation and representative sampling volume. The acquired computed-tomography datasets were subsequently processed and analysed using Avizo software.
Electrochemical studies of halogen-free electrolytes were performed using CR2025 coin cells, whereas those of halogen-containing electrolytes were performed using Swagelok cells. For CR2025 Zn–I2 coin cells, the iodine positive electrode, Zn negative electrode (70 µm) and separator (GF/D) had diameters of 12 mm, 16 mm and 19 mm, respectively. For Swagelok Zn–I2 cells, corresponding electrodes and separators had the same diameter of 12 mm. For CR2025 Al–I2 coin cells, the iodine positive electrode had a diameter of 12 mm, the Al–Zn alloy negative electrode had a diameter of 16 mm, and a GF/D separator with a diameter of 19 mm was used. An electrolyte volume of 100 μl was used for each cell. Coin cells were mechanically crimped at 50 kg cm−2 using a hydraulic crimping machine (MSK-110, Hefei Kejing Material Technology) during assembly. Swagelok cells were manually tightened during assembly.
Industry observers note that for the 1.1-Ah pouch cell, 2 double-side coated iodine positive electrodes (10 × 15 cm), and 3 Zn negative electrodes (70 µm, 10 × 15 cm) were stacked alternately. The areal iodine loading of positive electrodes is controlled at 10 mg cm−2. Four glass fibre separators (GF/D, 10.1 × 15.1 cm) were utilized, and 1.5 ml electrolyte was added to each separator. The electrolyte consisted of 1.5 M ZnSO4, 0.5 M Zn(CH3COO)2 and 0.4 M nicotinamide. Titanium foils were connected to electrodes as tabs. After lamination, the assembled battery was encapsulated in an aluminium–plastic film and mechanically constrained using a customized model during electrochemical measurements. The applied pressure was not specifically quantified.
It has been revealed that GCD tests were conducted using a Neware battery test system in a room maintained at an ambient temperature of approximately 25–28 °C. All other electrochemical measurements described below were performed at an ambient laboratory temperature of approximately 18–25 °C. Cyclic voltammetry, linear sweep voltammetry and EIS measurements were performed using a Biologic VMP-3 potentiostat. For the electrochemical stability window analysis, linear sweep voltammetry measurements were performed using a three-electrode configuration consisting of a titanium mesh working electrode (1 × 2 cm), an AC counter electrode (1 × 2 cm) and an Ag/AgCl reference electrode at a scan rate of 2 mV s−1. The measured current was normalized to an exposed geometric area of 1 cm², and the potentials are reported directly versus Ag/AgCl. The polarization measurements were performed in asymmetric Zn–Ti CR2025 coin cells using Zn foil (16 mm in diameter), titanium foil (12 mm in diameter) and a glass fibre separator (19 mm in diameter) at a scan rate of 5 mV s−1. The measured current was normalized to the geometric area of the titanium electrode. For in situ EIS tests, a thin Zn wire was inserted into the coin cell as an additional reference electrode to establish a three-electrode configuration. This reference electrode was placed between the positive electrode and negative electrode, separated by two layers of separators (GF/A, Whatman). For measurements of the individual iodine positive electrode, the potential is reported versus the Zn reference electrode as potential (V versus Zn/Zn²+), whereas the full-cell and Zn negative electrode responses are reported as voltage (V) owing to the voltage was applied on full cell. For peak assignment, the assembled cells were connected to a Biologic VMP-3 potentiostat to perform staircase potentio EIS with a potential range of approximately 0.6–1.8 V. For rate-step identification, the assembled cells simultaneously connected to a Biologic VMP-3 potentiostat and a Neware battery test system to conduct potentio EIS and GCD cycling, respectively. All Nyquist plots were fitted using EC-Lab software based on the equivalent circuit (R1 + Q2/R2 + Q3/R3 + W4). DRT data were calculated from EIS data using MatlabR2019 with the DRT tool developed by Francesco Ciucci’s research group. The differential capacitance was calculated using the following equation:.
Sources indicate that where C is the differential capacitance, ω is the angular frequency and Zim is the imaginary component of the impedance. In this work, a specific frequency of 1,000 Hz was used. Measurements were performed in asymmetric Zn–Ti cells assembled in CR2025 coin-cell configuration, using Zn foil (16 mm in diameter) and titanium foil (12 mm in diameter) as the two electrodes and a glass fibre separator (19 mm in diameter). The potential was varied from 1.0 V to 1.7 V versus Zn/Zn2+. No ohmic-drop (iR) correction was applied to the potentials or voltages reported in this work.
In a recent development, all molecular-dynamics simulations were performed using the LAMMPS package45 to investigate the bulk solvation structure of various aqueous electrolytes. The initial configurations were constructed using Packmol46, which randomly packed electrolyte components into a periodic cubic box according to the target molar ratios, ensuring no initial atomic overlaps. The simulation cell was then relaxed by energy minimization before subsequent equilibration. Force-field parameters for organic molecules were taken from the OPLS-AA family47,48, whereas others were adopted from validated aqueous zinc salt parameter sets in the literature. To partially account for polarization effects in concentrated electrolytes, the atomic charges were uniformly scaled (scaling factor 0.8)49. Interaction of water was represented by TIP3P50, and all X–H bonds were constrained using the SHAKE algorithm51. Each system was first energy-minimized and equilibrated in the isothermal–isobaric ensemble (300 K, 1 atm) using a Nosé–Hoover thermostat until both the density and potential energy were stable. Subsequently, production runs were performed in the canonical ensemble for 5 ns (5,000 ps) with a 1-fs integration step to ensure complete equilibration while avoiding structural drift.
Sources indicate that radial distribution functions gij(r) were computed to analyse ion pairing and solvation structure. Coordination numbers were obtained by integrating gij(r) up to their first minimum. Both radial distribution functions and hydrogen bonds were identified using the hydrogen-bond analysis tools implemented in VMD52. Average hydrogen-bond numbers and distributions were determined over the equilibrated trajectories to characterize the reorganization of the hydrogen-bond network by different anions.
According to recent reports, to probe field-induced ion and molecular redistribution, an additional set of simulations was conducted in the canonical ensemble with a uniform static electric field applied along the z axis. The field strength corresponded to the experimentally estimated potential gradient.
Density-functional-theory calculations were performed using the Gaussian16 program package, using the M06-2X exchange-correlation functional53. Geometry optimizations were conducted using a mixed basis-set approach: the 6-311+G(d,p) basis set was applied to all elements excluding iodine54. Iodine was described using an effective core potential from the Stuttgart/Dresden group55. Solvent effects were accounted for using the polarizable continuum model, with water selected as the solvent56.
The data that support the findings of this study are available within this article and its Supplementary Information. Further data are available from the corresponding author upon request. Source data are provided with this paper.
It has been revealed that liang, Y. & Yao, Y. Designing modern aqueous batteries. Nat. Rev. Mater. 8, 109–122 (2022).
Article Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that xu, C. et al. Practical high-energy aqueous zinc–bromine static batteries enabled by synergistic exclusion–complexation chemistry. Joule 8, 461–481 (2024).
CAS Google Scholar.
Yang, H. et al. Interfacial ion depletion at high concentration guides electrolyte design for aqueous aluminum–iodine batteries. Joule 10, 102502 (2026).
CAS Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that li, X., Xu, W. & Zhi, C. Halogen-powered static conversion chemistry. Nat. Rev. Chem. 8, 359–375 (2024).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that zou, Y. et al. A four-electron Zn–I2 aqueous battery enabled by reversible I−/I2/I+ conversion. Nat. Commun. 12, 170 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Yang, S. et al. High-rate aqueous aluminum-ion batteries enabled by confined iodine conversion chemistry. Small Methods 5, e2100611 (2021).
PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, sambandam, B. & Kim, J. Zinc–iodine batteries with two-plus-two electron conversion chemistry: a focus review. ACS Energy Lett. 11, 3676–3688 (2026).
Liang, G. et al. Development of rechargeable high-energy hybrid zinc–iodine aqueous batteries exploiting reversible chlorine-based redox reaction. Nat. Commun. 14, 1856 (2023).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that zong, W. et al. Dynamical Janus interface design for reversible and fast-charging zinc–iodine battery under extreme operating conditions. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 146, 21377–21388 (2024).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that zhang, S. J. et al. Electroactive ferrocene/ferrocenium redox coupling for shuttle-free aqueous zinc–iodine pouch cells. Nat. Chem. 18, 266–274 (2026).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that xu, J. et al. Ion-replenishing interlayer and tailored electrolyte jointly activate four-electron zinc–iodine batteries. Adv. Mater. 38, e73355 (2026).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Wieske, L. H. E. & Erdelyi, M. Halogen bonds of halogen(I) ions horizontal line where are we and where to go? J. Am. Chem. Soc. 146, 3–18 (2024).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that lv, S. et al. A high-performance quasi-solid-state aqueous zinc-dual halogen battery. ACS Nano 16, 20389–20399 (2022).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Turunen, L. & Erdelyi, M. Halogen bonds of halonium ions. Chem. Soc. Rev. 49, 2688–2700 (2020).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Du, H. L. et al. Electroreduction of nitrogen with almost 100% current-to-ammonia efficiency. Nature 609, 722–727 (2022).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that wagner, A., Sahm, C. D. & Reisner, E. Towards molecular understanding of local chemical environment effects in electro- and photocatalytic CO2 reduction. Nat. Catal. 3, 775–786 (2020).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Hua, M. et al. Strong tough hydrogels via the synergy of freeze-casting and salting out. Nature 590, 594–599 (2021).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Zhou, Y. W., Ibáñez-Alé, E., López, N., Roldan Cuenya, B. & Kley, C. S. Carbonate anions and radicals induce interfacial water ordering in CO2 electroreduction on gold. Nat. Chem. 18, 473–481 (2026).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that zhao, Z. et al. Catalyst–electrolyte synergy enables ultrafast and long-life two-electron aqueous zinc–iodine batteries. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 0, e9322658 (2026).
CAS Google Scholar.
Guan, D. et al. π–d conjugated coordination mediated catalysis for four-electron-transfer fast-charging aqueous zinc–iodine batteries. Matter 8, 101932 (2025).
CAS Google Scholar.
Yi, Z. et al. Deciphering SN2-type nucleophilic substitution via halogen-free intermediates for high-energy zinc–iodine batteries. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 147, 26889–26897 (2025).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that xu, Y., Li, T., Peng, Z., Xie, C. & Li, X. Grid-scale corrosion-free Zn/Br flow batteries enabled by a multi-electron transfer reaction. Nat. Energy 10, 1470–1481 (2025).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that ward, J. S., Fiorini, G., Frontera, A. & Rissanen, K. Asymmetric [N–I–N]+ halonium complexes. Chem. Commun. 56, 8428–8431 (2020).
CAS Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that ye, C. et al. Harnessing interfacial solvation structure for next-generation secondary batteries. Nat. Energy 11, 167–175 (2026).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that yang, H. et al. Reunderstanding aqueous Zn electrochemistry from interfacial specific adsorption of solvation structures. Energy Environ. Sci. 16, 2910–2923 (2023).
CAS Google Scholar.
