A California customer objects to Once Upon a Farm marketing a baby food pouch product as containing a fruit and vegetable blend.
According to recent reports, (CN) â Green in appearance and solid in salads, avocados have a lot of people fooled. Botanically, theyâre not vegetables, but fruits: tree-borne berries native to Mexico, Central America and further south.
In California, U.S. District Judge Edward M. Chen has been chewing on putative class action litigation against a Berkeley baby food companyâs marketing of an avocado-containing product as a âFruit & Veggie Blend.â On Monday, Chen reversed his prior dismissal of the case, allowing the false advertising lawsuit to proceed.
Once Upon a Farm was founded in 2011; its childrenâs food products can now be found âin more than 22,000 stores nationwide,â according to its website. The company went public in February and has a current market cap of close to half a billion dollars. Actress Jennifer Garner and former Annieâs CEO John Foraker round out its C-suite.
Los Angeles-area resident Alexa Parashos sued Once Upon a Farm last year over its âWild Rumpus Avocadoâ organic food pouch. The productâs front label describes it as an âOrganic Fruit & Veggie Blend,â and its ingredients are pineapple, banana, apple, avocado and mint.
Industry observers note that parashos pointed to the U.S. Food and Drug Administrationâs classifications of avocado as a fruit and mint as an herb, meaning the blend contains no actual vegetables. Seeking a class action, she argued that Once Upon a Farm was committing fraud and violating California consumer protection and false advertising laws.
In early August, Chen granted the companyâs motion to dismiss, deeming Once Upon a Farmâs use of âveggieâ as not âliterally false or so unambiguously deceptive that a reasonable consumer would not be expected to check the back label.â Two weeks later, the Barack Obama appointee changed his mind and asked for additional briefing.
Based on a 2024 Ninth Circuit decision, Whiteside v. Kimberly Clark Corp, Chen found that Parashosâ claim of misrepresentation is viable.
ââFruit & Veggie Blendâ is not a âmeaningless marketing termâ that the consumer would necessarily need more information to understand," he wrote.
“The very fact that a reasonable consumer could reasonably conclude that the product contains a vegetable other than avocados is sufficient to state a claim of falsity without requiring consumers to read the back label,” he added.
Chen denied Parashosâ request to enjoin Once Upon a Farm from marketing the product in the same way but allowed her claim for punitive damages and push for a class action to proceed.
Once Upon a Farm did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
According to recent reports, our weekly newsletter Closing Arguments offers the latest about ongoing trials, major litigation and rulings in courthouses around the U.S. and the world, while the monthly Under the Lights dishes the legal dirt from Hollywood, sports, Significant Tech and the arts.
