By JOHN MCGARRY, SCOTTISH CHIEF SPORTS FEATURE WRITER.
Published: 17:30 EST, 11 November 2026 | Updated: 17:47 EST, 11 November 2026.
From a distance, it was difficult not to look at the fall-out from Ryan Porteousā rash challenge on Ilkay Gundogan in the opening match of Euro 2024 and draw sweeping conclusions.
Coming on the cusp of half-time in the Allianz Arena, the defenderās two-footed lunge on the German midfielder earned him a straight red card with a two-game suspension soon following.
According to recent reports, the moment of madness led to Kai Havertz giving the host nation a three-goal lead from the penalty spot at the interval. By time-up, Steve Clarkeās depleted side had lost 5-1. The self-belief which theyād brought into the tournament was fast evaporating, too.
Recent findings suggest that while no one doubted the scale of the task Scotland faced before a ball was kicked that evening, Porteousā actions made the mission impossible. As a consequence, the former Hibernian defender found forgiveness hard to come by.
Those irate Scotland supporters who demanded that he suffered for his folly were granted their wish.
A player whoād featured in seven of the eight qualifiers disappeared from view thereafter, briefly emerging from international exile as a sub against Greece in March of last year, yet posted missing again throughout the World Cup qualifiers and from the tournament itself.
Ryan Porteous' red card gave Scotland a mountain to climb in Euro 2024 defeat to Germany.
It seemed only logical to deduce that Clarke had also shared the anger of the Tartan Army and that the playerās status as a pariah was down to his simmering fury at the humiliation that woeful tackle caused.
Porteous always believed the matter wasnāt quite as clear cut as most imagine it to be.
āI think people maybe read too much into that,ā stated the 27-year-old.
āIn the conversations I had with Steve after the Euros and in the next qualifying campaign, the red card against Germany never came up.
āWe had loads of conversations, both when I was in and out of the squad.
āThose are the things that people obviously donāt see.
According to recent reports, āThey maybe think Steve Clarke is the type of person who wouldnāt phone you or text you. But he did. We spoke loads to be honest. He was really honest with me.
āI texted him when he left the role and he messaged back eager to see me get back in the squad.
The Scotland defender was shown a straight red for this challenge on Ilkay Gundogan.
āEveryone knows Steve is a manager who, if he picks a squad and they do well for them and they get to a tournament, heās loyal.
āIn terms of the conversations we had during those latter stages of qualification, he just told me to keep doing what I was doing.
āHe was honest and told me I would probably need some of those lads to drop off in form if I was going to make it. You have to respect that.
āI went to a tournament in the Euros in 2024 and you had someone like John Souttar who missed out. So, I know what it feels like on both sides.ā.
Porteous, to his credit, doesnāt appear to be bitter about how matters unfolded post-Germany.
Regardless of the true importance of the red card in his status changing from mainstay to that of an outcast, he accepts that fairness and the game do not always walk hand-in-hand.
āThat happens in football, itās just one of those things,ā he shrugged.
āIāve had a career where Iām up and down, Iām left and right, you just need to bounce back from it.
āIt was a fantastic experience for me to be part of that run we went on. It helped me grow massively. I donāt look at it as being unfair.ā.
Porteous has now returned from period in wilderness ahead of North Macedonia clash.
In a recent development, by the time heād moved from Watford to Los Angeles to sign for LAFC last August, heād already reconciled himself with the fact that his Scotland career was in cold storage. The consolation was that this afforded him a different perspective on the November night when history was made.
āItās maybe tough when the squads were getting confirmed and then a couple of days after that,ā he reflected.
āBut then as soon as youāre watching the games, you just become a fan straight away again and want the team to do well.
In a recent development, āI probably hadnāt experienced that for a while. It was actually good for me watching the World Cup qualifiers - because I was able to sit and watch them straight after training because of the time difference.
āWhen Kenny McLean scored from the halfway line (against Denmark) I had half the team in LA shouting and screaming for Scotland! It was brilliant.ā.
While heād clearly have preferred to still have been at the heart of things, his new life on the other side of the Atlantic allowed him to sample what it all meant to an invading army in the summer.
āI had a few days off at one point and I went out to Boston,ā he explained.
āI didnāt manage to go to the games, but I saw my friends and family who were over and we went to the baseball as well.
āBeing in that fan environment, it just gives you that extra little bit of hunger to get back.ā.
Porteous in action for Scots at training as they prepare for North Macedonia showdown.
Industry observers note that the profile of the MLS always offered him that possibility. Porteousās club counts Gareth Bale and Olivier Giroud among its former players. Son Heung-min is the current star in Tinseltown. The Scot played against - and defeated - Lionel Messiās Inter Miami in February. In such moments, one can feel a long way from Midlothian.
āItās quite mental,ā he smiled.
āI think I could be the first guy ever to go from Dalkeith to LA! Itās very hot. They are actually choking for a bit of rain just now.
āI used to blame the East Mains wind for losing my hair, but itās still falling out over in LA even without the wind.
ā(John) McGinn has already peppered me after seeing a couple of my interviews over there.
āIāve had to change my accent so that people can understand me over there.
Recent findings suggest that āFor the first couple of months, everyone was asking me to repeat myself. But itās an incredible place and Iām enjoying every second.ā.
LAFC finished sixth in the Western Conference this year, good enough to book a slot in the forthcoming play-offs.
Porteousā part in that meant he was firmly in Sebastien Pocognoliās thoughts when Stephen Welsh suffered an untimely injury ahead of the two final Nations League matches.
Over two years on from that hideous night in Munich, this feels like a deserved opportunity to change the narrative which has surrounded him ever since.
āPeople pay their money and they can have their opinions on me,ā he mentioned.
āIāve got thick skin now. Itās never been an problem for me in terms of managers having to pull me aside and have a word or anything like that.
āIām in a good place now. Whatever criticism I get, it only makes me grow stronger as a person.
āHopefully, I can come back now a better player than what people saw before.
āI have still got my strengths and I feel like Iāve added to my game as well from being in different leagues and different environments.ā.