Kim, S. et al. In situ initiator-free self-polymerizing gel electrolytes under ambient conditions enabling sustainable aqueous zinc metal batteries. Small 22, e11783 (2026).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, dong, D. et al. Aqueous electrolyte solutions with anion-bridged secondary solvation sheaths for highly efficient zinc metal batteries. Nat. Nanotechnol. 21, 699–708 (2026).
Article CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that yang, J. et al. Unlocking a novel pathway for rapidly generating effective solid electrolyte interface layer inspired by tRNA working mechanism. Adv. Mater. 38, e73079 (2026).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Zhao, W. et al. Cluster level entropy enhancement in neutral acetate electrolytes enables economical and durable zinc air batteries. Nat. Commun. 17, 548 (2026).
Article CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that luo, J. et al. Regulating the inner Helmholtz plane with a high donor additive for efficient anode reversibility in aqueous Zn-ion batteries. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 62, e202302302 (2023).
CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, nau, W. M. et al. Specific ion effects of chaotropic and superchaotropic anions probed by Raman hydration-shell spectroscopy. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 65, e6630432 (2026).
CAS Google Scholar.
Jaspers, M., Rowan, A. E. & Kouwer, P. H. J. Tuning hydrogel mechanics using the Hofmeister effect. Adv. Funct. Mater. 25, 6503–6510 (2015).
CAS Google Scholar.
Smokers, I. B. et al. Selective ion binding and uptake shape the microenvironment of biomolecular condensates. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 147, 25692 (2025).
CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that ren, J. et al. Super-tough, non-swelling zwitterionic hydrogel sensor based on the Hofmeister effect for potential motion monitoring of marine animals. Adv. Mater. 36, e2412162 (2024).
PubMed Google Scholar.
Recent findings suggest that zhou, L. et al. Two-dimensional Cu plates with steady fluid fields for high-rate nitrate electroreduction to ammonia and efficient Zn-nitrate batteries. Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 63, e202401924 (2024).
CAS Google Scholar.
Huang, S., Hou, L., Li, T., Jiao, Y. & Wu, P. Antifreezing hydrogel electrolyte with ternary hydrogen bonding for high-performance zinc-ion batteries. Adv. Mater. 34, e2110140 (2022).
PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that kou, R., Zhang, J., Wang, T. & Liu, G. Interactions between polyelectrolyte brushes and Hofmeister ions: chaotropes versus kosmotropes. Langmuir 31, 10461–10468 (2015).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Chen, J., Quattrocchi, E., Ciucci, F. & Chen, Y. Charging processes in lithium–oxygen batteries unraveled through the lens of the distribution of relaxation times. Chem 9, 2267–2281 (2023).
CAS Google Scholar.
Sources indicate that huang, J. D., Meisel, C., Sullivan, N. P., Zakutayev, A. & O’Hayre, R. Rapid mapping of electrochemical processes in energy-conversion devices. Joule 8, 2049–2072 (2024).
CAS Google Scholar.
Hu, T. et al. Development of inverse-opal-structured charge-deficient Co9S8@nitrogen-doped-carbon to catalytically enable high energy and high power for the two-electron transfer I+/I− electrode. Adv. Mater. 36, e2312246 (2024).
PubMed Google Scholar.
Sun, S. et al. Eliminating interfacial O-involving degradation in Li-rich Mn-based cathodes for all-solid-state lithium batteries. Sci. Adv. 8, eadd5189 (2022).
CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that wang, H. et al. Accelerating sulfur redox kinetics by electronic modulation and drifting effects of pre-lithiation electrocatalysts. Adv. Mater. 36, e2307741 (2024).
PubMed Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that yan, C. et al. Architecting a stable high-energy aqueous Al-ion battery. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 142, 15295–15304 (2020).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Carlsson, A.-C. C. et al. Substituent effects on the [N–I–N]+ halogen bond. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 138, 9853–9863 (2016).
CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that thompson, A. P. et al. LAMMPS—a flexible simulation tool for particle-based materials modeling at the atomic, meso, and continuum scales. Comput. Phys. Commun. 271, 108171 (2022).
Martinez, L., Andrade, R., Birgin, E. G. & Martinez, J. M. PACKMOL: a package for building initial configurations for molecular dynamics simulations. J. Comput. Chem. 30, 2157–2164 (2009).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that jorgensen, W. L., Maxwell, D. S. & Tirado-Rives, J. Development and testing of the OPLS all-atom force field on conformational energetics and properties of organic liquids. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 118, 11225–11236 (1996).
CAS Google Scholar.
According to recent reports, joung, I. S. & Cheatham, T. E. III Determination of alkali and halide monovalent ion parameters for use in explicitly solvated biomolecular simulations. J. Phys. Chem. B 112, 9020–9041 (2008).
CAS PubMed PubMed Central Google Scholar.
In a recent development, leontyev, I. & Stuchebrukhov, A. Accounting for electronic polarization in non-polarizable force fields. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 13, 2613–2626 (2011).
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Jorgensen, W. L., Chandrasekhar, J., Madura, J. D., Impey, R. W. & Klein, M. L. Comparison of simple potential functions for simulating liquid water. J. Chem. Phys. 79, 926–935 (1983).
CAS Google Scholar.
Andersen, H. C. Rattle: a “velocity” version of the shake algorithm for molecular dynamics calculations. J. Comput. Phys. 52, 24–34 (1983).
CAS Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that humphrey, W., Dalke, A. & Schulten, K. VMD: visual molecular dynamics. J. Mol. Graph. 14, 33–38 (1996). 27-38.
CAS PubMed Google Scholar.
Industry observers note that zhao, Y. & Truhlar, D. G. The M06 suite of density functionals for main group thermochemistry, thermochemical kinetics, noncovalent interactions, excited states, and transition elements: two upcoming functionals and systematic testing of four M06-class functionals and 12 other functionals. Theor. Chem. Acc. 120, 215–241 (2008).
Article CAS Google Scholar.
McLean, A. & Chandler, G. Contracted Gaussian basis sets for molecular calculations. I. Second row atoms, Z = 11–18. J. Chem. Phys. 72, 5639–5648 (1980).
CAS Google Scholar.
Igel-Mann, G., Stoll, H. & Preuss, H. Pseudopotentials for main group elements (IIIa through VIIa). Mol. Phys. 65, 1321–1328 (1988).
CAS Google Scholar.
Scalmani, G. & Frisch, M. J. Continuous surface charge polarizable continuum models of solvation. I. General formalism. J. Chem. Phys. 132, 114110 (2010).
PubMed Google Scholar.
In a recent development, we acknowledge BatPaC for battery-cost calculations. We thank C. E. Knapp, J. K. Cockcroft, A. Aliev, J. Wang and L. Li for their help with the synthesis and characterization of the halogen-bond complexes; and P. R. Shearing, Z. Song and J. Chen for their assistance with the X-ray micro-computed-tomography characterization and analysis.
This work was supported by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC; EP/V027433/3), UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) under the UK government’s Horizon Europe funding (101077226; EP/Y008707/1), and the EPSRC Centre for Doctoral Training in Molecular Modelling and Materials Science (EP/L015862/1).
These authors contributed equally: Ruwei Chen, Haobo Dong.
Department of Chemistry, University College London, London, UK.
Ruwei Chen, Haobo Dong, Jingyu Wang, Jie Chen, Jiyang Liu, Jianrui Feng, Yunpeng Zhong, Wei Zhang, Hang Yang, Zhe Cui & Guanjie He.
Department of Engineering Science, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
Search author on:PubMed Google Scholar.
It has been revealed that R.C. and G.H. conceived of this work. R.C. designed and conducted the experiments. R.C. wrote the paper. G.H. supervised the research and edited the paper. H.D. performed the theoretical calculations and corresponding analysis. Y.D., J.W., J.C., J.L., J.F., Y.Z. and W. Zong helped with measurements and data analysis. W. Zhang, H.Y. and Z.C. helped with materials synthesis and electrode fabrication.
Correspondence to Guanjie He.
The authors declare no competing interests.
Industry observers note that nature thanks Min Ling, Jung Hoon Yang and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available.
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
According to recent reports, a, DRT profiles of the iodine positive electrode at different states in the KA (SO42−)-PA (CH3COO−)-Nuc electrolyte. b, DRT profiles of the iodine positive electrode at different states in the CF3SO3−-PA (CH3COO−)-Nuc electrolyte without KA. c, DRT profiles of the iodine positive electrode at different states in the KA (SO42−)-CF3SO3−-Nuc electrolyte without PA. d-f, Corresponding DRT contour plots for the KA (SO42−)-PA (CH3COO−)-Nuc, CF3SO3−-PA (CH3COO−)-Nuc, and KA (SO42−)-CF3SO3−-Nuc electrolytes, respectively. Measurements were performed using the specialized three-electrode configuration shown in Supplementary Fig. 41a. The iodine loading on the positive electrode was 2.2 mg cm−2.
a, Cycling performance of the I0/I+ conversion at 1 A g−1. b, Comparison of the measured capacity retention with that calculated from CE values. c, GCD profiles of the I0/I+ conversion. d, In situ Raman spectra of the iodine positive electrode at different discharge states. e, Ex situ Raman spectra of the cycled separators and extracted iodine positive electrode solution; inset images show the corresponding separators. f, Schematic illustration of the I0/I+ conversion and associated degradation pathways. Electrochemical measurements in a-c were performed using Zn-I2 coin cells, whereas the in situ Raman measurements in d were conducted using the dedicated in situ Zn-I2 cell configuration described in the Methods. Ex situ characterization in e was performed using Zn-I2 Swagelok cells to facilitate cell disassembly and post-cycling sample collection. The iodine mass loading was 2.2 mg cm−2 for all cell configurations.
It has been revealed that a, Cycling performance of the I−/I0 conversion at 1 A g−1. b, Comparison of the measured capacity retention with that calculated from CE values. c, GCD profiles of the I−/I0 conversion. d, In situ Raman spectra of the iodine positive electrode at different discharge states. e, Ex situ Raman spectra of the cycled separators; inset images show the corresponding separators. f, Schematic illustration of the I−/I0 conversion and associated degradation pathways. Electrochemical measurements in a-c were performed using Zn-I2 coin cells, whereas the in situ Raman measurements in d were conducted using the dedicated in situ Zn-I2 cell configuration described in the Methods. Ex situ characterization in e was performed using Zn-I2 Swagelok cells to facilitate cell disassembly and post-cycling sample collection. The iodine mass loading was 2.2 mg cm−2 for all cell configurations.
a, Comparison of the measured capacity retention with that calculated from CE values. b, Ratio of the discharge to charge capacities of the I−/I0 plateau during coupled I−/I0/I+ conversion. c, GCD profiles of the coupled I−/I0/I+ conversion, showing that the discharge capacity for the I−/I0 process exceeds the corresponding charge capacity. d, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) spectra of the cycled separator and iodine positive electrodes at different discharge states. e, Raman spectra of the cycled separator and iodine positive electrodes at different discharge states. f, GCD profiles of the decoupled I−/I0 conversion, showing that the discharge plateau is lower than the corresponding charge plateau. g, Schematic illustration of the coupled I−/I0/I+ conversion and associated degradation pathways. Electrochemical measurements were performed using Zn-I2 coin cells, whereas Zn-I2 Swagelok cells were used for the ex situ characterization to facilitate cell disassembly and post-cycling sample collection. The iodine mass loading was 2.2 mg cm−2 for all cell configurations.
