Recent findings suggest that the B.C. Supreme Court heard arguments over a port operator's application to bar picketing outside the port amid a labor dispute at a mine.
VANCOUVER, British Columbia (CN) â A British Columbia court will need to decide whether labor relations board decisions are sufficient to deter future picketing at a port by striking steelworkers and allied unions â and, if not, whether an injunction is an appropriate response.
It has been revealed that united Steelworkers Local 7619 has been on strike against Teck Resourcesâ Highland Valley Copper mine since Oct. 24, which expanded to a picket at a North Vancouver port terminal operated by PKM Canada Services Inc. starting Nov. 7.
Sources indicate that that secondary picketing at the terminal is the subject of a lawsuit brought by PKM and the B.C. Maritime Employers Association. They claim the picket at the port terminal was illegal and that USW and the B.C. Federation of Labour were illegally interfering with the portâs business.
According to recent reports, their application for an injunction was debated in B.C. Supreme Court on Monday in a hearing that was originally expected to run three and a half hours but ultimately took the whole day, with a decision expected on Thursday afternoon.
According to recent reports, at problem was whether interim orders by the B.C. Labour Relations Board and the Canada Industrial Relations Board are sufficient to protect the portâs interests.
The former barred USWâs secondary picket at the terminal, while the latter forced longshore workers to ignore a âhot edictâ declared by the B.C. Federation of Labour calling on unionized workers to refuse to handle the mineâs materials.
In a recent development, lawyers for the federation and USW argued the injunction isnât within the purview of the court, saying the B.C. Labour Relations Code is clear that the legality of picket locations is the exclusive jurisdiction of the Labour Relations Board.
They said an injunction would be an extraordinary step given the fact it involves potentially arresting people who violate it.
And they added thereâs no evidence of risk that USW or the federation would disobey the labor boards’ orders, noting there hasnât been any secondary picketing at the terminal in a week.
âWe donât anticipate coming back,â mentioned the federationâs lawyer, Chris Buchanan. USWâs lawyer, William Clements, said the same.
The two suggested they would be in favor of an agreement not to return to picket the location without reasonable notice to PKM.
But PKMâs lawyer, Ryan Copeland, urged the court not to accept that.
âA promise to not do something is just a promise. And this court has rejected those types of promises in the past and issued injunctive relief,â Copeland mentioned.
Industry observers note that copeland argued the orders left the port tech giant vulnerable to actions by allied unions and to Teckâs discretion on whether or not to enforce the B.C. Labour Relations Boardâs order against secondary picketing at the terminal.
Copeland argued that PKM isnât a party to the dispute between USW and Teck, and itâs therefore unclear whether PKM has standing to enforce that order, making an injunction potentially the only remedy available to it.
âI think our clients are entitled to that, to have that certainty, given the stakes,â Copeland said.
And while PKM can enforce the Canada Industrial Relations Board’s order against its longshore workers, it canât control whether or not truck drivers or others will refuse to cross the picket line.
Copeland also argued PKM needs the injunction to protect against people who might ignore the labor boardsâ orders. The B.C. Labour Relations Boardâs order to end the picket line came on Nov. 8, but the picket continued into Nov. 9.
He noted that it wasnât only USW and the federation on the picket line â signs from the picket line indicated attendees were from a wide variety of unions.
âThere are other parties that are involved in this. Unfortunately, weâre here trying to scramble to protect ourselves, and with respect to what the B.C. Federation may say, they donât control what the other unions [do],â he said.
In a recent development, beyond the injunction, PKM and B.C. Maritime Employers Association are seeking damages for lost business and reputational harm from the picket at the port.
Part of the issue behind the labor dispute is workersâ wages, according to a statement by the federation and USW, which claimed Teck is âpulling in record profits,â while asking the union to make concessions.
âNo company this profitable should be falling so far short of the wages and pensions they can afford to pay,â said USW Western Canada director Scott Lunny in the statement.
Courthouse News reporter Dustin Godfrey is based in Vancouver, Canada.
It has been revealed that our weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Big Tech and the arts.
