Almost £3.5bn was splurged on transfers this summer in a league supposedly described as the best in the world, so why does VAR continue to prove so ineffective and divisive?
Seven years after its introduction, it remains a scourge on the Premier League and here at the City Ground was another exhibit of maddening off-field meddling.
Tottenham Hotspur avoided a third successive defeat after the crucial intervention of VAR prevented Neco Williams from securing Oliver Glasner his first win as Nottingham Forest’s head coach.
The big moment occurred in the 65th minute. Morgan Gibbs-White’s chip over Antonin Kinsky should have been dealt with by Sandro Tonali and Jan Paul van Hecke but both players got themselves in a muddle and Williams bundled the ball in from almost on the goal-line.
Replays appeared to show the ball went in off Williams’ knee and he was protecting his face with his hands to avoid a stray boot. The VAR review ruled that Williams had handled the ball, yet in this billion-pound industry there was not one camera angle which proved entirely conclusive.
Sources indicate that on this occasion the VAR official was Peter Bankes, recommending to referee Craig Pawson that the goal be disallowed. Williams mentioned: “It’s a goal. VAR is there when there is a clear and obvious error and for me that is not clear and obvious. I’ve seen the images and the replays and at not one moment did I think I handballed it because I never did. I headed it in between my arms. I’m at a loss at that one, it’s disappointing. If you’re going to pause it, it’s going to look like it hit my arm but it didn’t hit my arm.”.
Glasner and the other Forest players were also incensed, and once again supporters are questioning how critical moments in matches are being decided by officials sitting at Stockley Park. “I think the VAR can’t intervene when he is guessing,” noted Glasner. “I told the referee after the game that I felt the goal should have stood.
“The VAR should say to stay with the onfield decision because it is about strengthening the referee. If it’s not 100 per cent clear, stick to the onfield decision. We had a briefing before the season that the threshold for VAR intervention this year should be very high which is why this is wrong.”.
While Tottenham were perhaps fortunate to pick up their first point, they are still waiting to score their first Premier League goal of the season. They did not manage a shot on target.
According to recent reports, the grand £350m rebuild is proving a slow-burner and it is only Mykhailo Mudryk who will have cause to remember such a dull affair. Signed on loan from Chelsea on deadline day, Mudryk made his first appearance since November 2024 after being suspended by the Football Association following a positive test for performance-enhancing meldonium.
The Ukrainian forward was introduced with 16 minutes left, with his manager Roberto De Zerbi determined to reinvigorate his career.
Tottenham are still waiting for lift-off but De Zerbi remains convinced that his team will eventually click, particularly in attacking areas.
In a recent development, one of their summer arrivals, Omar Marmoush, wasted their best chance in the 16th minute by drilling a shot wide of the post. De Zerbi mentioned: “In the last third we have to improve. We have to maybe keep more calm when we are very close to doing something crucial.
Industry observers note that “If we improve in the last third I think we can score many goals because we have the players with big qualities. We could have scored three or four goals.
Considering we were only all working together on Thursday for the first time, this is the right spirit and the right way to move on.” On Mudryk, De Zerbi said: “He’s working to reach the best physical condition and he needs time.”.
Sources indicate that after the disallowed Williams goal, Forest were feeling further aggrieved soon after when Rodrigo Bentancur appeared to pull back substitute Igor Jesus in the penalty area. These are two teams clearly in period of transition and patience will be required from both sets of supporters.
It’s full time at GTech Stadium: Brentford 1 Sunderland 1.
Industry observers note that pierre Sage has his first win while Alvaro Arbeloa has lost his first three Premier League games and go to Anfield next Saturday. Frank de Boer vibes.
City needed Donnarumma to spare their blushes with several good saves.
Industry observers note that brighton 1 Leeds 1. Pascal Gross missed a late sitter and Leeds are still winless in Brighton’s ‘new’ stadium in 11 visits.
It remains 0-0 so Spurs are goalless in three, both sides remain winless.
Sources indicate that iliman Ndiaye took a knock and has come off after treatment. He has sat on the bench, though, rather than headed down the tunnel, which suggests it is not an injury.
Enzo Le Fee equalises from the penalty spot.
VAR does not intervene after Lewis-Potter was penalised for holding. Le Fee chipped a pen straight at the keeper there last season.
Ellis Simms with the latest, clocking Donnarumma flush in the face with his close-range effort.