Sources indicate that supplementary Figs. 1–67, Tables 1–4 and References.
Chen, R., Dong, H., Dai, Y. et al. Non-halogen aqueous electrolytes for four-electron iodine conversion. Nature 659, 372–377 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11282-0.
Version of record: 11 November 2026.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11282-0.
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:.
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (377 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

Filippo Galli praised Gerry Cardinale a few weeks ago, and he’s repeated the praise for the AC Milan chairman today.
At present, Milan are in a good place. Although they’ve had a few disappointing results in midweek games, they’ve largely been solid when it’s mattered and picked up several really impressive results.
Industry observers note that read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
According to recent reports, for Cardinale, it’s been a great start to life under Ruben Amorim – who he backed heavily in the summer – and the hope is that it will continue for the foreseeable future. In January, more investments are planned, and the aim is to continue the upward trajectory.
Speaking to Tuttosport, Galli pleaded for patience from the fans about Cardinale and Amorim, endorsing the pair heavily, as MilanNews relayed.
“I urge the fans to have patience and faith: I’m convinced that the Cardinale-Amorim project will be rewarding. This AC Milan will return to winning ways in the coming years. Scudetto? I see Inter and Roma a step above all the others for first place.
“Also keep an eye on Lazio, who are flying and only play one game a week, but AC Milan can also have their say. As a fan, I hope the Rossoneri can compete until the end.”.
“Are there talks about Inacio, Calvani, and Reggiani for the defence? They’re excellent players, but there are those who are better than me at being responsible for the club’s transfer decisions: I trust them. I’ll just say that, after Gabbia’s injury, a reinforcement is needed in the back.
Sources indicate that “Gila at full-back? I’m really enjoying the Spaniard, even as a full-back. He’s playing his newly introduced role very well, also making a significant contribution in supporting the attack. I was sure he would establish himself quickly; already at Lazio, he proved himself to be one of the best defensive players in Serie A. Great acquisition.”.
Recent findings suggest that in recent weeks, after the legends dinner, Galli has been very vocal, especially about Cardinale. The constant praise for him is telling for a figure who, until this year, has been very polarising. Long may it continue.
📅 28 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (562 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readchelsea

Jamie Gittens has withdrawn from the England Under-21 squad. He suffered an ankle injury during Tuesday’s qualifier against Kazakhstan at Molineux. The Chelsea winger left the ground on crutches. He has returned to Stamford Bridge, where the Jamie Gittens injury will now be assessed by the club’s medical staff.
Gittens picked up the knock after a challenge during the second half of England’s win over Kazakhstan. He was withdrawn as a precaution. He did not take any further part in the match. England have been careful not to overstate the problem and no further reports have come out further.
Recent findings suggest that the 21-year-old struggled to put weight on the affected ankle and was seen limping around Molineux after full time. That prompted an immediate release back to his club, rather than any attempt to assess him further in camp.
In a recent development, england Under-21 boss Lee Carsley addressed the injury directly after the game. He confirmed the nature of the knock and the decision to send Gittens home.
Sources indicate that “Jamie got a kick on his ankle,” Carsley said after the match. “We never take any risks. With the age of these players, we don’t ever keep them in camp to see how they are. He will go back.”.
England’s statement on the squad changes, detailed in a report from Football.London, confirmed the wider fallout from the fixture.
“Mukasa’s call-up follows the withdrawal of Chelsea’s Jamie Gittens and Norwich City pair Kellen Fisher and Ben Chrisene through injury,” the statement read. West Ham midfielder Divine Mukasa has been called up as cover for all three.
It has been revealed that gittens has been an unused substitute in every Premier League fixture Chelsea have played this season, with his only two appearances under Xabi Alonso coming in the Carabao Cup. Those minutes have offered him little platform after his big summer move.
Alonso’s squad selection has been a talking point since he took charge. Our earlier look at Xabi Alonso’s squad choices at Stamford Bridge covered how competitive things have become. An ankle injury will not change his pecking order in the short term. It does, though, remove any chance of him pushing his case this week.
It has been revealed that chelsea’s break has brought other headlines too. Cole Palmer also withdrew, for entirely different reasons, after his recall by senior boss Thomas Tuchel to the full England squad. Chelsea will be watching both returns closely before domestic football resumes.
Sources indicate that chelsea have not yet issued a formal revision on the severity of the injury. Any recovery timeline will depend on an assessment by the club’s medical team once Gittens is back at Cobham. Nothing beyond the crutches seen at Molineux has been confirmed.
Given his limited game time this season, the immediate concern is less about missed fixtures than a setback to his integration under Alonso. Fans can follow how the squad shapes up before the next fixtures through our recent line-up updates. Further news on Gittens is expected once Chelsea’s medical staff finish their evaluation.
According to recent reports, shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 09 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (452 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Manchester United will use the November international break to decide whether Michael Carrick stays on as head coach, after a three-game reprieve that delivered only one win.
According to The Guardian, Carrick came close to being sacked after the 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth on 25 October.
Director of football Jason Wilcox and chief executive Omar Berrada discussed his position at the training ground the following day and agreed to give him three matches to turn things around before the break.
Industry observers note that those games brought a 2-0 defeat at Chelsea, a 3-2 win over Roma and a chaotic 4-4 draw with Aston Villa at Old Trafford on Sunday. United conceded eight goals across the three fixtures, and defensive frailty remains the biggest worry.
Wilcox is now leading a review of Carrick’s position. He will consult Berrada before making a recommendation to Sir Jim Ratcliffe, who oversees the club’s sporting operations. Talks are expected to begin on Monday and continue through the break.
It has been revealed that the league table makes grim reading. United sit in the Premier League relegation zone with just one league win in their last 10 matches.
In a recent development, if he does win a stay of execution, results will need to follow. Manchester United cannot be languishing in 17th place.
Carrick remains defiant. Speaking to Sky Sports News after the Villa draw, he admitted his side “haven’t won enough games” but insisted he expects to move forward.
“I’m quite clear with what direction the club needs to go in, and it’s got to win games, remarked Carrick after the late Villa draw.
“I think there’s more than enough [to turn things around].”.
Recent findings suggest that if United do make a change, former Newcastle manager Eddie Howe is reported to be Wilcox’s preferred candidate. Howe has been out of work since leaving St James’ Park during pre-season, after four and a half years in charge.
In the meantime, there are no aims to strengthen Carrick’s coaching staff.
It has been revealed that for now, Carrick is expected to be in charge for United’s next match, against Liverpool. Whether three games were enough to convince the hierarchy should become clear before then.
The trip to Anfield could be do or die for the decorated former United midfielder.
He’s not likely to survive a heavy defeat at the home of the club’s fierce rivals, but a galvanising win would surely buy him time and goodwill.
It has been revealed that that’s if he makes it through the next fortnight before then. A decision or indication could be two days or two weeks away.
The only certainty at Old Trafford is uncertainty.
📅 26 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 32 min read (6419 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Co

It has been revealed that there had been so much talk – first raised by Thomas Tuchel after the shocking World Cup exit to Argentina – about England’s DNA. About whether they could keep the ball, pass the ball, control the ball, the way Spain do.
The world and European champions were England’s first opponents – after the World Cup – in this Nations League campaign and came away from Wembley with a deserved win. They are now 39 games unbeaten with substitute Mikel Oyarzabal, who scored the winning goal against England in the final of the last European Championship, doing so again.
Sources indicate that mikel Oyarzabal SCORES against England AGAIN! 🎯Spain retake the lead after a slick finish from the Spaniard 👏#ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/pPT3KvRHWl.
That may have been no surprise, even if the inevitable “olés” after Spain’s third goal will have hurt. But the nature of it? For the England manager this was another shocker. Not in the way his team went about the task. They were positive, fun, attacking. But in the way they conceded – goals and chances – and lost.
On this performance, DNA, for England, stands for Defensively Not Able, as they threw away what could have been a famous and restorative victory. Instead, with Croatia beating the Czech Republic in the other group game, England are under immediate pressure to win in Prague on Tuesday.
In a recent development, in fact, England have conceded 13 goals in their past six matches – in fairness including four in that third-place World Cup 6-4 win over France – and that is not good enough for a top-tier nation. Tuchel needs to sort it out defensively.
According to recent reports, it could have been very different if Harry Kane had not missed from the penalty spot, slipping as he struck the ball, with England improbably 2-1 ahead. “It would have been the decisive punch,” Tuchel stated. Maybe so, even if there was always the feeling that Spain could go through the gears.
It has been revealed that kane MISSES from the penalty spot! 😧Harry Kane slips when he strikes the ball, let off for Spain and Luis de la Fuente#ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/pvg3GGa9ma.
Industry observers note that afterwards there were claims, led by the impressive Anthony Gordon, that this was a missed opportunity for England. A bit like the World Cup. They need to shake this theme.
The irony was this was one of their best creative displays for quite some time. They took the game to Spain and could have scored more. And conceded more.
In truth it could have been Spain 4 England 0 inside half an hour and before Tuchel’s team laid a glove on their opponents.
Another let off for England 😧Ferran Torres misses another big chance one-on-one with James Trafford #ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/KFkJoJUW6c.
The manager had also spoken about how England should “embrace the chaos” as their best route to success. That may appear a questionable tactic – does chaos ever win a tournament? – but England certainly did that. This was as chaotic and, admittedly, entertaining as it gets.
England attacked with pace and power with the pick of their players the two based in Spain: Gordon, who scored, and Jude Bellingham. And the defenders? This was a bad night for Marc Guéhi, his Manchester City team-mate Nico O’Reilly (cue speculation about whether they were distracted by the verdict on the Premier League charges against their club) and for Jarell Quansah at right-back who is so evidently a centre-half.
According to recent reports, A penny, once more, for the thoughts of the unused Trent Alexander-Arnold. The fourth defender, Ezri Konsa, vented his frustration at what was happening around him.
It was not just the errors but the unforced nature of them. Poor in possession with misplaced passes and defensively wide open. There is a gap between Spain and England but not as big as the gaps that were exposed in England’s back four. They endured a full house of calamities. They seemed strangely unaware – or incapable of dealing with – the danger posed by the outstanding Lamine Yamal.
Maybe because of the opposition – or the criticism – England felt the need to play out. But what an horrific start. What an inexplicable moment for Guéhi as he received the ball from O’Reilly and turned into trouble, gifting possession to Yamal who ran on and scored. Inside two minutes.
WHAT A START FROM SPAIN 🇪🇸Lamine Yamal pounces on a Marc Guéhi error to give Spain an early lead at Wembley #ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/Et83EyTPlp.
Sources indicate that spain walked out with the second star on their shirt – to mark their second World Cup triumph. That was the star Tuchel had promised for England.
Industry observers note that now, straight away, they were up against it. It could have turned very ugly. Ferran Torres, who had scored the winner in the World Cup Final, had one disallowed for offside, then was thwarted by James Trafford after – inexplicably again – being played onside by Quansah.
