Pokemon fans and game preservationists are frustrated after a playable copy of the long-lost PokePark Fishing Rally DS was authenticated and sealed inside a PSA case, leaving the 20-year-old title inaccessible to most people who hoped to finally play it.
PokePark Fishing Rally DS, also known as PokePark Fishing Contest DS, was distributed through Download Play at Japan’s PokePark theme park in 2005. Copies were temporary by design, disappearing when the Nintendo DS was switched off or after 12 hours. The game was never sold at retail, making it one of the most elusive pieces of lost Pokemon media.
As first reported by IGN, collector Daniel Qudari indicated the outlet a working cartridge capable of sending the game to other Nintendo DS systems through Download Play.
PSA researcher Claire Shelton reportedly played the game during a private meeting with the owner before the cartridge was submitted for authentication and encapsulation.
The discovery initially appeared to be a major breakthrough for Pokemon historians and lost media researchers. However, much of the online reaction has focused on the decision to put the cartridge in a PSA slab before its contents were publicly preserved.
Anthony, known as @KirbyCheatFurby on X, criticized the decision, writing that “instead of making it so we can all play the ROM by dumping its contents online, they got it put in a f***ing PSA case.” The post was widely shared by fans who had hoped the discovery would lead to a public ROM dump.
and instead of making it so we can all play the ROM by dumping its contents online, they got it put in a fucking PSA case https://t.co/9NNjsxBeFI.
In another post, Anthony directly asked the collector to “crack that slab open and dump the ROM,” arguing that another case could be purchased after the software had been preserved.
Pokemon collectors fear fake PSA slabs after AliExpress sells custom labels and cases for any card.
Long-lost Pokemon DS cartridge sells for $11,000 after resurfacing on eBay.
PSA confirms FBI investigating $1 million Pokemon & trading card heist as full stolen list revealed.
collector, please crack that slab open and dump the ROM.. you gotta have the cash to put it in another slab once you're done. help us out here 😭.
Sources indicate that the reaction intensified after PSA’s certification listing confirmed that the item was genuine. Anthony later shared the certification page after saying a friend initially suspected the story could be an elaborate prank involving a 3D-printed cartridge.
my friend thought that the article was ragebait and that the slab could have just been an elaborate prank with a 3D printed cart, but sadly…https://t.co/ONrAGpuhUh.
Industry observers note that the criticism is centered on access rather than the cartridge’s authenticity. PSA has presented encapsulation as a way to document and protect a unique piece of video game history, while fans and preservationists view a software dump as the more important form of preservation.
A sealed case protects the physical object, but it also means the cartridge cannot be used in a Nintendo DS unless it is removed. As of publication, no public ROM dump of the playable copy has been declared, leaving the game effectively out of reach for everyone except the owner and the small number of people who were allowed to see it privately.
In a recent development, dexerto previously reported on a separate PokePark development cartridge that sold for around $11,000 after fans hoped it might finally reveal the lost game’s contents. That cartridge’s software was never publicly confirmed, making the playable discovery even more significant.