And it’s a third goal from a left-back, but this time it’s the substitute Ben Chilwell.
Enzo jeered by Coventry fans when taken off was predictable. Replaced by Ayyoub Bouaddi.
Jaidon Anthony bundled the ball in but had used his hands.
And Mykhailo Mudryk is on for his first appearance since November 2024.
It has been revealed that forest are feeling aggrieved over that disallowed goal. Replays appeared to show the ball went in off Williams’ knee and he was protecting his face with his hands to avoid a stray boot.
It has been revealed that big cheer for Phil Foden when he came on for Rayan Cherki. Cherki has been creative for City and this might be trying another mode of attack for Enzo Maresca or saving legs for the Champions League in midweek. They have two full days of rest before facing Porto on Tuesday.
It has been revealed that that is a massive chance for Coventry. Loum Tchaouna got room in the penalty area and it needed Gianluigi Donnarumma to save low to his right.
Luka Vuskovic heads in from an inswinging corner.
Controversy at the City Ground – and it’s again a result of Var.
Morgan Gibbs-White’s chip over Antonin Kinsky should have been dealt with by Sandro Tonali and Jan Paul van Hecke but both players got themselves in a muddle and Neco Williams bundled the ball in from almost on the goalline.
Industry observers note that the goal did go to Var for a possible handball by Williams, and it was ruled that the Wales international did handle it. Did look very harsh.
So it remains 0-0 at the City Ground.
In a recent development, coventry are still in this game but City have their chances to put them away. Enzo was deemed offside when he set up a strike for Haaland. The UK’s most expensive player has got better during this game.
Looks like it will be ruled out for handball.
Vitaly Janelt breaks the deadlock after Brentford were battered in the first half.
Keith Andrews is a brave manager. Having been forced into a change after 17 minutes when his captain, Nathan Collisn was injured, he shook it up at half-time by replacing three of his biggest signings, Kayode, Sangaré and Ouattara for Hickey, Yarmoliuk and Anthony.
There might be a VAR check but Neco Williams is in like Flynn when Tonali makes a bad mistake.
Mohammed Kudus comes on for Sávio and Andy Robertson for Destiny Udogie.
Igor Jesus and Daniel Muñoz come on for Ola Aina and Dan Ndoye.
Industry observers note that tyrick Mitchell has scored his second. What do they say about London buses….
Recent findings suggest that mitchell rampaging up the left, shoots. It’s blocked by García who tries to clear by hitting it straight into Mitchell’s foot whence it ricochets past Bernd Leno.
It was the culmination of a long passage of huffing and puffing after Marmoush had scudded a free-kick straight into the Forest wall.
Good spell of pressure here from Spurs.
Forest are clinging on a bit at the moment with some pretty desperate defending.
It was put in by Jacob Strand Larsen, who came on for Eddie Nketiah at half-time but he was offside.
With Tottenham appearing so toothless in attack, you have to wonder whether Roberto De Zerbi ends the long wait for Mykhailo Mudryk.
It is over 600 days since Mudryk last played a competitive match.
There is also the option of Dominic Solanke on the bench too.
Tanaka was offside when he turned in Stach’s free-kick. Leeds squander opportunity to double their lead.
Because of the 4½ minute VAR check for the Ballard ‘goal’ and an injury to Nathan Collins that forced the Bees’ captain off.
These are clearly two teams in transition.
Tottenham have spent over £300m this summer and are still waiting for lift-off.
Forest are embarking on a newly introduced era under Oliver Glasner with a style of play that will take time to implement.
It’s been a messy game so far with both teams struggling to impose themselves.
The best chance fell to one of Tottenham’s upcoming arrivals, Omar Marmoush, but he drilled a shot wide of the post.
Josh King scores one and makes one. César Palacios with the rebound after Gonzalo García’s effort was parried to him.
Oliver Glasner’s wife Bettina is making her first visit to the City Ground today.
Glasner remarked that he is hoping to celebrate dinner tonight with his first three points since taking charge.
In a ding-dong match, the left-back, Tyrick Mitchell, pounces to fire Palace level.
Lewis Dunk saves Brighton after Calvert-Lewin had rounded Verbruggen and tried to slide it in on the angle.
Erling Haaland at the back post with a thunderous header – his 300th goal in club football.