SIGNIFICANT SAVE from James Trafford 🧤The Leeds United goalkeeper keeps out Ferran Torres#ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/nj5b8AUSQU.
Then Torres was sent clear following Elliot Anderson’s poor pass, only to drag his shot wide. The third miss came from Dani Olmo, again set up by Yamal.
It could – it should – have been game over. Then England unexpectedly turned it around. They had kept attacking despite what was going on at the back and struck through a truly thrilling counter-attack, with Gordon and Bellingham combining before the Barcelona winger calmly beat goalkeeper Unai Simon.
Recent findings suggest that ENGLAND ARE LEVEL! 🏴A brilliant finish from Anthony Gordon after a breathtaking counter attack 👏#ITVFootball | @England pic.twitter.com/z0nSfWIHVd.
It was an exceptional goal and was quickly followed by a fortunate one as O’Reilly’s cross was met by Kane who stooped to steer in a header, only for it to strike Marc Cucurella, who made a mess of clearing, and it went past Simón.
I think we'll give that goal to Harry Kane 🎯England come from behind to lead Spain thanks Harry Kane, with assistance from Marc Cucurella ⚽️#ITVFootball | @England pic.twitter.com/X3qSOWUhVT.
The Spain left-back hit the post with a cross, misjudged by Trafford who was given this game and the next to stake his claim ahead of Jordan Pickford who has so long been the undisputed first-choice.
England dominated for a while and Bellingham won a penalty, after a VAR intervention, only for Kane to strike the crossbar.
Sources indicate that how Spain made them pay and worryingly so. O’Reilly passed the ball straight to Olmo who swept it inside. Substitute Álex Baena checked and beat Trafford from the edge of the area. Even worse was how Spain cut through the heart of England defence with Baena finding Oyarzabal. Why was no defender closer to him? What was Guéhi doing? And O’Reilly? Oyarzabal exquisitely dinked the ball over Trafford.
Thomas Tuchel does not think Manchester City’s guilty verdict over almost all of their Premier League charges distracted his England players in the Nations League defeat to Spain.
City players Marc Guéhi and Nico O’Reilly were at fault for two of Spain’s goals and both Tuchel, the head coach, and England captain Harry Kane confirmed news of the verdict had been discussed among the squad.
Tuchel does not plan to address the issue with his players ahead of the remaining Nations League games against Czech Republic and Croatia.
In a recent development, asked if the City verdict had been a cause of discussion ahead of the Spain game, Tuchel replied: “Not for me, but I can imagine maybe for the Man City players. I won’t comment on it as it’s an ongoing case.
Industry observers note that “I didn’t make it a topic. It was not a topic for me. I’m just thinking about Spain and the team and meetings. The players have more time than me. So I can imagine they talk about it. It’s good they do. I don’t think it was a distraction for them.”.
Kane added: “There was a discussion, but when we’re with England, we kind of put club football to one side and it was no different this week.”.
Tuchel also refused to point the finger of blame at Guéhi, O’Reilly or Kane, who missed a penalty, for England’s defeat despite admitting his team got off to the worst possible start by conceding a goal after two minutes.
“We will focus on the positives, but also highlight the stuff we can do better,” Tuchel noted. “Not even speaking about individual mistakes because this is normal. It just happens. It should not happen, and for sure not in this amount. But there is no sense in showing the individual mistakes or telling them ‘please don’t make mistakes’. That is normal, but we can do things better. We can defend the third goal better. But we will focus on the positives. There is a lot to take away from the game.
Sources indicate that “We wanted to be the team desperately to beat them [Spain] and we think we had them. We still think we had them at half-time. That was the way the team highlighted up after half-time. So we will focus on that, but the reality is we lost and the reality is we need to prove it again.”.
Sources indicate that “It was a terrible start, the worst possible start, which makes it so difficult against a team like this. The reaction was very good. After 10/12 minutes, we were the better team but we gave away too many mistakes. We were the better team. If we had converted the penalty, it could have been the decisive moment. We have to keep going and learn from the mistakes. We could have created more if we had been more clinical in the final 20 metres. We revealed great bravery and courage with our high-ball wins. There will always be moments you suffer against teams like this. The effort and quality were there tonight but the result does not prove it today.”.
It has been revealed that “I think there is a gap [between Spain and England]. They [Spain] are the world champions and European champions. Mikel Oyarzabal was never going to miss. He was always in control of the situation. Honestly, people talk about sexy football, that is sexy football. I would watch that all night.”.
🗣️ "We went toe to toe with the European and world champions" 💪Harry Kane remains positive about England performance despite their 3-2 defeat to Spain 🏴🇪🇸#ITVFootball | @gabrielclarke05 | @England pic.twitter.com/qkhqsqmPEl.
🗣️ "You have to beat them to show people we can do this" 💪@IanWright0 reflects on England's 3-2 defeat to Spain at Wembley#ITVFootball | @markpougatch pic.twitter.com/ko2FYs4VqA.
It has been revealed that marc Guehi and Nico O’Reilly may want to look away now but Jude Bellingham and Anthony Gordon scored well. Our very own Mike McGrath has provided his player ratings.
Tonight: England 2 Spain 3 (H)Tuesday September 29: Czech Republic (A), kick-off 7.45pmSaturday October 3: Croatia (A), kick-off 5pmTuesday October 6: Czech Republic (H), kick-off 7.45pm.
🗣️ "I think it's a bit of a missed chance" 👀Anthony Gordon says mistakes cost England the win tonight against Spain at Wembley 🏴#ITVFootball | @gabrielclarke05 | @England pic.twitter.com/AJBxVNjbjq.
According to recent reports, A highly entertaining game. England will probably argue the game changed on Kane’s missed penalty, but Spain missed a lot of very clear chances and will feel they deserved the victory. A losing start to the Nations League for Tuchel and his team, but there were some positives. Gordon, Bellingham and Anderson were all excellent. Some of the defending, not so excellent.
Possession: England 47%-53% SpainShots: 13-15Shots on target: 5-5Corners: 6-3Touches in opposition box: 37-15.
Sources indicate that england have one last chance with a corner out on the left. This will be it. Spain are able to deal with it and clear their lines.
Then comes the final whistle at Wembley and the world champions Spain claim a 3-2 victory in north London. It was an absorbing game, where momentum swung one way and then the other, but it is Spain who are the victors.
Industry observers note that baena brings down Rogers with a silly challenge to gift England a free-kick deep in the Spanish half. This could be England’s last chance.
Anderson is over it but his delivery is poor, easily caught by Unai Simon.
England are running out of time to find an equaliser.
O’Reilly appears to be suffering with cramp but England have made all five substitutions.
There will be five added minutes.
A late change for England as Branthwaite replaces Guehi.
Rogers delivers a dangerous cross from the right that runs through the six-yard box and forces Pubill to put it behind for a corner.
England take it short before Anderson clips it in but Laporte heads away.
According to recent reports, garner should have done so much better with that. His run into the Spain box on the left side is picked out by Anderson’s pass. Garner has Calvert-Lewin waiting at the back post but the former massively overhits the cross.
Recent findings suggest that double substitution from England as Calvert-Lewin and Gibbs-White replace Kane and Saka. Rare to say Kane taken off, especially when England are behind.
Industry observers note that saka goes down under a challenge from Cucurella inside the Spain penalty box but no penalty is forthcoming. VAR has cleared the incident. Moments later, Bellingham is then booked for stopping Spain going on the counter.
Spain make a change as Merino replaces Olmo.
The way Spain control possession and keep the ball is impressive. They toy with you pretty well and often look so composed.
According to recent reports, baena, who has been superb since coming on, feeds a lovely pass into the path of Oyarzabal on the right side of the box. Oyarzabal takes one touch before lifting it over Trafford into the England net. That is a lovely assist from Baena and lovely finish from Oyarzabal.
In a recent development, mikel Oyarzabal SCORES against England AGAIN! 🎯Spain retake the lead after a slick finish from the Spaniard 👏#ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/pPT3KvRHWl.
Given the quality of the opposition and the sustained threat he carried, that might have been Gordon’s best-ever performance in an England shirt. Him and Bellingham have been excellent. But now he’s been replaced by Morgan Rogers.
Guehi joins O’Reilly in the book for a cynical foul on Olmo. You can put that yellow card in the category of a professional foul.
England are making a double change as Garner and Rogers come on for Lewis-Skelly and Gordon. Garner was not in the initial squad but takes his chance now after the withdrawals.
Spain also make a substitution as Pedri replaces Ruiz.
At one end, Yamal has a shot blocked after England gave the ball away before Lewis-Skelly’s shot down the other end is easily saved.
The first booking of the night sees O’Reilly shown a yellow card for a foul on Yamal.
In a recent development, england come close to going back in front. After good work from Bellingham, Saka has it on the right side of the box. Saka cuts inside onto his left and looks to pick out the far corner but his effort goes narrowly wide.
Industry observers note that another big mistake from England is punished. It is absolutely dreadful from O’Reilly, who gives the ball away so poorly deep inside the England half. Spain capitalise and it is the man who has only just come on, Baena, who curls into the bottom corner from the edge of the box. All to play for with half an hour to go at Wembley.
SPAIN EQUALISE! 🇪🇸A brilliant finish from Alex Baena after a Nico O'Reilly mistake 🎯#ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/tXygPfbPmb.
Yamal and Baena exchange a lovely one-two on the right side of the box and you think the former will find the far corner but his effort goes wide.
How did Yamal MISS that! 🤯A big opportunity goes begging to pull Spain level! #ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/jyzLm9VBd5.
Cucurella has a real habit of making himself unpopular wherever he plays. The Wembley crowd have been booing his every touch and were not happy with him staying down after the ball hit him in the head. Spain haven’t got going at all in this second half.
Spain have made a double change as Oyarzabal and Baena replace Torres and Williams.
It has been revealed that kane steps up but his effort smashes into the bar. Kane slipped just as he took it. In fact, a free-kick is given to Spain as it was a double hit.
Sources indicate that kane MISSES from the penalty spot! 😧Harry Kane slips when he strikes the ball, let off for Spain and Luis de la Fuente#ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/pvg3GGa9ma.
According to recent reports, the referee overturns the original decision and points to the spot. A foul from a Barcelona midfielder on a Real Madrid midfielder is given.
Yet more England appeals for a penalty. Bellingham goes down, believing he was fouled by Rodri, but the referee gives nothing. There is contact but is it enough for a penalty? The referee had a good view and there is a decent shout for a penalty.
The referee is being sent to the screen so we know what that usually means...
Certainly no sitting on the lead from England at the start of the second half. Tuchel was adamant that Bellingham should have been awarded a penalty after going down in the area.
And Tuchel might get his way as VAR have sent referee Davide Massa to the screen.
England want a penalty. Saka goes down under a challenge from Laporte from behind but those appeals are waved away. VAR checks and clears the incident. Laporte got the ball.
Chance for England. Bellingham’s cross from the left picks out Quansah in the centre of the box but the defender’s header from eight yards out misses the target. What an opportunity that was for Quansah to score his first international goal.
Industry observers note that spain are unbeaten in nearly 40 competitive matches and, as it stands, that run is set to come to an end. Still a long way to come though tonight and Spain could have been 3-0 up before England even scored one goal.
Recent findings suggest that we are back under way at Wembley. No changes for either side at the break.
During half-time, Kyle Walker received a framed shirt to celebrate his 96 England caps.
What a response from our #ThreeLions! 💪 pic.twitter.com/qBoY0J79JL.
Sources indicate that 2 - Lamine Yamal has scored the third quickest goal England have ever conceded at Wembley Stadium, behind only first minute goals for Scotland in 1957 and Hungary in 1953.Punch. pic.twitter.com/NxVp1qOnVi.
Possession: England 45%-55% SpainShots: 6-8Shots on target: 2-2Corners: 3-3Touches in opposition box: 10-10.
It has been revealed that tuchel will be delighted with the half-time score and England’s spirit after going behind so early. But how on earth have Spain only scored once? They’ve missed a couple of one-on-ones, hit the post and blazed over the bar. Highly entertaining and England will know they will have to defend better if they are going to hold on to their lead.
Recent findings suggest that an absorbing and end-to-end first half is brought to an end. Somehow, despite the fact at one point they could have been 3-0 down, England lead 2-1 at the break.
Cucurella’s cross from the left loops all the way to the back post, where it strikes the frame of the goal. I do not think Cucurella meant that.
There will be one added minute.
It is chances galore at both ends, with the latest falling to Ruiz, whose shot from the edge of the box is deflected wide for a corner. Bellingham heads away at the front post.
England gift the ball away so poorly and Yamal should punish them with his second goal of the game but he blazes high over the bar.
It has been revealed that what on earth has happened to Spain? O’Reilly’s cross from the byline picks out Kane, who guides a header towards goal. Cucurella makes an absolute mess of things, effectively kneeing the ball past his keeper and into his own net. Kane will try and claim it but surely that has to go down as an own goal. 10 minutes ago, Spain should have been 3-0 up. Now, England are 2-1 ahead.
I think we'll give that goal to Harry Kane 🎯England come from behind to lead Spain thanks Harry Kane, with assistance from Marc Cucurella ⚽️#ITVFootball | @England pic.twitter.com/X3qSOWUhVT.
In a recent development, england are inches away from taking the lead. Saka drives forward towards the Spain box and lays it across to Kane, whose shot goes just wide. Should Kane have scored? Maybe.
SO CLOSE FROM KANE! 🫣England nearly go in front 🏴#ITVFootball | @England pic.twitter.com/YgoRblxuiH.
Sources indicate that somehow, England are on level terms. Spain should have been 3-0 up but England equalise with a clinical counter-attack. Anderson wins the ball back for England on the edge of their own box and plays it forward to Gordon, who flicks it brilliantly first time into the path of Bellingham, who drives into the Spain half. Gordon is on his bike and is ready to receive the forward pass from Bellingham. Gordon takes it to the Spain box before slotting home clinically past Simon.
Industry observers note that ENGLAND ARE LEVEL! 🏴A brilliant finish from Anthony Gordon after a breathtaking counter attack 👏#ITVFootball | @England pic.twitter.com/z0nSfWIHVd.
England have missed Declan Rice’s delivery so far this evening. Saka has floated a couple of corners straight into the hands of Spain goalkeeper Simon and there have been some promising free-kicks wasted too.
According to recent reports, no love lost between the Real Madrid team-mates Jude Bellingham and Marc Cucurella, there. Bellingham was unhappy with a challenge from the left-back and let’s just say they exchanged words afterwards.
If Olmo had slotted that home, the assist from Yamal would have been quite incredible. A quite sensational flick from Yamal plays Olmo in behind on the right side of the box and the latter’s shot goes narrowly wide of the far post.
Saka’s shot is blocked and the ball spins behind for an England corner out on the right. Saka takes the corner he won but his inswinger is caught by Unai Simon.
According to recent reports, england want a penalty. Lewis-Skelly goes down inside the Spain penalty area under a challenge from Cubarsi and his appeals are waved away. The referee was spot on with that call.
That is a second sitter missed of the half from Torres and Spain should be 3-0 up. Rodri times his through ball to perfection and Torres’ first touch is glorious to take him past Anderson and away. Torres is one-on-one with Trafford and should score but his effort slides by the left post. How Spain are not 3-0 up is beyond me.
Another let off for England 😧Ferran Torres misses another major chance one-on-one with James Trafford #ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/KFkJoJUW6c.
That is a waste from Bellingham. The Real Madrid man is found by Quansah on the edge of the box and Bellingham should get his shot off promptly but dithers for too long. Bellingham then goes down far too softly, wanting a free-kick, but those appeals are rightly waved away.
England have enjoyed more of the possession thus far but are still yet to register a shot through 25 minutes.
Recent findings suggest that the Spain fans are certainly enjoying their night in north London. In general, they have a lot to be happy about right now holding the World Cup and Euros trophies as well as the fact that their team is 1-0 up this evening.
That is a substantial save from Trafford and a big miss from Torres. Yamal plays a through ball to pick out the run of Torres, whom many in the ground think is offside. However, he was clearly being played onside by Quansah and Torres, who is fine scoring form this season for PSG, should score with a one-on-one opportunity but is denied by Trafford. England could and perhaps should be 2-0 down.
BIG SAVE from James Trafford 🧤The Leeds United goalkeeper keeps out Ferran Torres#ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/nj5b8AUSQU.
Anderson plays a lovely switch from right to left to pick out Gordon in space. Gordon takes just one touch before getting it out of his feet quickly, curling a cross to the back post. He is looking for Saka but Cucurella just about deals with it, even though he did not know much about it. The ball appeared to come off Cucurella last but a goal-kick is given.
After a very shaky start, England are beginning to grow into the game, slowly, but it is gradually happening.
England are really not helping themselves at the moment, gifting the ball away in dangerous area. This time it is Lewis-Skelly who gives it away and Spain end up with a corner.
The delivery is drilled to the edge of the box, where Yamal’s powerful volley is blocked by Gordon.
Sources indicate that spain keep it alive and the ball comes back into the England box. Torres fires into the bottom corner but the offside flag goes up and replays show he was clearly offside.
The OFFSIDE Flag saves England's blushes 👀Ferran Torres saw his close range finish chalked off #ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/unIj6NsO7z.
Industry observers note that england have their first sight of the Spain goal. Kane plays Gordon in down the left and the latter gets past his man easily. He gets to the byline before crossing but Unai Simon in the Spain goal is on hand to cut it out.
What on earth are you doing Guehi? Spain take the lead inside two minutes and it is a real gift. Guehi should pass to O’Reilly or Gordon to his left but instead comes back towards his own goal, seemingly unaware that Yamal is right behind him. What then follows is a clinical finish from Yamal, who drives into the England box before curling towards the far corner, with the ball going in off the inside of the post. That will help Yamal’s pursuit of the Ballon d’Or. Dreadful from Guehi, fantastic from Yamal.
WHAT A START FROM SPAIN 🇪🇸Lamine Yamal pounces on a Marc Guéhi error to give Spain an early lead at Wembley #ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/Et83EyTPlp.
Now Tuchel is out with his arms crossed after that nightmare start from England. The Spain fans are in good voice.
We are under way at Wembley. There is VAR in use.
Tuchel was not shown on the big screens ahead of kick-off. He’s just got up off his seat for the first time and entered his technical area to complain about something.
It has been revealed that before we get under way at Wembley, we stop to remember the great Kevin Keegan with a minute’s applause, with a wreath being laid down on the side of the pitch. England are also wearing black armbands to remember Keegan. Wembley also pays tribute to a few other England players who have died over recent months.
England: Trafford, Quansah, Konsa, Guehi, O’Reilly, Anderson, Lewis-Skelly, Bellingham, Saka, Gordon, Kane.Substitutes: Pickford, Alexander-Arnold, Scott, Chalobah, Hall, Branthwaite, Rogers, Garner, Calvert-Lewin, Gibbs-White, Eze, Steele.
Spain: Unai, Pubill, Cubarsi, Laporte, Cucurella, Rodri, Ruiz, Olmo, Yamal, Williams, Torres.Substitutes: Raya, Martinez, Huijsen, Grimaldo, Merino, Lopez, Pino, Baena, Zubimendi, Pedri, Oyarzabal.
As feels customary at every England game, Oasis rings around the stadium to build up the atmosphere.
In a recent development, here come the two sides and it is time for the national anthems. Marcha Real followed by God Save The King. There are plenty of Spanish supporters in attendance tonight and they are making their voices heard.
Here comes the Wonderwall compilation. Harry Kane remarked yesterday that he wants to win the Nations League next summer and then celebrate by going to one of the Oasis gigs.
Spain have been forced into a late alteration during the warm-ups and it comes at right-back, with Eric Garcia injured so Marc Pubill comes in.
According to recent reports, I quite like Tuchel’s idea of giving Trafford the first two Nations League games, against Spain tonight and Czech Republic in Prague, and then going back to Pickford for the final two, in Croatia and against the Czechs at home. How will we ever know if England have an alternative to Pickford if nobody ever gets a proper go?
Sources indicate that chelsea’s Cole Palmer was one of a number of England withdrawals. Thomas Tuchel had his say on Palmer missing too many games in his press conference and ITV’s Roy Keane has had his say:.
Industry observers note that “If you think he is going to get England to another level, forget about it. I watched him before the break against Brentford. I think he has far too many bad habits for me.”.
According to recent reports, harry Kane or Lamine Yamal? 🏆The ITV panel discuss some of the contenders to win the 2026 Ballon d'Or#ITVFootball | @markpougatch | @IanWright0 | @juanmata8 pic.twitter.com/bssBX0ljWF.
The England players all got good receptions from the England fans inside Wembley when their names were read out. We’re yet to see head coach Thomas Tuchel on the pitch or the big screens. Will he also get a big cheer? He was booed by England fans ahead of the World Cup bronze medal match in Miami.
🗣️ "They're [Spain] the team to beat" 💪Thomas Tuchel is excited about being the first team to play Spain after they were crowned World Cup champions 🏴#ITVFootball | @England pic.twitter.com/s0z737Vsfm.
🗣️ "It's always nice to come back and see your own fans again" ❤️Jarell Quansah is excited to be back at Wembley taking on the World champions, Spain 🏴🇪🇸#ITVFootball | @gabrielclarke05 pic.twitter.com/fsAZOIrHxq.
Thomas Tuchel has confirmed that James Trafford will start the first two games of this international break and then Jordan Pickford will start the other two. Tuchel insists that Pickford “has done nothing wrong”.
In a recent development, thomas Tuchel has decided to start Leeds’ James Trafford in goal instead of Jordan Pickford. Is that the right decision? You can have your say in the comments section at the bottom of the blog.
Sources indicate that thomas Tuchel is limited to a 23-man matchday squad for this game, so Rio Ngumoha is not on the bench. The Liverpool forward impressed during the pre-World Cup squad in Florida when he earned his first cap. It would be harsh if he did not make the bench over the course of the international break, with two matches against Czech Republic and a clash against Croatia coming up.