Kamada was offside by a gnat’s whisker. VAR is making this job ridiculous.
Recent findings suggest that both Calvert-Lewin and Tanaka should have finished but Bogle was there to make sure. Elvedi spun on to the ball in the right of the penalty area to stand up a left-foot cross to the back post. Calvert-Lewin leapt and powered a low header hat Rushworth scooped out. Tanaka, following up, sliced his shot from five yards across goal where Bogle blindsided a defender to tap it in.
Kamada equalises at the Cottage, played in by an excellent pass from Pino.
Coventry fans are in good voice – and jeering Enzo Fernandez when he gets the ball. The Argentina midfielder has been quiet so far.
Messy start here at the City Ground with both teams struggling for fluency.
Tottenham are still waiting for their first goal of the season with a drastically reshaped team.
Danso was deemed to be interfering with play in an offside position, blocking the goalkeeper’s view of Ballard’s strike.
It has been revealed that disasi gives the ball away to Charles who finds Bobb. His pass sets up King for a shot which is deflected past Henderson.
Kevin Danso was standing in front of Kelleher in an offside position.
Was a Sunderland player blocking the goalkeeper?
Dan Ballard opens the scoring at the GTech from a free-kick.
Cherki makes headway down the left and sends over a dipping, menacing cross towards Enzo who is pushed high as a No10 but Carl Rushworth plucks it out of the air.
It’s Enzo Fernández replacing Nico O’Reilly not Ayyoub Bouaddi.
Enzo Fernandez will start, it has been confirmed, with O’Reilly injured in the warm-up.
Fernandez is lined up in the tunnel ready to come out.
England left-back, who was slated to play in midfield, hurt his back/hip in the warm-up.
Seems to have a problem with his lower back or hip. He has been ruled out of the match.
One pleasing thing about the signing of Melvin Bard by Leeds is the prospect of it reviving oft-heard Elland Road shouts from 1989-92 of ‘Giyit Mel’ and ‘G’won Mel’ in encouragement of the sainted Sterland, the Zico of Fullerton Park.
You can follow all the reaction and a report from Newcastle’s 2-2 draw with Bournemouth here.
Liam Delap will make his first start for Forest today after becoming the club’s record signing this summer.
It was a relatively quiet transfer window for the club, which has not always been the case since their return to the Premier League in 2022.
To discover more on Forest’s patient recruitment strategy click here.
In a recent development, brentford Kelleher, Kayode, Ajer, Collins, Lewis-Potter, Sangare, Janelt, Ouattara, Damsgaard, Schade, Thiago. Substitutes Valdimarsson, Hickey, Henry, Yarmolyuk, Wilson, Carvalho, Anthony, Diouf, Schuster.
It has been revealed that sunderland Roefs, Meunier, Mukiele, Ballard, Danso, Mandava, Le Fee, Sadiki, Xhaka, Angulo, Brobbey. Substitutes Ellborg, Methalie, Rigg, O’Nien, Alderete, Isidor, Ahoka, Hume, Fofana.
Referee Thomas Bramall (Sheffield).
Brighton Verbruggen, Kadioglu, Vuskovic, Dunk, Boscagli, Gross, Ayari, Gomez, Yalcouye, De Cuyper, Kostoulas.Substitutes Steele, Hadjam, Struijk, David, Andres, Osman, Costinha, O’Riley, Oriola.
Leeds United Trafford, Justin, Elvedi, Muharemovic, Bogle, Ampadu, Tanaka, Gudmundsson, Stach, Okafor, Calvert-Lewin.Substitutes Zetterer, James, Longstaff, Wilson, Aaronson, Nmecha, Bijol, Bahoya, Bard.
Referee Stuart Attwell (Nuneaton).
Fulham Leno, Castagne, Andersen, Bassey, Robinson, Charles, Iwobi, Bobb, King, Palacios, Garcia. Substitutes: Lecomte, Rodrigo Muniz, Kevin, Larsson, Berge, Angel, Affengruber, Sessegnon, Smith Rowe.
Crystal Palace Henderson, Canvot, Richards, Disasi, Khalaili, Wharton, Timber, Mitchell, Pino, Kamada, Nketiah. Substitutes Benitez, Gozo, Tomiyasu, Hughes, Larsen, Osorio, Doucoure, Mingueza, Chilwell.
Referee Sam Barrott (Huddersfield.
Man City vs Coventry City teams.