🗣️ "They were cheating and they have to take their medicine" 👀The ITV Panel discuss Man City being allegedly found guilty of breaching 114 of 115 charges relating to the Premier League's financial regulations@markpougatch |@IanWright0 | @juanmata8 pic.twitter.com/Lf9GdBX9Tg.
🗣️ "We didn't show any bravery against Argentina" 👀@IanWright0 reflects on England's World Cup exit at the hands of Argentina #ITVFootball | @markpougatch pic.twitter.com/10Y3TtsFm6.
It has been revealed that 🗣️ "We played with the mindset [vs. Argentina] that we have something to lose"Thomas Tuchel reflects on England's World Cup exit to Argentina 🏴#ITVFootball | @gabrielclarke05 | @England pic.twitter.com/kIHMx8bDE1.
England: Trafford, Quansah, Konsa, Guehi, O’Reilly, Anderson, Lewis-Skelly, Bellingham, Saka, Gordon, Kane.Substitutes: Pickford, Alexander-Arnold, Scott, Chalobah, Hall, Branthwaite, Rogers, Garner, Calvert-Lewin, Gibbs-White, Eze, Steele.
Spain: Unai, Garcia, Cubarsi, Laporte, Cucurella, Rodri, Ruiz, Olmo, Yamal, Williams, Torres.Substitutes: Raya, Martinez, Huijsen, Grimaldo, Merino, Lopez, Pino, Pubill, Baena, Zubimendi, Pedri, Oyarzabal.
Harry Kane wants England to address how they lost their identity and went “against our beliefs” at the World Cup.
In a brutally honest assessment of the tournament, the England captain admitted Thomas Tuchel’s team did not play to their full potential in several games – even before the painful semi-final exit against Argentina.
Kane, who played golf instead of watching the World Cup final, revealed the 2-1 Atlanta defeat hurt more than missing a penalty four years earlier in Qatar, when England were knocked out by France in the quarter-finals.
Sources indicate that “This one hurt more than any other one. I would probably say even more than when I missed a penalty in Qatar because of the manner that it happened,” Kane remarked. “It was not us as a team.
According to recent reports, “We trust our players and the player know very well that if you miss a camp then someone plays well in your position that the competition is always on. You have to make sure to be available and to produce top-level performances in camp and if you do so, that counts for something. Right now, it is not on my list of worries. I am not wired like this. From the moment I arrived at SGP my full focus is 100 per cent with the players who are here.
“There is no threat, distrust or threat of consequences. It will come naturally. I truly believe that we have the opposite. You will talk to our captain, Harry Kane, who has the most minutes for club and country and is happy to be here while teammates of his are enjoying a 10-day break. He is the role model and that is the vibe we have here.”.
🚨 THE XI IS IN. 🇪🇸Upcoming adventure. Same hunger. 🔥Here's our starting XI to take on England.#VamosEspaña | #NationsL pic.twitter.com/jP87xd7TfJ.
Sources indicate that this is the first meeting between these two nations since the Euro 2024 final in Berlin. From that team, only Harry Kane, Marc Guehi, Bukayo Saka and Jude Bellingham are starting tonight. Most of Spain’s winners from that evening are playing here at Wembley. Dani Carvajal, Robin Le Normand and Alvaro Morata are those who are not playing from that team.
According to recent reports, the numbers make for interesting reading for England 👀Only 1️⃣ win in the last 5️⃣ matches vs. the current World and European champions 🏴🇪🇸#ITVFootball pic.twitter.com/29QR8MBtra.
According to recent reports, your England team to take on Spain! 💪 pic.twitter.com/9L03iN5dl7.
Tonight: Spain (H), kick-off 7.45pmTuesday September 29: Czech Republic (A), kick-off 7.45pmSaturday October 3: Croatia (A), kick-off 5pmTuesday October 6: Czech Republic (H), kick-off 7.45pm.
Harry Kane has ARRIVED at Wembley 🏟️#ITVFootball | @England pic.twitter.com/RsfXWok4KB.
In memory of Kevin Keegan ❤️Today's official matchday programme ⤵️.
They do have plenty to cheer about:.
James Trafford is poised to start for England ahead of Jordan Pickford against Spain tonight.
Pickford has been England’s No1 for eight years but Thomas Tuchel is set to make a change to face the world champions in the Nations League opener at Wembley.
Trafford went to the World Cup in the summer and has started the Premier League in good form following his move to Leeds.
In the first match since the World Cup, changing his goalkeeper is a major selection decision from Tuchel.
Elsewhere, Jarell Quansah is set to play at right-back ahead of Trent Alexander-Arnold while Myles Lewis-Skelly is also in line to return to the starting XI after being recalled into the squad after missing the World Cup.
England begin their Nations League campaign with a home game against the world champions Spain. This is England’s first game since the World Cup, with their dreams of glory ended by Argentina in the semi-finals, but they did finish third after beating France in a high-scoring third/fourth play-off. The last meeting between these sides saw Spain beat England to win Euro 2024. They also faced off in the Nations League back in 2018, with Spain winning at Wembley and England taking victory over in Spain.
Industry observers note that england’s aims for these games has been disrupted by a number of withdrawals. Cole Palmer had earned a recall having been left out of the World Cup squad but the Chelsea forward has withdrawn due to a minor injury, despite playing the full game for Chelsea against Brentford in the final game before the international beak.
It has been revealed that “He [Palmer] plays with discomfort and pain and cannot play on the highest level with discomfort and pain,” Tuchel remarked. “Chelsea informed us. That is my understanding. We are not managing load. This is not an ‘international break’. It is a competitive environment, where the players love to train and be together. That is what we created. We will never compromise on that. We will never let this feeling creep in that the players do not want to come [to England camps]. We focus on the guys who absolutely want to play for England.
“For sure it is a missed opportunity. It is another missed opportunity. He misses too many opportunities. I do not blame him for it, it is just a fact. He misses way too many camps with injuries. I only want to rely on what I personally witness and see within my team. For that you have to be in camp. If you are not in camp there is a next level to impress that you cannot achieve because you can only do it with me on the pitch and with us on the pitch. It is a missed opportunity.”.
Industry observers note that declan Rice has also withdrawn from the squad despite playing the full game in Arsenal’s defeat to Brighton as have Kobbie Mainoo, Marcus Rashford and Tino Livramento. Morgan Gibbs-White and James Garner have been called up as a result.
Recent findings suggest that trent Alexander-Arnold is back in the fold for the first time since June 2025. 18-year-old Liverpool winger Rio Ngumoha made his England debut against New Zealand during the World Cup warm-ups and takes his place in this squad, although he does make the matchday squad for tonight’s game. England will also take on Czechia, Croatia and then Cezchia again during this international break.
Having been crowned world champions back in July, Spain are now champions of both Europe and the world. Back in June 2025, Spain made the Nations League final but lost on penalties to Portugal. Ahead of this international window, The Royal Spanish Federation has extended Luis de la Fuente’s contract until 2032. After tonight, Spain will host Croatia and Czechia before travelling to Croatia to cap off this international window.
This is an extended international break, with four games to take place during this window. Team news from Wembley to follow shortly.
📅 28 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (549 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readchelsea

According to recent reports, roma have put an £86m (€100m) price tag on Manu Koné, according to Gazzetta dello Sport, reviving the Manu Koné Chelsea transfer link that first emerged over the summer. Roma want any interested club, including Chelsea, to know the price before serious talks can even begin.
Koné remains under contract at the Stadio Olimpico, and he has become a key part of Roma’s midfield since his move from Borussia Mönchengladbach. The Gazzetta report reads like a warning to potential buyers rather than proof of any talks between the two clubs.
Roma sporting director Tony D’Amico has confirmed Chelsea made contact late in the summer window, though he was quick to draw a clear line under how far things went.
“There was an inquiry and some preliminary contact with Chelsea on the final day of the transfer window. No official offers arrived that would allow us to approach the player. Something was imagined that simply didn’t happen. There was no official offer; the final day of the transfer window got everyone a little worked up.”.
D’Amico’s comments confirm Chelsea looked at signing Koné before the deadline, but they stop well short of showing an official bid was ever made. He also explained why Roma had no wish to sell a key player so close to the window closing.
“Before the match against Fiorentina (on 24 August), I said it would be difficult for us to deprive ourselves of vital players so near to the end of the transfer session, and so it proved. Kone is an important player, we’re happy he stayed with us, and we’re confident he’ll give his contribution during the season.”.
Chelsea’s midfield has changed shape under Xabi Alonso since the summer, with Morgan Rogers arriving to add depth and competition for places. That signing came during a window that also saw exits acceleration under Xabi Alonso, as the head coach reshaped his squad around his own style.
It has been revealed that koné’s ball winning and his range of progressive passing would suit Alonso well, should Chelsea ever revisit their interest. Supporters have already seen how Alonso rotates his midfield for the biggest games, including the recent derby line-up selections against Brentford.
According to recent reports, for now, Rogers and Chelsea’s existing central options give Alonso enough cover without needing an immediate signing. Roma’s reluctance to sell also means any deal would need patience rather than a quick resolution.
Nothing in D’Amico’s comments suggests Roma are open to a sale in the near term, and Koné has given no sign that he wants to leave. The £86m valuation, reported by Football London, stands as Roma’s marker rather than an asking price involved with Chelsea.
Sources indicate that will Chelsea return with a more formal approach in a future window? D’Amico’s comments give no hint either way. The Manu Koné Chelsea transfer link is unlikely to fade given Chelsea’s history of scouting France’s leading midfielders, but any fresh move will have to wait for Roma’s stance to soften.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 10 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (398 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Michael Carrick arrived at Carrington for Manchester United training as normal on Tuesday morning, while his bosses were preparing to decide his future in talks on the Mediterranean.
Chief executive Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox are flying to Monaco to meet Sir Jim Ratcliffe, with the BBC reporting that the pair will recommend Carrick is sacked.The Guardian has indicated representatives of the Glazer family will also be involved.
The club insists the Monaco summit was pre-planned and is not solely about the head coach and while that may be true, it hardly matters.By allowing the meeting to become public knowledge, United have turned a straightforward football decision into unnecessary drama, compounding an already difficult situation.
What does is say about Man United in 2026 that a manager is given three games to secure his job, then left to train the squad during an international break while the executives are flying off to rule on his future? It’s farcical.
The latest chapter is another muddled process.Wilcox and Berrada met at Carrington the day after the 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth on 25 October and agreed to give Carrick three more matches.A defeat at Chelsea, a win over Roma and a 4-4 draw with Aston Villa later, they appear to have reached the conclusion many expected a fortnight ago.
It has been revealed that if the timeline holds, the decision will be made at Wednesday’s meeting, with an official announcement expected later in the week.United reportedly want to tell Carrick face to face, which means he could spend another day or two working under a cloud. In reality, it could be two days or two weeks.
Recent findings suggest that the stakes could hardly be higher. United have won once in 10 league games, their worst-ever start to a Premier League season, and sit one point off the bottom in 18th place.
It has been revealed that should Carrick go, attention will turn quickly to his successor.ESPN reports that United States head coach Mauricio Pochettino is the favoured candidate, while Eddie Howe has been named as Wilcox’s preferred choice. Antonio Conte has also been mentioned.
Carrick deserves better than this.Whatever the outcome, a club that wants to be taken seriously should not be settling its manager’s future in the full glare of the media while he is still out on the training pitch.
📅 29 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (458 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readchelsea

Joao Pedro missed Chelsea’s 3-0 Premier League defeat to Brentford with a knee problem, and the injury has since ruled him out of Brazil’s squad for the friendlies against Australia and India.
He was absent from Xabi Alonso’s confirmed lineups against Brentford, with Chelsea turning to other forward options instead.
In a recent development, brazil’s coaching staff confirmed the withdrawal, pointing to the same knee issue that kept him out of the derby. Chelsea have not set a firm return date for Joao Pedro, leaving supporters to wait for further updates during the international break.
The Joao Pedro injury situation took a latest turn when the Standard reported that he is seeing a specialist during the international break to speed up his recovery.
According to the Standard, the forward is using this pause in the calendar to get ahead of the problem rather than wait for Chelsea to resume domestic action.
Chelsea have not issued their own statement on the specialist visit, and the club’s official line on Joao Pedro’s fitness remains limited to his withdrawal from matchday duty.
Full detail on the reported treatment can be found in football.london’s reported injury update, which first carried the specialist claim alongside Xabi Alonso’s comments on the striker’s season.
Until Chelsea confirm otherwise, the Standard’s report stands as the clearest picture of how the club are handling the knee concern.
It suggests a measured approach, with recovery prioritised over rushing Joao Pedro back into contention for the next fixture.
Before the injury forced him out, Xabi Alonso had made his admiration for Joao Pedro clear. The Chelsea manager ranked the forward among the Premier League’s elite strikers, alongside Manchester City’s Erling Haaland.
“If you count how many top strikers we have in the Premier League, I’m sure that João is there, Haaland for sure is there.
Recent findings suggest that “So I would rate him that way. He has a very strong goal this year: to have a great season, to score many goals, and to be a nominee for not just this month but more months. I am not surprised, but really happy with the kind of player that we have here with João.”.
With Joao Pedro sidelined, Alonso must lean again on the depth built into his squad.
His approach to rotation, part of the squad management this season, faces another test while his in-form forward is unavailable.
According to recent reports, graeme Hanna is the site lead of Read Rangers and also writes about West Ham for Read West Ham. A Rangers season-ticket holder and freelance writer, he has previously written for Vital Rangers, Rangers Review, Football Ground Guide and Give Me Sport, and has a long association with the Follow Follow fanzine.
📅 14 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 7 min read (1471 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Dailymail

Published: 18:49 EST, 14 November 2026 | Updated: 18:49 EST, 14 November 2026.
THE guy with the flyer was persistent.
It has been revealed that ‘Mate, we are walking out in the 21st minute to protest 21 years of the Glazers. Will you join us?’ he asks earnestly, handing me a leaflet that announces: ‘Enough is Enough! Empty Old Trafford! Leave the stadium in the 21st minute. 21 years of failed ownership. Glazers OUT! Ineos OUT!’.
More than 70,000 spectators leaving their seat and walking out of the stadium in the 21st minute have been quite the statement, especially live on Sky Sports.
But as admirable as Saeed TV’s aim is (I discover later he is some sort of youtuber), it’s hard to see gain any traction.
‘Dad, we are not walking out of the match. It’s my first time in Old Trafford,’ I am told as we continue to meander up Matt Busby Way, a declaration from my 10-year-old that causes a fair bit of mirth among the crowd.
Mate, we are walking out in the 21st minute to protest 21 years of the Glazers. Will you join us?’.
‘What’s wrong with the owners anyway?’ Dan enquires innocently, which leads to a bind.
How deep down the rabbit-hole should I go with my ten-year-old on his first visit to the Theatre of Dreams.
It’s probably not the time or place to try and explain leveraged buyouts and how much debt the Glazers have saddled the club with, £1.2 billion at the last count while taking millions out of it in dividends. Do I need to go further back and talk about Rock of Gibraltar’s unexpected success on the track and the concept of stud fees?
‘They are not putting enough money into the team and taking loads of money out of the club,’ is all I offer.
‘When Manchester City need a midfielder, they can buy Elliot Anderson and Enzo Fernandez while United have to make do with someone who was sitting on Chelsea’s bench.’.
He doesn’t look convinced that’s much of a reason to walk out of a football but as the cathedral of consumerism that is the Manchester United megastore has appeared, he forgets about United’s disastrous ownership model – for now, at least.
During his doomed attempt to coax Jurgen Klopp to Old Trafford around 2014, Ed Woodward apparently told him that United was the sporting version of Disneyland.
And to be sardined inside the megastore in the couple of hours before kick-off, you have to accept that the much-maligned former CEO may have been right about one thing.
Sources indicate that think Arnott’s a couple of days before Christmas, just with a lot more people. You even need to pass through airport-like security before even entering and spend your dosh.
One of the common refrains among United supporters is why are the Glazers holding onto the club when they don’t even seem to care.
Thirty seconds inside the megastore on match-day and you realise why the Americans are so keen to hold onto the asset they’re bleeding dry – and they probably care a great deal.
Dan gets obligatory photo at statue of United's holy trinity, a moment he will look back on.
Even with the team languishing in the relegation zone, having won a single league game all season, people are keen to spend, spend, spend.
I see people wandering around with five or six different shirts, from different eras (I did succumb and bought Dan the black shirt from 95-96 season, because it reminds me of Eric Cantona, Roy Keane and better times!).
Industry observers note that you can get a photo with a replica of a Premier League trophy. That’s just £10. Or Lego sets of Old Trafford or the Munich clock.
In a recent development, that will just set you back £25. For many in this shop, it seems allowing the club to empty their wallet is as much a part of the day as the actual football.
There are other parts of the ritual, which remain and have yet to be infected by the poisonous atmosphere around the club – and remind the three dads bringing their kids to Old Trafford for the first time of better days.
Such as curry chips and battered sausage from Lou Macari’s chipper. And the customary photo in front of the statue of the holy trinity of Best, Law and Charlton.
The megastore was the one place that seemed immune to the toxicity in the air. Once outside again and all that could be heard was the moans and groans, mainly because Shea Lacey wasn’t starting.
Coming here since the 1990s, we have seen the skyline of Manchester transformed as it became a sleek, modern city. It seems the one place that hasn’t changed is Old Trafford. It has remained the same.
Stuck in time. It looked sleek and modern in 1999, but now there is a tired, decrepit feel to the stadium – and not just because of the leaking roof. It could do with a lick or two of paint.
Stuck in time. It looked sleek and modern in 1999, but now there is a tired, decrepit feel to the stadium.
No wonder Massive Sir Jim is determined to plough ahead with his prepares to make a crudely-designed circus tent ‘the Wembley of the North.’ Not that there is anyone inside Old Trafford of the same mind.
Senne Lammens has just trotted onto the field with Tom Heaton and Karl Darlow to do their pre-match warm-up when the chants start, telling Jim Ratcliffe he can stick his new stadium up his posterior.
It is a weird atmosphere, with all the chanting against the owners – both Glazers and Ineos – and nothing being sung in support of the players.
As my friend points out it must be so difficult for the team to show the best of themselves when things are this toxic in the stadium.
Dan has been to the Jodi Stand enough times on a Friday night to know there is plenty of choice and crude language at football matches, but still I nearly felt at covering his ears at some of the stuff being sung in Old Trafford last Sunday, especially that directed at CEO Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox.
We had hoped that things might have been different when the game kicked off, but within a minute, Aston Villa had scored.
And three minutes later, they had scored again when Lammens fumbled Alysson’s shot into Nicolas Jackson’s path. Maybe walking out in the 21st minute wasn’t such a bad idea.
It has been revealed that the crowd’s ire had gone from the owners to the players now, with a sustained chant of ‘You are not fit to wear the shirt.’ United did rally and by half-time, it was 2-2. But the mood was still dismal as we queued for a quick beer.
According to recent reports, the 1958 Group had asked fans not to buy booze, another protest against the owners. But it seemed nobody was paying much attention to that.
One of the issues at United is that there seem to be too many splintered fan groups – there is also ClaimBackUnited and Fan Coalition ’58 – as well as Saeed TV, who seemed to be on his own solo run.
Recent findings suggest that we didn’t feel bad about ignoring the booze ban, as everyone was doing it. And within a couple of minutes of the second-half, we saw the reason why. You need to fortify yourself to watch Diogo Dalot try to defend.
For much of the second-half, it seemed like Michael Carrick’s brief tenure was going to peter out in a forgettable defeat, as Villa seemed to manage the game perfectly.
Dan and his friends were growing frustrated, pointing out the players weren’t doing what their coaches tell them to do on a weekly basis, leading me to conclude that maybe my son’s under-11 side are better-coached than United.
The last on-pitch act of Carrick's tenure.
In a recent development, and then there was the chaotic and crazy final few minutes in stoppage-time. And a draw that came out of nowhere and was celebrated like a victory.
It has been revealed that that was the thing. Even though the mood inside the stadium was toxic for most of the game, even though the team were two down inside four minutes and the season has been a disaster, everyone still came away from Old Trafford, happy and with a smile on their face.
It has been revealed that only football can do that. More than that, perhaps only Manchester United – despite everything – can do that.
Sorry we are not at the moment accepting comments on this article.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (402 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Manchester United have sacked Michael Carrick as head coach following a disastrous start to the 2026/27 campaign that has left the club in the Premier League relegation zone.
The former Manchester United midfielder was informed of the decision today after travelling to the Carrington after meeting chief executive Omar Berrada, director of football Jason Wilcox and co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe.
Industry observers note that michael Carrick initially took charge on an interim basis after Ruben Amorim was sacked last season. He had a great start in the interim role, guiding Manchester United to third place and securing a return to the Champions League after missing the last two seasons.
Michael Carrick sacked by MUFC. Top lad, got the team in the Champions League against expectations. Gave it his all, night and day. Protected others, never threw anyone under a bus. Worked in difficult circumstances. Leaves with head held high. I wish him and his staff the very….
His first full season at Old Trafford has been a completely different story.
Manchester United have managed just one Premier League victory from their opening 10 matches, collecting just eight points from five draws and four defeats. Their only win came against Ipswich Town in August, while a disastrous run of results has pushed the club down to 18th in the table.
Sunday’s chaotic late 4-4 draw against Aston Villa was another setback, with United failing to climb out of the relegation zone before the international break.
Manchester United have already identified Mauricio Pochettino as their preferred replacement, with reports indicating that an agreement in principle has been reached with the former Tottenham and Chelsea manager.
The Argentine is presently in charge of the United States national team but is understood to be interested in taking the Old Trafford job.
In a recent development, pochettino’s contract reportedly includes a release clause worth around £7-7.5 million, which United would need to activate. Talks over personal terms are also understood to be advanced with Pochettino’s camp.
United are now preparing for another change in the dugout, with Pochettino expected to be handed the responsibility of rescuing their season.
Recent findings suggest that shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (464 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Sempremilan

In January, AC Milan will make some massive investments, if reports are to be believed. At the moment, two names are leading the talk.