Man City Donnarumma, Khusanov, Dias, Guehi, Gvardiol, O’Reilly, Anderson, Ndiaye, Cherki, Semenyo, Haaland.Substitutes Rulli, Kovacic, Fernandez, Ait Nouri, Matheus Luiz, Bouaddi, Foden, McAidoo, Lewis.
Coventry Rushworth, Thomas, Amenda, Pinnock, Van Ewijk Onyeka, Grimes Dasilva, Rudoni, Mason-Clark, Awoniyi.Substitutes Bentley, Sakamoto, Yirenkyi, Simms, Tchaouna, Latibeaudiere, Thomas-Asante, Overgaard, Hamer.
Nottm Forest vs Tottenham Hotspur teams.
Recent findings suggest that nottm Forest Sels, Jair Cunha, Milenkovic, Murillo, Aina, Schlager, McAtee, Williams, Gibbs-White, Ndoye, Delap. Substitutes John Victor, Diomande, Hudson-Odoi, Dominguez, Wood, Igor Jesus, Yates, Netz, Munoz.
Tottenham Hotspur Kinsky, Porro, van Hecke, van de Ven, Udogie, Bentancur, Tonali, Savio, Gallagher, Tel, Marmoush. Substitutes Dubravka, Robertson, Senesi, Gray, Bergvall, Fernandes, Solanke, Kudus, Mudryk.
Referee Craig Pawson (Sheffield).
The major headline news from Tottenham is that Mykhailo Mudryk is on the bench.
Signed from Chelsea on deadline day on an initial loan, Mudryk was once branded as a future Ballon d’Or winner by Roberto De Zerbi after they worked together at Shakhtar.
Mudryk has not played a competitive match since November 2024 after being suspended by the Football Association following a positive test for performance-enhancing meldonium.
Enzo Fernández’s record deal to Manchester City was facilitated by English-founded agency Unique Sports Management, it can be revealed.
Fernández sealed a £125m move from Chelsea on deadline day, equalling the UK transfer record of Alexander Isak to Liverpool a year ago.
Football Association documents due to be published later in the season will show Unique to have played their part in the biggest transfer of the summer.
Fernández is represented by The Elegant Game, headed by ex-Argentina international Javier Pastore, although he is not registered with the FA for transfers in England.
Unique, which also represented Anthony Gordon for his move to Barcelona, were brought in to close the deal, which was agreed between clubs on deadline day afternoon.
The English-founded agency have Marc Guéhi, who moved to City in January, on their books and their summer deals included Gordon to Barca, Maxence Lacroix to Chelsea and Taylor Harwood-Bellis to Aston Villa. Troy Parrott, who scored the winner for Real Betis against Jose Mourinho’s Real Madrid, is also in the Unique stable.
Will this be third time lucky for Tottenham Hotspur after their £300m+ summer reset?
In typical Tottenham fashion, their start to the Premier League season has not been straightforward with two defeats, five goals conceded and none scored so far.
The popular opinion is that it will eventually click, but Tottenham’s supporters are still scarred by those two successive 17th-placed finishes.
Forest have won their last four games against Spurs, so it will be an early sign of promise if Roberto De Zerbi can secure a positive result here.
Quinton Timber makes his debut, replacing Jorgen Strand Larsen while Axel Disasi relegates Takehiro Tomiyasu to the bench:.
According to recent reports, COYP. 🫡 pic.twitter.com/Ro4BBK1D8I.
Shea Charles starts instead of Sander Berge:.
Industry observers note that álvaro Arbeloa's Fulham. 🤍 pic.twitter.com/GXYI6ZwNqS.
🇦🇹 Kevin Danso's in from the off.RLB's XI to take on Brentford 👊#BRESUN pic.twitter.com/RuFI40wVeI.
Your Bees to face the Black Cats 🐝 pic.twitter.com/N0q2qMGKQw.
Pinnock and Onyeka come in for Tchaouna and Yirenki in switch to back three:.
It has been revealed that your City in Manchester. 📋 pic.twitter.com/f5i0n72VxD.
Ndiaye makes debut in place of Foden, Fernández on the bench:.
Your City side to face Coventry 🩵XI | Donnarumma, Khusanov, Dias (C), Guéhi, Gvardiol, Anderson, O'Reilly, Ndiaye, Cherki, Semenyo, HaalandSUBS | Rulli, Kovačić, Fernández, Aït-Nouri, Nunes, Bouaddi, Foden, McAidoo, Lewis🤝 @etihad pic.twitter.com/Pl88ZkjL5O.
Two changes: Gudmundsson replaces Rodon, Elvedi in for Bijol and Tanaka replaces Aaronson.
📋 Your #LUFC XI... pic.twitter.com/woHsZmcrOj.
According to recent reports, TEAM NEWS! 🚨 Our #BHAFC starting XI to face Leeds this afternoon. ✍️ pic.twitter.com/gEuCnnFcrj.
Sávio makes first Premier League start:.
Our Spurs side on Trentside 🫡🔢 @krakenfx pic.twitter.com/5ppc8oJ53q.
Sources indicate that our XI this afternoon. 🗞️ pic.twitter.com/CThvS9P9IV.
Enzo Maresca believes streetwise Enzo Fernández will give Manchester City an extra winning edge – as he told his record £125 million signing to forget about the size of the fee.
City made the Argentina midfielder the joint most expensive purchase in Premier League history with their deadline day swoop from Chelsea.
Maresca has opted against naming Fernández among his captains’ leadership group, which features Ruben Dias, Erling Haaland, Marc Guéhi and Gianluigi Donnarumma.
But the Italian – who knows Fernández well from their time together at Stamford Bridge – is confident his fierce competitive instincts will bring an added dimension to his side.
Recent findings suggest that “I don’t know if it’s streetwise but he knows how to win,” Maresca stated, who is in line to hand Fernández his debut against Coventry on Saturday. “When you want to compete or win, it’s much more notable to have players that already know how to do that than players who have never done it in the past.
According to recent reports, “Enzo is not the only one. This squad has many players who know how to win titles and how to compete and this is what we are looking for.
“I know Enzo quite well and I know what he can bring to the team. He is a winner, [has] a winner’s mentality and knows how to win [after] the World Cup, Club World Cup [success].
“I just noted he is a winner and when you belong to the squad and another winning player arrives, they are always happy.
Sources indicate that “I can promise you that in the last four or five days, four or five players from the squad were asking if was coming or not because they wanted him to be with us. It’s very notable that he is with us.”.
Sources indicate that maresca said he planned to use Fernandez predominantly as a No 6 or No 8 depending on the game. “I see Enzo as a six, a little bit more deep, or [an eight] a little higher arriving in the box,” he said.
Sources indicate that good afternoon and welcome to live coverage of the Saturday afternoon 3pm kick-offs of which we are treated to a rare number this week as Sky and TNT Sports decide to inconvenience only 10 sets of matchgoing supporters rather than the usual 12 or 14. The matches start, purely alphabetically, with unbeaten Brentford hosting Sunderland, Leeds United travelling to Brighton and Hove Albion’s Amex Stadium where they have never won and have come away with only three points in their seven visits, the something’s-got-to-give quasi derby between winless Fulham and pointless Palace, leaders Man City hosting Coventry City for the Sky Blue Cup and Tottenham head to Nottingham Forest in pursuit of their first point to spoil the gaiety of a nation.
We have Mike McGrath reporting from the Etihad and John Percy at the City Ground and I will endeavour to keep you up to date with developments at the other three grounds via various methods. Forest vs Spurs seems the most consequential of the fixtures, not because either manager is in any danger but because now the window has closed it should give us a clearer picture of how Roberto De Zerbi prepares to marshal his surfeit of wingers into a coherent attack that can break their goalscoring duck and how he proposes to organise a back four that have shipped five goals.
Fulham and Palace have come in for a lot of criticism regarding their recruitment and while I can understand the frustration of the former’s fans for doing so much business with Real Madrid, I think Gonzalo García is a proper player and will shine over the course of the season.
It has been revealed that palace, I think, are paying the price for the January splurge on Brennan Johnson and Jorgen Strand Larsen, not just the inflated fees but the sizeable wages on players who contributed almost nothing. I was at Leeds vs Brentford last week and there was plenty to admire about both sides but fear for Leeds’ so-far commendable resilience at their Amex knacker’s yard and wonder whether Sunderland will be able to live with Brentford’s pace. Manchester City vs Coventry, meanwhile, probably will not give us the Bouaddi-Fernández-Anderson £325m midfield from the start but we might be given a glimpse.