According to recent reports, it could be a significant month for Milan if things go their way in January. They hope to add a central defender to their squad – and have hoped to do so since before the end of the summer mercato – but the headline signing may be an attacking option, with quite a few names in the mix.
Industry observers note that read SempreMilan ad-free and get access to exclusive news. Click here for a free trial!
The favourites are clear, though: Endrick and Nicolo Tresoldi.
Speaking on Fabrizio Romano’s YouTube channel, Matteo Moretto provided an update on the Rossoneri’s pursuit for both forwards and whether either was progressing, as MilanNews relayed.
“Although Mourinho continues to say that Endrick will stay at Real Madrid, the truth is that the player has the ball right now. If the player decides to tell Real Madrid that he wants to try a new experience to grow and play, Real Madrid will not object. And I can tell you that these are precisely the indications.
“To date, there have been no official communications between the parties, but I can confirm that Endrick, as he also stated in a recent interview, is open to a new loan experience, Lyon-style, which could give him that extra focus and playing time, also with a view to the national team.
“A few days ago, I told you how Milan were really close to signing Tresoldi a few years ago, so much so that the player arrived, visited Milanello, and stayed at Casa Milan; the contracts were even ready.
“I want to clarify that, since he was a very young player at the time, it wasn’t a deal directly supervised by Paolo Maldini. There were other people managing the deal. Ricky Massara was also Milan’s transfer manager at the time, and there were others as well.
“The deal never actually got signed because Milan stalled, and the player returned to Germany, effectively signing a newly introduced contract with Hannover. Beyond that, there’s a lot of talk about Tresoldi now in terms of Milan’s present and future.
In a recent development, “I want to clarify a few points, however. I can confirm that it’s true that Cardinale really likes him, and Milan really likes him. The club is evaluating what steps to take to make this kind of move…”.
Sources indicate that it’s clear that the Diavolo are keen to add some attacking firepower to their ranks in January, understandably. However, it must be the right fit and there are certainly a few questions about Tresoldi now, with the price only rising.
📅 12 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (509 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readmanutd

Gary Neville has rolled out a furious attack on Manchester United’s leadership over the way the club handled Michael Carrick’s dismissal.
United confirmed on Thursday that Carrick had been sacked, four days after the 4-4 draw with Aston Villa left them 18th in the Premier League with eight points from 10 games.
The club stated it had reached the “extremely difficult conclusion that a change is necessary”.
Neville had already branded the process “classless” on The Overlap’s Stick to Football podcast before the announcement, pointing out that it was widely known Carrick was about to go while United were holding talks with potential replacements.
Speaking to Sky Sports after the decision was confirmed, the former United captain went even further.
“It’s just quite simply disgusting,” he noted.
“That falls well below the standard of what you would expect in any other business, in any other industry. It would be constructive dismissal and you’d be getting sued.”.
Neville took particular aim at the decision to hold the crucial meeting in Monaco, with chief executive Omar Berrada and director of football Jason Wilcox flying out to meet Sir Jim Ratcliffe while Carrick was still taking training at Carrington.
“The optics of being in Monaco whilst the team, the staff, the people who are running the club on a day-to-day basis are in Manchester, it’s just not good and it reflects badly on the leadership,” he said.
Industry observers note that it seems the only ones not to realise that are the trio above, but they aren’t stupid. How they explain it, or attempt to rationalise, it will be painful to listen to.
Sources indicate that neville also argued the club should have acted sooner. Looking back to the 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth in October, he noted United “effectively watched Michael Carrick resign on the pitch” as he waved goodbye to supporters at full time, only for the board to hand him three more games.
He summed up the episode as “indecision, lack of authority, just basically really poor leadership”.
It’s more than an episode, it’s an omnishambles that reflects the dysfunctional state of MUFC in its current guise.
Sources indicate that united are now expected to move quickly for Mauricio Pochettino. The United States head coach is reported to have reached an agreement in principle with the club, which is prepared to pay his release clause.
First, they will need to wait until the USMNT completes its CONCACAF Nations League quarter-final double header against Haiti on Saturday and Wednesday.
Yes. Man United to wait until an international break to appoint an international manager….
For Neville, though, the bigger problem lies above the dugout and no manager can be the scapegoat for that massive glitch.
Graeme Hanna is the site lead of Read Rangers and also writes about West Ham for Read West Ham. A Rangers season-ticket holder and freelance writer, he has previously written for Vital Rangers, Rangers Review, Football Ground Guide and Give Me Sport, and has a long association with the Follow Follow fanzine.
📅 30 Sep 2026 | ⏱️ 3 min read (583 words, 📚 Deep Dive) | Source: Readchelsea

Recent findings suggest that manchester City have been found guilty of 114 financial charges, the Premier League has confirmed. The verdict follows an eight-week hearing that opened almost two years ago. It closes one of the most significant disciplinary cases in the competition’s history.
It has been revealed that former head coach Pep Guardiola has already broken his silence. Reaction to the Pep Guardiola Man City charges verdict is spreading fast across the division, with Chelsea among the clubs watching closely.
Sources indicate that guardiola joined Manchester City in 2016 and turned them into the dominant force in English football. He left his post earlier this summer, with the club having already worked through prepares to replace Pep Guardiola at City.
His exit means he holds no formal role at the Etihad. Yet he moved quickly to make his loyalty clear once the ruling landed. According to the football.london report that first carried his statement, Guardiola posted directly to his supporters.
“I want every single @ManCity fan to know I am here; more than ever. I am, always have been, always will, be behind my club, my owner, my chairman [Khaldoon Al Mubarak], Ferran [Soriano], the players, staff, Enzo [Maresca] and you, our unique supporters. Let me be clear: we will get through this together. I love you all.”.
Industry observers note that manchester City chief executive Ferran Soriano has confirmed that the club intends to appeal the verdict. The statement from Guardiola comes to City’s defence despite him leaving the role this summer. He is still viewed as the man who built this era of success, even though he no longer sits in the dugout at the Etihad.
It has been revealed that the Pep Guardiola Man City charges case matters just as much to Chelsea as it does to Manchester City themselves. Chelsea, along with Arsenal and Tottenham, are among the Premier League clubs directly affected by the outcome. Every point City may have gained through breaches has a knock on effect further down the table.
Most top flight clubs including Chelsea are now pushing for City to face relegation as a consequence of the verdict. Some are reported to be weighing up legal action of their own. Guardiola has spoken about Chelsea before, including Guardiola’s previous comments on Chelsea. This latest statement fits a pattern of public backing for Manchester City, despite the criticism now directed at the club.
Recent findings suggest that for Chelsea supporters, the case is not just about points on a table. It touches on the integrity of seasons they competed in directly. That is why so many rivals are refusing to let the matter rest with a guilty verdict alone.
Manchester City’s appeal process is now the next stage in a case that has already run for nearly two years. Ferran Soriano has made clear the club will contest the findings. No date has been confirmed for when that appeal will be heard.
Until then, no points deductions, penalties or changes to past titles have been confirmed by the Premier League. Chelsea and their rivals will be watching the appeal timeline just as closely as they watched the original hearing. The final outcome could still be a long way off.
Shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
📅 11 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (471 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readarsenal

Ceadach O’Neill has suffered a setback in his development after being ruled out of the Northern Ireland squad due to injury.
O’Neill had been named by Michael O’Neill in the squad for the last two games of the Nations League against Ukraine and Hungary. The 18-year-old was hoping to make his first senior start after appearing in four games for Northern Ireland, but all as a substitute.
Sources indicate that however, he will miss the international break after suffering an injury. He was also unable to play in Arsenal’s Under-21s 5-2 win over Aston Villa on Sunday.
The news comes at a good time for the winger who has recently been getting more attention in Arsenal’s first team.
O’Neill has impressed Mikel Arteta in training with the senior players and has also made his first team debut in the Carabao Cup.
According to recent reports, his performances have indicated he may be another academy player who will fight for a spot under Arteta. He also impressed during Arsenal’s loss to Fleetwood in the Carabao Cup.
The teenager was one of only a few players to leave the game with their head held high after providing Gyokeres with a good cross to bring the score back level.
It has been revealed that he was also included in the Arsenal squad that travelled to Liverpool in the Premier League. Although he did not play, it was still a positive result.
Recent findings suggest that the inclusion of the Northern Ireland call-up means he could continue to develop. Getting his first senior start would help him show he can perform outside of the academy.
According to recent reports, O’Neill’s departure is a key moment for Northern Ireland. They still have much to play for in their final Nations League fixtures.
The squad sit one point above Hungary in Group B2 with Ukraine four points behind. They must now face Ukraine before they take on Hungary.
A first-place finish would guarantee promotion to League A. Finishing second would see them enter the promotion play-offs. With a promising young player leaving after the last international break, Michael O’Neill will be disappointed to lose him.
Recent findings suggest that the manager praised O’Neill for his contribution to the squad and wished him a speedy recovery. The winger will now work on getting back to full fitness.
According to recent reports, his recent inclusion in the first team, demonstrates how far he has come in recent weeks. He will be hoping to get another chance when he is fully fit.
Sources indicate that lucie Turner writes about Arsenal for Read Arsenal and Newcastle United for Read Newcastle. A long-time Arsenal supporter, she also follows rugby, snooker, darts and Formula 1. Her work covers match previews and reports, breaking news, player profiles and opinion pieces.
📅 13 Nov 2026 | ⏱️ 2 min read (305 words, 📖 Standard) | Source: Readmanutd

Manchester United have confirmed an agreement with Mauricio Pochettino to become their next head coach, with the Argentine set to take charge after the international break.
Industry observers note that the 54-year-old will replace Michael Carrick, who was dismissed on Thursday following United’s disastrous start to the Premier League season. Pochettino is set to sign a two-and-a-half-year contract that will keep him at Old Trafford until the summer of 2029.
The former Tottenham and Chelsea boss is right now managing the United States national team but is expected to fly straight to Manchester after completing his USA international games.
Pochettino will first oversee the USA’s CONCACAF Nations League quarter-final ties against Haiti on Saturday and next Tuesday. He is expected to arrive in Manchester on Wednesday before taking charge of the club on Thursday.
Pochettino’s first taste of action as a United manager will be against Liverpool at Anfield on November 22.
Pochettino brings considerable Premier League experience after previous spells with Southampton, Tottenham and Chelsea. He has also managed Paris Saint-Germain before the USA job.
His appointment makes him Manchester United’s eighth permanent manager since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013.
It has been revealed that carrick’s departure came less than six months after he signed a two-year contract. His second spell in charge ended after United managed just one win in their opening 10 league matches, leaving them in the relegation zone.
Carrick’s coaching staff, including Jonny Evans, Jonathan Woodgate, Steve Holland, Travis Binnion and goalkeeping coach Craig Mawson, have all left alongside Carrick.
In a recent development, shumail Sajid writes about Manchester United for Read Man Utd and Crystal Palace for Read Crystal Palace, with occasional pieces on other Premier League clubs. He has also written for FanSided's Red Devils Dispatch, Yardbarker, Anfield Central and The Sports Side.
Total Artikel Dibaca: 0
Total Bookmark Tersimpan: 0
Streak Membaca: 1 Hari